From Binary Function Logic to Binary Operator Logic (BFL → BOL) A new framework for proving classical two-valued propositions through operator methods, without changing their truth values or the mathematical objects being proved. This paper proposes a transition from Binary Function Logic (BFL), the conventional two-valued logic of predicates and characteristic functions, to Binary Operator Logic (BOL), in which the same mathematical propositions are represented in Hilbert spaces and investigated through operators, spectral relations, and rigorous proof certificates. The central principle is simple: the truth of a mathematical proposition remains binary; what changes is the mathematical machinery used to prove it. For an implication A ⇒ B, the paper establishes the exact correspondence A ⇒ B ⇔ X_A ⊆ X_B ⇔ P_B P_A = P_A ⇔ P_B − P_A ≥ 0, where X_A and X_B are the sets defined by the predicates and P_A, P_B are their orthogonal projections. This provides a rigorous bridge from classical Boolean implication to operator inequalities. BOL is therefore proposed as an extension of proof methods, not as a replacement for classical truth or Boolean logic. The framework is organized around four fundamental requirements: Separation of truth and representation: scalar truth values are distinguished from vectors, superpositions, and operator spectra. Preservation of classical Boolean logic: conventional binary reasoning is faithfully embedded as a commuting projection subsystem. Preservation of interference and proof soundness: off-diagonal cross terms are retained, and operator certificates must imply the original proposition. Invariance of the proof object: mathematical proofs must not alter the proposition or its represented object. No physical measurement, state collapse, or time evolution is introduced. The mathematical development incorporates closed quadratic forms, infinite-dimensional dual Schur complements, Galerkin residual estimates, equivalent operator representations, and polarization reconstruction. Dirac-comb and Fourier-wave representations provide natural Hilbert-space realizations of integers. Noncommutative arithmetic operators illustrate how additional cross information can enter proofs while preserving the original arithmetic problem. The paper also presents computer-assisted examples involving finite-dimensional Weil-form compressions, demonstrating how retaining off-diagonal information and using different operator representations can improve rigorous positivity certification. The proposed transition BFL → BOL does not introduce a third truth value. Affirmed, refuted, and uncertified are three possible certification outcomes, not three forms of mathematical truth. The work establishes a conceptual and mathematical framework for operator-based proofs. It does not claim a general decision procedure for mathematical propositions or a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis or the ABC conjecture. The central contribution is a change in the language of mathematical proof: from evaluating binary predicates to constructing sound operator certificates for the same binary propositions.
From Binary Function Logic to Binary Operator Logic (BFL → BOL) A new framework for proving classical two-valued propositions through operator methods, without changing their truth values or the mathematical objects being proved. This paper proposes a transition from Binary Function Logic (BFL), the conventional two-valued logic of predicates and characteristic functions, to Binary Operator Logic (BOL), in which the same mathematical propositions are represented in Hilbert spaces and investigated through operators, spectral relations, and rigorous proof certificates. The central principle is simple: the truth of a mathematical proposition remains binary; what changes is the mathematical machinery used to prove it. For an implication A ⇒ B, the paper establishes the exact correspondence A ⇒ B ⇔ X_A ⊆ X_B ⇔ P_B P_A = P_A ⇔ P_B − P_A ≥ 0, where X_A and X_B are the sets defined by the predicates and P_A, P_B are their orthogonal projections. This provides a rigorous bridge from classical Boolean implication to operator inequalities. BOL is therefore proposed as an extension of proof methods, not as a replacement for classical truth or Boolean logic. The framework is organized around four fundamental requirements: Separation of truth and representation: scalar truth values are distinguished from vectors, superpositions, and operator spectra. Preservation of classical Boolean logic: conventional binary reasoning is faithfully embedded as a commuting projection subsystem. Preservation of interference and proof soundness: off-diagonal cross terms are retained, and operator certificates must imply the original proposition. Invariance of the proof object: mathematical proofs must not alter the proposition or its represented object. No physical measurement, state collapse, or time evolution is introduced. The mathematical development incorporates closed quadratic forms, infinite-dimensional dual Schur complements, Galerkin residual estimates, equivalent operator representations, and polarization reconstruction. Dirac-comb and Fourier-wave representations provide natural Hilbert-space realizations of integers. Noncommutative arithmetic operators illustrate how additional cross information can enter proofs while preserving the original arithmetic problem. The paper also presents computer-assisted examples involving finite-dimensional Weil-form compressions, demonstrating how retaining off-diagonal information and using different operator representations can improve rigorous positivity certification. The proposed transition BFL → BOL does not introduce a third truth value. Affirmed, refuted, and uncertified are three possible certification outcomes, not three forms of mathematical truth. The work establishes a conceptual and mathematical framework for operator-based proofs. It does not claim a general decision procedure for mathematical propositions or a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis or the ABC conjecture. The central contribution is a change in the language of mathematical proof: from evaluating binary predicates to constructing sound operator certificates for the same binary propositions.
We propose a linear algebraic method, named Eigenlogic, for two-, many-valued and fuzzy logic using observables in Hilbert space. All logical connectives are represented by observables where the truth values correspond to eigenvalues and the atomic input propositional cases, i.e. the “models” of a propositional system, to the respective eigenvectors. In this way propositional logic can be formalized by using combinations of tensored elementary quantum observables. The outcome of a “measurement” of a logical observable will give the truth value of the associated logical proposition, and becomes “interpretable” when applied to vectors of its eigenspace, leading to an original insight into the quantum measurement postulate.Recently the concept of “quantum predicate” has been proposed in leading to similar concepts.We develop logical observables for binary logic and extend them to many-valued logic.For binary logic and truth values {0, 1} logical observables are commuting projector operators.For truth values {+1,−1} the logical observables are isometries formally equivalent to the ones of a composite quantum spin 12 system, these observables are reversible quantum logic gates.The analogy of many-valued logic with quantum angular momentum is then established using a general algebraic method, based on classical interpolation framework suggested by the finite-elementmethod. Logical observables for three-valued logic are formulated using the orbital angular momentum observable Lz with ` = 1. The representative 3-valued 2-argument logical observables for theternary threshold logical connectives Min and Max are then explicitly obtained.Also in this approach fuzzy logic arises naturally when considering vectors outside the eigensystem.The fuzzy membership function is obtained by the quantum mean value (Born rule) of the logical projector observable and turns out to be a probability measure. Fuzziness arises because ofthe quantum superposition of atomic propositional cases, the truth of a proposition being in this case a probabilistic value ranging from completely false to completely true.This method could be employed for developing algorithms in high-dimensional vector spaces for example in modern semantic theories, such as distributional semantics or in connectionist modelsof cognition. For practical implementation, due to the exponential growth of the vector space dimension, adapted logical reduction methods must then be used. LSA (Latent Semantic Analysis)algorithms are often used in quantum-like approaches, this was done using the HAL (Hyperspace Analogue to Language) algorithm.Our approach is also of interest for quantum computation because several of the observables in Eigenlogic are well-known quantum gates (for example CONTROL-Z) and other ones can be derived by unitary transformations. Ternary-logic quantum gates using qu-trits lead to less complex circuits, our formulation of multi-valued logical observables could help the development of new multi-valued quantum gate architectures.
The thesis investigates the possibility of a classical semantics for quantum propositional structures. A classical semantics is defined as a set of mappings each of which is (i) bivalent, i.e., the value 1 (true) or 0 (false) is assigned to each proposition, and (ii) truth-functional, i.e., the logical operations are preserved. In addition, this set must be "full", i.e., any pair of distinct propositions is assigned different values by some mapping in the set. When the propositions make assertions about the properties of classical or of quantum systems, the mappings should also be (iii) "state-induced", i.e., values assigned by the semantics should accord with values assigned by classical or by quantum mechanics. In classical propositional logic, (equivalence classes of) propositions form a Boolean algebra, and each semantic mapping assigns the value 1 to the members of a certain subset of the algebra, namely, an ultrafilter, and assigns 0 to the members of the dual ultraideal, where the union of these two subsets is the entire algebra. The propositional structures of classical mechanics are likewise Boolean algebras, so one can straightforwardly provide a classical semantics, which also satisfies (iii). However, quantum propositional structures are non-Boolean, so it is an open question whether a semantics satisfying (i), (ii) and (iii) can be provided. Von Neumann first proposed (1932) that the algebraic structures of the subspaces (or projectors) of Hilbert space be regarded as the pro-positional structures PQM of quantum mechanics. These structures have been formalized in two ways: as orthomodular lattices which have the binary operations "and", "or", defined among all elements, compatible [symbol omitted] and incompatible [symbol omitted]; and as partial-Boolean algebras which have the binary operations defined among only compatible elements. In the thesis, two basic senses in which these structures are non-Boolean are discriminated. And two notions of truth-functionality are distinguished: truth-functionality [symbols omitted] applicable to the PQM lattices; and truth-functionality [symbol omitted] applicable to both the lattices and partial-Boolean algebras. Then it is shown how the lattice definitions of "and", "or", among incompatibles rule out a bivalent, truth-functional [symbols omitted] semantics for any lattice containing incompatible, elements. In contrast, the Gleason and Kochen-Specker proofs of the impossibility of hidden-variables for quantum mechanics show the impossibility of a bivalent, truth-functional [symbol omitted] semantics for three-or-higher dimensional Hilbert space structures; and the presence of incompatible elements is necessary but is not sufficient to rule out such a semantics. As for (iii), each quantum state-induced expectation-function on a PQM truth-functionally assigns 1 and 0 values to the elements in a ultrafilter and dual ultraideal of PQM³ where, in general the union of an ultrafilter and its dual ultraideal is smaller than the entire structure. Thus it is argued that each expectation-function is the quantum analog of a classical semantic mapping, even though the domain where each expectation-function is bivalent and truth-functional is usually a non-Boolean substructure of PQM. The final portion of the thesis surveys proposals for the introduction of hidden variables into quantum mechanics, proofs of the impossibility of such hidden-variable proposals, and criticisms of these impossibility proofs. And arguments in favour of the partial-Boolean algebra, rather than the orthomodular lattice, formalization of the quantum propositional structures are reviewed.
Eigenlogic proposes a new method in logic inspired from quantum theory using operators. It expresses logical propositions using linear algebra. Logical functions are represented by operators and logical truth tables correspond to the eigenvalue structure. It extends the possibilities of classical logic by changing the semantics from the Boolean binary alphabet {0,1} using projection operators to the binary alphabet {+1,-1} employing reversible involution operators. Also, many-valued logical operators are synthesized, for whatever alphabet, using operator methods based on Lagrange interpolation and on the Cayley-Hamilton theorem. Considering a superposition of logical input states one gets a fuzzy logic representation where the fuzzy membership function is the quantum probability given by the Born rule. Eigenlogic is essentially a logic of operators and its truth-table logical semantics is provided by the eigenvalue structure which is shown to be related to the universality of logical quantum gates, a fundamental role being played by non-commutativity and entanglement.
Considering links between logic and physics is important because of the fast development of quantum information technologies in our everyday life. This paper discusses a new method in logic inspired from quantum theory using operators, named Eigenlogic. It expresses logical propositions using linear algebra. Logical functions are represented by operators and logical truth tables correspond to the eigenvalue structure. It extends the possibilities of classical logic by changing the semantics from the Boolean binary alphabet { 0 , 1 } using projection operators to the binary alphabet { + 1 , - 1 } employing reversible involution operators. Also, many-valued logical operators are synthesized, for whatever alphabet, using operator methods based on Lagrange interpolation and on the Cayley-Hamilton theorem. Considering a superposition of logical input states one gets a fuzzy logic representation where the fuzzy membership function is the quantum probability given by the Born rule. Historical parallels from Boole, Post, Poincaré and Combinatory Logic are presented in relation to probability theory, non-commutative quaternion algebra and Turing machines. An extension to first order logic is proposed inspired by Grover's algorithm. Eigenlogic is essentially a logic of operators and its truth-table logical semantics is provided by the eigenvalue structure which is shown to be related to the universality of logical quantum gates, a fundamental role being played by non-commutativity and entanglement.
According to quantum mechanics, the pure states of a microsystem are represented by vectors in a Hilbert Space. Sentences of the form, "x є L" (where x is the state vector for a system, L a subspace of the appropriate Hilbert space), may be called Q-propositions: such sentences serve to summarise our information about the results of possible experiments on the system. Quantum logic investigates the relations which hold among the Q-propositions about a given physical sys tem. These logical relations correspond to algebraic relations among the subspaces of Hilbert space. The algebra of this set of subspaces is non-Boolean, and may be regarded either as an orthomodular lattice or as a partial Boolean algebra. With each type of structure we can associate a logic. A general approach to the semantics for such a logic is provided in terms of interpretations of a formal language within an algebraic structure; an interpretation maps sentences of the language homomorphically onto elements of the structure. When the structure in question is a Boolean algera, the resulting logic is classical; here we develop a semantics for the logic associated with partial Boolean algebras. Two systems of proof, based on the natural deduction systems of Gentzen, are shown for this logic. With respect to the given sematics, these calculi are sound and weakly complete. Strong completeness is conjectured. Quantum logic deals with the logical relations between sentences, and so is properly called a logic. However, it is the logic appropriate to a limited class of sentences: proposals that it should replace classical logic wherever the latter is used should be viewed with suspicion.
Traditional formal logic is built upon classical bivalent foundations, featuring the law of excluded middle and the dichotomy of truth values. However, these classical frameworks struggle to capture the non-classical features of quantum information processing, such as superposition, entanglement, and coherence. To bridge the gap between quantum mechanics and formal logic, this paper introduces a novel logical framework termed Quantum Proof Logic (QPL). The core idea of QPL is to transcend the single-state limitation of traditional proofs by elevating proof states to state vectors within a complex Hilbert space. In this framework, a logical proof can exist in a linear superposition of multiple foundational proof paths, denoted as |Psi_proof> = sum_{k=1}^{K} c_k |s_k>, allowing the system to concurrently explore multiple logical hypotheses. We systematically establish QPL's axiomatic system—including the superposition axiom, unitary evolution derivation axiom, non-local entangled proof axiom, and measurement collapse axiom—alongside its algebraic semantics using density operators and logical entropy. Furthermore, we explore QPL's profound implications for the foundations of mathematics, including potential perspectives on Godel's incompleteness theorems, as well as its practical applications in fault-tolerant quantum error correction and the formal verification of quantum programs. QPL provides a rigorous mathematical foundation and a comprehensive logical tool for reasoning about complex quantum systems.