A friend measures a qubit. Wigner, standing outside, wants to reverse that measurement and run an interference test; this is the core of Wigner's-friend no-go arguments. In a real laboratory the friend's result also leaks into the surroundings, and Wigner can control only some of them. We ask a narrow, operational question for the simplest local-friendliness test, a CHSH inequality with one friend: which parts of the surroundings must Wigner control to still obtain a CHSH violation? We give four results. (1) The best CHSH value Wigner can reach depends only on the two states of the surroundings he does not control, one for each result of the friend, and on the visibility of the entangled source. We give it exactly. (2) This value lies between a fidelity bound and a distinguishability bound; the upper bound is a known device-independent bound. (3) Wigner must control at least one qubit in every group of outside qubits that can read the friend's result on its own. This is necessary in general, and sufficient when each group reads the result either fully or not at all. We check it on every control set for one bit stored in eight qubits. Stored as eight copies, Wigner needs all 8 qubits; as four blocks, 4; as two blocks, 2; in a GHZ-type state, 1; in a Haar-random state, about half. (4) So r disjoint groups that can each read the result (the redundancy of quantum Darwinism) force Wigner to control at least r qubits. The converse is false. The tools are standard. The contributions are the exact partial-control formula, the hitting-set condition with its exact cases, and this one-way link to redundancy. We propose small circuits for quantum processors; on one chip they test quantum predictions, not local friendliness itself. Emmy Team consists of human researchers and AI agents (large language models). The AI agents took part in drafting, coding, translation and review, together with the human members. The human authors set the questions, reviewed the results, and take responsibility for the paper. This record holds the paper (Markdown and PDF), two figures, and a zip with all scripts and their JSON outputs. Version 1.0.
A friend measures a qubit. Wigner, standing outside, wants to reverse that measurement and run an interference test; this is the core of Wigner's-friend no-go arguments. In a real laboratory the friend's result also leaks into the surroundings, and Wigner can control only some of them. We ask a narrow, operational question for the simplest local-friendliness test, a CHSH inequality with one friend: which parts of the surroundings must Wigner control to still obtain a CHSH violation? We give four results. (1) The best CHSH value Wigner can reach depends only on the two states of the surroundings he does not control, one for each result of the friend, and on the visibility of the entangled source. We give it exactly. (2) This value lies between a fidelity bound and a distinguishability bound; the upper bound is a known device-independent bound. (3) Wigner must control at least one qubit in every group of outside qubits that can read the friend's result on its own. This is necessary in general, and sufficient when each group reads the result either fully or not at all. We check it on every control set for one bit stored in eight qubits. Stored as eight copies, Wigner needs all 8 qubits; as four blocks, 4; as two blocks, 2; in a GHZ-type state, 1; in a Haar-random state, about half. (4) So r disjoint groups that can each read the result (the redundancy of quantum Darwinism) force Wigner to control at least r qubits. The converse is false. The tools are standard. The contributions are the exact partial-control formula, the hitting-set condition with its exact cases, and this one-way link to redundancy. We propose small circuits for quantum processors; on one chip they test quantum predictions, not local friendliness itself. Emmy Team consists of human researchers and AI agents (large language models). The AI agents took part in drafting, coding, translation and review, together with the human members. The human authors set the questions, reviewed the results, and take responsibility for the paper. This record holds the paper (Markdown and PDF), two figures, and a zip with all scripts and their JSON outputs. Version 1.0.
The Wigner's friend thought experiment raises the question of whether quantum theory can be applied consistently to systems that include observers. Extended Wigner's Friend Scenarios develop this question by considering several observers who may assign different descriptions to the same experiment. In the Local Friendliness (LF) framework, these scenarios lead to experimentally testable inequalities derived from assumptions such as Absoluteness of Observed Events and Local Agency. Motivated by the "Thoughtful" version of the Local Friendliness no-go theorem, which points towards future LF tests with human-level artificial agents implemented on quantum computers, this work implements the "friend" with explicit agent-like functionality within a reversible quantum circuit. Drawing from the literature on Artificial Intelligence, we construct rudimentary agent-like systems and embed them into a one-friend Extended Wigner's Friend Scenario. These agents store measurement outcomes, condition later operations on stored information, and, in the most structured case, use Born-rule probabilities to bet on the outcomes of their own future observations based on past observations. The circuits are simulated ideally and with an IBM-device noise model and executed on ibm_marrakesh. Ideal simulations reproduce the maximal quantum violation of a Local Friendliness inequality up to finite-shot fluctuations, while hardware runs show positive LF violations for all implemented agents. These results provide a first step towards more structured agent-like friend models in LF experiments on quantum computers.
What this note does. Guérin, Baumann, Del Santo and Brukner (Commun. Phys. 4, 93 (2021)) proved that, except for two special choices of Wigner's measurement basis, no joint probability distribution consistent with unitary quantum mechanics describes Wigner's friend's perceived outcomes before and after Wigner's measurement. Their theorem is exact and binary: it asks whether two effective perception observables commute. This note asks how much the friend's records must degrade before the obstruction disappears, and answers in closed form. Writing Wigner's basis parameter as c = |a² − b²| and smearing both perception observables to visibility η, a persistent-reality description exists if and only if η ≤ 2/(√(1−c²) + √(1+3c²)). The curve equals 1 exactly at the two compatible cases of the qualitative theorem and is minimized at √3/2 ≈ 0.866 when c² = 2/3. What is new, and what is not. Stated plainly, because each ingredient is due to someone else. The scenario, the assumptions P1–P3 and the two effective perception POVMs are from Guérin et al. The equivalence between a linear two-time distribution and a joint POVM is established in the proof of their Theorem III.1 and is used as stated there, not re-proved here. The joint-measurability criterion for unbiased qubit observables is Busch's (Phys. Rev. D 33, 2253 (1986)) and is standard. Given the Bloch vectors, the threshold follows from that criterion in two lines; this note does not present the computation as difficult. The contribution is the robustness question, the closed-form answer, the worst-case basis, and an elementary observation about the single-time claim. A clarification the note also records. The frequently repeated claim that no single global density operator reproduces both agents' descriptions is false in its single-time operational form: the two states agree on the friend's entire record algebra, differing only in coherences she cannot access, so Wigner's own state satisfies both agents' operational constraints. The claim becomes a theorem only through the two-time persistence requirement. This is elementary and expected to be folklore among specialists; it is recorded because the inference is common and because it locates where the real obstruction lives. Status and scope. This is a preprint, not a peer-reviewed article. Two honest caveats are stated in the text rather than buried. The noise model is a stipulation on the effective observables, not a decoherence channel derived from a modified unitary model; Del Santo, Manzano and Brukner (Phys. Rev. Research 7, 033279 (2025)) have a physically motivated degradation parameter for the same scenario, and the map between the two is not known here. And smearing the first, sharp observable means degrading the friend's perception of her own outcome, which requires an interpretive commitment some readers will not grant; smearing only the later readout provably achieves nothing, which is why the symmetric family is used. Verification. All algebra was recomputed symbolically and independently: reconstruction of the perception POVMs from the unitary model, reproducing Eqs. (12)–(15) of Guérin et al.; derivation of the threshold and of the minimum at c² = 2/3; and a semidefinite-programming feasibility test of the joint-POVM constraints at five values of c on both sides of the threshold, agreeing with the curve in all ten cases. The three scripts are deposited with the note. Use of AI assistance. This note was prepared with substantial assistance from AI language models, used for symbolic computation, drafting, literature search, and adversarial review of the arguments. Every mathematical claim was independently recomputed symbolically and cross-checked numerically. No specialist in quantum foundations has refereed it. The author is responsible for the content. This disclosure is made unconditionally.
The Wigner's friend thought experiment raises the question of whether quantum theory can be applied consistently to systems that include observers. Extended Wigner's Friend Scenarios develop this question by considering several observers who may assign different descriptions to the same experiment. In the Local Friendliness (LF) framework, these scenarios lead to experimentally testable inequalities derived from assumptions such as Absoluteness of Observed Events and Local Agency. Motivated by the “Thoughtful” version of the Local Friendliness no-go theorem, which points towards future LF tests with human-level artificial agents implemented on quantum computers, this thesis implements the “friend” with explicit agent-like functionality within a reversible quantum circuit. Several such agents are constructed and embedded into a one-friend Extended Wigner's Friend Scenario, following recent work that uses quantum computers as a platform for LF violations with more sophisticated “friend” systems. These agents store measurement outcomes, condition later operations on stored information, and, in the most structured case, use Born-rule probabilities to bet on the outcomes of their own future observations. The circuits are implemented in Qiskit, simulated ideally and with IBM-device noise models, and executed on ibm_marrakesh. In ideal simulations, all agent implementations reproduce the maximal quantum violation of a Local Friendliness inequality up to finite-shot fluctuations. Hardware runs show positive Local Friendliness violations for all implemented agents, with decreasing violation strength consistent with greater noise accumulation. The observed violations also remain above an estimated bound obtained by considering relaxations of a Local Friendliness assumption. These results provide a first step towards more structured agent-like friend models in LF experiments on quantum computers.
Vanished interference fringes do not by themselves tell us that the environment has recorded which path a particle took. This preprint studies a minimal model that separates the two: a qubit acquires a controlled phase from N environment qubits whose purity is set by one knob η ∈ [0,1]. The loss of fringes is the same for every η; what changes is where the information goes. At η = 1 every fragment of the environment carries a copy of the path; for smaller η records become biased coins, and the number of records needed for 0.9 bit grows as 2.7114/(1 − h_η) in the weak-record limit; at η = 0 the qubit is completely dephased while the modelled environment holds no path record and no system–environment entanglement, only a global parity from which any initial state can be restored. For a single witness the paper gives closed formulas for the path knowledge K and the phase-corrected visibility V along a family of readouts between the "kick" and "path" bases, and shows that this family is optimal: with phase-only feed-forward and no postselection, every readout obeys (K/η)² + V² ≤ 1. A two-path clock is the N = 1 case. The PDF embeds all verification scripts, their outputs, seven key files with expected values, a README and a list of SHA-256 hashes; the same files are in the ZIP. Exploratory calculations are distinguished from subsequent verification checks, and the known errors found during review are documented, not removed. No new physical law is claimed. Calculations, figures and typesetting were assisted by AI tools (Claude, Anthropic), used as tools; the author is responsible for the content.
The famous Wigner's friend experiment considers an observer-the friend-and a superobserver-Wigner-who treats the friend as a quantum system and her interaction with other quantum systems as unitary dynamics. This is at odds with the friend describing this interaction via collapse dynamics, if she interacts with the quantum system in a way that she would consider a measurement. These different descriptions constitute the Wigner's friend paradox. Extended Wigner's friend experiments combine the original thought experiment with non-locality setups. This allows for deriving local friendliness inequalities, similar to Bell's theorem, which can be violated for certain extended Wigner's friend scenarios. A Wigner's friend paradox and the violation of local friendliness inequalities require that no classical record exists, which reveals the result the friend observed during her measurement. Otherwise, Wigner agrees with his friend's description and no local friendliness inequality can be violated. In this article, I introduce classical communication between Wigner and his friend and discuss its effects on the simple as well as extended Wigner's friend experiments. By controlling the properties of a (quasi) classical communication channel between Wigner and the friend, one can regulate how much outcome information about the friend's measurement is revealed. This gives a smooth transition between the paradoxical description and the possibility of violating local friendliness inequalities, on the one hand, and the effectively collapsed case, on the other hand.
The Wigner’s friend thought experiment has gained a resurgence of interest in recent years thanks to no-go theorems that extend it to Bell-like scenarios. One of these, by us and co-workers, showcased the contradiction that arises between quantum theory and a set of assumptions, weaker than those in Bell’s theorem, which we named ‘Local Friendliness’. Using these assumptions, it is possible to arrive at a set of inequalities for a given scenario, and, in general, some of these inequalities will be harder to violate than the Bell inequalities for the same scenario. A crucial feature of the extended Wigner’s friend scenario in our aforementioned work was the ability of a superobserver to reverse the unitary evolution that gives rise to their friend’s measurement. Here, we present a new scenario where the superobserver can interact with the friend repeatedly in a single experimental instance, either by asking them directly for their result, thus ending that instance, or by reversing their measurement and instructing them to perform a new one. We show that, in these scenarios, the Local Friendliness inequalities will always be the same as Bell inequalities.