Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning

Benchmarking Quantum Simulators: Comparative Analysis of Quantum Network Protocols Across Six Frameworks

Rajesh Thulasi, Dr. Thanga Kumar

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum networking protocol advancement heavily relies on classical simulation for algorithm design, validation, and optimization before deployment on quantum hardware. However, selecting the quantum computing framework significantly influences simulation performance memory utilization, and productivity. This research paper renders a systematic performance analysis of quantum computing simulators for network protocol implementation across six important quantum frameworks: Qiskit, CirQ, Amazon Braket SDK, PyQuil, Q#, and PennyLane. We have evaluated it by implementing nine fundamental networking protocols, conducting 1,620 simulation executions with N = 30 trials per measurement under both ideal and noisy conditions. We have observed significant performance disparities: PyQuil accomplishes 405× faster total execution than Qiskit with 1,237× lower peak memory consumption, whereas Q# demonstrates comparable speed using JIT compilation. while using real depolarizing noise (p=0.001) all frameworks exhibit 0.1–1.0% teleportation fidelity degradation.

DOI
10.51483/ijaiml.2748

Related papers

Benchmarking quantum computing statevector simulators on high-performance computing

Jesús Cerrudo-Herrera, Daniel Talaván-Vega, Paloma Rodríguez-Oliver +2 more

The increasing complexity of quantum algorithms and the limitations of current Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware underscore the importance of efficient classical simulators. To support informed decision-making by users of quantum circuit simulators, we benchmark seven statevector-based quantum circuit simulators (Qiskit, Qulacs, Qibo, Qsimov, Cirq, Pennylane and the Intel Quantum Simulator (IQS)) on a multicore node of the Lusitania high-performance computing (HPC) system. We evaluate their performance in terms of execution time, memory usage and core scalability using Grover’s algorithm, the quantum Fourier transform (QFT), and quantum volume (QV) circuits, across qubit counts ranging from 3 to 30. Our results reveal that Qulacs offers the best performance for circuits below 22 qubits, while Qiskit becomes the fastest for larger and more complex circuits. Qiskit and Qulacs achieve the most efficient parallel performance across multiple cores, while others display limited scaling benefits. IQS shows the lowest memory consumption in QFT and QV benchmarks for systems under 24 qubits; however, it suffers from higher execution times, particularly for Grover’s algorithm. The experimental implementation of Qsimov consistently underperforms in both runtime and scalability; for this reason, it is employed as a baseline in our measurements, serving to highlight the importance of performance optimizations in statevector-based quantum circuit simulators. Previous findings provide a comprehensive performance landscape to guide researchers in selecting appropriate simulators for both standard and large-scale quantum workloads on HPC infrastructures.

SIMULATION•Apr 22, 2026•0 citations

Breaking Cryptography with Quantum Simulators: A Performance Study of Qiskit, Cirq, and QuTiP

Seema Kute, Mukti E. Jadhav

Quantum computing has emerged as a transformative technological advancement with the potential to challenge the foundations of classical cryptography. Traditional cryptographic algorithms, such as RSA, rely heavily on the computational hardness of problems like integer factorization—a problem quantum algorithm like Shor's can theoretically solve efficiently. This research investigates the practical capabilities and performance limitations of three prominent quantum simulation frameworks: Qiskit, Cirq, and QuTiP. The study aims to analyze and compare their efficiency in simulating the decryption process for encrypted data of varying bit lengths—specifically 8 -bit, 16 -bit, 32 -bit, 64 -bit, 128 -bit, and 512 -bit keys. By simulating classical decryption schemes through quantum circuits, we assess the computational resources, execution time, and overall performance of each platform. This benchmarking helps to highlight how effectively these simulators can model cryptographic tasks and where they currently fall short in terms of scalability and execution time. The results offer valuable insights into the practicality of deploying quantum computing for real-world cryptographic operations and outline the current limitations imposed by simulation-based approaches, especially as key sizes grow in complexity. Ultimately, this research contributes to a deeper understanding of how existing quantum tools perform under cryptographic workloads and what improvements are necessary to make quantum-assisted cryptanalysis viable at scale.

International Conference on Applications of Machine Intelligence and Data Analytics (ICAMIDA)•Aug 21, 2025•0 citations

Performance Analysis of Quantum Computing Frameworks for Cryptographic Applications

Mikhail Grigoryevich Babenko, A. Koronskiy, Andrei Nikolaevitch Tchernykh +2 more

Abstract Quantum computing represents a substantial threat to contemporary cryptographic systems, primarily due to the vulnerabilities introduced by quantum algorithms such as Shor’s algorithm, Deutsch’s algorithm, and Grover’s algorithm. In this study, advanced quantum computing frameworks, including Curl, PennyLane, and Qiskit, were selected to model these algorithms and to facilitate a comprehensive comparative analysis. A generalization scheme for quantum computing and its limitations are discussed. The pseudo-codes of the principal algorithms and their implications for cryptography are presented in detail. An empirical evaluation of time and memory consumption demonstrates that the Qiskit library exhibits superior performance in the implementation of the three aforementioned algorithms, requiring fewer lines of code, reduced execution time, and lower memory usage. This work offers insights into the efficiency of quantum computing algorithms and frameworks and highlights the broader impact of advances in quantum computing on traditional cryptographic paradigms.

Programming and Computer Software•Dec 1, 2025•0 citations

Hybrid Classical-Quantum Algorithms for Optimization: A Multi-SDK Framework

Murali Krishna Pasupuleti

Abstract: This paper explores hybrid quantum-classical optimization algorithms implemented across multiple quantum software development kits (SDKs): Qiskit and Cirq,. We evaluate the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) in terms of convergence rate, final cost value, and fidelity, using both simulators and real quantum hardware backends. Our results offer comparative insights into SDK performance and propose a standardized benchmarking approach for future quantum algorithm research. Keywords: Hybrid Quantum Algorithms, Qiskit, Cirq, VQE, QAOA, Quantum SDKs, Quantum Optimization, NISQ

International Journal of Academic and Industrial Research Innovations(IJAIRI)•May 20, 2025•0 citations

Investigating Quantum Machine Learning Frameworks and Simulating Quantum Approaches

Muhammad Jawad Khan, Sumeera Bibi, Muzammil Ahmad Khan +4 more

Quantum machine learning (QML) has emerged as a promising field, combining the power of quantum computing with classical machine learning techniques to solve complex computational tasks. As the demand for efficient quantum simulations grows, multiple QML frameworks, including PennyLane, Qiskit, and TensorFlow Quantum (TFQ), have been developed to facilitate hybrid quantum-classical computations. This study aims to evaluate and compare the performance of three leading QML frameworks PennyLane, Qiskit, and TensorFlow Quantum in simulating quantum machine learning models, focusing on accuracy, execution time, and noise tolerance. The study examined three leading quantum machine learning (QML) frameworks PennyLane (v0.24), Qiskit (v0.43.2), and TensorFlow Quantum (TFQ, v0.7) each tested on a 64-bit Ubuntu Linux system with an Intel Core i7 processor, 32 GB RAM, and NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 GPU. Quantum algorithms like variational quantum circuits (VQCs) and quantum support vector machines (QSVMs) were simulated using these frameworks. Various quantum gates, including Pauli-X, Y, Z, Hadamard, CNOT, and Rotation gates (Rx, Ry, Rz), were used for parameter optimization and quantum superposition. The Iris and MNIST datasets were adapted for quantum encoding using Amplitude and Angle Encoding for binary classification tasks. Simulations were run on classical computers, while select circuits were executed on IBM Quantum’s Falcon r5.11 processor to compare hardware performance. PennyLane achieved the highest accuracy (92%) in quantum simulations, excelling in hybrid quantum-classical model integration. TensorFlow Quantum provided the fastest execution time, especially in classical simulations, making it suitable for rapid prototyping. Qiskit produced deeper quantum circuits but had higher error rates (6%) on real quantum hardware, highlighting noise and decoherence effects. The VQC models optimized by stochastic gradient descent (SGD) showed significant improvements in model performance, and QSVMs effectively classified both linearly separable and non-separable datasets, demonstrating the potential of quantum algorithms over classical approaches. Statistical analysis confirmed the significance of the results (p < 0.05). PennyLane is the most robust framework for hybrid quantum-classical models, while TensorFlow Quantum is suited for rapid prototyping. Qiskit, despite longer execution times, excels in hardware implementation. The choice of framework should align with the specific needs of quantum machine learning tasks.

The Asian Bulletin of Big Data Management•Oct 21, 2024•2 citations

Benchmarking Distributed Quantum Computing Emulators

Guillermo Díaz-Camacho, Iago F. Llovo, F. Javier Cardama +7 more

Scalable quantum computing requires architectural solutions beyond monolithic processors. Distributed quantum computing (DQC) addresses this challenge by interconnecting smaller quantum nodes through quantum communication protocols, enabling collaborative computation. While several experimental and theoretical proposals for DQC exist, emulator platforms are essential tools for exploring their feasibility under realistic conditions. In this work, we introduce a benchmarking framework to evaluate DQC emulators using a distributed implementation of the inverse Quantum Fourier Transform ($\mathrm{QFT}^{\dagger}$) as a representative test case, which enables efficient phase recovery from pre-encoded Fourier states. The QFT is partitioned across nodes using teleportation-based protocols, and performance is analyzed in terms of execution time, memory usage, and fidelity with respect to a monolithic baseline. As part of this work, we review a broad range of emulators, identifying their capabilities and limitations for programming distributed quantum algorithms. Many platforms either lacked support for teleportation protocols or required complex workarounds. Consequently, we select and benchmark four representative emulators: Qiskit Aer, SquidASM, Interlin-q, and SQUANCH. They differ significantly in their support for discrete-event simulation, quantum networking, noise modeling, and parallel execution. Our results highlight the trade-offs between architectural fidelity and simulation scalability, providing a foundation for future emulator development and the validation of distributed quantum protocols. This framework can be extended to support additional algorithms and emulators.

quant-pharXiv:2512.01807•Dec 2, 2025•1 citation
Quantum networking protocol advancement heavily relies on classical simulation for algorithm design, validation, and optimization before deployment on quantum hardware. However, selecting the quantum computing framework significantly influences simulation performance memory utilization, and productivity. This research paper renders a systematic performance analysis of quantum computing simulators for network protocol implementation across six important quantum frameworks: Qiskit, CirQ, Amazon Braket SDK, PyQuil, Q#, and PennyLane. We have evaluated it by implementing nine fundamental networking protocols, conducting 1,620 simulation executions with N = 30 trials per measurement under both ideal and noisy conditions. We have observed significant performance disparities: PyQuil accomplishes 405× faster total execution than Qiskit with 1,237× lower peak memory consumption, whereas Q# demonstrates comparable speed using JIT compilation. while using real depolarizing noise (p=0.001) all frameworks exhibit 0.1–1.0% teleportation fidelity degradation.
The increasing complexity of quantum algorithms and the limitations of current Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware underscore the importance of efficient classical simulators. To support informed decision-making by users of quantum circuit simulators, we benchmark seven statevector-based quantum circuit simulators (Qiskit, Qulacs, Qibo, Qsimov, Cirq, Pennylane and the Intel Quantum Simulator (IQS)) on a multicore node of the Lusitania high-performance computing (HPC) system. We evaluate their performance in terms of execution time, memory usage and core scalability using Grover’s algorithm, the quantum Fourier transform (QFT), and quantum volume (QV) circuits, across qubit counts ranging from 3 to 30. Our results reveal that Qulacs offers the best performance for circuits below 22 qubits, while Qiskit becomes the fastest for larger and more complex circuits. Qiskit and Qulacs achieve the most efficient parallel performance across multiple cores, while others display limited scaling benefits. IQS shows the lowest memory consumption in QFT and QV benchmarks for systems under 24 qubits; however, it suffers from higher execution times, particularly for Grover’s algorithm. The experimental implementation of Qsimov consistently underperforms in both runtime and scalability; for this reason, it is employed as a baseline in our measurements, serving to highlight the importance of performance optimizations in statevector-based quantum circuit simulators. Previous findings provide a comprehensive performance landscape to guide researchers in selecting appropriate simulators for both standard and large-scale quantum workloads on HPC infrastructures.
Quantum computing has emerged as a transformative technological advancement with the potential to challenge the foundations of classical cryptography. Traditional cryptographic algorithms, such as RSA, rely heavily on the computational hardness of problems like integer factorization—a problem quantum algorithm like Shor's can theoretically solve efficiently. This research investigates the practical capabilities and performance limitations of three prominent quantum simulation frameworks: Qiskit, Cirq, and QuTiP. The study aims to analyze and compare their efficiency in simulating the decryption process for encrypted data of varying bit lengths—specifically 8 -bit, 16 -bit, 32 -bit, 64 -bit, 128 -bit, and 512 -bit keys. By simulating classical decryption schemes through quantum circuits, we assess the computational resources, execution time, and overall performance of each platform. This benchmarking helps to highlight how effectively these simulators can model cryptographic tasks and where they currently fall short in terms of scalability and execution time. The results offer valuable insights into the practicality of deploying quantum computing for real-world cryptographic operations and outline the current limitations imposed by simulation-based approaches, especially as key sizes grow in complexity. Ultimately, this research contributes to a deeper understanding of how existing quantum tools perform under cryptographic workloads and what improvements are necessary to make quantum-assisted cryptanalysis viable at scale.
Abstract Quantum computing represents a substantial threat to contemporary cryptographic systems, primarily due to the vulnerabilities introduced by quantum algorithms such as Shor’s algorithm, Deutsch’s algorithm, and Grover’s algorithm. In this study, advanced quantum computing frameworks, including Curl, PennyLane, and Qiskit, were selected to model these algorithms and to facilitate a comprehensive comparative analysis. A generalization scheme for quantum computing and its limitations are discussed. The pseudo-codes of the principal algorithms and their implications for cryptography are presented in detail. An empirical evaluation of time and memory consumption demonstrates that the Qiskit library exhibits superior performance in the implementation of the three aforementioned algorithms, requiring fewer lines of code, reduced execution time, and lower memory usage. This work offers insights into the efficiency of quantum computing algorithms and frameworks and highlights the broader impact of advances in quantum computing on traditional cryptographic paradigms.
Abstract: This paper explores hybrid quantum-classical optimization algorithms implemented across multiple quantum software development kits (SDKs): Qiskit and Cirq,. We evaluate the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) in terms of convergence rate, final cost value, and fidelity, using both simulators and real quantum hardware backends. Our results offer comparative insights into SDK performance and propose a standardized benchmarking approach for future quantum algorithm research. Keywords: Hybrid Quantum Algorithms, Qiskit, Cirq, VQE, QAOA, Quantum SDKs, Quantum Optimization, NISQ
Quantum machine learning (QML) has emerged as a promising field, combining the power of quantum computing with classical machine learning techniques to solve complex computational tasks. As the demand for efficient quantum simulations grows, multiple QML frameworks, including PennyLane, Qiskit, and TensorFlow Quantum (TFQ), have been developed to facilitate hybrid quantum-classical computations. This study aims to evaluate and compare the performance of three leading QML frameworks PennyLane, Qiskit, and TensorFlow Quantum in simulating quantum machine learning models, focusing on accuracy, execution time, and noise tolerance. The study examined three leading quantum machine learning (QML) frameworks PennyLane (v0.24), Qiskit (v0.43.2), and TensorFlow Quantum (TFQ, v0.7) each tested on a 64-bit Ubuntu Linux system with an Intel Core i7 processor, 32 GB RAM, and NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 GPU. Quantum algorithms like variational quantum circuits (VQCs) and quantum support vector machines (QSVMs) were simulated using these frameworks. Various quantum gates, including Pauli-X, Y, Z, Hadamard, CNOT, and Rotation gates (Rx, Ry, Rz), were used for parameter optimization and quantum superposition. The Iris and MNIST datasets were adapted for quantum encoding using Amplitude and Angle Encoding for binary classification tasks. Simulations were run on classical computers, while select circuits were executed on IBM Quantum’s Falcon r5.11 processor to compare hardware performance. PennyLane achieved the highest accuracy (92%) in quantum simulations, excelling in hybrid quantum-classical model integration. TensorFlow Quantum provided the fastest execution time, especially in classical simulations, making it suitable for rapid prototyping. Qiskit produced deeper quantum circuits but had higher error rates (6%) on real quantum hardware, highlighting noise and decoherence effects. The VQC models optimized by stochastic gradient descent (SGD) showed significant improvements in model performance, and QSVMs effectively classified both linearly separable and non-separable datasets, demonstrating the potential of quantum algorithms over classical approaches. Statistical analysis confirmed the significance of the results (p < 0.05). PennyLane is the most robust framework for hybrid quantum-classical models, while TensorFlow Quantum is suited for rapid prototyping. Qiskit, despite longer execution times, excels in hardware implementation. The choice of framework should align with the specific needs of quantum machine learning tasks.
Scalable quantum computing requires architectural solutions beyond monolithic processors. Distributed quantum computing (DQC) addresses this challenge by interconnecting smaller quantum nodes through quantum communication protocols, enabling collaborative computation. While several experimental and theoretical proposals for DQC exist, emulator platforms are essential tools for exploring their feasibility under realistic conditions. In this work, we introduce a benchmarking framework to evaluate DQC emulators using a distributed implementation of the inverse Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT†\mathrm{QFT}^{\dagger}QFT†) as a representative test case, which enables efficient phase recovery from pre-encoded Fourier states. The QFT is partitioned across nodes using teleportation-based protocols, and performance is analyzed in terms of execution time, memory usage, and fidelity with respect to a monolithic baseline. As part of this work, we review a broad range of emulators, identifying their capabilities and limitations for programming distributed quantum algorithms. Many platforms either lacked support for teleportation protocols or required complex workarounds. Consequently, we select and benchmark four representative emulators: Qiskit Aer, SquidASM, Interlin-q, and SQUANCH. They differ significantly in their support for discrete-event simulation, quantum networking, noise modeling, and parallel execution. Our results highlight the trade-offs between architectural fidelity and simulation scalability, providing a foundation for future emulator development and the validation of distributed quantum protocols. This framework can be extended to support additional algorithms and emulators.