Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The incomparability ortholattice of covering histories is not quantum logic

NANJIE MA

Published Oct 15, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The incomparability polarity of a finite poset P yields a complete ortholattice L(P) of polarity-closed sets. The map from P to L(P) is the STANDARD closed-set / polarity-closed ortholattice of an orthogonality space, with incomparability as orthogonality. It is not a new causal logic. What is new is the covering-specific image of that functor: Boolean on tree-orders, the non-modular non-orthomodular hexagon after a merge-induced zigzag, and no injective ortholattice embedding into the projection lattice of any Hilbert space when L(P) is not orthomodular. Covering histories are finite posets of the mathematical type of finite causal sets. They are not identified with physical spacetime. Covering birth is not Rideout-Sorkin sequential growth. Companion Paper 30 is a different exclusion theorem (sprinkling versus covering support and Rideout-Sorkin CSG); cite 10.5281/zenodo.23385450. This note does not derive quantum mechanics, Hilbert space, spacetime, or a unique sequential growth law. New child record. Never is-new-version-of the parent programme manuscript.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23386148

Related papers

The center of an orthologic

Barbara Jeffcott

Since 1933, when Kolmogorov laid the foundations for probability and statistics as we know them today [1], it has been recognized that propositions asserting that such and such an event occurred as a consequence of the execution of a particular random experiment tend to band together and form a Boolean algebra. In 1936, Birkhoff and von Neumann [2] suggested that the so-called logic of quantum mechanics should not be a Boolean algebra, but rather should form what is now called a modular ortholattice [3]. Presumably, the departure from Boolean algebras encountered in quantum mechanics can be attributed to the fact that in quantum mechanics, one must consider more than one physical experiment, e.g., an experiment measuring position, an experiment measuring charge, an experiment measuring momentum, etc., and, because of the uncertainty principle, these experiments need not admit a common refinement in terms of which the Kolmogorov theory is directly applicable. Mackey's Axioms I–VI for quantum mechanics [4] imply that the logic of quantum mechanics should be a σ-orthocomplete orthomodular poset [5]. Most contemporary practitioners of quantum logic seem to agree that a quantum logic is (at least) an orthomodular poset [6], [7], [8], [9], [10] or some variation thereof [11]. P. D. Finch [12] has shown that every completely orthomodular poset is the logic arising from sets of Boolean logics, where these sets have a structure similar to the structures generally given to quantum logic. In all of these versions of quantum logic, a fundamental relation, the relation of compatibility or commutativity, plays a decisive role.

Journal of Symbolic Logic•Dec 1, 1972•15 citations

Sublattices and Δ-blocks of orthomodular posets

Ivan Chajda, Helmut Länger

Abstract States of quantum systems correspond to vectors in a Hilbert space and observations to closed subspaces. Hence, this logic corresponds to the algebra of closed subspaces of a Hilbert space. This can be considered as a complete lattice with orthocomplementation, but it is not distributive. It satisfies a weaker condition, the so-called orthomodularity. Later on, it was recognized that joins in this structure need not exist provided the subspaces are not orthogonal. Hence, the resulting structure need not be a lattice but a so-called orthomodular poset, more generally an orthoposet only. For orthoposets, we introduce a binary relation $\mathrel \Delta$ and a binary operator $d(x,y)$ that are generalizations of the binary relation $\textrm{C}$ and the commutator $c(x,y)$, respectively, known for orthomodular lattices. We characterize orthomodular posets among orthogonal posets. Moreover, we describe connections between the relations $\mathrel \Delta$ and $\leftrightarrow$ (the latter was introduced by P. Pták and S. Pulmannová) and the operator $d(x,y)$. In addition, we investigate certain orthomodular posets of subsets of a finite set. In particular, we describe maximal orthomodular sublattices and Boolean subalgebras of such orthomodular posets. Finally, we study properties of $\Delta$-blocks with respect to Boolean subalgebras and distributive subposets they include.

arXiv:2004.01962•Journal of Logic and Computation•Jun 25, 2020•0 citations

Which Bell Causality? Operational Abelianization and a Rideout–Sorkin Theorem for Quantum Sequential Growth

Thomas G Hamilton

Classical Rideout–Sorkin growth is constrained by Bell-type spectator independence, whose equivalent scalar formulations need not remain equivalent for noncommuting quantum transitions. We ask which comparison domains matter for the finite-cylinder predictions of causal-past-ordered quantum sequential growth. Four conventions are distinguished: own-core, direct, source-faithful, and broad. With invertible finite-dimensional transitions, an operator Markov sum rule, and strict covariance of reached vectors, direct Bell implies a parent-independent precursor factorization and a faithful commutative algebra on the reached module. This yields an algebra-valued Rideout–Sorkin reconstruction with a single exceptional junction correction. Although the four conventions have strictly different full-matrix solution classes, the operator defects in three separating examples are invisible on reached states. By contrast, an explicit all-stage rank-two own-core model violates a direct-Bell graft constraint at the level of its Gram kernel, establishing a genuine predictive separation. An all-stage broad-Bell example and a general visibility criterion show that the junction correction can also affect finite-cylinder interference. These results distinguish full operator identities from reached dynamics and coherent finite-cylinder data; they do not claim an extension to covariant infinite-history events. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds ten standalone Python scripts that check every finite computation cited in the paper using exact integer and rational arithmetic, together with their result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle and, inside its folder, run: python3 run_all.py. It verifies the checksums, runs all ten certificates and reports ALL PASS. The all-stage theorems are proved in the manuscript; the scripts are finite checks. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Third paper in a series, following T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788, and "Bell causality and operational rigidity in quantum sequential growth", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.24006143.Version 2 (13 November 2026): revised for submission to Physical Review D. Adds a mechanism theorem for own-core predictive separation in a stated class of complete models: all normalized precursor factors commute, the only possible obstruction is the two-chain graft, all nine birth-six target pairs are decided, and the complete Gram kernel is direct-Bell realizable if and only if the three-chain growth weight is not split. Exact-arithmetic certificates: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24159976.

•Nov 9, 2026•1 citation

Between quantum logic and concurrency

Luca Bernardinello, Carlo Ferigato, Lucia Pomello

We start from two closure operators defined on the elements of a special kind of partially ordered sets, called causal nets. Causal nets are used to model histories of concurrent processes, recording occurrences of local states and of events. If every maximal chain (line) of such a partially ordered set meets every maximal antichain (cut), then the two closure operators coincide, and generate a complete orthomodular lattice. In this paper we recall that, for any closed set in this lattice, every line meets either it or its orthocomplement in the lattice, and show that to any line, a two-valued state on the lattice can be associated. Starting from this result, we delineate a logical language whose formulas are interpreted over closed sets of a causal net, where every line induces an assignment of truth values to formulas. The resulting logic is non-classical; we show that maximal antichains in a causal net are associated to Boolean (hence “classical”) substructures of the overall quantum logic. 1

•Jan 1, 2012•1 citation

The Entanglement Closure Theorem: Nonseparable Future Histories, Bell Correlations, and No-Signalling in pq-Spacetime

Adam Alexander Dick

This is Paper 142 in the Anaxiomatic Mechanics / pq-Spacetime stack. It develops a finite mechanical account of quantum entanglement within pq-spacetime. Entanglement is identified with the persistence of a non-factorable family of admissible future histories. Two measurement regions can therefore appear as separate local systems in emergent spacetime while still remaining projections of one joint finite closure problem. Bell inequality violation follows because the joint outcomes are not generated by two independent local completion families. No-signalling is nevertheless preserved because complete changes to a distant measurement boundary do not alter the local marginal outcome weights. The paper establishes the Entanglement Closure Theorem and distinguishes microscopic non-factorability from observable entanglement after coarse-graining into stable measurement records. It also gives an explicit minimal singlet construction using two opposed history fibers carrying the relevant four-phase weights. The resulting finite ledger is antisymmetric, nonseparable, and exactly balanced at each local wing. Complete changes of basis on the distant side preserve those local marginals. Using the previously derived Hilbert-space and beta-Dirac bridges of pq-spacetime, the paper recovers the familiar spinor overlap law, the quantum singlet correlation, the maximal Bell-CHSH value, monogamy of maximal entanglement, and decoherence through environmental boundary enlargement. The analysis also explains why no preferred measurement ordering is required and why entanglement remains compatible with relativistic causality. The resulting picture is direct. Entangled systems do not exchange superluminal messages, carry classical answer sheets, or require a force acting across space. Their local outcomes arise from one shared finite admissibility structure whose joint correlations are nonlocal while its controllable local statistics remain causal. Entanglement is therefore physically real, nonclassical, and nonlocal in correlation, but not a signalling mechanism.

•Aug 3, 2026•0 citations

Bell Causality and Operational Rigidity in Quantum Sequential Growth: What noncommuting transition operators can do on reachable causal-set histories

Thomas G Hamilton

A quantum sequential-growth dynamics should allow interference between causal-set histories while respecting the causal and relabelling principles that constrain classical growth. Recent work on causal-past-ordered Bell causality (CPOBC) allows noncommuting transition operators, raising a physical question: can this algebraic freedom act nontrivially on histories that the dynamics actually prepares? For invertible operator-valued growth satisfying the operator Markov sum rule and strict state-vector covariance, we prove a dimension-independent answer for immediate sibling births. At every reached parent with at least two elements, the gregarious operators of its children act identically on the parent's state, and all same-parent transition commutators annihilate that state. The proof uses only source-faithful spectator reductions; it assumes neither operator-level covariance nor global factorization. An all-stage dark-sector model shows why this is not a theorem of operator commutativity. The local conclusion strengthens to the full cyclic module generated by the transitions of any fixed reached parent, ruling out an irreducible transition algebra on that parent for carrier dimension at least two. Conditional reductions and three-dimensional examples delineate the surviving possibilities, including a measure-level effect at the exceptional singleton junction. To our knowledge, this on-state rigidity consequence has not previously been isolated for this CPOBC convention. We identify, but do not resolve, the question of independent non-sibling quantum-measure effects at later births. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds seven standalone Python scripts that reproduce every finite-stage computation in the paper, using exact rational or algebraic-number arithmetic. It also contains logs, result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle, create an empty folder, and from it run: python -I ../certificates/run_all.py. All outputs are written to the current folder. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Companion to T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788.

•Nov 6, 2026•1 citation
The incomparability polarity of a finite poset P yields a complete ortholattice L(P) of polarity-closed sets. The map from P to L(P) is the STANDARD closed-set / polarity-closed ortholattice of an orthogonality space, with incomparability as orthogonality. It is not a new causal logic. What is new is the covering-specific image of that functor: Boolean on tree-orders, the non-modular non-orthomodular hexagon after a merge-induced zigzag, and no injective ortholattice embedding into the projection lattice of any Hilbert space when L(P) is not orthomodular. Covering histories are finite posets of the mathematical type of finite causal sets. They are not identified with physical spacetime. Covering birth is not Rideout-Sorkin sequential growth. Companion Paper 30 is a different exclusion theorem (sprinkling versus covering support and Rideout-Sorkin CSG); cite 10.5281/zenodo.23385450. This note does not derive quantum mechanics, Hilbert space, spacetime, or a unique sequential growth law. New child record. Never is-new-version-of the parent programme manuscript.
Since 1933, when Kolmogorov laid the foundations for probability and statistics as we know them today [1], it has been recognized that propositions asserting that such and such an event occurred as a consequence of the execution of a particular random experiment tend to band together and form a Boolean algebra. In 1936, Birkhoff and von Neumann [2] suggested that the so-called logic of quantum mechanics should not be a Boolean algebra, but rather should form what is now called a modular ortholattice [3]. Presumably, the departure from Boolean algebras encountered in quantum mechanics can be attributed to the fact that in quantum mechanics, one must consider more than one physical experiment, e.g., an experiment measuring position, an experiment measuring charge, an experiment measuring momentum, etc., and, because of the uncertainty principle, these experiments need not admit a common refinement in terms of which the Kolmogorov theory is directly applicable. Mackey's Axioms I–VI for quantum mechanics [4] imply that the logic of quantum mechanics should be a σ-orthocomplete orthomodular poset [5]. Most contemporary practitioners of quantum logic seem to agree that a quantum logic is (at least) an orthomodular poset [6], [7], [8], [9], [10] or some variation thereof [11]. P. D. Finch [12] has shown that every completely orthomodular poset is the logic arising from sets of Boolean logics, where these sets have a structure similar to the structures generally given to quantum logic. In all of these versions of quantum logic, a fundamental relation, the relation of compatibility or commutativity, plays a decisive role.
Abstract States of quantum systems correspond to vectors in a Hilbert space and observations to closed subspaces. Hence, this logic corresponds to the algebra of closed subspaces of a Hilbert space. This can be considered as a complete lattice with orthocomplementation, but it is not distributive. It satisfies a weaker condition, the so-called orthomodularity. Later on, it was recognized that joins in this structure need not exist provided the subspaces are not orthogonal. Hence, the resulting structure need not be a lattice but a so-called orthomodular poset, more generally an orthoposet only. For orthoposets, we introduce a binary relation Δ\mathrel \DeltaΔ and a binary operator d(x,y)d(x,y)d(x,y) that are generalizations of the binary relation C\textrm{C}C and the commutator c(x,y)c(x,y)c(x,y), respectively, known for orthomodular lattices. We characterize orthomodular posets among orthogonal posets. Moreover, we describe connections between the relations Δ\mathrel \DeltaΔ and ↔\leftrightarrow↔ (the latter was introduced by P. Pták and S. Pulmannová) and the operator d(x,y)d(x,y)d(x,y). In addition, we investigate certain orthomodular posets of subsets of a finite set. In particular, we describe maximal orthomodular sublattices and Boolean subalgebras of such orthomodular posets. Finally, we study properties of Δ\DeltaΔ-blocks with respect to Boolean subalgebras and distributive subposets they include.
Classical Rideout–Sorkin growth is constrained by Bell-type spectator independence, whose equivalent scalar formulations need not remain equivalent for noncommuting quantum transitions. We ask which comparison domains matter for the finite-cylinder predictions of causal-past-ordered quantum sequential growth. Four conventions are distinguished: own-core, direct, source-faithful, and broad. With invertible finite-dimensional transitions, an operator Markov sum rule, and strict covariance of reached vectors, direct Bell implies a parent-independent precursor factorization and a faithful commutative algebra on the reached module. This yields an algebra-valued Rideout–Sorkin reconstruction with a single exceptional junction correction. Although the four conventions have strictly different full-matrix solution classes, the operator defects in three separating examples are invisible on reached states. By contrast, an explicit all-stage rank-two own-core model violates a direct-Bell graft constraint at the level of its Gram kernel, establishing a genuine predictive separation. An all-stage broad-Bell example and a general visibility criterion show that the junction correction can also affect finite-cylinder interference. These results distinguish full operator identities from reached dynamics and coherent finite-cylinder data; they do not claim an extension to covariant infinite-history events. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds ten standalone Python scripts that check every finite computation cited in the paper using exact integer and rational arithmetic, together with their result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle and, inside its folder, run: python3 run_all.py. It verifies the checksums, runs all ten certificates and reports ALL PASS. The all-stage theorems are proved in the manuscript; the scripts are finite checks. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Third paper in a series, following T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788, and "Bell causality and operational rigidity in quantum sequential growth", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.24006143.Version 2 (13 November 2026): revised for submission to Physical Review D. Adds a mechanism theorem for own-core predictive separation in a stated class of complete models: all normalized precursor factors commute, the only possible obstruction is the two-chain graft, all nine birth-six target pairs are decided, and the complete Gram kernel is direct-Bell realizable if and only if the three-chain growth weight is not split. Exact-arithmetic certificates: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24159976.
We start from two closure operators defined on the elements of a special kind of partially ordered sets, called causal nets. Causal nets are used to model histories of concurrent processes, recording occurrences of local states and of events. If every maximal chain (line) of such a partially ordered set meets every maximal antichain (cut), then the two closure operators coincide, and generate a complete orthomodular lattice. In this paper we recall that, for any closed set in this lattice, every line meets either it or its orthocomplement in the lattice, and show that to any line, a two-valued state on the lattice can be associated. Starting from this result, we delineate a logical language whose formulas are interpreted over closed sets of a causal net, where every line induces an assignment of truth values to formulas. The resulting logic is non-classical; we show that maximal antichains in a causal net are associated to Boolean (hence “classical”) substructures of the overall quantum logic. 1
This is Paper 142 in the Anaxiomatic Mechanics / pq-Spacetime stack. It develops a finite mechanical account of quantum entanglement within pq-spacetime. Entanglement is identified with the persistence of a non-factorable family of admissible future histories. Two measurement regions can therefore appear as separate local systems in emergent spacetime while still remaining projections of one joint finite closure problem. Bell inequality violation follows because the joint outcomes are not generated by two independent local completion families. No-signalling is nevertheless preserved because complete changes to a distant measurement boundary do not alter the local marginal outcome weights. The paper establishes the Entanglement Closure Theorem and distinguishes microscopic non-factorability from observable entanglement after coarse-graining into stable measurement records. It also gives an explicit minimal singlet construction using two opposed history fibers carrying the relevant four-phase weights. The resulting finite ledger is antisymmetric, nonseparable, and exactly balanced at each local wing. Complete changes of basis on the distant side preserve those local marginals. Using the previously derived Hilbert-space and beta-Dirac bridges of pq-spacetime, the paper recovers the familiar spinor overlap law, the quantum singlet correlation, the maximal Bell-CHSH value, monogamy of maximal entanglement, and decoherence through environmental boundary enlargement. The analysis also explains why no preferred measurement ordering is required and why entanglement remains compatible with relativistic causality. The resulting picture is direct. Entangled systems do not exchange superluminal messages, carry classical answer sheets, or require a force acting across space. Their local outcomes arise from one shared finite admissibility structure whose joint correlations are nonlocal while its controllable local statistics remain causal. Entanglement is therefore physically real, nonclassical, and nonlocal in correlation, but not a signalling mechanism.
A quantum sequential-growth dynamics should allow interference between causal-set histories while respecting the causal and relabelling principles that constrain classical growth. Recent work on causal-past-ordered Bell causality (CPOBC) allows noncommuting transition operators, raising a physical question: can this algebraic freedom act nontrivially on histories that the dynamics actually prepares? For invertible operator-valued growth satisfying the operator Markov sum rule and strict state-vector covariance, we prove a dimension-independent answer for immediate sibling births. At every reached parent with at least two elements, the gregarious operators of its children act identically on the parent's state, and all same-parent transition commutators annihilate that state. The proof uses only source-faithful spectator reductions; it assumes neither operator-level covariance nor global factorization. An all-stage dark-sector model shows why this is not a theorem of operator commutativity. The local conclusion strengthens to the full cyclic module generated by the transitions of any fixed reached parent, ruling out an irreducible transition algebra on that parent for carrier dimension at least two. Conditional reductions and three-dimensional examples delineate the surviving possibilities, including a measure-level effect at the exceptional singleton junction. To our knowledge, this on-state rigidity consequence has not previously been isolated for this CPOBC convention. We identify, but do not resolve, the question of independent non-sibling quantum-measure effects at later births. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds seven standalone Python scripts that reproduce every finite-stage computation in the paper, using exact rational or algebraic-number arithmetic. It also contains logs, result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle, create an empty folder, and from it run: python -I ../certificates/run_all.py. All outputs are written to the current folder. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Companion to T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788.