Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Imaginary weak values and the Hubble diagram

João Magueijo, Michael Fine

Published Oct 14, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Imaginary weak values are a peculiarity of standard quantum mechanics subject to post-selection and weak measurements. We examine their possible role and physical meaning in teleological or post-selected quantum cosmology, in the context of the Hubble diagram. We only consider the linear Hubble diagram, controlled by the Hubble parameter and the redshift effect. We set up a variety of von Neumann models entangling the geometry with different pointers, either upstream, via the redshift itself, or downstream, via the instruments used to measure the arriving frequency of calibrated lines. We find that the AAV (Aharonov, Albert and Vaidman) formula for weak values remains valid in these models, even though the assumptions are wildly different. Hence the imaginary part of the weak value of the Hubble parameter translates into a shift in the conjugate variable of the pointer, and we evaluate the very diverse expressions this takes for the various meters considered. Furthermore, in situations where meters are coupled, the effect may only appear in the first meter explicitly sensitive to the geometry and, unlike real weak values, need not propagate down the chain. The imaginary weak value is therefore distinctly in the ``eye of the beholder'', as a result of quantum measurement theory. This could distinguish teleological quantum explanations of cosmic acceleration from dark-energy alternatives that reproduce the same real Hubble diagram.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23371235

Related papers

Role of weak values in strong measurements

F. De Zela

The physical meaning of the quantum weak value still remains a matter of debate. Originally introduced by Aharonov et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 1351 (1988).] as another counterintuitive feature of quantum mechanics, it eventually evolved into a practical tool that is widely used. The theoretical framework in which weak values were introduced was given by von Neumann's model of quantum measurements. In this model, a system is submitted to measurement by coupling it to a ``pointer,'' or meter. In the weak-coupling regime, one may perform a low-order Taylor expansion for the evolution operator of the system and meter. This standard approach ties weak values with weak couplings and weak measurements. We report closed-form expressions that can be used to untie weak values from weak measurements. The regime of strong measurements thereby becomes accessible to weak values, without leaving the framework in which the latter were originally introduced. The reported results should also help us to better understand the physical meaning of weak values.

Physical Review A•Apr 4, 2022•13 citations

Weak measurement: Effect of the detector dynamics

Antonio Di Lorenzo, J. Carlos Egues

The contribution of the detector dynamics to the weak measurement is analyzed. According to the usual theory [Y. Aharonov, D. Z. Albert, and L. Vaidman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 1351 (1988)] the outcome of a weak measurement with preselection and postselection can be expressed as the real part of a complex number: the weak value. By accounting for the Hamiltonian evolution of the detector, here we find that there is a contribution proportional to the imaginary part of the weak value to the outcome of the weak measurement. This is due to the coherence of the probe being essential for the concept of complex weak value to be meaningful. As a particular example, we consider the measurement of a spin component and find that the contribution of the imaginary part of the weak value is sizable.

arXiv:0801.1814•Physical Review A•Apr 16, 2008•52 citations

Weak values in a classical theory with an epistemic restriction

Angela Karanjai, Eric G. Cavalcanti, Stephen D. Bartlett +1 more

Weak measurement of a quantum system followed by postselection based on a subsequent strong measurement gives rise to a quantity called the weak value : a complex number for which the interpretation has long been debated. We analyse the procedure of weak measurement and postselection, and the interpretation of the associated weak value, using a theory of classical mechanics supplemented by an epistemic restriction that is known to be operationally equivalent to a subtheory of quantum mechanics. Both the real and imaginary components of the weak value appear as phase space displacements in the postselected expectation values of the measurement device's position and momentum distributions, and we recover the same displacements as in the quantum case by studying the corresponding evolution in our theory of classical mechanics with an epistemic restriction. By using this epistemically restricted theory, we gain insight into the appearance of the weak value as a result of the statistical effects of post selection, and this provides us with an operational interpretation of the weak value, both its real and imaginary parts. We find that the imaginary part of the weak value is a measure of how much postselection biases the mean phase space distribution for a given amount of measurement disturbance. All such biases proportional to the imaginary part of the weak value vanish in the limit where disturbance due to measurement goes to zero. Our analysis also offers intuitive insight into how measurement disturbance can be minimized and the limits of weak measurement.

arXiv:1503.05203•New Journal of Physics•Jul 14, 2015•14 citations

The real and imaginary parts of a weak value appearing as back-actions via a post-selection

Kazuhiro Yokota

In a weak measurement the real and imaginary parts of a weak value participate in the shifts of the complementary variables of a pointer. While the real part represents the value of an observable in the limit of zero measurement strength, the imaginary one is regarded as the back-action due to the measurement with a post-selection, which has an influence on the post-selection probability. In this paper I give a case in which a real part could also appear as such a back-action in a post-selection probability on an equal footing with an imaginary one. It is also shown that both of the real and imaginary parts can be inferred by observing the probability in practice, which has an advantage that an additional system of a pointer is not needed.

arXiv:1909.04806•Sep 11, 2019•1 citation

Complex weak values in quantum measurement

Richard Jozsa

In the weak value formalism of Aharonov et al., the weak value ${A}_{w}$ of any observable $A$ is generally a complex number. We derive a physical interpretation of its value in terms of the shift in the measurement pointer's mean position and mean momentum. In particular, we show that the mean position shift contains a term jointly proportional to the imaginary part of the weak value and the rate at which the pointer is spreading in space as it enters the measurement interaction.

arXiv:0706.4207•Physical Review A•Oct 11, 2007•344 citations

Weak values beyond weak measurement

Jeff Z. Salvail

The AAV effect is the well-known phenomenon where a weak measurement followed by post-selection leads to a pointer shift proportional to the weak value of the measured observable. The effect is usually derived by considering a perturbative expansion of the time-evolution operator corresponding to the measurement. We show that the AAV effect can be instead derived given three simple conditions on the pointer states. The most important condition is that the pointer states be approximately indistinguishable. The other two conditions relate the observables used to characterize the pointer with the measured system observable. This intuitive approach does not require any model for the measurement process, but is completely consistent with the usual approach based on the von Neumann Hamiltonian. Moreover, this approach predicts and explains a new phenomenon, called weak echo, where the usual weak value behaviour can re-emerge at high interaction strengths.

arXiv:1310.4193•Oct 15, 2013•5 citations
Imaginary weak values are a peculiarity of standard quantum mechanics subject to post-selection and weak measurements. We examine their possible role and physical meaning in teleological or post-selected quantum cosmology, in the context of the Hubble diagram. We only consider the linear Hubble diagram, controlled by the Hubble parameter and the redshift effect. We set up a variety of von Neumann models entangling the geometry with different pointers, either upstream, via the redshift itself, or downstream, via the instruments used to measure the arriving frequency of calibrated lines. We find that the AAV (Aharonov, Albert and Vaidman) formula for weak values remains valid in these models, even though the assumptions are wildly different. Hence the imaginary part of the weak value of the Hubble parameter translates into a shift in the conjugate variable of the pointer, and we evaluate the very diverse expressions this takes for the various meters considered. Furthermore, in situations where meters are coupled, the effect may only appear in the first meter explicitly sensitive to the geometry and, unlike real weak values, need not propagate down the chain. The imaginary weak value is therefore distinctly in the ``eye of the beholder'', as a result of quantum measurement theory. This could distinguish teleological quantum explanations of cosmic acceleration from dark-energy alternatives that reproduce the same real Hubble diagram.
The physical meaning of the quantum weak value still remains a matter of debate. Originally introduced by Aharonov et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 1351 (1988).] as another counterintuitive feature of quantum mechanics, it eventually evolved into a practical tool that is widely used. The theoretical framework in which weak values were introduced was given by von Neumann's model of quantum measurements. In this model, a system is submitted to measurement by coupling it to a ``pointer,'' or meter. In the weak-coupling regime, one may perform a low-order Taylor expansion for the evolution operator of the system and meter. This standard approach ties weak values with weak couplings and weak measurements. We report closed-form expressions that can be used to untie weak values from weak measurements. The regime of strong measurements thereby becomes accessible to weak values, without leaving the framework in which the latter were originally introduced. The reported results should also help us to better understand the physical meaning of weak values.
The contribution of the detector dynamics to the weak measurement is analyzed. According to the usual theory [Y. Aharonov, D. Z. Albert, and L. Vaidman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 1351 (1988)] the outcome of a weak measurement with preselection and postselection can be expressed as the real part of a complex number: the weak value. By accounting for the Hamiltonian evolution of the detector, here we find that there is a contribution proportional to the imaginary part of the weak value to the outcome of the weak measurement. This is due to the coherence of the probe being essential for the concept of complex weak value to be meaningful. As a particular example, we consider the measurement of a spin component and find that the contribution of the imaginary part of the weak value is sizable.
Weak measurement of a quantum system followed by postselection based on a subsequent strong measurement gives rise to a quantity called the weak value : a complex number for which the interpretation has long been debated. We analyse the procedure of weak measurement and postselection, and the interpretation of the associated weak value, using a theory of classical mechanics supplemented by an epistemic restriction that is known to be operationally equivalent to a subtheory of quantum mechanics. Both the real and imaginary components of the weak value appear as phase space displacements in the postselected expectation values of the measurement device's position and momentum distributions, and we recover the same displacements as in the quantum case by studying the corresponding evolution in our theory of classical mechanics with an epistemic restriction. By using this epistemically restricted theory, we gain insight into the appearance of the weak value as a result of the statistical effects of post selection, and this provides us with an operational interpretation of the weak value, both its real and imaginary parts. We find that the imaginary part of the weak value is a measure of how much postselection biases the mean phase space distribution for a given amount of measurement disturbance. All such biases proportional to the imaginary part of the weak value vanish in the limit where disturbance due to measurement goes to zero. Our analysis also offers intuitive insight into how measurement disturbance can be minimized and the limits of weak measurement.
In a weak measurement the real and imaginary parts of a weak value participate in the shifts of the complementary variables of a pointer. While the real part represents the value of an observable in the limit of zero measurement strength, the imaginary one is regarded as the back-action due to the measurement with a post-selection, which has an influence on the post-selection probability. In this paper I give a case in which a real part could also appear as such a back-action in a post-selection probability on an equal footing with an imaginary one. It is also shown that both of the real and imaginary parts can be inferred by observing the probability in practice, which has an advantage that an additional system of a pointer is not needed.
In the weak value formalism of Aharonov et al., the weak value Aw{A}_{w}Aw​ of any observable AAA is generally a complex number. We derive a physical interpretation of its value in terms of the shift in the measurement pointer's mean position and mean momentum. In particular, we show that the mean position shift contains a term jointly proportional to the imaginary part of the weak value and the rate at which the pointer is spreading in space as it enters the measurement interaction.
The AAV effect is the well-known phenomenon where a weak measurement followed by post-selection leads to a pointer shift proportional to the weak value of the measured observable. The effect is usually derived by considering a perturbative expansion of the time-evolution operator corresponding to the measurement. We show that the AAV effect can be instead derived given three simple conditions on the pointer states. The most important condition is that the pointer states be approximately indistinguishable. The other two conditions relate the observables used to characterize the pointer with the measured system observable. This intuitive approach does not require any model for the measurement process, but is completely consistent with the usual approach based on the von Neumann Hamiltonian. Moreover, this approach predicts and explains a new phenomenon, called weak echo, where the usual weak value behaviour can re-emerge at high interaction strengths.