Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

An independent certified computation excluding four mutually unbiased bases in dimension six

Manvir Jaswal

Published Oct 13, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We show that there are no four mutually unbiased bases in ℂ⁶, so that the maximum number of such bases is three. The proof is computer-assisted and assumes that the machine on which the computation ran carried out binary64 arithmetic correctly, as made precise in Section 3.1. It carries out the discretization proof of a recent preprint by OpenAI, which has not appeared in a refereed journal. Our programs are written from the text of the preprint, and we prove every statement of the preprint that our proof uses. Four mutually unbiased bases could be taken to consist of the standard basis, the columns of a complex Hadamard matrix divided by √6, and two further bases. Finitely many balls in phase coordinates cover all complex Hadamard matrices of order six up to equivalence, and on each small ball a finite search shows that these two further bases do not exist. Every inequality that the programs decide in order to reject a case or to cover a set of matrices is decided in exact integer arithmetic or in interval arithmetic with outward rounding. The programs, with the logs and data of the computation, are deposited.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23255857

Related papers

The maximum number of mutually unbiased bases in dimension six

OpenAI

We prove that the maximum number of mutually unbiased orthonormal bases in ℂ6 is three, resolving Zauner's dimension-six MUB conjecture. The upper bound is computer-assisted: under the stated binary64 arithmetic and compiler conditions, a complete execution of the documented verification pipeline excludes four arbitrary complex bases.

•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

Using topology to reveal all mutually unbiased bases in dimension six

Mateo Cárdenes Wuttig, Joseph Tindall

Mutually unbiased bases (MUBs) describe complementary quantum measurements: certainty in one basis gives no information about the others. In dimension six, triples of MUBs are known, but whether a fourth basis could exist remained unresolved for over three decades. OpenAI recently reported a proof that none exists. Here we use the topology of the space of complex Hadamard matrices, which describe transitions between MUBs, to characterize all sets in dimension six. We prove that every mutually unbiased triple belongs to a two-parameter family or is a single isolated triple built from the Fourier matrix. Since none of them extend to a fourth basis, this also proves that no four MUBs exist. Our proof rests on a new topological result that all order-six complex Hadamard matrices except Tao's form a connected space. Connectedness reduces the classification of triples to finitely many overlapping four-dimensional phase balls. We certify with interval arithmetic that these balls cover the space and for every pair of MUBs represented in a ball, we then determine all third bases that extend it. Dimension six is now the first non-prime-power dimension in which all sets of MUBs are classified.

arXiv:2611.06917•Nov 4, 2026•1 citation

Constructing mutually unbiased bases in dimension six

STEPHEN D. BRIERLEY, Stefan Weigert

The density matrix of a qudit may be reconstructed with optimal efficiency if the expectation values of a specific set of observables are known. In dimension six, the required observables only exist if it is possible to identify six mutually unbiased complex $(6\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}6)$ Hadamard matrices. Prescribing a first Hadamard matrix, we construct all others mutually unbiased to it, using algebraic computations performed by a computer program. We repeat this calculation many times, sampling all known complex Hadamard matrices, and we never find more than two that are mutually unbiased. This result adds considerable support to the conjecture that no seven mutually unbiased bases exist in dimension six.

arXiv:0901.4051•Physical Review A•May 14, 2009•119 citations

More mutually unbiased bases

Mateo Cárdenes Wuttig, Joseph Tindall

Mutually unbiased bases (MUBs) describe quantum measurements for which certainty in one basis gives uniform outcomes in the others. Their maximum number remains unknown in dimensions that are not powers of a prime. We introduce an ansatz that, in many dimensions, allows us to construct more MUBs than have previously been found. Each basis in the ansatz consists of a diagonal phase matrix applied to a fixed unitary, which is a tensor product of Fourier matrices and, optionally, any real Hadamard matrix. This construction yields five MUBs in dimension 12, six in dimensions 48, 96, and 192, seven in dimensions 36 and 108, and ten in dimension 648. These bases can then be extended to exceed the tensor product bound, asymptotically, in every eighteenth dimension. Moreover, we show that Paley's real Hadamard matrix can be used to construct $q+1$ bases in dimension $d = q(q+1)$ for every prime power $q\equiv3\pmod4$. This count grows as $\sqrt d$ and cannot be exceeded by tensor products of smaller sets.

quant-pharXiv:2609.40311•Oct 1, 2026•2 citations

The Maximum Number of Mutually Unbiased Bases in Dimension Six - Pompetzki, Chris

Christopher Pompetzki

We prove that the maximum number of mutually unbiased bases in complex dimension sixis three. The proof is structural and does not rely on exhaustive classification, numerical search,or probabilistic arguments. The key ingredients are: (1) a Laurent–polynomial obstructionblocking the Haagerup family of complex Hadamard matrices, (2) an analogous obstructionblocking the 2-circulant family, and (3) a structural Bridge Lemma showing that any complexHadamard matrix arising as a transition matrix in a MUB triplet must exhibit an opposite-pairphenomenon in its row-ratio multisets. Combined with the recognition theorem of Matszangoszand Sz¨oll˝osi, this forces all MUB-triplet transition matrices in dimension six into families alreadyobstructed, yielding a contradiction to the existence of a fourth mutually unbiased basis.

•Dec 13, 2025•0 citations

Mutually unbiased bases and Hadamard matrices of order six

Ingemar Bengtsson, Wojciech Bruzda, Åsa Ericsson +3 more

We report on a search for mutually unbiased bases (MUBs) in six dimensions. We find only triplets of MUBs, and thus do not come close to the theoretical upper bound 7. However, we point out that the natural habitat for sets of MUBs is the set of all complex Hadamard matrices of the given order, and we introduce a natural notion of distance between bases in Hilbert space. This allows us to draw a detailed map of where in the landscape the MUB triplets are situated. We use available tools, such as the theory of the discrete Fourier transform, to organize our results. Finally, we present some evidence for the conjecture that there exists a four dimensional family of complex Hadamard matrices of order 6. If this conjecture is true the landscape in which one may search for MUBs is much larger than previously thought.

arXiv:quant-ph/0610161•Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 2007•130 citations
We show that there are no four mutually unbiased bases in ℂ⁶, so that the maximum number of such bases is three. The proof is computer-assisted and assumes that the machine on which the computation ran carried out binary64 arithmetic correctly, as made precise in Section 3.1. It carries out the discretization proof of a recent preprint by OpenAI, which has not appeared in a refereed journal. Our programs are written from the text of the preprint, and we prove every statement of the preprint that our proof uses. Four mutually unbiased bases could be taken to consist of the standard basis, the columns of a complex Hadamard matrix divided by √6, and two further bases. Finitely many balls in phase coordinates cover all complex Hadamard matrices of order six up to equivalence, and on each small ball a finite search shows that these two further bases do not exist. Every inequality that the programs decide in order to reject a case or to cover a set of matrices is decided in exact integer arithmetic or in interval arithmetic with outward rounding. The programs, with the logs and data of the computation, are deposited.
Mutually unbiased bases (MUBs) describe complementary quantum measurements: certainty in one basis gives no information about the others. In dimension six, triples of MUBs are known, but whether a fourth basis could exist remained unresolved for over three decades. OpenAI recently reported a proof that none exists. Here we use the topology of the space of complex Hadamard matrices, which describe transitions between MUBs, to characterize all sets in dimension six. We prove that every mutually unbiased triple belongs to a two-parameter family or is a single isolated triple built from the Fourier matrix. Since none of them extend to a fourth basis, this also proves that no four MUBs exist. Our proof rests on a new topological result that all order-six complex Hadamard matrices except Tao's form a connected space. Connectedness reduces the classification of triples to finitely many overlapping four-dimensional phase balls. We certify with interval arithmetic that these balls cover the space and for every pair of MUBs represented in a ball, we then determine all third bases that extend it. Dimension six is now the first non-prime-power dimension in which all sets of MUBs are classified.
The density matrix of a qudit may be reconstructed with optimal efficiency if the expectation values of a specific set of observables are known. In dimension six, the required observables only exist if it is possible to identify six mutually unbiased complex $(6\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}6)$ Hadamard matrices. Prescribing a first Hadamard matrix, we construct all others mutually unbiased to it, using algebraic computations performed by a computer program. We repeat this calculation many times, sampling all known complex Hadamard matrices, and we never find more than two that are mutually unbiased. This result adds considerable support to the conjecture that no seven mutually unbiased bases exist in dimension six.
Mutually unbiased bases (MUBs) describe quantum measurements for which certainty in one basis gives uniform outcomes in the others. Their maximum number remains unknown in dimensions that are not powers of a prime. We introduce an ansatz that, in many dimensions, allows us to construct more MUBs than have previously been found. Each basis in the ansatz consists of a diagonal phase matrix applied to a fixed unitary, which is a tensor product of Fourier matrices and, optionally, any real Hadamard matrix. This construction yields five MUBs in dimension 12, six in dimensions 48, 96, and 192, seven in dimensions 36 and 108, and ten in dimension 648. These bases can then be extended to exceed the tensor product bound, asymptotically, in every eighteenth dimension. Moreover, we show that Paley's real Hadamard matrix can be used to construct q+1q+1q+1 bases in dimension d=q(q+1)d = q(q+1)d=q(q+1) for every prime power q≡3(mod4)q\equiv3\pmod4q≡3(mod4). This count grows as d\sqrt dd​ and cannot be exceeded by tensor products of smaller sets.
We prove that the maximum number of mutually unbiased bases in complex dimension sixis three. The proof is structural and does not rely on exhaustive classification, numerical search,or probabilistic arguments. The key ingredients are: (1) a Laurent–polynomial obstructionblocking the Haagerup family of complex Hadamard matrices, (2) an analogous obstructionblocking the 2-circulant family, and (3) a structural Bridge Lemma showing that any complexHadamard matrix arising as a transition matrix in a MUB triplet must exhibit an opposite-pairphenomenon in its row-ratio multisets. Combined with the recognition theorem of Matszangoszand Sz¨oll˝osi, this forces all MUB-triplet transition matrices in dimension six into families alreadyobstructed, yielding a contradiction to the existence of a fourth mutually unbiased basis.
We report on a search for mutually unbiased bases (MUBs) in six dimensions. We find only triplets of MUBs, and thus do not come close to the theoretical upper bound 7. However, we point out that the natural habitat for sets of MUBs is the set of all complex Hadamard matrices of the given order, and we introduce a natural notion of distance between bases in Hilbert space. This allows us to draw a detailed map of where in the landscape the MUB triplets are situated. We use available tools, such as the theory of the discrete Fourier transform, to organize our results. Finally, we present some evidence for the conjecture that there exists a four dimensional family of complex Hadamard matrices of order 6. If this conjecture is true the landscape in which one may search for MUBs is much larger than previously thought.