Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Are electromagnetic waves always quantized? Field quanta, exchange quanta, and the experiments that tell them apart

Jarek Duda

Published Oct 12, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Mainstream physics says yes: the electromagnetic field is a quantum system, and even the vacuum fluctuates. But “quantized” can mean two things. Either the field itself carries quanta in flight, or only matter is quantized, with discreteness appearing in what emitters and absorbers exchange, as in direct-action electrodynamics. We sort the evidence. The photoelectric effect, Compton scattering and spectra need only quantized matter. Antibunching, two-photon interference, squeezing, non-destructive photon counting, vacuum sampling, Bell tests and light-by-light scattering exclude a classical field, but none excludes quantum direct action. Two-photon interference follows from summing over emitter–absorber pairings, a permanent, with no quanta in flight. In its established constructions, direct action reproduces QED only with a complete future absorber, which Hoyle and Narlikar found impossible in open Friedmann models. Where light is never absorbed, the readings therefore differ. A history weight on free-ending photons acts as a photon chemical potential, and the microwave background’s blackbody spectrum bounds it at about 2×10⁻⁴. We classify delocalized radiation and propose tests: directional vacuum sampling toward the night sky, where QED predicts no difference and exchange a loss of half the vacuum term or more; a cavity photon with a sky-facing port; and a positron source between open and blocked directions.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23314126

Related papers

A QED-compatible wave theory of light, electrons, and their interactions

Henry H. Lindner

The photoelectric effect, the Compton effects, and now anticorrelation experiments have been claimed to prove that light consists of particles flying through a void. However the particle model is decisively falsified by the known wave qualities of electromagnetic radiation. Quantum Electrodynamics also uses spreading wave amplitudes; not flying particles. The evidence indicates that light is a wave and electrons are electromagnetic wave-structures that absorb and emit light in discrete wave-packets. These wave-quanta are emitted directionally and then spread in space in proportion to their wavelength. Their waves superposition with all other waves in space. In low intensity experiments, the waves that an electron in a photodetector absorbs come from the superpositioning of the source wave-quanta and background radiation. The importance of background radiation is evidenced by "dark counts". Treating electrons and the quanta they absorb and emit as particles when they are composed of waves is the source of all the paradoxes, unreality and confusion in Quantum Mechanics. The word "photon" should be replaced by "quantum" in the description of this particular electronic process. The conceptual model presented here explains the known phenomena without producing paradoxes and unifies quantum and classical electromagnetics.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Sep 8, 2011•1 citation

The Origin of the "Particle Nature" of Light — How a Continuous Transverse Wave Manifests Discrete Behavior when Coupled to Matter

卓冰 蒋

Quantum field theory describes the particle nature of electromagnetic radiation using the "photon," but has never explained why a fundamental particle exhibits such perfect wave behavior. This paper provides a complete alternative explanation: the photoelectric effect, Compton scattering, and antibunching experiments — landmark experiments considered proof of photon particle nature — require no photon concept. Quantization is not a property of light itself, but of the discrete energy level structure governing how bound electrons emit and absorb energy. Light remains a continuous transverse wave; discreteness results from electrons as "prisoners" in atomic "cages" that can only transition between specific energy steps. Waves propagate continuously and are emitted and absorbed in quantized form — the photon is not a particle, but the name of an energy-exchange event.

•Jun 18, 2026•0 citations

Genesis of quantization of matter and radiation field

Luis de la Peña, Ana María Cetto

Are we to accept quantization as a fundamental property of nature, the origin of which does not require or admit further investigation? To get an insight into this question we consider atomic systems as open systems, since they are by necessity in contact with the electromagnetic radiation field. This includes not only photonic radiation, but, more importantly for our purposes, the random zero-point or nonthermal radiation that pervades the Universe. The Heisenberg inequalities, atomic stability and the existence of discrete solutions are explained as a result of the permanent action of this field upon matter and the balance between mean absorbed and emitted powers in the equilibrium regime. A detailed study carried out along the years has led to the usual quantum-mechanical formalism as a powerful and revealing statistical description of the behavior of matter in the radiationless approximation, as well as to the radiative corrections of nonrelativistic QED. The theory presented gives thus a response to the question posed above, within a local, realist and objective framework: quantization appears as an emergent phenomenon due to the matter-field interaction.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Sep 10, 2015•0 citations

What Exactly Are Photons and Quanta?

Xiangqian Zhang, Yuchuan Xu

This paper investigates the essence of photons and quanta by reexamining the bottom layer meanings of the ultraviolet catastrophe, physical calculus, Planck constant, natural constant, energy frequency relation, photoelectric effect, Compton scattering, double slit interference, and wave particle duality. The paper argues that a quantum is not a tiny particle in the universe, and a photon is not a small ball flying through space. A quantum is a discrete fact manifested when the source endpoint opens a ledger and the receiving endpoint seals it under finite space unit refresh. A photon is the discrete readout formed when an open electromagnetic ledger is issued at the source endpoint or sealed at the receiving endpoint. In the Natural Origins framework, the root of the ultraviolet catastrophe is not the blackbody itself, but the mistaken treatment of mathematical infinitesimals as physical ontology. Space units possess finite elementary length and finite elementary frequency, and the speed of light comes from relay refresh of space units. Therefore, physical processes cannot be divided without limit into zero space and zero time. Planck constant is not an isolated patch, but the manifestation of a complete cycle action ledger. The proportional relation between energy and frequency comes from the rhythm readout by which a difference ledger drives elemental cells to complete ledger opening and sealing. The photoelectric effect shows that an open ledger must cross the material unsealing threshold by single unit energy, while Compton scattering shows that the open ledger and the closed electron ledger can reallocate their accounts. The paper further states that in double slit interference, what truly passes through the double slit is not a photon ball, but an open electromagnetic ledger. The double slit boundary rephases, reorganizes, and reissues the ledger, while screen elemental cells form bright and dark fringes according to ledger alignment and cancellation. So called wave particle duality is a misunderstanding caused by mixing the propagation layer with the settlement layer. The wave belongs to the geometric unfolding of the open ledger during propagation, while the particle belongs to the discrete fact formed after endpoint elemental cell sealing. The whole paper finally forms a unified chain: discrete ledger opening at the source endpoint, open propagation through space units, boundary reissuance, and discrete ledger sealing at the receiving endpoint. The propagation ledger only transmits without retaining, elemental cell sealing generates the quantum, and endpoint readout manifests as the photon.

•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

The concept of the photon

Marlan O. Scully, Murray Sargent

The idea of the photon has stirred the imaginations of physicists ever since 1905 when Einstein originally proposed the use of light quanta to explain the photoelectric effect. This concept is formalized in the quantum theory of radiation, which has had unfailing success in explaining the interaction of electromagnetic radiation with matter, seemingly limited only by the ability of physicists to perform the indicated calculations. Nevertheless, it has its conceptual problems—various infinities and frequent misinterpretations. Consequently an increasing number of workers are asking, “to what extent is the quantized field really necessary and useful?” In fact the experimental results of the photoelectric effect were explained by G. Wentzel in 1927 without the quantum theory of radiation. Similarly most electro-optic phenomena such as stimulated emission, reaction of the emitted field on the emitting atom, resonance fluorescence, and so on, do not require the quantization of the field for their explanation. As we will see, these processes can all be quantitatively explained and physically understood in terms of the semiclassical theory of the matter–field interaction in which the electric field is treated classically while the atoms obey the laws of quantum mechanics. The quantized field is fundamentally required for accurate descriptions of certain processes involving fluctuations in the electromagnetic field: for example, spontaneous emission, the Lamb shift, the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron, and certain aspects of blackbody radiation. (The Compton effect also fits here, but see later under references 8b and c.) Here we will outline how the photon concept originated and developed, where it is not required and is often misused, and finally where it plays an essential role in the understanding of physical phenomena. In our discussion we will attempt to give a logically consistent definition of the word “photon”—a statement far more necessary than one might think, for so many contradictory uses exist of this elusive beast. In particular consider the original coining of the word by G. N. Lewis: “[because it appears to spend] only a minute fraction of its existence as a carrier of radiant energy, while the rest of the time it remains an important structural element within the atom…, I therefore take the liberty of proposing for this hypothetical new atom which is not light but plays an essential part in every process of radiation, the name photon!” (our exclamation point). Clearly the present usage of the word is very different.

Physics Today•Mar 1, 1972•148 citations

1A Brief Overview of the Quantum Theory of Electromagnetic Fields

Michael A. Parker

The study of light through the centuries has produced a number of theories and experiments. Newton advanced the corpuscular theory, building on the early Greek view of matter composed of atoms. Then Young essentially proved the wave nature of light through the interference experiments. Maxwell provided the firm theoretical basis for the wave nature. During the late 1800s and early 1900s, further experiments showed predictions based on a continuous wave led to the well-known ultraviolet catastrophe. Plank and Einstein originated and developed the notion of the photon as an elementary quantum of propagating electromagnetic (EM) energy. The first half of the 20th century saw the development of the field quantization and the quantum electrodynamics (QED). Feynmann labeled QED as ‘‘the best theory we have’’ to describe the matter-light interaction. The second half of the 20th century witnessed the development of the coherent and squeezed optical states attributable to Glauber and Yuen. The study of light and electromagnetic fields has a long history. This chapter explores the nature of light in terms of quantum optics.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 3, 2018•0 citations
Mainstream physics says yes: the electromagnetic field is a quantum system, and even the vacuum fluctuates. But “quantized” can mean two things. Either the field itself carries quanta in flight, or only matter is quantized, with discreteness appearing in what emitters and absorbers exchange, as in direct-action electrodynamics. We sort the evidence. The photoelectric effect, Compton scattering and spectra need only quantized matter. Antibunching, two-photon interference, squeezing, non-destructive photon counting, vacuum sampling, Bell tests and light-by-light scattering exclude a classical field, but none excludes quantum direct action. Two-photon interference follows from summing over emitter–absorber pairings, a permanent, with no quanta in flight. In its established constructions, direct action reproduces QED only with a complete future absorber, which Hoyle and Narlikar found impossible in open Friedmann models. Where light is never absorbed, the readings therefore differ. A history weight on free-ending photons acts as a photon chemical potential, and the microwave background’s blackbody spectrum bounds it at about 2×10⁻⁴. We classify delocalized radiation and propose tests: directional vacuum sampling toward the night sky, where QED predicts no difference and exchange a loss of half the vacuum term or more; a cavity photon with a sky-facing port; and a positron source between open and blocked directions.
The photoelectric effect, the Compton effects, and now anticorrelation experiments have been claimed to prove that light consists of particles flying through a void. However the particle model is decisively falsified by the known wave qualities of electromagnetic radiation. Quantum Electrodynamics also uses spreading wave amplitudes; not flying particles. The evidence indicates that light is a wave and electrons are electromagnetic wave-structures that absorb and emit light in discrete wave-packets. These wave-quanta are emitted directionally and then spread in space in proportion to their wavelength. Their waves superposition with all other waves in space. In low intensity experiments, the waves that an electron in a photodetector absorbs come from the superpositioning of the source wave-quanta and background radiation. The importance of background radiation is evidenced by "dark counts". Treating electrons and the quanta they absorb and emit as particles when they are composed of waves is the source of all the paradoxes, unreality and confusion in Quantum Mechanics. The word "photon" should be replaced by "quantum" in the description of this particular electronic process. The conceptual model presented here explains the known phenomena without producing paradoxes and unifies quantum and classical electromagnetics.
Quantum field theory describes the particle nature of electromagnetic radiation using the "photon," but has never explained why a fundamental particle exhibits such perfect wave behavior. This paper provides a complete alternative explanation: the photoelectric effect, Compton scattering, and antibunching experiments — landmark experiments considered proof of photon particle nature — require no photon concept. Quantization is not a property of light itself, but of the discrete energy level structure governing how bound electrons emit and absorb energy. Light remains a continuous transverse wave; discreteness results from electrons as "prisoners" in atomic "cages" that can only transition between specific energy steps. Waves propagate continuously and are emitted and absorbed in quantized form — the photon is not a particle, but the name of an energy-exchange event.
Are we to accept quantization as a fundamental property of nature, the origin of which does not require or admit further investigation? To get an insight into this question we consider atomic systems as open systems, since they are by necessity in contact with the electromagnetic radiation field. This includes not only photonic radiation, but, more importantly for our purposes, the random zero-point or nonthermal radiation that pervades the Universe. The Heisenberg inequalities, atomic stability and the existence of discrete solutions are explained as a result of the permanent action of this field upon matter and the balance between mean absorbed and emitted powers in the equilibrium regime. A detailed study carried out along the years has led to the usual quantum-mechanical formalism as a powerful and revealing statistical description of the behavior of matter in the radiationless approximation, as well as to the radiative corrections of nonrelativistic QED. The theory presented gives thus a response to the question posed above, within a local, realist and objective framework: quantization appears as an emergent phenomenon due to the matter-field interaction.
This paper investigates the essence of photons and quanta by reexamining the bottom layer meanings of the ultraviolet catastrophe, physical calculus, Planck constant, natural constant, energy frequency relation, photoelectric effect, Compton scattering, double slit interference, and wave particle duality. The paper argues that a quantum is not a tiny particle in the universe, and a photon is not a small ball flying through space. A quantum is a discrete fact manifested when the source endpoint opens a ledger and the receiving endpoint seals it under finite space unit refresh. A photon is the discrete readout formed when an open electromagnetic ledger is issued at the source endpoint or sealed at the receiving endpoint. In the Natural Origins framework, the root of the ultraviolet catastrophe is not the blackbody itself, but the mistaken treatment of mathematical infinitesimals as physical ontology. Space units possess finite elementary length and finite elementary frequency, and the speed of light comes from relay refresh of space units. Therefore, physical processes cannot be divided without limit into zero space and zero time. Planck constant is not an isolated patch, but the manifestation of a complete cycle action ledger. The proportional relation between energy and frequency comes from the rhythm readout by which a difference ledger drives elemental cells to complete ledger opening and sealing. The photoelectric effect shows that an open ledger must cross the material unsealing threshold by single unit energy, while Compton scattering shows that the open ledger and the closed electron ledger can reallocate their accounts. The paper further states that in double slit interference, what truly passes through the double slit is not a photon ball, but an open electromagnetic ledger. The double slit boundary rephases, reorganizes, and reissues the ledger, while screen elemental cells form bright and dark fringes according to ledger alignment and cancellation. So called wave particle duality is a misunderstanding caused by mixing the propagation layer with the settlement layer. The wave belongs to the geometric unfolding of the open ledger during propagation, while the particle belongs to the discrete fact formed after endpoint elemental cell sealing. The whole paper finally forms a unified chain: discrete ledger opening at the source endpoint, open propagation through space units, boundary reissuance, and discrete ledger sealing at the receiving endpoint. The propagation ledger only transmits without retaining, elemental cell sealing generates the quantum, and endpoint readout manifests as the photon.
The idea of the photon has stirred the imaginations of physicists ever since 1905 when Einstein originally proposed the use of light quanta to explain the photoelectric effect. This concept is formalized in the quantum theory of radiation, which has had unfailing success in explaining the interaction of electromagnetic radiation with matter, seemingly limited only by the ability of physicists to perform the indicated calculations. Nevertheless, it has its conceptual problems—various infinities and frequent misinterpretations. Consequently an increasing number of workers are asking, “to what extent is the quantized field really necessary and useful?” In fact the experimental results of the photoelectric effect were explained by G. Wentzel in 1927 without the quantum theory of radiation. Similarly most electro-optic phenomena such as stimulated emission, reaction of the emitted field on the emitting atom, resonance fluorescence, and so on, do not require the quantization of the field for their explanation. As we will see, these processes can all be quantitatively explained and physically understood in terms of the semiclassical theory of the matter–field interaction in which the electric field is treated classically while the atoms obey the laws of quantum mechanics. The quantized field is fundamentally required for accurate descriptions of certain processes involving fluctuations in the electromagnetic field: for example, spontaneous emission, the Lamb shift, the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron, and certain aspects of blackbody radiation. (The Compton effect also fits here, but see later under references 8b and c.) Here we will outline how the photon concept originated and developed, where it is not required and is often misused, and finally where it plays an essential role in the understanding of physical phenomena. In our discussion we will attempt to give a logically consistent definition of the word “photon”—a statement far more necessary than one might think, for so many contradictory uses exist of this elusive beast. In particular consider the original coining of the word by G. N. Lewis: “[because it appears to spend] only a minute fraction of its existence as a carrier of radiant energy, while the rest of the time it remains an important structural element within the atom…, I therefore take the liberty of proposing for this hypothetical new atom which is not light but plays an essential part in every process of radiation, the name photon!” (our exclamation point). Clearly the present usage of the word is very different.
The study of light through the centuries has produced a number of theories and experiments. Newton advanced the corpuscular theory, building on the early Greek view of matter composed of atoms. Then Young essentially proved the wave nature of light through the interference experiments. Maxwell provided the firm theoretical basis for the wave nature. During the late 1800s and early 1900s, further experiments showed predictions based on a continuous wave led to the well-known ultraviolet catastrophe. Plank and Einstein originated and developed the notion of the photon as an elementary quantum of propagating electromagnetic (EM) energy. The first half of the 20th century saw the development of the field quantization and the quantum electrodynamics (QED). Feynmann labeled QED as ‘‘the best theory we have’’ to describe the matter-light interaction. The second half of the 20th century witnessed the development of the coherent and squeezed optical states attributable to Glauber and Yuen. The study of light and electromagnetic fields has a long history. This chapter explores the nature of light in terms of quantum optics.