Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The space of extensions that restrict to faithful states

Shane James Crerar

Published Dec 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This work is a technical examination of concepts in Arveson’s paper Probability of Entanglement [3]. For finite dimensional Hilbert spaces H with dimension n and K with dimension m such that 2 ≤ n ≤ m, every extension of a faithful state of B(H) to a state of B(K ⊗ H) is parameterized by a complex nm2 × n matrix v with the property that v∗v is the identity on B(H). The set of all such nm2 × n matrices is a Steifel manifold V mn(H,K) which corresponds to the set of isometries from H to K⊗mn. We show that the set of extensions of a faithful state E(!) is isomorphic to V mn(H,K)/U(Cmn) where U(Cmn) is the set of unitary linear operators from Cmn → Cmn. We can construct a filtration of extensions: E1(!) ⊆ · · · ⊆ Er(!) ⊆ · · · ⊆ Emn(!) where Er(!) is the set of extensions with rank at most r. Each Er(!) is isomorphic to V r(H,K)/U(Cr). We show that there is a unique measure μ on V r(H,K) defined by the inner product on B(H, r · K) where hu, vi = Tr(v∗u) for u, v ∈ B(H, r · K). We show that entangled extensions of every rank exist and for r < √dimH every extension in Er(!) is entangled. With respect to μ, for a fixed r with 1 ≤ r ≤ mn the set of extensions with rank strictly less than r in Er(!) has measure zero. For r < dimH almost every extension is entangled, in other words the probability that an extension of a faithful state with rank less than dimH is not entangled is zero.

DOI
10.82465/7672

Related papers

On the notion of entanglement in Hilbert spaces

Александр Семенович Холево, Максим Евгеньевич Широков, Reinhard F. Werner

A density operator (state) on a tensor product H ⊗ K of Hilbert spaces is separable if it is in the convex closure of the subset of all tensor product states. Non-separable states are called entangled. These concepts are of great importance in quantum information theory, but they have been studied in depth only in the finite-dimensional context [1]. In this note we give a general integral representation for separable states and provide the first example of separable states that are not countably decomposable. We also prove a structure theorem for quantum communication channels that are entanglement-breaking, generalizing the finite-dimensional result of [2]. In the finite-dimensional case such channels can be characterized as having a Stinespring–Kraus representation (3) with operators Vj of rank 1. The above example implies the existence of infinite-dimensional entanglement-breaking channels having no such representation. In what follows,H,K,... are separable Hilbert spaces, T(H) is the Banach space of trace-class operators and S(H) is the convex subset of all density operators on H. For brevity we shall also call them states, having in mind that a density operator ρ uniquely determines a normal state on the algebra B(H) of all bounded operators on H. Equipped with the trace-norm topology, S(H) is a complete separable metric space. If π is a Borel probability measure on S(H), then

Russian Mathematical Surveys•Apr 30, 2005•50 citations

The geometry of multi-qubit entanglement

Toshihiro Iwai

This paper, a continuation of a previous one ( Iwai 2007 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 40 1361 ), studies the geometry of multi-qubit entanglement with respect to bipartite partitions. An n -qubit system ( C 2 ) ⊗ n is isomorphic with , the linear space of 2 ℓ × 2 m complex matrices, where ℓ + m = n . According to the isomorphism, the local transformation group U (2 ℓ ) × U (2 m ) acts on the space of normalized states in . Let M and G denote the space of normalized states and the local transformation group acting on M , respectively. According to the orbit types, M is stratified into strata, among which a principal stratum and the sets of separable states and maximally entangled states will be identified. For , a function F ( C ) = det( I − CC *) proves to serve as a measure of entanglement, where I denotes the 2 ℓ × 2 ℓ identity matrix. The F ( C ) attains the minimal and the maximal values, respectively, on the sets of separable states and maximally entangled states, and further takes no extremal values on the principal stratum. The F ( C ) projects to a function on the factor space G \ M . A naturally defined metric on M also projects to that on G \ M , which serves to measure the distance between the separable states, F −1 (0), and the states, F −1 ( k ), of prescribed value k of measure. To be precise, one has to restrict M to the principal stratum, when projecting the metric. Three- and four-qubit systems will be studied intensively, and then multi-qubit systems discussed.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 18, 2007•11 citations

Restricted numerical shadow and the geometry of quantum entanglement

Zbigniew Puchała, Jarosław Adam Miszczak, Piotr Gawron +3 more

The restricted numerical range W R ( A ) of an operator A acting on a D -dimensional Hilbert space is defined as a set of all possible expectation values of this operator among pure states which belong to a certain subset R of the set of pure quantum states of dimension D . One considers for instance the set of real states, or in the case of composite spaces, the set of product states and the set of maximally entangled states. Combining the operator theory with a probabilistic approach we introduce the restricted numerical shadow of A —a normalized probability distribution on the complex plane supported in W R ( A ). Its value at point is equal to the probability that the expectation value 〈ψ| A |ψ〉 is equal to z , where |ψ〉 represents a random quantum state in subset R distributed according to the natural measure on this set, induced by the unitarily invariant Fubini–Study measure. Studying restricted shadows of operators of a fixed size D = N A N B we analyse the geometry of sets of separable and maximally entangled states of the N A × N B composite quantum system. Investigating trajectories formed by evolving quantum states projected into the plane of the shadow, we study the dynamics of quantum entanglement. A similar analysis extended for operators on D = 2 3 -dimensional Hilbert space allows us to investigate the structure of the orbits of GHZ and W quantum states of a three-qubit system.

arXiv:1201.2524•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Oct 2, 2012•20 citations

Entanglement quantification by local unitary operations

Alex Monràs, Gerardo Adesso, S. M. Giampaolo +3 more

Invariance under local unitary operations is a fundamental property that must be obeyed by every proper measure of quantum entanglement. However, this is not the only aspect of entanglement theory where local unitary operations play a relevant role. In the present work we show that the application of suitable local unitary operations defines a family of bipartite entanglement monotones, collectively referred to as ``mirror entanglement.'' They are constructed by first considering the (squared) Hilbert-Schmidt distance of the state from the set of states obtained by applying to it a given local unitary operator. To the action of each different local unitary operator there corresponds a different distance. We then minimize these distances over the sets of local unitary operations with different spectra, obtaining an entire family of different entanglement monotones. We show that these mirror-entanglement monotones are organized in a hierarchical structure, and we establish the conditions that need to be imposed on the spectrum of a local unitary operator for the associated mirror entanglement to be faithful, i.e., to vanish in and only in separable pure states. We analyze in detail the properties of one particularly relevant member of the family, the ``stellar mirror entanglement'' associated with the traceless local unitary operations with nondegenerate spectra and equispaced eigenvalues in the complex plane. This particular measure generalizes the original analysis of S. M. Giampaolo and F. Illuminati [Phys. Rev. A 76, 042301 (2007)], valid for qubits and qutrits. We prove that the stellar entanglement is a faithful bipartite entanglement monotone in any dimension and that it is bounded from below by a function proportional to the linear entropy and from above by the linear entropy itself, coinciding with it in two- and three-dimensional spaces.

arXiv:1104.0941•Physical Review A•Jul 1, 2011•35 citations

Geometry of quantum systems: density states and entanglement

Janusz Grabowski, Marek Kuś, Giuseppe Marmo

Various problems concerning the geometry of the space of Hermitian operators on a Hilbert space are addressed. In particular, we study the canonical Poisson and Riemann–Jordan tensors and the corresponding foliations into Kähler submanifolds. It is also shown that the space of density states on an n -dimensional Hilbert space is naturally a manifold stratified space with the stratification induced by the the rank of the state. Thus the space of rank- k states, k = 1, ..., n , is a smooth manifold of (real) dimension 2 nk − k 2 − 1 and this stratification is maximal in the sense that every smooth curve in , viewed as a subset of the dual to the Lie algebra of the unitary group , at every point must be tangent to the strata it crosses. For a quantum composite system, i.e. for a Hilbert space decomposition , an abstract criterion of entanglement is proved.

arXiv:math-ph/0507045•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Nov 9, 2005•94 citations

Symmetry in quantum mechanics

Symmetry in quantum mechanicsRoughly speaking, a symmetry of some mathematical object is an invertible transformation that leaves all relevant structure as it is.Thus a symmetry of a set is just a bijection (as sets have no further structure, whence invertibility is the only demand on a symmetry), a symmetry of a topological space is a homeomorphism, a symmetry of a Banach space is a linear isometric isomorphism, and, crucially important for this chapter, a symmetry of a Hilbert space H is a unitary operator, i.e., a linear map u : H → H satisfying one and hence all of the following equivalent conditions:• u is invertible and preserves the inner product, i.e., uϕ, uψ = ϕ, ψ (ϕ, ψ ∈ H).The discussion of symmetries in quantum physics is based on the above idea, but the mathematically obvious choices need not be the physically relevant ones.Even in elementary quantum mechanics, where A = B(H), i.e., the C*-algebra of all bounded operators on some Hilbert space H, the concept of a symmetry is already diverse.The main structures whose symmetries we shall study in this chapter are:1.The normal pure state space P 1 (H), i.e., the set of one-dimensional projections on H, with transition probability τ : P 1 (H) × P 1 (H) → [0, 1] defined by (2.44).2. The normal state space D(H), i.e. the convex set of density operators ρ on H. The self-adjoint operators B(H)sa on H, seen as a Jordan algebra (see below).4. The effects E (H) = [0, 1] B(H) , seen as a convex partially ordered set (poset). 5.The projections P(H) on H, seen as an orthocomplemented lattice.6.The unital commutative C*-subalgebras C (B(H)) of B(H), seen as a poset.Each of these structures comes with its own notion of a symmetry, but the main point of this chapter will be to show these notions are equivalent, corresponding in all cases to either unitary or-surprisingly-anti-unitary operators, both merely defined up to a phase.The latter subtlety will open the world of projective unitary group representation to quantum mechanics (without which the existence of spin-1 2 particles such as electrons, and therewith also of ourselves, would be impossible).

Institute of Physics eBooks•Nov 26, 2004•0 citations
This work is a technical examination of concepts in Arveson’s paper Probability of Entanglement [3]. For finite dimensional Hilbert spaces H with dimension n and K with dimension m such that 2 ≤ n ≤ m, every extension of a faithful state of B(H) to a state of B(K ⊗ H) is parameterized by a complex nm2 × n matrix v with the property that v∗v is the identity on B(H). The set of all such nm2 × n matrices is a Steifel manifold V mn(H,K) which corresponds to the set of isometries from H to K⊗mn. We show that the set of extensions of a faithful state E(!) is isomorphic to V mn(H,K)/U(Cmn) where U(Cmn) is the set of unitary linear operators from Cmn → Cmn. We can construct a filtration of extensions: E1(!) ⊆ · · · ⊆ Er(!) ⊆ · · · ⊆ Emn(!) where Er(!) is the set of extensions with rank at most r. Each Er(!) is isomorphic to V r(H,K)/U(Cr). We show that there is a unique measure μ on V r(H,K) defined by the inner product on B(H, r · K) where hu, vi = Tr(v∗u) for u, v ∈ B(H, r · K). We show that entangled extensions of every rank exist and for r < √dimH every extension in Er(!) is entangled. With respect to μ, for a fixed r with 1 ≤ r ≤ mn the set of extensions with rank strictly less than r in Er(!) has measure zero. For r < dimH almost every extension is entangled, in other words the probability that an extension of a faithful state with rank less than dimH is not entangled is zero.
A density operator (state) on a tensor product H ⊗ K of Hilbert spaces is separable if it is in the convex closure of the subset of all tensor product states. Non-separable states are called entangled. These concepts are of great importance in quantum information theory, but they have been studied in depth only in the finite-dimensional context [1]. In this note we give a general integral representation for separable states and provide the first example of separable states that are not countably decomposable. We also prove a structure theorem for quantum communication channels that are entanglement-breaking, generalizing the finite-dimensional result of [2]. In the finite-dimensional case such channels can be characterized as having a Stinespring–Kraus representation (3) with operators Vj of rank 1. The above example implies the existence of infinite-dimensional entanglement-breaking channels having no such representation. In what follows,H,K,... are separable Hilbert spaces, T(H) is the Banach space of trace-class operators and S(H) is the convex subset of all density operators on H. For brevity we shall also call them states, having in mind that a density operator ρ uniquely determines a normal state on the algebra B(H) of all bounded operators on H. Equipped with the trace-norm topology, S(H) is a complete separable metric space. If π is a Borel probability measure on S(H), then
This paper, a continuation of a previous one ( Iwai 2007 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 40 1361 ), studies the geometry of multi-qubit entanglement with respect to bipartite partitions. An n -qubit system ( C 2 ) ⊗ n is isomorphic with , the linear space of 2 ℓ × 2 m complex matrices, where ℓ + m = n . According to the isomorphism, the local transformation group U (2 ℓ ) × U (2 m ) acts on the space of normalized states in . Let M and G denote the space of normalized states and the local transformation group acting on M , respectively. According to the orbit types, M is stratified into strata, among which a principal stratum and the sets of separable states and maximally entangled states will be identified. For , a function F ( C ) = det( I − CC *) proves to serve as a measure of entanglement, where I denotes the 2 ℓ × 2 ℓ identity matrix. The F ( C ) attains the minimal and the maximal values, respectively, on the sets of separable states and maximally entangled states, and further takes no extremal values on the principal stratum. The F ( C ) projects to a function on the factor space G \ M . A naturally defined metric on M also projects to that on G \ M , which serves to measure the distance between the separable states, F −1 (0), and the states, F −1 ( k ), of prescribed value k of measure. To be precise, one has to restrict M to the principal stratum, when projecting the metric. Three- and four-qubit systems will be studied intensively, and then multi-qubit systems discussed.
The restricted numerical range W R ( A ) of an operator A acting on a D -dimensional Hilbert space is defined as a set of all possible expectation values of this operator among pure states which belong to a certain subset R of the set of pure quantum states of dimension D . One considers for instance the set of real states, or in the case of composite spaces, the set of product states and the set of maximally entangled states. Combining the operator theory with a probabilistic approach we introduce the restricted numerical shadow of A —a normalized probability distribution on the complex plane supported in W R ( A ). Its value at point is equal to the probability that the expectation value 〈ψ| A |ψ〉 is equal to z , where |ψ〉 represents a random quantum state in subset R distributed according to the natural measure on this set, induced by the unitarily invariant Fubini–Study measure. Studying restricted shadows of operators of a fixed size D = N A N B we analyse the geometry of sets of separable and maximally entangled states of the N A × N B composite quantum system. Investigating trajectories formed by evolving quantum states projected into the plane of the shadow, we study the dynamics of quantum entanglement. A similar analysis extended for operators on D = 2 3 -dimensional Hilbert space allows us to investigate the structure of the orbits of GHZ and W quantum states of a three-qubit system.
Invariance under local unitary operations is a fundamental property that must be obeyed by every proper measure of quantum entanglement. However, this is not the only aspect of entanglement theory where local unitary operations play a relevant role. In the present work we show that the application of suitable local unitary operations defines a family of bipartite entanglement monotones, collectively referred to as ``mirror entanglement.'' They are constructed by first considering the (squared) Hilbert-Schmidt distance of the state from the set of states obtained by applying to it a given local unitary operator. To the action of each different local unitary operator there corresponds a different distance. We then minimize these distances over the sets of local unitary operations with different spectra, obtaining an entire family of different entanglement monotones. We show that these mirror-entanglement monotones are organized in a hierarchical structure, and we establish the conditions that need to be imposed on the spectrum of a local unitary operator for the associated mirror entanglement to be faithful, i.e., to vanish in and only in separable pure states. We analyze in detail the properties of one particularly relevant member of the family, the ``stellar mirror entanglement'' associated with the traceless local unitary operations with nondegenerate spectra and equispaced eigenvalues in the complex plane. This particular measure generalizes the original analysis of S. M. Giampaolo and F. Illuminati [Phys. Rev. A 76, 042301 (2007)], valid for qubits and qutrits. We prove that the stellar entanglement is a faithful bipartite entanglement monotone in any dimension and that it is bounded from below by a function proportional to the linear entropy and from above by the linear entropy itself, coinciding with it in two- and three-dimensional spaces.
Various problems concerning the geometry of the space of Hermitian operators on a Hilbert space are addressed. In particular, we study the canonical Poisson and Riemann–Jordan tensors and the corresponding foliations into Kähler submanifolds. It is also shown that the space of density states on an n -dimensional Hilbert space is naturally a manifold stratified space with the stratification induced by the the rank of the state. Thus the space of rank- k states, k = 1, ..., n , is a smooth manifold of (real) dimension 2 nk − k 2 − 1 and this stratification is maximal in the sense that every smooth curve in , viewed as a subset of the dual to the Lie algebra of the unitary group , at every point must be tangent to the strata it crosses. For a quantum composite system, i.e. for a Hilbert space decomposition , an abstract criterion of entanglement is proved.
Symmetry in quantum mechanicsRoughly speaking, a symmetry of some mathematical object is an invertible transformation that leaves all relevant structure as it is.Thus a symmetry of a set is just a bijection (as sets have no further structure, whence invertibility is the only demand on a symmetry), a symmetry of a topological space is a homeomorphism, a symmetry of a Banach space is a linear isometric isomorphism, and, crucially important for this chapter, a symmetry of a Hilbert space H is a unitary operator, i.e., a linear map u : H → H satisfying one and hence all of the following equivalent conditions:• u is invertible and preserves the inner product, i.e., uϕ, uψ = ϕ, ψ (ϕ, ψ ∈ H).The discussion of symmetries in quantum physics is based on the above idea, but the mathematically obvious choices need not be the physically relevant ones.Even in elementary quantum mechanics, where A = B(H), i.e., the C*-algebra of all bounded operators on some Hilbert space H, the concept of a symmetry is already diverse.The main structures whose symmetries we shall study in this chapter are:1.The normal pure state space P 1 (H), i.e., the set of one-dimensional projections on H, with transition probability τ : P 1 (H) × P 1 (H) → [0, 1] defined by (2.44).2. The normal state space D(H), i.e. the convex set of density operators ρ on H. The self-adjoint operators B(H)sa on H, seen as a Jordan algebra (see below).4. The effects E (H) = [0, 1] B(H) , seen as a convex partially ordered set (poset). 5.The projections P(H) on H, seen as an orthocomplemented lattice.6.The unital commutative C*-subalgebras C (B(H)) of B(H), seen as a poset.Each of these structures comes with its own notion of a symmetry, but the main point of this chapter will be to show these notions are equivalent, corresponding in all cases to either unitary or-surprisingly-anti-unitary operators, both merely defined up to a phase.The latter subtlety will open the world of projective unitary group representation to quantum mechanics (without which the existence of spin-1 2 particles such as electrons, and therewith also of ourselves, would be impossible).