Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Optimality of trine states for two-copy discrimination

Hyun-Ho Cha, Jungwoo Lee

Published Oct 9, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum measurements can sometimes extract more information from multiple copies of a state than from each copy separately. One of the simplest settings is the discrimination of three qubit states when two identical copies are available and one is allowed to perform an arbitrary joint measurement. Recent numerical work identified the double-trine ensemble as the apparent optimal benchmark in this setting, but an analytic proof of its optimality remained open. In this paper, we prove that the double-trine ensemble is indeed globally optimal. More precisely, among all triples of equally likely qubit states, no choice of states can give a larger optimal two-copy discrimination success probability. The result holds in full generality, whether the signal states are pure or mixed, real or complex. This exactly solved case serves as a foundation for a broader analytic understanding of optimal collective measurements.

DOI
10.1103/pxrf-bf72

Related papers

Optimal measurement strategies for the trine states with arbitrary prior probabilities

Graeme Weir, Catherine Hughes, Stephen Mark Barnett +1 more

Abstract We investigate the optimal measurement strategy for state discrimination of the trine ensemble of qubit states prepared with arbitrary prior probabilities. Our approach generates the minimum achievable probability of error and also the maximum confidence strategy. Although various cases with symmetry have been considered and solution techniques put forward in the literature, to our knowledge this is only the second such closed form, analytical, arbitrary prior, example available for the minimum-error figure of merit, after the simplest and well-known two-state example.

arXiv:1803.03590•Quantum Science and Technology•Apr 9, 2018•13 citations

Accessible information in three pure mirror-symmetric qubit states

Michael R. Frey

We formulate an expression for the accessible information in mirror-symmetric ensembles of real qubit states. This expression is used to make a detailed study of optimum quantum measurements for extracting the accessible information in three-state, mirror-symmetric ensembles. Distinct measurement regimes are identified for these ensembles with optimal measurement strategies involving different numbers of measurement operators, similar to results found for minimum error discrimination. Our results generalize known results for the accessible information in two pure states and in the trine ensemble.

Physical Review A•Mar 10, 2006•6 citations

Information accessible by measurement in mirror-symmetric ensembles of qubit states

Michael R. Frey

We formulate an expression for the accessible information in mirror-symmetric ensembles of real qubit states. This expression is used to make a detailed study of optimum quantum measurements for extracting the accessible information in three-state, mirror-symmetric ensembles. Distinct measurement regimes are identified for these ensembles with optimal measurement strategies involving different numbers of measurement operators, similar to results found for minimum error discrimination. Our results generalize known results for the accessible information in two pure states and in the trine ensemble.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•May 5, 2006•0 citations

Unambiguous discrimination between linearly dependent states with multiple copies

Anthony Chefles

A set of quantum states can be unambiguously discriminated if and only if they are linearly independent. However, for a linearly dependent set, if C copies of the state are available, then the resulting C particle states may form a linearly independent set, and be amenable to unambiguous discrimination. We obtain one necessary and one sufficient condition for the possibility of unambiguous discrimination among N states given that C copies are available and that the single copies span a D-dimensional space. These conditions are found to be identical for qubits. We then examine in detail the linearly dependent trine ensemble. The set of $C>1$ copies of each state is a set of linearly independent lifted trine states. The maximum unambiguous discrimination probability is evaluated for all $C>1$ with equal a priori probabilities.

arXiv:quant-ph/0105016•Physical Review A•Nov 9, 2001•71 citations

The most discriminable quantum states in the multicopy regime

Maria Kvashchuk, Polina Chernyshova, Lucas E. A. Porto +3 more

This work investigates which sets of quantum states give rise to the highest achievable success probability in minimum-error state discrimination if multiple copies of the unknown state are given. Specifically, we consider uniformly distributed ensembles of the form $\left\{\frac{1}{N},ρ_i^{\otimes k}\right\}_{i=1}^N$, where $N$ states in dimension $d$ are provided in $k$ identical copies, and derive universal limits in this scenario. For pure state ensembles, we prove that whenever $N$ is large enough to support a state $k$-design, these designs will exactly give rise to the maximally discriminable sets. We further show that when $N$ exceeds the size required for a $k$-design, mixed states can outperform all pure state ensembles. We then recognise that the problem of most discriminable classical states in the multi-copy regime is in one-to-one correspondence to the concept of the multiplicative Bayes capacity of independent uses of classical channels, a concept that emerges naturally in the context of classical information leakage. This connection allows us to completely solve the classical analogue of our problem when $N\geq \binom{d + k - 1}{k}$, and to prove that quantum systems offer a quadratic advantage (in number of copies $k$) over classical ones. Then, we prove that this quantum over classical advantage is strongly reduced when one is restricted to real quantum states, more precisely, when $N \geq k + 1$, pure real qubits only offer a constant advantage over classical bits. Finally, we introduce computational techniques to find sets of most discriminable ensembles and to obtain rigorous universal upper bounds on the maximal success probability for multi-copy state discrimination in cases that are analytically intractable.

quant-pharXiv:2604.26927•Apr 30, 2026•1 citation

Optimal discrimination of quantum states

Graeme Weir

Quantum state discrimination is a fundamental task in the field of quantum communication and quantum information theory. Unless the states to be discriminated are mutually orthogonal, there will be some error in any attempt to determine which state was sent. Several strategies to optimally discriminate between quantum states exist, each maximising some figure of merit. In this thesis we mainly investigate the minimum-error strategy, in which the probability of correctly guessing the signal state is maximised. We introduce a method for constructing the optimal Positive-Operator Valued Measure (POVM) for this figure of merit, which is applicable for arbitrary states and arbitrary prior probabilities. We then use this method to solve minimum-error state discrimination for the so-called trine states with arbitrary prior probabilities - the first such general solution for a set of quantum states since the two-state case was solved when the problem of state discrimination was first introduced. We also investigate the difference between local and global measurements for a bipartite ensemble of states, and find that in certain circumstances the local measurement is superior. We conclude by finding a bipartite analogue to the Helstrom conditions, which indicate when a POVM satisfies the minimum-error criteria.

•Jan 1, 2018•4 citations
Quantum measurements can sometimes extract more information from multiple copies of a state than from each copy separately. One of the simplest settings is the discrimination of three qubit states when two identical copies are available and one is allowed to perform an arbitrary joint measurement. Recent numerical work identified the double-trine ensemble as the apparent optimal benchmark in this setting, but an analytic proof of its optimality remained open. In this paper, we prove that the double-trine ensemble is indeed globally optimal. More precisely, among all triples of equally likely qubit states, no choice of states can give a larger optimal two-copy discrimination success probability. The result holds in full generality, whether the signal states are pure or mixed, real or complex. This exactly solved case serves as a foundation for a broader analytic understanding of optimal collective measurements.
Abstract We investigate the optimal measurement strategy for state discrimination of the trine ensemble of qubit states prepared with arbitrary prior probabilities. Our approach generates the minimum achievable probability of error and also the maximum confidence strategy. Although various cases with symmetry have been considered and solution techniques put forward in the literature, to our knowledge this is only the second such closed form, analytical, arbitrary prior, example available for the minimum-error figure of merit, after the simplest and well-known two-state example.
We formulate an expression for the accessible information in mirror-symmetric ensembles of real qubit states. This expression is used to make a detailed study of optimum quantum measurements for extracting the accessible information in three-state, mirror-symmetric ensembles. Distinct measurement regimes are identified for these ensembles with optimal measurement strategies involving different numbers of measurement operators, similar to results found for minimum error discrimination. Our results generalize known results for the accessible information in two pure states and in the trine ensemble.
We formulate an expression for the accessible information in mirror-symmetric ensembles of real qubit states. This expression is used to make a detailed study of optimum quantum measurements for extracting the accessible information in three-state, mirror-symmetric ensembles. Distinct measurement regimes are identified for these ensembles with optimal measurement strategies involving different numbers of measurement operators, similar to results found for minimum error discrimination. Our results generalize known results for the accessible information in two pure states and in the trine ensemble.
A set of quantum states can be unambiguously discriminated if and only if they are linearly independent. However, for a linearly dependent set, if C copies of the state are available, then the resulting C particle states may form a linearly independent set, and be amenable to unambiguous discrimination. We obtain one necessary and one sufficient condition for the possibility of unambiguous discrimination among N states given that C copies are available and that the single copies span a D-dimensional space. These conditions are found to be identical for qubits. We then examine in detail the linearly dependent trine ensemble. The set of C>1C>1C>1 copies of each state is a set of linearly independent lifted trine states. The maximum unambiguous discrimination probability is evaluated for all C>1C>1C>1 with equal a priori probabilities.
This work investigates which sets of quantum states give rise to the highest achievable success probability in minimum-error state discrimination if multiple copies of the unknown state are given. Specifically, we consider uniformly distributed ensembles of the form {1N,ρi⊗k}i=1N\left\{\frac{1}{N},ρ_i^{\otimes k}\right\}_{i=1}^N{N1​,ρi⊗k​}i=1N​, where NNN states in dimension ddd are provided in kkk identical copies, and derive universal limits in this scenario. For pure state ensembles, we prove that whenever NNN is large enough to support a state kkk-design, these designs will exactly give rise to the maximally discriminable sets. We further show that when NNN exceeds the size required for a kkk-design, mixed states can outperform all pure state ensembles. We then recognise that the problem of most discriminable classical states in the multi-copy regime is in one-to-one correspondence to the concept of the multiplicative Bayes capacity of independent uses of classical channels, a concept that emerges naturally in the context of classical information leakage. This connection allows us to completely solve the classical analogue of our problem when N≥(d+k−1k)N\geq \binom{d + k - 1}{k}N≥(kd+k−1​), and to prove that quantum systems offer a quadratic advantage (in number of copies kkk) over classical ones. Then, we prove that this quantum over classical advantage is strongly reduced when one is restricted to real quantum states, more precisely, when N≥k+1N \geq k + 1N≥k+1, pure real qubits only offer a constant advantage over classical bits. Finally, we introduce computational techniques to find sets of most discriminable ensembles and to obtain rigorous universal upper bounds on the maximal success probability for multi-copy state discrimination in cases that are analytically intractable.
Quantum state discrimination is a fundamental task in the field of quantum communication and quantum information theory. Unless the states to be discriminated are mutually orthogonal, there will be some error in any attempt to determine which state was sent. Several strategies to optimally discriminate between quantum states exist, each maximising some figure of merit. In this thesis we mainly investigate the minimum-error strategy, in which the probability of correctly guessing the signal state is maximised. We introduce a method for constructing the optimal Positive-Operator Valued Measure (POVM) for this figure of merit, which is applicable for arbitrary states and arbitrary prior probabilities. We then use this method to solve minimum-error state discrimination for the so-called trine states with arbitrary prior probabilities - the first such general solution for a set of quantum states since the two-state case was solved when the problem of state discrimination was first introduced. We also investigate the difference between local and global measurements for a bipartite ensemble of states, and find that in certain circumstances the local measurement is superior. We conclude by finding a bipartite analogue to the Helstrom conditions, which indicate when a POVM satisfies the minimum-error criteria.