Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Z-boson pair entanglement against all separable states: a decay-angle witness for H → ZZ*

David Dudaš

Published Oct 9, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

ATLAS has reported evidence of Z-boson pair entanglement in H → ZZ* → 4ℓ at 4.7σ (4.9σ expected) with 304 fb⁻¹. The separable hypothesis it tests is a single state, the pure product state |00⟩, which ATLAS describes as the only separable state consistent with its assumptions. That is true only for pure states. By ATLAS's own criterion, every state whose two measured coefficients vanish is separable, and that set contains the CP-invariant mixtures of the helicity states |+−⟩, |00⟩ and |−+⟩, not just |00⟩. Restricting the null to |00⟩ therefore presupposes that the spin state is pure, which an entanglement test should not assume. We give a witness built from one event score, Q = (n̂·m̂)², where n̂ and m̂ are the lepton directions in the two Z rest frames. Its mean c lies between 0.32 and 0.36 for every separable two-qutrit state, does not depend on the leptons' analysing power, equals a fixed linear combination of three standard angular coefficients, and gives a tight lower bound on the negativity. In a generator-level model calibrated to the ATLAS result, an ATLAS-style test keeps less than a quarter of its significance when the null is the dephased Standard Model state, which has the Standard Model Z polarizations and no helicity coherence: 1.15σ expected. In this model no test on the same events has an expected significance above 2.4–3.1σ against that state, and the published coefficients give 1.4σ observed evidence of coherence. The witness, valid against every separable state, has an expected significance of 1.8σ (1.6–2.0σ) at 304 fb⁻¹ and 5.6σ (4.9–6.4σ) at 3000 fb⁻¹, from statistics alone. This record includes the paper, its LaTeX source and figures, and the Python scripts, with their outputs, that reproduce every number in it.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23270202

Related papers

Measurements of Z -Boson Pair Entanglement in Decays of Higgs Bosons at the ATLAS Experiment

G. Aad, Erlend Aakvaag, B. Abbott +97 more

Entanglement is a key property of quantum systems. In this Letter the first measurements of quantum entanglement between spins in pairs of Z bosons are reported, using proton-proton collision data from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at center-of-mass energies of 13 and 13.6 TeV, recorded with the ATLAS detector. Measurements of angular observables sensitive to ZZ^{*} spin-density-matrix elements in the H→ZZ^{*}→ℓ^{+}ℓ^{-}ℓ^{+}ℓ^{-} process yield coefficients C_{2,1,2,-1}=-0.71±0.45 and C_{2,2,2,-2}=0.08±0.44, consistent with their Standard Model predictions. A complementary hypothesis test using the full angular distribution, and relying on several Standard Model assumptions in the decays, provides substantially higher sensitivity to quantum correlations and disfavors the separable-state hypothesis at a significance of 4.7 standard deviations (expected 4.9σ) relative to the entangled Standard Model hypothesis. These results provide strong evidence of quantum entanglement between massive bosons (spin qutrits) at the electroweak scale.

arXiv:2603.26463•Physical Review Letters•Jul 16, 2026•13 citations

Measurements of $Z$-boson pair entanglement in decays of Higgs bosons at the ATLAS experiment

G. Aad, Erlend Aakvaag, B. Abbott +97 more

Entanglement is a key property of quantum systems. In this Letter the first measurements of quantum entanglement between spins in pairs of $Z$ bosons are reported, using proton-proton collision data from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at center-of-mass energies of 13 TeV and 13.6 TeV, recorded with the ATLAS detector. Measurements of angular observables sensitive to $ZZ^*$ spin-density-matrix elements in the $H\rightarrow ZZ^* \rightarrow \ell^+\ell^-\ell^+\ell^-$ process yield coefficients $C_{2,1,2,-1} = -0.71 \pm 0.45$ and $C_{2,2,2,-2}=0.08 \pm 0.44$, consistent with their Standard Model predictions. A complementary hypothesis test using the full angular distribution, and relying on several Standard Model assumptions in the decays, provides substantially higher sensitivity to quantum correlations and disfavors the separable-state hypothesis at a significance of 4.7 standard deviations (expected $4.9σ$) relative to the entangled Standard Model hypothesis. These results provide strong evidence of quantum entanglement between massive bosons (spin qutrits) at the electroweak scale.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Observation of quantum entanglement in top-quark pairs using the ATLAS detector

G. Aad, B. Abbott, K. Abeling +97 more

Entanglement is a key feature of quantum mechanics$^{1–3}$, with applications in fields such as metrology, cryptography, quantum information and quantum computation$^{4–8}$. It has been observed in a wide variety of systems and length scales, ranging from the microscopic$^{9–13}$ to the macroscopic$^{14–16}$. However, entanglement remains largely unexplored at the highest accessible energy scales. Here we report the highest-energy observation of entanglement, in top–antitop quark events produced at the Large Hadron Collider, using a proton–proton collision dataset with a centre-of-mass energy of √s = 13 TeV and an integrated luminosity of 140 inverse femtobarns (fb)$^{−1}$ recorded with the ATLAS experiment. Spin entanglement is detected from the measurement of a single observable D, inferred from the angle between the charged leptons in their parent top- and antitop-quark rest frames. The observable is measured in a narrow interval around the top–antitop quark production threshold, at which the entanglement detection is expected to be significant. It is reported in a fiducial phase space defined with stable particles to minimize the uncertainties that stem from the limitations of the Monte Carlo event generators and the parton shower model in modelling top-quark pair production. The entanglement marker is measured to be D = −0.537 ± 0.002 (stat.) ± 0.019 (syst.) for $340\,{\rm{GeV}} < {m}_{t\bar{t}} < 380\,{\rm{GeV}}$. The observed result is more than five standard deviations from a scenario without entanglement and hence constitutes the first observation of entanglement in a pair of quarks and the highest-energy observation of entanglement so far.

arXiv:2311.07288•ENLIGHTEN (Jurnal Bimbingan dan Konseling Islam)•Jan 1, 2023•171 citations

Tripartite entanglement in H → Z Z , W W decays

J. A. Aguilar–Saavedra

The decays of the Higgs boson produce a state in which the spins of the decay products and the orbital angular momentum ( L ) are highly entangled. We obtain the tripartite density operator, as well as reduced operators, for the decay into two weak bosons. For H → Z Z in the four-lepton final state we also estimate the statistical sensitivity at the Large Hadron Collider and future upgrades, using a binned method to reconstruct the density operators from distributions. With the expected Run 3 data, establishing genuine tripartite entanglement would be possible beyond the 5 σ level. The violation of Bell inequalities involving the spins of the two weak bosons could also be established beyond the 5 σ level. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2403.13942•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jun 21, 2024•42 citations

Quantum entanglement and Bell inequality violation in semi-leptonic top decays

Tao Han, Matthew Low, Tong Arthur Wu

A bstract Quantum entanglement is a fundamental property of quantum mechanics. Recently, studies have explored entanglement in the $$ t\overline{t} $$ t t ¯ system at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) when both the top quark and anti-top quark decay leptonically. Entanglement is detected via correlations between the polarizations of the top and anti-top and these polarizations are measured through the angles of the decay products of the top and anti-top. In this work, we propose searching for evidence of quantum entanglement in the semi-leptonic decay channel where the final state includes one lepton, one neutrino, two b -flavor tagged jets, and two light jets from the W decay. We find that this channel is both easier to reconstruct and has a larger effective quantity of data than the fully leptonic channel. As a result, the semi-leptonic channel is 60% more sensitive to quantum entanglement and a factor of 3 more sensitive to Bell inequality violation, compared to the leptonic channel. In 139 fb − 1 (3 ab −1 ) of data at the LHC (HL-LHC), it should be feasible to measure entanglement at a precision of ≲ 3% (0 . 7%). Detecting Bell inequality violation, on the other hand, is more challenging. With 300 fb −1 (3 ab −1 ) of integrated luminosity at the LHC Run-3 (HL-LHC), we expect a sensitivity of 1 . 3 σ (4 . 1 σ ). In our study, we utilize a realistic parametric fitting procedure to optimally recover the true angular distributions from detector effects. Compared to unfolding this procedure yields more stable results.

arXiv:2310.17696•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jul 22, 2024•98 citations

Probing quantum entanglement using Higgs to ZZ* to 4 leptons at ATLAS

M. Varma

Quantum entanglement, a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics, has become a powerful tool impacting various areas of physics. In this proceeding, we investigate the presence of quantum entanglement within the Higgs to ZZ* (HZZ*) interaction at the ATLAS experiment. Utilizing quantum tomography techniques, we extract the complete spin density matrix characterizing the HZZ* interaction from ATLAS Standard Monte Carlo (MC) HZZ* 4l Run2 samples. We then evaluate the presence of quantum entanglement in the system using the derived spin density matrix. Our investigation sheds light on the entanglement properties within the HZZ* interaction, which offers valuable insights into its quantum characteristics.

arXiv:2412.04194•Dec 5, 2024•0 citations
ATLAS has reported evidence of Z-boson pair entanglement in H → ZZ* → 4ℓ at 4.7σ (4.9σ expected) with 304 fb⁻¹. The separable hypothesis it tests is a single state, the pure product state |00⟩, which ATLAS describes as the only separable state consistent with its assumptions. That is true only for pure states. By ATLAS's own criterion, every state whose two measured coefficients vanish is separable, and that set contains the CP-invariant mixtures of the helicity states |+−⟩, |00⟩ and |−+⟩, not just |00⟩. Restricting the null to |00⟩ therefore presupposes that the spin state is pure, which an entanglement test should not assume. We give a witness built from one event score, Q = (n̂·m̂)², where n̂ and m̂ are the lepton directions in the two Z rest frames. Its mean c lies between 0.32 and 0.36 for every separable two-qutrit state, does not depend on the leptons' analysing power, equals a fixed linear combination of three standard angular coefficients, and gives a tight lower bound on the negativity. In a generator-level model calibrated to the ATLAS result, an ATLAS-style test keeps less than a quarter of its significance when the null is the dephased Standard Model state, which has the Standard Model Z polarizations and no helicity coherence: 1.15σ expected. In this model no test on the same events has an expected significance above 2.4–3.1σ against that state, and the published coefficients give 1.4σ observed evidence of coherence. The witness, valid against every separable state, has an expected significance of 1.8σ (1.6–2.0σ) at 304 fb⁻¹ and 5.6σ (4.9–6.4σ) at 3000 fb⁻¹, from statistics alone. This record includes the paper, its LaTeX source and figures, and the Python scripts, with their outputs, that reproduce every number in it.
Entanglement is a key property of quantum systems. In this Letter the first measurements of quantum entanglement between spins in pairs of Z bosons are reported, using proton-proton collision data from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at center-of-mass energies of 13 and 13.6 TeV, recorded with the ATLAS detector. Measurements of angular observables sensitive to ZZ^{*} spin-density-matrix elements in the H→ZZ^{*}→ℓ^{+}ℓ^{-}ℓ^{+}ℓ^{-} process yield coefficients C_{2,1,2,-1}=-0.71±0.45 and C_{2,2,2,-2}=0.08±0.44, consistent with their Standard Model predictions. A complementary hypothesis test using the full angular distribution, and relying on several Standard Model assumptions in the decays, provides substantially higher sensitivity to quantum correlations and disfavors the separable-state hypothesis at a significance of 4.7 standard deviations (expected 4.9σ) relative to the entangled Standard Model hypothesis. These results provide strong evidence of quantum entanglement between massive bosons (spin qutrits) at the electroweak scale.
Measurements of ZZZ-boson pair entanglement in decays of Higgs bosons at the ATLAS experiment
Entanglement is a key property of quantum systems. In this Letter the first measurements of quantum entanglement between spins in pairs of ZZZ bosons are reported, using proton-proton collision data from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at center-of-mass energies of 13 TeV and 13.6 TeV, recorded with the ATLAS detector. Measurements of angular observables sensitive to ZZ∗ZZ^*ZZ∗ spin-density-matrix elements in the H→ZZ∗→ℓ+ℓ−ℓ+ℓ−H\rightarrow ZZ^* \rightarrow \ell^+\ell^-\ell^+\ell^-H→ZZ∗→ℓ+ℓ−ℓ+ℓ− process yield coefficients C2,1,2,−1=−0.71±0.45C_{2,1,2,-1} = -0.71 \pm 0.45C2,1,2,−1​=−0.71±0.45 and C2,2,2,−2=0.08±0.44C_{2,2,2,-2}=0.08 \pm 0.44C2,2,2,−2​=0.08±0.44, consistent with their Standard Model predictions. A complementary hypothesis test using the full angular distribution, and relying on several Standard Model assumptions in the decays, provides substantially higher sensitivity to quantum correlations and disfavors the separable-state hypothesis at a significance of 4.7 standard deviations (expected 4.9σ4.9σ4.9σ) relative to the entangled Standard Model hypothesis. These results provide strong evidence of quantum entanglement between massive bosons (spin qutrits) at the electroweak scale.
Entanglement is a key feature of quantum mechanics1–3^{1–3}1–3, with applications in fields such as metrology, cryptography, quantum information and quantum computation4–8^{4–8}4–8. It has been observed in a wide variety of systems and length scales, ranging from the microscopic9–13^{9–13}9–13 to the macroscopic14–16^{14–16}14–16. However, entanglement remains largely unexplored at the highest accessible energy scales. Here we report the highest-energy observation of entanglement, in top–antitop quark events produced at the Large Hadron Collider, using a proton–proton collision dataset with a centre-of-mass energy of √s = 13 TeV and an integrated luminosity of 140 inverse femtobarns (fb)−1^{−1}−1 recorded with the ATLAS experiment. Spin entanglement is detected from the measurement of a single observable D, inferred from the angle between the charged leptons in their parent top- and antitop-quark rest frames. The observable is measured in a narrow interval around the top–antitop quark production threshold, at which the entanglement detection is expected to be significant. It is reported in a fiducial phase space defined with stable particles to minimize the uncertainties that stem from the limitations of the Monte Carlo event generators and the parton shower model in modelling top-quark pair production. The entanglement marker is measured to be D = −0.537 ± 0.002 (stat.) ± 0.019 (syst.) for 340 GeV<mttˉ<380 GeV340\,{\rm{GeV}} < {m}_{t\bar{t}} < 380\,{\rm{GeV}}340GeV<mttˉ​<380GeV. The observed result is more than five standard deviations from a scenario without entanglement and hence constitutes the first observation of entanglement in a pair of quarks and the highest-energy observation of entanglement so far.
The decays of the Higgs boson produce a state in which the spins of the decay products and the orbital angular momentum ( L ) are highly entangled. We obtain the tripartite density operator, as well as reduced operators, for the decay into two weak bosons. For H → Z Z in the four-lepton final state we also estimate the statistical sensitivity at the Large Hadron Collider and future upgrades, using a binned method to reconstruct the density operators from distributions. With the expected Run 3 data, establishing genuine tripartite entanglement would be possible beyond the 5 σ level. The violation of Bell inequalities involving the spins of the two weak bosons could also be established beyond the 5 σ level. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
A bstract Quantum entanglement is a fundamental property of quantum mechanics. Recently, studies have explored entanglement in the tt‾ t\overline{t} tt t t ¯ system at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) when both the top quark and anti-top quark decay leptonically. Entanglement is detected via correlations between the polarizations of the top and anti-top and these polarizations are measured through the angles of the decay products of the top and anti-top. In this work, we propose searching for evidence of quantum entanglement in the semi-leptonic decay channel where the final state includes one lepton, one neutrino, two b -flavor tagged jets, and two light jets from the W decay. We find that this channel is both easier to reconstruct and has a larger effective quantity of data than the fully leptonic channel. As a result, the semi-leptonic channel is 60% more sensitive to quantum entanglement and a factor of 3 more sensitive to Bell inequality violation, compared to the leptonic channel. In 139 fb − 1 (3 ab −1 ) of data at the LHC (HL-LHC), it should be feasible to measure entanglement at a precision of ≲ 3% (0 . 7%). Detecting Bell inequality violation, on the other hand, is more challenging. With 300 fb −1 (3 ab −1 ) of integrated luminosity at the LHC Run-3 (HL-LHC), we expect a sensitivity of 1 . 3 σ (4 . 1 σ ). In our study, we utilize a realistic parametric fitting procedure to optimally recover the true angular distributions from detector effects. Compared to unfolding this procedure yields more stable results.
Quantum entanglement, a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics, has become a powerful tool impacting various areas of physics. In this proceeding, we investigate the presence of quantum entanglement within the Higgs to ZZ* (HZZ*) interaction at the ATLAS experiment. Utilizing quantum tomography techniques, we extract the complete spin density matrix characterizing the HZZ* interaction from ATLAS Standard Monte Carlo (MC) HZZ* 4l Run2 samples. We then evaluate the presence of quantum entanglement in the system using the derived spin density matrix. Our investigation sheds light on the entanglement properties within the HZZ* interaction, which offers valuable insights into its quantum characteristics.