Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The pure-state ECQC conjecture: counterexamples and a prime-dimensional classification

Ya Zhang

Published Oct 9, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Complete written proof and exact checkers for the pure-state prime-dimensional ECQC question: it holds universally exactly at p=2; every odd prime has a full-Schmidt-rank pure-state counterexample; dimensions 3 and 5 attain the sharp pure-state ratios 3/2 and 5/2. The three-dimensional witness has a separate complete Lean proof, but the full prime-dimensional classification is not claimed Lean-complete. This record explicitly distinguishes prior mixed-state counterexamples and does not claim first priority. The fixed immutable GitHub Release is https://github.com/mxym/math/releases/tag/ecqc-pure-state-classification-v1. AI-assisted research and writing; no external funding. Existing licenses and third-party notices are retained.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23256947

Related papers

Extremal same-basis correlations: full-rank rigidity and a stabilizer classification

Ya Zhang

Complete written proofs and two exact replayable checker implementations classify all full-Schmidt-rank equality states without assuming stabilizer structure, classify every two-qudit pure stabilizer score at odd prime dimension, and determine the sharp pure-state ratio p/2 for every prime p congruent to 1 modulo 4. The general rank-deficient equality classification and the sharp ratio for primes congruent to 3 modulo 4, p at least 7, remain open in this record. This is an independently authored preprint with AI-assisted research and self-audit, not external professional peer review or a priority claim. The fixed immutable GitHub Release is https://github.com/mxym/math/releases/tag/ecqc-extremal-classification-v1. AI-assisted research and writing; no external funding. Existing licenses and third-party notices are retained.

•Oct 9, 2026•0 citations

Concentratable entanglement: counterexamples and sharp repairs

Anonymous

Unrefereed mathematical candidate. Exact counterexamples to a proposed universal mixed-state total concentratable-entanglement upper bound, including full-rank noisy and genuinely tripartite-entangled families; sharp uniform and fixed-size concave-roof impurity repairs. Analytic proofs and producer-side exact arithmetic checks are provided. AI-assisted internal review does not establish external peer review, independent reproduction, formal verification, priority or impact. Original prose and data CC0-1.0; original code MIT. Source literature retains its own terms.

•Oct 13, 2026•0 citations

The Schmidt number of PPT states in 3 × 4 dimensions: partial results and the open case

Neko2333OWO

Status. Partial results only. The note studies, without answering it, the question of Yang, Leung and Tang (Linear Algebra Appl. 503 (2016), Question 3.9): is there an indecomposable 2-positive linear map M_3 → M_4? Dually: can a PPT state of a qutrit and a ququart (C^3 ⊗ C^4) have Schmidt number three? Proved. (1) A 2-block-positive operator on C^3 ⊗ C^4 that vanishes on one nonzero product vector is decomposable, so a witness for Schmidt number three among PPT states would have to be strictly positive on all product vectors. (2) For min(M,N) ≥ 2, the range of every PPT state on C^M ⊗ C^N is spanned by its vectors of Schmidt rank at most min(M,N) − 1; hence no range-only test that is valid for all positive operators can show full Schmidt number for a PPT state. (3) With a lemma of Chen, Yang and Tang: every non-extreme PPT state of birank (6,6) on C^3 ⊗ C^4, and every positive operator on C^3 ⊗ C^N of operator Schmidt rank at most seven, has a separable compression to a two-dimensional local subspace, hence Schmidt number at most two. (4) The maps proposed by C. A. Winda (J. Linear Topol. Algebra 14 (2025) 129–136) as indecomposable 2-positive maps M_3 → M_4 are not 2-positive. Open. A birank-(6,6) counterexample would have to be an extreme edge state with product-free kernels and operator Schmidt rank eight or nine. Numerically, every state tested (42 states covering all ten relevant birank classes) has a separable two-dimensional compression; the note describes where the proof attempts for birank (6,6) stopped. Files. ppt-3x4.pdf is the note. ppt-3x4-supplement.zip contains the statements, proofs and blind reviews of the results as written, the exact computation for the Winda maps, the numerical data and scripts (including exact rational birank-(6,6) edge states with separable compressions), the record of failed proof routes, and the unreviewed working files. "python check.py" (NumPy and SymPy) verifies the hashes and repeats the exact and numerical checks (a few seconds on the laptop used to assemble the archive). The written proofs have not yet been verified line by line by a human reviewer. AI tools. The author chose the question and the statements to attack, set the working rules (blind review of every result by the other model family; fixed stopping rules), had the published Winda maps checked and supplied the paper for that, decided when to stop, and is responsible for the content. The research was carried out on 4–5 November 2026 by an AI research system built on Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic) and GPT-6 Astra (OpenAI); the text was revised on 9 November 2026. Each proof was written by one of the two models and accepted by a blind review from the other; the Winda computation was done by both independently; Claude Opus 5.5 drafted the manuscript and GPT-6 Astra reviewed it blind. Section IX of the note has the details.

•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

Explicit Absolutely Maximally Entangled states in dimensions twice a prime power

Palash Pandya

Absolutely maximally entangled (AME) states are pure multipartite states with maximally mixed reductions on every set of at most half the parties. We construct explicit families in local dimension $2q$, twice an odd prime power $q$, using an established coupling of qubits and $q$-level systems. The $q$-level states remove interference between branches, so the qubit states need maximally mixed reductions only on average. This gives AME$(9,2q)$ and AME$(11,2q)$ for every odd prime power $q\geq5$, AME$(13,2q)$ for $q\geq17$, AME$(15,2q)$ for $q\geq9$, and AME$(17,2q)$ for $q\geq67$. For every odd $N\geq3$, the same coupling gives AME$(N,2q)$ under the sufficient condition $q\geq\max\{N,2^{N-2}\}$ on the odd prime power $q$. Within this coupling, the smallest such $q$ must grow exponentially with $N$. Combined with known inputs and products, these families complete the nine-party classification: for integer $d\geq2$, an AME$(9,d)$ state exists if and only if $d\geq3$. Choosing the branch pairing also gives AME$(15,2p)$ states with a cyclic shift of the parties compensated by local unitaries, for every prime $p\equiv1\pmod{15}$.

arXiv:2611.17216•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Balanced Antipodal Qutrit Pairs: Lorentzian Factorization, Qubit Equivalence, and Equality Classification

Vasily Psykovsky

This preprint establishes a Lorentzian factorization theorem for balanced antipodal quantum-state pairs in three-dimensional Hilbert space, with consequences for qubit–qutrit equivalence, prepare-and-measure correlations, and quantum dimension witnesses. We define a pair of qutrit states as balanced when tr(ρ₊ρ₋)² ≤ (1 − tr ρ₊²)(1 − tr ρ₋²). This class includes orthogonal pure-state pairs and pairs with orthogonal supports. Main contributions: Universal factorization theorem. We prove that every prepare-and-measure correlation table generated by balanced qutrit pairs and admissible binary measurements, without shared randomness, satisfies the Euclidean factorization bound γ₂(T) ≤ 1, regardless of the number of pairs or measurement queries. Exact qubit reproducibility. Combining the factorization theorem with an earlier exact qubit criterion, we establish that balanced qutrit configurations are qubit-reproducible whenever there are at most three antipodal pairs or at most three binary queries. In particular, three orthogonal pure-state pairs cannot distinguish a qutrit from a qubit in this setting. Lorentzian geometric construction. The proof uses the quadratic form Q(X) = 2 tr(X²) − (tr X)² on Hermitian 3 × 3 matrices, with signature (8,1). Its dual representation and the spectral inequality −e₂(A) ≤ 1 yield an explicit Euclidean Gram factorization. Unconditional equality classification. We show that every equality configuration of three orthogonal pure-state pairs belongs, up to unitary equivalence, to an embedded-qubit configuration or one of two previously constructed genuinely three-dimensional families: the spin-1 family and the common-vector family. This removes an additional hypothesis required in the preceding note. Reduction of the remaining open problem. We show that any possible three-pair separation can be reduced to configurations containing pure states paired with states of rank at most two, with at least one overlapping pair. We also introduce a semidefinite-programmable certificate whose conjectured universal validity is supported by numerical experiments but remains unproved. The general conjecture that three arbitrary antipodal qutrit state pairs never separate a qutrit from a qubit remains open. The proved results are independent of the numerical investigations. The accompanying reproducibility archive contains preregistered B4h experiments, symbolic and numerical verification scripts, computational results, and SHA-256 manifests. This is the fifth preprint in a research series on qubit–qutrit equivalence, separation, and the geometry of quantum correlations. Status: Research preprint, version 1 (13 November 2026); not peer reviewed.

•Nov 13, 2026•2 citations

Refuting the X-MEMS closest-separable-state conjecture in arXiv:2209.01430v2, Appendix A, Eq. (A11)

Haobo Ma, Wenlin Zhang

We refute the closest-fully-separable-state shape conjecture of Consiglio, Apollaro and Wieśniak, arXiv:2209.01430v2, Appendix A, Eq. (A11), already for three qubits on the low branch at gamma = 11/112. Every fully separable state of the proposed shape has squared Hilbert–Schmidt distance at least 109/23520, whereas an explicit mixture of ten pure product states has distance 417965512477/90316800000000. The counterexample and exact restricted minimum have self-contained written proofs, as do related counterexamples to the full-separability and concurrence comparisons in the posing source. An elementary bound also establishes its large-qubit limit without the conjectured shape.

•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations
Complete written proof and exact checkers for the pure-state prime-dimensional ECQC question: it holds universally exactly at p=2; every odd prime has a full-Schmidt-rank pure-state counterexample; dimensions 3 and 5 attain the sharp pure-state ratios 3/2 and 5/2. The three-dimensional witness has a separate complete Lean proof, but the full prime-dimensional classification is not claimed Lean-complete. This record explicitly distinguishes prior mixed-state counterexamples and does not claim first priority. The fixed immutable GitHub Release is https://github.com/mxym/math/releases/tag/ecqc-pure-state-classification-v1. AI-assisted research and writing; no external funding. Existing licenses and third-party notices are retained.
Complete written proofs and two exact replayable checker implementations classify all full-Schmidt-rank equality states without assuming stabilizer structure, classify every two-qudit pure stabilizer score at odd prime dimension, and determine the sharp pure-state ratio p/2 for every prime p congruent to 1 modulo 4. The general rank-deficient equality classification and the sharp ratio for primes congruent to 3 modulo 4, p at least 7, remain open in this record. This is an independently authored preprint with AI-assisted research and self-audit, not external professional peer review or a priority claim. The fixed immutable GitHub Release is https://github.com/mxym/math/releases/tag/ecqc-extremal-classification-v1. AI-assisted research and writing; no external funding. Existing licenses and third-party notices are retained.
Unrefereed mathematical candidate. Exact counterexamples to a proposed universal mixed-state total concentratable-entanglement upper bound, including full-rank noisy and genuinely tripartite-entangled families; sharp uniform and fixed-size concave-roof impurity repairs. Analytic proofs and producer-side exact arithmetic checks are provided. AI-assisted internal review does not establish external peer review, independent reproduction, formal verification, priority or impact. Original prose and data CC0-1.0; original code MIT. Source literature retains its own terms.
Status. Partial results only. The note studies, without answering it, the question of Yang, Leung and Tang (Linear Algebra Appl. 503 (2016), Question 3.9): is there an indecomposable 2-positive linear map M_3 → M_4? Dually: can a PPT state of a qutrit and a ququart (C^3 ⊗ C^4) have Schmidt number three? Proved. (1) A 2-block-positive operator on C^3 ⊗ C^4 that vanishes on one nonzero product vector is decomposable, so a witness for Schmidt number three among PPT states would have to be strictly positive on all product vectors. (2) For min(M,N) ≥ 2, the range of every PPT state on C^M ⊗ C^N is spanned by its vectors of Schmidt rank at most min(M,N) − 1; hence no range-only test that is valid for all positive operators can show full Schmidt number for a PPT state. (3) With a lemma of Chen, Yang and Tang: every non-extreme PPT state of birank (6,6) on C^3 ⊗ C^4, and every positive operator on C^3 ⊗ C^N of operator Schmidt rank at most seven, has a separable compression to a two-dimensional local subspace, hence Schmidt number at most two. (4) The maps proposed by C. A. Winda (J. Linear Topol. Algebra 14 (2025) 129–136) as indecomposable 2-positive maps M_3 → M_4 are not 2-positive. Open. A birank-(6,6) counterexample would have to be an extreme edge state with product-free kernels and operator Schmidt rank eight or nine. Numerically, every state tested (42 states covering all ten relevant birank classes) has a separable two-dimensional compression; the note describes where the proof attempts for birank (6,6) stopped. Files. ppt-3x4.pdf is the note. ppt-3x4-supplement.zip contains the statements, proofs and blind reviews of the results as written, the exact computation for the Winda maps, the numerical data and scripts (including exact rational birank-(6,6) edge states with separable compressions), the record of failed proof routes, and the unreviewed working files. "python check.py" (NumPy and SymPy) verifies the hashes and repeats the exact and numerical checks (a few seconds on the laptop used to assemble the archive). The written proofs have not yet been verified line by line by a human reviewer. AI tools. The author chose the question and the statements to attack, set the working rules (blind review of every result by the other model family; fixed stopping rules), had the published Winda maps checked and supplied the paper for that, decided when to stop, and is responsible for the content. The research was carried out on 4–5 November 2026 by an AI research system built on Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic) and GPT-6 Astra (OpenAI); the text was revised on 9 November 2026. Each proof was written by one of the two models and accepted by a blind review from the other; the Winda computation was done by both independently; Claude Opus 5.5 drafted the manuscript and GPT-6 Astra reviewed it blind. Section IX of the note has the details.
Absolutely maximally entangled (AME) states are pure multipartite states with maximally mixed reductions on every set of at most half the parties. We construct explicit families in local dimension 2q2q2q, twice an odd prime power qqq, using an established coupling of qubits and qqq-level systems. The qqq-level states remove interference between branches, so the qubit states need maximally mixed reductions only on average. This gives AME(9,2q)(9,2q)(9,2q) and AME(11,2q)(11,2q)(11,2q) for every odd prime power q≥5q\geq5q≥5, AME(13,2q)(13,2q)(13,2q) for q≥17q\geq17q≥17, AME(15,2q)(15,2q)(15,2q) for q≥9q\geq9q≥9, and AME(17,2q)(17,2q)(17,2q) for q≥67q\geq67q≥67. For every odd N≥3N\geq3N≥3, the same coupling gives AME(N,2q)(N,2q)(N,2q) under the sufficient condition q≥max⁡{N,2N−2}q\geq\max\{N,2^{N-2}\}q≥max{N,2N−2} on the odd prime power qqq. Within this coupling, the smallest such qqq must grow exponentially with NNN. Combined with known inputs and products, these families complete the nine-party classification: for integer d≥2d\geq2d≥2, an AME(9,d)(9,d)(9,d) state exists if and only if d≥3d\geq3d≥3. Choosing the branch pairing also gives AME(15,2p)(15,2p)(15,2p) states with a cyclic shift of the parties compensated by local unitaries, for every prime p≡1(mod15)p\equiv1\pmod{15}p≡1(mod15).
This preprint establishes a Lorentzian factorization theorem for balanced antipodal quantum-state pairs in three-dimensional Hilbert space, with consequences for qubit–qutrit equivalence, prepare-and-measure correlations, and quantum dimension witnesses. We define a pair of qutrit states as balanced when tr(ρ₊ρ₋)² ≤ (1 − tr ρ₊²)(1 − tr ρ₋²). This class includes orthogonal pure-state pairs and pairs with orthogonal supports. Main contributions: Universal factorization theorem. We prove that every prepare-and-measure correlation table generated by balanced qutrit pairs and admissible binary measurements, without shared randomness, satisfies the Euclidean factorization bound γ₂(T) ≤ 1, regardless of the number of pairs or measurement queries. Exact qubit reproducibility. Combining the factorization theorem with an earlier exact qubit criterion, we establish that balanced qutrit configurations are qubit-reproducible whenever there are at most three antipodal pairs or at most three binary queries. In particular, three orthogonal pure-state pairs cannot distinguish a qutrit from a qubit in this setting. Lorentzian geometric construction. The proof uses the quadratic form Q(X) = 2 tr(X²) − (tr X)² on Hermitian 3 × 3 matrices, with signature (8,1). Its dual representation and the spectral inequality −e₂(A) ≤ 1 yield an explicit Euclidean Gram factorization. Unconditional equality classification. We show that every equality configuration of three orthogonal pure-state pairs belongs, up to unitary equivalence, to an embedded-qubit configuration or one of two previously constructed genuinely three-dimensional families: the spin-1 family and the common-vector family. This removes an additional hypothesis required in the preceding note. Reduction of the remaining open problem. We show that any possible three-pair separation can be reduced to configurations containing pure states paired with states of rank at most two, with at least one overlapping pair. We also introduce a semidefinite-programmable certificate whose conjectured universal validity is supported by numerical experiments but remains unproved. The general conjecture that three arbitrary antipodal qutrit state pairs never separate a qutrit from a qubit remains open. The proved results are independent of the numerical investigations. The accompanying reproducibility archive contains preregistered B4h experiments, symbolic and numerical verification scripts, computational results, and SHA-256 manifests. This is the fifth preprint in a research series on qubit–qutrit equivalence, separation, and the geometry of quantum correlations. Status: Research preprint, version 1 (13 November 2026); not peer reviewed.
We refute the closest-fully-separable-state shape conjecture of Consiglio, Apollaro and Wieśniak, arXiv:2209.01430v2, Appendix A, Eq. (A11), already for three qubits on the low branch at gamma = 11/112. Every fully separable state of the proposed shape has squared Hilbert–Schmidt distance at least 109/23520, whereas an explicit mixture of ten pure product states has distance 417965512477/90316800000000. The counterexample and exact restricted minimum have self-contained written proofs, as do related counterexamples to the full-separability and concurrence comparisons in the posing source. An elementary bound also establishes its large-qubit limit without the conjectured shape.