Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entropy and Routing Obstructions for the Boundary-Field Spin-1 Heisenberg Chain, with Exact AKLT Matrix Elements

Zeraoulia Rafik

Published Oct 6, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We study the odd open spin-1 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain with positive endpoint fields through its reversible ground-state transform. The main results are two unconditional all-length obstructions to standard proof strategies. First, a high-magnetization projection recursion gives an explicit product bound on the fully polarized ground-state probability. For every positive field sequence \( h_N=o(N) \) this yields \( \alpha_N(h_N)\to 0 \), \( \qquad \limsup_{N\to\infty}\alpha_N(h_N)\log(N/h_N)\leq \frac{30}{7} \), for the ordinary logarithmic Sobolev constant of the ground-state process, with logarithmic tail coefficient at least (7/6). This does not imply collapse of either the Hamiltonian gap or the modified logarithmic Sobolev constant. Second, for the Diaconis–Stroock/Sinclair length-weighted congestion functional used in this paper, every routing with unit edge lengths has congestion at least linear in N; the same conclusion holds for uniformly comparable edge lengths, while routings forced through a polarized configuration obey a stronger rare-state obstruction. These are limitations of that comparison certificate, not upper bounds on the physical gap.As a complementary exact calculation, transfer matrices for the open AKLT ground space give both the singlet/triplet compression of \( W_m=\sum_{i=1}^{m-1}P_{1,i} \) and its coupling to the orthogonal complement. The compressed spectral diameter is \( O(m3^{-m}) \), whereas \( ||Q_mW_m\mathsf P_m||\sim\sqrt{2(m-1)}/3 \). This finite-block statement quantifies why the bare compressed splitting alone does not control the perturbation at the Heisenberg point; it is not a replacement for a locality-sensitive AKLT stability theorem. Exact rational inertia and interval arithmetic then provide supporting finite-volume certificates: full gaps and the complete AKLT–Heisenberg interpolation are certified for \( N=3,5 \), and at \( N=5,h=1 \) one obtains both a negative pointwise Bakry–Émery curvature witness and [ 27/25<\Delta_5(1)<567/500. \( 27/25<\Delta_5(1)<567/500 \)These finite-volume statements have no asserted local-to-global consequence. The fixed-field uniform boundary-gap problem remains open.

DOI
10.20944/preprints202610.0337.v1

Related papers

Thermodynamic Gaplessness of the Spin-1/2 Kagome Heisenberg Antiferromagnet: An Exact Computer-Assisted Proof

Gary Djigo

This record contains the full author preprint (12 pages), its mathematical supplement (17 pages), and the complete article archive with LaTeX sources, the version note, SHA-256 manifests and the licence. The two PDFs are also provided as individual files for direct reading. Version v3 clarifies the Haar normalization convention in section 9.1 of the mathematical supplement (equation 45). The unnormalised transform H has H*H = 2I and Tr(HQH*) = 2Tr(Q); the equivalent orthogonal transform is H/sqrt(2). This agrees with the existing root/detail identity and exact verifier. The main article, verification code, Lean files, matrix certificates and stated constants are unchanged. See the publication version note for the precise scope of this correction. AbstractWe prove that the nearest-neighbor spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model on the infinite Kagome lattice is gapless in the bulk GNS sense. The argument constructs six explicit local preimages and their complete infinite-lattice Hamiltonian commutators. Two rigorous 17-spin positivity certificates, each decomposed into 31 nontrivial swap-character blocks and nine SU(2) multiplicity blocks, give a state-uniform off-kernel mass floor. Exact operator transport on the two genuine outward Kagome continuations propagates the same physical family through a finite stationary interface. A root/detail/current decomposition, a local current–boundary identity, and state-uniform norm estimates yield a horizon-independent Dirichlet-energy bound. With harmonic weights, for every infinite-volume ground state ω and every R ≥ 1 the same finite family satisfies M_R(ω) ≥ (15/32) ∑_{k=1}^{R} 1/k and E_R(ω) ≤ 761429817528146602401/25088000. Any positive GNS gap would force the second quantity to diverge with the first. Hence every admissible ground-state representation has zero gap, and the declared bulk gap is zero. All finite operator identities and matrix inequalities are checked from exact algebraic data, with rigorous ball arithmetic used for the large positive-definiteness tests. Lean 4 verifies the arbitrary-horizon harmonic implication and the final variational contradiction. The proof uses neither finite-size gap extrapolation nor a spectral cutoff. Companion public verification code, Lean 4 formalization and exact certificates: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23675708 Distribution and reuse are governed by the Public Scientific Evaluation and Reproducibility Terms included with this record. The deposit excludes the author's private discovery engine and proprietary know-how.

•Oct 25, 2026•0 citations

On the uniqueness of translation-invariant ground states of the $S=1$ Heisenberg and $J$--$D$ antiferromagnetic chains

Hal Tasaki

Using the analytic machinery and numerical inputs of OpenAI's proofs of the Haldane gap, we prove uniqueness of the translation-invariant ground state of the infinite $S=1$ Heisenberg antiferromagnetic chain and of the $J$-$D$ model for sufficiently small $|D|$. Uniqueness is among all translation-invariant ground states in the operator-algebraic sense, without assuming a gap or spin-rotation symmetry for a competing state. The proof combines concentration of the spatial transfer spectrum, an exponentially small low-temperature free-energy correction, and a Golden--Thompson comparison for separated local observables. The unique translation-invariant state is pure, locally unique and gapped, and continuous in $D$. The ground states of even periodic chains and odd open chains with equal positive endpoint fields converge to this state along their full sequences, uniformly in $D$, with a stretched-exponential local rate. Every choice of ground states of open chains without endpoint magnetic fields has the same local limit. These conclusions do not establish uniqueness among arbitrary nontranslation-invariant ground states of the infinite chain. The author formulated the problems and proposed the core strategies. ChatGPT Astra made substantial contributions to developing the proofs and preparing the manuscript.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2610.34330•Oct 27, 2026•1 citation

A boundary-field gap for the spin-one Heisenberg chain

OpenAI

We prove a uniform spectral gap for odd open spin-one antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chains with the same fixed magnetic field at both endpoints. The field h=3/5 gives a gap greater than \log(10)/392 on every chain of 2L+1 sites with L ≥ 960. Tasaki's index theorem then gives index −1 for every subsequential local limit of these boundary-selected ground states.

•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

Boundary-induced spin-density waves in linear Heisenberg antiferromagnetic spin chains with S≥1

Dayasindhu Dey, Manoranjan Kumar, Z. G. Soos

Linear Heisenberg antiferromagnets (HAFs) are chains of spin-$S$ sites with isotropic exchange $J$ between neighbors. Open and periodic boundary conditions return the same ground-state energy per site in the thermodynamic limit, but not the same spin ${S}_{G}$ when $S\ensuremath{\ge}1$. The ground state of open chains of $N$ spins has ${S}_{G}=0$ or $S$, respectively, for even or odd $N$. Density-matrix renormalization-group calculations with different algorithms for even and odd $N$ are presented up to $N=500$ for the energy and spin densities $\ensuremath{\rho}(r,N)$ of edge states in HAFs with $S=1$, 3/2, and 2. The edge states are boundary-induced spin density waves (BI-SDWs) with $\ensuremath{\rho}(r,N)\ensuremath{\propto}{(\ensuremath{-}1)}^{r\ensuremath{-}1}$ for $r=1,2,...,N$. The SDWs are in phase when $N$ is odd, are out of phase when $N$ is even, and have finite excitation energy $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}(N)$ that decreases exponentially with $N$ for integer $S$ and faster than $1/N$ for half integer $S$. The spin densities and excitation energy are quantitatively modeled for integer $S$ chains longer than $5\ensuremath{\xi}$ spins by two parameters, the correlation length $\ensuremath{\xi}$ and the SDW amplitude, with $\ensuremath{\xi}=6.048$ for $S=1$ and 49.0 for $S=2$. The BI-SDWs of $S=3/2$ chains are not localized and are qualitatively different for even and odd $N$. Exchange between the ends for odd $N$ is mediated by a delocalized effective spin in the middle that increases $|\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}(N)|$ and weakens the size dependence. The nonlinear sigma model ($\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$) has been applied to the HAFs, primarily to $S=1$ with even $N$, to discuss spin densities and exchange between localized states at the ends as $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}(N)\ensuremath{\propto}{(\ensuremath{-}1)}^{N}exp(\ensuremath{-}N/\ensuremath{\xi})$. $S=1$ chains with odd $N$ are fully consistent with the $\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$; $S=2$ chains have two gaps $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}(N)$ with the same $\ensuremath{\xi}$ as predicted whose ratio is 3.45 rather than 3; the $\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$ is more approximate for $S=3/2$ chains with even $N$ and is modified for exchange between ends for odd $N$.

arXiv:1606.05054•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 14, 2016•9 citations

Strict majorization flow of the half-chain entanglement spectrum under bond healing in the open XX chain: An exact finite-size theorem with mode-resolved monotonicity

Jinghe Xu

We prove an exact, finite-size theorem for the open XX spin chain of length N = 4m whose central bond has a tunable strength t ∈ (0,1]: as the bond heals (t increases), the half-chain ground-state entanglement spectrum becomes strictly more uniform in the majorization order. Mode by mode, the 2m single-particle entanglement (correlation-matrix) eigenvalues pair as 1/2 ± s_k(t), and every s_k(t) is strictly decreasing on (0,1] — a Sign Lemma whose proof is the mathematical core of the paper. As consequences: every strictly Schur-concave entanglement functional (von Neumann entropy, all Rényi entropies of order α > 0) is strictly increasing along the bond-healing path; the largest Schmidt coefficient is strictly decreasing; and the Nielsen LOCC order strictly increases. The proof is entirely elementary and closed at finite size: a two-leg reflection folding reduces the problem to a rank-one-perturbed Jacobi matrix family J(t); the mode velocities dr_k/dt satisfy an exact master identity expressing them as a convex combination of Stieltjes-type sums W_a with weights Ω_a > 0 certified by a zero-counting argument on a Cauchy-type oscillation pencil; and a uniform endpoint bound W_a(t) ≥ W_a(1) > 1/π + 1/(2K) (K = 2M+1) closes the chain. All constants are explicit, every analytic step is checkable by hand, and the finite rational-interval certificates are mechanically re-derivable by exact arithmetic from the stated rules; numerical verifications (double precision plus 60-digit micro-mode layer) accompany every proved statement as non-load-bearing corroboration. We state the interacting case (XXZ, Δ > 0) as a precise conjecture supported by exact-diagonalization numerics, locate exactly where the free-fermion proof breaks, discuss the relation to the entropic g-theorem (complementary, not overlapping), and propose quantum-simulator and photonic-ring tests. The phenomenon and its mode-resolved monotonicity appear to be new; the failure of such monotonicity in nearby settings (bulk RG, strong-coupling Kondo defects) is recalled to delimit the scope. Status labelling. Every claim in this paper carries one of the tags [proved] (complete hand-checkable proof in the text), [established] (proof structure complete with mechanical expansions delegated to an appendix or supplement, all load-bearing steps proved), [conjecture], or [numerical]. Theorem M and the Sign Lemma are [proved].

•Sep 23, 2026•0 citations

Relative-Window Obstructions and Explicit Uniform Gaps in Anisotropic SU(3) Cube Chains

Ken Umeno

We study the untruncated SU(3) lattice gauge Hamiltonian on open chains of elementary cubes, with fixed transverse plaquette coupling and variable side coupling s. A product of exact transverse plaquette ground states defines a nonnegative relative-excitation operator Dn. For every fixed 0 < s ≤ 1, we prove that the interacting vacuum has Dn-expectation at least c(s)n, with an explicit positive rational function c. Consequently, complete global relative-energy windows used with an affine complementary-space lower bound require linearly growing thresholds and exponentially growing dimensions. In the same model, we prove a spectral gap uniform in the chain length for 0 ≤ s ≤ 77/2350080: both the full kinematic Hamiltonian and its neutral Gauss restriction have gap at least 77/765. The proof combines an all-charge single-plaquette gap bound with a self-contained creation- operator contraction and excitation-resolvent estimate on infinite-dimensional site spaces. All smallness constants are explicit. The two results distinguish the cost of a fixed-reference window certificate from the presence of a physical spectral gap. They complement the finite-volume certificates at s = 1 in G1B. No uniform statement at s = 1, growing three-dimensional cross-section, or continuum limit is asserted.

•Oct 25, 2026•0 citations
We study the odd open spin-1 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain with positive endpoint fields through its reversible ground-state transform. The main results are two unconditional all-length obstructions to standard proof strategies. First, a high-magnetization projection recursion gives an explicit product bound on the fully polarized ground-state probability. For every positive field sequence ( h_N=o(N) ) this yields ( \alpha_N(h_N)\to 0 ), ( \qquad \limsup_{N\to\infty}\alpha_N(h_N)\log(N/h_N)\leq \frac{30}{7} ), for the ordinary logarithmic Sobolev constant of the ground-state process, with logarithmic tail coefficient at least (7/6). This does not imply collapse of either the Hamiltonian gap or the modified logarithmic Sobolev constant. Second, for the Diaconis–Stroock/Sinclair length-weighted congestion functional used in this paper, every routing with unit edge lengths has congestion at least linear in N; the same conclusion holds for uniformly comparable edge lengths, while routings forced through a polarized configuration obey a stronger rare-state obstruction. These are limitations of that comparison certificate, not upper bounds on the physical gap.As a complementary exact calculation, transfer matrices for the open AKLT ground space give both the singlet/triplet compression of ( W_m=\sum_{i=1}^{m-1}P_{1,i} ) and its coupling to the orthogonal complement. The compressed spectral diameter is ( O(m3^{-m}) ), whereas ( ||Q_mW_m\mathsf P_m||\sim\sqrt{2(m-1)}/3 ). This finite-block statement quantifies why the bare compressed splitting alone does not control the perturbation at the Heisenberg point; it is not a replacement for a locality-sensitive AKLT stability theorem. Exact rational inertia and interval arithmetic then provide supporting finite-volume certificates: full gaps and the complete AKLT–Heisenberg interpolation are certified for ( N=3,5 ), and at ( N=5,h=1 ) one obtains both a negative pointwise Bakry–Émery curvature witness and [ 27/25<\Delta_5(1)<567/500. ( 27/25<\Delta_5(1)<567/500 )These finite-volume statements have no asserted local-to-global consequence. The fixed-field uniform boundary-gap problem remains open.
This record contains the full author preprint (12 pages), its mathematical supplement (17 pages), and the complete article archive with LaTeX sources, the version note, SHA-256 manifests and the licence. The two PDFs are also provided as individual files for direct reading. Version v3 clarifies the Haar normalization convention in section 9.1 of the mathematical supplement (equation 45). The unnormalised transform H has H*H = 2I and Tr(HQH*) = 2Tr(Q); the equivalent orthogonal transform is H/sqrt(2). This agrees with the existing root/detail identity and exact verifier. The main article, verification code, Lean files, matrix certificates and stated constants are unchanged. See the publication version note for the precise scope of this correction. AbstractWe prove that the nearest-neighbor spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model on the infinite Kagome lattice is gapless in the bulk GNS sense. The argument constructs six explicit local preimages and their complete infinite-lattice Hamiltonian commutators. Two rigorous 17-spin positivity certificates, each decomposed into 31 nontrivial swap-character blocks and nine SU(2) multiplicity blocks, give a state-uniform off-kernel mass floor. Exact operator transport on the two genuine outward Kagome continuations propagates the same physical family through a finite stationary interface. A root/detail/current decomposition, a local current–boundary identity, and state-uniform norm estimates yield a horizon-independent Dirichlet-energy bound. With harmonic weights, for every infinite-volume ground state ω and every R ≥ 1 the same finite family satisfies M_R(ω) ≥ (15/32) ∑_{k=1}^{R} 1/k and E_R(ω) ≤ 761429817528146602401/25088000. Any positive GNS gap would force the second quantity to diverge with the first. Hence every admissible ground-state representation has zero gap, and the declared bulk gap is zero. All finite operator identities and matrix inequalities are checked from exact algebraic data, with rigorous ball arithmetic used for the large positive-definiteness tests. Lean 4 verifies the arbitrary-horizon harmonic implication and the final variational contradiction. The proof uses neither finite-size gap extrapolation nor a spectral cutoff. Companion public verification code, Lean 4 formalization and exact certificates: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23675708 Distribution and reuse are governed by the Public Scientific Evaluation and Reproducibility Terms included with this record. The deposit excludes the author's private discovery engine and proprietary know-how.
On the uniqueness of translation-invariant ground states of the S=1S=1S=1 Heisenberg and JJJ--DDD antiferromagnetic chains
Using the analytic machinery and numerical inputs of OpenAI's proofs of the Haldane gap, we prove uniqueness of the translation-invariant ground state of the infinite S=1S=1S=1 Heisenberg antiferromagnetic chain and of the JJJ-DDD model for sufficiently small ∣D∣|D|∣D∣. Uniqueness is among all translation-invariant ground states in the operator-algebraic sense, without assuming a gap or spin-rotation symmetry for a competing state. The proof combines concentration of the spatial transfer spectrum, an exponentially small low-temperature free-energy correction, and a Golden--Thompson comparison for separated local observables. The unique translation-invariant state is pure, locally unique and gapped, and continuous in DDD. The ground states of even periodic chains and odd open chains with equal positive endpoint fields converge to this state along their full sequences, uniformly in DDD, with a stretched-exponential local rate. Every choice of ground states of open chains without endpoint magnetic fields has the same local limit. These conclusions do not establish uniqueness among arbitrary nontranslation-invariant ground states of the infinite chain. The author formulated the problems and proposed the core strategies. ChatGPT Astra made substantial contributions to developing the proofs and preparing the manuscript.
Linear Heisenberg antiferromagnets (HAFs) are chains of spin-SSS sites with isotropic exchange JJJ between neighbors. Open and periodic boundary conditions return the same ground-state energy per site in the thermodynamic limit, but not the same spin SG{S}_{G}SG​ when $S\ensuremath{\ge}1$. The ground state of open chains of NNN spins has SG=0{S}_{G}=0SG​=0 or SSS, respectively, for even or odd NNN. Density-matrix renormalization-group calculations with different algorithms for even and odd NNN are presented up to N=500N=500N=500 for the energy and spin densities $\ensuremath{\rho}(r,N)$ of edge states in HAFs with S=1S=1S=1, 3/2, and 2. The edge states are boundary-induced spin density waves (BI-SDWs) with $\ensuremath{\rho}(r,N)\ensuremath{\propto}{(\ensuremath{-}1)}^{r\ensuremath{-}1}$ for r=1,2,...,Nr=1,2,...,Nr=1,2,...,N. The SDWs are in phase when NNN is odd, are out of phase when NNN is even, and have finite excitation energy $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}(N)$ that decreases exponentially with NNN for integer SSS and faster than 1/N1/N1/N for half integer SSS. The spin densities and excitation energy are quantitatively modeled for integer SSS chains longer than $5\ensuremath{\xi}$ spins by two parameters, the correlation length $\ensuremath{\xi}$ and the SDW amplitude, with $\ensuremath{\xi}=6.048$ for S=1S=1S=1 and 49.0 for S=2S=2S=2. The BI-SDWs of S=3/2S=3/2S=3/2 chains are not localized and are qualitatively different for even and odd NNN. Exchange between the ends for odd NNN is mediated by a delocalized effective spin in the middle that increases $|\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}(N)|$ and weakens the size dependence. The nonlinear sigma model ($\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$) has been applied to the HAFs, primarily to S=1S=1S=1 with even NNN, to discuss spin densities and exchange between localized states at the ends as $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}(N)\ensuremath{\propto}{(\ensuremath{-}1)}^{N}exp(\ensuremath{-}N/\ensuremath{\xi})$. S=1S=1S=1 chains with odd NNN are fully consistent with the $\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$; S=2S=2S=2 chains have two gaps $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}(N)$ with the same $\ensuremath{\xi}$ as predicted whose ratio is 3.45 rather than 3; the $\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$ is more approximate for S=3/2S=3/2S=3/2 chains with even NNN and is modified for exchange between ends for odd NNN.
We prove an exact, finite-size theorem for the open XX spin chain of length N = 4m whose central bond has a tunable strength t ∈ (0,1]: as the bond heals (t increases), the half-chain ground-state entanglement spectrum becomes strictly more uniform in the majorization order. Mode by mode, the 2m single-particle entanglement (correlation-matrix) eigenvalues pair as 1/2 ± s_k(t), and every s_k(t) is strictly decreasing on (0,1] — a Sign Lemma whose proof is the mathematical core of the paper. As consequences: every strictly Schur-concave entanglement functional (von Neumann entropy, all Rényi entropies of order α > 0) is strictly increasing along the bond-healing path; the largest Schmidt coefficient is strictly decreasing; and the Nielsen LOCC order strictly increases. The proof is entirely elementary and closed at finite size: a two-leg reflection folding reduces the problem to a rank-one-perturbed Jacobi matrix family J(t); the mode velocities dr_k/dt satisfy an exact master identity expressing them as a convex combination of Stieltjes-type sums W_a with weights Ω_a > 0 certified by a zero-counting argument on a Cauchy-type oscillation pencil; and a uniform endpoint bound W_a(t) ≥ W_a(1) > 1/π + 1/(2K) (K = 2M+1) closes the chain. All constants are explicit, every analytic step is checkable by hand, and the finite rational-interval certificates are mechanically re-derivable by exact arithmetic from the stated rules; numerical verifications (double precision plus 60-digit micro-mode layer) accompany every proved statement as non-load-bearing corroboration. We state the interacting case (XXZ, Δ > 0) as a precise conjecture supported by exact-diagonalization numerics, locate exactly where the free-fermion proof breaks, discuss the relation to the entropic g-theorem (complementary, not overlapping), and propose quantum-simulator and photonic-ring tests. The phenomenon and its mode-resolved monotonicity appear to be new; the failure of such monotonicity in nearby settings (bulk RG, strong-coupling Kondo defects) is recalled to delimit the scope. Status labelling. Every claim in this paper carries one of the tags [proved] (complete hand-checkable proof in the text), [established] (proof structure complete with mechanical expansions delegated to an appendix or supplement, all load-bearing steps proved), [conjecture], or [numerical]. Theorem M and the Sign Lemma are [proved].
We study the untruncated SU(3) lattice gauge Hamiltonian on open chains of elementary cubes, with fixed transverse plaquette coupling and variable side coupling s. A product of exact transverse plaquette ground states defines a nonnegative relative-excitation operator Dn. For every fixed 0 < s ≤ 1, we prove that the interacting vacuum has Dn-expectation at least c(s)n, with an explicit positive rational function c. Consequently, complete global relative-energy windows used with an affine complementary-space lower bound require linearly growing thresholds and exponentially growing dimensions. In the same model, we prove a spectral gap uniform in the chain length for 0 ≤ s ≤ 77/2350080: both the full kinematic Hamiltonian and its neutral Gauss restriction have gap at least 77/765. The proof combines an all-charge single-plaquette gap bound with a self-contained creation- operator contraction and excitation-resolvent estimate on infinite-dimensional site spaces. All smallness constants are explicit. The two results distinguish the cost of a fixed-reference window certificate from the presence of a physical spectral gap. They complement the finite-volume certificates at s = 1 in G1B. No uniform statement at s = 1, growing three-dimensional cross-section, or continuum limit is asserted.