Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Nonclassicality in noisy quantum networks

Brian Dopkins Doolittle

Published Sep 28, 2023• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Quantum networks are rapidly being developed using the noisy quantum devices available today.As quantum networks scale, noise will lead to significant challenges in quantum network characterization, design, and automation, challenges that classical methods may be ill equipped to tackle.Moreover, the advantage and value of quantum networks is not well understood in the presence of noise, making it difficult to justify the cost of quantum network development for real-world applications.In this dissertation, we define operational nonclassicality as a quantifier of quantum advantage in general multipoint communication networks and describe a procedure for deriving operational tests of nonclassicality in general communication networks.Then, we develop a quantum-hardware-compatible variational optimization framework for optimizing quantum networks to exhibit nonclassicality.In a wide range of communication network topologies, including nonsignaling networks, multiaccess networks, broadcast networks, and interference networks, we derive operational tests that witness nonclassicality.We then use our variational framework to optimize various quantum resource configurations for maximal performance against these operational tests of nonclassicality.In all communication network topologies, we find examples where quantum resources lead to observable violations of the nonclassicality witnesses, implying that quantum resources provide a strict advantage over classical resources.Furthermore, we investigate how the presence of noise diminishes these advantages, and by extension, the value of quantum resources.Finally, we demonstrate that our variational optimization techniques can be deployed on quantum hardware and applied well beyond the scope of finding nonclassical quantum behaviors.In conclusion, we find that nearly all quantum resource configurations in communication networks can provide operational advantage as witnessed by operational tests of nonclassicality.These nonclassical network behaviors show novel ways that quantum physics defies the classical assumptions of locality, causality, and realism, but nonclassicality can also be used to test and certify quantum resources in communication networks.Furthermore, nonclassicality can also provide advantages in information security and distributed computing.We assert that variational quantum optimization techniques are well-suited to design and automation tasks in quantum networks.The advantages of these methods are that they are hardware agnostic, do not require full network characterization, and can optimize quantum systems against their inherent and unknown noise models.Thus, we introduce variational quantum networking as an engineering paradigm for designing and automating noisy quantum networks.In many ways, variational quantum networking circumvents the challenges of characterizing, designing, and automating noisy quantum networks.

Related papers

An Operational Framework for Nonclassicality in Quantum Communication Networks

Brian Doolittle, Felix Leditzky, Eric Chitambar

Quantum resources, such as entanglement or quantum communication, offer significant communication advantages in information processing. We develop an operational framework for realizing these communication advantages in resource-constrained quantum networks. The framework computes linear bounds on the input/output probabilities of classical networks with limited communication and globally shared randomness. Since the violation of these classical bounds witnesses nonclassicality, a measurable communication advantage, the framework maximizes the violation of the classical bound using variational quantum optimization methods tailored to the communication network and quantum resources. This operational framework for nonclassicality can be scaled on quantum computers or deployed in the field to optimize noisy quantum networks for communication advantages. Applying this framework, we investigate the nonclassicality of communication networks that are assisted by quantum resources. We find that entanglement between communication-constrained parties is sufficient for nonclassicality to be found, whereas in networks with multiple senders, quantum communication with no entanglement-assistance is sufficient for nonclassicality to be found. As a result, entanglement is necessary for nonclassicality when a single sender broadcasts to multiple receivers.

arXiv:2403.02988•Quantum•Apr 8, 2026•5 citations

Variational Quantum Optimization of Nonlocality in Noisy Quantum Networks

Brian Doolittle, R. Thomas Bromley, Nathan Killoran +1 more

The noise and complexity inherent to quantum communication networks leads to technical challenges in designing quantum network protocols using classical methods. We address this issue with a hybrid variational quantum optimization framework (VQO) that simulates quantum networks on quantum hardware and optimizes the simulation using differential programming. We maximize nonlocality in noisy quantum networks to showcase our VQO framework. Using a classical simulator we investigate the noise robustness of quantum nonlocality. Our VQO methods reproduce known results and uncover novel phenomena. We find that maximally entangled states maximize nonlocality in the presence of unital qubit channels, while nonmaximally entangled states can maximize nonlocality in the presence of nonunital qubit channels. Thus, we show VQO to be a practical design tool for quantum networks even when run on a classical simulator. Finally, using IBM quantum computers we demonstrate that our VQO framework can maximize nonlocality on noisy quantum hardware. In the long-term, our VQO techniques show promise of scaling beyond classical approaches and can be deployed on quantum network hardware to optimize network protocols against their inherent noise.

arXiv:2205.02891•IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering•Jan 1, 2023•22 citations

Operational Characterization of Infinite-Dimensional Quantum Resources

Erkka Haapasalo, Tristan Kraft, Juha-Pekka Pellonpää +1 more

Recently, various nonclassical properties of quantum states and channels have been characterized through an advantage they provide in quantum information tasks over their classical counterparts. Such advantage can be typically proven to be quantitative, in that larger amounts of quantum resources lead to better performance in the corresponding tasks. So far, these characterizations have been established only in the finite-dimensional setting, hence, leaving out central resources in continuous variable systems such as entanglement and nonclassicality of states as well as entanglement breaking and broadcasting channels. In this Letter, we present a fully general framework for resource quantification in infinite-dimensional systems. The framework is applicable to a wide range of resources with the only premises being that classical randomness cannot create a resource and that the resourceless objects form a closed set in an appropriate sense. As the latter may be hard to establish for the abstract topologies of continuous variable systems, we provide a relaxation of the condition with no reference to topology. This envelopes the aforementioned resources and various others, hence, giving them an interpretation as performance enhancement in so-called input-output games.

arXiv:2010.10927•Physical Review Letters•Dec 15, 2021•1 citation

Variational Quantum Optimization of Noisy Polarization Qubit Experiments

Timur Javid, Brian Doolittle, Colin P. Lualdi +4 more

Quantum networking enables advanced communication protocols, distributed quantum computing, and enhanced sensing. These applications are often hindered by current realizations of quantum network nodes, which utilize noisy and imperfect hardware. Here, we apply variational optimization to counteract the effects of such imperfections. We parameterize network protocols for use with variational methods and then use these methods to optimize simple prepare-and-measure protocols on an optical testbed as a proof-of-principle demonstration. We demonstrate automated polarization compensation, achieving results comparable to conventional methods. We also analyze the effects of hardware imperfections and dark counts on the performance of our optimizations. We compare the performance of various gradient estimation methods and propose natural extensions, including further improvements through the use of global optimization and hybrid gradient estimation methods, as well as the application of variational optimization to nodes deployed on fiber networks.

quant-pharXiv:2610.33290•Oct 27, 2026•0 citations

Operational Characterization of Infinite-Dimensional Quantum Resources

Haapasalo Erkka, Kraft Tristan, Juha-Pekka Pellonpää +1 more

Recently, various nonclassical properties of quantum states and channels have been characterized through an advantage they provide in quantum information tasks over their classical counterparts.Such advantage can be typically proven to be quantitative, in that larger amounts of quantum resources lead to better performance in the corresponding tasks.So far, these characterizations have been established only in the finite-dimensional setting, hence, leaving out central resources in continuous variable systems such as entanglement and nonclassicality of states as well as entanglement breaking and broadcasting channels.In this Letter, we present a fully general framework for resource quantification in infinite-dimensional systems.The framework is applicable to a wide range of resources with the only premises being that classical randomness cannot create a resource and that the resourceless objects form a closed set in an appropriate sense.As the latter may be hard to establish for the abstract topologies of continuous variable systems, we provide a relaxation of the condition with no reference to topology.This envelopes the aforementioned resources and various others, hence, giving them an interpretation as performance enhancement in so-called input-output games.

•Oct 27, 2022•4 citations

Distributing and tailoring noisy resource states in quantum networks

Maria Flors Mor-Ruiz

Quantum information science is an interdisciplinary field that investigates the principles and applications of quantum mechanics in information processing. Upcoming quantum technologies promise a range of valuable applications, including powerful simulation of complex systems, enhanced computational capabilities, high-precision sensing and metrology, and secure communication via quantum key distribution. A central concept is entanglement, a unique type of correlation between quantum systems that has no classical counterpart. Entanglement plays a pivotal role in many quantum protocols, particularly as a key resource in quantum communication, where protocols such as distributed quantum computation and secret sharing are executed in a distributed setting. Hence, distributing entanglement over long distances and manipulating it locally is essential for enabling quantum communication applications. However, the effectiveness of such applications is limited by the challenges of transmitting quantum information and maintaining precise control over quantum systems. For example, quantum information carriers, such as photons traveling through optical fibers, may be lost, or the operations performed may not be perfect. Consequently, it is crucial to develop robust tools for distributing and manipulating entanglement in distributed settings in order to fully unlock the capabilities of quantum technologies. In this thesis, we explore the influence of noise on the manipulation of entanglement in entanglement-based quantum networks. First, we examine the noise resilience of various resource states, i.e., pre-established entangled states, used to achieve bipartite or tripartite communication. This is followed by an analysis of a fully asymmetric network scenario, incorporating the noise introduced by the delays from classical messaging within the quantum network. We then propose classical communication protocols to achieve bipartite communication and evaluate their noise impact under the optimization of the arrangement of the pre-established entanglement. In addition, we propose an alternative approach to quantum repeaters, a key device for entanglement distribution, based on growing multipartite states, allowing entanglement to be recycled and patched. All investigations have been carried out employing a novel formalism, also developed in this thesis, for efficiently and accurately simulating noisy quantum processes on classical hardware, with broader applicability beyond quantum communication.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations
Quantum networks are rapidly being developed using the noisy quantum devices available today.As quantum networks scale, noise will lead to significant challenges in quantum network characterization, design, and automation, challenges that classical methods may be ill equipped to tackle.Moreover, the advantage and value of quantum networks is not well understood in the presence of noise, making it difficult to justify the cost of quantum network development for real-world applications.In this dissertation, we define operational nonclassicality as a quantifier of quantum advantage in general multipoint communication networks and describe a procedure for deriving operational tests of nonclassicality in general communication networks.Then, we develop a quantum-hardware-compatible variational optimization framework for optimizing quantum networks to exhibit nonclassicality.In a wide range of communication network topologies, including nonsignaling networks, multiaccess networks, broadcast networks, and interference networks, we derive operational tests that witness nonclassicality.We then use our variational framework to optimize various quantum resource configurations for maximal performance against these operational tests of nonclassicality.In all communication network topologies, we find examples where quantum resources lead to observable violations of the nonclassicality witnesses, implying that quantum resources provide a strict advantage over classical resources.Furthermore, we investigate how the presence of noise diminishes these advantages, and by extension, the value of quantum resources.Finally, we demonstrate that our variational optimization techniques can be deployed on quantum hardware and applied well beyond the scope of finding nonclassical quantum behaviors.In conclusion, we find that nearly all quantum resource configurations in communication networks can provide operational advantage as witnessed by operational tests of nonclassicality.These nonclassical network behaviors show novel ways that quantum physics defies the classical assumptions of locality, causality, and realism, but nonclassicality can also be used to test and certify quantum resources in communication networks.Furthermore, nonclassicality can also provide advantages in information security and distributed computing.We assert that variational quantum optimization techniques are well-suited to design and automation tasks in quantum networks.The advantages of these methods are that they are hardware agnostic, do not require full network characterization, and can optimize quantum systems against their inherent and unknown noise models.Thus, we introduce variational quantum networking as an engineering paradigm for designing and automating noisy quantum networks.In many ways, variational quantum networking circumvents the challenges of characterizing, designing, and automating noisy quantum networks.
Quantum resources, such as entanglement or quantum communication, offer significant communication advantages in information processing. We develop an operational framework for realizing these communication advantages in resource-constrained quantum networks. The framework computes linear bounds on the input/output probabilities of classical networks with limited communication and globally shared randomness. Since the violation of these classical bounds witnesses nonclassicality, a measurable communication advantage, the framework maximizes the violation of the classical bound using variational quantum optimization methods tailored to the communication network and quantum resources. This operational framework for nonclassicality can be scaled on quantum computers or deployed in the field to optimize noisy quantum networks for communication advantages. Applying this framework, we investigate the nonclassicality of communication networks that are assisted by quantum resources. We find that entanglement between communication-constrained parties is sufficient for nonclassicality to be found, whereas in networks with multiple senders, quantum communication with no entanglement-assistance is sufficient for nonclassicality to be found. As a result, entanglement is necessary for nonclassicality when a single sender broadcasts to multiple receivers.
The noise and complexity inherent to quantum communication networks leads to technical challenges in designing quantum network protocols using classical methods. We address this issue with a hybrid variational quantum optimization framework (VQO) that simulates quantum networks on quantum hardware and optimizes the simulation using differential programming. We maximize nonlocality in noisy quantum networks to showcase our VQO framework. Using a classical simulator we investigate the noise robustness of quantum nonlocality. Our VQO methods reproduce known results and uncover novel phenomena. We find that maximally entangled states maximize nonlocality in the presence of unital qubit channels, while nonmaximally entangled states can maximize nonlocality in the presence of nonunital qubit channels. Thus, we show VQO to be a practical design tool for quantum networks even when run on a classical simulator. Finally, using IBM quantum computers we demonstrate that our VQO framework can maximize nonlocality on noisy quantum hardware. In the long-term, our VQO techniques show promise of scaling beyond classical approaches and can be deployed on quantum network hardware to optimize network protocols against their inherent noise.
Recently, various nonclassical properties of quantum states and channels have been characterized through an advantage they provide in quantum information tasks over their classical counterparts. Such advantage can be typically proven to be quantitative, in that larger amounts of quantum resources lead to better performance in the corresponding tasks. So far, these characterizations have been established only in the finite-dimensional setting, hence, leaving out central resources in continuous variable systems such as entanglement and nonclassicality of states as well as entanglement breaking and broadcasting channels. In this Letter, we present a fully general framework for resource quantification in infinite-dimensional systems. The framework is applicable to a wide range of resources with the only premises being that classical randomness cannot create a resource and that the resourceless objects form a closed set in an appropriate sense. As the latter may be hard to establish for the abstract topologies of continuous variable systems, we provide a relaxation of the condition with no reference to topology. This envelopes the aforementioned resources and various others, hence, giving them an interpretation as performance enhancement in so-called input-output games.
Quantum networking enables advanced communication protocols, distributed quantum computing, and enhanced sensing. These applications are often hindered by current realizations of quantum network nodes, which utilize noisy and imperfect hardware. Here, we apply variational optimization to counteract the effects of such imperfections. We parameterize network protocols for use with variational methods and then use these methods to optimize simple prepare-and-measure protocols on an optical testbed as a proof-of-principle demonstration. We demonstrate automated polarization compensation, achieving results comparable to conventional methods. We also analyze the effects of hardware imperfections and dark counts on the performance of our optimizations. We compare the performance of various gradient estimation methods and propose natural extensions, including further improvements through the use of global optimization and hybrid gradient estimation methods, as well as the application of variational optimization to nodes deployed on fiber networks.
Recently, various nonclassical properties of quantum states and channels have been characterized through an advantage they provide in quantum information tasks over their classical counterparts.Such advantage can be typically proven to be quantitative, in that larger amounts of quantum resources lead to better performance in the corresponding tasks.So far, these characterizations have been established only in the finite-dimensional setting, hence, leaving out central resources in continuous variable systems such as entanglement and nonclassicality of states as well as entanglement breaking and broadcasting channels.In this Letter, we present a fully general framework for resource quantification in infinite-dimensional systems.The framework is applicable to a wide range of resources with the only premises being that classical randomness cannot create a resource and that the resourceless objects form a closed set in an appropriate sense.As the latter may be hard to establish for the abstract topologies of continuous variable systems, we provide a relaxation of the condition with no reference to topology.This envelopes the aforementioned resources and various others, hence, giving them an interpretation as performance enhancement in so-called input-output games.
Quantum information science is an interdisciplinary field that investigates the principles and applications of quantum mechanics in information processing. Upcoming quantum technologies promise a range of valuable applications, including powerful simulation of complex systems, enhanced computational capabilities, high-precision sensing and metrology, and secure communication via quantum key distribution. A central concept is entanglement, a unique type of correlation between quantum systems that has no classical counterpart. Entanglement plays a pivotal role in many quantum protocols, particularly as a key resource in quantum communication, where protocols such as distributed quantum computation and secret sharing are executed in a distributed setting. Hence, distributing entanglement over long distances and manipulating it locally is essential for enabling quantum communication applications. However, the effectiveness of such applications is limited by the challenges of transmitting quantum information and maintaining precise control over quantum systems. For example, quantum information carriers, such as photons traveling through optical fibers, may be lost, or the operations performed may not be perfect. Consequently, it is crucial to develop robust tools for distributing and manipulating entanglement in distributed settings in order to fully unlock the capabilities of quantum technologies. In this thesis, we explore the influence of noise on the manipulation of entanglement in entanglement-based quantum networks. First, we examine the noise resilience of various resource states, i.e., pre-established entangled states, used to achieve bipartite or tripartite communication. This is followed by an analysis of a fully asymmetric network scenario, incorporating the noise introduced by the delays from classical messaging within the quantum network. We then propose classical communication protocols to achieve bipartite communication and evaluate their noise impact under the optimization of the arrangement of the pre-established entanglement. In addition, we propose an alternative approach to quantum repeaters, a key device for entanglement distribution, based on growing multipartite states, allowing entanglement to be recycled and patched. All investigations have been carried out employing a novel formalism, also developed in this thesis, for efficiently and accurately simulating noisy quantum processes on classical hardware, with broader applicability beyond quantum communication.