Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

How seriously do we take CPT? Levels of time-symmetry acceptance, and what each predicts for final-boundary tests and two-way quantum computing

Jarek Duda

Published Oct 2, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The laws of physics are CPT-symmetric, yet laboratory quantum mechanics prepares the past and only samples the future. This working paper distinguishes five levels of taking the symmetry seriously — symmetric laws with the open future left implicit, a two-boundary description, symmetric processes, a nontrivial final boundary, and laboratory access to it — places published views and experiments on them, and states what each predicts for a final-boundary test, in which an engineered terminal acts on a flag and an entangled partner is read on every trial. Exact results: an open future propagates backward through any physical channel; a terminal can only transfer, never manufacture, final-side contrast, giving lambda = tanh(hbar omega / 2 k T_f) in a swap model, the mirror of a reset; a clamp of budget A needs an energy of at least k T_f ln A in some branch; under free local control any every-trial final condition signals, with visibility equal to the clamp strength. Under stated transfer models a null reads as a lower bound on a swap-equivalent final temperature (Partridge: above 3.5e7 K for escaping microwaves; planned qubit tests: about 27 K and 360 K). The paper audits transport to the future, specifies what any physical source of a final condition must supply, and finds that no named candidate meets the specification. CPT motivates the reversed-resource question; channel duality bounds its possible transfer; laboratory access remains an additional physical hypothesis, decided only by experiment. No new experimental result is reported. Drafted with AI assistance and revised after AI-assisted reviews; responsibility rests with the author.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23101894

Related papers

How seriously do we take CPT? Levels of time-symmetry acceptance, and what each predicts for final-boundary tests and two-way quantum computing

Jarek Duda

•Oct 2, 2026•0 citations

QTT Physical Contact Selection and Predictive Transfer Theorem

Attar Ali

From independently qualified work to one interaction and several observations \[\boxed{L\ker B=\{0\}.}\] When does a device's independently specified work already determine its interaction? In a finite affine constructor, the answer is exact: every unresolved calibration direction must disappear from the observable interaction. The paper proves necessity and sufficiency, constructs a dual certificate, and counts the additional linear probes needed when selection fails. The QTT source-to-contact construction connects geometry, supported work, mode participation and the actual electrode waveform to a single coupling. That same coupling predicts one-excitation transfer, two-excitation redistribution, phase response and parity controls. A finite future-memory theorem identifies what must remain in the retained packet so that later operations cannot reveal something the model discarded. For independently specified insertion magnitudes, the cross-occupation prediction is \[P_{11}=\cos^2(F\Theta),\qquad F^2=f_{2,a}^2+f_{2,b}^2.\] For symmetric-slot modes, the corresponding frequency ratio obeys \[\boxed{\left(\frac{\Omega_2}{2\Omega_1}\right)^2=1-\frac{1}{2K_a}-\frac{1}{2K_b}.}\] Version 2.0 adds complete feasible-set selection, a harmonic three-dimensional drive, unequal-capacity transfer, and the full preparation-to-detector calculation. A cross-Kerr counterexample shows why a perfect one-excitation calibration alone cannot settle the two-excitation prediction. The package contains the manuscript, proofs, executable checks, synthetic examples and a reproducible audit of the public Hou trapped-ion tables. The selection and transfer results are proved within their stated finite classes. The canonical realization shares laboratory probabilities with matched microscopic quantum mechanics; finite-slot discrimination requires independently qualified physical capacities and instruments. The archive is a retrospective eligibility audit. The separate prospective test commits the measurement design before a laboratory supplies its physical capsule. Companion: Artian's Physical Contact Transfer Test. Source dependencies: Completed-Event Transport and Quantum Coherence; QTT Main Book. Independent experimental context: Hou et al., Nature Physics (2024). Browse the corpus. The main PDF is the preview; the ZIP contains the full reconstruction package.

•Sep 26, 2026•6 citations

The Ledger Is Not Enough: Counts, Memory and Observable Content in a Finite Record Framework

David Elliman

STATUS (18 October 2026). The physics programme that motivated this work was concluded in October 2026 and its claim of a unified derivation withdrawn. The results in this paper do not depend on that programme and stand as stated. Can an exact account of recorded events also determine what happens next? We examine this question in a finite quantum model with 48 preparations and an apparatus with ten distinguishable outcomes. Two reversible evolution rules reproduce exactly the same first-use specification but predict different results when the apparatus is used again. A separate example fixes one evolution rule: two possible histories then have identical counts of reads, commits and service events, yet different probabilities for the next outcome. Counts alone are therefore insufficient for prediction in this model. What remains visible depends on the observation. At eight preparations, even the complete individual-read distributions agree between the two rules, while correlations between the reads distinguish them. We classify two explicitly specified families of observations and determine exact ranges for the simpler family, showing both how distinctions are lost and how they can survive. The results separate event accounting, the choice of evolution, retained memory and the conversion of records into measured responses. They are conditional finite-model results, not a derivation of a physical dynamics or a measured coupling. The contribution is a set of exact counterexamples and classifications, rather than new principles of quantum theory. Exact computations and explicit proofs identify the additional response, weighting and sampling choices that a predictive physical interpretation must supply. Version 0.2 incorporates corrections following an author-requested preprint review. The deposit supplies the PDF, editable LaTeX with three TikZ figures, bibliography, exact fixture data for 96 two-read processes over 48 preparations, and a portable Python/SymPy verifier. The revised verifier passes 2,926 exact assertions. These are conditional finite-model results; no physical law, bridge, weighting or sampling measure is selected. The unchanged historical audit sources are available in a separately linked companion archive. Frozen audit sources and INT99 result dossier: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22541080.

•Sep 6, 2026•0 citations

The Two-Boundary Universe: A Time-Symmetric, Information-Conserving Framework for Physics

Black, Aaron

Modern physics is built on the assumption that time only moves one way, beginning at the initial boundary (or initial condition), fixed effectively at the Big Bang. Our theories begin at that starting point and evolve from there. Yet the laws of nature work both forward and backward. This one-way view lies at the root of many of physics’ biggest puzzles, like wavefunction collapse, quantum “spookiness,” the arrow of time, and the clash between quantum mechanics and relativity. Two-Boundary Theory (2BT) proposes a minimal correction: the universe is a unique four-dimensional history jointly constrained by two real temporal boundaries, an initial (α) and a final (Ω). No new dynamics or hidden variables are added; the same lawful evolution operates in both directions, and the realized world is the intersection of the forward image of α with the backward image of Ω. From within time, partial knowledge of α and ignorance of Ω make outcomes appear stochastic and the future “open,” though the underlying history is globally deterministic and locally causal. This two-sided admissibility resolves the major paradoxes in a single move: Bell-level correlations arise from whole-trajectory consistency rather than superluminal influence; measurement collapse becomes an epistemic update, not a physical jump; and the arrow of time reflects asymmetric boundary information, not asymmetric law. The analysis preserves unitarity, covariance, and conservation principles intact. The paper confines itself to the conceptual and ontological core of the framework; later work develops the informational field Φ(t) and weighted-operator formalism that implement the same constraint mathematically. The result is an Ockham-minimal, time-symmetric completion of the scientific worldview: one reversible law, two boundaries, one consistent universe.

•Nov 15, 2025•0 citations

No time asymmetry from quantum mechanics

Don Nelson Page

With CPT-invariant initial conditions that commute with CPT-invariant final conditions, the respective probabilities (when defined) of a set of histories and its CPT reverse are equal, giving a CPT-symmetric universe. This leads me to question whether the asymmetry of the Gell-Mann--Hartle decoherence functional for ordinary quantum mechanics should be interpreted as an asymmetry of time.

arXiv:gr-qc/9304027•Physical Review Letters•Jun 28, 1993•13 citations

Asymmetric-Loss Equal-Born Test: a tabletop search for record-information-dependent optical loss

Robert James Cecil, Mark Trewick

Standard linear optics requires that the transmittance of an optic be independent of photon number: for a linear element the input–output relation a_out = t·a_in + r·b_in is an operator identity, so single-photon and bright-light transmission are equal as a theorem rather than as an approximation. We are not aware of a dedicated test of that equality with a controlled scatterer at the 10⁻⁴ level. We state a hypothesis in which the equality fails in the single-quantum sector by a fixed dimensionless coupling λ*, and specify the tabletop experiment that would exclude it. The observable is Δ = D_quantum − D_classical, where D is the half-difference of a two-arm log-ratio under an ABBA swap of a weak scatterer, measured once with counting detectors and once with photodiodes through identical geometry. Standard quantum mechanics fixes Δ = 0 exactly; the hypothesis predicts Δ = −λ*·(−p ln p), or −0.046·λ* at a 1% transmission deficit. The loss map is stated as a photon-number-dependent Kraus channel, K = Σ exp[−½λ*·I_R(n)]|n⟩⟨n| with P_R(n) = 1 − (1−p)^n, which is linear, completely positive, local and non-signalling; invariance of a remote marginal is verified explicitly on a two-mode squeezed vacuum to 3×10⁻¹⁷. An earlier thermal formulation of the same idea is excluded by published SNSPD efficiency data at 2 K by a factor of 2×10⁵ and is withdrawn. An attempt to derive the criterion distinguishing which optical elements incur the cost failed under independent adversarial review and is reported as a failure; the surviving readings are converted into five pre-registered experimental arms with their nulls stated in advance. A borrowed teaching bench at 780 nm reaches a total uncertainty of 2.9×10⁻⁴ per operating point at 2×10⁸ counts, giving 5σ sensitivity at λ* ≥ 0.031 and 95% exclusion to 0.013 at a 1% scatterer; an extended scan through the turnover at p = 36.8% reaches 0.0039 and 0.0016 respectively, subject to a costed high-loss error-budget row and seven stated pass criteria. Five signatures distinguish the effect from systematics, including a −p ln p scaling and a maximum located at p = 0.368. The cheapest arm needs no interferometer: the single-photon versus bright transmission of one 50/50 beam splitter at 10⁻³, which bounds one reading of the hypothesis below λ* = 0.003 in an afternoon’s run on a prepared bench. The protocol is pre-registered before any bench is borrowed. The result will be published in either direction; a null is reported as the best bound in this sector.

•Sep 9, 2026•0 citations
The laws of physics are CPT-symmetric, yet laboratory quantum mechanics prepares the past and only samples the future. This working paper distinguishes five levels of taking the symmetry seriously — symmetric laws with the open future left implicit, a two-boundary description, symmetric processes, a nontrivial final boundary, and laboratory access to it — places published views and experiments on them, and states what each predicts for a final-boundary test, in which an engineered terminal acts on a flag and an entangled partner is read on every trial. Exact results: an open future propagates backward through any physical channel; a terminal can only transfer, never manufacture, final-side contrast, giving lambda = tanh(hbar omega / 2 k T_f) in a swap model, the mirror of a reset; a clamp of budget A needs an energy of at least k T_f ln A in some branch; under free local control any every-trial final condition signals, with visibility equal to the clamp strength. Under stated transfer models a null reads as a lower bound on a swap-equivalent final temperature (Partridge: above 3.5e7 K for escaping microwaves; planned qubit tests: about 27 K and 360 K). The paper audits transport to the future, specifies what any physical source of a final condition must supply, and finds that no named candidate meets the specification. CPT motivates the reversed-resource question; channel duality bounds its possible transfer; laboratory access remains an additional physical hypothesis, decided only by experiment. No new experimental result is reported. Drafted with AI assistance and revised after AI-assisted reviews; responsibility rests with the author.
From independently qualified work to one interaction and several observations Lker⁡B={0}.\boxed{L\ker B=\{0\}.}LkerB={0}.​ When does a device's independently specified work already determine its interaction? In a finite affine constructor, the answer is exact: every unresolved calibration direction must disappear from the observable interaction. The paper proves necessity and sufficiency, constructs a dual certificate, and counts the additional linear probes needed when selection fails. The QTT source-to-contact construction connects geometry, supported work, mode participation and the actual electrode waveform to a single coupling. That same coupling predicts one-excitation transfer, two-excitation redistribution, phase response and parity controls. A finite future-memory theorem identifies what must remain in the retained packet so that later operations cannot reveal something the model discarded. For independently specified insertion magnitudes, the cross-occupation prediction is P11=cos⁡2(FΘ),F2=f2,a2+f2,b2.P_{11}=\cos^2(F\Theta),\qquad F^2=f_{2,a}^2+f_{2,b}^2.P11​=cos2(FΘ),F2=f2,a2​+f2,b2​. For symmetric-slot modes, the corresponding frequency ratio obeys (Ω22Ω1)2=1−12Ka−12Kb.\boxed{\left(\frac{\Omega_2}{2\Omega_1}\right)^2=1-\frac{1}{2K_a}-\frac{1}{2K_b}.}(2Ω1​Ω2​​)2=1−2Ka​1​−2Kb​1​.​ Version 2.0 adds complete feasible-set selection, a harmonic three-dimensional drive, unequal-capacity transfer, and the full preparation-to-detector calculation. A cross-Kerr counterexample shows why a perfect one-excitation calibration alone cannot settle the two-excitation prediction. The package contains the manuscript, proofs, executable checks, synthetic examples and a reproducible audit of the public Hou trapped-ion tables. The selection and transfer results are proved within their stated finite classes. The canonical realization shares laboratory probabilities with matched microscopic quantum mechanics; finite-slot discrimination requires independently qualified physical capacities and instruments. The archive is a retrospective eligibility audit. The separate prospective test commits the measurement design before a laboratory supplies its physical capsule. Companion: Artian's Physical Contact Transfer Test. Source dependencies: Completed-Event Transport and Quantum Coherence; QTT Main Book. Independent experimental context: Hou et al., Nature Physics (2024). Browse the corpus. The main PDF is the preview; the ZIP contains the full reconstruction package.
STATUS (18 October 2026). The physics programme that motivated this work was concluded in October 2026 and its claim of a unified derivation withdrawn. The results in this paper do not depend on that programme and stand as stated. Can an exact account of recorded events also determine what happens next? We examine this question in a finite quantum model with 48 preparations and an apparatus with ten distinguishable outcomes. Two reversible evolution rules reproduce exactly the same first-use specification but predict different results when the apparatus is used again. A separate example fixes one evolution rule: two possible histories then have identical counts of reads, commits and service events, yet different probabilities for the next outcome. Counts alone are therefore insufficient for prediction in this model. What remains visible depends on the observation. At eight preparations, even the complete individual-read distributions agree between the two rules, while correlations between the reads distinguish them. We classify two explicitly specified families of observations and determine exact ranges for the simpler family, showing both how distinctions are lost and how they can survive. The results separate event accounting, the choice of evolution, retained memory and the conversion of records into measured responses. They are conditional finite-model results, not a derivation of a physical dynamics or a measured coupling. The contribution is a set of exact counterexamples and classifications, rather than new principles of quantum theory. Exact computations and explicit proofs identify the additional response, weighting and sampling choices that a predictive physical interpretation must supply. Version 0.2 incorporates corrections following an author-requested preprint review. The deposit supplies the PDF, editable LaTeX with three TikZ figures, bibliography, exact fixture data for 96 two-read processes over 48 preparations, and a portable Python/SymPy verifier. The revised verifier passes 2,926 exact assertions. These are conditional finite-model results; no physical law, bridge, weighting or sampling measure is selected. The unchanged historical audit sources are available in a separately linked companion archive. Frozen audit sources and INT99 result dossier: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22541080.
Modern physics is built on the assumption that time only moves one way, beginning at the initial boundary (or initial condition), fixed effectively at the Big Bang. Our theories begin at that starting point and evolve from there. Yet the laws of nature work both forward and backward. This one-way view lies at the root of many of physics’ biggest puzzles, like wavefunction collapse, quantum “spookiness,” the arrow of time, and the clash between quantum mechanics and relativity. Two-Boundary Theory (2BT) proposes a minimal correction: the universe is a unique four-dimensional history jointly constrained by two real temporal boundaries, an initial (α) and a final (Ω). No new dynamics or hidden variables are added; the same lawful evolution operates in both directions, and the realized world is the intersection of the forward image of α with the backward image of Ω. From within time, partial knowledge of α and ignorance of Ω make outcomes appear stochastic and the future “open,” though the underlying history is globally deterministic and locally causal. This two-sided admissibility resolves the major paradoxes in a single move: Bell-level correlations arise from whole-trajectory consistency rather than superluminal influence; measurement collapse becomes an epistemic update, not a physical jump; and the arrow of time reflects asymmetric boundary information, not asymmetric law. The analysis preserves unitarity, covariance, and conservation principles intact. The paper confines itself to the conceptual and ontological core of the framework; later work develops the informational field Φ(t) and weighted-operator formalism that implement the same constraint mathematically. The result is an Ockham-minimal, time-symmetric completion of the scientific worldview: one reversible law, two boundaries, one consistent universe.
Standard linear optics requires that the transmittance of an optic be independent of photon number: for a linear element the input–output relation a_out = t·a_in + r·b_in is an operator identity, so single-photon and bright-light transmission are equal as a theorem rather than as an approximation. We are not aware of a dedicated test of that equality with a controlled scatterer at the 10⁻⁴ level. We state a hypothesis in which the equality fails in the single-quantum sector by a fixed dimensionless coupling λ*, and specify the tabletop experiment that would exclude it. The observable is Δ = D_quantum − D_classical, where D is the half-difference of a two-arm log-ratio under an ABBA swap of a weak scatterer, measured once with counting detectors and once with photodiodes through identical geometry. Standard quantum mechanics fixes Δ = 0 exactly; the hypothesis predicts Δ = −λ*·(−p ln p), or −0.046·λ* at a 1% transmission deficit. The loss map is stated as a photon-number-dependent Kraus channel, K = Σ exp[−½λ*·I_R(n)]|n⟩⟨n| with P_R(n) = 1 − (1−p)^n, which is linear, completely positive, local and non-signalling; invariance of a remote marginal is verified explicitly on a two-mode squeezed vacuum to 3×10⁻¹⁷. An earlier thermal formulation of the same idea is excluded by published SNSPD efficiency data at 2 K by a factor of 2×10⁵ and is withdrawn. An attempt to derive the criterion distinguishing which optical elements incur the cost failed under independent adversarial review and is reported as a failure; the surviving readings are converted into five pre-registered experimental arms with their nulls stated in advance. A borrowed teaching bench at 780 nm reaches a total uncertainty of 2.9×10⁻⁴ per operating point at 2×10⁸ counts, giving 5σ sensitivity at λ* ≥ 0.031 and 95% exclusion to 0.013 at a 1% scatterer; an extended scan through the turnover at p = 36.8% reaches 0.0039 and 0.0016 respectively, subject to a costed high-loss error-budget row and seven stated pass criteria. Five signatures distinguish the effect from systematics, including a −p ln p scaling and a maximum located at p = 0.368. The cheapest arm needs no interferometer: the single-photon versus bright transmission of one 50/50 beam splitter at 10⁻³, which bounds one reading of the hypothesis below λ* = 0.003 in an afternoon’s run on a prepared bench. The protocol is pre-registered before any bench is borrowed. The result will be published in either direction; a null is reported as the best bound in this sector.