Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Defining the Observer: A General Physical Criterion, Its Relation to Existing Models, Impossibility of the final ascent, and the Impossibility of the Ideal Limit

Sergej Materov

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.2139/ssrn.7552101

Related papers

The Observer and Spacetime: On the Existential Precondition of Physical Theory

Juliet Zhong

•Jan 1, 2026•1 citation

Defining the Observer

Sergej Materov

Defining the Observer:A General Physical Criterion, Its Relation to Existing Models, Impossibility of the final ascent, and the Impossibility of the Ideal Limit. No treatment of quantum gravity that takes observers seriously can avoid the question of what an observer physically is, and existing treatments - including the author's own (Materov 2026a,b,c) - each state a modelling assumption for the observer without deriving it. This paper's contribution is narrow and specific, not a claim to be the first physical account of an observer: a particular combination of requirements (D1–D4) on the trajectory of an embedded tensor factor, a separately-argued self-capacity criterion for individuation (D3′) tied to the no-cloning theorem, and a short, self-contained no-go argument (Proposition 4.1) for complete reconstruction of an observer's complement. We show that the observer-notions already in use in Materov (2026a,b,c) relate to this combination in three structurally different ways - as a more general object, as a concrete realization, and as a structurally parallel system not yet unified with it - and work out one concrete case, the photonic Friend of Local-Friendliness experiments, in detail. Since no observer can be ideal in this omniscient sense, we instead investigate uniqueness for a weaker, separately-defined notion (a self-dominant observer, whose own representational capacity exceeds its observing capacity); no dimension-counting argument we have found forces this either, and the question remains, honestly, open.

•Oct 5, 2026•0 citations

The role of the observer in physical science.

Lowenstein Jm

•Aug 1, 1957•0 citations

A glance beyond the quantum model

Miguel Navascués, Harald Wunderlich

One of the most important problems in physics is to reconcile quantum mechanics with general relativity, and some authors have suggested that this may be realized at the expense of having to drop the quantum formalism in favour of a more general theory. Here, we propose a mechanism to make general claims on the microscopic structure of the Universe by postulating that any post-quantum theory should recover classical physics in the macroscopic limit. We use this mechanism to bound the strength of correlations between distant observers in any physical theory. Although several quantum limits are recovered, such as the set of two-point quantum correlators, our results suggest that there exist plausible microscopic theories of Nature that predict correlations impossible to reproduce in any quantum mechanical system.

arXiv:0907.0372•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Nov 11, 2009•297 citations

From limits of quantum operations to multicopy entanglement witnesses and state-spectrum estimation

Paweł Horodecki

Limits of state transformations in quantum mechanics are studied. Impossibility of physical implementation of the transformation ${\ensuremath{\varrho}}^{\ensuremath{\bigotimes}n}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{\ensuremath{\varrho}}^{n}$ in quantum mechanics is proved. The most natural notions of structural completely positive approximation and structural physical approximations of nonphysical map are introduced. It is shown that these always exist for linear Hermitian maps and can be optimized under natural conditions. It is pointed out that it is physically possible to measure in a simple way the traces of $n\mathrm{th}$ power of quantum state $\mathrm{Tr}({\ensuremath{\varrho}}^{n})$ if only joint measurements on n copies of the system are allowed. This gives the interpretation of Tsallis entropies as values of ``multicopy'' observables. Following this observations, the notion of multicopy entanglement witnesses is defined and examples are provided. Finally, using notion of multicopy observable, a simple method of spectrum state estimation is discussed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0111036•Physical Review A•Nov 3, 2003•113 citations

The Observer and Consciousness: On the Ontological Ground of Measurement

Juliet Zhong

•Jan 1, 2026•1 citation
Defining the Observer:A General Physical Criterion, Its Relation to Existing Models, Impossibility of the final ascent, and the Impossibility of the Ideal Limit. No treatment of quantum gravity that takes observers seriously can avoid the question of what an observer physically is, and existing treatments - including the author's own (Materov 2026a,b,c) - each state a modelling assumption for the observer without deriving it. This paper's contribution is narrow and specific, not a claim to be the first physical account of an observer: a particular combination of requirements (D1–D4) on the trajectory of an embedded tensor factor, a separately-argued self-capacity criterion for individuation (D3′) tied to the no-cloning theorem, and a short, self-contained no-go argument (Proposition 4.1) for complete reconstruction of an observer's complement. We show that the observer-notions already in use in Materov (2026a,b,c) relate to this combination in three structurally different ways - as a more general object, as a concrete realization, and as a structurally parallel system not yet unified with it - and work out one concrete case, the photonic Friend of Local-Friendliness experiments, in detail. Since no observer can be ideal in this omniscient sense, we instead investigate uniqueness for a weaker, separately-defined notion (a self-dominant observer, whose own representational capacity exceeds its observing capacity); no dimension-counting argument we have found forces this either, and the question remains, honestly, open.
One of the most important problems in physics is to reconcile quantum mechanics with general relativity, and some authors have suggested that this may be realized at the expense of having to drop the quantum formalism in favour of a more general theory. Here, we propose a mechanism to make general claims on the microscopic structure of the Universe by postulating that any post-quantum theory should recover classical physics in the macroscopic limit. We use this mechanism to bound the strength of correlations between distant observers in any physical theory. Although several quantum limits are recovered, such as the set of two-point quantum correlators, our results suggest that there exist plausible microscopic theories of Nature that predict correlations impossible to reproduce in any quantum mechanical system.
Limits of state transformations in quantum mechanics are studied. Impossibility of physical implementation of the transformation ${\ensuremath{\varrho}}^{\ensuremath{\bigotimes}n}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{\ensuremath{\varrho}}^{n}$ in quantum mechanics is proved. The most natural notions of structural completely positive approximation and structural physical approximations of nonphysical map are introduced. It is shown that these always exist for linear Hermitian maps and can be optimized under natural conditions. It is pointed out that it is physically possible to measure in a simple way the traces of nthn\mathrm{th}nth power of quantum state $\mathrm{Tr}({\ensuremath{\varrho}}^{n})$ if only joint measurements on n copies of the system are allowed. This gives the interpretation of Tsallis entropies as values of ``multicopy'' observables. Following this observations, the notion of multicopy entanglement witnesses is defined and examples are provided. Finally, using notion of multicopy observable, a simple method of spectrum state estimation is discussed.