IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems
Performance Analysis of Hybrid Digital–Quantum Satellite Links: Comparative Study of Classical BER and Quantum QBER under Turbulent Atmospheric Conditions
Classical satellite communications which rely on standard cryptographic techniques like the Rivest–Shamir–Adleman (RSA) and the Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC) face an existential threat—quantum computers which run algorithms like the Shor's Algorithm which are capable of breaking these techniques in polynomial time. To counter this loophole, we present a MATLAB based hybrid satellite-to-ground optical link, merging an adaptive BPSK/16-QAM classical data transmission link with a BB84 Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) link over a Wavelength Division Multiplexing (WDM) optical channel. In our methodology we present a comprehensive framework which models different enabling pa rameters of satellite communication like Gaussian Beam Divergence, Beer–Lambert law, Rytov Scintillation, Square Root Raised Cosine (SRRC) pulse shaping, and the Shannon–Hartley channel capacity. The findings demonstrate that under a clear sky, at Low Earth Orbit (LEO), the system achieves a moderate secret key rate of 348.26kbps while the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) stays below the Shor–Preskill bound of 11%. Concurrently, the Binary Phase Shift Keying (BPSK) achieves a Bit Error Rate (BER) less than 10−6 for slant heights up to 1216km. Ultimately, our findings validate the viability of the integration of quantum and classical channels via WDM as a practical solution for Next Generation satellite-to-ground communications.
Classical satellite communications which rely on standard cryptographic techniques like the Rivest–Shamir–Adleman (RSA) and the Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC) face an existential threat—quantum computers which run algorithms like the Shor's Algorithm which are capable of breaking these techniques in polynomial time. To counter this loophole, we present a MATLAB based hybrid satellite-to-ground optical link, merging an adaptive BPSK/16-QAM classical data transmission link with a BB84 Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) link over a Wavelength Division Multiplexing (WDM) optical channel. In our methodology we present a comprehensive framework which models different enabling pa rameters of satellite communication like Gaussian Beam Divergence, Beer–Lambert law, Rytov Scintillation, Square Root Raised Cosine (SRRC) pulse shaping, and the Shannon–Hartley channel capacity. The findings demonstrate that under a clear sky, at Low Earth Orbit (LEO), the system achieves a moderate secret key rate of 348.26kbps while the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) stays below the Shor–Preskill bound of 11%. Concurrently, the Binary Phase Shift Keying (BPSK) achieves a Bit Error Rate (BER) less than 10−6 for slant heights up to 1216km. Ultimately, our findings validate the viability of the integration of quantum and classical channels via WDM as a practical solution for Next Generation satellite-to-ground communications.
Satellite-based free-space quantum key distribution (QKD) provides a practical framework for achieving secure global communication beyond the limitations of optical fibers. In this work, the quantum bit error rate (QBER) and secure key rate of four representative protocols-BB84, B92, BBM92, and E91 are investigated over low earth orbit (LEO) links in both uplink and downlink configurations. The optical link is modeled using a Gaussian beam formalism, incorporating the effects of diffraction, pointing errors, atmospheric turbulence, and background noise contributions. The protocols are examined under day and night-time operating conditions, and their dependence on the zenith angle is analyzed. The findings show that downlink links generally exhibit lower QBER and higher secure key rates than uplinks, and among prepare-and-measure schemes, BB84 consistently outperforms B92, while in entanglement-based approaches, BBM92 achieves higher key rates than E91.
This study aims at extending the concept of QKD to the optical free-space quantum communications domain. Moreover, the feasibility of a global satellite based quantum key distribution, in the low earth orbit (LEO) is investigated. Inline with this, three different link scenarios, including ground-to-ground, ground-to-satellite and satellite-to-satellite are considered. Moreover, system performance is analysed to show the sensitivity of the link to effect such as atmospheric attenuation, turbulence and detector noise. Generally, these factors are assumed to impair system performance by causing an overall increase in the systems quantum bit error rate (QBER), let alone limiting the communication bit rate and transmission distance of the link. The obtained results reveal the feasibility of satellite-based quantum key distribution in the LEO platform, a concept which could be potentially extended to geostationary earth orbit (GEO).
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) has emerged as a fundamentally secure approach to communication in the era of quantum computing, offering protection against threats posed to classical cryptographic schemes such as RSA and Diffie-Hellman. This thesis presents a comprehensive performance analysis of satellite-based QKD protocols, focusing on both prepare-and-measure and entanglement-based schemes under realistic atmospheric and operational conditions. The study begins by introducing the theoretical foundations of quantum communication, including qubits, entanglement, and quantum entropy, and motivates the need for satellite-based QKD to overcome the distance limitations of fiber-based systems. Subsequently, the thesis evaluates four prominent QKD protocols-BB84, B92, BBM92, and E91-using a circular beam propagation model that incorporates atmospheric effects such as diffraction, turbulence, attenuation, and pointing errors, along with environmental noise contributions for uplink and downlink. Comparative numerical simulations reveal that protocol performance is strongly influenced by channel asymmetries, beam propagation characteristics, and noise, providing guidance on optimal protocol selection for low Earth orbit (LEO) satellite links. The research further investigates high-dimensional (HD) QKD protocols, specifically HD-BB84 and HD-Extended B92, using the elliptic-beam approximation to account for turbulence-induced distortions for both uplink and downlink. Simulations under vary ing system dimensions, weather conditions, and zenith angles demonstrate that HD-BB84 achieves higher key rates, superior noise tolerance, and more favorable probability distributions of the key rate compared to HD-Extended B92, highlighting the advantages of high-dimensional encoding for robust satellite-based QKD.
Abstract Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides information-theoretic security for future communication networks by exploiting the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics. However, satellite-to-ground QKD links suffer significant performance degradation due to atmospheric turbulence, absorption, scattering, and satellite-induced pointing errors. This paper investigates the BB84 QKD protocol over a Free-Space Optical (FSO) channel modeled using the Gamma–Gamma distribution, which accurately captures both small-scale and large-scale atmospheric irradiance fluctuations. Closed-form and numerical results for outage probability and Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) are presented under weak, moderate, and strong turbulence regimes. The Secure Key Rate (SKR) is analyzed as a function of link distance under clear and foggy weather conditions. Additionally, the impact of satellite vibration is evaluated using a jitter-dependent pointing error model, demonstrating that misalignment significantly reduces link reliability. Simulation results show that strong turbulence conditions introduce more than 15 dB SNR penalty compared to clear-sky operation, while haze conditions limit QKD range to under 8–10 km. These findings provide practical performance benchmarks for Low-Earth Orbit (LEO) quantum downlinks in realistic atmospheric environments. The results provide practical insights for electronic receiver design and system implementation of satellite quantum communication links.
Satellite-based quantum key distribution (QKD) offers a pathway to secure global communications, yet its performance is fundamentally constrained by atmospheric turbulence. This paper presents a detailed analysis of the BBM92 entanglement-based protocol under realistic satellite-to-ground conditions using the Hufnagel-Valley turbulence model. We examine the role of key atmospheric factors, including wind speed, ground station altitude, and diurnal variations, on quantum performance metrics across a mean photon number (MPN) range of 0.001-0.3. Results reveal that turbulence strength, captured via the refractive index structure constant, governs channel transmittance through Rytov variance and scintillation index, directly impacting quantum bit error rate (QBER) and secret key rate (SKR). Simulations show that elevated ground stations improve SKR by15−25%, nighttime operation yields40 - 80 %gains compared with daytime, and wind speeds of30m/scan reduce SKR by up to 60% relative to10m/sconditions. Optimal operation lies in the MPN range of 0.1-0.2, beyond which multiphoton noise degrades security as QBER approaches the 9% threshold.
The current literature on quantum key distribution is limited mainly to transmissions over fiber optic, atmospheric, or satellite links and is not directly applicable to underwater environments with different channel characteristics. In this paper, we analyze the quantum bit error rate (QBER) and secret key rate (SKR) performance of the well-known BB84 protocol in underwater channels. As a path loss model, we consider a modified version of the Beer–Lambert formula, which takes into account the effect of scattering. We derive a closed-form expression for the wave structure function to determine the average power transfer over a turbulent underwater path and use this to obtain an upper bound on QBER as well as a lower bound on SKR. Based on the derived bounds, we present the performance of the BB84 protocol in different water types including clear, coastal, and turbid and under different atmospheric conditions such as clear, hazy, and overcast. We further investigate the effect of system parameters such as aperture size and detector field of view on QBER and SKR performance metrics.