Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

PhyDid B - Didaktik der Physik - Beiträge zur DPG-Frühjahrstagung

A Fundamental Path to Quantum Physics: The Space Paradox

Hans-Otto Carmesin

Published Nov 29, 2025• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Quantum physics is a successful field of science with many relevant applications in everyday life. An exciting question is still, what is the fundamental reason for the postulates about quanta? An answer would provide a deeper insight into nature. Such an insight can sometimes be achieved with help of a paradox. How can we derive the quantum postulates with help of a paradox? In present-day science, space is usually modelled as a single entity. However, special relativity shows that this view is paradoxical. Instead, space consists of several volume portions that move at the velocity of light. According to the observed isotropy of space at a universal scale, space is a statistical average of rapidly moving volume portions. This solves the paradox. Therefrom, the deeper insight is achieved as follows: The dynamics of these volume portions is derived. Therefrom, the Schrödinger equation and the quantum postulates are derived. In this manner, the dynamics of space provides the fundamental reason for the postulates about quanta. In the learning process, the students achieve an intensive awareness, as they experience a cognitive conflict, the paradox. With it, they realize that the basic concept of a single entity of space is insufficient. They realize that the new concept requires rapidly moving volume portions and provides the quantum postulates. A concept for teaching is presented and experiences are reported.

Related papers

A Derivation of Quantum Mechanics from START

Jaime Keller

Quantum Mechanics is a successful model to describe physical phenomena. We show that a simple set of postulates about the description of objects in Nature allows the derivation of the principles of QM, transforming this theory into a deductive approach to Physics. The main postulate is: Objects are described as energy distributions in Space–Time. 1 Quantum Mechanics from START It is universally accepted that Quantum Mechanics is a successful model to describe physical phenomena, in particular of the electronic structure of atoms, molecules and solids. As such it has been reformulated in several different forms (see for example: Nine formulations of quantum mechanics, Daniel F. Styer et al. [15]). The aim of the present paper is to show that a simple set of postulates about the description of objects in Nature allows the derivation of the principles of QM, transforming this theory into a deductive approach to Physics. In our approach the main postulate is: Objects are described as energy distributions in Space–Time. The theory is in fact a systematic mathematical analysis of this postulate and of other general considerations about action, energy–momentum and the role of the theory as a useful description of Nature. The paper also shows the fundamental and basic status of Density Functional Theory, also contained in our approach. The initial mathematical structure is a geometric (quadratic form based) union of space, time and action. In physics bundles of trajectories are used to describe the objects of nature: distribution of heights over a surface, a real object is described as a bundle of space-time trajectories, here we use a description as a bundle of action valves in space-time (energy densities in space following light-like lines). The author is fully aware that the presentation is strongly guided by the knowledge of the usual computational approach to study atoms, molecules and condensed matter electronic structure.

•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

A REFORMULATION OF QUANTUM MECHANICS

Saul Youssef

We show that the phenomena explained by quantum mechanics can alternatively be explained as a breakdown of probability theory without the need for wave-particle duality or the idea that a particle does not have a unique path in space. The single-particle Lagrangian consistent with the reformulated quantum mechanics is derived and specialized to the Schrödinger and Klein-Gordon theories. The usual paradoxes of quantum mechanics are explained. A connection to gravity is proposed. Probability theory is restored in the classical limit.

Modern Physics Letters A•Jan 30, 1991•20 citations

RELATIVE REALITY

Rongwei Yang

The ``Hard Problem" of consciousness refers to a long-standing enigma about how qualia emerge from physical processes in the brain. Building on insights from the development of non-Euclidean geometry, this paper seeks to present a structured and logically coherent theory of qualia to address this problem. The proposed theory starts with a definition on what it means for an entity to be non-physical. A postulate about awareness is posed and utilized to rigorously prove that qualia are non-physical and thoughts are qualia. Then the paper introduces a key concept: relative reality, meaning that perceptions of reality are relative to the observer and time. The concept is analyzed through a mathematical model grounded in Hilbert space theory. The model also sheds new light on cognitive science and physics. In particular, the Schrödinger equation can be derived easily through this model. Moreover, this model shows that eigenstates also exist for classical energy-conserving systems. Analyses on the G. P. Thomson experiment and the classical harmonic oscillator are made to illustrate this finding. The insight gained sheds new light on the Bohr-Einstein debate concerning the interpretation of quantum mechanics. At last, the paper proposes a postulate about qualia force and demonstrates that it constitutes a fundamental part of absolute reality, much like the four fundamental forces in nature.

arXiv:2502.05536•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

The ABC of Physics

John Skilling, Kevin H. Knuth

Why quantum? Why spacetime? We find that the key idea underlying both is uncertainty. In a world lacking probes of unlimited delicacy, our knowledge of quantities is necessarily accompanied by uncertainty. Consequently, physics requires a calculus of number pairs and not only scalars for quantity alone. Basic symmetries of shuffling and sequencing dictate that pairs obey ordinary component-wise addition, but they can have three different multiplication rules. We call those rules A, B and C. “A” shows that pairs behave as complex numbers, which is why quantum theory is complex. However, consistency with the ordinary scalar rules of probability shows that the fundamental object is not a particle on its Hilbert sphere but a stream represented by a Gaussian distribution. “B” is then applied to pairs of complex numbers (qubits) and produces the Pauli matrices for which its operation defines the space of four vectors. “C” then allows integration of what can then be recognised as energy-momentum into time and space. The picture is entirely consistent. Spacetime is a construct of quantum and not a container for it.

International Workshop on Bayesian Inference and Maximum Entropy Methods in Science and Engineering (MaxEnt)•Dec 10, 2021•1 citation

Students Learn to Derive Nonlocality from Fundamental Physics

Hans-Otto Carmesin

In everyday life, in smartphones, we use electromagnetic waves for telecommunication. These waves propagate at the velocity of light. Is telecommunication at superluminal velocity (at ) possible? Einstein (1907) wrote that no action can travel faster than light, as such action would imply a causality violation. However, quantum physics includes actions that travel faster than light, see e. g. Einstein, Podolski and Rosen (1935). Accordingly, Einstein (1948) named such actions (at ) ‘spukhafte Fernwirkung’ or ‘spooky action at a distance’. But Aspect, Grangier and Roger (1982) provided such action at in experiments with pairs of entangled photons. While this experiment demonstrates the seeming transfer of information at , delayed-choice experiments do additionally demonstrate the seeming transport of energy and matter at , see Jaques (2008) and Manning et al. (2015). Do these actions at violate the principle of causality? Does quantum gravity escape causality violation, as Hobson, Efstathiou and Lasenby hope (2006, p. 346)? Can such action at be used in telecommunications and quantum computers? These questions are answered with help of the dynamics of volume in nature, the volume dynamics, VD, see Carmesin (2023a). The VD bridge general relativity and quantum physics. For these results, we provide a learning process, so that you can directly use the concept in your courses. The learning process has been tested in various learning groups, and experiences are reported.

PhyDid B - Didaktik der Physik - Beiträge zur DPG-Frühjahrstagung•Nov 28, 2024•0 citations

Basics of Quantum Physics

Mohammad Etrati Khosroshahi

There is no dissent regarding the quantum theory success on the small-scale structure of the world but there is equally an open subject of debate about its interpretation. Both quantum mechanics and the theory of relativity are indeed extensions of classical mechanics, that is, they reproduce their results in other appropriate limiting cases. Quantum mechanics provides a new set of laws and a method of description of microscopic systems that has been very successful. The chapter discusses some of the fundamental principles of this highly controversial subject. In quantum physics, it is difficult to uphold a sharp distinction between the object and the observer. The chapter examines why quantum mechanics seems to be so hard for newcomers to learn and understand. The theory of quantum mechanics has led to many applications: laser, the electron microscope and many other technological devices.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 30, 2017•0 citations
Quantum physics is a successful field of science with many relevant applications in everyday life. An exciting question is still, what is the fundamental reason for the postulates about quanta? An answer would provide a deeper insight into nature. Such an insight can sometimes be achieved with help of a paradox. How can we derive the quantum postulates with help of a paradox? In present-day science, space is usually modelled as a single entity. However, special relativity shows that this view is paradoxical. Instead, space consists of several volume portions that move at the velocity of light. According to the observed isotropy of space at a universal scale, space is a statistical average of rapidly moving volume portions. This solves the paradox. Therefrom, the deeper insight is achieved as follows: The dynamics of these volume portions is derived. Therefrom, the Schrödinger equation and the quantum postulates are derived. In this manner, the dynamics of space provides the fundamental reason for the postulates about quanta. In the learning process, the students achieve an intensive awareness, as they experience a cognitive conflict, the paradox. With it, they realize that the basic concept of a single entity of space is insufficient. They realize that the new concept requires rapidly moving volume portions and provides the quantum postulates. A concept for teaching is presented and experiences are reported.
Quantum Mechanics is a successful model to describe physical phenomena. We show that a simple set of postulates about the description of objects in Nature allows the derivation of the principles of QM, transforming this theory into a deductive approach to Physics. The main postulate is: Objects are described as energy distributions in Space–Time. 1 Quantum Mechanics from START It is universally accepted that Quantum Mechanics is a successful model to describe physical phenomena, in particular of the electronic structure of atoms, molecules and solids. As such it has been reformulated in several different forms (see for example: Nine formulations of quantum mechanics, Daniel F. Styer et al. [15]). The aim of the present paper is to show that a simple set of postulates about the description of objects in Nature allows the derivation of the principles of QM, transforming this theory into a deductive approach to Physics. In our approach the main postulate is: Objects are described as energy distributions in Space–Time. The theory is in fact a systematic mathematical analysis of this postulate and of other general considerations about action, energy–momentum and the role of the theory as a useful description of Nature. The paper also shows the fundamental and basic status of Density Functional Theory, also contained in our approach. The initial mathematical structure is a geometric (quadratic form based) union of space, time and action. In physics bundles of trajectories are used to describe the objects of nature: distribution of heights over a surface, a real object is described as a bundle of space-time trajectories, here we use a description as a bundle of action valves in space-time (energy densities in space following light-like lines). The author is fully aware that the presentation is strongly guided by the knowledge of the usual computational approach to study atoms, molecules and condensed matter electronic structure.
We show that the phenomena explained by quantum mechanics can alternatively be explained as a breakdown of probability theory without the need for wave-particle duality or the idea that a particle does not have a unique path in space. The single-particle Lagrangian consistent with the reformulated quantum mechanics is derived and specialized to the Schrödinger and Klein-Gordon theories. The usual paradoxes of quantum mechanics are explained. A connection to gravity is proposed. Probability theory is restored in the classical limit.
The ``Hard Problem" of consciousness refers to a long-standing enigma about how qualia emerge from physical processes in the brain. Building on insights from the development of non-Euclidean geometry, this paper seeks to present a structured and logically coherent theory of qualia to address this problem. The proposed theory starts with a definition on what it means for an entity to be non-physical. A postulate about awareness is posed and utilized to rigorously prove that qualia are non-physical and thoughts are qualia. Then the paper introduces a key concept: relative reality, meaning that perceptions of reality are relative to the observer and time. The concept is analyzed through a mathematical model grounded in Hilbert space theory. The model also sheds new light on cognitive science and physics. In particular, the Schrödinger equation can be derived easily through this model. Moreover, this model shows that eigenstates also exist for classical energy-conserving systems. Analyses on the G. P. Thomson experiment and the classical harmonic oscillator are made to illustrate this finding. The insight gained sheds new light on the Bohr-Einstein debate concerning the interpretation of quantum mechanics. At last, the paper proposes a postulate about qualia force and demonstrates that it constitutes a fundamental part of absolute reality, much like the four fundamental forces in nature.
Why quantum? Why spacetime? We find that the key idea underlying both is uncertainty. In a world lacking probes of unlimited delicacy, our knowledge of quantities is necessarily accompanied by uncertainty. Consequently, physics requires a calculus of number pairs and not only scalars for quantity alone. Basic symmetries of shuffling and sequencing dictate that pairs obey ordinary component-wise addition, but they can have three different multiplication rules. We call those rules A, B and C. “A” shows that pairs behave as complex numbers, which is why quantum theory is complex. However, consistency with the ordinary scalar rules of probability shows that the fundamental object is not a particle on its Hilbert sphere but a stream represented by a Gaussian distribution. “B” is then applied to pairs of complex numbers (qubits) and produces the Pauli matrices for which its operation defines the space of four vectors. “C” then allows integration of what can then be recognised as energy-momentum into time and space. The picture is entirely consistent. Spacetime is a construct of quantum and not a container for it.
In everyday life, in smartphones, we use electromagnetic waves for telecommunication. These waves propagate at the velocity of light. Is telecommunication at superluminal velocity (at ) possible? Einstein (1907) wrote that no action can travel faster than light, as such action would imply a causality violation. However, quantum physics includes actions that travel faster than light, see e. g. Einstein, Podolski and Rosen (1935). Accordingly, Einstein (1948) named such actions (at ) ‘spukhafte Fernwirkung’ or ‘spooky action at a distance’. But Aspect, Grangier and Roger (1982) provided such action at in experiments with pairs of entangled photons. While this experiment demonstrates the seeming transfer of information at , delayed-choice experiments do additionally demonstrate the seeming transport of energy and matter at , see Jaques (2008) and Manning et al. (2015). Do these actions at violate the principle of causality? Does quantum gravity escape causality violation, as Hobson, Efstathiou and Lasenby hope (2006, p. 346)? Can such action at be used in telecommunications and quantum computers? These questions are answered with help of the dynamics of volume in nature, the volume dynamics, VD, see Carmesin (2023a). The VD bridge general relativity and quantum physics. For these results, we provide a learning process, so that you can directly use the concept in your courses. The learning process has been tested in various learning groups, and experiences are reported.
There is no dissent regarding the quantum theory success on the small-scale structure of the world but there is equally an open subject of debate about its interpretation. Both quantum mechanics and the theory of relativity are indeed extensions of classical mechanics, that is, they reproduce their results in other appropriate limiting cases. Quantum mechanics provides a new set of laws and a method of description of microscopic systems that has been very successful. The chapter discusses some of the fundamental principles of this highly controversial subject. In quantum physics, it is difficult to uphold a sharp distinction between the object and the observer. The chapter examines why quantum mechanics seems to be so hard for newcomers to learn and understand. The theory of quantum mechanics has led to many applications: laser, the electron microscope and many other technological devices.