In the current era of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, hardware resources are limited and costly, making software validation a significant engineering challenge. This paper addresses the need for efficient evaluation methods by proposing a set of pre-runtime metrics to predict the success of quantum circuit execution without requiring physical execution. A total of 63 static metrics—categorized as Elemental, Structural, Behavioral, and Quantum-Specific—were implemented within the open-source qWard library and validated through an empirical study using Grover’s algorithm on IBM Quantum processors. The empirical analysis identified 27 statistically significant metrics (with ≤ 10−6) capable of anticipating performance degradation. Furthermore, the study reveals a counterintuitive relationship in which aggressive compiler optimization reduces the linear correlation between static metrics and physical outcomes, and identifies distinct operational zones—stable, chaotic, and death—that enable developers to optimize resource usage by anticipating circuit instability.
In the current era of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, hardware resources are limited and costly, making software validation a significant engineering challenge. This paper addresses the need for efficient evaluation methods by proposing a set of pre-runtime metrics to predict the success of quantum circuit execution without requiring physical execution. A total of 63 static metrics—categorized as Elemental, Structural, Behavioral, and Quantum-Specific—were implemented within the open-source qWard library and validated through an empirical study using Grover’s algorithm on IBM Quantum processors. The empirical analysis identified 27 statistically significant metrics (with ≤ 10−6) capable of anticipating performance degradation. Furthermore, the study reveals a counterintuitive relationship in which aggressive compiler optimization reduces the linear correlation between static metrics and physical outcomes, and identifies distinct operational zones—stable, chaotic, and death—that enable developers to optimize resource usage by anticipating circuit instability.
As quantum computing (QC) matures towards practical applications, effective methods to evaluate quantum algorithms, circuits, and execution quality in quantum software are gaining more relevance. To apply such methods, a set of meaningful metrics must be defined, understood, calculated, and applied. In an effort to solve that problem, this paper categorizes quantum related metrics into pre-runtime (derived from the static analysis of circuits before execution) and post-runtime (derived from the analysis of execution results). It is worthwhile to mention that while popular quantum SDKs such as Qiskit, PennyLane, and Q\# offer some circuit characteristics, there is often a gap between these native capabilities and the broader set of insightful pre- and post-runtime metrics in the literature. This paper introducesqWard, a Python library developed to bridge this gap by offering an initial implementation for the Qiskit SDK. qWard provides a toolkit designed to compute and visualize key pre-runtime and post-runtime metrics, facilitating the analysis of quantum algorithms. To illustrate its application, an experiment using a bell state circuit is conducted, which includes different backend configurations within the simulator as well as its execution on the IBM “torino” quantum processor. It is important to note that the initial version of qWard is limited to the Qiskit SDK and the Qiskit AER simulator.
The Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era poses a challenge for developers: hardware providers expose capabilities through heterogeneous interfaces with proprietary metrics varying widely across providers, hindering informed backend selection. Static characterization metrics - coherence times T1/T2, gate error rates - exhibit limitations: they fail to capture dynamic variability across successive executions, overlook the impact of transpilation, and lack architectural comparability across physically distinct technologies. We propose a Figure of Merit (FoM) based on Grover's algorithm as an algorithmic stress test evaluating quantum backend performance holistically. The metric combines success probability on target states with penalties for non-uniform amplification and leakage to non-marked states, yielding a unified score across hardware architectures. Implemented via the Qonscious framework - a conditional execution platform using polymorphic adapters, it executes agnostically on IBM, IonQ backends, and simulators. Main contributions: (1) proposal and validation of GroverFigureOfMerit, incorporating uniformity and leakage penalties (adapted from GRADE) with emphasis on noise, transpilation, and topological constraints; (2) systematic analysis of heterogeneity across nine quantum providers motivating agnostic metrics; and (3) experimental demonstration via ideal simulators and real-processor noise models, confirming sensitivity to noise, topology, and transpilation overhead. Results confirm the metric distinguishes backend performance under a unified score, capturing intrinsic algorithmic limits. Validation on physical QPUs is identified as a natural next step.
Quantum computers represent a radical technological advancement in the way information is processed by using the principles of quantum mechanics to solve very complex problems that exceed the capabilities of classical systems. However, in the current NISQ era (Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum devices), the available hardware presents several limitations, such as a limited number of qubits, high error rates, and reduced coherence times. Efficient management of quantum resources, both physical (qubits, error rates, connectivity) and logical (quantum gates, algorithms, error correction), becomes particularly relevant in the design and deployment of quantum algorithms. In this work, we analyze the role of resources in the various uses of NISQ devices today, identifying their relevance and implications for software engineering focused on the use of quantum computers. We propose a vision for runtime-aware quantum software development, identifying key challenges to its realization, such as limited introspection capabilities and temporal constraints in current platforms. As a proof of concept, we introduce Qonscious, a prototype framework that enables conditional execution of quantum programs based on dynamic resource evaluation. With this contribution, we aim to strengthen the field of Quantum Resource Estimation (QRE) and move towards the development of scalable, reliable, and resource-aware quantum software.
Grover's quantum search algorithm provides a proven quadratic speedup over classical linear search for unstructured databases. While its theoretical advantage is well established, experimental validation on real noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware remains limited by noise, decoherence, and hardware constraints. In this work, we present an experimental comparison between classical linear search and Grover's quantum search algorithm executed on IBM Quantum real superconducting hardware using Qiskit Runtime. A four-qubit implementation corresponding to a 16-element search space is evaluated across multiple experimental runs. The results demonstrate consistent amplitude amplification, achieving an average success probability of 54.25% and an amplification factor of 8.68× over random guessing. Although classical execution remains faster in wall-clock time due to quantum hardware overhead, the experiment empirically validates the algorithmic advantage of Grover's search and quantifies the performance gap between ideal and real quantum processors in the NISQ era.
Quantum circuit optimization plays a critical role in improving the performance of algorithms executed on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. While modern quantum compilers provide multiple optimization levels, selecting an appropriate optimization strategy remains a non-trivial task due to the complex interplay between circuit structure and hardware noise. In this work, we present a comprehensive noise-aware evaluation of quantum circuit optimization strategies using a diverse set of 33 circuits, including Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT), Grover's search, Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE), and randomly generated circuits. We analyze the impact of different transpiler optimization levels on circuit depth, entanglement (CNOT count), and output fidelity under a realistic depolarizing noise model. Our experimental results reveal that no single optimization level consistently yields the best performance across all circuit types. While aggressive optimization is beneficial for structured circuits such as QFT and VQE, moderate optimization levels often provide a better trade-off between circuit complexity and fidelity for unstructured or randomly generated circuits. These findings highlight that optimization-level selection is inherently dependent on circuit characteristics and cannot be effectively addressed using static or heuristic approaches alone. To address this challenge, we further propose a lightweight learning-based model that predicts the optimal optimization level based on circuit features. The model achieves an accuracy of 93.9% across the evaluated dataset, demonstrating that simple machine learning techniques can effectively approximate optimal compiler decisions without requiring exhaustive evaluation. Overall, this work provides practical insights into optimization behavior in NISQ systems and introduces a scalable approach for adaptive optimization selection, contributing toward more efficient quantum software development.
Quantum computing in the Noisy IntermediateScale Quantum (NISQ) era presents significant challenges in differentiating quantum software bugs from hardware noise. Traditional debugging techniques from classical software engineering cannot directly resolve this issue due to the inherently stochastic nature of quantum computation mixed with noises from NISQ computers. To address this gap, we propose a statistical approach leveraging probabilistic metrics to differentiate between quantum software bugs and hardware noise. We evaluate our methodology empirically using well-known quantum algorithms, including Grover's algorithm, Deutsch-Jozsa algorithm, and Simon's algorithm. Experimental results demonstrate the efficacy and practical applicability of our approach, providing quantum software developers with a reliable analytical tool to identify and classify unexpected behavior in quantum programs.