Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

An entanglement-based separation of magic states

Alejandro Borda Kuhlmann

Published May 30, 2025• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In this work, we set out to study and define a fundamental separation between two classes of magic states in quantum computation. In order to reach this goal, we define the “left Clifford equivalence,” an equivalence relation that aims to properly distinguish the interplay between magic and entanglement in magic states. Utilizing such an equivalence relation, we define the notion of a “magic class” and show that there are two different magic classes under this notion, which we call T-magic and W-magic. The former displays an almost trivial relationship with entanglement, meaning they behave as completely independent resources. Meanwhile, the latter is not only exclusively a feature of entangled states, but we find that the non-stabilizer resources themselves of W-magic states are intrinsically related to entanglement. In order to further study the distinction between these classes, we discuss how the separation of these classes shows itself in the topic of universality. Then, we depict the whole space of magic states as defined by these classes, and we study the relationship between measurements and both magic classes.

Related papers

Magic-protected entanglement and Clifford-irreducible structure in magic state space

Alejandro Borda Kuhlmann, Julian Rincon

We develop a Clifford-orbit framework for studying magic-protected entanglement, which we refer to as magical entanglement: the part of bipartite entanglement that remains after optimal stabilizer simplification. This construction leverages residual entanglement under Clifford reduction as a state-level organizing principle for magic state space. It defines canonical representatives, spectra, and ranks that characterize the Clifford-irreducible structure of a state. We identify two regimes of the magic-entanglement interplay. In the $T$-magic regime, local nonstabilizer resources can coexist with entanglement, but the protected component remains weak and state-dependent. In the $W$-magic regime, by contrast, entanglement is Clifford-irreducibly tied to nonstabilizerness, producing typical, strongly self-averaging behavior. Analytical examples and random-circuit numerics support a crossover from broad $T$-magic fluctuations to concentrated, Haar-like $W$-magic behavior. These results identify magical entanglement as an orbit-level diagnostic of how nonstabilizerness protects quantum correlations against Clifford reduction.

quant-pharXiv:2607.18400•Jul 22, 2026•1 citation

Magic transition in measurement-only circuits

Poetri Sonya Tarabunga, Emanuele Tirrito

Magic, or nonstabilizerness, quantifies the distance of a quantum state from stabilizer states and serves as a resource for quantum computational advantage. Here, we investigate magic transitions in measurement-only quantum circuits comprising competing Clifford and non-Clifford measurements. Remarkably, this circuit can be mapped onto a classical model, enabling efficient large-scale numerical simulations and exact characterization of magic using measures that are additive for tensor products of single-qubit states. We identify a magic transition between two phases exhibiting extensive magic, separated by a critical point where mutual magic displays scaling analogous to entanglement entropy. Additionally, these distinct phases can be distinguished by topological magic. In contrast, with a vanishing rate of non-Clifford measurements, the system exhibits saturation of magic. Our results clarify the nature of magic and its linear combinations in quantum circuits utilizing genuine magic measures, thereby advancing our understanding of quantum complexity in monitored quantum systems.

arXiv:2407.15939•npj Quantum Information•Oct 21, 2025•34 citations

Theory of Magic Phase Transitions in Encoding-Decoding Circuits

Piotr Sierant, Xhek Turkeshi

Quantum magic resources, or nonstabilizerness, are a central ingredient for universal quantum computation. In noisy many-body systems, the interplay between these resources and errors leads to sharp magic phase transitions. However, the microscopic mechanism behind these critical phenomena is still an open question, especially since early empirical evidence showed conflicting results regarding their universality classes. In this work, we provide a comprehensive picture of magic phase transitions for the class of encoding-decoding quantum circuits to resolve these ambiguities. We analytically show that the behavior of magic resources is fundamentally dictated by the chosen measurement protocol. When we fix, or post-select, the class of measurement syndromes, the magic transition inherits the universal features of the error-resilience phase transition in the circuits. Interestingly, this clean transition survives even for fully random Haar encoders showing that it is a consequence of initial's state retrieval, and not an artifact of the Clifford encoders. On the other hand, if we consider realistic Born-rule sampling, the intrinsic statistical fluctuations of a given syndrome measurement act as a relevant perturbation. This brings in strong finite-size drifts and an apparent multifractality, which end up altering the critical behavior of the system. We reveal that magic phase transitions are actually direct manifestations of error-resilience thresholds, rather than independent critical phenomena, reconciling conflicting observations from the earlier literature. Ultimately, our framework clarifies how the quantum computational power can survive, or be irreversibly destroyed, due to the competition between scrambling, measurements, and errors.

quant-pharXiv:2603.00235•Mar 3, 2026•15 citations

The relative entropy of magic and its nonadditivity

Carolin Deckers, Justus Neumann, Hermann Kampermann +1 more

In most stabilizer-based quantum computing schemes, so-called magic states are a necessary resource for implementing non-transversal quantum gates. With the resource theory of magic, it is possible to analyze and quantify the generation of the non-stabilizer states. The relative entropy is a measure used in various resource theories. For single qubits, we characterize magic states and their closest stabilizer states by applying analytical results known from the relative entropy of entanglement and show that the magic states and their closest stabilizer states are arranged symmetrically around the states at the centers of the faces of the stabilizer octahedron. For tensor products of single-qubit states, we prove analytically that the relative entropy of magic is nonadditive in almost all cases.

quant-pharXiv:2605.22392•May 22, 2026•0 citations

Distributed Resource Theory of Entanglement and Magic

Xiao Yuan, Wenhao Zhang, Qiming Ding +1 more

In distributed fault-tolerant quantum computing, entanglement and magic are essential resources for quantum communication and universal fault-tolerant computation, respectively. Although they are usually treated as distinct resource currencies, whether they admit a unified resource-theoretic description remains an open question. Here, we introduce the distributed resource theory of entanglement and magic (DREAM). In this framework, the free states are convex mixtures of product local stabilizer states, and the free operations are local stabilizer circuits assisted by classical communication (LSCC). We show that DREAM contains nontrivial resource states that are neither entanglement nor magic, so it is strictly richer than treating the two resources independently. Surprisingly, such resources can enable the teleportation of magic states between distant parties without consuming entanglement, revealing a counterintuitive form of resource teleportation mediated entirely by separable states. We further generalize this result to quantum networks and investigate general quantum-state teleportation under LSCC. We show that the shared resource under DREAM is closely related to the teleportation capability, quantified by the magic of the teleported state. Our work establish a systematic framework for studying distributed quantum resources and uncover intrinsic relations among distinct resources within a unified resource theory.

quant-pharXiv:2608.24299•Aug 26, 2026•1 citation

Quantum entanglement as a foundational and informational resource: A unified perspective for separability, nonlocal games, contextuality, decoherence, and measurement

Sachin .

Quantum entanglement is the defining feature of composite quantum systems, underpinning correlations beyond classical randomness and enabling quantum communication, cryptography, and error correction. Surveys treat entanglement, Bell nonlocality, contextuality, and decoherence in isolation or narrow subcommunities. This review advances a unified perspective analysing these phenomena as distinct but interrelated manifestations of nonclassical correlations with an operational structure. We organise bipartite entanglement through separability criteria, Schmidt decomposition, and partial-transpose techniques, and develop tools for nonlocal correlations based on Bell inequalities, Tsirelson’s bound, nonlocal games, and self-testing, emphasising device-independent protocols. We then examine contextuality and magic states as resources for quantum computational advantage beyond entanglement, clarifying their relationship to nonlocality. Finally, we characterise decoherence as environment-induced entanglement selecting classical records, and use this perspective to specify which aspects of the measurement problem it addresses and which require interpretational or dynamical extensions. Integrating these dimensions, the review clarifies how notions of nonclassicality relate, diverge, and underpin quantum technologies.

International Journal of Physics and Mathematics•Jul 1, 2025•0 citations
In this work, we set out to study and define a fundamental separation between two classes of magic states in quantum computation. In order to reach this goal, we define the “left Clifford equivalence,” an equivalence relation that aims to properly distinguish the interplay between magic and entanglement in magic states. Utilizing such an equivalence relation, we define the notion of a “magic class” and show that there are two different magic classes under this notion, which we call T-magic and W-magic. The former displays an almost trivial relationship with entanglement, meaning they behave as completely independent resources. Meanwhile, the latter is not only exclusively a feature of entangled states, but we find that the non-stabilizer resources themselves of W-magic states are intrinsically related to entanglement. In order to further study the distinction between these classes, we discuss how the separation of these classes shows itself in the topic of universality. Then, we depict the whole space of magic states as defined by these classes, and we study the relationship between measurements and both magic classes.
We develop a Clifford-orbit framework for studying magic-protected entanglement, which we refer to as magical entanglement: the part of bipartite entanglement that remains after optimal stabilizer simplification. This construction leverages residual entanglement under Clifford reduction as a state-level organizing principle for magic state space. It defines canonical representatives, spectra, and ranks that characterize the Clifford-irreducible structure of a state. We identify two regimes of the magic-entanglement interplay. In the TTT-magic regime, local nonstabilizer resources can coexist with entanglement, but the protected component remains weak and state-dependent. In the WWW-magic regime, by contrast, entanglement is Clifford-irreducibly tied to nonstabilizerness, producing typical, strongly self-averaging behavior. Analytical examples and random-circuit numerics support a crossover from broad TTT-magic fluctuations to concentrated, Haar-like WWW-magic behavior. These results identify magical entanglement as an orbit-level diagnostic of how nonstabilizerness protects quantum correlations against Clifford reduction.
Magic, or nonstabilizerness, quantifies the distance of a quantum state from stabilizer states and serves as a resource for quantum computational advantage. Here, we investigate magic transitions in measurement-only quantum circuits comprising competing Clifford and non-Clifford measurements. Remarkably, this circuit can be mapped onto a classical model, enabling efficient large-scale numerical simulations and exact characterization of magic using measures that are additive for tensor products of single-qubit states. We identify a magic transition between two phases exhibiting extensive magic, separated by a critical point where mutual magic displays scaling analogous to entanglement entropy. Additionally, these distinct phases can be distinguished by topological magic. In contrast, with a vanishing rate of non-Clifford measurements, the system exhibits saturation of magic. Our results clarify the nature of magic and its linear combinations in quantum circuits utilizing genuine magic measures, thereby advancing our understanding of quantum complexity in monitored quantum systems.
Quantum magic resources, or nonstabilizerness, are a central ingredient for universal quantum computation. In noisy many-body systems, the interplay between these resources and errors leads to sharp magic phase transitions. However, the microscopic mechanism behind these critical phenomena is still an open question, especially since early empirical evidence showed conflicting results regarding their universality classes. In this work, we provide a comprehensive picture of magic phase transitions for the class of encoding-decoding quantum circuits to resolve these ambiguities. We analytically show that the behavior of magic resources is fundamentally dictated by the chosen measurement protocol. When we fix, or post-select, the class of measurement syndromes, the magic transition inherits the universal features of the error-resilience phase transition in the circuits. Interestingly, this clean transition survives even for fully random Haar encoders showing that it is a consequence of initial's state retrieval, and not an artifact of the Clifford encoders. On the other hand, if we consider realistic Born-rule sampling, the intrinsic statistical fluctuations of a given syndrome measurement act as a relevant perturbation. This brings in strong finite-size drifts and an apparent multifractality, which end up altering the critical behavior of the system. We reveal that magic phase transitions are actually direct manifestations of error-resilience thresholds, rather than independent critical phenomena, reconciling conflicting observations from the earlier literature. Ultimately, our framework clarifies how the quantum computational power can survive, or be irreversibly destroyed, due to the competition between scrambling, measurements, and errors.
In most stabilizer-based quantum computing schemes, so-called magic states are a necessary resource for implementing non-transversal quantum gates. With the resource theory of magic, it is possible to analyze and quantify the generation of the non-stabilizer states. The relative entropy is a measure used in various resource theories. For single qubits, we characterize magic states and their closest stabilizer states by applying analytical results known from the relative entropy of entanglement and show that the magic states and their closest stabilizer states are arranged symmetrically around the states at the centers of the faces of the stabilizer octahedron. For tensor products of single-qubit states, we prove analytically that the relative entropy of magic is nonadditive in almost all cases.
In distributed fault-tolerant quantum computing, entanglement and magic are essential resources for quantum communication and universal fault-tolerant computation, respectively. Although they are usually treated as distinct resource currencies, whether they admit a unified resource-theoretic description remains an open question. Here, we introduce the distributed resource theory of entanglement and magic (DREAM). In this framework, the free states are convex mixtures of product local stabilizer states, and the free operations are local stabilizer circuits assisted by classical communication (LSCC). We show that DREAM contains nontrivial resource states that are neither entanglement nor magic, so it is strictly richer than treating the two resources independently. Surprisingly, such resources can enable the teleportation of magic states between distant parties without consuming entanglement, revealing a counterintuitive form of resource teleportation mediated entirely by separable states. We further generalize this result to quantum networks and investigate general quantum-state teleportation under LSCC. We show that the shared resource under DREAM is closely related to the teleportation capability, quantified by the magic of the teleported state. Our work establish a systematic framework for studying distributed quantum resources and uncover intrinsic relations among distinct resources within a unified resource theory.
Quantum entanglement is the defining feature of composite quantum systems, underpinning correlations beyond classical randomness and enabling quantum communication, cryptography, and error correction. Surveys treat entanglement, Bell nonlocality, contextuality, and decoherence in isolation or narrow subcommunities. This review advances a unified perspective analysing these phenomena as distinct but interrelated manifestations of nonclassical correlations with an operational structure. We organise bipartite entanglement through separability criteria, Schmidt decomposition, and partial-transpose techniques, and develop tools for nonlocal correlations based on Bell inequalities, Tsirelson’s bound, nonlocal games, and self-testing, emphasising device-independent protocols. We then examine contextuality and magic states as resources for quantum computational advantage beyond entanglement, clarifying their relationship to nonlocality. Finally, we characterise decoherence as environment-induced entanglement selecting classical records, and use this perspective to specify which aspects of the measurement problem it addresses and which require interpretational or dynamical extensions. Integrating these dimensions, the review clarifies how notions of nonclassicality relate, diverge, and underpin quantum technologies.