Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

What a quantum annealer's effective temperature measures: coherent rate, residual excitations, and a factor of 2π

Dustin Kovac

Published Sep 29, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Three recent experimental studies of D-Wave annealers each report an unexplained effective-temperature phenomenon: fitted inverse temperatures whose dependence on annealing time is left empirical, with sampling quality degrading at a critical frustration point [Pelofske, PRR 8, 033280 (2026)]; a coupling-independent temperature offset t-bar in [0.2,0.4] that violates the assumed T_eff ∝ 1/J scaling [Grattan et al., arXiv:2512.03162]; and hardware inverse temperatures a "consistent" factor of 5–7 above closed-system theory, attributed to uncontrollable hardware effects [Kim et al., PRE 113, 035302 (2026)]. We show that a single account, built from the diabatic effective-temperature relation of Gyhm et al. evaluated on the vendor's published fast-anneal schedules and one thermal bath, organizes all three. First, on real schedules the coherent inverse temperature is nearly linear in annealing time — not ∝ sqrt(t_a) as for linearly vanishing drivers — because the transverse field decays exponentially and dies by s ≈ 0.6; exact statevector simulation confirms the first-order integral to 0.4–4.2% in its validity window. Second, a units identity, beta_cyclic(t_a) = beta_correct(t_a/2pi), resolves the factor of 5–7: the published theoretical reference curves in this lane are quantitatively consistent with schedule data evaluated in cyclic rather than angular frequency units. The foundational paper's own schedule evaluations carry the rescale: its earlier single evaluation, beta ≈ 0.54 at 5 ns, equals our correct-convention value at t_a/2pi (0.539), and all 24 of its current tabulated beta and c_2 values that we can recompute from vendor schedule tables are reproduced at t_a/2pi to within 0.11%; a free-rescale fit to Kim et al.'s published simulation curve gives r = 6.40, with 2pi = 6.283 inside the fit's shallow region; what remains after the correction is consistent with open-system cooling. Third, the coupling-independent offset is a residual-excitation floor read through a domain-wall thermometer, t-bar ≈ 2/ln(1/rho): the implied kink densities (9e-5 to 4e-3) overlap published kink measurements, the excitation-floor form beats the constant-offset (noise) model on AIC for all four reported machines, and the logarithm compresses two and a half decades of rho into the narrow observed band, explaining its apparent universality. In the coherent nanosecond regime the closed-system law is an upper envelope on hardware inverse temperature; the shortfall is a candidate in-situ decoherence diagnostic, machine-resolved, and at the one matched cell where both machines are coherent the measured cross-machine ratio (2.63) agrees with the parameter-free prediction at the few-percent level. All hypotheses, tolerances, and kill criteria were registered before data extraction; failed and undecidable gates are reported alongside the successes. No quantum-advantage claim is made. AI use and validation: This work was produced in close collaboration with AI research assistants, directed by the author, who set the research direction, the standards of evidence, and all decisions about what is claimed and published. Anthropic's Claude (Fable 5) performed the analysis, simulation, extraction, and drafting; xAI's Grok (via Cursor) provided independent pre-publication review; and Anthropic's Claude Opus 5.5 performed a post-publication adversarial audit of the manuscript against its pinned evidence, with findings and dispositions logged in the project ledger and incorporated in subsequent versions. The registered-verdict protocol is designed so that no result rests on trusting a model's output: hypotheses, tolerances, and kill criteria were committed to the repository before any data was extracted; failed and undecidable gates are reported in the paper; every numeric claim traces to pinned, machine-readable extraction files and analysis code included in this deposit; figure data was extracted from the source PDFs' vector drawing operations rather than read by a model; and verbatim quotes were verified against raw page dumps.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23042015

Related papers

Fast quenches estimate partition functions because rate dials temperature: a closed-system account of anomalous accuracy on quantum annealers

Dustin Kovac

A recent experiment [Le and Pelofske, arXiv:2512.19685] estimated the density of states and partition function of a 25-spin ±J Ising instance by reading raw energy histograms of D-Wave annealer samples, and highlighted a striking unexplained observation: the fastest anneals (8ns, within the coherent timescale of the device) gave the best estimates, reaching a log-relative error of 7.6 × 10−6. We show that no anomaly remains once two known ingredients are combined. First, a diabatic anneal is approximately a Boltzmann sampler whose inverse temperature βe is set by the annealing rate [Gyhm et al., arXiv:2409.18126]; we verify this in exact closed-system simulations at the experimental size n = 25, across two schedules, to sub-percent accuracy in the fast regime, and we measure the sampled ensembles to be uniform within energy shells to high precision, validating the energy-only description. Second, the raw-histogram estimator is unbiased only for a flat sampler: its bias is exactly φ(β + βe) − φ(βe) − φ(β), with φ(x) = ln⟨e−xE⟩unif, which grows linearly in βe while low-energy enrichment buys no compensating variance reduction for a Gaussian-like bulk. The fastest anneals are therefore accurate because they are nearly flat samplers sitting on the shot-noise floor; slow or strongly coupled anneals degrade exactly as observed; the interior optima in the reported cumulative sweeps are the bias–variance crossover of histogram pooling; and the headline 7.6 × 10−6 is consistent with the order statistics of a grid search over shot-noise-limited cells. The same analysis yields a free upgrade: because the schedule predicts each cell’s temperature, multi-histogram reweighting (WHAM) applies with rate-derived weights, converting the anneal-time ladder into a temperature ladder, removing the pooling bias by up to three orders of magnitude in our simulations, and extending accurate estimation toward temperatures where flat sampling fails. We state what the closed-system account does not explain as concrete, falsifiable predictions for reanalysis of the hardware data. AI use and validation: This work was produced in close collaboration with an AI research assistant (Anthropic's Claude, Fable 5), directed by the author, who set the research direction, the standards of evidence, and all decisions about what is claimed and published. The model performed analysis, simulation, and drafting under a registered protocol: hypotheses, tolerances, and kill criteria were committed to the repository before the experiments were run; validation scripts and their outputs are included in this deposit; and all results are reproducible from the code and data archived here.

•Sep 22, 2026•0 citations

The Participating Clock: Conditioned Relational Dynamics as a Weak-Value Drive, and a Parameter-Free Second-Order Law

Ryan Cardwell, Claude

Version 3 (2026-08). One correction, chair-directed after an independent text-only rebuild: the setting's conventions dictionary is regenerated from the code of record. The pointer packet is an ENERGY-basis Gaussian launched at tick zero (v1/v2 described it as a tick-space packet of tick-width sigma_n; the temporal width is in fact the inverse, NC/(4 pi sigma_n) ticks); the tick-state sign convention, the second geometry's sigma_n = 3, the twin/control definitions, and the post-selection probabilities are now printed; a standing text-only rebuild gate (fresh implementation from the setting paragraph alone, matching the exact conditioned state at 3.5e-14) guards the dictionary. Every published number stands (the independent rebuild reproduced the NC = 24 physics cold, the lane's first exterior verification, recorded in the data-and-code paragraph); the dictionary was broken. The methods law is minted program-wide: a geometry prints its dictionary, generated from the code, never transcribed. Version 2 (2026-08). Changes from v1: the clock-width profile is completed end to end: v1's spike-plus-plateau is the interior of a measured disturbance VALLEY with an optimal clock width (minimum at sigma_n* = 2.5; the broad side rises 93x by sigma_n = 24, tracked by the value law against exact evolution at ratios 0.985 and 0.995), so the least-disturbing clock is neither time-sharp nor energy-sharp; a pre-registered identification of the plateau with the sharp-clock limit was killed by a factor of 160 and is ledgered; the open problems are re-posed at the valley's optimum. When a finite quantum clock gates a register's interactions and the run is conditioned on the clock's final reading, the register's conditioned dynamics is derived at two orders and machine-verified against exact evolution. First order: the drive is the complex Aharonov-Albert-Vaidman weak value of the gating window projector (real part = Hermitian envelope, imaginary part = post-selection reweighting); a twin evolved under this envelope removes the entire first-order mismatch a mean-envelope control retains (state-metric deficits g^1.1 vs g^2.1, factor 56 at g = 0.1). Second order: the deficit is governed by the connected two-time window correlator under post-selection, resolved along the interaction picture; the resulting parameter-free value law matches measured deficits at ratios 0.92-1.05 across the clock-width grid and at a second geometry (1.03-1.07). The when/what trade-off of a participating clock is promoted from confounded excess to derived law: the disturbance is the connected fluctuation of the clock's timing answer, its clock-width profile is a predicted spike-plus-plateau (not a power law), and two earlier exponent claims are superseded with the reconciliation recorded. Two honest derivation failures (equal-time invisibility resurrected by the interaction picture; the kernel belonging inside the integral) are ledgered as the steps that located the law.

•Aug 19, 2026•1 citation

Classical Thermometry of Quantum Annealers

George Grattan, Pratik Sathe, Cristiano Nisoli

Quantum annealers are emerging as programmable, dynamical experimental platforms for probing strongly correlated spin systems. Yet key thermal assumptions, chiefly a Gibbs-distributed output ensemble, remain unverified in the large-scale regime. Here, we experimentally and quantitatively assess Gibbs sampling fidelity across system sizes spanning over three orders of magnitude. We explore a wide parameter space of coupling strengths, system sizes, annealing times, and D-wave hardware architectures. We find that the naively assumed scaling law for the effective temperature requires a non-negligible, coupling-independent offset that is robust across machines and parameter regimes, quantifying residual non-thermal effects that still conform to an effective Gibbs description. These non-idealities are further reflected in a systematic discrepancy between the physical temperature inferred from the sampled ensemble and the nominal cryogenic temperature of the device. Our results systematically assess the viability of quantum annealers as experimental platforms for probing classical thermodynamics, correct previous assumptions, and provide a physically grounded thermometry framework to benchmark these machines for future thermodynamic experiments.

quant-pharXiv:2512.03162•Dec 4, 2025•3 citations

Schedule-dependent basin occupation and instance-specific effective scales in cycled reverse annealing on programmable quantum annealers

Luis Lozano

Reverse annealing initializes a programmable quantum annealer in a chosen classical state, reintroduces quantum fluctuations down to a pause point, and returns to readout; repeated cycles form a configurable dissipative dynamics whose schedule knobs are routinely treated as a temperature. On mixed-frustration 12-qubit Ising instances on two D-Wave generations (Advantage2 and Advantage_system6.4), we measure schedule-driven redistribution of the subsystem readout and calibrate each schedule's effective scales, using exhaustive enumeration of the $2^{12}$ configurations, a locked analysis plan with a prior-knowledge disclosure, and regenerated classical reference families. First, schedule shape redistributes basin occupation: 11 of 20 random instances respond to a single-pause-to-two-pause change (15 of 20 for long-hold; block permutation, FDR-controlled), with shifts up to 38 percentage points and changes of dominant-configuration identity. Second, the single-qubit probe temperature does not transfer to the many-body problem: moment-matched inverse temperatures span 0.63-9.1 against a probe value of 7.22, and pause depth and duration each shift the scale on most instances (19/20 and 15/20). Third, no observation requires more than the tested classical families: with update budgets extended below one sweep per cycle, all 33 (device, instance, schedule) cells are reproduced within the tested family (minimum intersection-union $p=0.76$), and schedule-aware spin-vector Monte Carlo brings the late-window statistics within semiclassical reach. A pre-registered linear predictor fails on held-out instances, and an earlier pilot's two-pause enhancement claim is contradicted (Fisher $p=0.0013$). Reverse-anneal schedules are instance-specific basin-occupation controls whose effective scales must be calibrated per instance and schedule; nothing here licenses a quantum-mechanistic reading.

quant-pharXiv:2605.17604•May 19, 2026•0 citations

Understanding the physics of D-Wave annealers: From Schrödinger to Lindblad to Markovian dynamics

Vrinda Mehta, Hans A. De Raedt, Kristel F. L. Michielsen +1 more

Understanding the physical nature of the D-Wave annealers remains a subject of active investigation. In this study, we analyze the sampling behavior of these systems and explore whether their results can be replicated using quantum and Markovian models. Employing the standard and the fast annealing protocols, we observe that the D-Wave annealers sample states with frequencies matching the Gibbs distribution for sufficiently long annealing times. Using Bloch equation simulations for single-qubit problems and Lindblad and Markovian master equations for two-qubit systems, we compare experimental data with theoretical predictions. Our results provide insights into the role of quantum mechanics in these devices.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

The Offset Belongs to the Boundary: the trace split of the entanglement Hamiltonian, a measured Clausius region, and an offset with no bulk

Jeromie Beasley

For a region of a free-fermion ground state the entanglement Hamiltonian K_A = log[(1 - C_A) C_A^-1] splits into a part proportional to the identity and a trace-free remainder. The identity part shifts every level rigidly, so every observable built from level differences is blind to it. This paper is about that part. It is not a bulk quantity. The block carries one ladder per entangling cut, the trace is the difference of the two cut-phase charges, and on the exactly dimerised chain with a single cut carrying the whole charge it has the closed form 2 artanh(v / sqrt(v^2 + t^2)), derived in one line and measured to 10^-11. In exact arithmetic the trace is a definite number: zero to thirty-three digits when the two cut phases agree, and 0.786153199019314523 when they do not. The apparent divergence reported in earlier work was double-precision truncation of a finite sum, and is retired here. Along the two lines through the Rice-Mele plane where the half-line entanglement Hamiltonian is known in closed form, it is proportional to the Bisognano-Wichmann deformation T = (1/2){X, H} with no additive constant, and the ladder spacing and phase are fixed by the literature. Between those lines the commuting operator survives, measured at 10^-13 against controls that fail at 1.5 and 29, but the proportionality does not: the level map acquires an intercept b that is zero to 3 x 10^-9 on both lines and of order 10^-1 in the interior, and is identical whether the region has one entangling cut or two. That intercept is the measured failure of exact Bisognano-Wichmann proportionality. At first order in the staggering v the intercept is derived rather than fitted. The symbol's determinant is det(z - P) = z(z - 1) independently of momentum, so the factorisation is canonical everywhere; its logarithm is affine in an involution R = H/E with R^2 = I; the abelian Szego-type boundary functional is identically even in v and therefore cannot carry an odd intercept; and the first-order piece follows from the chiral zero mode of the dimerised chain, whose amplitudes are (-r)^j C(2j,j) 4^-j in closed form. The result is b/v = 2(E' - K')/(1 - r^2) + K', K' = K(1 - r^2), E' = E(1 - r^2), r = t1/t2, whose expansion in the modulus u is, in exact rationals, h(u)/(pi/8) = 1 - (5/8) u^2 - (9/64) u^4 - (65/1024) u^6 - (595/16384) u^8 - ... So pi/8, -5/8 and -9/64 are consequences rather than recognitions, and the natural elliptic candidate [9E - K]/16 - pi/8 is excluded by 7.7 percent on the first coefficient it does not get to choose. The closed form agrees with direct measurement extrapolated to v -> 0 by two to three orders better than the fitted series it replaces; a previously reported u^6 coefficient of -0.0648 is corrected here to -65/1024 and identified as truncation. The trace-free half is treated in parallel. A Clausius relation with a single temperature holds exactly when that half is proportional to the region's own Hamiltonian. At a ground state it never is, and the measured temperature is zero, which is correct rather than a failure. In a thermal state the same instrument returns 1/beta to five significant figures, and the boundary of the region where it does so collapses onto two dimensionless ratios. Two further results are included. The offset vanishes when the two cuts sit at the same phase in the unit cell, without requiring chirality, time reversal, inversion or cleanliness, and a mirror-symmetrised disordered chain gives a larger offset than its unsymmetrised control, which rules reflection out as the mechanism. And in two dimensions the offset is exactly additive along the boundary for a transverse coupling proportional to the identity in sublattice space, for a reason short enough to state, with a derived crossing past which additivity fails and a sigma_z coupling that breaks it smoothly. Every claim carries one of four grades: [T] proven here, [V] computationally verified with stated controls and a stated failure mode, [C] imported from the cited literature, [H] interpretation. The two exact lines, the commuting deformation, the boundary-locality of the entanglement spectrum, and the first law of entanglement entropy are not this work's and are used as given. Sixteen retired claims, including two withdrawn from earlier versions of this manuscript, are listed with the measurement that killed each. Files in this deposit: the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_submission.pdf — 35 pages, gate output verbatim, script listings supplied separately. the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_complete.pdf — 59 pages, identical body with all scripts printed inline. offset_v8_scripts.zip — 23 files. Every number quoted in the paper is printed by one of them; the two gate files reproduce their stored output byte for byte. KEYWORDS entanglement Hamiltonian; entanglement spectrum; modular Hamiltonian; Bisognano-Wichmann; Rice-Mele model; SSH model; free fermions; boundary charge; cut-phase charge; corner transfer matrix; Toeplitz operators; Wiener-Hopf factorisation; Szego-Widom asymptotics; algebraic Heun operator; complete elliptic integrals; entanglement first law; area law; Landau-Widom counting function ADDITIONAL NOTES Supersedes earlier versions of this manuscript. Two claims present in versions 1 to 3 are withdrawn and recorded in the kill list: that the incommensurate offset has no value, and that the offset is one quantum. Both were double-precision truncation of a finite sum. The u^6 coefficient of the shape function reported in the companion results ledger is likewise superseded by the derived value. Computational verification, gating and drafting assistance by an AI collaborator (Claude, Anthropic). Every gate is independently re-runnable from the ancillary scripts.

•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations
Three recent experimental studies of D-Wave annealers each report an unexplained effective-temperature phenomenon: fitted inverse temperatures whose dependence on annealing time is left empirical, with sampling quality degrading at a critical frustration point [Pelofske, PRR 8, 033280 (2026)]; a coupling-independent temperature offset t-bar in [0.2,0.4] that violates the assumed T_eff ∝ 1/J scaling [Grattan et al., arXiv:2512.03162]; and hardware inverse temperatures a "consistent" factor of 5–7 above closed-system theory, attributed to uncontrollable hardware effects [Kim et al., PRE 113, 035302 (2026)]. We show that a single account, built from the diabatic effective-temperature relation of Gyhm et al. evaluated on the vendor's published fast-anneal schedules and one thermal bath, organizes all three. First, on real schedules the coherent inverse temperature is nearly linear in annealing time — not ∝ sqrt(t_a) as for linearly vanishing drivers — because the transverse field decays exponentially and dies by s ≈ 0.6; exact statevector simulation confirms the first-order integral to 0.4–4.2% in its validity window. Second, a units identity, beta_cyclic(t_a) = beta_correct(t_a/2pi), resolves the factor of 5–7: the published theoretical reference curves in this lane are quantitatively consistent with schedule data evaluated in cyclic rather than angular frequency units. The foundational paper's own schedule evaluations carry the rescale: its earlier single evaluation, beta ≈ 0.54 at 5 ns, equals our correct-convention value at t_a/2pi (0.539), and all 24 of its current tabulated beta and c_2 values that we can recompute from vendor schedule tables are reproduced at t_a/2pi to within 0.11%; a free-rescale fit to Kim et al.'s published simulation curve gives r = 6.40, with 2pi = 6.283 inside the fit's shallow region; what remains after the correction is consistent with open-system cooling. Third, the coupling-independent offset is a residual-excitation floor read through a domain-wall thermometer, t-bar ≈ 2/ln(1/rho): the implied kink densities (9e-5 to 4e-3) overlap published kink measurements, the excitation-floor form beats the constant-offset (noise) model on AIC for all four reported machines, and the logarithm compresses two and a half decades of rho into the narrow observed band, explaining its apparent universality. In the coherent nanosecond regime the closed-system law is an upper envelope on hardware inverse temperature; the shortfall is a candidate in-situ decoherence diagnostic, machine-resolved, and at the one matched cell where both machines are coherent the measured cross-machine ratio (2.63) agrees with the parameter-free prediction at the few-percent level. All hypotheses, tolerances, and kill criteria were registered before data extraction; failed and undecidable gates are reported alongside the successes. No quantum-advantage claim is made. AI use and validation: This work was produced in close collaboration with AI research assistants, directed by the author, who set the research direction, the standards of evidence, and all decisions about what is claimed and published. Anthropic's Claude (Fable 5) performed the analysis, simulation, extraction, and drafting; xAI's Grok (via Cursor) provided independent pre-publication review; and Anthropic's Claude Opus 5.5 performed a post-publication adversarial audit of the manuscript against its pinned evidence, with findings and dispositions logged in the project ledger and incorporated in subsequent versions. The registered-verdict protocol is designed so that no result rests on trusting a model's output: hypotheses, tolerances, and kill criteria were committed to the repository before any data was extracted; failed and undecidable gates are reported in the paper; every numeric claim traces to pinned, machine-readable extraction files and analysis code included in this deposit; figure data was extracted from the source PDFs' vector drawing operations rather than read by a model; and verbatim quotes were verified against raw page dumps.
A recent experiment [Le and Pelofske, arXiv:2512.19685] estimated the density of states and partition function of a 25-spin ±J Ising instance by reading raw energy histograms of D-Wave annealer samples, and highlighted a striking unexplained observation: the fastest anneals (8ns, within the coherent timescale of the device) gave the best estimates, reaching a log-relative error of 7.6 × 10−6. We show that no anomaly remains once two known ingredients are combined. First, a diabatic anneal is approximately a Boltzmann sampler whose inverse temperature βe is set by the annealing rate [Gyhm et al., arXiv:2409.18126]; we verify this in exact closed-system simulations at the experimental size n = 25, across two schedules, to sub-percent accuracy in the fast regime, and we measure the sampled ensembles to be uniform within energy shells to high precision, validating the energy-only description. Second, the raw-histogram estimator is unbiased only for a flat sampler: its bias is exactly φ(β + βe) − φ(βe) − φ(β), with φ(x) = ln⟨e−xE⟩unif, which grows linearly in βe while low-energy enrichment buys no compensating variance reduction for a Gaussian-like bulk. The fastest anneals are therefore accurate because they are nearly flat samplers sitting on the shot-noise floor; slow or strongly coupled anneals degrade exactly as observed; the interior optima in the reported cumulative sweeps are the bias–variance crossover of histogram pooling; and the headline 7.6 × 10−6 is consistent with the order statistics of a grid search over shot-noise-limited cells. The same analysis yields a free upgrade: because the schedule predicts each cell’s temperature, multi-histogram reweighting (WHAM) applies with rate-derived weights, converting the anneal-time ladder into a temperature ladder, removing the pooling bias by up to three orders of magnitude in our simulations, and extending accurate estimation toward temperatures where flat sampling fails. We state what the closed-system account does not explain as concrete, falsifiable predictions for reanalysis of the hardware data. AI use and validation: This work was produced in close collaboration with an AI research assistant (Anthropic's Claude, Fable 5), directed by the author, who set the research direction, the standards of evidence, and all decisions about what is claimed and published. The model performed analysis, simulation, and drafting under a registered protocol: hypotheses, tolerances, and kill criteria were committed to the repository before the experiments were run; validation scripts and their outputs are included in this deposit; and all results are reproducible from the code and data archived here.
Version 3 (2026-08). One correction, chair-directed after an independent text-only rebuild: the setting's conventions dictionary is regenerated from the code of record. The pointer packet is an ENERGY-basis Gaussian launched at tick zero (v1/v2 described it as a tick-space packet of tick-width sigma_n; the temporal width is in fact the inverse, NC/(4 pi sigma_n) ticks); the tick-state sign convention, the second geometry's sigma_n = 3, the twin/control definitions, and the post-selection probabilities are now printed; a standing text-only rebuild gate (fresh implementation from the setting paragraph alone, matching the exact conditioned state at 3.5e-14) guards the dictionary. Every published number stands (the independent rebuild reproduced the NC = 24 physics cold, the lane's first exterior verification, recorded in the data-and-code paragraph); the dictionary was broken. The methods law is minted program-wide: a geometry prints its dictionary, generated from the code, never transcribed. Version 2 (2026-08). Changes from v1: the clock-width profile is completed end to end: v1's spike-plus-plateau is the interior of a measured disturbance VALLEY with an optimal clock width (minimum at sigma_n* = 2.5; the broad side rises 93x by sigma_n = 24, tracked by the value law against exact evolution at ratios 0.985 and 0.995), so the least-disturbing clock is neither time-sharp nor energy-sharp; a pre-registered identification of the plateau with the sharp-clock limit was killed by a factor of 160 and is ledgered; the open problems are re-posed at the valley's optimum. When a finite quantum clock gates a register's interactions and the run is conditioned on the clock's final reading, the register's conditioned dynamics is derived at two orders and machine-verified against exact evolution. First order: the drive is the complex Aharonov-Albert-Vaidman weak value of the gating window projector (real part = Hermitian envelope, imaginary part = post-selection reweighting); a twin evolved under this envelope removes the entire first-order mismatch a mean-envelope control retains (state-metric deficits g^1.1 vs g^2.1, factor 56 at g = 0.1). Second order: the deficit is governed by the connected two-time window correlator under post-selection, resolved along the interaction picture; the resulting parameter-free value law matches measured deficits at ratios 0.92-1.05 across the clock-width grid and at a second geometry (1.03-1.07). The when/what trade-off of a participating clock is promoted from confounded excess to derived law: the disturbance is the connected fluctuation of the clock's timing answer, its clock-width profile is a predicted spike-plus-plateau (not a power law), and two earlier exponent claims are superseded with the reconciliation recorded. Two honest derivation failures (equal-time invisibility resurrected by the interaction picture; the kernel belonging inside the integral) are ledgered as the steps that located the law.
Quantum annealers are emerging as programmable, dynamical experimental platforms for probing strongly correlated spin systems. Yet key thermal assumptions, chiefly a Gibbs-distributed output ensemble, remain unverified in the large-scale regime. Here, we experimentally and quantitatively assess Gibbs sampling fidelity across system sizes spanning over three orders of magnitude. We explore a wide parameter space of coupling strengths, system sizes, annealing times, and D-wave hardware architectures. We find that the naively assumed scaling law for the effective temperature requires a non-negligible, coupling-independent offset that is robust across machines and parameter regimes, quantifying residual non-thermal effects that still conform to an effective Gibbs description. These non-idealities are further reflected in a systematic discrepancy between the physical temperature inferred from the sampled ensemble and the nominal cryogenic temperature of the device. Our results systematically assess the viability of quantum annealers as experimental platforms for probing classical thermodynamics, correct previous assumptions, and provide a physically grounded thermometry framework to benchmark these machines for future thermodynamic experiments.
Reverse annealing initializes a programmable quantum annealer in a chosen classical state, reintroduces quantum fluctuations down to a pause point, and returns to readout; repeated cycles form a configurable dissipative dynamics whose schedule knobs are routinely treated as a temperature. On mixed-frustration 12-qubit Ising instances on two D-Wave generations (Advantage2 and Advantage_system6.4), we measure schedule-driven redistribution of the subsystem readout and calibrate each schedule's effective scales, using exhaustive enumeration of the 2122^{12}212 configurations, a locked analysis plan with a prior-knowledge disclosure, and regenerated classical reference families. First, schedule shape redistributes basin occupation: 11 of 20 random instances respond to a single-pause-to-two-pause change (15 of 20 for long-hold; block permutation, FDR-controlled), with shifts up to 38 percentage points and changes of dominant-configuration identity. Second, the single-qubit probe temperature does not transfer to the many-body problem: moment-matched inverse temperatures span 0.63-9.1 against a probe value of 7.22, and pause depth and duration each shift the scale on most instances (19/20 and 15/20). Third, no observation requires more than the tested classical families: with update budgets extended below one sweep per cycle, all 33 (device, instance, schedule) cells are reproduced within the tested family (minimum intersection-union p=0.76p=0.76p=0.76), and schedule-aware spin-vector Monte Carlo brings the late-window statistics within semiclassical reach. A pre-registered linear predictor fails on held-out instances, and an earlier pilot's two-pause enhancement claim is contradicted (Fisher p=0.0013p=0.0013p=0.0013). Reverse-anneal schedules are instance-specific basin-occupation controls whose effective scales must be calibrated per instance and schedule; nothing here licenses a quantum-mechanistic reading.
Understanding the physical nature of the D-Wave annealers remains a subject of active investigation. In this study, we analyze the sampling behavior of these systems and explore whether their results can be replicated using quantum and Markovian models. Employing the standard and the fast annealing protocols, we observe that the D-Wave annealers sample states with frequencies matching the Gibbs distribution for sufficiently long annealing times. Using Bloch equation simulations for single-qubit problems and Lindblad and Markovian master equations for two-qubit systems, we compare experimental data with theoretical predictions. Our results provide insights into the role of quantum mechanics in these devices.
For a region of a free-fermion ground state the entanglement Hamiltonian K_A = log[(1 - C_A) C_A^-1] splits into a part proportional to the identity and a trace-free remainder. The identity part shifts every level rigidly, so every observable built from level differences is blind to it. This paper is about that part. It is not a bulk quantity. The block carries one ladder per entangling cut, the trace is the difference of the two cut-phase charges, and on the exactly dimerised chain with a single cut carrying the whole charge it has the closed form 2 artanh(v / sqrt(v^2 + t^2)), derived in one line and measured to 10^-11. In exact arithmetic the trace is a definite number: zero to thirty-three digits when the two cut phases agree, and 0.786153199019314523 when they do not. The apparent divergence reported in earlier work was double-precision truncation of a finite sum, and is retired here. Along the two lines through the Rice-Mele plane where the half-line entanglement Hamiltonian is known in closed form, it is proportional to the Bisognano-Wichmann deformation T = (1/2){X, H} with no additive constant, and the ladder spacing and phase are fixed by the literature. Between those lines the commuting operator survives, measured at 10^-13 against controls that fail at 1.5 and 29, but the proportionality does not: the level map acquires an intercept b that is zero to 3 x 10^-9 on both lines and of order 10^-1 in the interior, and is identical whether the region has one entangling cut or two. That intercept is the measured failure of exact Bisognano-Wichmann proportionality. At first order in the staggering v the intercept is derived rather than fitted. The symbol's determinant is det(z - P) = z(z - 1) independently of momentum, so the factorisation is canonical everywhere; its logarithm is affine in an involution R = H/E with R^2 = I; the abelian Szego-type boundary functional is identically even in v and therefore cannot carry an odd intercept; and the first-order piece follows from the chiral zero mode of the dimerised chain, whose amplitudes are (-r)^j C(2j,j) 4^-j in closed form. The result is b/v = 2(E' - K')/(1 - r^2) + K', K' = K(1 - r^2), E' = E(1 - r^2), r = t1/t2, whose expansion in the modulus u is, in exact rationals, h(u)/(pi/8) = 1 - (5/8) u^2 - (9/64) u^4 - (65/1024) u^6 - (595/16384) u^8 - ... So pi/8, -5/8 and -9/64 are consequences rather than recognitions, and the natural elliptic candidate [9E - K]/16 - pi/8 is excluded by 7.7 percent on the first coefficient it does not get to choose. The closed form agrees with direct measurement extrapolated to v -> 0 by two to three orders better than the fitted series it replaces; a previously reported u^6 coefficient of -0.0648 is corrected here to -65/1024 and identified as truncation. The trace-free half is treated in parallel. A Clausius relation with a single temperature holds exactly when that half is proportional to the region's own Hamiltonian. At a ground state it never is, and the measured temperature is zero, which is correct rather than a failure. In a thermal state the same instrument returns 1/beta to five significant figures, and the boundary of the region where it does so collapses onto two dimensionless ratios. Two further results are included. The offset vanishes when the two cuts sit at the same phase in the unit cell, without requiring chirality, time reversal, inversion or cleanliness, and a mirror-symmetrised disordered chain gives a larger offset than its unsymmetrised control, which rules reflection out as the mechanism. And in two dimensions the offset is exactly additive along the boundary for a transverse coupling proportional to the identity in sublattice space, for a reason short enough to state, with a derived crossing past which additivity fails and a sigma_z coupling that breaks it smoothly. Every claim carries one of four grades: [T] proven here, [V] computationally verified with stated controls and a stated failure mode, [C] imported from the cited literature, [H] interpretation. The two exact lines, the commuting deformation, the boundary-locality of the entanglement spectrum, and the first law of entanglement entropy are not this work's and are used as given. Sixteen retired claims, including two withdrawn from earlier versions of this manuscript, are listed with the measurement that killed each. Files in this deposit: the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_submission.pdf — 35 pages, gate output verbatim, script listings supplied separately. the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_complete.pdf — 59 pages, identical body with all scripts printed inline. offset_v8_scripts.zip — 23 files. Every number quoted in the paper is printed by one of them; the two gate files reproduce their stored output byte for byte. KEYWORDS entanglement Hamiltonian; entanglement spectrum; modular Hamiltonian; Bisognano-Wichmann; Rice-Mele model; SSH model; free fermions; boundary charge; cut-phase charge; corner transfer matrix; Toeplitz operators; Wiener-Hopf factorisation; Szego-Widom asymptotics; algebraic Heun operator; complete elliptic integrals; entanglement first law; area law; Landau-Widom counting function ADDITIONAL NOTES Supersedes earlier versions of this manuscript. Two claims present in versions 1 to 3 are withdrawn and recorded in the kill list: that the incommensurate offset has no value, and that the offset is one quantum. Both were double-precision truncation of a finite sum. The u^6 coefficient of the shape function reported in the companion results ledger is likewise superseded by the derived value. Computational verification, gating and drafting assistance by an AI collaborator (Claude, Anthropic). Every gate is independently re-runnable from the ancillary scripts.