Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Composite order in the four-colour quantum Ashkin–Teller chain: the N=4 strong-disorder exception at the clean self-dual point

Egemen Ekinci

Published Sep 29, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Preprint. Not peer reviewed. The random quantum Ashkin-Teller chain with N Ising colours was solved by strong-disorder renormalization for every N except four, where internal states couple at second order and the standard decimation cannot discard them (Barghathi, Hrahsheh, Hoyos, Narayanan and Vojta, Phys. Scr. T165, 014040 (2015); arXiv:1404.2509, section IV.D). This record treats that case. An exact change of variables maps the 16-state site onto four-state Potts matter coupled to two binary charges. At zero transverse field and zero pair-bond coupling the charges are conserved and the matter is a q=4 Potts chain; at finite couplings their fate is the research problem. An equivalent transformation appears in the reference above and no priority is claimed for it. In the strong-field corner the retained site doublet supports an effective Ising chain for the four-colour product, with bond 3K^2/[4(g_i+g_j)] and field 4h. The leading composite coefficient is derived for general even N=2m, while for odd N the all-colour transition is forbidden at every order in K. The N=4 exception is therefore the first member of an even series rather than an isolated accident. Keeping the doublet mixing gives error scaling lambda^3 (measured 3.00087) against lambda^2 (2.00717) when it is dropped, so the mixing the published decimation could not discard is a leading-order term. DMRG on the full unprojected 16-state chain finds a composite-ordered regime: at K/g=0.20 the quartet endpoint correlation plateaus at 0.936034 from L=12 through L=24 while single-, pair- and triple-colour correlations stay short-ranged, within 5.34e-4 of the unfitted third-order prediction. Projection onto all four positive global parities changes it by 2.15e-7 while raising the central-cut entropy by log 2 to within 1.83e-7, confirming a symmetric cat state. At the self-dual point the entanglement profile matches an independently implemented q=4 Potts chain to 7.52e-6 nats. With finite charge-changing couplings h=J=1/epsilon the deviation from a matched q=4 Potts control is second order in 1/epsilon, separable from the DMRG residual, and its amplitude is length-independent across L=6,8,10 (5.03, 4.95, 4.91 x 10^-3), with the L=10 value predicted before it was computed. The mechanism is identified analytically: the second-order numerator is a constant plus twice the existing transverse term, so new operators can enter only through the matter-dependent energy denominator, and both mechanisms are local. The clean N=4 exception therefore resolves to q=4 Potts criticality with a fixed local perturbative correction. Review status. Sections 1-4 rest on results that passed this project's independent review process, three audit rounds included in the deposit. Section 5 has NOT been independently reviewed and is flagged as such in the manuscript and the README. A self-audit of the unreviewed stages is deposited; it is a starting point for a real review, not a substitute for one. A broad-disorder section was withdrawn before deposit. A 20-sample gap-scaling run gave a ln-gap width growth suggesting infinite-randomness behaviour; a 100-sample run under the same pre-registered rule returned INDETERMINATE, and the earlier value proved to be carried by two tail samples. Both runs, both pre-registrations and the analysis are deposited. The random critical point remains open. Not claimed: a thermodynamic phase boundary, scaling dimensions of the generated operators, anything about the random critical point, or priority for the variable transformation. Every stage's predictions were written before execution, every result file records the SHA-256 of its sources, and historical outputs are preserved unchanged. DMRG state checkpoints (about 93 MB) are excluded from the archive; each is reproducible from its recorded seed and settings, and its SHA-256 is stored in the result file it belongs to. AI assistance. Produced with substantial assistance from a generative AI system (Claude, Anthropic), and earlier stages with a second system (Codex, OpenAI), which also served as the independent reviewer between stages. The systems are not authors. The author defined the research direction, made the scientific decisions, and takes full responsibility for the content.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23043330

Related papers

Strong-randomness phenomena in quantum Ashkin–Teller models

Hatem Barghathi, Fawaz Y. Hrahsheh, José A. Hoyos +2 more

The N -color quantum Ashkin–Teller spin chain is a prototypical model for the study of strong-randomness phenomena at first-order and continuous quantum phase transitions. In this paper, we first review the existing strong-disorder renormalization group approaches to the random quantum Ashkin–Teller chain in the weak-coupling as well as the strong-coupling regimes. We then introduce a novel general variable transformation that unifies the treatment of the strong-coupling regime. This allows us to determine the phase diagram for all color numbers N , and the critical behavior for all . In the case of two colors, N = 2, a partially ordered product phase separates the paramagnetic and ferromagnetic phases in the strong-coupling regime. This phase is absent for all , i.e., there is a direct phase boundary between the paramagnetic and ferromagnetic phases. In agreement with the quantum version of the Aizenman–Wehr theorem, all phase transitions are continuous, even if their clean counterparts are of first order. We also discuss the various critical and multicritical points. They are all of infinite-randomness type, but depending on the coupling strength, they belong to different universality classes.

arXiv:1404.2509•Physica Scripta•Oct 1, 2015•18 citations

Monte Carlo simulations of the disordered three-color quantum Ashkin-Teller chain

Ahmed K. Ibrahim, Thomas Vojta

We investigate the zero-temperature quantum phase transitions of the disordered three-color quantum Ashkin-Teller spin chain by means of large-scale Monte Carlo simulations. We find that the first-order phase transitions of the clean system are rounded by the quenched disorder. For weak intercolor coupling, the resulting emergent quantum critical point between the paramagnetic phase and the magnetically ordered Baxter phase is of infinite-randomness type and belongs to the universality class of the random transverse-field Ising model, as predicted by recent strong-disorder renormalization group calculations. We also find evidence for unconventional critical behavior in the case of strong intercolor coupling, even though an unequivocal determination of the universality class is beyond our numerical capabilities. We compare our results to earlier simulations, and we discuss implications for the classification of phase transitions in the presence of disorder.

arXiv:1612.05617•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 1, 2017•6 citations

Improved matrix product operator renormalization group: application to the N -color random Ashkin–Teller chain

Christophe Chatelain

Abstract Strong-disorder renormalization group (SDRG), despite being a relatively simple real-space renormalization procedure, provides in principle exact results on the critical properties at the infinite-randomness fixed point of random quantum spin chains. Numerically, SDRG can be efficiently implemented as a renormalization of matrix product operators (MPO-RG). By considering larger blocks than SDRG, MPO-RG was recently used to compute non-critical quantities of finite chains that are inaccessible to SDRG. In this work, the accuracy of this approach is studied and two simple and fast improvements are proposed. The accuracy on the ground state energy is improved by a factor at least equal to four for the random Ising chain in a transverse field. Finally, the proposed algorithms are shown to yield Binder cumulants of the three-color random Ashkin–Teller chain that are compatible with a second-order phase transition while a first-order one is predicted by the original MPO-RG algorithm.

arXiv:1807.08984•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Sep 1, 2019•3 citations

Power-Law Holographic Forces and Causal Transport in MERA Quantum Circuits

Jon Cackler

CORRECTION NOTICE (v5, 2026-09-06). The central result of v1-v4 is WITHDRAWN. This record has not been peer reviewed. Issued 2026-09-06 by the author (v5 of this record). This notice was added to the archived record; the manuscript itself is unaltered. This record has not been peer reviewed. What is wrong The force exponent reported here as alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 is an artifact of the fitting procedure, not a property of the data. The fit was unweighted least squares in linear space applied to a steeply falling profile, which places 95.8 percent of its objective on the single point at the shortest retained separation. Re-fitting the same data with nothing discarded, changing only the error model, gives 2.82 (relative-error weighting) or 2.89 (log-space regression). Across fifteen combinations of standard estimator and fit window the exponent spans 2.53 to 3.92, and the value published here is the largest of them. What the data show instead, and how firmly The retraction is certain. The replacement is not. On the open 24-site chain the same data give alpha = 2.6 +/- 0.2, where the interval is the spread of a plateau in the local logarithmic slope over six consecutive separations, not a statistical error (the bootstrap error on the published fit to the same data is 0.63); the plateau value was reproduced at 2.5921 by a separately written implementation run on the same recorded state (SIM-2026-073). This is a single geometry at a single size. On a 24-site periodic ring, analysed with chord distance as pre-registered, two probes that are both energy-density-like (Delta = 1) give 1.83 and 2.37 against a CFT two-point value of 2 (SIM-2026-074): one size, not converged, disagreeing with each other by 29 percent, and not attributable to a single operator channel. No corrected exponent is established. The exchange channel is an open question. Treat 2.6 +/- 0.2 as the provisional open-chain value, not as a result. Also withdrawn or voided alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24 sites) and alpha = 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16 sites, exact) from stress-tensor exchange. Was: headline result and its first corroboration. Now: withdrawn. Why: the same estimator artifact: both move in lockstep under it (3.92 to 2.56, 3.97 to 2.75 on dropping the contact point), because they share one observable, one fit window and one fitting routine. scalar exchange (alpha = 2) excluded. Was: stated as excluded at about 12 sigma. Now: withdrawn. Why: the 12 sigma used the covariance error 0.16; at the bootstrap error 0.63 computed before release the exclusion is about 2.2 sigma, and under any window starting at separation 3 the point estimate itself falls to about 2.56. alpha = 4 is universal; alpha = 4.00 at Ising, tricritical Ising and Potts. Was: confirmed at three classes. Now: withdrawn; the operator towers at all three classes stand. Why: the exponent was measured only at Ising and inherited by the other two; the towers are spectra, not forces. third independent evaluation alpha = 4.07 (chi = 3 MERA), and with it the statement that this was the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. Was: supporting evidence and a priority claim. Now: both withdrawn. Why: the profile changes sign inside its own fit window and cannot be a fixed-sign power law; the priority claim rests on that evaluation alone and was never gated against prior work. the discriminating test: stress tensor (Z_j Z_j+1) versus spin primary (X_j). Was: registered killer test. Now: void. Why: at the critical point these are one operator, related by exact Kramers-Wannier self-duality. Measured on the periodic ring: identical expectation values to 1e-15 and identical force profiles to 1e-13 at 14 sites, 2.4e-9 at 24 sites (SIM-2026-074). Open boundaries break the duality, which is why the open-chain run of this test (SIM-2026-073) showed a spurious difference between the two arms. The test compared the energy density to itself. Neither label was correct: Z_j Z_j+1 is the energy density, not the stress tensor; X_j is its dual, not the spin primary. transport time T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2 percent as a geometric prediction. Was: confirmed. Now: measurement stands (T = 2.239 at N = 16); geometric reading not established. Why: l_AdS cancels in the cited derivation, which also gives pi rather than the pi/2 the manuscript compares against; the chi = 3 estimate of l_AdS gives a 57 percent miss; the transport driver never applies a MERA. The true spin primary Z_j was never in the design, and the direct replacement test is blocked: Z_j is odd under the Z2 symmetry, so the energy-difference observable used throughout this work subtracts across symmetry sectors and is undefined for it. A replacement test using two Z2-even probes has been pre-registered (PREREGISTRATION-T.md, committed before its driver) and run; its result is deliberately not part of this correction and will appear in a later version. Not previously reported The published fit has a reduced chi-squared of 6.008 on 9 degrees of freedom, and a bootstrap standard deviation of 0.63 rather than the quoted 0.16. Both were computed before release and omitted. What is unaffected Of the claims in this record: the two-phase optimization method, the chi = 3 criticality threshold, the exact-diagonalization gates, the measured OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-epsilon = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact 1/2, and the conformal towers at all three classes. Not part of this record, mentioned only because they are sometimes read together with it: the later C_TTT stress-tensor self-coupling measurements (SIM-2026-067/068/069, dated after this record) and the matched off-critical ring control (SIM-2026-074) are unaffected by this correction and make no claim about the force exponent. How the error was found and what this record contains The error was found by the author's own internal adversarial audit, not by a reviewer; the journal submission it was found after is closed, and no review of this work has taken place. Files in this record: the full re-analysis (SIM-2026-072.json, driver, figure), the pre-registered chain test (SIM-2026-073.json) and ring test (SIM-2026-074.json) with both pre-registrations as committed before the runs, the runnable drivers with their shared module and the negative test suite for their validation gates, and the error register (ERRATA.md). Concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19660302 always resolves to the current version. The abstract of the original manuscript follows unchanged, for the record. Every claim in it about the force exponent should be read against the correction above. We report results from classical simulation of critical spin chains that establish quantitative physical content in the MERA-AdS correspondence. First, the interaction energy between boundary-primary excitations follows a power law F(dr) ~ dr^(-alpha) with three consistent evaluations yielding alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24q), 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16q), and 4.07 +/- 0.18 (16q chi=3 MERA), all consistent with stress-tensor exchange (alpha = 2*Delta_T = 4) and inconsistent with scalar exchange (alpha = 2); the exponent is explained by the Ising CFT fusion rule eps x eps = [1]. Because Delta_T = 2 is fixed by conformal symmetry in every unitary 2D CFT, alpha = 4 is universal: we confirm this at two further fixed points - the tricritical Ising model (c = 7/10), where a scale-invariant MERA recovers the full M(4,5) primary spectrum (Delta_sigma = 0.092, Delta_eps = 0.204, Delta_T = 1.999), and the three-state Potts model (c = 4/5), where a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers Delta_sigma = 0.134, Delta_eps = 0.805, Delta_T = 2.001 - giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes. Second, the holographic transport time matches the AdS_3 null geodesic prediction T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2% at N = 16 sites on a time-grid-converged measurement, with the residual shrinking from 2.8% at N = 12. Third, we introduce a two-phase optimization method (ALM + Z2 projection) for Z2-symmetric MERA ground states at 24 qubits. Fourth, extending the MERA bond dimension from chi=2 to chi=3 overcomes the expressibility barrier, achieving 0.15% energy error at 16 qubits and enabling the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. The OPE coefficient is also measured directly from the fixed-point tensors: C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact Ising value 1/2. A hardware path is designed for Quantinuum Helios (57 CNOTs, 0.57% logical error). Version 4 changes (relative to v3): Transport: N=16 residual restated as the time-grid-converged value of -1.21% (dt = 1e-3), with -2.78% at N=12 showing the finite-size trend; the 0.72% figure in v3 was an artifact of the dt = 0.05 integration grid and is now labeled as such. The N=24 transport point carries a new reliability caveat (double-lobe trace structure). The l_AdS comparison table is recomputed against the converged transport time (best fit 1.425, deviation 1.21%). Effective-mass derivation rewritten in a consistent AdS3 convention m^2 l^2 = Delta(Delta-2); m_eff = 0.693 = 1/l_AdS follows from Delta = 1 exactly. NEW: universality section extended to a third fixed point - a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers the three-state Potts (c = 4/5) tower, giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes (c = 1/2, 7/10, 4/5). NEW: the OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 measured directly from the fixed-point tensors, with C_sigma-sigma-sigma = 0 at machine precision as the Z2 structural check. Supplemental table row SIM-007 annotated (record lost; script preserved); data availability expanded; Zenodo DOI added to the front matter.

•Apr 20, 2026•1 citation

N -color Ashkin-Teller model

Gary S. Grest, Michael Widom

We study a model Hamiltonian consisting of $N$ Ising models coupled pairwise through a four-spin interaction ${K}_{4}$. When $N=2$ this model is the well-known Ashkin-Teller model which shows nonuniversal critical behavior in two dimensions in the neighborhood of ${K}_{4}=0$. To see if this behavior persists for $N\ensuremath{\ne}2$ we perform a first-order-perturbation expansion around the decoupling point in two dimensions. As an aid in interpreting the results of this perturbation expansion we have determined the phase diagram of the system through mean-field theory and Monte Carlo studies in both two and three dimensions for $N=3$. The results show that $N=2$ is special because the coupling between Ising models is marginal over a range of values of ${K}_{4}$. We discuss the effect of the coupling ${K}_{4}$ for $N\ensuremath{\ne}2$.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 1, 1981•80 citations

Exact Hermitian Formula and Rigorous Asymptotics of Remote Bogoliubov-Kubo-Mori Distinguishability after Local Gaussian Filtering in a Massive Harmonic Chain

Alexandru Rora

This record contains the preprint, its Supplemental Material, and the complete computational package behind them. VERSION 2 NOTE. This version corrects the physical interpretation of the decay rate. No previously reported scientific result, coefficient, numerical value, or computational formula was altered, and the code archive is carried over unchanged from v1. Eq. (4) was algebraically expanded to state kappa explicitly; an explanatory section, numbered S0 so as to leave the version-1 numbering intact, was added to the Supplemental Material; and the vertical range of Fig. 2 was rescaled to match its data, with no plotted value changed. On a spatial lattice the inverse equal-time correlation length kappa and the Hamiltonian energy gap m_L are distinct quantities, coinciding only in the continuum limit. Version 1 described 2 kappa as a two-particle spectral threshold, which reads as a statement about the energy spectrum; the two-particle energy threshold is 2 m_L. The result concerns the spatial decay of an equal-time correlator and is governed throughout by kappa. RESULT. For a massive harmonic chain, a local Gaussian filter applied at one site changes the reduced state of a distant block of b sites by an amount whose Bogoliubov-Kubo-Mori distinguishability decays as delta_B(r) ~ r^{-1} exp(-2 kappa r), at exactly twice the one-particle inverse equal-time correlation length kappa = 2 arcsinh(m_L/2) = arccosh(1 + m_L^2/2). The doubled rate is the lowest two-particle SPATIAL exponent of the even (:phi^2:) channel: the equal-time :phi^2: correlator is the square of the one-particle propagator, so its nearest complex-momentum singularity sits at twice the one-particle branch point. On the lattice kappa is distinct from the energy gap m_L = min_k omega(k), from which it differs at third order in the mass; the sweep resolves the difference directly, the static-source benchmark returning lambda_A/kappa = 1.00000000 at all six masses while lambda_A/m_L falls to 0.99496 at m_L = 0.35. The same branch point fixes the algebraic prefactor. Smearing the filter with a form factor having a zero of order p at the branch point suppresses the one-particle kernel amplitude by r^{-p}; because the covariance tangent is quadratic in that kernel, the BKM distinguishability acquires an additional factor r^{-2p}, giving delta_B^(p)(r) ~ r^{-(2p+1)} exp(-2 kappa r) for arbitrary fixed p. THREE LOAD-BEARING RESULTS, EACH WITH AN INDEPENDENT COMPUTATIONAL ROUTE. (1) An exact Hermitian formula for the restricted BKM susceptibility, chi_b(X_Q) = -sum_ij H_ij Ytilde_ij^2, in which positivity is manifest and eigenvalue degeneracies are handled by the divided-difference limit. Checked against a from-scratch Gaussian relative-entropy implementation by finite-differencing D(V + eps X || V), and against a Daleckii-Krein route at 2136 sampled points with median relative difference 4.3e-15, the worst-conditioned point re-checked at 100 digits. (2) Rigorous asymptotics obtained by collapsing the Fourier contour onto the branch cut and using an exact Beta representation. This gives a Poincare expansion to arbitrary order with a uniform Taylor-Lagrange remainder, and the source hierarchy for arbitrary fixed p rather than only the first few orders. The third-order coefficient a_3 = (80 coth kappa - 75 coth^3 kappa)/1024 follows from the same route. (3) A 24-cell finite-lattice sweep and an independent arbitrary-precision infinite-chain calculation, the latter free of finite-size and periodic-image artifacts, confirming the coefficients through third order across all cells. -------------------------------------------------------------- This record contains the preprint, its Supplemental Material, and the complete computational package behind them. VERSION 1 NOTE RESULT. For a massive harmonic chain, a local Gaussian filter applied at one site changes the reduced state of a distant block of b sites by an amount whose Bogoliubov-Kubo-Mori distinguishability decays as delta_B(r) ~ r^{-1} exp(-2 kappa r), at exactly twice the one-particle inverse correlation length kappa. The doubled rate is the lowest two-particle threshold of the even (:phi^2:) channel; the branch point of the lattice propagator fixes the algebraic prefactor. Smearing the filter with a form factor having a zero of order p at the branch point suppresses the tail by a further factor r^{-p}, for arbitrary fixed p. THREE LOAD-BEARING RESULTS, EACH WITH AN INDEPENDENT COMPUTATIONAL ROUTE. (1) An exact Hermitian formula for the restricted BKM susceptibility, chi_b(X_Q) = -sum_ij H_ij Ytilde_ij^2, in which positivity is manifest and eigenvalue degeneracies are handled by the divided-difference limit. Checked against a from-scratch Gaussian relative-entropy implementation by finite-differencing D(V + eps X || V), and against a Daleckii-Krein route at 2136 sampled points with median relative difference 4.3e-15, the worst-conditioned point re-checked at 100 digits. (2) Rigorous asymptotics obtained by collapsing the Fourier contour onto the branch cut and using an exact Beta representation. This gives a Poincare expansion to arbitrary order with a uniform Taylor-Lagrange remainder, and the source hierarchy for arbitrary fixed p rather than only the first few orders. The third-order coefficient a_3 = (80 coth kappa - 75 coth^3 kappa)/1024 follows from the same route. (3) A third-order accounting of the finite-window fit deficit across all 24 (m_L, b) cells of the lattice sweep, including the scalar closed form c_3 = (22 coth kappa - 21 coth^3 kappa)/128 at b = 1, which cross-checks the whole propagation chain. WHAT IS IN THE ARCHIVE. Seven production modules for the finite-lattice sweep; six independent verification scripts; 87 unit tests and 12 integration tests; the persisted raw sweep data for all 24 cells; and the implementation and mutation-audit records. Every number quoted in the paper is produced by a script included here. The full sweep takes about nine minutes but is not required: its output is included, with its SHA-256 recorded. ON THE AUDIT RECORDS. Two files on this record document failures rather than successes, deliberately. VERIFICATION_LOG.txt lists what was found wrong and fixed while assembling the package: ten stale equation cross-references, three proof gaps, a LaTeX typo that compiled without any warning, an arithmetic overstatement. EXTERNAL_AUDIT_LOG.md records four adversarial review rounds run by two independent systems given each other's output and instructed to disagree. One of those rounds produced a coverage result rather than a fix: deliberate mutation testing showed that two normalization constants were, at the time, verified only self-consistently by the test suite. The shipped code was and is correct, and the affected published numbers were reproduced independently from outside the codebase, but "the tests pass" was not by itself sufficient evidence for those two constants. The oracle tests in test_normalization_oracles.py close that gap by measuring both from the lattice operator directly. LICENSING. The two manuscript PDFs are All Rights Reserved. Within the archive, source code is MIT and data and documentation are CC BY 4.0; see LICENSE. AI-USE DISCLOSURE. Claude Sonnet 5 (Anthropic) was used for derivation, implementation, numerical verification, literature and citation checking, and drafting. Independent adversarial review used OpenAI ChatGPT (web) in Codex/Work Mode, reported by that system as Codex based on GPT-5.6 Sol High, across multiple rounds between approximately 20 July and 9 August 2026. A further adversarial audit, the branch-cut/Beta derivation through a_3 and c_3, and the mutation-testing round used Claude Opus 5 (Anthropic), 10-11 August 2026. Every issue raised by any reviewer was independently re-derived or re-computed before any change was accepted. The author reviewed and is responsible for all content, all code, and all claims.

•Jul 27, 2026•0 citations
Preprint. Not peer reviewed. The random quantum Ashkin-Teller chain with N Ising colours was solved by strong-disorder renormalization for every N except four, where internal states couple at second order and the standard decimation cannot discard them (Barghathi, Hrahsheh, Hoyos, Narayanan and Vojta, Phys. Scr. T165, 014040 (2015); arXiv:1404.2509, section IV.D). This record treats that case. An exact change of variables maps the 16-state site onto four-state Potts matter coupled to two binary charges. At zero transverse field and zero pair-bond coupling the charges are conserved and the matter is a q=4 Potts chain; at finite couplings their fate is the research problem. An equivalent transformation appears in the reference above and no priority is claimed for it. In the strong-field corner the retained site doublet supports an effective Ising chain for the four-colour product, with bond 3K^2/[4(g_i+g_j)] and field 4h. The leading composite coefficient is derived for general even N=2m, while for odd N the all-colour transition is forbidden at every order in K. The N=4 exception is therefore the first member of an even series rather than an isolated accident. Keeping the doublet mixing gives error scaling lambda^3 (measured 3.00087) against lambda^2 (2.00717) when it is dropped, so the mixing the published decimation could not discard is a leading-order term. DMRG on the full unprojected 16-state chain finds a composite-ordered regime: at K/g=0.20 the quartet endpoint correlation plateaus at 0.936034 from L=12 through L=24 while single-, pair- and triple-colour correlations stay short-ranged, within 5.34e-4 of the unfitted third-order prediction. Projection onto all four positive global parities changes it by 2.15e-7 while raising the central-cut entropy by log 2 to within 1.83e-7, confirming a symmetric cat state. At the self-dual point the entanglement profile matches an independently implemented q=4 Potts chain to 7.52e-6 nats. With finite charge-changing couplings h=J=1/epsilon the deviation from a matched q=4 Potts control is second order in 1/epsilon, separable from the DMRG residual, and its amplitude is length-independent across L=6,8,10 (5.03, 4.95, 4.91 x 10^-3), with the L=10 value predicted before it was computed. The mechanism is identified analytically: the second-order numerator is a constant plus twice the existing transverse term, so new operators can enter only through the matter-dependent energy denominator, and both mechanisms are local. The clean N=4 exception therefore resolves to q=4 Potts criticality with a fixed local perturbative correction. Review status. Sections 1-4 rest on results that passed this project's independent review process, three audit rounds included in the deposit. Section 5 has NOT been independently reviewed and is flagged as such in the manuscript and the README. A self-audit of the unreviewed stages is deposited; it is a starting point for a real review, not a substitute for one. A broad-disorder section was withdrawn before deposit. A 20-sample gap-scaling run gave a ln-gap width growth suggesting infinite-randomness behaviour; a 100-sample run under the same pre-registered rule returned INDETERMINATE, and the earlier value proved to be carried by two tail samples. Both runs, both pre-registrations and the analysis are deposited. The random critical point remains open. Not claimed: a thermodynamic phase boundary, scaling dimensions of the generated operators, anything about the random critical point, or priority for the variable transformation. Every stage's predictions were written before execution, every result file records the SHA-256 of its sources, and historical outputs are preserved unchanged. DMRG state checkpoints (about 93 MB) are excluded from the archive; each is reproducible from its recorded seed and settings, and its SHA-256 is stored in the result file it belongs to. AI assistance. Produced with substantial assistance from a generative AI system (Claude, Anthropic), and earlier stages with a second system (Codex, OpenAI), which also served as the independent reviewer between stages. The systems are not authors. The author defined the research direction, made the scientific decisions, and takes full responsibility for the content.
The N -color quantum Ashkin–Teller spin chain is a prototypical model for the study of strong-randomness phenomena at first-order and continuous quantum phase transitions. In this paper, we first review the existing strong-disorder renormalization group approaches to the random quantum Ashkin–Teller chain in the weak-coupling as well as the strong-coupling regimes. We then introduce a novel general variable transformation that unifies the treatment of the strong-coupling regime. This allows us to determine the phase diagram for all color numbers N , and the critical behavior for all . In the case of two colors, N = 2, a partially ordered product phase separates the paramagnetic and ferromagnetic phases in the strong-coupling regime. This phase is absent for all , i.e., there is a direct phase boundary between the paramagnetic and ferromagnetic phases. In agreement with the quantum version of the Aizenman–Wehr theorem, all phase transitions are continuous, even if their clean counterparts are of first order. We also discuss the various critical and multicritical points. They are all of infinite-randomness type, but depending on the coupling strength, they belong to different universality classes.
We investigate the zero-temperature quantum phase transitions of the disordered three-color quantum Ashkin-Teller spin chain by means of large-scale Monte Carlo simulations. We find that the first-order phase transitions of the clean system are rounded by the quenched disorder. For weak intercolor coupling, the resulting emergent quantum critical point between the paramagnetic phase and the magnetically ordered Baxter phase is of infinite-randomness type and belongs to the universality class of the random transverse-field Ising model, as predicted by recent strong-disorder renormalization group calculations. We also find evidence for unconventional critical behavior in the case of strong intercolor coupling, even though an unequivocal determination of the universality class is beyond our numerical capabilities. We compare our results to earlier simulations, and we discuss implications for the classification of phase transitions in the presence of disorder.
Abstract Strong-disorder renormalization group (SDRG), despite being a relatively simple real-space renormalization procedure, provides in principle exact results on the critical properties at the infinite-randomness fixed point of random quantum spin chains. Numerically, SDRG can be efficiently implemented as a renormalization of matrix product operators (MPO-RG). By considering larger blocks than SDRG, MPO-RG was recently used to compute non-critical quantities of finite chains that are inaccessible to SDRG. In this work, the accuracy of this approach is studied and two simple and fast improvements are proposed. The accuracy on the ground state energy is improved by a factor at least equal to four for the random Ising chain in a transverse field. Finally, the proposed algorithms are shown to yield Binder cumulants of the three-color random Ashkin–Teller chain that are compatible with a second-order phase transition while a first-order one is predicted by the original MPO-RG algorithm.
CORRECTION NOTICE (v5, 2026-09-06). The central result of v1-v4 is WITHDRAWN. This record has not been peer reviewed. Issued 2026-09-06 by the author (v5 of this record). This notice was added to the archived record; the manuscript itself is unaltered. This record has not been peer reviewed. What is wrong The force exponent reported here as alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 is an artifact of the fitting procedure, not a property of the data. The fit was unweighted least squares in linear space applied to a steeply falling profile, which places 95.8 percent of its objective on the single point at the shortest retained separation. Re-fitting the same data with nothing discarded, changing only the error model, gives 2.82 (relative-error weighting) or 2.89 (log-space regression). Across fifteen combinations of standard estimator and fit window the exponent spans 2.53 to 3.92, and the value published here is the largest of them. What the data show instead, and how firmly The retraction is certain. The replacement is not. On the open 24-site chain the same data give alpha = 2.6 +/- 0.2, where the interval is the spread of a plateau in the local logarithmic slope over six consecutive separations, not a statistical error (the bootstrap error on the published fit to the same data is 0.63); the plateau value was reproduced at 2.5921 by a separately written implementation run on the same recorded state (SIM-2026-073). This is a single geometry at a single size. On a 24-site periodic ring, analysed with chord distance as pre-registered, two probes that are both energy-density-like (Delta = 1) give 1.83 and 2.37 against a CFT two-point value of 2 (SIM-2026-074): one size, not converged, disagreeing with each other by 29 percent, and not attributable to a single operator channel. No corrected exponent is established. The exchange channel is an open question. Treat 2.6 +/- 0.2 as the provisional open-chain value, not as a result. Also withdrawn or voided alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24 sites) and alpha = 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16 sites, exact) from stress-tensor exchange. Was: headline result and its first corroboration. Now: withdrawn. Why: the same estimator artifact: both move in lockstep under it (3.92 to 2.56, 3.97 to 2.75 on dropping the contact point), because they share one observable, one fit window and one fitting routine. scalar exchange (alpha = 2) excluded. Was: stated as excluded at about 12 sigma. Now: withdrawn. Why: the 12 sigma used the covariance error 0.16; at the bootstrap error 0.63 computed before release the exclusion is about 2.2 sigma, and under any window starting at separation 3 the point estimate itself falls to about 2.56. alpha = 4 is universal; alpha = 4.00 at Ising, tricritical Ising and Potts. Was: confirmed at three classes. Now: withdrawn; the operator towers at all three classes stand. Why: the exponent was measured only at Ising and inherited by the other two; the towers are spectra, not forces. third independent evaluation alpha = 4.07 (chi = 3 MERA), and with it the statement that this was the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. Was: supporting evidence and a priority claim. Now: both withdrawn. Why: the profile changes sign inside its own fit window and cannot be a fixed-sign power law; the priority claim rests on that evaluation alone and was never gated against prior work. the discriminating test: stress tensor (Z_j Z_j+1) versus spin primary (X_j). Was: registered killer test. Now: void. Why: at the critical point these are one operator, related by exact Kramers-Wannier self-duality. Measured on the periodic ring: identical expectation values to 1e-15 and identical force profiles to 1e-13 at 14 sites, 2.4e-9 at 24 sites (SIM-2026-074). Open boundaries break the duality, which is why the open-chain run of this test (SIM-2026-073) showed a spurious difference between the two arms. The test compared the energy density to itself. Neither label was correct: Z_j Z_j+1 is the energy density, not the stress tensor; X_j is its dual, not the spin primary. transport time T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2 percent as a geometric prediction. Was: confirmed. Now: measurement stands (T = 2.239 at N = 16); geometric reading not established. Why: l_AdS cancels in the cited derivation, which also gives pi rather than the pi/2 the manuscript compares against; the chi = 3 estimate of l_AdS gives a 57 percent miss; the transport driver never applies a MERA. The true spin primary Z_j was never in the design, and the direct replacement test is blocked: Z_j is odd under the Z2 symmetry, so the energy-difference observable used throughout this work subtracts across symmetry sectors and is undefined for it. A replacement test using two Z2-even probes has been pre-registered (PREREGISTRATION-T.md, committed before its driver) and run; its result is deliberately not part of this correction and will appear in a later version. Not previously reported The published fit has a reduced chi-squared of 6.008 on 9 degrees of freedom, and a bootstrap standard deviation of 0.63 rather than the quoted 0.16. Both were computed before release and omitted. What is unaffected Of the claims in this record: the two-phase optimization method, the chi = 3 criticality threshold, the exact-diagonalization gates, the measured OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-epsilon = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact 1/2, and the conformal towers at all three classes. Not part of this record, mentioned only because they are sometimes read together with it: the later C_TTT stress-tensor self-coupling measurements (SIM-2026-067/068/069, dated after this record) and the matched off-critical ring control (SIM-2026-074) are unaffected by this correction and make no claim about the force exponent. How the error was found and what this record contains The error was found by the author's own internal adversarial audit, not by a reviewer; the journal submission it was found after is closed, and no review of this work has taken place. Files in this record: the full re-analysis (SIM-2026-072.json, driver, figure), the pre-registered chain test (SIM-2026-073.json) and ring test (SIM-2026-074.json) with both pre-registrations as committed before the runs, the runnable drivers with their shared module and the negative test suite for their validation gates, and the error register (ERRATA.md). Concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19660302 always resolves to the current version. The abstract of the original manuscript follows unchanged, for the record. Every claim in it about the force exponent should be read against the correction above. We report results from classical simulation of critical spin chains that establish quantitative physical content in the MERA-AdS correspondence. First, the interaction energy between boundary-primary excitations follows a power law F(dr) ~ dr^(-alpha) with three consistent evaluations yielding alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24q), 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16q), and 4.07 +/- 0.18 (16q chi=3 MERA), all consistent with stress-tensor exchange (alpha = 2*Delta_T = 4) and inconsistent with scalar exchange (alpha = 2); the exponent is explained by the Ising CFT fusion rule eps x eps = [1]. Because Delta_T = 2 is fixed by conformal symmetry in every unitary 2D CFT, alpha = 4 is universal: we confirm this at two further fixed points - the tricritical Ising model (c = 7/10), where a scale-invariant MERA recovers the full M(4,5) primary spectrum (Delta_sigma = 0.092, Delta_eps = 0.204, Delta_T = 1.999), and the three-state Potts model (c = 4/5), where a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers Delta_sigma = 0.134, Delta_eps = 0.805, Delta_T = 2.001 - giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes. Second, the holographic transport time matches the AdS_3 null geodesic prediction T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2% at N = 16 sites on a time-grid-converged measurement, with the residual shrinking from 2.8% at N = 12. Third, we introduce a two-phase optimization method (ALM + Z2 projection) for Z2-symmetric MERA ground states at 24 qubits. Fourth, extending the MERA bond dimension from chi=2 to chi=3 overcomes the expressibility barrier, achieving 0.15% energy error at 16 qubits and enabling the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. The OPE coefficient is also measured directly from the fixed-point tensors: C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact Ising value 1/2. A hardware path is designed for Quantinuum Helios (57 CNOTs, 0.57% logical error). Version 4 changes (relative to v3): Transport: N=16 residual restated as the time-grid-converged value of -1.21% (dt = 1e-3), with -2.78% at N=12 showing the finite-size trend; the 0.72% figure in v3 was an artifact of the dt = 0.05 integration grid and is now labeled as such. The N=24 transport point carries a new reliability caveat (double-lobe trace structure). The l_AdS comparison table is recomputed against the converged transport time (best fit 1.425, deviation 1.21%). Effective-mass derivation rewritten in a consistent AdS3 convention m^2 l^2 = Delta(Delta-2); m_eff = 0.693 = 1/l_AdS follows from Delta = 1 exactly. NEW: universality section extended to a third fixed point - a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers the three-state Potts (c = 4/5) tower, giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes (c = 1/2, 7/10, 4/5). NEW: the OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 measured directly from the fixed-point tensors, with C_sigma-sigma-sigma = 0 at machine precision as the Z2 structural check. Supplemental table row SIM-007 annotated (record lost; script preserved); data availability expanded; Zenodo DOI added to the front matter.
We study a model Hamiltonian consisting of NNN Ising models coupled pairwise through a four-spin interaction K4{K}_{4}K4​. When N=2N=2N=2 this model is the well-known Ashkin-Teller model which shows nonuniversal critical behavior in two dimensions in the neighborhood of K4=0{K}_{4}=0K4​=0. To see if this behavior persists for $N\ensuremath{\ne}2$ we perform a first-order-perturbation expansion around the decoupling point in two dimensions. As an aid in interpreting the results of this perturbation expansion we have determined the phase diagram of the system through mean-field theory and Monte Carlo studies in both two and three dimensions for N=3N=3N=3. The results show that N=2N=2N=2 is special because the coupling between Ising models is marginal over a range of values of K4{K}_{4}K4​. We discuss the effect of the coupling K4{K}_{4}K4​ for $N\ensuremath{\ne}2$.
This record contains the preprint, its Supplemental Material, and the complete computational package behind them. VERSION 2 NOTE. This version corrects the physical interpretation of the decay rate. No previously reported scientific result, coefficient, numerical value, or computational formula was altered, and the code archive is carried over unchanged from v1. Eq. (4) was algebraically expanded to state kappa explicitly; an explanatory section, numbered S0 so as to leave the version-1 numbering intact, was added to the Supplemental Material; and the vertical range of Fig. 2 was rescaled to match its data, with no plotted value changed. On a spatial lattice the inverse equal-time correlation length kappa and the Hamiltonian energy gap m_L are distinct quantities, coinciding only in the continuum limit. Version 1 described 2 kappa as a two-particle spectral threshold, which reads as a statement about the energy spectrum; the two-particle energy threshold is 2 m_L. The result concerns the spatial decay of an equal-time correlator and is governed throughout by kappa. RESULT. For a massive harmonic chain, a local Gaussian filter applied at one site changes the reduced state of a distant block of b sites by an amount whose Bogoliubov-Kubo-Mori distinguishability decays as delta_B(r) ~ r^{-1} exp(-2 kappa r), at exactly twice the one-particle inverse equal-time correlation length kappa = 2 arcsinh(m_L/2) = arccosh(1 + m_L^2/2). The doubled rate is the lowest two-particle SPATIAL exponent of the even (:phi^2:) channel: the equal-time :phi^2: correlator is the square of the one-particle propagator, so its nearest complex-momentum singularity sits at twice the one-particle branch point. On the lattice kappa is distinct from the energy gap m_L = min_k omega(k), from which it differs at third order in the mass; the sweep resolves the difference directly, the static-source benchmark returning lambda_A/kappa = 1.00000000 at all six masses while lambda_A/m_L falls to 0.99496 at m_L = 0.35. The same branch point fixes the algebraic prefactor. Smearing the filter with a form factor having a zero of order p at the branch point suppresses the one-particle kernel amplitude by r^{-p}; because the covariance tangent is quadratic in that kernel, the BKM distinguishability acquires an additional factor r^{-2p}, giving delta_B^(p)(r) ~ r^{-(2p+1)} exp(-2 kappa r) for arbitrary fixed p. THREE LOAD-BEARING RESULTS, EACH WITH AN INDEPENDENT COMPUTATIONAL ROUTE. (1) An exact Hermitian formula for the restricted BKM susceptibility, chi_b(X_Q) = -sum_ij H_ij Ytilde_ij^2, in which positivity is manifest and eigenvalue degeneracies are handled by the divided-difference limit. Checked against a from-scratch Gaussian relative-entropy implementation by finite-differencing D(V + eps X || V), and against a Daleckii-Krein route at 2136 sampled points with median relative difference 4.3e-15, the worst-conditioned point re-checked at 100 digits. (2) Rigorous asymptotics obtained by collapsing the Fourier contour onto the branch cut and using an exact Beta representation. This gives a Poincare expansion to arbitrary order with a uniform Taylor-Lagrange remainder, and the source hierarchy for arbitrary fixed p rather than only the first few orders. The third-order coefficient a_3 = (80 coth kappa - 75 coth^3 kappa)/1024 follows from the same route. (3) A 24-cell finite-lattice sweep and an independent arbitrary-precision infinite-chain calculation, the latter free of finite-size and periodic-image artifacts, confirming the coefficients through third order across all cells. -------------------------------------------------------------- This record contains the preprint, its Supplemental Material, and the complete computational package behind them. VERSION 1 NOTE RESULT. For a massive harmonic chain, a local Gaussian filter applied at one site changes the reduced state of a distant block of b sites by an amount whose Bogoliubov-Kubo-Mori distinguishability decays as delta_B(r) ~ r^{-1} exp(-2 kappa r), at exactly twice the one-particle inverse correlation length kappa. The doubled rate is the lowest two-particle threshold of the even (:phi^2:) channel; the branch point of the lattice propagator fixes the algebraic prefactor. Smearing the filter with a form factor having a zero of order p at the branch point suppresses the tail by a further factor r^{-p}, for arbitrary fixed p. THREE LOAD-BEARING RESULTS, EACH WITH AN INDEPENDENT COMPUTATIONAL ROUTE. (1) An exact Hermitian formula for the restricted BKM susceptibility, chi_b(X_Q) = -sum_ij H_ij Ytilde_ij^2, in which positivity is manifest and eigenvalue degeneracies are handled by the divided-difference limit. Checked against a from-scratch Gaussian relative-entropy implementation by finite-differencing D(V + eps X || V), and against a Daleckii-Krein route at 2136 sampled points with median relative difference 4.3e-15, the worst-conditioned point re-checked at 100 digits. (2) Rigorous asymptotics obtained by collapsing the Fourier contour onto the branch cut and using an exact Beta representation. This gives a Poincare expansion to arbitrary order with a uniform Taylor-Lagrange remainder, and the source hierarchy for arbitrary fixed p rather than only the first few orders. The third-order coefficient a_3 = (80 coth kappa - 75 coth^3 kappa)/1024 follows from the same route. (3) A third-order accounting of the finite-window fit deficit across all 24 (m_L, b) cells of the lattice sweep, including the scalar closed form c_3 = (22 coth kappa - 21 coth^3 kappa)/128 at b = 1, which cross-checks the whole propagation chain. WHAT IS IN THE ARCHIVE. Seven production modules for the finite-lattice sweep; six independent verification scripts; 87 unit tests and 12 integration tests; the persisted raw sweep data for all 24 cells; and the implementation and mutation-audit records. Every number quoted in the paper is produced by a script included here. The full sweep takes about nine minutes but is not required: its output is included, with its SHA-256 recorded. ON THE AUDIT RECORDS. Two files on this record document failures rather than successes, deliberately. VERIFICATION_LOG.txt lists what was found wrong and fixed while assembling the package: ten stale equation cross-references, three proof gaps, a LaTeX typo that compiled without any warning, an arithmetic overstatement. EXTERNAL_AUDIT_LOG.md records four adversarial review rounds run by two independent systems given each other's output and instructed to disagree. One of those rounds produced a coverage result rather than a fix: deliberate mutation testing showed that two normalization constants were, at the time, verified only self-consistently by the test suite. The shipped code was and is correct, and the affected published numbers were reproduced independently from outside the codebase, but "the tests pass" was not by itself sufficient evidence for those two constants. The oracle tests in test_normalization_oracles.py close that gap by measuring both from the lattice operator directly. LICENSING. The two manuscript PDFs are All Rights Reserved. Within the archive, source code is MIT and data and documentation are CC BY 4.0; see LICENSE. AI-USE DISCLOSURE. Claude Sonnet 5 (Anthropic) was used for derivation, implementation, numerical verification, literature and citation checking, and drafting. Independent adversarial review used OpenAI ChatGPT (web) in Codex/Work Mode, reported by that system as Codex based on GPT-5.6 Sol High, across multiple rounds between approximately 20 July and 9 August 2026. A further adversarial audit, the branch-cut/Beta derivation through a_3 and c_3, and the mutation-testing round used Claude Opus 5 (Anthropic), 10-11 August 2026. Every issue raised by any reviewer was independently re-derived or re-computed before any change was accepted. The author reviewed and is responsible for all content, all code, and all claims.