How many photon-number levels must a finite model retain to approximate Wigner-positive light reliably? This article gives both a construction that preserves Wigner positivity and the mean-energy budget, and a necessary cutoff that applies even to more general finite-support models. For any fixed mean total photon budget \(E>0\), every sufficiently large cutoff \(L\) admits a Wigner-positive source \(\rho_L\) of energy exactly \(E\) such that \[\inf_{\tau=\Pi_L\tau\Pi_L}\|\rho_L-\tau\|_1\ge c_E(L+1)^{-5/6},\qquad \Pi_L=\mathbf1_{\{N\le L\}}.\] The infimum is over all density operators supported in this fixed total-photon subspace, with arbitrary coherences and correlations between modes. The approximant need not be Wigner positive or satisfy the energy cap. The same source obstructs every such approximant at a given cutoff. Thus a uniform guarantee with full trace-norm error at most \(\varepsilon\) requires \[L=\Omega_E(\varepsilon^{-6/5})\qquad(\varepsilon\downarrow0).\] The mechanism is coherence between retained low photon numbers and an omitted high-photon shell. A bounded polar-decomposition witness detects this coherence while vanishing on every cutoff-supported state. The physical source construction retains its infinite Fock tails and pays its actual mean energy; it permits rare high-energy branches. Conversely, for \(m\) finite modes, the article constructs Wigner-positive approximants under the same energy cap with a sufficient cutoff \[L=O\!\left((E+1)\varepsilon^{-2}\left[m+\ln\frac{E+2}{\varepsilon}\right]\right).\] The necessary and sufficient orders are distinct. Both concern a fixed oscillator basis and total-photon cutoff, rather than an arbitrary choice of finite-rank subspace. At zero energy, the vacuum already gives an exact finite model. The positivity-preserving construction also yields finite semidefinite programmes with certified errors for bounded-observable optimisation and, at fixed mode count and energy, controlled approximations to Wigner entropy minima. This updated 21-page article includes the necessary-cutoff theorem, its complete proof, the physical source construction, two figures and the earlier finite-model results.
How many photon-number levels must a finite model retain to approximate Wigner-positive light reliably? This article gives both a construction that preserves Wigner positivity and the mean-energy budget, and a necessary cutoff that applies even to more general finite-support models. For any fixed mean total photon budget (E>0), every sufficiently large cutoff (L) admits a Wigner-positive source (\rho_L) of energy exactly (E) such that [\inf_{\tau=\Pi_L\tau\Pi_L}|\rho_L-\tau|1\ge c_E(L+1)^{-5/6},\qquad \Pi_L=\mathbf1{{N\le L}}.] The infimum is over all density operators supported in this fixed total-photon subspace, with arbitrary coherences and correlations between modes. The approximant need not be Wigner positive or satisfy the energy cap. The same source obstructs every such approximant at a given cutoff. Thus a uniform guarantee with full trace-norm error at most (\varepsilon) requires [L=\Omega_E(\varepsilon^{-6/5})\qquad(\varepsilon\downarrow0).] The mechanism is coherence between retained low photon numbers and an omitted high-photon shell. A bounded polar-decomposition witness detects this coherence while vanishing on every cutoff-supported state. The physical source construction retains its infinite Fock tails and pays its actual mean energy; it permits rare high-energy branches. Conversely, for (m) finite modes, the article constructs Wigner-positive approximants under the same energy cap with a sufficient cutoff [L=O!\left((E+1)\varepsilon^{-2}\left[m+\ln\frac{E+2}{\varepsilon}\right]\right).] The necessary and sufficient orders are distinct. Both concern a fixed oscillator basis and total-photon cutoff, rather than an arbitrary choice of finite-rank subspace. At zero energy, the vacuum already gives an exact finite model. The positivity-preserving construction also yields finite semidefinite programmes with certified errors for bounded-observable optimisation and, at fixed mode count and energy, controlled approximations to Wigner entropy minima. This updated 21-page article includes the necessary-cutoff theorem, its complete proof, the physical source construction, two figures and the earlier finite-model results.
How much high-photon quantum coherence is controlled by a nonnegative phase-space distribution? This article gives quantitative guarantees for approximating an optical state by a finite photon-number block, and constructs physical states showing why the guarantee cannot be inferred from mean energy or Wigner positivity alone at the strength available for a Gaussian-mixture source. Source classes and scope. The comparison concerns one optical mode with [Q,P]=i, mean photon number at most E>0, and a known parity centre. The full class WE consists of normal Wigner-positive states at the exact vacuum min-entropy endpoint, equivalently states supported on the even photon sector in that frame. The subclass GE consists of actual probability mixtures of centred pure squeezed vacua. Mixture labels are unavailable, component energies may be arbitrarily large, and their true average energy is charged. Infinite photon tails are retained. A hierarchy of coherent-tail guarantees. Let PL project onto photon numbers at most L, and define the cutoff error by eL(ρ)=21∥ρ−PLρPL∥1. This quantity includes both discarded photon population and coherence across the cutoff. A mean-energy constraint alone gives the standard OE(L−1/2) guarantee. At the exact Wigner endpoint, the article proves supρ∈WEeL(ρ)≤CE(L+1)−3/4,supρ∈GEeL(ρ)≤L+14E,L≥2. The stronger endpoint bound combines operator positivity and Wigner positivity on the same density kernel, followed by a controlled conversion to trace norm. It requires only mean energy, without a uniform second photon moment. Physical coherence beyond the Gaussian-mixture bound. A family τd∈WE has exact energy E, covariance (E+1/2)I, strictly positive Wigner functions and nonzero population at every even photon number. For cutoffs Ld=Θ(d3), eLd(τd)≥cEd−5/2,(Ld+1)eLd(τd)⟶∞. Thus the Gaussian-mixture L−1 law fails uniformly on the full endpoint class. The construction preserves coherence through an actual optical partial trace and pays its physical energy cost. Positive phase mixing further yields distinct states with identical complete photon statistics and covariance but nearly indistinguishable bounded optical responses. The rare bright branches obey the prescribed mean-energy budget; no efficient experimental preparation protocol or uniform branch-energy bound is assumed. Consequences for a specified measurement system. Each independent copy is measured by bounded centred squeezing followed by a vacuum/nonvacuum binary test. At fixed energy, squeezing range and confidence, let nX(δ) be the minimum worst-case number of copies for trace-distance accuracy δ over source class X. As δ↓0, the bounds are lognGE(δ)=Θ(δ−1),cδ−6/5≤lognWE(δ)≤Cδ−4/3. These are measurement-restricted reconstruction costs. The lower bounds allow adaptive randomized settings. The upper bounds use finite designs and estimates in the original source class, with the energy budget respected for every record; they establish statistical existence rather than an efficient catalogue-generation algorithm. The full-class exponents remain distinct lower and upper bounds. The article also characterizes infinite-order Wigner entropy equality by displaced even-parity support and corrects the pure-Gaussian-only equality clause at infinite order in Dias and Prata (2023). The 27-page integrated article includes the complete proofs, figures and references.
Loss can restore the vacuum entropy bound without erasing non-Gaussian structure. This paper determines when an entropy statement justifies a coherent-state approximation, when non-Gaussian structure survives optical loss, and what mode and source-request budgets are needed to use that structure. The results give quantum-optics researchers separate criteria for entropy recovery, state approximation, Gaussian concentration and conversion to a specified output. Version 1.5 — revised 10 October 2026. The 96-page PDF contains the main article, Methods, Supplementary Information and references. This revision connects the exact loss boundary to a mode-uniform near-equality certificate, finite-data validation, a conversion-cost lower bound for the same thermally repaired source, and an exact equal-entropy comparison of sources with different conversion-cost exponents. The central figures are updated accordingly. 1. Near-vacuum states can have an unbounded entropy deficit Write νm for the m-mode vacuum and define Δα,m(ρ)=Hα(Wνm)−Hα(Wρ), using natural logarithms; H1 is Shannon entropy. Positive deficit means entropy below vacuum. We construct physical Wigner-positive states satisfying, simultaneously, Em=Tr(Nmρm)→0,21∥ρm−νm∥1→0,dFm(ρm)→0,Δ1,m(ρm)→+∞. Here Fm is the trace-norm-closed convex hull of Gaussian states and dFm uses half the trace norm. Thus proximity to the entire Gaussian model does not control Wigner entropy uniformly in mode number. Independent weak modes amplify a one-mode entropy effect while their total excitation vanishes. For the same sequence, half loss instead gives −Em≤Δ1,m(L1/2⊗mρm)≤0, so the entropy difference from vacuum tends to zero. 2. The exact pure-loss recovery boundary For Wigner-positive inputs, intensity transmissivity η and any fixed positive total input-energy budget E, the sharp threshold is ηc(α)={1/2,α/2,0<α≤1,1<α<2. With Pm,E={ρ:Wρ≥0,Tr(Nmρ)≤E}, supm≥1supρ∈Pm,EΔα,m(Lη⊗mρ)={0,+∞,η≤ηc(α),η>ηc(α). The recovery statement includes the boundary itself and is independent of mode number. Half loss also restores vacuum majorization for arbitrary density operators. For α≥2, established Wigner-norm bounds give the vacuum entropy bound at every transmissivity for Wigner-positive outputs. These statements distinguish a universal guarantee from the earlier sign crossing that a particular source may exhibit. 3. Near equality gives a certificate for the entire input For an arbitrary input ρ, define the half-loss output Shannon excess s(ρ)=h(WL1/2⊗mρ)−m(1+lnπ)≥0. The half-loss identity identifies this quantity with the input's total Wehrl entropy excess. Applying mode-uniform Wehrl stability yields infa∥ρ−∣a⟩⟨a∣∥12≤ln264s(ρ). The bound controls the full input state, with no energy or photon-support restriction. One coherent reference then controls every subsequent quantum channel and every unconditional measurement event. In particular, an event-probability error at most ϵ is guaranteed by s≤(ln2)ϵ2/16. Conversely, a surviving output Gaussian-hull gap enforces s(ρ)≥16ln2dFm(L1/2⊗mρ)2. Recovery of the inequality and proximity to equality therefore support different physical inferences: the former permits residual non-Gaussian structure, while the latter certifies a coherent-state approximation. 4. Surviving structure has mode and conversion costs A thermally repaired vacuum–three-photon source with per-mode occupation c/m has total input energy tending to 3c. Along the recovery boundary, its attenuated state obeys liminfm→∞dFm(ρm,ηc)≥cηc3exp{−c[1−(1−ηc)3]}>0. At half transmission this lower bound is g(c)=(c/8)e−7c/8. Starting from one complete block, Gaussian processing requires Θ(m) output modes to retain any fixed positive gap below this bound at success probability at least a fixed p0>0. Gaussian ancillary states, adaptive Gaussian measurements, feedback, discarding and postselection are included. A distinct task requests fresh independent blocks of this same half-loss source to produce the one-mode target τ∗=(18∣0⟩⟨0∣+6∣1⟩⟨1∣+∣2⟩⟨2∣)/25 within half trace distance 10−6. Let Cm be the infimum of expected complete-block requests divided by success probability, including all failed requests. For fixed 0<c≤1, every achieving Gaussian protocol obeys the asymptotic lower bound logCm≥1281(m/c)1/3−logm−O(1). This is a source-request lower bound; the optimal achievable cost for this source remains undetermined. The proof evaluates a curvature-controlled input certificate for the actual thermally repaired state and applies the Gaussian conversion theorem of the companion paper cited below. 5. Exactly equal entropy does not fix conversion cost For two separate two-mode quartic source families, their mixture probabilities can be adjusted so that their half-loss Shannon entropies are exactly equal. Under a common target, tolerance and failure-inclusive accounting, the inherited matching conversion laws become h(WωA)=h(WωB)=2(1+lnπ)+s,logCA(s)=Θ(s−1/3),logCB(s)=Θ(s−1/2). The target tolerance is held fixed in these asymptotics. The delivered energies after entropy matching satisfy EA,EB∼s/2. At exactly equal energy, the two excesses instead share si(E)=2E−(35/8)E2+O(E3) and differ by sA(E)−sB(E)=15E3+O(E4). Entropy alone therefore cannot select the cheaper source for a fixed output task. 6. Finite data and finite mode budgets Under a declared displaced-input photon-tail bound Tr[N1N>Kσa]≤τK, trusted half loss and all-mode on/off detection with efficiency at least ξmin, the click probability q gives s(σ)≤AKq+τK,AK=1−(1−ξmin/2)KK. A one-sided binomial bound turns this into an entropy confidence certificate. An explicit undisplaced four-photon-cutoff example uses K=4, τK=0, ξ=0.8 and N=3,517,336 independent validation blocks, accepting at most 41 clicks, to certify unconditional event error at most 0.05 with false-acceptance probability at most 0.001 and missed acceptance at most 0.001 on the stated low-click alternative class. All vacuum results count; training, calibration and source heralding are separate costs. When coherent-state approximation alone is the task, the same click measurement supplies a stronger direct fidelity test. The paper also gives all-input finite-budget exclusions above the loss-recovery line. For example, at E=1, α=1.9, η=0.9505 and m=105, the certified bound Δα<0.06942 rules out a target deficit of 0.1 nat. A separate finite single-mode preparation model predicts positive Shannon deficit near η=0.97, negative deficit near η=0.85, and a Gaussian-hull witness above 4.4×10−3 at half transmission, with explicit preparation, measurement-error and raw-trial budgets in the PDF. 7. Dimensional scales, a strict entropy floor and ORCS Near order two, put α=2−δ and L=ln(1/δ). For the maximum deficit Dm,E at fixed total energy, Dm,E(2−δ)=Θm,E(δ/L)for fixed m,Th(δ,E)=ΘE,h(L/δ), where Th is the first mode number allowing a fixed positive deficit h. Beyond a sufficiently large fixed multiple of L/δ, Dm,E(2−δ)=ΘE(mδ). The manuscript separates proved sufficient fronts from necessary exit bounds; the sharp first-crossing coefficient remains open. At every fixed mode number, an energy-unrestricted strict Shannon floor also holds: h(Wρ)≥mln(2π)+εm with εm>0 for all Wigner-positive states. The ordering-resolved coherence spectrum (ORCS) supplies an exact single-mode loss coordinate. With Cr,k denoting the ordering-weighted norm of photon-number-difference block k, Cr,k(Lηρ)=CTη(r),k(ρ),Tη(r)=1−η1−r. For vacuum–n-photon coherence and 1<α<2, C1−α/2(Lη∣n⟩⟨0∣)=(α2η)n. This formula exposes the high-order coherence mechanism at the loss threshold; the universal recovery result is proved through the full nonlinear Wigner-norm inequality. Related papers and history The counterexample paper Wigner entropy below vacuum: physical counterexamples and stability limits expands arXiv:2609.13312v1, submitted on 10 September 2026. This stability paper develops the dimensional, loss-dependent and operational consequences. Its state-approximation and conversion interfaces use the companion results From phase-space entropy to coherent-state error: mode-uniform Rényi–Wehrl stability and Phase records control the conversion cost of non-Gaussian light. The mode-retention comparison connects to Limits to Gaussian concentration of non-Gaussian light.
Can a finite-rank quantum state approximate a given optical state while reproducing an entire continuous measurement record and its original mean energy exactly? This paper provides a constructive affirmative answer, with quantitative rank, trace-distance and entropy control. The main result concerns one oscillator A=L2(R), with [Q,P]=i and photon operator N=(Q2+P2−1)/2, coupled to a finite memory B=Cb. The input is any normal state ρAB with mean photons E=Tr(NρA)<∞. Its complete position–memory record Gρ(q) retains both the position probability and the conditional quantum state of the memory. For every integer L≥0 and 0<a≤1, there is a state ω satisfying Gω=Gρ,Tr(NωA)=E,rankω≤b(L+2),21∥ρ−ω∥1≤L+1E+a. Thus the approximants converge inside the same exact-record, exact-energy constraint set. A purification needs a new register of dimension at most b(L+2); retaining both the original memory and this register costs total dimension at most b2(L+2). The construction preserves a positive head of the original state and replaces its actual positive tail. If the head has rank at most r and the tail mass is p, at most b replacement vectors suffice, giving rank at most r+b and half trace-distance error at most p before energy restoration. A position-dependent unitary with ∥U−I∥≤a then restores the exact energy without changing rank, spectrum or the measured record. With natural logarithms, ∣S(ρ)−S(ω)∣≤h2(p)+p[g(E/p)+logb], where h2 is binary entropy, g(x)=(1+x)log(1+x)−xlogx, and the zero-tail case is understood continuously. The same estimate controls quantum conditional entropy. Horizontal matrix purification removes kinetic overhead while handling zeros, changes of rank and the full real line. Scalar position distributions admit the corresponding construction for any fixed finite number of modes. The approximation is chosen from the known source, and finite rank refers to full wavefunctions rather than finite photon support. The integrated 12-page PDF contains two figures, complete proofs, and attribution of the classical kinetic, purification and phase identities used.
How many uses of an optical device are needed to certify that it preserves quantum information? This article determines the optimal asymptotic number of coherent-light probes under an average photon budget. Matching upper and lower bounds show that a single optical mode carries an unavoidable logarithmic cost, while every fixed higher mode number follows a different power law. Certification task and resource accounting. The device is an arbitrary normal, memoryless bosonic quantum channel. The task distinguishes the identity from channels at least ε away in the energy-constrained diamond norm, defined using the full trace norm and a signal-energy budget Es. This guarantee includes inputs entangled with an unrestricted reference system. The physical probes are fresh coherent states with classically chosen amplitudes. Adaptive choices, retained quantum outputs and a final joint measurement are allowed. Every device call, including a vacuum pulse, is counted, and the actual illumination obeys ∑t=1TEK∥αt∥2≤TEp under every channel in the testing promise. The probe budget Ep is distinct from the signal budget Es defining the certification guarantee. Optimal mean-energy query laws. For fixed positive Es,Ep, fixed finite mode number m, and both testing errors at most δ, the minimax number of calls satisfies Tmean(1)(ε,δ)=ΘEs,Ep(ε−4logε1logδ1),Tmean(m)(ε,δ)=Θm,Es,Ep(ε−(2m+2)logδ1),m≥2. The bounds hold for sufficiently small ε, uniformly over 0<δ≤1/4. Independent probes drawn from a physical positive multiscale source, followed by individual binary target tests, attain these orders. The matching converse covers adaptive coherent-probe protocols with quantum output memory. Thus those additional processing capabilities do not improve the asymptotic order within the stated preparation model. The result specifies matching scaling laws, rather than exact finite-query counts or optimal numerical constants. Why one mode has an extra logarithm. Rare high-photon coherences can strongly affect an energy-bounded quantum input while leaving only a weak signature on coherent probes. The proof retains this interference through a positive coherent-frame Green kernel. Its spectral sum grows as tlogt for one mode and as tm for fixed m≥2. A complementary family of physical channels shows that the single-mode logarithm is necessary, rather than an artifact of the reconstruction bound. What source brightness changes. The optimal mean-only laws contrast with prescribed independent Gaussian modulation, for which logTG=Θ(ε−2) at fixed confidence. A fixed brightness cap gives logTcap=Θ(ε−2log(1/ε)). The article also establishes matching logarithmic orders under stretched-exponential brightness constraints and develops the conversion from average coherent-probe error to thermal Choi-state and energy-constrained worst-input guarantees. These are worst-case certification limits for the specified coherent-probe access model. The channel class retains infinite photon tails and imposes no output-energy bound. This updated, integrated 37-page article contains the main results, two figure groups, complete proofs and references.
How much quantum memory is needed to retain the contributions of rare photon events to a measurement record? This paper determines the memory scales required to approach the best heterodyne conditional entropy when the total optical energy tends to zero. Its resource laws distinguish precisions for which counting photon configurations suffices from critical precisions at which energy-calibrated entropy corrections determine additional memory costs. Full preparation model and reference value. The optical system has m bosonic modes, total mean photon number at most E, and an entire accessible quantum side system B of dimension at most D, including retained preparation labels. The optical source and its correlations with the memory are optimized over all normal mixed states; arbitrary coherences and infinite photon tails are allowed. With natural logarithms and heterodyne measure dμ=π−md2mz, define Vm,D(E)=minρABHμ(Z∣B),Hμ(Z∣B)=hμ(Z)−χ(Z:B). Here Z is the heterodyne outcome and χ is Holevo information. The unlimited-memory optimum at the same energy is Bm(E)=m−Eln(1+m/E),Dmin(m,E,ε)=min{D:Vm,D(E)−Bm(E)≤ε}. The tolerance ε is a total conditional-entropy excess in nats. It is not a measurement-error probability. Classical side information satisfies Hμ(Z∣Y)≥m; entangled quantum side information can go below this benchmark. The resource D is a Hilbert-space dimension, corresponding to ⌈log2D⌉ qubits. Precision selects a photon-number hierarchy. Along arbitrary joint limits m→∞, E→0, with no prescribed relation between E and 1/m, Eε→c>0⟹Dmin∼e−cm. For every fixed integer K≥2, EKε→c∈(0,1/K!)⟹Dmin∼(1−K!c)K!mK. Although higher-photon events become rarer, they occupy increasingly many orthogonal mode configurations. Resolving their entropy contribution therefore requires a larger memory dimension. In qubits, the fixed-K law is Klog2m+O(1). Critical precisions resolve costs beyond sector counting. At the exact tolerance E2/2, the complete vacuum–one-photon head is not sufficient at leading dimension: Dmin(m,E,E2/2)=m+1+(1+o(1))(2m+6Em2). The error is relative to the additional dimension in parentheses. Both terms come from the entropy of the mean-calibrated finite head, together with an all-state output-entropy comparison. At the next critical tolerance E3/6, the paper determines an added-to-removed-level transition near the complete two-photon head (2m+2), including the boundary near mE=4 and precisely qualified integer conclusions. An exact finite-energy source. For every finite m, 2≤D≤m+1, and 0<E≤10−4, let r=D−1 and choose orthonormal one-photon modes u1,…,ur. The preparation ∣Ψ⟩=1−E∣0⟩A∣0⟩B+E/r∑j=1r∣uj⟩A∣j⟩B attains the original global minimum over the full preparation class. Its vacuum–one-photon support is a conclusion of the optimization, rather than an imposed photon cutoff. The paper also characterizes exact small-energy optima for every fixed complete photon head. A record-reconstruction interpretation with explicit resource accounting. A common finite heterodyne digitizer, including a genuine overflow symbol, approximates the conditional entropy uniformly over all legal preparations. For independent repetitions of a known preparation, classical–quantum Slepian–Wolf coding identifies the asymptotic reconstruction rate with H(X∣B). The uniform comparison transfers the hierarchy to the excess optimized communication rate relative to unlimited finite memory using the same digitizer. Preserving the first critical formula requires digitization error ξ=o(E2/m+E3); the corresponding error scales for the separated second-critical regimes are also given. The decoder may act collectively after receiving the classical message. For n independent preparations, the supplied side-system dimension is at most Dn and total mean optical energy is at most nE. This is a supplied-memory resource law, not an optimization over arbitrary correlated block preparations, a minimum Schumacher-compressed storage rate, or a bound on peak decoder workspace. Coding limits are taken at fixed finite parameters before the low-energy, growing-mode limit. The work develops the low-photon, growing-mode regime of the preparation problem studied in Optimal entanglement weights for heterodyne uncertainty with finite quantum memory (doi:10.5281/zenodo.23647071). The integrated 29-page paper contains the complete proofs, three figures and two tables.
Positive Wigner functions can have less Shannon entropy than the vacuum, even arbitrarily close to the vacuum state. We construct physical counterexamples and identify the competition that controls their entropy: the relative entropy to the vacuum phase-space density can exceed twice the mean photon number. A two-level family exhibits a finite window in which coherence lowers entropy while preserving global Wigner positivity. A complementary construction repairs a remote negative tail with an exponentially small thermal admixture; an explicit mixing weight of 2×10−21 preserves a rigorously established entropy decrease. Optimisation over all one-mode Wigner-nonnegative states gives the sharp low-energy scale Eγ/[ln(1/E)]β, with γ≃0.7412 and β≃0.5861. Because γ<1, tensor products can have vanishing total energy and trace distance from vacuum while their entropy deficit diverges. We derive the exact half-transmission threshold for universal Shannon-entropy recovery and connect it to companion results showing residual non-Gaussian structure. The counterexamples reveal distinct controls on entropy: coherence sets the local descent, mode number amplifies it, and loss restores the vacuum bound.