Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum correlations and exceptional points in superconducting processors: collective measurements, generative learning, and dynamical control

Patrycja Tulewicz

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Quantum systems are inherently linear at the level of their evolution equations, yet the properties that make them useful for computation, communication, and sensing are profoundly nonlinear.Entanglement cannot be captured by any single linear observable; generating a state with prescribed quantum correlations requires navigating a highly non-convex optimization landscape; and the dynamics of open quantum systems can develop singularities in parameter space that have no counterpart in ordinary Hermitian physics.This dissertation addresses all three aspects of this nonlinearity on current superconducting quantum hardware: how to measure it efficiently, how to generate it deliberately, and how to exploit it as a resource rather than treat it as an obstacle.The characterization problem is addressed in Chapter 2 through a family of multicopy measurement protocols that operate on pairs or small sets of identically prepared state copies rather than on a single copy at a time.This approach reduces the number of measurement settings required to estimate entanglement from the exponential cost of full quantum state tomography, reducing the exponent base from 4 n to 2 n in the number of qubits, with a verified 67% reduction in overhead for two-qubit systems on IBM Quantum hardware.A central result of this chapter is the identification of partial-transpose moments as chirality-chirality correlators: the difference between partial-transpose and purity moments encodes the scalar spin chirality, a quantity familiar from condensed-matter physics as the order parameter of chiral spin liquids.This connection provides a physical interpretation for an otherwise abstract algebraic operation, and it extends naturally to bound entanglement detection through the realignment non-Hermiticity gap.Using the same controlled-SWAP circuit infrastructure, a multi-channel spectral classifier detects bound entanglement across all three known families of 3 × 3 positive-partial-transpose entangled states, including states invisible to any single realignment criterion, achieving 99.6% cross-validated recall at zero false positives in simulation and 94% recall on ibm_fez hardware.This is the first family-agnostic demonstration of bound entanglement detection on a gate-based superconducting processor.Gröbner basis decision trees provide an additional route to negativity estimation, converting spectral moments into entanglement values adaptively and achieving a five-to sevenfold reduction in measurement settings relative to full tomography.

Related papers

Spin chirality across quantum state copies detects hidden entanglement

Patrycja Tulewicz, Karol Bartkiewicz, Franco Nori

Entanglement can hide in two fundamentally different ways. First, multi-copy correlations can carry information that no single-copy measurement on an unknown state is able to access. Second, bound entangled states possess a positive partial transpose, which makes them invisible to the Peres-Horodecki criterion and all moment inequalities that depend on it. Here we show that the moment difference between the partial transpose and purity decomposes exactly as a chirality-chirality correlator, where the relevant operator is the scalar spin chirality -- the same quantity that governs chiral spin liquids and the topological Hall effect. This decomposition identifies the specific physical structure that multi-copy entanglement detection probes. Using the same controlled-SWAP circuits, we develop a multi-channel spectral classifier for bound entanglement. The classifier combines realignment spectral features with chirality corrections and achieves 99.9% recall at zero false positives across all three known 3x3 bound entangled families, compared with ~40% for the CCNR criterion alone. We also introduce a marginal-noise construction that produces CCNR-invisible bound entangled states, which the classifier detects but which remain invisible to all single-parameter criteria. We validate our approach experimentally on three IBM Quantum processors and demonstrate negativity reconstruction with mean errors of 0.002-0.027, chirality detection for pure and mixed entangled states, and bound entanglement detection across two structurally distinct families (Horodecki and chessboard) on a single gate-based superconducting processor.

quant-pharXiv:2605.14515•May 15, 2026•0 citations

New Perspectives on Quantum Technologies: Progress on Quantum Sensing and Quantum Computation

R. Cappuccio

This dissertation reports three studies in quantum technologies, addressing one practical obstacle on each of three fronts through theoretical modelling and numerical simulation: hardware design for elevated-temperature operation of superconducting processors, a hybrid quantum-classical machine-learning architecture characterized against matched classical controls and validated on physical hardware, and a model of a single-photon detector intended for high-magnetic-field environments. The first contribution presents a theoretical analysis of an asymmetric Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (SQUID) transmon qubit based on NbN/AlN/NbN Josephson junctions, designed for operation at 4 K rather than at conventional millikelvin temperatures. Through circuit-level modelling and decoherence analysis, the study shows that the asymmetric SQUID supports two flux-insensitive sweet spots, and projects a two-qubit gate fidelity of approximately 98% under an echo cross-resonance protocol at the elevated-temperature operating point. Operation at 4 K would substantially reduce cryogenic complexity, although whether the projections survive a fabrication and measurement campaign remains an open experimental question. The second contribution develops, trains and physically validates a hybrid quantum-classical convolutional neural network (Q-CNN) for binary satellite-image classification on a subset of the EuroSAT dataset. A multi-seed campaign at R = 10 seeds compares the hybrid against two purpose-built classical controls — a structurally isomorphic matched-capacity baseline (within 0.07% of the hybrid's parameter count) and a high-capacity reference — and quantifies, through paired Wilcoxon exact tests, a ~2.6 pp asymptotic-accuracy deficit of the hybrid against the matched control alongside a ~29 pp training-efficiency advantage at the first training epoch. The contribution also derives a runtime-aware credit-cost model calibrated against the IQM Emerald production campaign, and closes the loop with a credit-bounded fine-tuning of the simulator-trained checkpoint on the IQM Emerald 54-qubit superconducting processor, where parameter-shift gradients restore the simulator's full validation accuracy in two on-device epochs. A complementary paired multi-seed study on a reduced 4-qubit version of the architecture under a calibrated IBM Heron r2 noise model further indicates that the hybrid pipeline is noise-resilient in the studied regime, with final classification accuracy statistically indistinguishable from the noiseless reference. The third contribution models a Rydberg-atom avalanche detector for single-photon sensitivity, motivated by the readout requirements of axion-haloscope searches. Numerical simulations across 0–5 T external magnetic fields predict amplification factors exceeding 3, dark-count rates below 0.01 Hz at 4 K, and a stable avalanche timescale of approximately 9–13 μs across the field range. The model provides quantitative performance targets for an experimental implementation that has not yet been attempted.

•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations

Metrological Characterization of Non-Gaussian Entangled States of Superconducting Qubits

Kai Xu, Yu-Ran Zhang, Zheng-Hang Sun +12 more

Multipartite entangled states are significant resources for both quantum information processing and quantum metrology. In particular, non-Gaussian entangled states are predicted to achieve a higher sensitivity of precision measurements than Gaussian states. On the basis of metrological sensitivity, the conventional linear Ramsey squeezing parameter (RSP) efficiently characterizes the Gaussian entangled atomic states but fails for much wider classes of highly sensitive non-Gaussian states. These complex non-Gaussian entangled states can be classified by the nonlinear squeezing parameter (NLSP), as a generalization of the RSP with respect to nonlinear observables and identified via the Fisher information. However, the NLSP has never been measured experimentally. Using a 19-qubit programmable superconducting processor, we report the characterization of multiparticle entangled states generated during its nonlinear dynamics. First, selecting ten qubits, we measure the RSP and the NLSP by single-shot readouts of collective spin operators in several different directions. Then, by extracting the Fisher information of the time-evolved state of all 19 qubits, we observe a large metrological gain of 9.89_{-0.29}^{+0.28} dB over the standard quantum limit, indicating a high level of multiparticle entanglement for quantum-enhanced phase sensitivity. Benefiting from high-fidelity full controls and addressable single-shot readouts, the superconducting processor with interconnected qubits provides an ideal platform for engineering and benchmarking non-Gaussian entangled states that are useful for quantum-enhanced metrology.

Physical Review Letters•Apr 12, 2022•57 citations

Resource-efficient quantum correlation measurements via multicopy neural network methods

Patrycja Tulewicz, Karol Bartkiewicz, Adam Miranowicz +1 more

Measuring complex properties in quantum systems, such as measures of quantum entanglement and Bell nonlocality, is inherently challenging. Traditional methods, like quantum state tomography (QST), require a full reconstruction of the density matrix for a given system and demand resources that scale exponentially with system size. We propose an alternative strategy that reduces the required information by combining multicopy measurements with artificial neural networks (ANNs), resulting in a 67% reduction in measurement requirements compared to QST. We have successfully measured two-qubit quantum correlations of Bell states subjected to a depolarizing channel (resulting in Werner states) and an amplitude-damping channel (leading to Horodecki states) using the multicopy approach on real quantum hardware. Our experiments, conducted with transmon qubits on IBMQ quantum processors, quantified the violation of Bell's inequality and the negativity of two-qubit entangled states. We compared these results with those obtained from the standard QST approach and applied a maximum likelihood method to mitigate noise. We trained ANNs to estimate degrees of entanglement and nonlocality measures using optimized sets of projections identified through Shapley's (SHAP) analysis for the Werner and Horodecki states. The ANN output, based on this reduced set of projections, aligns well with expected values and enhances noise robustness. This approach simplifies and improves the error robustness of multicopy measurements, eliminating the need for complex nonlinear equation analysis. It represents a significant advancement in AI-assisted quantum measurements, making the practical implementation on current quantum hardware more feasible. The experimental results demonstrate improved noise robustness on the current noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware, representing a practical advance in resource-efficient characterization of quantum correlations.

arXiv:2411.05745•Scientific Reports•Nov 19, 2025•1 citation

Quantum Nonlinear Properties from a Single Measurement Setting

Zihao Li, Datong Chen, Dayue Qin +2 more

Nonlinear properties of quantum states are essential to quantum information and many-body physics, but assessing them experimentally is challenging, as it typically requires multi-copy operations or a large number of measurement settings. To address this challenge, we develop a universal framework, collision-based nonlinear estimation (CBNE), for efficiently measuring nonlinear quantities of a quantum state $ρ$, such as the higher-order expectation value ${\rm tr}(Oρ^t)$ for some observable $O$, using single-copy randomized measurements. Strikingly, our protocol requires only a single measurement setting, provided that the system dimension is sufficiently large or a few ancillary qubits are available; this contrasts with the conventional expectation that multiple measurement bases are necessary for nonlinear estimation. In addition, CBNE is observable-independent at the experimental stage, which enables simultaneous estimation of multiple nonlinear functions. It further extends to broader tasks, including the estimation of principal component properties and partial-transpose moments of quantum states. Our results provide a practical and scalable route for measuring nonlinear state properties on near-term quantum devices.

quant-pharXiv:2605.09958•May 12, 2026•5 citations

Beyond Qubits: Qudits for Quantum Computing and Many-Body Simulation in Superconducting Circuits

Noah Goss

Quantum processors based on superconducting circuitry have reached the scale of hundreds of qubits and demonstrated computational capabilities that challenge state-of-the-art classical methods for carefully designed problems. Despite these advances, fundamental questions persist over how to best improve and scale the computational power of this emerging technology. Most transmon-based quantum processors encode information in two-level systems, or qubits, leaving the rich multilevel structure of the transmon largely unexploited. In this thesis, we demonstrate how the capabilities of these devices can be meaningfully extended by harnessing this intrinsic multilevel structure to encode qudits — d-level quantum systems that access a larger and more connected Hilbert space than their qubit counterparts. We begin by demonstrating universal single-qudit operation before turning to microwave-activated entanglement to realize scalable two-qudit gates. We present a high-fidelity, fully entangling two-qutrit CZ gate based on a novel tunable cross-Kerr mechanism. We further explore two-qudit gates that selectively entangle subspaces of the full Hilbert space via two-photon multipartite Raman transitions, employing these operations to generate large entangled states across a transmon array. To address the noisy nature of near-term qudit computation, we introduce and characterize error suppression techniques for qudit circuits, including dynamical decoupling and quantum error mitigation. We then synthesize these directions by exploring simulations of quantum systems that have innate multilevel interactions and are therefore well tailored to qudit operation. First we investigate digital quantum simulations of collective neutrino oscillations and the spin-1 truncated Abelian Higgs model, finding error mitigation methods critical for improving circuit performance. Finally, out of equilibrium --- or Floquet --- spin-1 systems are realized using an array of 15 superconducting qutrits to probe a novel Z3 discrete time crystalline (DTC) phase of matter with intrinsically chiral interactions. This DTC result demonstrates that native qudit hardware provides powerful access to non-equilibrium phases rooted in higher discrete symmetries, opening a route to a broader landscape of dynamical orders beyond the Z2 Ising paradigm.

•May 1, 2026•0 citations
Quantum systems are inherently linear at the level of their evolution equations, yet the properties that make them useful for computation, communication, and sensing are profoundly nonlinear.Entanglement cannot be captured by any single linear observable; generating a state with prescribed quantum correlations requires navigating a highly non-convex optimization landscape; and the dynamics of open quantum systems can develop singularities in parameter space that have no counterpart in ordinary Hermitian physics.This dissertation addresses all three aspects of this nonlinearity on current superconducting quantum hardware: how to measure it efficiently, how to generate it deliberately, and how to exploit it as a resource rather than treat it as an obstacle.The characterization problem is addressed in Chapter 2 through a family of multicopy measurement protocols that operate on pairs or small sets of identically prepared state copies rather than on a single copy at a time.This approach reduces the number of measurement settings required to estimate entanglement from the exponential cost of full quantum state tomography, reducing the exponent base from 4 n to 2 n in the number of qubits, with a verified 67% reduction in overhead for two-qubit systems on IBM Quantum hardware.A central result of this chapter is the identification of partial-transpose moments as chirality-chirality correlators: the difference between partial-transpose and purity moments encodes the scalar spin chirality, a quantity familiar from condensed-matter physics as the order parameter of chiral spin liquids.This connection provides a physical interpretation for an otherwise abstract algebraic operation, and it extends naturally to bound entanglement detection through the realignment non-Hermiticity gap.Using the same controlled-SWAP circuit infrastructure, a multi-channel spectral classifier detects bound entanglement across all three known families of 3 × 3 positive-partial-transpose entangled states, including states invisible to any single realignment criterion, achieving 99.6% cross-validated recall at zero false positives in simulation and 94% recall on ibm_fez hardware.This is the first family-agnostic demonstration of bound entanglement detection on a gate-based superconducting processor.Gröbner basis decision trees provide an additional route to negativity estimation, converting spectral moments into entanglement values adaptively and achieving a five-to sevenfold reduction in measurement settings relative to full tomography.
Entanglement can hide in two fundamentally different ways. First, multi-copy correlations can carry information that no single-copy measurement on an unknown state is able to access. Second, bound entangled states possess a positive partial transpose, which makes them invisible to the Peres-Horodecki criterion and all moment inequalities that depend on it. Here we show that the moment difference between the partial transpose and purity decomposes exactly as a chirality-chirality correlator, where the relevant operator is the scalar spin chirality -- the same quantity that governs chiral spin liquids and the topological Hall effect. This decomposition identifies the specific physical structure that multi-copy entanglement detection probes. Using the same controlled-SWAP circuits, we develop a multi-channel spectral classifier for bound entanglement. The classifier combines realignment spectral features with chirality corrections and achieves 99.9% recall at zero false positives across all three known 3x3 bound entangled families, compared with ~40% for the CCNR criterion alone. We also introduce a marginal-noise construction that produces CCNR-invisible bound entangled states, which the classifier detects but which remain invisible to all single-parameter criteria. We validate our approach experimentally on three IBM Quantum processors and demonstrate negativity reconstruction with mean errors of 0.002-0.027, chirality detection for pure and mixed entangled states, and bound entanglement detection across two structurally distinct families (Horodecki and chessboard) on a single gate-based superconducting processor.
This dissertation reports three studies in quantum technologies, addressing one practical obstacle on each of three fronts through theoretical modelling and numerical simulation: hardware design for elevated-temperature operation of superconducting processors, a hybrid quantum-classical machine-learning architecture characterized against matched classical controls and validated on physical hardware, and a model of a single-photon detector intended for high-magnetic-field environments. The first contribution presents a theoretical analysis of an asymmetric Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (SQUID) transmon qubit based on NbN/AlN/NbN Josephson junctions, designed for operation at 4 K rather than at conventional millikelvin temperatures. Through circuit-level modelling and decoherence analysis, the study shows that the asymmetric SQUID supports two flux-insensitive sweet spots, and projects a two-qubit gate fidelity of approximately 98% under an echo cross-resonance protocol at the elevated-temperature operating point. Operation at 4 K would substantially reduce cryogenic complexity, although whether the projections survive a fabrication and measurement campaign remains an open experimental question. The second contribution develops, trains and physically validates a hybrid quantum-classical convolutional neural network (Q-CNN) for binary satellite-image classification on a subset of the EuroSAT dataset. A multi-seed campaign at R = 10 seeds compares the hybrid against two purpose-built classical controls — a structurally isomorphic matched-capacity baseline (within 0.07% of the hybrid's parameter count) and a high-capacity reference — and quantifies, through paired Wilcoxon exact tests, a ~2.6 pp asymptotic-accuracy deficit of the hybrid against the matched control alongside a ~29 pp training-efficiency advantage at the first training epoch. The contribution also derives a runtime-aware credit-cost model calibrated against the IQM Emerald production campaign, and closes the loop with a credit-bounded fine-tuning of the simulator-trained checkpoint on the IQM Emerald 54-qubit superconducting processor, where parameter-shift gradients restore the simulator's full validation accuracy in two on-device epochs. A complementary paired multi-seed study on a reduced 4-qubit version of the architecture under a calibrated IBM Heron r2 noise model further indicates that the hybrid pipeline is noise-resilient in the studied regime, with final classification accuracy statistically indistinguishable from the noiseless reference. The third contribution models a Rydberg-atom avalanche detector for single-photon sensitivity, motivated by the readout requirements of axion-haloscope searches. Numerical simulations across 0–5 T external magnetic fields predict amplification factors exceeding 3, dark-count rates below 0.01 Hz at 4 K, and a stable avalanche timescale of approximately 9–13 μs across the field range. The model provides quantitative performance targets for an experimental implementation that has not yet been attempted.
Multipartite entangled states are significant resources for both quantum information processing and quantum metrology. In particular, non-Gaussian entangled states are predicted to achieve a higher sensitivity of precision measurements than Gaussian states. On the basis of metrological sensitivity, the conventional linear Ramsey squeezing parameter (RSP) efficiently characterizes the Gaussian entangled atomic states but fails for much wider classes of highly sensitive non-Gaussian states. These complex non-Gaussian entangled states can be classified by the nonlinear squeezing parameter (NLSP), as a generalization of the RSP with respect to nonlinear observables and identified via the Fisher information. However, the NLSP has never been measured experimentally. Using a 19-qubit programmable superconducting processor, we report the characterization of multiparticle entangled states generated during its nonlinear dynamics. First, selecting ten qubits, we measure the RSP and the NLSP by single-shot readouts of collective spin operators in several different directions. Then, by extracting the Fisher information of the time-evolved state of all 19 qubits, we observe a large metrological gain of 9.89_{-0.29}^{+0.28} dB over the standard quantum limit, indicating a high level of multiparticle entanglement for quantum-enhanced phase sensitivity. Benefiting from high-fidelity full controls and addressable single-shot readouts, the superconducting processor with interconnected qubits provides an ideal platform for engineering and benchmarking non-Gaussian entangled states that are useful for quantum-enhanced metrology.
Measuring complex properties in quantum systems, such as measures of quantum entanglement and Bell nonlocality, is inherently challenging. Traditional methods, like quantum state tomography (QST), require a full reconstruction of the density matrix for a given system and demand resources that scale exponentially with system size. We propose an alternative strategy that reduces the required information by combining multicopy measurements with artificial neural networks (ANNs), resulting in a 67% reduction in measurement requirements compared to QST. We have successfully measured two-qubit quantum correlations of Bell states subjected to a depolarizing channel (resulting in Werner states) and an amplitude-damping channel (leading to Horodecki states) using the multicopy approach on real quantum hardware. Our experiments, conducted with transmon qubits on IBMQ quantum processors, quantified the violation of Bell's inequality and the negativity of two-qubit entangled states. We compared these results with those obtained from the standard QST approach and applied a maximum likelihood method to mitigate noise. We trained ANNs to estimate degrees of entanglement and nonlocality measures using optimized sets of projections identified through Shapley's (SHAP) analysis for the Werner and Horodecki states. The ANN output, based on this reduced set of projections, aligns well with expected values and enhances noise robustness. This approach simplifies and improves the error robustness of multicopy measurements, eliminating the need for complex nonlinear equation analysis. It represents a significant advancement in AI-assisted quantum measurements, making the practical implementation on current quantum hardware more feasible. The experimental results demonstrate improved noise robustness on the current noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware, representing a practical advance in resource-efficient characterization of quantum correlations.
Nonlinear properties of quantum states are essential to quantum information and many-body physics, but assessing them experimentally is challenging, as it typically requires multi-copy operations or a large number of measurement settings. To address this challenge, we develop a universal framework, collision-based nonlinear estimation (CBNE), for efficiently measuring nonlinear quantities of a quantum state ρρρ, such as the higher-order expectation value tr(Oρt){\rm tr}(Oρ^t)tr(Oρt) for some observable OOO, using single-copy randomized measurements. Strikingly, our protocol requires only a single measurement setting, provided that the system dimension is sufficiently large or a few ancillary qubits are available; this contrasts with the conventional expectation that multiple measurement bases are necessary for nonlinear estimation. In addition, CBNE is observable-independent at the experimental stage, which enables simultaneous estimation of multiple nonlinear functions. It further extends to broader tasks, including the estimation of principal component properties and partial-transpose moments of quantum states. Our results provide a practical and scalable route for measuring nonlinear state properties on near-term quantum devices.
Quantum processors based on superconducting circuitry have reached the scale of hundreds of qubits and demonstrated computational capabilities that challenge state-of-the-art classical methods for carefully designed problems. Despite these advances, fundamental questions persist over how to best improve and scale the computational power of this emerging technology. Most transmon-based quantum processors encode information in two-level systems, or qubits, leaving the rich multilevel structure of the transmon largely unexploited. In this thesis, we demonstrate how the capabilities of these devices can be meaningfully extended by harnessing this intrinsic multilevel structure to encode qudits — d-level quantum systems that access a larger and more connected Hilbert space than their qubit counterparts. We begin by demonstrating universal single-qudit operation before turning to microwave-activated entanglement to realize scalable two-qudit gates. We present a high-fidelity, fully entangling two-qutrit CZ gate based on a novel tunable cross-Kerr mechanism. We further explore two-qudit gates that selectively entangle subspaces of the full Hilbert space via two-photon multipartite Raman transitions, employing these operations to generate large entangled states across a transmon array. To address the noisy nature of near-term qudit computation, we introduce and characterize error suppression techniques for qudit circuits, including dynamical decoupling and quantum error mitigation. We then synthesize these directions by exploring simulations of quantum systems that have innate multilevel interactions and are therefore well tailored to qudit operation. First we investigate digital quantum simulations of collective neutrino oscillations and the spin-1 truncated Abelian Higgs model, finding error mitigation methods critical for improving circuit performance. Finally, out of equilibrium --- or Floquet --- spin-1 systems are realized using an array of 15 superconducting qutrits to probe a novel Z3 discrete time crystalline (DTC) phase of matter with intrinsically chiral interactions. This DTC result demonstrates that native qudit hardware provides powerful access to non-equilibrium phases rooted in higher discrete symmetries, opening a route to a broader landscape of dynamical orders beyond the Z2 Ising paradigm.