Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Dihotomia subiect–obiect în fizică și filosofie

Mirică, Andreea Elena

Published Dec 14, 2010• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Yearbook of the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca, Series HUMANISTICA; Vol. 8 (2010); pp. 215–233. Abstract: This paper consists of a brief analysis of the passing from the concept of classic mechanics to the theory of relativity and quantum mechanics and certain consequences produced by the discoveries of science over philosophical concepts as time, space and causality. Classic mechanics stands that time and space are absolute and this consideration is true for the mathematical equations used in this part of physics. These ideas were taken for granted until Albert Einstein showed that no signal could be transmitted with a higher speed than the speed of light in vacuum. Space and time are relative notions; therefore we can no longer speak about the absolute simultaneity of the events. The papers is divided in two parts, one which describes the actual modification of the concepts mentioned above along with the revolutions that took place in physics and the other part is dedicated to the philosophical theories which accompanied classic mechanics ( some of the guiding theories elaborated by Plato, Rene Descartes, John Stuart Mill, Simon Laplace). In the first part we analyzed the debates between the physicians whom considered necessary to develop philosophical theories in order to explain the new discoveries. We refer to Niels Bohr, Albert Einstein, David Bohm, Paul Vigier and others. Building a new philosophy in order to try to explain that existence and the mechanisms of the universe is proving to be, once again, a huge and never-ending process. English title: The Separation between the Subject and the Object of Knowledge in Physics and Philosophy. How to cite: Mirică, A. E. (2010). Dihotomia subiect–obiect în fizică și filosofie [The Separation between the Subject and the Object of Knowledge in Physics and Philosophy]. Yearbook of the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca, Series Humanistica, 8, 215–233. © 2010 The Author(s). All rights reserved. First published by the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca — The Publishing House of the Romanian Academy (ISSN 1584-4404). The full text is freely available for reading, downloading and printing at https://humanistica.ro/issues/2010/2010_15_Mirica.html

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22965989

Related papers

Notes sur la complémentarité, la nature et la recherche du réel

Ionuţ Isac

Yearbook of the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca, Series HUMANISTICA; Vol. 6 (2008); pp. 227–238. Abstract: Quantum mechanics is nowadays unanimous acknowledged by the community of physicists not only as the theory of physics which has accomplished a true revolution of the scientific thought, but also as a true 'framework theory', able to determine a complete reconsideration of the view about reality. Finally, it also gives the ground for new ontological models. Having all these in sight, we propose to the reader, throughout these notes, some reflections upon three controversial issues: Bohr's principle of complementarity as a source of post-modernism in philosophy of science; the cultural meaning of the principle of complementarity; the conception of nature and the research for the 'real' by B. d'Espagnat. How to cite: Isac, I. (2008). Notes sur la complémentarité, la nature et la recherche du réel. Yearbook of the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca, Series Humanistica, 6, 227–238. © 2008 The Author(s). All rights reserved. First published by the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca — The Publishing House of the Romanian Academy (ISSN 1584-4404). The full text is freely available for reading, downloading and printing at https://humanistica.ro/issues/2008/2008_13_Isac.html

•Dec 14, 2008•0 citations

Time in the Physical Picture of the World

Andrey Yu. Sevalnikov

The article is devoted to the problem of time in modern science, where in recent years there have been major changes related to the latest discoveries in the field of the foundations of quantum theory. The author refers to works of K.-F. von Weizsacker (which works are not well-known in Russian-speaking field). Weizsacker deploys a large-scale program of building modern physics, while starting (not only as a physicist, but also a professional philosopher) with questions of philosophical interpretation of postulates of modern physics, especially quantum mechanics. His key thesis is that time in physics is fundamentally distinct, which represents the whole physics as an integral scientific discipline. Weizsacker comes from physical and philosophical reflections, that give a special value to his work. Analyzing the conclusions of theoretical physics, namely the issues of substantiation of statistical mechanics, thermodynamics, and, above all, quantum mechanics, Weizsacker comes to the key idea of the structure of time in the substantiation of physical theory. The author in this conclusion disagrees with the opinion of most modern physicists that time has a subjective character, and the modus of the past, present and future reflects its essential character. The allocation of the time structure requires special logic. Such a logic is temporal and quantum. Starting from temporal logic, introducing the concept of possibility and probability, he comes to the substantiation of quantum mechanics. Being modal logic, it is based on the concept of possibility and probability. Key concept for Weizsacker is a binary alternative (Uralternative), closely related to the principle of superposition in quantum mechanics. By introducing the concept of certain alternatives, essentially actualized alternatives, Weizsacker shows how one can get the theory of relativity with its space-time structure. Further, he shows that based on its structure, you can get the theory of relativity. The space-time structure in this case is secondary, relational, as understood by Leibniz, Mach, and Einstein.

Epistemology & Philosophy of Science•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Background to the STSM-idea: Understanding the special theory of relativity

Anders Månsson

This paper constitutes a background to the paper 'Quantum mechanics as space-time statistical mechanics?', arXiv:quant-ph/0501133, presented previously by the author. But it is also a free-standing and self-contained paper. The purpose of this paper is to give the reader an increased and a deeper understanding of the special theory of relativity, and the ideas lying behind the above mentioned paper. We will here consider, discuss, define, analyse, and explain things such as, e.g., the constancy of the speed of light, synchronization, simultaneity, absolute simultaneity, absolute space and time, the ether, and spacetime. Albert Einstein's original version of the special theory of relativity is fundamentally an operational theory, free from interpretation. But the old Lorentzian interpretation and the standard spacetime interpretation of the special theory of relativity will also be considered. This paper also discusses and analyses aspects of the philosophy of science that in my opinion are relevant for an understanding of the special theory of relativity.

•Jan 29, 2009•0 citations

The Golden Period: Two Master Strokes of the 20th Century—Relativity and Quantum Mechanics

Subal Kar

In the 20th century, two new terms were added to the scientific lexicon: relativistic mechanics and quantum mechanics. The challenge to the concept of the absoluteness of space and time started at the end of the 19th century and gave birth to Einstein's special relativity theory in 1905. This unified space and time to a single entity, space–time, and we have been introduced to many new concepts such as time dilation, space contraction, mass–energy relation, and the space–time continuum in relativity theory. We have also learned that the highest possible velocity in this universe is that of light and that nothing in the universe can move faster than light. Einstein's general theory of relativity took into consideration gravitation and established the chronogeometric concept of gravity. Quantum mechanics developed by Bohr, de Broglie, Heisenberg, Schrödinger, and others gave us knowledge in the atomic and subatomic domain and led to the wave–particle duality of de Broglie, the uncertainty principle of Heisenberg, the wave mechanics of Schrödinger, and so forth. We have learned that three distinct chords are at the heart of quantum mechanics—granularity, relational, and indeterminism. Although quantum mechanics is a weird subject, as we will discuss, the modern physics is totally based on it.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 14, 2022•0 citations

Philosophy and the New Physics

Jonathan Powers

First Published in 1982 Philosophy and the New Physics is a compact and yet remarkably rich excursion through the history of physics from Newtonian mechanics to quantum physics. The theory of relativity, quantum mechanics and ideas about the ‘fundamental constituents’ of matter have attracted a great deal of philosophical comment. Indeed, the originators of some of these theories thought they were solving philosophical problems as well as scientific ones. Classical physics is often portrayed as epitomizing ‘mechanistic materialism’, and the revolution in modern physics is variously claimed to vindicate ‘logical positivism’, ‘operationalism’, ‘organicism’, ‘dialectical materialism’ and ‘Buddhist metaphysics’. In this book Jonathan Powers criticizes all of these claims and argues that such varied and conflicting interpretations are possible because of ineradicable elements of conventionality in scientific theories. This is a must read for scholars and researchers of philosophy of science and philosophy in general.

Routledge eBooks•Jul 10, 2023•3 citations

More on the quantum measurement problem

Gregory N. Derry

Although I have neither an objection to nor an endorsement of David Mermin’s major premise in his Quick Study, “There is no quantum measurement problem” (Physics Today, June 2022, page 62), I would like to make several contextual points.Mermin’s argument has an extensive history, along with a comparable history of rebuttal. Five decades ago Max Jammer wrote that “measurements in quantum mechanics are no more or less problematic than in classical physics, for the Hilbert space vector is only a purely formal device for relating the statistics associated with these arrangements to the physics of observations in classical physics.” That seems like a condensed version of the argument Mermin presents. On the following page, however, Jammer notes that a “problematic aspect whose serious implications were only gradually understood was the fact that as long as a quantum mechanical one-body or many-body system does not interact with macroscopic objects, as long as its motion is described by the deterministic Schrödinger time-dependent equation, no events could be considered to take place in the system.”11. M. Jammer, The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics: The Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective, Wiley (1974), pp. 473, 474.Niels Bohr giving a lecture in Copenhagen in April 1929. (Photograph by Samuel Goudsmit, courtesy of the AIP Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, Goudsmit Collection.)PPT|High resolutionRegarding the quotations from Niels Bohr, Mermin’s point is entirely valid and represents Bohr’s position accurately, but Bohr’s thought is always subtle and difficult to capture completely. Another quotation from Bohr, which is consistent with everything else he wrote, is, “The decisive point is that in neither case does the appropriate widening of our conceptual framework imply any appeal to the observing subject, which would hinder unambiguous communication of experience.”22. N. Bohr, Essays 1958–1962 on Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge, Ox Bow Press (1987), p. 7. That quotation seems inconsistent with Mermin’s paragraph that includes the passage “Why should I insist that my interpretation of science, which I use to make sense of the world that I experience, should never make any mention of me?” Bohr always insisted that his framework was a rational “generalization” of classical objectivity.The last and most conceptually important point concerns the ontological status of probability. I don’t necessarily disagree with Mermin and Bruno de Finetti, but it is by no means obvious that they are correct either. David Hawkins, for example, begins 50 pages of rigorous analysis with a brief statement of a major premise.The obvious and natural interpretation of probability in this context is that it introduces, not something that has to do with the nature of the physical system, but something that has to do with the incompleteness of our knowledge….But this opinion turns out to be false. Ignorance of dynamical regularity may be a motive for resorting to probabilities, but it does not explain the probabilities to which we resort.33. D. Hawkins, The Language of Nature: An Essay in the Philosophy of Science, W. H. Freeman (1964), p. 135.Another example can be found in Jammer’s well-known historical account of quantum theory: “For Einstein the notion of probability … was the traditional conception of classical physics, a mathematical objectivization of the human deficiency of complete or exact knowledge but ultimately a creation of the human mind…. For Born probability, as far as it was related to the wave function, was not merely a mathematical fiction but something endowed with physical reality.”44. M. Jammer, The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill (1966), p. 286.Of course, such examples don’t mean that Mermin’s position is incorrect, but I do think that they demand a better argument than a comparison to “Fairies and Witches.” I am confident that Mermin has such an argument, and I look forward to reading it as I continue working toward a coherent position on the unresolved interpretational issues of quantum theory.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. M. Jammer, The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics: The Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective, Wiley (1974), pp. 473, 474. Google Scholar2. N. Bohr, Essays 1958–1962 on Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge, Ox Bow Press (1987), p. 7. Google Scholar3. D. Hawkins, The Language of Nature: An Essay in the Philosophy of Science, W. H. Freeman (1964), p. 135. Google Scholar4. M. Jammer, The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill (1966), p. 286. Google Scholar© 2022 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Nov 1, 2022•2 citations
Yearbook of the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca, Series HUMANISTICA; Vol. 8 (2010); pp. 215–233. Abstract: This paper consists of a brief analysis of the passing from the concept of classic mechanics to the theory of relativity and quantum mechanics and certain consequences produced by the discoveries of science over philosophical concepts as time, space and causality. Classic mechanics stands that time and space are absolute and this consideration is true for the mathematical equations used in this part of physics. These ideas were taken for granted until Albert Einstein showed that no signal could be transmitted with a higher speed than the speed of light in vacuum. Space and time are relative notions; therefore we can no longer speak about the absolute simultaneity of the events. The papers is divided in two parts, one which describes the actual modification of the concepts mentioned above along with the revolutions that took place in physics and the other part is dedicated to the philosophical theories which accompanied classic mechanics ( some of the guiding theories elaborated by Plato, Rene Descartes, John Stuart Mill, Simon Laplace). In the first part we analyzed the debates between the physicians whom considered necessary to develop philosophical theories in order to explain the new discoveries. We refer to Niels Bohr, Albert Einstein, David Bohm, Paul Vigier and others. Building a new philosophy in order to try to explain that existence and the mechanisms of the universe is proving to be, once again, a huge and never-ending process. English title: The Separation between the Subject and the Object of Knowledge in Physics and Philosophy. How to cite: Mirică, A. E. (2010). Dihotomia subiect–obiect în fizică și filosofie [The Separation between the Subject and the Object of Knowledge in Physics and Philosophy]. Yearbook of the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca, Series Humanistica, 8, 215–233. © 2010 The Author(s). All rights reserved. First published by the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca — The Publishing House of the Romanian Academy (ISSN 1584-4404). The full text is freely available for reading, downloading and printing at https://humanistica.ro/issues/2010/2010_15_Mirica.html
Yearbook of the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca, Series HUMANISTICA; Vol. 6 (2008); pp. 227–238. Abstract: Quantum mechanics is nowadays unanimous acknowledged by the community of physicists not only as the theory of physics which has accomplished a true revolution of the scientific thought, but also as a true 'framework theory', able to determine a complete reconsideration of the view about reality. Finally, it also gives the ground for new ontological models. Having all these in sight, we propose to the reader, throughout these notes, some reflections upon three controversial issues: Bohr's principle of complementarity as a source of post-modernism in philosophy of science; the cultural meaning of the principle of complementarity; the conception of nature and the research for the 'real' by B. d'Espagnat. How to cite: Isac, I. (2008). Notes sur la complémentarité, la nature et la recherche du réel. Yearbook of the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca, Series Humanistica, 6, 227–238. © 2008 The Author(s). All rights reserved. First published by the "George Barițiu" Institute of History of Cluj-Napoca — The Publishing House of the Romanian Academy (ISSN 1584-4404). The full text is freely available for reading, downloading and printing at https://humanistica.ro/issues/2008/2008_13_Isac.html
The article is devoted to the problem of time in modern science, where in recent years there have been major changes related to the latest discoveries in the field of the foundations of quantum theory. The author refers to works of K.-F. von Weizsacker (which works are not well-known in Russian-speaking field). Weizsacker deploys a large-scale program of building modern physics, while starting (not only as a physicist, but also a professional philosopher) with questions of philosophical interpretation of postulates of modern physics, especially quantum mechanics. His key thesis is that time in physics is fundamentally distinct, which represents the whole physics as an integral scientific discipline. Weizsacker comes from physical and philosophical reflections, that give a special value to his work. Analyzing the conclusions of theoretical physics, namely the issues of substantiation of statistical mechanics, thermodynamics, and, above all, quantum mechanics, Weizsacker comes to the key idea of the structure of time in the substantiation of physical theory. The author in this conclusion disagrees with the opinion of most modern physicists that time has a subjective character, and the modus of the past, present and future reflects its essential character. The allocation of the time structure requires special logic. Such a logic is temporal and quantum. Starting from temporal logic, introducing the concept of possibility and probability, he comes to the substantiation of quantum mechanics. Being modal logic, it is based on the concept of possibility and probability. Key concept for Weizsacker is a binary alternative (Uralternative), closely related to the principle of superposition in quantum mechanics. By introducing the concept of certain alternatives, essentially actualized alternatives, Weizsacker shows how one can get the theory of relativity with its space-time structure. Further, he shows that based on its structure, you can get the theory of relativity. The space-time structure in this case is secondary, relational, as understood by Leibniz, Mach, and Einstein.
This paper constitutes a background to the paper 'Quantum mechanics as space-time statistical mechanics?', arXiv:quant-ph/0501133, presented previously by the author. But it is also a free-standing and self-contained paper. The purpose of this paper is to give the reader an increased and a deeper understanding of the special theory of relativity, and the ideas lying behind the above mentioned paper. We will here consider, discuss, define, analyse, and explain things such as, e.g., the constancy of the speed of light, synchronization, simultaneity, absolute simultaneity, absolute space and time, the ether, and spacetime. Albert Einstein's original version of the special theory of relativity is fundamentally an operational theory, free from interpretation. But the old Lorentzian interpretation and the standard spacetime interpretation of the special theory of relativity will also be considered. This paper also discusses and analyses aspects of the philosophy of science that in my opinion are relevant for an understanding of the special theory of relativity.
In the 20th century, two new terms were added to the scientific lexicon: relativistic mechanics and quantum mechanics. The challenge to the concept of the absoluteness of space and time started at the end of the 19th century and gave birth to Einstein's special relativity theory in 1905. This unified space and time to a single entity, space–time, and we have been introduced to many new concepts such as time dilation, space contraction, mass–energy relation, and the space–time continuum in relativity theory. We have also learned that the highest possible velocity in this universe is that of light and that nothing in the universe can move faster than light. Einstein's general theory of relativity took into consideration gravitation and established the chronogeometric concept of gravity. Quantum mechanics developed by Bohr, de Broglie, Heisenberg, Schrödinger, and others gave us knowledge in the atomic and subatomic domain and led to the wave–particle duality of de Broglie, the uncertainty principle of Heisenberg, the wave mechanics of Schrödinger, and so forth. We have learned that three distinct chords are at the heart of quantum mechanics—granularity, relational, and indeterminism. Although quantum mechanics is a weird subject, as we will discuss, the modern physics is totally based on it.
First Published in 1982 Philosophy and the New Physics is a compact and yet remarkably rich excursion through the history of physics from Newtonian mechanics to quantum physics. The theory of relativity, quantum mechanics and ideas about the ‘fundamental constituents’ of matter have attracted a great deal of philosophical comment. Indeed, the originators of some of these theories thought they were solving philosophical problems as well as scientific ones. Classical physics is often portrayed as epitomizing ‘mechanistic materialism’, and the revolution in modern physics is variously claimed to vindicate ‘logical positivism’, ‘operationalism’, ‘organicism’, ‘dialectical materialism’ and ‘Buddhist metaphysics’. In this book Jonathan Powers criticizes all of these claims and argues that such varied and conflicting interpretations are possible because of ineradicable elements of conventionality in scientific theories. This is a must read for scholars and researchers of philosophy of science and philosophy in general.
Although I have neither an objection to nor an endorsement of David Mermin’s major premise in his Quick Study, “There is no quantum measurement problem” (Physics Today, June 2022, page 62), I would like to make several contextual points.Mermin’s argument has an extensive history, along with a comparable history of rebuttal. Five decades ago Max Jammer wrote that “measurements in quantum mechanics are no more or less problematic than in classical physics, for the Hilbert space vector is only a purely formal device for relating the statistics associated with these arrangements to the physics of observations in classical physics.” That seems like a condensed version of the argument Mermin presents. On the following page, however, Jammer notes that a “problematic aspect whose serious implications were only gradually understood was the fact that as long as a quantum mechanical one-body or many-body system does not interact with macroscopic objects, as long as its motion is described by the deterministic Schrödinger time-dependent equation, no events could be considered to take place in the system.”11. M. Jammer, The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics: The Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective, Wiley (1974), pp. 473, 474.Niels Bohr giving a lecture in Copenhagen in April 1929. (Photograph by Samuel Goudsmit, courtesy of the AIP Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, Goudsmit Collection.)PPT|High resolutionRegarding the quotations from Niels Bohr, Mermin’s point is entirely valid and represents Bohr’s position accurately, but Bohr’s thought is always subtle and difficult to capture completely. Another quotation from Bohr, which is consistent with everything else he wrote, is, “The decisive point is that in neither case does the appropriate widening of our conceptual framework imply any appeal to the observing subject, which would hinder unambiguous communication of experience.”22. N. Bohr, Essays 1958–1962 on Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge, Ox Bow Press (1987), p. 7. That quotation seems inconsistent with Mermin’s paragraph that includes the passage “Why should I insist that my interpretation of science, which I use to make sense of the world that I experience, should never make any mention of me?” Bohr always insisted that his framework was a rational “generalization” of classical objectivity.The last and most conceptually important point concerns the ontological status of probability. I don’t necessarily disagree with Mermin and Bruno de Finetti, but it is by no means obvious that they are correct either. David Hawkins, for example, begins 50 pages of rigorous analysis with a brief statement of a major premise.The obvious and natural interpretation of probability in this context is that it introduces, not something that has to do with the nature of the physical system, but something that has to do with the incompleteness of our knowledge….But this opinion turns out to be false. Ignorance of dynamical regularity may be a motive for resorting to probabilities, but it does not explain the probabilities to which we resort.33. D. Hawkins, The Language of Nature: An Essay in the Philosophy of Science, W. H. Freeman (1964), p. 135.Another example can be found in Jammer’s well-known historical account of quantum theory: “For Einstein the notion of probability … was the traditional conception of classical physics, a mathematical objectivization of the human deficiency of complete or exact knowledge but ultimately a creation of the human mind…. For Born probability, as far as it was related to the wave function, was not merely a mathematical fiction but something endowed with physical reality.”44. M. Jammer, The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill (1966), p. 286.Of course, such examples don’t mean that Mermin’s position is incorrect, but I do think that they demand a better argument than a comparison to “Fairies and Witches.” I am confident that Mermin has such an argument, and I look forward to reading it as I continue working toward a coherent position on the unresolved interpretational issues of quantum theory.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. M. Jammer, The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics: The Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective, Wiley (1974), pp. 473, 474. Google Scholar2. N. Bohr, Essays 1958–1962 on Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge, Ox Bow Press (1987), p. 7. Google Scholar3. D. Hawkins, The Language of Nature: An Essay in the Philosophy of Science, W. H. Freeman (1964), p. 135. Google Scholar4. M. Jammer, The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill (1966), p. 286. Google Scholar© 2022 American Institute of Physics.