What should an optical memory retain when only a limited amount of source information can be kept? This paper gives the complete quantum information frontier for a fixed Gaussian source and relevance channel, and identifies when a single retained qubit preserves correlations that every classical record loses. It also turns that advantage into a concrete test of whether received light belongs to its stored source preparation. The physical experiment and the complete frontier A fixed Gaussian state on
A is prepared with its actual purifier
C. A normal encoder acts on
C to produce memory
M, while a prescribed Gaussian channel maps
A to the relevant optical output
B. The source-information cost and useful correlation are
r=I(A:M) and
v=I(B:M), respectively. All logarithms are natural. The paper determines
CQ(R)=supN:I(A:M)≤RI(B:M). For every fixed faithful finite-mode Gaussian source and finite-mode Gaussian relevance channel, optimization over arbitrary normal quantum encoders reduces to Gaussian supporting values and a mixture of at most two Gaussian branches. The branch flag is physically retained. The unrestricted frontier is a supremum with no imposed memory dimension or memory-energy cap; an explicit finite approximation gives an error uniform in the information budget. Hard finite-dimensional implementations are treated separately. Why one qubit can preserve the leading low-brightness information For a thermal source with mean photon number
n and a thermal attenuator with transmissivity
0<η<1, write the output occupation as
ηn+b, where
b≥0 is the environment's added thermal occupation. With
g(x)=(x+1)log(x+1)−xlogx, the exact optimum over all normal classical records is
Ccl(n,R)=g(ηn+b)−g(ηuR+b),uR=g−1(max{g(n)−R,0}). A legal encoder applies vacuum loss with transmissivity
λ to the purifier and then coherently retains two levels, resetting the entire higher-photon tail. For fixed
b>0 and
0<λ<1/2, at the common budget
Rn=g(n)+g(λn)−g((1−λ)n), its actual relevance satisfies
v2=1+bηλnlog(1/n)+O(n),Ccl(n,Rn)=2ληlog(1+1/b)n+O(log(1/n)n). The full optical tail is included in the resource accounting. At
n=0.01,
η=b=0.5,
λ=0.2 and
R=0.023875, the certified predictive-mutual-information advantage exceeds 85%. The leading correlation is quantified by memory-side discord and can survive when the final output–memory state is separable. The vacuum-environment endpoint is evaluated separately for the same encoder. A same-resource correlation decision The receiver distinguishes matched source pairs from independent systems with identical marginals. For
k uses, the retained predictive memory obeys
dimKk≤2k and
I(Ak:Kk)≤kR, including all retained flags. Both competitors may make arbitrary joint binary measurements on the received optical modes and their retained memory. The received modes are common observation access, outside the predictive-memory cap. Let
αk be the missed-correlation probability and
βk the false-match probability. For every classical block encoder, even with an unrestricted classical alphabet, the fixed-error converse is
αk≤ϵ⟹βk≥exp[−1−ϵkcnR+log2],cn=ηlog(1+1/n)log(1+1/(ηn+b)). At the finite parameters above and
ϵ=0.1, the product-qubit encoder achieves an asymptotic false-match exponent of 0.0049 nats per pair, whereas every classical block strategy has exponent below 0.003138386231. This uses one qubit per source pair and identical measurement permissions. It is an asymptotic discrimination guarantee, distinct from the 85% single-copy information comparison; it specifies neither a finite-sample threshold nor a laboratory receiver circuit. The integrated paper contains the complete proofs, resource accounting and figures. The exact thermal classical comparator, the finite-memory construction and the block-testing connection have explicit proof dependencies separate from the general Gaussian-frontier reduction.
Abstract Preparing additional quantum states while retaining a source requires information beyond an arbitrary unknown input. We formulate reconstruction from incom- plete classical preparation records as an identity channel on the source and two output preparations. For a short interval of QPE phase states, we derive the exact record-only minimax fidelity and an attaining endpoint superposition, closing the gap between center replay and an endpoint upper bound. An explicit one-ancilla circuit realizes the optimum with a known success probability, while deterministic synthesis provides a finite-circuit alternative. Shor and randomized-simulation examples expose different obstructions from discrete ambiguity and missing ran- dom choices. In one randomized-simulation setting, optimal conditional fidelity averaged over records was 0.925, although robust fidelity above five sixths was impossible for eight of ten records. Session calibration and resource-controlled comparisons distinguish average performance from worst-case guarantees. Hard- ware diagnostics test operational phase models, source waiting and preparation costs. They do not certify intrinsic gate angles, reconstruction fidelity or physical source preservation. The analysis identifies information and operational conditions without changing universal cloning bounds.
Free classical communication can yield an unbounded single-shot saving in quantum compression, even though it leaves the asymptotic rate of an i.i.d. source unchanged. At every fixed error in
(0,1), we exhibit sources whose unassisted compression cost is arbitrarily large, yet a single qubit suffices with classical communication and no preshared entanglement. We establish this separation by determining the exact optimal source fidelity for compression through an
m-dimensional noiseless quantum channel, with and without free classical communication, while preserving correlations with an inaccessible reference. Without classical assistance, the optimal fidelity is exactly the Ky Fan norm
∥ρ∥(m), the sum of the
m largest eigenvalues of the source state. With classical assistance, we obtain an explicit spectral threshold formula and a protocol attaining it. Classical communication strictly improves fidelity whenever
m is smaller than the source rank. The corresponding compression costs are two smoothed versions of the log-rank entropy, also called max-entropy: trace-distance smoothing under local operations and quadratic smoothing under LOCC. For i.i.d. copies of a fixed source with positive entropy variance, however, the two costs have identical first-, second-, and third-order asymptotic terms. For nonlattice spectra, we determine the constant-order advantage: classical communication saves
log2(e)−1 bits per block asymptotically, and the ratio of assisted to unassisted minimum communication dimensions converges to
2/e.
We determine exact resource limits for a qubit memory with retained classical records. For every qubit noise channel A, the largest output generalized entanglement-breaking robustness under an input budget R_G ≤ r is a semidefinite program in two 4 × 4 positive matrices, attained with at most five classical outcomes. For amplitude damping we solve the full budget curve, including two mixed-state regimes, and attain it with one classical bit. Its contraction coefficient is one, approached with vanishing input resource, although every fixed positive resource budget contracts strictly. A different argument controls memories prepared from a perfect qubit: for prescribed independent noise channels A_1, …, A_n, arbitrary adaptive instruments and finite classical records obey R_G(Γ_n) ≤ R(Γ_n) ≤ ∏_j ν(A_j), where ν(A) = max{0, 2λ_max J_A − 1} and J_A is normalized. The proof propagates a positive 2 × 2 operator over the branches. For amplitude-damping survivals with product b, both robustness optima equal b; the optimal average and worst-case pure-state fidelities are (2+b)/3, the optimal Bell fidelity is (1+b)/2, and the minimum half-diamond error is (1−b)/2. Finite protocols attain all four operational optima simultaneously. Thus classical control can improve fidelity while leaving optimal robustness unchanged. The model permits one persistent qubit and excludes quantum bypass, environment access, and postselection. A visual guide records the reasoning routes, their joint premises, and the distinction between prior tools and the results developed here.
AbstractRetained measurement records constrain recoverability, but their formation also depends on the available physical controls. We give exact, constructively attained answers to both questions in two specified models. For a balanced nondemolition qubit process with actual binary observer memories unavailable to the decoder, we determine the maximum recovery compatible with average readout accuracy and pair agreement. The finite-record solution includes its feasible region and a common memory-writing and recovery process, without assuming exchangeability of observed records. Under a complete conditional-pairwise-independence promise at fixed informative accuracy, the optimal coherence has a sharp inverse-square-root asymptotic; fully conditionally independent records instead give exponential decay. Thus identical single-record and pair-record calibrations need not justify the product-law recovery bound. We then fix a logical code in four spin-3/2 systems and sequential diagonal contacts with exact controlled-swap endpoints. Hard budgets for net contact action and added spectral control charge yield an exact peak-excursion frontier within a declared quadratic-plus-cubic control class. A single positive-amplitude preparation jointly attains the record, recovery and occupation requirements, connecting the two results through an exact finite-dimensional optimization. A closed three-record example distinguishes fixed complete records from fixed averaged data. Separately calibrated imperfect contacts admit one-sided finite-error extensions. Together, the results characterize both informational compatibility and control-dependent formation through common attaining apparatuses.Preprint status and related materialsAuthor-submitted preprint; not peer reviewed or accepted for publication. This theoretical and computational work addresses the compatibility of retained binary quantum records with optimized accessible-system recovery, and the control-dependent resources required to form those records in a specified spin encoding. The article provides exact finite-record bounds, attainable recovery and resource frontiers, and calibrated finite-error qualifications. The manuscript has been submitted to Foundations of Physics for journal consideration; this Figshare record is not a journal publication. The technical supplement is included as a second PDF in this same record. Related software, verification code, exact certificates, and selected computational evidence are available separately at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.34886079 under the MIT licence. When a journal version of record becomes available, a link to its DOI will be added here.AuthorKent Nimmo; Independent Researcher, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada; ORCID 0009-0003-8503-8891.Reading and related workBrowse Quantum Foundations for related work on records, access and measurement, and Mathematics for exact bounds and certified constructions. The MIT software/certificate archive remains a distinct record from these manuscript PDFs.
In this work, we study the problem of single-shot discrimination of von Neumann measurements, which we associate with measure-and-prepare channels. There are two possible approaches to this problem. The first one is simple and does not utilize entanglement. We focus only on the discrimination of classical probability distributions, which are outputs of the channels. We find necessary and sufficient criterion for perfect discrimination in this case. A more advanced approach requires the usage of entanglement. We quantify the distance between two measurements in terms of the diamond norm (called sometimes the completely bounded trace norm). We provide an exact expression for the optimal probability of correct distinction and relate it to the discrimination of unitary channels. We also state a necessary and sufficient condition for perfect discrimination and a semidefinite program which checks this condition. Our main result, however, is a cone program which calculates the distance between the measurements and hence provides an upper bound on the probability of their correct distinction. As a by-product, the program finds a strategy (input state) which achieves this bound. Finally, we provide a full description for the cases of Fourier matrices and mirror isometries.