The Empirical Distinguishability of Quantum Interpretations
Jeffrey Satinover
Abstract
Quantum experiments constrain physical descriptions with extraordinary precision, yet several disagreements about quantum reality remain unresolved. Their persistence has different causes that require different responses. This article distinguishes exact agreement of predictions, inadequate statistical resolution, uncertain background dynamics, restricted access to records, conditional exclusion by no-goresults, and incomplete predictive specification. It develops a comparative framework in which distinguishability belongs to specified formulations and experimental domains rather than to interpretation names. A critical review connects philosophical work on underdetermination, Pessoa’s account of relations between experiments and interpretations, and recent statistical approaches to quantum tests. Likelihood equality clarifies the limits of differential confirmation, while identification of individual claims explains how experiments can establish physical structure without determining a complete ontology. Two analytic examples make the distinction practically consequential: a collapse contrast with bounded background uncertainty, and an observer-record model in which inaccessible information limits discrimination. The examples show when additional data help, when calibration or coherent access is required, and when no improvement within the stipulated domain can decide the comparison. The resulting assessment rejects both unrestricted empirical equivalence and claims that particular experiments uniquely establish a favored interpretation. It specifies the additional predictions, controls, and outcomes needed to make those claims evidentially meaningful.