Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Range Versus Entanglement: A Diagnostic Study of Graph-Laplacian Constructions in Heisenberg Spin Chains

Paul Jarvis

Published Sep 14, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper builds a graph Laplacian from the ground state mutual information matrix of the isotropic antiferromagnetic Heisenberg (XXZ) spin chain and uses it as a case study in what this class of construction does and does not establish. A first-pass analysis reproduces several textbook-looking signatures, including a statistically significant nonzero finite-size intercept in the lowest nonzero eigenvalue that persists and grows under periodic boundaries, naively suggestive of an entanglement-induced mass scale. This reading does not survive scrutiny: the intercept's magnitude varies by an order of magnitude under different adjacency normalizations and can change sign under an AICc-preferred finite-size model with logarithmic corrections. Repeating the construction with the classical, non-entanglement, connected spin correlator reproduces the same intercept phenomenon more cleanly; toggling only quantum coherence on and off via discord leaves it almost unchanged; and restricting to an unambiguous entanglement-only measure, two-body concurrence, collapses the intercept to a value statistically indistinguishable from zero. Across every construction tested, the intercept tracks whether the underlying matrix has long-range support, not whether it is quantum in origin.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22753515

Related papers

Condition for zero and nonzero discord in graph Laplacian quantum states

Supriyo Dutta, Bibhas Adhikari, Subhashish Banerjee

This work is at the interface of graph theory and quantum mechanics. Quantum correlations epitomize the usefulness of quantum mechanics. Quantum discord is an interesting facet of bipartite quantum correlations. Earlier, it was shown that every combinatorial graph corresponds to quantum states whose characteristics are reflected in the structure of the underlined graph. A number of combinatorial relations between quantum discord and simple graphs were studied. To extend the scope of these studies, we need to generalize the earlier concepts applicable to simple graphs to weighted graphs, corresponding to a diverse class of quantum states. To this effect, we determine the class of quantum states whose density matrix representation can be derived from graph Laplacian matrices associated with a weighted directed graph and call them graph Laplacian quantum states. We find the graph theoretic conditions for zero and nonzero quantum discord for these states. We apply these results on some important pure two qubit states, as well as a number of mixed quantum states, such as the Werner, Isotropic, and [Formula: see text]-states. We also consider graph Laplacian states corresponding to simple graphs as a special case.

arXiv:1705.00808•International Journal of Quantum Information•Mar 1, 2019•7 citations

Quantum correlations and coherence in spin-1 Heisenberg chains

André Luiz Malvezzi, Göktuğ Karpat, Barış Çakmak +3 more

We explore quantum and classical correlations along with coherence in the ground states of spin-1 Heisenberg chains, namely the one-dimensional XXZ model and the one-dimensional bilinear biquadratic model, with the techniques of density matrix renormalization group theory. Exploiting the tools of quantum information theory, that is, by studying quantum discord, quantum mutual information, and three recently introduced coherence measures in the reduced density matrix of two nearest neighbor spins in the bulk, we investigate the quantum phase transitions and special symmetry points in these models. We point out the relative strengths and weaknesses of correlation and coherence measures as figures of merit to witness the quantum phase transitions and symmetry points in the considered spin-1 Heisenberg chains. In particular, we demonstrate that, as none of the studied measures can detect the infinite-order Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in the XXZ model, they appear to be able to signal the existence of the same type of transition in the biliear biquadratic model. However, we argue that what is actually detected by the measures here is the SU(3) symmetry point of the model rather than the infinite-order quantum phase transition. Moreover, we show in the XXZ model that examining even single site coherence can be sufficient to spotlight the second-order phase transition and the SU(2) symmetry point.

arXiv:1602.03731•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 24, 2016•149 citations

Entanglement and ground states of gapped Hamiltonians

Spyridon Michalakis

We begin by deriving bounds for the entanglement of a spin with an (adjacent and non-adjacent) interval of spins in an arbitrary pure Finitely Correlated States (FCS). The bounds we derive become exact in the case where one considers the entanglement of a single spin with a half-infinite chain to the right of it. Our result permits a more efficient calculation, numerically and in some cases even analytically, of the entanglement in arbitrary finitely correlated quantum spin chains. We continue the study of entanglement in the setting of ground states of Hamiltonians with a spectral gap. In particular, for $V$ a finite subset of $Z^d$, we let $H_V$ denote a Hamiltonian on $V$ with finite range, finite strength interactions and a unique ground state with a non-vanishing spectral gap. For a density matrix $ρ_A$ that describes the finite-volume restriction to a region $A$ of the unique ground state, we provide a detailed version of a proof by M. Hastings, that the entropy of $ρ_A$ is bounded by a uniform constant $C$. Moreover, we provide a detailed generalization of the 1-dimensional construction of Hastings' approximation to the ground state in dimensions 2 and higher. Finally, we turn our attention to the study of a conjecture central to Quantum Information Theory, the multiplicativity of the maximal output Schatten $p$-norm of quantum channels, for $p > 1$. In particular, we study the output 2-norm for a special class of quantum channels, the depolarized Werner-Holevo channels, and show that multiplicativity holds for a product of two identical channels in this class.

arXiv:0807.4741•Jul 29, 2008•1 citation

Ground-state properties of a spin-1 antiferromagnetic chain

Robert S. Botet, Rémi Jullien

A finite-cell-scaling analysis of the spin-1 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg-Ising chain, shows that the ground-state properties are completely different than in the spin-\textonehalf{} case. Between the $\mathrm{XY}$ gapless phase and the doublet ground-state N\'eel phase, it appears, in an extended range of the anisotropy ($0\ensuremath{\lesssim}\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\lesssim}1.18$) a characteristic Heisenberg-phase with a nonmagnetic singlet ground state, nonzero gap, and exponential decay of the correlation functions.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 1, 1983•267 citations

Entanglement and quantum correlations in many-body systems: a unified approach via local unitary operations

Marco Cianciaruso, S. M. Giampaolo, Wojciech Roga +3 more

Local unitary operations allow for a unifying approach to the quantification of quantum correlations among the constituents of a bipartite quantum system. For pure states, the distance between a given state and its image under least-perturbing local unitary operations is a bona fide measure of quantum entanglement, the so-called entanglement of response, which can be extended to mixed states via the convex roof construction. On the other hand, when defined directly on mixed states perturbed by local unitary operations, such a distance turns out to be a bona fide measure of quantum correlations, the so-called discord of response. Exploiting this unified framework, we perform a detailed comparison between two-body entanglement and two-body quantum discord in infinite XY quantum spin chains both in symmetry-preserving and symmetry-breaking ground states as well as in thermal states at finite temperature. The results of the investigation show that in symmetry-preserving ground states the two-point quantum discord dominates over the two-point entanglement, while in symmetrybreaking ground states the two-point quantum discord is strongly suppressed and the two-point entanglement is essentially unchanged. In thermal states, for certain regimes of Hamiltonian parameters, we show that the pairwise quantum discord and the pairwise entanglement can increase with increasing thermal fluctuations.

arXiv:1412.1054•Dec 2, 2014•4 citations

Band Curvature, Not Physics: A Finite-Size Windowing Artifact in Graph-Laplacian Dispersion Diagnostics for Spin-Chain Mutual Information

Paul Jarvis

A companion paper (Range Versus Entanglement) built a graph Laplacian from the ground state mutual information matrix of the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg (XXZ) spin chain and found that AICc model selection on the lowest eight nonzero eigenvalues consistently prefers a linear dispersion over the quadratic dispersion predicted by a continuum Laplace-Beltrami operator. This paper traces that tension and finds it is substantially, though not entirely, a methodological artifact. The exact open chain dispersion relation has a curvature inflection at k=N/2, proved analytically and confirmed numerically; a fixed eight-mode fitting window straddles or approaches this inflection whenever N is 16 or smaller, biasing AICc toward the linear model for any locally supported adjacency matrix on an open chain, whether or not it is derived from entanglement. This is demonstrated directly on a content-free, unweighted nearest-neighbor chain, which reproduces the same crossover with no physics at all, and on two-body concurrence, which shows the same crossover as mutual information. Once the fitting window is defined adaptively to stay below the proven inflection, AICc prefers the quadratic model at every informative system size. A genuine residual survives this correction: the fitted curvature of mutual information's low-k spectrum has the opposite sign from concurrence's or the ideal chain's, indicating a real, still-unexplained feature specific to spin-spin correlation derived adjacency matrices.

•Sep 14, 2026•0 citations
This paper builds a graph Laplacian from the ground state mutual information matrix of the isotropic antiferromagnetic Heisenberg (XXZ) spin chain and uses it as a case study in what this class of construction does and does not establish. A first-pass analysis reproduces several textbook-looking signatures, including a statistically significant nonzero finite-size intercept in the lowest nonzero eigenvalue that persists and grows under periodic boundaries, naively suggestive of an entanglement-induced mass scale. This reading does not survive scrutiny: the intercept's magnitude varies by an order of magnitude under different adjacency normalizations and can change sign under an AICc-preferred finite-size model with logarithmic corrections. Repeating the construction with the classical, non-entanglement, connected spin correlator reproduces the same intercept phenomenon more cleanly; toggling only quantum coherence on and off via discord leaves it almost unchanged; and restricting to an unambiguous entanglement-only measure, two-body concurrence, collapses the intercept to a value statistically indistinguishable from zero. Across every construction tested, the intercept tracks whether the underlying matrix has long-range support, not whether it is quantum in origin.
This work is at the interface of graph theory and quantum mechanics. Quantum correlations epitomize the usefulness of quantum mechanics. Quantum discord is an interesting facet of bipartite quantum correlations. Earlier, it was shown that every combinatorial graph corresponds to quantum states whose characteristics are reflected in the structure of the underlined graph. A number of combinatorial relations between quantum discord and simple graphs were studied. To extend the scope of these studies, we need to generalize the earlier concepts applicable to simple graphs to weighted graphs, corresponding to a diverse class of quantum states. To this effect, we determine the class of quantum states whose density matrix representation can be derived from graph Laplacian matrices associated with a weighted directed graph and call them graph Laplacian quantum states. We find the graph theoretic conditions for zero and nonzero quantum discord for these states. We apply these results on some important pure two qubit states, as well as a number of mixed quantum states, such as the Werner, Isotropic, and [Formula: see text]-states. We also consider graph Laplacian states corresponding to simple graphs as a special case.
We explore quantum and classical correlations along with coherence in the ground states of spin-1 Heisenberg chains, namely the one-dimensional XXZ model and the one-dimensional bilinear biquadratic model, with the techniques of density matrix renormalization group theory. Exploiting the tools of quantum information theory, that is, by studying quantum discord, quantum mutual information, and three recently introduced coherence measures in the reduced density matrix of two nearest neighbor spins in the bulk, we investigate the quantum phase transitions and special symmetry points in these models. We point out the relative strengths and weaknesses of correlation and coherence measures as figures of merit to witness the quantum phase transitions and symmetry points in the considered spin-1 Heisenberg chains. In particular, we demonstrate that, as none of the studied measures can detect the infinite-order Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in the XXZ model, they appear to be able to signal the existence of the same type of transition in the biliear biquadratic model. However, we argue that what is actually detected by the measures here is the SU(3) symmetry point of the model rather than the infinite-order quantum phase transition. Moreover, we show in the XXZ model that examining even single site coherence can be sufficient to spotlight the second-order phase transition and the SU(2) symmetry point.
We begin by deriving bounds for the entanglement of a spin with an (adjacent and non-adjacent) interval of spins in an arbitrary pure Finitely Correlated States (FCS). The bounds we derive become exact in the case where one considers the entanglement of a single spin with a half-infinite chain to the right of it. Our result permits a more efficient calculation, numerically and in some cases even analytically, of the entanglement in arbitrary finitely correlated quantum spin chains. We continue the study of entanglement in the setting of ground states of Hamiltonians with a spectral gap. In particular, for VVV a finite subset of ZdZ^dZd, we let HVH_VHV​ denote a Hamiltonian on VVV with finite range, finite strength interactions and a unique ground state with a non-vanishing spectral gap. For a density matrix ρAρ_AρA​ that describes the finite-volume restriction to a region AAA of the unique ground state, we provide a detailed version of a proof by M. Hastings, that the entropy of ρAρ_AρA​ is bounded by a uniform constant CCC. Moreover, we provide a detailed generalization of the 1-dimensional construction of Hastings' approximation to the ground state in dimensions 2 and higher. Finally, we turn our attention to the study of a conjecture central to Quantum Information Theory, the multiplicativity of the maximal output Schatten ppp-norm of quantum channels, for p>1p > 1p>1. In particular, we study the output 2-norm for a special class of quantum channels, the depolarized Werner-Holevo channels, and show that multiplicativity holds for a product of two identical channels in this class.
A finite-cell-scaling analysis of the spin-1 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg-Ising chain, shows that the ground-state properties are completely different than in the spin-\textonehalf{} case. Between the XY\mathrm{XY}XY gapless phase and the doublet ground-state N\'eel phase, it appears, in an extended range of the anisotropy ($0\ensuremath{\lesssim}\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\lesssim}1.18$) a characteristic Heisenberg-phase with a nonmagnetic singlet ground state, nonzero gap, and exponential decay of the correlation functions.
Local unitary operations allow for a unifying approach to the quantification of quantum correlations among the constituents of a bipartite quantum system. For pure states, the distance between a given state and its image under least-perturbing local unitary operations is a bona fide measure of quantum entanglement, the so-called entanglement of response, which can be extended to mixed states via the convex roof construction. On the other hand, when defined directly on mixed states perturbed by local unitary operations, such a distance turns out to be a bona fide measure of quantum correlations, the so-called discord of response. Exploiting this unified framework, we perform a detailed comparison between two-body entanglement and two-body quantum discord in infinite XY quantum spin chains both in symmetry-preserving and symmetry-breaking ground states as well as in thermal states at finite temperature. The results of the investigation show that in symmetry-preserving ground states the two-point quantum discord dominates over the two-point entanglement, while in symmetrybreaking ground states the two-point quantum discord is strongly suppressed and the two-point entanglement is essentially unchanged. In thermal states, for certain regimes of Hamiltonian parameters, we show that the pairwise quantum discord and the pairwise entanglement can increase with increasing thermal fluctuations.
A companion paper (Range Versus Entanglement) built a graph Laplacian from the ground state mutual information matrix of the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg (XXZ) spin chain and found that AICc model selection on the lowest eight nonzero eigenvalues consistently prefers a linear dispersion over the quadratic dispersion predicted by a continuum Laplace-Beltrami operator. This paper traces that tension and finds it is substantially, though not entirely, a methodological artifact. The exact open chain dispersion relation has a curvature inflection at k=N/2, proved analytically and confirmed numerically; a fixed eight-mode fitting window straddles or approaches this inflection whenever N is 16 or smaller, biasing AICc toward the linear model for any locally supported adjacency matrix on an open chain, whether or not it is derived from entanglement. This is demonstrated directly on a content-free, unweighted nearest-neighbor chain, which reproduces the same crossover with no physics at all, and on two-body concurrence, which shows the same crossover as mutual information. Once the fitting window is defined adaptively to stay below the proven inflection, AICc prefers the quadratic model at every informative system size. A genuine residual survives this correction: the fitted curvature of mutual information's low-k spectrum has the opposite sign from concurrence's or the ideal chain's, indicating a real, still-unexplained feature specific to spin-spin correlation derived adjacency matrices.