Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Electron Never Collapses: A Geometric Interpretation of Quantum Measurement in ZTD

Yan Zhuang

Published Sep 10, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

PrefaceThis is not a paper. It contains no rigorous mathematical proof, no complete chain ofderivation, and no peer review endorsement. It is simply a core intuition formed byan independent researcher during the construction of the ZTD theoretical framework,regarding the problem of “electron collapse.”Its purpose is to establish priority of thought, and at the same time to send asignal to potentially interested researchers: here is a path whose conceptual foundationhas been laid, and whose mathematical construction has just begun.The author has already left a large number of articles on Zenodo, attempting to openone black box after another—what is charge, what is mass, what is a field, what is energy,what is the nature of motion—and to provide the clearest physical picture. This articleis one of these thought records.If after reading this you think “this idea is somewhat interesting,” you are welcome tocontact me. If after reading this you think “this idea has problems,” you are even morewelcome to contact me.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22694066

Related papers

More on the quantum measurement problem

Gregory N. Derry

Although I have neither an objection to nor an endorsement of David Mermin’s major premise in his Quick Study, “There is no quantum measurement problem” (Physics Today, June 2022, page 62), I would like to make several contextual points.Mermin’s argument has an extensive history, along with a comparable history of rebuttal. Five decades ago Max Jammer wrote that “measurements in quantum mechanics are no more or less problematic than in classical physics, for the Hilbert space vector is only a purely formal device for relating the statistics associated with these arrangements to the physics of observations in classical physics.” That seems like a condensed version of the argument Mermin presents. On the following page, however, Jammer notes that a “problematic aspect whose serious implications were only gradually understood was the fact that as long as a quantum mechanical one-body or many-body system does not interact with macroscopic objects, as long as its motion is described by the deterministic Schrödinger time-dependent equation, no events could be considered to take place in the system.”11. M. Jammer, The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics: The Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective, Wiley (1974), pp. 473, 474.Niels Bohr giving a lecture in Copenhagen in April 1929. (Photograph by Samuel Goudsmit, courtesy of the AIP Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, Goudsmit Collection.)PPT|High resolutionRegarding the quotations from Niels Bohr, Mermin’s point is entirely valid and represents Bohr’s position accurately, but Bohr’s thought is always subtle and difficult to capture completely. Another quotation from Bohr, which is consistent with everything else he wrote, is, “The decisive point is that in neither case does the appropriate widening of our conceptual framework imply any appeal to the observing subject, which would hinder unambiguous communication of experience.”22. N. Bohr, Essays 1958–1962 on Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge, Ox Bow Press (1987), p. 7. That quotation seems inconsistent with Mermin’s paragraph that includes the passage “Why should I insist that my interpretation of science, which I use to make sense of the world that I experience, should never make any mention of me?” Bohr always insisted that his framework was a rational “generalization” of classical objectivity.The last and most conceptually important point concerns the ontological status of probability. I don’t necessarily disagree with Mermin and Bruno de Finetti, but it is by no means obvious that they are correct either. David Hawkins, for example, begins 50 pages of rigorous analysis with a brief statement of a major premise.The obvious and natural interpretation of probability in this context is that it introduces, not something that has to do with the nature of the physical system, but something that has to do with the incompleteness of our knowledge….But this opinion turns out to be false. Ignorance of dynamical regularity may be a motive for resorting to probabilities, but it does not explain the probabilities to which we resort.33. D. Hawkins, The Language of Nature: An Essay in the Philosophy of Science, W. H. Freeman (1964), p. 135.Another example can be found in Jammer’s well-known historical account of quantum theory: “For Einstein the notion of probability … was the traditional conception of classical physics, a mathematical objectivization of the human deficiency of complete or exact knowledge but ultimately a creation of the human mind…. For Born probability, as far as it was related to the wave function, was not merely a mathematical fiction but something endowed with physical reality.”44. M. Jammer, The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill (1966), p. 286.Of course, such examples don’t mean that Mermin’s position is incorrect, but I do think that they demand a better argument than a comparison to “Fairies and Witches.” I am confident that Mermin has such an argument, and I look forward to reading it as I continue working toward a coherent position on the unresolved interpretational issues of quantum theory.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. M. Jammer, The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics: The Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective, Wiley (1974), pp. 473, 474. Google Scholar2. N. Bohr, Essays 1958–1962 on Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge, Ox Bow Press (1987), p. 7. Google Scholar3. D. Hawkins, The Language of Nature: An Essay in the Philosophy of Science, W. H. Freeman (1964), p. 135. Google Scholar4. M. Jammer, The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill (1966), p. 286. Google Scholar© 2022 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Nov 1, 2022•2 citations

Electron structure

Wei Fu

This work presents a novel theoretical framework addressing a fundamental problem in atomic and quantum physics. We propose a new physical mechanism to resolve long-standing inconsistencies in the description of electron behavior within atoms, establishing a consistent physical picture that bridges classical electromagnetic principles and quantum mechanical observations. This work lays a foundational conceptual basis for further rigorous mathematical formalization, detailed theoretical derivation, and experimental validation, with the aim of formal publication in leading peer-reviewed physics journals.

•Apr 6, 2026•0 citations

Return to Physical Pictures: An Ontological Interpretation of Fundamental Physical Concepts in ZTD

Yan Zhuang

Mainstream quantum mechanics and quantum field theory have achieved unmatchedmathematical success, yet they leave numerous black boxes in the physicalpicture: what is a field, where does mass come from, why does electric charge havea sign, whether the wave function is a physical reality or a probabilistic tool, whereparticle nature comes from, and why gravity is both so weak and unquantizable.In this paper, within the framework of Marker Ontology (ZTD theory), and basedon the three core concepts of spatial primitives, nearest-neighbor propagation, andsurvivor selection, we provide a unified, natural, and intuitive ontological picturefor matter, energy, mass, momentum, charge, fields, light, gravity, spin, vacuum,quantum fluctuations, antimatter, and other fundamental physical concepts.This paper does not modify any existing mathematical prediction. However,it identifies a decisive experimental direction: the cascade interference experiment.The experiment predicts that in the strong-measurement limit the visibility of thesecond-level interference pattern does not vanish strictly, but retains a small nonzeroresidual. This differs from the predictions of the Copenhagen collapse interpretationand the many-worlds interpretation. It is currently the most important testableconsequence of the ZTD picture.Keywords: Marker Ontology; spatial primitives; constrained refreshment clusters;ontological picture; wave-particle duality; charge origin; mass–energy conversion;gravitational nature; cascade interference experiment

•Aug 29, 2026•0 citations

There is no quantum measurement problem

N. David Mermin

The idea that the collapse of a quantum state is a physical process stems from a misunderstanding of probability and the role it plays in quantum mechanics.

Physics Today•Jun 1, 2022•32 citations

Returning to Physical Pictures: ZTD's Ontological Interpretation of Fundamental Physical Concepts

Yan Zhuang

Mainstream quantum mechanics and quantum field theory have achieved unparalleled mathematical success, yet they have left numerous black boxes at the level of physical pictures: what a field is, where mass comes from, why electric charge has a sign, whether the wavefunction is physical reality or a probabilistic tool, where particle nature comes from, and why gravity is so weak and yet unquantizable. Within the framework of Marker Ontology (ZTD), based on three core concepts—the Discrete Asynchronous Poisson (DAP) network, nearest-neighbor propagation, and survivor selection—this paper provides a unified, natural, and intuitively comprehensible ontological picture for fundamental physical concepts such as matter, energy, mass, momentum, charge, field, light, gravity, spin, vacuum, quantum fluctuation, and antimatter. This paper further presents six mathematical skeletons (embedded in the corresponding physical concepts rather than arranged as a separate sequence): (1) energy as variance—energy is the statistical measure of the network's deviation from the ground state; (2) the algebraic origin of unitarity—the mode maintaining itself is equivalent to the evolution operator satisfying U†U = I; (3) the discrete algebraic root of the commutation relation—on a regular lattice, [X̂, p̂] = iℏ can be rigorously derived; (4) Hermiticity from measurement reality—the reality of measurement results requires observables to be Hermitian; (5) the algebraic cutoff of the uncertainty principle—the minimal primitive leads to a wavenumber cutoff, forming a double constraint together with the gravitational cutoff; (6) the two-state picture of the measurement problem—free state as random walk, measurement state as standing-wave reconstruction. This paper modifies no existing mathematical prediction, but provides a clear decisive experimental direction: the cascaded interference experiment. Keywords: Marker Ontology; DAP network; spatial primitive; constrained refreshment cluster; ontological picture; wave-particle duality; energy as variance; commutation relation; uncertainty principle; measurement problem; matter-antimatter asymmetry; nature of gravity; cascaded interference experiment

•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations

Decoding the Mystery of Wave Function Collapse

Ping Wang

We provide a reasonable explanation for measurement where no wave function in the sense of quantum mechanics is collapsed. The wave functions of the particles in the measuring device should be considered together with the measured particle as one system. The measurement is actually a physical process, which makes the wave functions of different paths orthogonal. The collapsed wave function is just an equivalent one to explain certain physical phenomena. There is no physical transition or process from the wave function in quantum mechanics to the equivalent one. Our understanding of measurement also provides reasonable explanations for both EPR paradox and the experiments of delayed quantum eraser

Advances in Theoretical & Computational Physics•Nov 18, 2024•0 citations
PrefaceThis is not a paper. It contains no rigorous mathematical proof, no complete chain ofderivation, and no peer review endorsement. It is simply a core intuition formed byan independent researcher during the construction of the ZTD theoretical framework,regarding the problem of “electron collapse.”Its purpose is to establish priority of thought, and at the same time to send asignal to potentially interested researchers: here is a path whose conceptual foundationhas been laid, and whose mathematical construction has just begun.The author has already left a large number of articles on Zenodo, attempting to openone black box after another—what is charge, what is mass, what is a field, what is energy,what is the nature of motion—and to provide the clearest physical picture. This articleis one of these thought records.If after reading this you think “this idea is somewhat interesting,” you are welcome tocontact me. If after reading this you think “this idea has problems,” you are even morewelcome to contact me.
Although I have neither an objection to nor an endorsement of David Mermin’s major premise in his Quick Study, “There is no quantum measurement problem” (Physics Today, June 2022, page 62), I would like to make several contextual points.Mermin’s argument has an extensive history, along with a comparable history of rebuttal. Five decades ago Max Jammer wrote that “measurements in quantum mechanics are no more or less problematic than in classical physics, for the Hilbert space vector is only a purely formal device for relating the statistics associated with these arrangements to the physics of observations in classical physics.” That seems like a condensed version of the argument Mermin presents. On the following page, however, Jammer notes that a “problematic aspect whose serious implications were only gradually understood was the fact that as long as a quantum mechanical one-body or many-body system does not interact with macroscopic objects, as long as its motion is described by the deterministic Schrödinger time-dependent equation, no events could be considered to take place in the system.”11. M. Jammer, The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics: The Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective, Wiley (1974), pp. 473, 474.Niels Bohr giving a lecture in Copenhagen in April 1929. (Photograph by Samuel Goudsmit, courtesy of the AIP Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, Goudsmit Collection.)PPT|High resolutionRegarding the quotations from Niels Bohr, Mermin’s point is entirely valid and represents Bohr’s position accurately, but Bohr’s thought is always subtle and difficult to capture completely. Another quotation from Bohr, which is consistent with everything else he wrote, is, “The decisive point is that in neither case does the appropriate widening of our conceptual framework imply any appeal to the observing subject, which would hinder unambiguous communication of experience.”22. N. Bohr, Essays 1958–1962 on Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge, Ox Bow Press (1987), p. 7. That quotation seems inconsistent with Mermin’s paragraph that includes the passage “Why should I insist that my interpretation of science, which I use to make sense of the world that I experience, should never make any mention of me?” Bohr always insisted that his framework was a rational “generalization” of classical objectivity.The last and most conceptually important point concerns the ontological status of probability. I don’t necessarily disagree with Mermin and Bruno de Finetti, but it is by no means obvious that they are correct either. David Hawkins, for example, begins 50 pages of rigorous analysis with a brief statement of a major premise.The obvious and natural interpretation of probability in this context is that it introduces, not something that has to do with the nature of the physical system, but something that has to do with the incompleteness of our knowledge….But this opinion turns out to be false. Ignorance of dynamical regularity may be a motive for resorting to probabilities, but it does not explain the probabilities to which we resort.33. D. Hawkins, The Language of Nature: An Essay in the Philosophy of Science, W. H. Freeman (1964), p. 135.Another example can be found in Jammer’s well-known historical account of quantum theory: “For Einstein the notion of probability … was the traditional conception of classical physics, a mathematical objectivization of the human deficiency of complete or exact knowledge but ultimately a creation of the human mind…. For Born probability, as far as it was related to the wave function, was not merely a mathematical fiction but something endowed with physical reality.”44. M. Jammer, The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill (1966), p. 286.Of course, such examples don’t mean that Mermin’s position is incorrect, but I do think that they demand a better argument than a comparison to “Fairies and Witches.” I am confident that Mermin has such an argument, and I look forward to reading it as I continue working toward a coherent position on the unresolved interpretational issues of quantum theory.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. M. Jammer, The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics: The Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective, Wiley (1974), pp. 473, 474. Google Scholar2. N. Bohr, Essays 1958–1962 on Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge, Ox Bow Press (1987), p. 7. Google Scholar3. D. Hawkins, The Language of Nature: An Essay in the Philosophy of Science, W. H. Freeman (1964), p. 135. Google Scholar4. M. Jammer, The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill (1966), p. 286. Google Scholar© 2022 American Institute of Physics.
This work presents a novel theoretical framework addressing a fundamental problem in atomic and quantum physics. We propose a new physical mechanism to resolve long-standing inconsistencies in the description of electron behavior within atoms, establishing a consistent physical picture that bridges classical electromagnetic principles and quantum mechanical observations. This work lays a foundational conceptual basis for further rigorous mathematical formalization, detailed theoretical derivation, and experimental validation, with the aim of formal publication in leading peer-reviewed physics journals.
Mainstream quantum mechanics and quantum field theory have achieved unmatchedmathematical success, yet they leave numerous black boxes in the physicalpicture: what is a field, where does mass come from, why does electric charge havea sign, whether the wave function is a physical reality or a probabilistic tool, whereparticle nature comes from, and why gravity is both so weak and unquantizable.In this paper, within the framework of Marker Ontology (ZTD theory), and basedon the three core concepts of spatial primitives, nearest-neighbor propagation, andsurvivor selection, we provide a unified, natural, and intuitive ontological picturefor matter, energy, mass, momentum, charge, fields, light, gravity, spin, vacuum,quantum fluctuations, antimatter, and other fundamental physical concepts.This paper does not modify any existing mathematical prediction. However,it identifies a decisive experimental direction: the cascade interference experiment.The experiment predicts that in the strong-measurement limit the visibility of thesecond-level interference pattern does not vanish strictly, but retains a small nonzeroresidual. This differs from the predictions of the Copenhagen collapse interpretationand the many-worlds interpretation. It is currently the most important testableconsequence of the ZTD picture.Keywords: Marker Ontology; spatial primitives; constrained refreshment clusters;ontological picture; wave-particle duality; charge origin; mass–energy conversion;gravitational nature; cascade interference experiment
Mainstream quantum mechanics and quantum field theory have achieved unparalleled mathematical success, yet they have left numerous black boxes at the level of physical pictures: what a field is, where mass comes from, why electric charge has a sign, whether the wavefunction is physical reality or a probabilistic tool, where particle nature comes from, and why gravity is so weak and yet unquantizable. Within the framework of Marker Ontology (ZTD), based on three core concepts—the Discrete Asynchronous Poisson (DAP) network, nearest-neighbor propagation, and survivor selection—this paper provides a unified, natural, and intuitively comprehensible ontological picture for fundamental physical concepts such as matter, energy, mass, momentum, charge, field, light, gravity, spin, vacuum, quantum fluctuation, and antimatter. This paper further presents six mathematical skeletons (embedded in the corresponding physical concepts rather than arranged as a separate sequence): (1) energy as variance—energy is the statistical measure of the network's deviation from the ground state; (2) the algebraic origin of unitarity—the mode maintaining itself is equivalent to the evolution operator satisfying U†U = I; (3) the discrete algebraic root of the commutation relation—on a regular lattice, [X̂, p̂] = iℏ can be rigorously derived; (4) Hermiticity from measurement reality—the reality of measurement results requires observables to be Hermitian; (5) the algebraic cutoff of the uncertainty principle—the minimal primitive leads to a wavenumber cutoff, forming a double constraint together with the gravitational cutoff; (6) the two-state picture of the measurement problem—free state as random walk, measurement state as standing-wave reconstruction. This paper modifies no existing mathematical prediction, but provides a clear decisive experimental direction: the cascaded interference experiment. Keywords: Marker Ontology; DAP network; spatial primitive; constrained refreshment cluster; ontological picture; wave-particle duality; energy as variance; commutation relation; uncertainty principle; measurement problem; matter-antimatter asymmetry; nature of gravity; cascaded interference experiment
We provide a reasonable explanation for measurement where no wave function in the sense of quantum mechanics is collapsed. The wave functions of the particles in the measuring device should be considered together with the measured particle as one system. The measurement is actually a physical process, which makes the wave functions of different paths orthogonal. The collapsed wave function is just an equivalent one to explain certain physical phenomena. There is no physical transition or process from the wave function in quantum mechanics to the equivalent one. Our understanding of measurement also provides reasonable explanations for both EPR paradox and the experiments of delayed quantum eraser