Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Fisher-Information No-Go Theorems for Emergent Interaction, and a Shared-Field Construction

El Bouazzaoui TAYB

Published Sep 6, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The hypothesis that physical information is not fundamentally destroyed motivates a mathematical question: can localization, correlation, and effective interaction be generated from an information-based variational principle without inserting the desired interaction potential by hand? We investigate this question in a framework built on the classical Fisher information of probability densities, organized around a strict anti-circularity requirement: no Coulomb kernel, inverse-distance potential, or prescribed interaction law is introduced into the fundamental functional. Several results are established at increasing levels of generality. First, under normalization and a fixed second moment, the Fisher information obeys the sharp bound I[ρ]≥d2/R2I[ρ]≥d2/R2, with equality attained uniquely by the isotropic Gaussian; this solves the one-body constrained problem completely. Second, for any joint density ρ12ρ12 with prescribed marginals, I12[ρ12]≥I[ρ1]+I[ρ2]I12[ρ12]≥I[ρ1]+I[ρ2], with equality attained by the product density; consequently a purely local, block-additive Fisher functional cannot generate an effective interaction at any separation, Keff(R)≡0Keff(R)≡0. Third, this no-go result is shown to be far more robust than the local case alone suggests: for any hidden-variable extension Q(x1,x2,z)Q(x1,x2,z) of a two-body density, ∀ Q(x1,x2,z):I[Q] ≥ I[ρ12] ≥ I[ρ1]+I[ρ2],∀Q(x1,x2,z):I[Q] ≥ I[ρ12] ≥ I[ρ1]+I[ρ2], unconditionally, with no independence, factorization, or weak-coupling assumption placed on the auxiliary variable zz, provided the enlarged functional remains the Fisher information of the enlarged density; no claim is made about enlargements governed by an arbitrary non-Fisher coupling of zz. Within that scope, this closes off an entire class of hidden-variable evasions of the no-go theorem at once, rather than ruling out evasions one construction at a time -- a consequence obtained by combining the superadditivity of Fisher information under marginalization, established by Carlen, with a further marginalization over the auxiliary sector; the contribution of this article is the variational reading of that combination as a no-interaction obstruction, together with an exact conditional-variance identity sharpening its equality case, rather than the underlying information inequality itself. We further characterize equality in the first marginalization step: equality of the full Fisher informations forces the auxiliary sector to factorize and to carry zero Fisher information, so on an unbounded connected auxiliary domain the equality case is impossible for a proper normalized density. We then show, with an explicit lower-bound hypothesis made a formal part of the statement rather than left implicit, that exact vanishing of KeffKeff follows whenever the auxiliary extension is block-factorized across the two subsystems, the governing functional contains no explicit cross-sector coupling term prior to elimination, and the functional obeys a block-additive lower bound over the entire admissible class (not merely on factorized configurations); the Fisher bound supplies this hypothesis automatically in the Fisher case. Conversely, Keff≠0Keff=0 implies that no admissible block-factorized configuration can realize the independent optimum, though the converse implication does not hold without further hypotheses. We then exhibit a concrete construction that violates factorization: an auxiliary scalar field sourced jointly by both subsystems. The functional E[ϕ,ρ]=κ2∫∣∇ϕ∣2−g∫sρϕE[ϕ,ρ]=2κ∫∣∇ϕ∣2−g∫sρϕ produces, after eliminating ϕϕ, a nonlocal quadratic functional with the Green kernel of the Laplacian, yielding a 1/R1/R interaction in three dimensions. We show carefully that this mechanism is not explained by the nonlocality of the map ρ↦ϕρ↦ϕ: a model with two independent, equally nonlocal fields remains sector-separable, and we verify directly (rather than by importing the Fisher-specific bound into a classical field functional, where it does not automatically apply) that its infimum splits additively, giving Keff≡0Keff≡0. The operative property behind the nonzero result is instead that a single shared field is sourced by the total density, which forces a cross term ∫∇ϕA⋅∇ϕB∫∇ϕA⋅∇ϕB absent from any factorized configuration. This mechanism reaches only the third of four levels in an anti-circularity hierarchy that we introduce; whether the field itself can be derived, rather than postulated, from an information-theoretic principle remains open. The resulting framework separates four logically distinct conclusions: a proved localization theorem, a proved no-interaction theorem for local Fisher information, an unconditional lower bound ruling out entire classes of hidden-variable evasions, and a concrete non-factorized extension whose physical interpretation and information-theoretic origin remain to be established. We close by fixing this boundary precisely and organizing the remaining program around a single unresolved question — whether a non-factorized shared mediator can itself be derived from an information-theoretic principle, rather than postulated — so that the present results are used as a fixed starting constraint on that question rather than reopened by it.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22532458

Related papers

A Coherence Connection on Fisher–Rao Probability Geometry

Barker Christian

A mathematically explicit extension of quantum hydrodynamics is developed in which a scalar coherence field ΦG modifies phase transport and is driven by the information-geometric structure of the probability density together with probability transport itself. The construction starts from the Madelung representation Ψ = √ρ eiS/ℏ, augments the phase gradient by the covariant shift ∇S ↦ ∇S − αℏ∇ΦG, and defines the dynamics through a variational (ρ, S) sector together with a dissipative Onsager-type relaxation law for ΦG. This yields a closed PDE system consisting of a continuity equation, a modified Hamilton–Jacobi equation, and a coherence-field equation that reduces in the overdamped limit to an elliptic closure. The source of ΦG is neither bare mass density nor bare probability density: it is a local Fisher-information density together with probability transport, so that ΦG measures coherence demand. The field equations are written explicitly; the coupling sign is fixed by an energy-stability argument, the transport-forcing sign by a dissipation argument, and the induced coherence-pressure term is computed exactly. A structural no-signalling condition is obtained by restricting the nonlinearity to Fisher-marginal source functionals that are blind to the entanglement Fisher excess under marginalisation. A coarse-grained Yukawa sector is shown to admit a conditional Newtonian limit under explicitly stated screening and additivity assumptions; this remains a conjectural macroscopic regime rather than a completed derivation of gravity. The paper closes with a falsifiable numerical programme—ablation studies, dispersion diagnostics, Fisher-information monitoring, and an explicit pilot solver scaffold—together with a claim-status ledger, a testability map, and a development roadmap that separate what is defined, what is derived, what is heuristic, and what remains unproven. Keywords: quantum hydrodynamics; Fisher–Rao geometry; Madelung dynamics; coherence field; no-signalling; information geometry.

•Jun 6, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Information and the Fundamental Phenomenality Hypothesis: A Representation Theorem, Non-Implication Results, and Witness Constraints on Constitutive Quantum Claims

Caesar Martinez

The Fundamental Phenomenality Hypothesis (FPH) identifies phenomenal consciousness with states of a hierarchical generative model, and defines its self-reference component through conditional mutual information, which admits a natural quantum lift. We separate a representational extension, in which classical information measures are replaced by quantum ones, from a constitutive extension, in which a certified nonclassical resource makes a nonredundant causal difference to an FPH variable. For the first we prove a representation theorem: with independently anchored roles in finite dimensions, the lifted functional is well defined, recovers the parent theory exactly on role-compatible product-basis-diagonal states, is invariant under an explicit gauge group, and carries bounded role ambiguity and open-system error through explicit uncertainty bounds, requiring no auxiliary coupling constant and no privileged classicalization map; among lifts linear in the marginal entropies it is the unique one with the correct classical limit. For the second we prove non-implication results: entangled and classical realizations can share every quantity the functional uses, every finite causal experiment admits an exact classical stochastic model, and a scalar measurement cannot separate a small quantum perturbation from a tuned ordinary one to first order. Radical-pair spin chemistry then supplies exact coherence witnesses together with control-theoretic and phase-versus-loss obstructions to implementing them, each stated within its hypotheses. An engineered construction separates a quantum implementation from every matched separable one, and the separation can be certified from three correlators. We close with identifiability results for the parent framework.

•Oct 17, 2026•0 citations

Fisher-Information Geometry Linking Schrodinger Dynamics, Bipartite Correlations, and Decoherence

J. Sumaya-Martinez

Fisher information appears in quantum theory in two mathematically distinct settings: as a classical probability functional in variational reconstructions of Schrodinger dynamics and as the quantum Fisher metric of parameterized density operators. Here we examine how far these roles can be connected without identifying the two objects. Starting from a Hamilton-Jacobi ensemble action, we recover the Fisher term that generates the quantum potential and isolate its contribution to the kinetic-energy expectation. We then analyze the quantum Fisher information matrix (QFIM) of bipartite states. For any pure two-qubit state, the optimized magnitude of the off-diagonal QFIM element for normalized local generators equals the concurrence, while a collective phase generator yields FQ = 4 C^2. Extending the optimized pure-state quantity by a convex roof gives an exact identity with Wootters concurrence for arbitrary mixed two-qubit states. This differs from evaluating the QFIM directly on a mixed density operator: for Werner states the raw optimized cross-QFIM is 2 p^2/(1 + p) and remains nonzero inside the separable region. The gap between the raw and convex-roof quantities therefore isolates, for this family, correlation geometry not captured by entanglement. Finally, in a two-path interferometer with a which-way marker, the optimal phase Fisher information available from local output statistics is I_phi^opt = V^2. These results place probability-gradient energy, bipartite correlation geometry, entanglement, and decoherence-induced loss of local phase sensitivity in a common mathematical setting while preserving the distinctions between classical Fisher information, QFIM geometry, Bell nonlocality, and global phase quantization.

quant-pharXiv:2609.26159•Aug 11, 2026•0 citations

The Fisher Information Action for Quantum Dynamics

Jesper Lyng Jensen

This work develops a Lorentz-invariant variational framework in which Fisher-information geometry appears as an intrinsic structural contribution to quantum dynamics. Motivated by longstanding attempts to connect quantum mechanics with information-theoretic principles, we introduce an action functional depending on the density and phase fields in the Madelung representation. Variation of this action yields a modified Klein–Gordon equation containing a single nonlinear term proportional to the four-dimensional Fisher-information curvature of the probability density. The standard Klein–Gordon equation is recovered when the structural parameter vanishes, ensuring full compatibility with established relativistic dynamics. Taking the nonrelativistic limit, we obtain a uniquely determined nonlinear Schrödinger equation in which the correction term is the functional derivative of the Fisher information. The resulting dynamics preserve probability, maintain the Hamilton–Jacobi correspondence, and contain the linear Schrödinger equation as a special case. Analytical expressions for Gaussian and superposed states demonstrate how the structural modification scales with spatial localization and interference structure, providing clear qualitative signatures that distinguish the model from previous nonlinear extensions and offer a theoretical basis for future experimental verification. The results establish a mathematically transparent link between information geometry and quantum dynamics and provide a foundation for future extensions to fermionic, gauge, and many-body systems.

•Dec 16, 2025•1 citation

The Converse Madelung Question

Jonathan R Dunkley

We pose the converse Madelung question: not whether Fisher information can reproduce quantum mechanics, but whether it is necessary. We work with minimal, physically motivated axioms on density and phase: locality, probability conservation, Euclidean invariance with a global phase symmetry, reversibility, and convex regularity. Within the resulting class of first order local Hamiltonian field theories, these axioms single out the canonical Poisson bracket on density and phase under the Dubrovin and Novikov assumptions for local hydrodynamic brackets. Using a pointwise, gauge covariant complex change of variables that maps density and phase to a single complex field, we show that the only convex, rotationally invariant, first derivative local functional of the density whose Euler Lagrange term yields a reversible completion that is exactly projectively linear is the Fisher functional. When its coefficient equals Planck constant squared divided by twice the mass, the dynamics reduce to the linear Schrodinger equation. For many body systems, a single local complex structure across sectors enforces the same relation species by species, fixing a single Planck constant. Galilean covariance appears through the Bargmann central extension, with the usual superselection consequences. Comparison with the Doebner and Goldin family identifies the reversible zero diffusion corner with linear Schrodinger dynamics. We provide operational falsifiers via residual diagnostics for the continuity and Hamilton Jacobi equations and report numerical minima at the Fisher scale that are invariant under Galilean boosts. In this setting, quantum mechanics emerges as a reversible fixed point of Fisher regularised information hydrodynamics. A code archive enables direct numerical checks, including a superposition stress test that preserves exact projective linearity within our axioms.

quant-pharXiv:2511.03552•Nov 6, 2025•0 citations

From Distinction to a Functional Triad: A Framework-Relative Ontology of Coherent Domain-Relative Self-Representation with Oriented Defects, Common Stationary Geometry, and Audited Physics Bridges

Paweł Krzysztof Chomiuk

This paper develops a framework-relative ontology of determinacy. Its core question is not what the world is made of, but what must minimally be accounted for if a stable deter- minate identity is internally self-representing. The primitive and functional core of Version 3.8 is retained: Being, the possibility of distinction, and domain-relative realizability define the sparse primitive basis; coherent self-representation then requires three non-equivalent func- tional questions—Support, Internal Encoding, and Correspondence. Explicit finite witness pairs establish uniform non-determination of each role from the other two in the unrestricted baseline class, while stronger canonical or equivariant subclasses remain open. Version 4.1.1 is a corrective consolidation of Version 4.1 rather than a new upstream on- tology step. It retains the Version 4.0 bridge revision and the Version 4.1 constructional layer. That layer adds the reverse evaluative direction Physics ⇒ Mathematics ⇒ Ontology and records where downstream structures constrain, but do not retroactively constitute, the ontol- ogy. Several previous bridge claims are weakened or rejected. Symmetry classification, tensor factorization, entanglement of a state, and path-dependent dynamics are kept as four distinct mathematical layers. A conditional expectation is treated as a localization map rather than as actualization; a branch instrument defines possible conditional events but does not select one realized branch; and a projection onto admissible spectral sectors is not called conservative dynamics without an independently derived dilation. The causal and propagation bridge is sharpened in two directions. First, a previous can- didate definition of a null relation by vanishing accumulated interval volume is proved degen- erate: every comparable pair admits a chain of links, so that criterion vanishes throughout the causal order. Link ensembles remain useful near-null approximants, but the null sector is therefore a limiting or measure-relative object rather than a pair-local primitive in the de- clared causal-set model. Second, the long-range free-chain calculation at 𝛼 = 2 is separated into two non-commuting limits. The infinite-range spectral symbol has maximal group veloc- ity 𝜋𝐽𝑎, whereas the envelope of finite-cutoff maxima tends to 2𝐽𝑎 Si(𝜋). These are spectral group-velocity statements; a causal signal cone still requires separate Lieb–Robinson-type hy- potheses. Isotropy and a unique physical Lorentz cone remain open. The defect bridge is updated with the completed 𝐾 = 512 data layer of the frozen ratio campaign. All 903 prescribed values of 𝜃 are present with eight branches each; 897 aggregate points are admissible and six lie in a short rejected interval. Neither √ 2 nor 𝜙 is a local or global minimum. The original preregistered primary ratio test nevertheless remains non- evaluable because its 𝐾 = 64 training gate is universally degenerate. Thus 𝐾 = 512 completes a characterization block; it does not retrospectively repair the primary estimator. Provenance registration and cross-platform verification remain pending. Version 4.0 turned Test 28A into an explicit reconstruction audit, and Version 4.1 retains that audit unchanged. For the standard three one-body extractions on ℋ = (C 3 ) ⊗3 , the combined linear map has exact rank 25 and kernel dimension 704. The hidden space splits as 192 two-body plus 512 fully traceless three-body directions; even the full 𝑆3-invariant class retains an exact 156-dimensional hidden sector. The preregistered continuation identifies an exact energy-selected fixed point, the totally antisymmetric state |𝜀⟩, while holonomy and variance objectives yield set-valued argmin correspondences. The historical non-triviality gate is therefore preserved but shown not to be a universal criterion, and no retroactive 𝑉28.4 verdict is declared. A prospectively frozen two-local QPH family provides an exact computer-assisted existence witness: its cycle-phase differential has rank 704/704 on the marginal kernel for the primary family and two preregistered replications, so marginals plus relational cycle phases are locally in- formationally complete in the fixed regularity stratum. Canonical modular-mismatch selectors are then audited rather than assumed. Identical additive qutrit references and every single pure mismatch under exact 𝑆3 protection obey strict capacity/rank no-go bounds. On the protected 156-dimensional domain a physically generated mixed mismatch has sufficient raw capacity but standard phase-only QPH remains incomplete. Exact cumulant analysis explains why order three is the natural next layer: the 𝑆3-hidden sector decomposes as 156 = 36 + 120, and the third connected cumulant is a complete affine coordinate on fibres of fixed proper marginals. A historical preregistered cubic-moment completion is retained only as a delicate T-NUM wit- ness, not as a theorem premise. This is the declared stopping point of the arity/cubic line: selecting one specific cubic observable would require a new independent physical law. Test 28B remains suspended. Version 4.0 added one further macro-level correction, retained in Version 4.1. Causal and conformal structure, transport geometry, stable matter sectors, and quantum correlations are treated as parallel downstream representations of one substrate model, not as a serial matter– space–time chain. A proposed identification of the matter admissibility projector Πadm with spacetime volume is rejected in its literal form: the projector is matter-branch specific, need not be nested under generative updates, and has no canonical finite trace in a type-III con- tinuum. In its place a conditional causal–transport conformal closure theorem is proved. If a causal reconstruction supplies a Lorentzian conformal class and an independent transport limit supplies a positive spatial metric on the same spacelike distribution, the conformal factor is fixed pointwise exactly when the two induced spatial metrics are conformally compatible. A scale-free generalized-eigenvalue defect provides a direct falsifier. The corresponding clock– cone–matter gate is also corrected by conformal weight: frequencies and dimensionful spectral scales have lapse weight one under a pure lapse deformation, whereas spectral ratios, localiza- tion fractions, and dimensionless stability-window coordinates have weight zero. A Tolman– thermal-time comparison is retained only as a relative lapse-profile gate; absolute time units remain open. Version 4.1 introduced a controlled common-substrate realization. Version 4.1.1 corrects its scope: parity alone excludes only an odd or linear mass/source identification with the same signed coordinate; an even law such as 𝑀 ∝ 𝑑 2 is not excluded by parity. On the declared graph Klein–Gordon sector, charge conjugation reverses Noether/gauge-current orientation while leaving mode energy and localization intensity unchanged. A grounded-graph Green- kernel theorem fixes the spatial uniformity of the cross-term sign, while the Coulomb sign itself is conditional on realizing a non-dynamical 𝐴0-type constraint sector; the same kernel in a dynamical scalar sector gives the opposite sign. A separate no-go proves that matter Dirichlet energy alone cannot select a nontrivial interior geometry. A state-selected positive geometry Hessian yields the conditional linear response 𝑦 = 𝐾 −1 𝐸 𝜏 , so weak 𝐶-even stress sources add while 𝐶-odd currents can cancel. The principal new bridge is a conditional stationary common causal–transport–matter con- struction. If one protected center supplies a common base, the transport branch supplies a positive spatial metric ℎ, and several modular/physical clocks agree on one relative lapse 𝑁, then 𝑔CTM = −𝑐 2 *𝑁2𝑑𝑇2 + ℎ has one timelike sign, predicts the same null front for all canonically normalized matter sectors, and fixes its stationary volume element without an additional scalar measure. Different masses and opposite 𝑈(1) representation weights remain lower-order data and do not alter the characteristic cone. The independently reconstructed HSMI conformal class remains a held-out test rather than an input to this construction. A second independent Version 4.1 result supplies a conditional physical law selecting com- plex rank two. A nonzero-Chern line cannot be closed under conjugation at rank one on 𝑆 2 , whereas 𝐿 ⊕ 𝐿¯ is the minimal conjugation-closed carrier; independently, ClC 2 ≃ 𝑀2(C) has minimal irreducible complex module dimension two. The existing odd-Chern defect-link con struction realizes this pair. If its Clifford algebra is physically admissible, the local carrier has 𝑀2(C) qubit kinematics. This is not an assertion that opposite electric charges form a coherent qubit, nor that every particle is a qubit. The resulting Version 4.1.1 is a constrained foundational proposal with a frozen primitive core, stronger positive and negative bridge results, a first common stationary geometry can- didate, an independently motivated minimal rank-two carrier, and a reproducibility-oriented ledger for every step from ontological determinacy toward physics. It also makes the external spin-sign, soft-graviton, equivalence-principle, and mass-budget inputs explicit without treat- ing them as evidence for the ontology.

•Jul 20, 2026•0 citations
The hypothesis that physical information is not fundamentally destroyed motivates a mathematical question: can localization, correlation, and effective interaction be generated from an information-based variational principle without inserting the desired interaction potential by hand? We investigate this question in a framework built on the classical Fisher information of probability densities, organized around a strict anti-circularity requirement: no Coulomb kernel, inverse-distance potential, or prescribed interaction law is introduced into the fundamental functional. Several results are established at increasing levels of generality. First, under normalization and a fixed second moment, the Fisher information obeys the sharp bound I[ρ]≥d2/R2I[ρ]≥d2/R2, with equality attained uniquely by the isotropic Gaussian; this solves the one-body constrained problem completely. Second, for any joint density ρ12ρ12 with prescribed marginals, I12[ρ12]≥I[ρ1]+I[ρ2]I12[ρ12]≥I[ρ1]+I[ρ2], with equality attained by the product density; consequently a purely local, block-additive Fisher functional cannot generate an effective interaction at any separation, Keff(R)≡0Keff(R)≡0. Third, this no-go result is shown to be far more robust than the local case alone suggests: for any hidden-variable extension Q(x1,x2,z)Q(x1,x2,z) of a two-body density, ∀ Q(x1,x2,z):I[Q] ≥ I[ρ12] ≥ I[ρ1]+I[ρ2],∀Q(x1,x2,z):I[Q] ≥ I[ρ12] ≥ I[ρ1]+I[ρ2], unconditionally, with no independence, factorization, or weak-coupling assumption placed on the auxiliary variable zz, provided the enlarged functional remains the Fisher information of the enlarged density; no claim is made about enlargements governed by an arbitrary non-Fisher coupling of zz. Within that scope, this closes off an entire class of hidden-variable evasions of the no-go theorem at once, rather than ruling out evasions one construction at a time -- a consequence obtained by combining the superadditivity of Fisher information under marginalization, established by Carlen, with a further marginalization over the auxiliary sector; the contribution of this article is the variational reading of that combination as a no-interaction obstruction, together with an exact conditional-variance identity sharpening its equality case, rather than the underlying information inequality itself. We further characterize equality in the first marginalization step: equality of the full Fisher informations forces the auxiliary sector to factorize and to carry zero Fisher information, so on an unbounded connected auxiliary domain the equality case is impossible for a proper normalized density. We then show, with an explicit lower-bound hypothesis made a formal part of the statement rather than left implicit, that exact vanishing of KeffKeff follows whenever the auxiliary extension is block-factorized across the two subsystems, the governing functional contains no explicit cross-sector coupling term prior to elimination, and the functional obeys a block-additive lower bound over the entire admissible class (not merely on factorized configurations); the Fisher bound supplies this hypothesis automatically in the Fisher case. Conversely, Keff≠0Keff=0 implies that no admissible block-factorized configuration can realize the independent optimum, though the converse implication does not hold without further hypotheses. We then exhibit a concrete construction that violates factorization: an auxiliary scalar field sourced jointly by both subsystems. The functional E[ϕ,ρ]=κ2∫∣∇ϕ∣2−g∫sρϕE[ϕ,ρ]=2κ∫∣∇ϕ∣2−g∫sρϕ produces, after eliminating ϕϕ, a nonlocal quadratic functional with the Green kernel of the Laplacian, yielding a 1/R1/R interaction in three dimensions. We show carefully that this mechanism is not explained by the nonlocality of the map ρ↦ϕρ↦ϕ: a model with two independent, equally nonlocal fields remains sector-separable, and we verify directly (rather than by importing the Fisher-specific bound into a classical field functional, where it does not automatically apply) that its infimum splits additively, giving Keff≡0Keff≡0. The operative property behind the nonzero result is instead that a single shared field is sourced by the total density, which forces a cross term ∫∇ϕA⋅∇ϕB∫∇ϕA⋅∇ϕB absent from any factorized configuration. This mechanism reaches only the third of four levels in an anti-circularity hierarchy that we introduce; whether the field itself can be derived, rather than postulated, from an information-theoretic principle remains open. The resulting framework separates four logically distinct conclusions: a proved localization theorem, a proved no-interaction theorem for local Fisher information, an unconditional lower bound ruling out entire classes of hidden-variable evasions, and a concrete non-factorized extension whose physical interpretation and information-theoretic origin remain to be established. We close by fixing this boundary precisely and organizing the remaining program around a single unresolved question — whether a non-factorized shared mediator can itself be derived from an information-theoretic principle, rather than postulated — so that the present results are used as a fixed starting constraint on that question rather than reopened by it.
A mathematically explicit extension of quantum hydrodynamics is developed in which a scalar coherence field ΦG modifies phase transport and is driven by the information-geometric structure of the probability density together with probability transport itself. The construction starts from the Madelung representation Ψ = √ρ eiS/ℏ, augments the phase gradient by the covariant shift ∇S ↦ ∇S − αℏ∇ΦG, and defines the dynamics through a variational (ρ, S) sector together with a dissipative Onsager-type relaxation law for ΦG. This yields a closed PDE system consisting of a continuity equation, a modified Hamilton–Jacobi equation, and a coherence-field equation that reduces in the overdamped limit to an elliptic closure. The source of ΦG is neither bare mass density nor bare probability density: it is a local Fisher-information density together with probability transport, so that ΦG measures coherence demand. The field equations are written explicitly; the coupling sign is fixed by an energy-stability argument, the transport-forcing sign by a dissipation argument, and the induced coherence-pressure term is computed exactly. A structural no-signalling condition is obtained by restricting the nonlinearity to Fisher-marginal source functionals that are blind to the entanglement Fisher excess under marginalisation. A coarse-grained Yukawa sector is shown to admit a conditional Newtonian limit under explicitly stated screening and additivity assumptions; this remains a conjectural macroscopic regime rather than a completed derivation of gravity. The paper closes with a falsifiable numerical programme—ablation studies, dispersion diagnostics, Fisher-information monitoring, and an explicit pilot solver scaffold—together with a claim-status ledger, a testability map, and a development roadmap that separate what is defined, what is derived, what is heuristic, and what remains unproven. Keywords: quantum hydrodynamics; Fisher–Rao geometry; Madelung dynamics; coherence field; no-signalling; information geometry.
The Fundamental Phenomenality Hypothesis (FPH) identifies phenomenal consciousness with states of a hierarchical generative model, and defines its self-reference component through conditional mutual information, which admits a natural quantum lift. We separate a representational extension, in which classical information measures are replaced by quantum ones, from a constitutive extension, in which a certified nonclassical resource makes a nonredundant causal difference to an FPH variable. For the first we prove a representation theorem: with independently anchored roles in finite dimensions, the lifted functional is well defined, recovers the parent theory exactly on role-compatible product-basis-diagonal states, is invariant under an explicit gauge group, and carries bounded role ambiguity and open-system error through explicit uncertainty bounds, requiring no auxiliary coupling constant and no privileged classicalization map; among lifts linear in the marginal entropies it is the unique one with the correct classical limit. For the second we prove non-implication results: entangled and classical realizations can share every quantity the functional uses, every finite causal experiment admits an exact classical stochastic model, and a scalar measurement cannot separate a small quantum perturbation from a tuned ordinary one to first order. Radical-pair spin chemistry then supplies exact coherence witnesses together with control-theoretic and phase-versus-loss obstructions to implementing them, each stated within its hypotheses. An engineered construction separates a quantum implementation from every matched separable one, and the separation can be certified from three correlators. We close with identifiability results for the parent framework.
Fisher information appears in quantum theory in two mathematically distinct settings: as a classical probability functional in variational reconstructions of Schrodinger dynamics and as the quantum Fisher metric of parameterized density operators. Here we examine how far these roles can be connected without identifying the two objects. Starting from a Hamilton-Jacobi ensemble action, we recover the Fisher term that generates the quantum potential and isolate its contribution to the kinetic-energy expectation. We then analyze the quantum Fisher information matrix (QFIM) of bipartite states. For any pure two-qubit state, the optimized magnitude of the off-diagonal QFIM element for normalized local generators equals the concurrence, while a collective phase generator yields FQ = 4 C^2. Extending the optimized pure-state quantity by a convex roof gives an exact identity with Wootters concurrence for arbitrary mixed two-qubit states. This differs from evaluating the QFIM directly on a mixed density operator: for Werner states the raw optimized cross-QFIM is 2 p^2/(1 + p) and remains nonzero inside the separable region. The gap between the raw and convex-roof quantities therefore isolates, for this family, correlation geometry not captured by entanglement. Finally, in a two-path interferometer with a which-way marker, the optimal phase Fisher information available from local output statistics is I_phi^opt = V^2. These results place probability-gradient energy, bipartite correlation geometry, entanglement, and decoherence-induced loss of local phase sensitivity in a common mathematical setting while preserving the distinctions between classical Fisher information, QFIM geometry, Bell nonlocality, and global phase quantization.
This work develops a Lorentz-invariant variational framework in which Fisher-information geometry appears as an intrinsic structural contribution to quantum dynamics. Motivated by longstanding attempts to connect quantum mechanics with information-theoretic principles, we introduce an action functional depending on the density and phase fields in the Madelung representation. Variation of this action yields a modified Klein–Gordon equation containing a single nonlinear term proportional to the four-dimensional Fisher-information curvature of the probability density. The standard Klein–Gordon equation is recovered when the structural parameter vanishes, ensuring full compatibility with established relativistic dynamics. Taking the nonrelativistic limit, we obtain a uniquely determined nonlinear Schrödinger equation in which the correction term is the functional derivative of the Fisher information. The resulting dynamics preserve probability, maintain the Hamilton–Jacobi correspondence, and contain the linear Schrödinger equation as a special case. Analytical expressions for Gaussian and superposed states demonstrate how the structural modification scales with spatial localization and interference structure, providing clear qualitative signatures that distinguish the model from previous nonlinear extensions and offer a theoretical basis for future experimental verification. The results establish a mathematically transparent link between information geometry and quantum dynamics and provide a foundation for future extensions to fermionic, gauge, and many-body systems.
We pose the converse Madelung question: not whether Fisher information can reproduce quantum mechanics, but whether it is necessary. We work with minimal, physically motivated axioms on density and phase: locality, probability conservation, Euclidean invariance with a global phase symmetry, reversibility, and convex regularity. Within the resulting class of first order local Hamiltonian field theories, these axioms single out the canonical Poisson bracket on density and phase under the Dubrovin and Novikov assumptions for local hydrodynamic brackets. Using a pointwise, gauge covariant complex change of variables that maps density and phase to a single complex field, we show that the only convex, rotationally invariant, first derivative local functional of the density whose Euler Lagrange term yields a reversible completion that is exactly projectively linear is the Fisher functional. When its coefficient equals Planck constant squared divided by twice the mass, the dynamics reduce to the linear Schrodinger equation. For many body systems, a single local complex structure across sectors enforces the same relation species by species, fixing a single Planck constant. Galilean covariance appears through the Bargmann central extension, with the usual superselection consequences. Comparison with the Doebner and Goldin family identifies the reversible zero diffusion corner with linear Schrodinger dynamics. We provide operational falsifiers via residual diagnostics for the continuity and Hamilton Jacobi equations and report numerical minima at the Fisher scale that are invariant under Galilean boosts. In this setting, quantum mechanics emerges as a reversible fixed point of Fisher regularised information hydrodynamics. A code archive enables direct numerical checks, including a superposition stress test that preserves exact projective linearity within our axioms.
This paper develops a framework-relative ontology of determinacy. Its core question is not what the world is made of, but what must minimally be accounted for if a stable deter- minate identity is internally self-representing. The primitive and functional core of Version 3.8 is retained: Being, the possibility of distinction, and domain-relative realizability define the sparse primitive basis; coherent self-representation then requires three non-equivalent func- tional questions—Support, Internal Encoding, and Correspondence. Explicit finite witness pairs establish uniform non-determination of each role from the other two in the unrestricted baseline class, while stronger canonical or equivariant subclasses remain open. Version 4.1.1 is a corrective consolidation of Version 4.1 rather than a new upstream on- tology step. It retains the Version 4.0 bridge revision and the Version 4.1 constructional layer. That layer adds the reverse evaluative direction Physics ⇒ Mathematics ⇒ Ontology and records where downstream structures constrain, but do not retroactively constitute, the ontol- ogy. Several previous bridge claims are weakened or rejected. Symmetry classification, tensor factorization, entanglement of a state, and path-dependent dynamics are kept as four distinct mathematical layers. A conditional expectation is treated as a localization map rather than as actualization; a branch instrument defines possible conditional events but does not select one realized branch; and a projection onto admissible spectral sectors is not called conservative dynamics without an independently derived dilation. The causal and propagation bridge is sharpened in two directions. First, a previous can- didate definition of a null relation by vanishing accumulated interval volume is proved degen- erate: every comparable pair admits a chain of links, so that criterion vanishes throughout the causal order. Link ensembles remain useful near-null approximants, but the null sector is therefore a limiting or measure-relative object rather than a pair-local primitive in the de- clared causal-set model. Second, the long-range free-chain calculation at 𝛼 = 2 is separated into two non-commuting limits. The infinite-range spectral symbol has maximal group veloc- ity 𝜋𝐽𝑎, whereas the envelope of finite-cutoff maxima tends to 2𝐽𝑎 Si(𝜋). These are spectral group-velocity statements; a causal signal cone still requires separate Lieb–Robinson-type hy- potheses. Isotropy and a unique physical Lorentz cone remain open. The defect bridge is updated with the completed 𝐾 = 512 data layer of the frozen ratio campaign. All 903 prescribed values of 𝜃 are present with eight branches each; 897 aggregate points are admissible and six lie in a short rejected interval. Neither √ 2 nor 𝜙 is a local or global minimum. The original preregistered primary ratio test nevertheless remains non- evaluable because its 𝐾 = 64 training gate is universally degenerate. Thus 𝐾 = 512 completes a characterization block; it does not retrospectively repair the primary estimator. Provenance registration and cross-platform verification remain pending. Version 4.0 turned Test 28A into an explicit reconstruction audit, and Version 4.1 retains that audit unchanged. For the standard three one-body extractions on ℋ = (C 3 ) ⊗3 , the combined linear map has exact rank 25 and kernel dimension 704. The hidden space splits as 192 two-body plus 512 fully traceless three-body directions; even the full 𝑆3-invariant class retains an exact 156-dimensional hidden sector. The preregistered continuation identifies an exact energy-selected fixed point, the totally antisymmetric state |𝜀⟩, while holonomy and variance objectives yield set-valued argmin correspondences. The historical non-triviality gate is therefore preserved but shown not to be a universal criterion, and no retroactive 𝑉28.4 verdict is declared. A prospectively frozen two-local QPH family provides an exact computer-assisted existence witness: its cycle-phase differential has rank 704/704 on the marginal kernel for the primary family and two preregistered replications, so marginals plus relational cycle phases are locally in- formationally complete in the fixed regularity stratum. Canonical modular-mismatch selectors are then audited rather than assumed. Identical additive qutrit references and every single pure mismatch under exact 𝑆3 protection obey strict capacity/rank no-go bounds. On the protected 156-dimensional domain a physically generated mixed mismatch has sufficient raw capacity but standard phase-only QPH remains incomplete. Exact cumulant analysis explains why order three is the natural next layer: the 𝑆3-hidden sector decomposes as 156 = 36 + 120, and the third connected cumulant is a complete affine coordinate on fibres of fixed proper marginals. A historical preregistered cubic-moment completion is retained only as a delicate T-NUM wit- ness, not as a theorem premise. This is the declared stopping point of the arity/cubic line: selecting one specific cubic observable would require a new independent physical law. Test 28B remains suspended. Version 4.0 added one further macro-level correction, retained in Version 4.1. Causal and conformal structure, transport geometry, stable matter sectors, and quantum correlations are treated as parallel downstream representations of one substrate model, not as a serial matter– space–time chain. A proposed identification of the matter admissibility projector Πadm with spacetime volume is rejected in its literal form: the projector is matter-branch specific, need not be nested under generative updates, and has no canonical finite trace in a type-III con- tinuum. In its place a conditional causal–transport conformal closure theorem is proved. If a causal reconstruction supplies a Lorentzian conformal class and an independent transport limit supplies a positive spatial metric on the same spacelike distribution, the conformal factor is fixed pointwise exactly when the two induced spatial metrics are conformally compatible. A scale-free generalized-eigenvalue defect provides a direct falsifier. The corresponding clock– cone–matter gate is also corrected by conformal weight: frequencies and dimensionful spectral scales have lapse weight one under a pure lapse deformation, whereas spectral ratios, localiza- tion fractions, and dimensionless stability-window coordinates have weight zero. A Tolman– thermal-time comparison is retained only as a relative lapse-profile gate; absolute time units remain open. Version 4.1 introduced a controlled common-substrate realization. Version 4.1.1 corrects its scope: parity alone excludes only an odd or linear mass/source identification with the same signed coordinate; an even law such as 𝑀 ∝ 𝑑 2 is not excluded by parity. On the declared graph Klein–Gordon sector, charge conjugation reverses Noether/gauge-current orientation while leaving mode energy and localization intensity unchanged. A grounded-graph Green- kernel theorem fixes the spatial uniformity of the cross-term sign, while the Coulomb sign itself is conditional on realizing a non-dynamical 𝐴0-type constraint sector; the same kernel in a dynamical scalar sector gives the opposite sign. A separate no-go proves that matter Dirichlet energy alone cannot select a nontrivial interior geometry. A state-selected positive geometry Hessian yields the conditional linear response 𝑦 = 𝐾 −1 𝐸 𝜏 , so weak 𝐶-even stress sources add while 𝐶-odd currents can cancel. The principal new bridge is a conditional stationary common causal–transport–matter con- struction. If one protected center supplies a common base, the transport branch supplies a positive spatial metric ℎ, and several modular/physical clocks agree on one relative lapse 𝑁, then 𝑔CTM = −𝑐 2 *𝑁2𝑑𝑇2 + ℎ has one timelike sign, predicts the same null front for all canonically normalized matter sectors, and fixes its stationary volume element without an additional scalar measure. Different masses and opposite 𝑈(1) representation weights remain lower-order data and do not alter the characteristic cone. The independently reconstructed HSMI conformal class remains a held-out test rather than an input to this construction. A second independent Version 4.1 result supplies a conditional physical law selecting com- plex rank two. A nonzero-Chern line cannot be closed under conjugation at rank one on 𝑆 2 , whereas 𝐿 ⊕ 𝐿¯ is the minimal conjugation-closed carrier; independently, ClC 2 ≃ 𝑀2(C) has minimal irreducible complex module dimension two. The existing odd-Chern defect-link con struction realizes this pair. If its Clifford algebra is physically admissible, the local carrier has 𝑀2(C) qubit kinematics. This is not an assertion that opposite electric charges form a coherent qubit, nor that every particle is a qubit. The resulting Version 4.1.1 is a constrained foundational proposal with a frozen primitive core, stronger positive and negative bridge results, a first common stationary geometry can- didate, an independently motivated minimal rank-two carrier, and a reproducibility-oriented ledger for every step from ontological determinacy toward physics. It also makes the external spin-sign, soft-graviton, equivalence-principle, and mass-budget inputs explicit without treat- ing them as evidence for the ontology.