Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Exact Measurement-Dependence Cost across the Noisy GHZ–Mermin Threshold

Qihang Wang, Zhiyuan Yao, Kun Chen

Published Aug 25, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Local hidden-variable models can reproduce Bell violations if settings depend on hidden variables. Using total-variation distance, we determine the minimum dependence needed to reproduce all outcome probabilities for Pauli X and Y measurements on n-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states, for every n ≥ 3, visibility and coherence phase. For odd n, the larger magnitude of the real and imaginary coherence components sets the cost; for even n, the smaller can raise it. States with identical, Bell-violating Mermin data can thus have different costs.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22089933

Related papers

Exact minimum measurement dependence for faithful local deterministic models of multipartite GHZ-Mermin correlations

Aaron Alai

A local deterministic model can reproduce Bell-inequality violations only if the hidden state depends on the measurement settings. Hall found the minimum such dependence for the singlet state [Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 250404 (2010)] and posed the corresponding problem for the Mermin state [Phys. Rev. A 84, 022102 (2011)]. This paper solves it, for the $n$-party GHZ-Mermin scenario at every $n \geq 3$, with the marginals reproduced as well as the correlators. The minimum measurement-dependence fraction is $F_{\min}(n) = R/[2(R+1)]$, with $R = 2^{\lfloor (n-1)/2 \rfloor}$ the Mermin violation ratio: $1/3, 2/5, 4/9, 8/17, \ldots$, always below $1/2$. The lower bound follows from Mermin's inequality by a general overlap bound; the upper bound is an explicit model, uniform on the hidden-variable classes that violate the fewest constraints, with closed-form counts; a reduction theorem shows that for Mermin scenarios the marginals impose no additional dependence. The Mermin values are also certified by integer-arithmetic enumeration through $n = 22$. The formula was stated as a conjecture in the first version of this paper and was first proved, by a different route, by Wang, Yao and Chen; the proof here was obtained independently and the two agree. Every minimal contradiction of size $k$ among stabilizer constraints has correlator-only minimum $1/(k-1)$. With the marginals included the minimum is the same on every core of the $C_5$ ring cluster, on the size-4 and size-5 cores of $C_4$ and on every four-core of $C_6$, but larger on the size-6 and size-7 cores of $C_4$ and on 112 of the 1,920 five-cores of $C_6$, with exact certificates on both sides in every case.

quant-pharXiv:2608.00124•Aug 3, 2026•2 citations

The Price of Locality

Aaron Alai

Bell's theorem rests on three assumptions: locality, determinism, and measurement independence. Experiments violate Bell inequalities, so at least one assumption must be abandoned. The first two exits are well explored; the third — allowing lawful, partial correlation between measurement settings and hidden variables — is usually dismissed as "superdeterminism" and assumed to require total conspiracy. This paper computes what that third exit actually costs. Hall (2010) priced the bipartite case exactly: 13.81% of measurement independence must be surrendered to reproduce singlet-state correlations. This work extends that program to multipartite GHZ/Mermin scenarios and computes, via exact linear programming, the minimum measurement dependence required to reproduce the full faithful statistics — every correlator and every marginal — for 3 through 13 parties. The floors climb a lawful staircase: 1/3, 2/5, 4/9, 8/17, 16/33, 32/65, all obeying the closed form F = R/(2(R+1)) with R the Mermin violation ratio. A proven universal ceiling shows the required dependence never exceeds 1/2 at any experiment size: quantum statistics never force total superdeterminism. The optimal hidden-variable distributions take a closed physical form — uniform measures on the ground states of the prepared state's frustrated stabilizer Hamiltonian — confirmed out-of-sample on cluster states. The result answers a question Hall posed and left open in 2011, and supplies an answer key against which every published lawful-measurement-dependence program (invariant-set theory, cellular-automaton interpretations, future-input dynamics, all-at-once retrocausality, and the displacement-condensate framework of the present authors) is graded in its own formalism. Operationally, the floors are counterfeiting thresholds for multipartite device-independent certificates. Every exact value is machine-verified on independent hardware and reproducible in under one minute from the linked repository: github.com/RandomInternetPreson/moire-phase-space-sampler (DST_Bell_MI directory). Also available at ai.viXra.org/abs/2607.0049.Version 2 (Oct 2026): closed form proved for all n; cluster-core census with exact certificates; scripts and run logs added.

•Jul 18, 2026•0 citations

Sharp Bell–CHSH Bounds Under Total-Variation Measurement Dependence

William He

This work derives an exact and operational tradeoff between Bell–CHSH violation and measurement dependence in local hidden-variable models. Measurement independence is relaxed via a single parameter MMM, defined as the maximum total-variation distance between hidden-variable distributions conditioned on different setting pairs. Under locality, we prove the sharp inequality ∣S∣≤min⁡(2+6M,4)|S| \le \min(2 + 6M, 4)∣S∣≤min(2+6M,4), valid for all admissible MMM, and construct an explicit two-state local model saturating the bound for every M∈[0,1/3]M \in [0, 1/3]M∈[0,1/3]. The result is invertible: any observed CHSH value ∣S∣=2+Δ|S| = 2 + \Delta∣S∣=2+Δ certifies a minimum required measurement dependence M≥Δ/6M \ge \Delta/6M≥Δ/6. The parameter MMM has a direct hypothesis-testing interpretation, placing Bell violations and setting predictability in the same operational units used in statistical distinguishability and cryptography. The paper also provides a linear-programming template that reproduces the analytic frontier and can be adapted to other Bell functionals.

•Jan 3, 2026•0 citations

Necessary and Sufficient Detection Efficiency for the Mermin Inequalities

Adán Cabello, David Rodríguez, Ignacio Villanueva

We prove that the threshold detection efficiency for a loophole-free Bell experiment using an n-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state and the correlations appearing in the n-partite Mermin inequality is n/(2n-2). If the detection efficiency is equal to or lower than this value, there are local hidden variable models that can simulate all the quantum predictions. If the detection efficiency is above this value, there is no local hidden variable model that can simulate all the quantum predictions.

arXiv:0712.3268•Physical Review Letters•Sep 16, 2008•50 citations

Simulating tripartite GHZ correlations with a local hidden-variable model

Daniele Cenni

A local hidden-variable model for tripartite GHZ states is constructed, in which a single threshold on the local signal magnitude governs detection and violates the fair-sampling assumption. The detection probability depends on the hidden variables, so the detected sample is unrepresentative, while the single-detector efficiency is independent of the polarizer settings. On the postselected sample the model violates the Mermin and Svetlichny inequalities, reaching M3=3.85 and S3=5.66, at a single-detector efficiency of 72.49%, below the threshold eta_crit=3/4 of Cabello et al.; the full ensemble satisfies both inequalities. A necessary upper bound eta <= 74.64% for the exact reproduction of the GHZ correlations by any model in this class is derived.

•Jan 23, 2026•0 citations

Efficient classical-communication-assisted local simulation of n-qubit GHZ correlations

Tracey E. Tessier, Ivan Deutsch, Carlton M. Caves

We present a local hidden-variable model supplemented by classical communication that reproduces the quantum-mechanical predictions for measurements of all products of Pauli operators on an n-qubit GHZ state (or "cat state"). The simulation is efficient since the required amount of communication scales linearly with the number of qubits, even though there are Bell-type inequalities for these states for which the amount of violation grows exponentially with n. The structure of our model yields insight into the Gottesman-Knill theorem by demonstrating that, at least in this limited case, the correlations in the set of nonlocal hidden variables represented by the stabilizer generators are captured by an appropriate set of local hidden variables augmented by n-2 bits of classical communication.

arXiv:quant-ph/0407133•Jul 16, 2004•2 citations
Local hidden-variable models can reproduce Bell violations if settings depend on hidden variables. Using total-variation distance, we determine the minimum dependence needed to reproduce all outcome probabilities for Pauli X and Y measurements on n-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states, for every n ≥ 3, visibility and coherence phase. For odd n, the larger magnitude of the real and imaginary coherence components sets the cost; for even n, the smaller can raise it. States with identical, Bell-violating Mermin data can thus have different costs.
A local deterministic model can reproduce Bell-inequality violations only if the hidden state depends on the measurement settings. Hall found the minimum such dependence for the singlet state [Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 250404 (2010)] and posed the corresponding problem for the Mermin state [Phys. Rev. A 84, 022102 (2011)]. This paper solves it, for the nnn-party GHZ-Mermin scenario at every n≥3n \geq 3n≥3, with the marginals reproduced as well as the correlators. The minimum measurement-dependence fraction is Fmin⁡(n)=R/[2(R+1)]F_{\min}(n) = R/[2(R+1)]Fmin​(n)=R/[2(R+1)], with R=2⌊(n−1)/2⌋R = 2^{\lfloor (n-1)/2 \rfloor}R=2⌊(n−1)/2⌋ the Mermin violation ratio: 1/3,2/5,4/9,8/17,…1/3, 2/5, 4/9, 8/17, \ldots1/3,2/5,4/9,8/17,…, always below 1/21/21/2. The lower bound follows from Mermin's inequality by a general overlap bound; the upper bound is an explicit model, uniform on the hidden-variable classes that violate the fewest constraints, with closed-form counts; a reduction theorem shows that for Mermin scenarios the marginals impose no additional dependence. The Mermin values are also certified by integer-arithmetic enumeration through n=22n = 22n=22. The formula was stated as a conjecture in the first version of this paper and was first proved, by a different route, by Wang, Yao and Chen; the proof here was obtained independently and the two agree. Every minimal contradiction of size kkk among stabilizer constraints has correlator-only minimum 1/(k−1)1/(k-1)1/(k−1). With the marginals included the minimum is the same on every core of the C5C_5C5​ ring cluster, on the size-4 and size-5 cores of C4C_4C4​ and on every four-core of C6C_6C6​, but larger on the size-6 and size-7 cores of C4C_4C4​ and on 112 of the 1,920 five-cores of C6C_6C6​, with exact certificates on both sides in every case.
Bell's theorem rests on three assumptions: locality, determinism, and measurement independence. Experiments violate Bell inequalities, so at least one assumption must be abandoned. The first two exits are well explored; the third — allowing lawful, partial correlation between measurement settings and hidden variables — is usually dismissed as "superdeterminism" and assumed to require total conspiracy. This paper computes what that third exit actually costs. Hall (2010) priced the bipartite case exactly: 13.81% of measurement independence must be surrendered to reproduce singlet-state correlations. This work extends that program to multipartite GHZ/Mermin scenarios and computes, via exact linear programming, the minimum measurement dependence required to reproduce the full faithful statistics — every correlator and every marginal — for 3 through 13 parties. The floors climb a lawful staircase: 1/3, 2/5, 4/9, 8/17, 16/33, 32/65, all obeying the closed form F = R/(2(R+1)) with R the Mermin violation ratio. A proven universal ceiling shows the required dependence never exceeds 1/2 at any experiment size: quantum statistics never force total superdeterminism. The optimal hidden-variable distributions take a closed physical form — uniform measures on the ground states of the prepared state's frustrated stabilizer Hamiltonian — confirmed out-of-sample on cluster states. The result answers a question Hall posed and left open in 2011, and supplies an answer key against which every published lawful-measurement-dependence program (invariant-set theory, cellular-automaton interpretations, future-input dynamics, all-at-once retrocausality, and the displacement-condensate framework of the present authors) is graded in its own formalism. Operationally, the floors are counterfeiting thresholds for multipartite device-independent certificates. Every exact value is machine-verified on independent hardware and reproducible in under one minute from the linked repository: github.com/RandomInternetPreson/moire-phase-space-sampler (DST_Bell_MI directory). Also available at ai.viXra.org/abs/2607.0049.Version 2 (Oct 2026): closed form proved for all n; cluster-core census with exact certificates; scripts and run logs added.
This work derives an exact and operational tradeoff between Bell–CHSH violation and measurement dependence in local hidden-variable models. Measurement independence is relaxed via a single parameter MMM, defined as the maximum total-variation distance between hidden-variable distributions conditioned on different setting pairs. Under locality, we prove the sharp inequality ∣S∣≤min⁡(2+6M,4)|S| \le \min(2 + 6M, 4)∣S∣≤min(2+6M,4), valid for all admissible MMM, and construct an explicit two-state local model saturating the bound for every M∈[0,1/3]M \in [0, 1/3]M∈[0,1/3]. The result is invertible: any observed CHSH value ∣S∣=2+Δ|S| = 2 + \Delta∣S∣=2+Δ certifies a minimum required measurement dependence M≥Δ/6M \ge \Delta/6M≥Δ/6. The parameter MMM has a direct hypothesis-testing interpretation, placing Bell violations and setting predictability in the same operational units used in statistical distinguishability and cryptography. The paper also provides a linear-programming template that reproduces the analytic frontier and can be adapted to other Bell functionals.
We prove that the threshold detection efficiency for a loophole-free Bell experiment using an n-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state and the correlations appearing in the n-partite Mermin inequality is n/(2n-2). If the detection efficiency is equal to or lower than this value, there are local hidden variable models that can simulate all the quantum predictions. If the detection efficiency is above this value, there is no local hidden variable model that can simulate all the quantum predictions.
A local hidden-variable model for tripartite GHZ states is constructed, in which a single threshold on the local signal magnitude governs detection and violates the fair-sampling assumption. The detection probability depends on the hidden variables, so the detected sample is unrepresentative, while the single-detector efficiency is independent of the polarizer settings. On the postselected sample the model violates the Mermin and Svetlichny inequalities, reaching M3=3.85 and S3=5.66, at a single-detector efficiency of 72.49%, below the threshold eta_crit=3/4 of Cabello et al.; the full ensemble satisfies both inequalities. A necessary upper bound eta <= 74.64% for the exact reproduction of the GHZ correlations by any model in this class is derived.
We present a local hidden-variable model supplemented by classical communication that reproduces the quantum-mechanical predictions for measurements of all products of Pauli operators on an n-qubit GHZ state (or "cat state"). The simulation is efficient since the required amount of communication scales linearly with the number of qubits, even though there are Bell-type inequalities for these states for which the amount of violation grows exponentially with n. The structure of our model yields insight into the Gottesman-Knill theorem by demonstrating that, at least in this limited case, the correlations in the set of nonlocal hidden variables represented by the stabilizer generators are captured by an appropriate set of local hidden variables augmented by n-2 bits of classical communication.