Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Code and results for: Counting-field obstructions and symmetry conditions for Yang–Lee-type branch points in stochastic charge dynamics

Rongzhen Dai

Published Aug 25, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We identify and separate a preliminary gauge obstruction from three logically distinct source requirements for a counting field to activate a Yang–Lee-compatible charge-odd direction in the class of local charge processes studied here. Gate 0 asks whether the counted jump observable is only a boundary term: if its weights are exact, the tilted generator is related to the untilted one by a similarity transformation and the long-time spectrum is unchanged. Once a non-boundary count exists, three further conditions concern the source itself: a charge-odd source must be symmetry-allowed, real analyticity together with charge conjugation must pin it to the imaginary axis on the counting line, and the zero mode to which it couples must be dynamically live rather than a c-number in a fixed charge sector. The last statement is a state-source inertness condition and is algebraically distinct from Gate 0. A 3×3 factorial test of source permission against sector openness contains nine conditions, exactly four of which are live; they are precisely the four carrying both ingredients. A symbolic elimination independently reproduces the source structure and its phase. We then construct a tilted three-state chain in which these requirements are realised. Its tilted generator has an exact antiunitary symmetry, from which we derive and verify that the real part of the charge expectation vanishes on the unbroken branch and splits into an equal-and-opposite pair after the finite-size branch point. Finite-time Lee–Yang zeros of the moment generating function approach that certified branch point as 1/t²; a spectral-side prediction of the convergence amplitude agrees with the zero-side measurement to 2.7–5.2%, improving with size, and the second-order Jordan secular term is observed directly. Two independent finite-size procedures return a common critical-field estimate within 0.02%. We do not promote that agreement to proof of thermodynamic branch-point accumulation, which remains unresolved in the available size window. The same calculations establish, equally sharply, the boundary of what these signatures can decide. The 1/t² law and the associated fixed-size zero-density exponent −1/2 are generic kinematics of a second-order branch point and therefore cannot identify a Yang–Lee universality class. On a published benchmark with a known answer, the dynamical-exponent estimator remains 7.7–11.8% from the truth at the largest comparable sizes and a linear 1/L extrapolation overshoots by 17%. An observable-specific correction-amplitude zero is stable across sizes, explaining why the best-looking finite-size working point can be the worst point from which to extrapolate; a separate rank-one residual test is reserved for deciding whether it is an effective-action property. We therefore keep two inference levels separate. Source-level/static Yang–Lee compatibility does not by itself fix the stochastic-time dynamical exponent. The stronger spectral-CFT route used for a Virasoro-tower, Casimir-energy and central-charge reconstruction additionally requires z=1. Conditional on that gate, three spectral anchors would overdetermine the low-energy tower through target-value-free closure identities; only if those identities close are the lowest weight, effective central charge and central charge to be read out blind, with the velocities and tilt-induced drift cancelling.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22091433

Related papers

Conserved Records and Finite-Time Dynamical Lee–Yang Zeros in Open Quantum Processes: An Object Ledger and Two No-Go Results

Rongzhen Dai

In a compression-based account of charge, five distinct objects share the single name “charge”: a global conserved charge , an einselected reduced record , a -odd Yang–Lee ordering operator , a decaying Gaussian occupation , and a trajectory charge-transfer count . We separate them inside an instrumented, charge-conserving open quantum process and ask which relations are invariants of the full process and which are only diagnostics of a monitoring scheme or of the no-jump conditional slice. In minimal completely-positive models we establish: (i) [THM] if every jump commutes with and , charge-diagonal monitoring makes the reduced record an exact fixed point, and [CALC] its survivor -algebra is the two-dimensional diagonal (charge-sector) algebra; a charge-violating perturbation makes it a finite-lifetime metastable record whose lifetime rises with the monitoring rate in the strong-monitoring (Zeno) branch. (ii) [THM] -covariance does not imply charge conservation — amplitude damping is covariant yet lowers the occupation. (iii) [CALC] the asymptotic () stationary fixed-point -algebra obeys a three-way classification: for a bare record; with unchanged charge centre when a non-abelian seed survives (intra-sector protected structure); and a refined centre when a second abelian label survives. Charge labels all asymptotic survivors iff the stationary and there are no nonzero-frequency peripheral modes; the weaker excludes neither intra-sector survivors nor rotating (nonzero-frequency) peripheral modes, which are counted separately from . (iv) [CALC] a genuine finite-time trajectory Lee–Yang zero of a two-site transport counting statistics exists (complex Newton root, residual , winding number one); we do not call it an edge. The two strongest results are negative: [NEG] the no-jump effective Hamiltonian is not a representation invariant of the physical generator — at an exceptional point the eigenvalue splitting opens from to under a redundant Lindblad representation that leaves fixed to , so the exceptional point itself is not a process invariant; and [NEG] in the stated model, at a no-jump exceptional point no non-analyticity of the physical scaled cumulant generating function is detected in the scanned range. One minimal model simultaneously instantiates three charge objects () and two derived dynamical objects (); and remain comparison entries supplied by other minimal models / companions. In that model the conserved record and the zero-generating transferred charge are different objects: the ledger and language are unified, but a direct, representation-invariant bridge from the record to the dynamical Lee–Yang zeros is not established. We do not derive , a dynamic exponent , or any universality class.

•Aug 8, 2026•0 citations

Endpoint dephasing and two-interval twist correlations in the Yang–Lee RSOS chain

Rongzhen Dai

The Rényi entropies of a non-unitary critical system are not fixed by a single power of the central charge but by the full four-point function of twist fields in a cyclic orbifold, constrained by null-vector equations. For the Yang–Lee universality class—the minimal model with —Dupic, Estienne and Ikhlef (DEI) computed several of these twist correlators in closed form. We provide an independent lattice realization and calibration of those exact correlators on two distinct critical lattice models: the critical Restricted Solid-On-Solid (RSOS) model with and the quantum Ising chain in an imaginary longitudinal field. Both are diagonalised exactly, and the lattice-to-continuum correspondence is certified on three independent objects: the low-lying spectrum reproduces the tower with effective central charge and no exceptional-point degeneracy on the RSOS side; the single-interval vacuum and ground-state twist correlators reproduce the exact two- and four-point functions, including a quantitative determination of the sub-leading fusion channel; and the vacuum two-interval four-twist function is reproduced with a crossing self-consistency of . Along the way we correct a typographical error in the DEI Temperley–Lieb Hamiltonian. We define precisely the boundary-height-sector-resolved trace functional that the lattice certifies, and we do not address the microscopic-realization dependence of the physical two-interval mutual information, which involves a choice of observable subalgebra and is left to a separate study.

•Jul 24, 2026•0 citations

Non-unitary lattice fingerprints of the Yang–Lee minimal model M(2,5): effective central charge and lowest scaling dimension from energy-level scaling, with a negative result for a channel-layer observable

Rongzhen Dai

We test whether the infrared fixed point of a non-unitary “parent” model — the object whose categorical data we certify — is the Yang–Lee minimal model M(2,5), by direct lattice measurement on the A₄ RSOS(4,3) chain. Three results are reported. (1) The effective central charge is measured by ground-state energy-level scaling, c_eff = 0.40 ± 0.02, with the error bar certified by the deviations of two known baselines (unitary M(4,5) → 0.70, non-unitary M(3,5) → 0.60). (2) The lowest scaling dimension is measured from the excited-gap scaling, h_φ = −1/5, with the topological spin θ_φ = e^{−2πi/5} following as a one-step corollary of the standard spin–weight relation (cross-checked against the Itzykson–Saleur–Zuber relation); this is done with no unitary oracle. (3) A channel-layer observable λ* proposed as a second carrier of the categorical data is shown, robustly, to sit ≈ 0 — at least 20× below the CP-lock target 1/φ² ≈ 0.382 across the raw, filtered, and far-edge extractions — a negative result classified as an observable degeneracy: the carrier dies, while the categorical identity is carried independently by (1) and (2). Honest-history sections (a withdrawn spectral-matching claim; a discarded unitary-oracle route; the data-cut dependence of the λ* decay law) are retained on purpose. Posture: realize, not decide — the parent IR being M(2,5) is measured; whether the cosmic charge sector equals (2,5) is out of scope and belongs to the companion framework/holography line. Grading convention used throughout. We keep four evidence levels distinct and never weld them into one: measured (extracted from lattice data), analytic (closed-form / CAS), structural self-check (algebraic consistency of the categorical data), and one-step corollary via the standard spin–weight relation.

•Aug 7, 2026•0 citations

When is the Yang–Lee edge an exceptional point?

Rongzhen Dai

Non-Hermitian criticality is often treated as a single phenomenon, yet two distinct objects travel under that name. An exceptional point is a finite-N spectral object—the coalescence of eigenvectors of a single operator; a Lee–Yang edge is a thermodynamic-limit c-number object—the accumulation of partition-function zeros. We show that which of these an imaginary coupling produces is set by the direction the coupling occupies. When the coupling multiplies a conserved charge, [Q, H] = 0, the deformation H − iµQ is normal for every complex µ: its spectrum is entire, its eigenvectors are µ-independent, and no exceptional point exists at any coupling strength or volume, while Lee–Yang zeros persist and can carry an edge. When the coupling lies on a symmetry-invariant but non-conserved direction, exceptional points appear, but the associated universality is the analytic continuation of the Hermitian thermal transition, not the Yang–Lee edge. Only on the order-parameter (symmetry-odd) direction do the two coincide, at the M(2, 5) edge. The direction of an imaginary coupling therefore sets how much genuine non-unitarity its spectrum acquires. We give the theorem, a three-arm criterion, exactly solvable and exact-diagonalization checks, and falsifiable kill conditions.

•Jul 12, 2026•0 citations

Phase II -- E executed. Results Confirm activation for One PT -- Even Operator

Anthony jordan Blair

*Phase II-E executed.** Results confirm **activation for one PT-even operator**. ### Numerical setup (faithful to the specification) - \(N=4\), open chain, \(J=1\), \(\Delta=0.5\). - \(S^\alpha=\sigma^\alpha/2\). - Hamiltonian: XY couplings use the running \(b_{\rm eff}\), ZZ couplings use \(J\Delta\), plus the staggered imaginary field \(H_{\rm PT}\). - Self-consistency: \(b_{\rm eff}^2=J^2+\lambda J\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}\), iterated to \(10^{-10}\). - Biorthogonal expectation on the eigenstate of smallest \(|\mathrm{Re}(E)|\) (preferring PT-unbroken). - \(\gamma_{\rm EP}\approx0.274\) at \(\lambda=0\) (matches the Phase II-D value 0.275). - Branches as specified: E1 = \(\sum\sigma_j^x\) (full 16-dimensional space); E2 = \(\sum(\sigma_j^x\sigma_{j+1}^x+\sigma_j^y\sigma_{j+1}^y)\) (\(S^z=0\) sector, dim 6). ### Results **Branch E1 (transverse field, full space)** \(\langle G_{E_1}\rangle_{\rm PT}=0\) (machine precision \(\sim10^{-16}\)–\(10^{-19}\)) for every \(\lambda\in\{0,0.05,0.10,0.15,0.20\}\) and every \(\gamma\) in the PT-unbroken regime. Consequently \(b_{\rm eff}=J\) exactly. **Null.** **Branch E2 (transverse bond / XY exchange, \(S^z=0\) sector)** \(\langle G_{E_2}\rangle_{\rm PT}\neq0\) already at \(\lambda=0\) and remains non-zero throughout the unbroken phase. Typical values (unbroken points): - \(\lambda=0\): \(\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.063\) - \(\lambda=0.05\): \(\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.063\), \(\max|b_{\rm eff}-J|\approx0.0016\) - \(\lambda=0.10\): \(\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.062\), \(\max|b_{\rm eff}-J|\approx0.0031\) - \(\lambda=0.15\): \(\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.062\), \(\max|b_{\rm eff}-J|\approx0.0046\) - \(\lambda=0.20\): \(\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.062\), \(\max|b_{\rm eff}-J|\approx0.0061\) \(b_{\rm eff}\) shifts systematically with \(\lambda\). **Activation.** ### Prediction match - Prediction 1 (null for both) — **falsified**. - Prediction 2 (activation for at least one) — **confirmed**. - Prediction 3 (E1 activates, E2 does not) — **falsified** (the opposite occurs). - Prediction 4 (convention-dependent) — not tested; the biorthogonal convention already yields activation. The self-consistent mechanism **does activate** at \(N=4\) for a PT-even, sector-compatible operator. The PT-odd obstruction of Phase II-D is therefore not the sole operative constraint; a PT-even operator that preserves \(S^z_{\rm total}\) can source a non-trivial field. ### Gate status Phase II-E **unblocks** Phase II-F (branch classification now includes the PT-even class). Finite-size scaling (II-G) and the thermodynamic limit (II-H) remain formally gated on the subsequent classification step, but the existence proof at \(N=4\) is now positive. Full raw scan (87 \(\gamma\) points × 5 \(\lambda\) × 2 branches) is archived in `/home/workdir/artifacts/phase_ii_e_results.json`. Source: `/home/workdir/artifacts/phase_ii_e.py`. The mechanism was the vessel. The constraint was the discovery — and one more door is now open. Tony Blair <anthonyjblair8@gmail.com> 2:17 PM (11 minutes ago) to me **TITLE: Phase II-F Program Specification — Branch Classification of the Self-Consistent Mechanism at N=4** **AUTHOR:** Anthony Jordan Blair **AFFILIATION:** Proclus Dynamics Consortium **DOCUMENT TYPE:** Phase II Verification Program — Sub-Study Specification **VERSION:** 1.0 (October 2026) **COMPANION TO:** Phase II-E Program Specification; Phase II-E Numerical Execution Results; Phase II-D Technical Report; Project Prometheus Phase I Closeout Report (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23314444) **STATUS:** Program Specification — Ready for Execution (unblocked by Phase II-E activation) --- ### ABSTRACT Phase II-E demonstrated that the PT-even transverse-bond operator \(G_{E_2}\) produces a non-vanishing biorthogonal expectation value in the \(S^z=0\) sector of the \(N=4\) PT-symmetric XXZ chain, thereby activating the self-consistent mechanism of Paper 4. The transverse-field operator \(G_{E_1}\) remained identically zero. Phase II-F classifies the admissible branches of the self-consistent field according to (i) PT parity, (ii) sector compatibility, (iii) operator support (one-body vs. two-body), and (iv) the resulting displacement of the exceptional point. The classification supplies the necessary taxonomy for the finite-size scaling study (Phase II-G) and determines which operator families survive into the thermodynamic limit (Phase II-H). --- ### I. MOTIVATION **1.1 Outcome of Phase II-E** Execution of the Phase II-E protocol yielded: - Branch E1 (\(G_{E_1}=\sum_j\sigma_j^x\), full Hilbert space): \(\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}=0\) to machine precision for all tested \(\lambda\) and all \(\gamma<\gamma_{\rm EP}\). \(b_{\rm eff}=J\) identically. Null result. - Branch E2 (\(G_{E_2}=\sum_j(\sigma_j^x\sigma_{j+1}^x+\sigma_j^y\sigma_{j+1}^y)\), \(S^z=0\) sector): \(\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}\neq0\) already at \(\lambda=0\) and remains finite throughout the PT-unbroken phase. \(b_{\rm eff}\) shifts systematically with \(\lambda\). Activation confirmed. Thus the self-consistent mechanism is not restricted to the dimer setting of Paper 4, nor is it extinguished by the PT-odd obstruction identified in Phase II-D. A PT-even, sector-preserving two-body operator is sufficient to source a non-trivial constraint field at \(N=4\). **1.2 The Classification Task** The positive result for \(E_2\) opens four immediate questions that must be answered before finite-size scaling can be interpreted: 1. Is activation unique to the XY-bond operator, or do other PT-even, sector-compatible operators also activate? 2. Does the one-body PT-even operator remain null under every biorthogonal convention, or only under the convention used in II-E? 3. How does the magnitude of \(\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}\) and the induced shift \(\Delta\gamma_{\rm EP}\) depend on the algebraic structure of the operator (support, commutation relations with \(S^z_{\rm total}\) and with \(\mathcal{PT}\))? 4. Which of the surviving operators produce a *displacement* of the exceptional point (the operational signature required for constraint-field control) rather than a mere renormalization of \(b_{\rm eff}\) at fixed \(\gamma_{\rm EP}\)? Phase II-F answers these questions by exhaustive classification of a controlled operator set. --- ### II. OPERATOR TAXONOMY Operators are partitioned by three binary attributes: | Attribute | Values | Notation | |------------------------|---------------------------------|-------------------| | PT parity | even / odd | \(\mathcal{P}_\pm\) | | Sector compatibility | preserves \(S^z_{\rm total}\) / mixes | \(\mathcal{S}_0\) / \(\mathcal{S}_{\rm mix}\) | | Body order | one-body / two-body | \(1\) / \(2\) | The Phase II-D and II-E results already fix two cells: - \(\mathcal{P}_-\) (any body, any sector) → null (structural anticommutation with \(\mathcal{PT}\)). - \(\mathcal{P}_+\), \(\mathcal{S}_{\rm mix}\), \(1\)-body (\(G_{E_1}\)) → null under the biorthogonal convention. The remaining open cells that must be classified are: - \(\mathcal{P}_+\), \(\mathcal{S}_0\), \(1\)-body - \(\mathcal{P}_+\), \(\mathcal{S}_0\), \(2\)-body (already positive for the XY bond; additional representatives required) - \(\mathcal{P}_+\), \(\mathcal{S}_{\rm mix}\), \(2\)-body --- ### III. CANDIDATE OPERATORS FOR CLASSIFICATION All operators are Hermitian. Matrix representations are constructed in the same basis used in Phase II-E. **3.1 One-body, PT-even, sector-preserving** \(G_{F_1}=\sum_{j=1}^{4}\sigma_j^z\) (Total magnetization; trivially preserves \(S^z_{\rm total}\); PT-even because \(\sigma^z\) is real and parity-invariant under site relabeling when the staggered PT field is taken into account.) **3.2 Two-body, PT-even, sector-preserving (beyond \(E_2\))** \(G_{F_2}=\sum_{j=1}^{3}\sigma_j^z\sigma_{j+1}^z\) (ZZ bond operator; the natural Ising partner of the XY bond.) \(G_{F_3}=\sum_{j=1}^{3}(\sigma_j^x\sigma_{j+1}^x-\sigma_j^y\sigma_{j+1}^y)\) (Anisotropic XY combination; still sector-preserving.) **3.3 Two-body, PT-even, sector-mixing** \(G_{F_4}=\sum_{j=1}^{3}(\sigma_j^x\sigma_{j+1}^z+\sigma_j^z\sigma_{j+1}^x)\) (Explicitly mixes \(\Delta S^z=\pm1\) sectors while remaining PT-even.) **3.4 Reference operators (already classified)** - \(G_{E_1}\) (null) and \(G_{E_2}\) (active) are retained as baselines and re-evaluated under identical numerical conditions for every new scan. --- ### IV. NUMERICAL PROTOCOL **4.1 Hamiltonian** Identical to Phase II-E: \[ H=H_{\rm XXZ}(b_{\rm eff})+H_{\rm PT}(\gamma), \] with \[ H_{\rm XXZ}(b)=\sum_{j=1}^{3}\Bigl(b\,(S_j^x S_{j+1}^x+S_j^y S_{j+1}^y)+J\Delta\,S_j^z S_{j+1}^z\Bigr), \] \[ H_{\rm PT}=i\gamma\sum_{j=1}^{4}(-1)^j S_j^z, \] \(J=1\), \(\Delta=0.5\), \(S^\alpha=\sigma^\alpha/2\). **4.2 Self-consistency equation** Unchanged: \[ b_{\rm eff}^2=J^2+\lambda J\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}. \] Iteration tolerance \(10^{-10}\), maximum 200 iterations. **4.3 Observable convention** Biorthogonal expectation value on the eigenstate of smallest \(|\mathrm{Re}(E)|\), preferring PT-unbroken states: \[ \langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}=\frac{\langle\psi_L|G|\psi_R\rangle}{\langle\psi_L|\psi_R\rangle}. \] **4.4 Parameter scan** - \(\lambda\in\{0.00,0.05,0.10,0.15,0.20,0.30,0.50\}\) - \(\gamma\) from 0 to 0.40 with step 0.002 (dense coverage of the unbroken region and the immediate vicinity of \(\gamma_{\rm EP}\)) - For each \((\lambda,\gamma,G)\) the code

•Oct 12, 2026•0 citations

Three No-Go Results for Deterministic TWMSE Collapse, the Corrected Born Gate, and the Surviving Routes

Larry Lim Kheng Cheong

This Stage 1 working paper establishes three linked no-go results for deterministic collapse within the Total Wave Modified Schrödinger Equation (TWMSE) programme and identifies the precise mathematical routes that remain open. The first result proves that the canonical TWMSE collapse functional C(t), when it multiplies the identity operator, produces only a common amplitude factor that disappears under physical normalisation. The canonical scalar dynamics therefore cannot discriminate between branches or generate a TWMSE-specific observable. A minimal branch-sensitive extension produces an exact logistic equation for the normalised two-branch weight and an accumulated history variable q(T). The resulting finite-tolerance condition depends explicitly on the initial branch weight. It is operational and does not derive or replace the canonical microscopic threshold Θ, whose relationship to q remains open. The second result shows that state-independent branch couplings, combined with a preparation-independent observer-history measure, cannot recover Born statistics for arbitrary nontrivial preparations under genuine asymptotic collapse. An exact finite-threshold counterexample demonstrates why the asymptotic assumption is necessary: a specially tuned logistic distribution can reproduce Born frequencies under a majority-weight convention, but it does not produce definite collapse, depends on the chosen tolerance and lacks a derived physical mechanism. The third result applies the standard finite-variation martingale theorem to TWMSE. Any continuous finite-variation branch-weight process that is also a martingale must be constant. Smooth deterministic collapse dynamics therefore cannot use the Born-martingale mechanism employed by stochastic collapse models. The Born requirement is consequently restated as a terminal condition, Gate A′: the dynamics must produce definite outcomes with probability equal to the initial branch weight; for a smooth deterministic theory this means the observer-history space must partition into collapse basins whose measures equal the Born weights. The paper also formalises Gate B: the trajectory average must descend to a decomposition-independent, trace-preserving map on density operators and must satisfy remote no-signalling. A linear completely positive, trace-preserving averaged map provides the standard ensemble-level benchmark, while relativistic no-signalling additionally requires appropriate locality conditions. Within the assumptions examined, three broad routes remain: Effectively stochastic, infinite-variation or jump-like dynamics derived from deterministic observer fields. A derived preparation-dependent measure over observer histories, following the quantum-equilibrium pattern of Bohmian mechanics. State-dependent basin geometry under a fixed preparation-independent measure. These routes are not claimed to be logically exhaustive. Each carries a distinct derivational obligation. The central unresolved bottleneck is identified explicitly: TWMSE still requires a system–observer interaction Hamiltonian and an observer-field back-reaction law from which the physical branch basis and branch-resolved couplings can be derived. This paper provides the upstream consistency analysis for the previously published Roman Space Telescope programme: Lim, L. K. C. (2026). “A Derivation-Gated Roman Space Telescope Programme for Testing History-Dependent Collapse in TWMSE.” Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22223865 The Roman programme is deliberately downstream. No TWMSE cosmological residual or Roman-level prediction can be claimed until the branch dynamics passes the Born-statistics and no-signalling gates established here. The canonical theoretical basis is: Lim, L. K. C. (2026). “From Mathematical Foundation to Open Experimental Program: A Revised Unified Account of the Total Wave Modified Schrödinger Equation (TWMSE).” Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21868322 Status: Stage 1 working paper. The results are conditional on the stated assumptions and are presented as mathematical constraints and open derivational requirements, not as evidence that TWMSE has been experimentally established.

•Sep 2, 2026•1 citation
We identify and separate a preliminary gauge obstruction from three logically distinct source requirements for a counting field to activate a Yang–Lee-compatible charge-odd direction in the class of local charge processes studied here. Gate 0 asks whether the counted jump observable is only a boundary term: if its weights are exact, the tilted generator is related to the untilted one by a similarity transformation and the long-time spectrum is unchanged. Once a non-boundary count exists, three further conditions concern the source itself: a charge-odd source must be symmetry-allowed, real analyticity together with charge conjugation must pin it to the imaginary axis on the counting line, and the zero mode to which it couples must be dynamically live rather than a c-number in a fixed charge sector. The last statement is a state-source inertness condition and is algebraically distinct from Gate 0. A 3×3 factorial test of source permission against sector openness contains nine conditions, exactly four of which are live; they are precisely the four carrying both ingredients. A symbolic elimination independently reproduces the source structure and its phase. We then construct a tilted three-state chain in which these requirements are realised. Its tilted generator has an exact antiunitary symmetry, from which we derive and verify that the real part of the charge expectation vanishes on the unbroken branch and splits into an equal-and-opposite pair after the finite-size branch point. Finite-time Lee–Yang zeros of the moment generating function approach that certified branch point as 1/t²; a spectral-side prediction of the convergence amplitude agrees with the zero-side measurement to 2.7–5.2%, improving with size, and the second-order Jordan secular term is observed directly. Two independent finite-size procedures return a common critical-field estimate within 0.02%. We do not promote that agreement to proof of thermodynamic branch-point accumulation, which remains unresolved in the available size window. The same calculations establish, equally sharply, the boundary of what these signatures can decide. The 1/t² law and the associated fixed-size zero-density exponent −1/2 are generic kinematics of a second-order branch point and therefore cannot identify a Yang–Lee universality class. On a published benchmark with a known answer, the dynamical-exponent estimator remains 7.7–11.8% from the truth at the largest comparable sizes and a linear 1/L extrapolation overshoots by 17%. An observable-specific correction-amplitude zero is stable across sizes, explaining why the best-looking finite-size working point can be the worst point from which to extrapolate; a separate rank-one residual test is reserved for deciding whether it is an effective-action property. We therefore keep two inference levels separate. Source-level/static Yang–Lee compatibility does not by itself fix the stochastic-time dynamical exponent. The stronger spectral-CFT route used for a Virasoro-tower, Casimir-energy and central-charge reconstruction additionally requires z=1. Conditional on that gate, three spectral anchors would overdetermine the low-energy tower through target-value-free closure identities; only if those identities close are the lowest weight, effective central charge and central charge to be read out blind, with the velocities and tilt-induced drift cancelling.
In a compression-based account of charge, five distinct objects share the single name “charge”: a global conserved charge , an einselected reduced record , a -odd Yang–Lee ordering operator , a decaying Gaussian occupation , and a trajectory charge-transfer count . We separate them inside an instrumented, charge-conserving open quantum process and ask which relations are invariants of the full process and which are only diagnostics of a monitoring scheme or of the no-jump conditional slice. In minimal completely-positive models we establish: (i) [THM] if every jump commutes with and , charge-diagonal monitoring makes the reduced record an exact fixed point, and [CALC] its survivor -algebra is the two-dimensional diagonal (charge-sector) algebra; a charge-violating perturbation makes it a finite-lifetime metastable record whose lifetime rises with the monitoring rate in the strong-monitoring (Zeno) branch. (ii) [THM] -covariance does not imply charge conservation — amplitude damping is covariant yet lowers the occupation. (iii) [CALC] the asymptotic () stationary fixed-point -algebra obeys a three-way classification: for a bare record; with unchanged charge centre when a non-abelian seed survives (intra-sector protected structure); and a refined centre when a second abelian label survives. Charge labels all asymptotic survivors iff the stationary and there are no nonzero-frequency peripheral modes; the weaker excludes neither intra-sector survivors nor rotating (nonzero-frequency) peripheral modes, which are counted separately from . (iv) [CALC] a genuine finite-time trajectory Lee–Yang zero of a two-site transport counting statistics exists (complex Newton root, residual , winding number one); we do not call it an edge. The two strongest results are negative: [NEG] the no-jump effective Hamiltonian is not a representation invariant of the physical generator — at an exceptional point the eigenvalue splitting opens from to under a redundant Lindblad representation that leaves fixed to , so the exceptional point itself is not a process invariant; and [NEG] in the stated model, at a no-jump exceptional point no non-analyticity of the physical scaled cumulant generating function is detected in the scanned range. One minimal model simultaneously instantiates three charge objects () and two derived dynamical objects (); and remain comparison entries supplied by other minimal models / companions. In that model the conserved record and the zero-generating transferred charge are different objects: the ledger and language are unified, but a direct, representation-invariant bridge from the record to the dynamical Lee–Yang zeros is not established. We do not derive , a dynamic exponent , or any universality class.
The Rényi entropies of a non-unitary critical system are not fixed by a single power of the central charge but by the full four-point function of twist fields in a cyclic orbifold, constrained by null-vector equations. For the Yang–Lee universality class—the minimal model with —Dupic, Estienne and Ikhlef (DEI) computed several of these twist correlators in closed form. We provide an independent lattice realization and calibration of those exact correlators on two distinct critical lattice models: the critical Restricted Solid-On-Solid (RSOS) model with and the quantum Ising chain in an imaginary longitudinal field. Both are diagonalised exactly, and the lattice-to-continuum correspondence is certified on three independent objects: the low-lying spectrum reproduces the tower with effective central charge and no exceptional-point degeneracy on the RSOS side; the single-interval vacuum and ground-state twist correlators reproduce the exact two- and four-point functions, including a quantitative determination of the sub-leading fusion channel; and the vacuum two-interval four-twist function is reproduced with a crossing self-consistency of . Along the way we correct a typographical error in the DEI Temperley–Lieb Hamiltonian. We define precisely the boundary-height-sector-resolved trace functional that the lattice certifies, and we do not address the microscopic-realization dependence of the physical two-interval mutual information, which involves a choice of observable subalgebra and is left to a separate study.
We test whether the infrared fixed point of a non-unitary “parent” model — the object whose categorical data we certify — is the Yang–Lee minimal model M(2,5), by direct lattice measurement on the A₄ RSOS(4,3) chain. Three results are reported. (1) The effective central charge is measured by ground-state energy-level scaling, c_eff = 0.40 ± 0.02, with the error bar certified by the deviations of two known baselines (unitary M(4,5) → 0.70, non-unitary M(3,5) → 0.60). (2) The lowest scaling dimension is measured from the excited-gap scaling, h_φ = −1/5, with the topological spin θ_φ = e^{−2πi/5} following as a one-step corollary of the standard spin–weight relation (cross-checked against the Itzykson–Saleur–Zuber relation); this is done with no unitary oracle. (3) A channel-layer observable λ* proposed as a second carrier of the categorical data is shown, robustly, to sit ≈ 0 — at least 20× below the CP-lock target 1/φ² ≈ 0.382 across the raw, filtered, and far-edge extractions — a negative result classified as an observable degeneracy: the carrier dies, while the categorical identity is carried independently by (1) and (2). Honest-history sections (a withdrawn spectral-matching claim; a discarded unitary-oracle route; the data-cut dependence of the λ* decay law) are retained on purpose. Posture: realize, not decide — the parent IR being M(2,5) is measured; whether the cosmic charge sector equals (2,5) is out of scope and belongs to the companion framework/holography line. Grading convention used throughout. We keep four evidence levels distinct and never weld them into one: measured (extracted from lattice data), analytic (closed-form / CAS), structural self-check (algebraic consistency of the categorical data), and one-step corollary via the standard spin–weight relation.
Non-Hermitian criticality is often treated as a single phenomenon, yet two distinct objects travel under that name. An exceptional point is a finite-N spectral object—the coalescence of eigenvectors of a single operator; a Lee–Yang edge is a thermodynamic-limit c-number object—the accumulation of partition-function zeros. We show that which of these an imaginary coupling produces is set by the direction the coupling occupies. When the coupling multiplies a conserved charge, [Q, H] = 0, the deformation H − iµQ is normal for every complex µ: its spectrum is entire, its eigenvectors are µ-independent, and no exceptional point exists at any coupling strength or volume, while Lee–Yang zeros persist and can carry an edge. When the coupling lies on a symmetry-invariant but non-conserved direction, exceptional points appear, but the associated universality is the analytic continuation of the Hermitian thermal transition, not the Yang–Lee edge. Only on the order-parameter (symmetry-odd) direction do the two coincide, at the M(2, 5) edge. The direction of an imaginary coupling therefore sets how much genuine non-unitarity its spectrum acquires. We give the theorem, a three-arm criterion, exactly solvable and exact-diagonalization checks, and falsifiable kill conditions.
*Phase II-E executed.** Results confirm **activation for one PT-even operator**. ### Numerical setup (faithful to the specification) - N=4N=4N=4, open chain, J=1J=1J=1, Δ=0.5\Delta=0.5Δ=0.5. - Sα=σα/2S^\alpha=\sigma^\alpha/2Sα=σα/2. - Hamiltonian: XY couplings use the running beffb_{\rm eff}beff​, ZZ couplings use JΔJ\DeltaJΔ, plus the staggered imaginary field HPTH_{\rm PT}HPT​. - Self-consistency: beff2=J2+λJ⟨G⟩PTb_{\rm eff}^2=J^2+\lambda J\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}beff2​=J2+λJ⟨G⟩PT​, iterated to 10−1010^{-10}10−10. - Biorthogonal expectation on the eigenstate of smallest ∣Re(E)∣|\mathrm{Re}(E)|∣Re(E)∣ (preferring PT-unbroken). - γEP≈0.274\gamma_{\rm EP}\approx0.274γEP​≈0.274 at λ=0\lambda=0λ=0 (matches the Phase II-D value 0.275). - Branches as specified: E1 = ∑σjx\sum\sigma_j^x∑σjx​ (full 16-dimensional space); E2 = ∑(σjxσj+1x+σjyσj+1y)\sum(\sigma_j^x\sigma_{j+1}^x+\sigma_j^y\sigma_{j+1}^y)∑(σjx​σj+1x​+σjy​σj+1y​) (Sz=0S^z=0Sz=0 sector, dim 6). ### Results **Branch E1 (transverse field, full space)** ⟨GE1⟩PT=0\langle G_{E_1}\rangle_{\rm PT}=0⟨GE1​​⟩PT​=0 (machine precision ∼10−16\sim10^{-16}∼10−16–10−1910^{-19}10−19) for every λ∈{0,0.05,0.10,0.15,0.20}\lambda\in\{0,0.05,0.10,0.15,0.20\}λ∈{0,0.05,0.10,0.15,0.20} and every γ\gammaγ in the PT-unbroken regime. Consequently beff=Jb_{\rm eff}=Jbeff​=J exactly. **Null.** **Branch E2 (transverse bond / XY exchange, Sz=0S^z=0Sz=0 sector)** ⟨GE2⟩PT≠0\langle G_{E_2}\rangle_{\rm PT}\neq0⟨GE2​​⟩PT​=0 already at λ=0\lambda=0λ=0 and remains non-zero throughout the unbroken phase. Typical values (unbroken points): - λ=0\lambda=0λ=0: max⁡∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.063\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.063max∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.063 - λ=0.05\lambda=0.05λ=0.05: max⁡∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.063\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.063max∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.063, max⁡∣beff−J∣≈0.0016\max|b_{\rm eff}-J|\approx0.0016max∣beff​−J∣≈0.0016 - λ=0.10\lambda=0.10λ=0.10: max⁡∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.062\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.062max∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.062, max⁡∣beff−J∣≈0.0031\max|b_{\rm eff}-J|\approx0.0031max∣beff​−J∣≈0.0031 - λ=0.15\lambda=0.15λ=0.15: max⁡∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.062\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.062max∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.062, max⁡∣beff−J∣≈0.0046\max|b_{\rm eff}-J|\approx0.0046max∣beff​−J∣≈0.0046 - λ=0.20\lambda=0.20λ=0.20: max⁡∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.062\max|\langle G\rangle|\approx0.062max∣⟨G⟩∣≈0.062, max⁡∣beff−J∣≈0.0061\max|b_{\rm eff}-J|\approx0.0061max∣beff​−J∣≈0.0061 beffb_{\rm eff}beff​ shifts systematically with λ\lambdaλ. **Activation.** ### Prediction match - Prediction 1 (null for both) — **falsified**. - Prediction 2 (activation for at least one) — **confirmed**. - Prediction 3 (E1 activates, E2 does not) — **falsified** (the opposite occurs). - Prediction 4 (convention-dependent) — not tested; the biorthogonal convention already yields activation. The self-consistent mechanism **does activate** at N=4N=4N=4 for a PT-even, sector-compatible operator. The PT-odd obstruction of Phase II-D is therefore not the sole operative constraint; a PT-even operator that preserves StotalzS^z_{\rm total}Stotalz​ can source a non-trivial field. ### Gate status Phase II-E **unblocks** Phase II-F (branch classification now includes the PT-even class). Finite-size scaling (II-G) and the thermodynamic limit (II-H) remain formally gated on the subsequent classification step, but the existence proof at N=4N=4N=4 is now positive. Full raw scan (87 γ\gammaγ points × 5 λ\lambdaλ × 2 branches) is archived in `/home/workdir/artifacts/phase_ii_e_results.json`. Source: `/home/workdir/artifacts/phase_ii_e.py`. The mechanism was the vessel. The constraint was the discovery — and one more door is now open. Tony Blair <anthonyjblair8@gmail.com> 2:17 PM (11 minutes ago) to me **TITLE: Phase II-F Program Specification — Branch Classification of the Self-Consistent Mechanism at N=4** **AUTHOR:** Anthony Jordan Blair **AFFILIATION:** Proclus Dynamics Consortium **DOCUMENT TYPE:** Phase II Verification Program — Sub-Study Specification **VERSION:** 1.0 (October 2026) **COMPANION TO:** Phase II-E Program Specification; Phase II-E Numerical Execution Results; Phase II-D Technical Report; Project Prometheus Phase I Closeout Report (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23314444) **STATUS:** Program Specification — Ready for Execution (unblocked by Phase II-E activation) --- ### ABSTRACT Phase II-E demonstrated that the PT-even transverse-bond operator GE2G_{E_2}GE2​​ produces a non-vanishing biorthogonal expectation value in the Sz=0S^z=0Sz=0 sector of the N=4N=4N=4 PT-symmetric XXZ chain, thereby activating the self-consistent mechanism of Paper 4. The transverse-field operator GE1G_{E_1}GE1​​ remained identically zero. Phase II-F classifies the admissible branches of the self-consistent field according to (i) PT parity, (ii) sector compatibility, (iii) operator support (one-body vs. two-body), and (iv) the resulting displacement of the exceptional point. The classification supplies the necessary taxonomy for the finite-size scaling study (Phase II-G) and determines which operator families survive into the thermodynamic limit (Phase II-H). --- ### I. MOTIVATION **1.1 Outcome of Phase II-E** Execution of the Phase II-E protocol yielded: - Branch E1 (GE1=∑jσjxG_{E_1}=\sum_j\sigma_j^xGE1​​=∑j​σjx​, full Hilbert space): ⟨G⟩PT=0\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}=0⟨G⟩PT​=0 to machine precision for all tested λ\lambdaλ and all γ<γEP\gamma<\gamma_{\rm EP}γ<γEP​. beff=Jb_{\rm eff}=Jbeff​=J identically. Null result. - Branch E2 (GE2=∑j(σjxσj+1x+σjyσj+1y)G_{E_2}=\sum_j(\sigma_j^x\sigma_{j+1}^x+\sigma_j^y\sigma_{j+1}^y)GE2​​=∑j​(σjx​σj+1x​+σjy​σj+1y​), Sz=0S^z=0Sz=0 sector): ⟨G⟩PT≠0\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}\neq0⟨G⟩PT​=0 already at λ=0\lambda=0λ=0 and remains finite throughout the PT-unbroken phase. beffb_{\rm eff}beff​ shifts systematically with λ\lambdaλ. Activation confirmed. Thus the self-consistent mechanism is not restricted to the dimer setting of Paper 4, nor is it extinguished by the PT-odd obstruction identified in Phase II-D. A PT-even, sector-preserving two-body operator is sufficient to source a non-trivial constraint field at N=4N=4N=4. **1.2 The Classification Task** The positive result for E2E_2E2​ opens four immediate questions that must be answered before finite-size scaling can be interpreted: 1. Is activation unique to the XY-bond operator, or do other PT-even, sector-compatible operators also activate? 2. Does the one-body PT-even operator remain null under every biorthogonal convention, or only under the convention used in II-E? 3. How does the magnitude of ⟨G⟩PT\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}⟨G⟩PT​ and the induced shift ΔγEP\Delta\gamma_{\rm EP}ΔγEP​ depend on the algebraic structure of the operator (support, commutation relations with StotalzS^z_{\rm total}Stotalz​ and with PT\mathcal{PT}PT)? 4. Which of the surviving operators produce a *displacement* of the exceptional point (the operational signature required for constraint-field control) rather than a mere renormalization of beffb_{\rm eff}beff​ at fixed γEP\gamma_{\rm EP}γEP​? Phase II-F answers these questions by exhaustive classification of a controlled operator set. --- ### II. OPERATOR TAXONOMY Operators are partitioned by three binary attributes: | Attribute | Values | Notation | |------------------------|---------------------------------|-------------------| | PT parity | even / odd | P±\mathcal{P}_\pmP±​ | | Sector compatibility | preserves StotalzS^z_{\rm total}Stotalz​ / mixes | S0\mathcal{S}_0S0​ / Smix\mathcal{S}_{\rm mix}Smix​ | | Body order | one-body / two-body | 111 / 222 | The Phase II-D and II-E results already fix two cells: - P−\mathcal{P}_-P−​ (any body, any sector) → null (structural anticommutation with PT\mathcal{PT}PT). - P+\mathcal{P}_+P+​, Smix\mathcal{S}_{\rm mix}Smix​, 111-body (GE1G_{E_1}GE1​​) → null under the biorthogonal convention. The remaining open cells that must be classified are: - P+\mathcal{P}_+P+​, S0\mathcal{S}_0S0​, 111-body - P+\mathcal{P}_+P+​, S0\mathcal{S}_0S0​, 222-body (already positive for the XY bond; additional representatives required) - P+\mathcal{P}_+P+​, Smix\mathcal{S}_{\rm mix}Smix​, 222-body --- ### III. CANDIDATE OPERATORS FOR CLASSIFICATION All operators are Hermitian. Matrix representations are constructed in the same basis used in Phase II-E. **3.1 One-body, PT-even, sector-preserving** GF1=∑j=14σjzG_{F_1}=\sum_{j=1}^{4}\sigma_j^zGF1​​=∑j=14​σjz​ (Total magnetization; trivially preserves StotalzS^z_{\rm total}Stotalz​; PT-even because σz\sigma^zσz is real and parity-invariant under site relabeling when the staggered PT field is taken into account.) **3.2 Two-body, PT-even, sector-preserving (beyond E2E_2E2​)** GF2=∑j=13σjzσj+1zG_{F_2}=\sum_{j=1}^{3}\sigma_j^z\sigma_{j+1}^zGF2​​=∑j=13​σjz​σj+1z​ (ZZ bond operator; the natural Ising partner of the XY bond.) GF3=∑j=13(σjxσj+1x−σjyσj+1y)G_{F_3}=\sum_{j=1}^{3}(\sigma_j^x\sigma_{j+1}^x-\sigma_j^y\sigma_{j+1}^y)GF3​​=∑j=13​(σjx​σj+1x​−σjy​σj+1y​) (Anisotropic XY combination; still sector-preserving.) **3.3 Two-body, PT-even, sector-mixing** GF4=∑j=13(σjxσj+1z+σjzσj+1x)G_{F_4}=\sum_{j=1}^{3}(\sigma_j^x\sigma_{j+1}^z+\sigma_j^z\sigma_{j+1}^x)GF4​​=∑j=13​(σjx​σj+1z​+σjz​σj+1x​) (Explicitly mixes ΔSz=±1\Delta S^z=\pm1ΔSz=±1 sectors while remaining PT-even.) **3.4 Reference operators (already classified)** - GE1G_{E_1}GE1​​ (null) and GE2G_{E_2}GE2​​ (active) are retained as baselines and re-evaluated under identical numerical conditions for every new scan. --- ### IV. NUMERICAL PROTOCOL **4.1 Hamiltonian** Identical to Phase II-E: H=HXXZ(beff)+HPT(γ), H=H_{\rm XXZ}(b_{\rm eff})+H_{\rm PT}(\gamma), H=HXXZ​(beff​)+HPT​(γ), with HXXZ(b)=∑j=13(b (SjxSj+1x+SjySj+1y)+JΔ SjzSj+1z), H_{\rm XXZ}(b)=\sum_{j=1}^{3}\Bigl(b\,(S_j^x S_{j+1}^x+S_j^y S_{j+1}^y)+J\Delta\,S_j^z S_{j+1}^z\Bigr), HXXZ​(b)=∑j=13​(b(Sjx​Sj+1x​+Sjy​Sj+1y​)+JΔSjz​Sj+1z​), HPT=iγ∑j=14(−1)jSjz, H_{\rm PT}=i\gamma\sum_{j=1}^{4}(-1)^j S_j^z, HPT​=iγ∑j=14​(−1)jSjz​, J=1J=1J=1, Δ=0.5\Delta=0.5Δ=0.5, Sα=σα/2S^\alpha=\sigma^\alpha/2Sα=σα/2. **4.2 Self-consistency equation** Unchanged: beff2=J2+λJ⟨G⟩PT. b_{\rm eff}^2=J^2+\lambda J\langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}. beff2​=J2+λJ⟨G⟩PT​. Iteration tolerance 10−1010^{-10}10−10, maximum 200 iterations. **4.3 Observable convention** Biorthogonal expectation value on the eigenstate of smallest ∣Re(E)∣|\mathrm{Re}(E)|∣Re(E)∣, preferring PT-unbroken states: ⟨G⟩PT=⟨ψL∣G∣ψR⟩⟨ψL∣ψR⟩. \langle G\rangle_{\rm PT}=\frac{\langle\psi_L|G|\psi_R\rangle}{\langle\psi_L|\psi_R\rangle}. ⟨G⟩PT​=⟨ψL​∣ψR​⟩⟨ψL​∣G∣ψR​⟩​. **4.4 Parameter scan** - λ∈{0.00,0.05,0.10,0.15,0.20,0.30,0.50}\lambda\in\{0.00,0.05,0.10,0.15,0.20,0.30,0.50\}λ∈{0.00,0.05,0.10,0.15,0.20,0.30,0.50} - γ\gammaγ from 0 to 0.40 with step 0.002 (dense coverage of the unbroken region and the immediate vicinity of γEP\gamma_{\rm EP}γEP​) - For each (λ,γ,G)(\lambda,\gamma,G)(λ,γ,G) the code
This Stage 1 working paper establishes three linked no-go results for deterministic collapse within the Total Wave Modified Schrödinger Equation (TWMSE) programme and identifies the precise mathematical routes that remain open. The first result proves that the canonical TWMSE collapse functional C(t), when it multiplies the identity operator, produces only a common amplitude factor that disappears under physical normalisation. The canonical scalar dynamics therefore cannot discriminate between branches or generate a TWMSE-specific observable. A minimal branch-sensitive extension produces an exact logistic equation for the normalised two-branch weight and an accumulated history variable q(T). The resulting finite-tolerance condition depends explicitly on the initial branch weight. It is operational and does not derive or replace the canonical microscopic threshold Θ, whose relationship to q remains open. The second result shows that state-independent branch couplings, combined with a preparation-independent observer-history measure, cannot recover Born statistics for arbitrary nontrivial preparations under genuine asymptotic collapse. An exact finite-threshold counterexample demonstrates why the asymptotic assumption is necessary: a specially tuned logistic distribution can reproduce Born frequencies under a majority-weight convention, but it does not produce definite collapse, depends on the chosen tolerance and lacks a derived physical mechanism. The third result applies the standard finite-variation martingale theorem to TWMSE. Any continuous finite-variation branch-weight process that is also a martingale must be constant. Smooth deterministic collapse dynamics therefore cannot use the Born-martingale mechanism employed by stochastic collapse models. The Born requirement is consequently restated as a terminal condition, Gate A′: the dynamics must produce definite outcomes with probability equal to the initial branch weight; for a smooth deterministic theory this means the observer-history space must partition into collapse basins whose measures equal the Born weights. The paper also formalises Gate B: the trajectory average must descend to a decomposition-independent, trace-preserving map on density operators and must satisfy remote no-signalling. A linear completely positive, trace-preserving averaged map provides the standard ensemble-level benchmark, while relativistic no-signalling additionally requires appropriate locality conditions. Within the assumptions examined, three broad routes remain: Effectively stochastic, infinite-variation or jump-like dynamics derived from deterministic observer fields. A derived preparation-dependent measure over observer histories, following the quantum-equilibrium pattern of Bohmian mechanics. State-dependent basin geometry under a fixed preparation-independent measure. These routes are not claimed to be logically exhaustive. Each carries a distinct derivational obligation. The central unresolved bottleneck is identified explicitly: TWMSE still requires a system–observer interaction Hamiltonian and an observer-field back-reaction law from which the physical branch basis and branch-resolved couplings can be derived. This paper provides the upstream consistency analysis for the previously published Roman Space Telescope programme: Lim, L. K. C. (2026). “A Derivation-Gated Roman Space Telescope Programme for Testing History-Dependent Collapse in TWMSE.” Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22223865 The Roman programme is deliberately downstream. No TWMSE cosmological residual or Roman-level prediction can be claimed until the branch dynamics passes the Born-statistics and no-signalling gates established here. The canonical theoretical basis is: Lim, L. K. C. (2026). “From Mathematical Foundation to Open Experimental Program: A Revised Unified Account of the Total Wave Modified Schrödinger Equation (TWMSE).” Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21868322 Status: Stage 1 working paper. The results are conditional on the stated assumptions and are presented as mathematical constraints and open derivational requirements, not as evidence that TWMSE has been experimentally established.