Abstract Circuit topology—the pattern of two-qubit entangling gates—determines noise propagation paths in variational quantum circuits (VQCs). Using the normalized rank-displacement diagnostic D(ε) across 26 experiment configurations spanning five topologies and five CPTP noise types, plus 135 IBM ibm fez hardware circuits, we show that topology accounts for 48.9% of explainable D(0.05) variance under ω 2 decomposition (Cohen’s d = 2.66 between ring and star; permutation p = 7.1×10−12). The ranking hierarchy (star>grid≈linear>ring, where lower D indicates better ranking preservation) is invariant across the four nondepolarizing noise types (Kendall τ = 1.0 over four ranked lists, p = 0.017 by exact permutation test) but collapses under depolarizing noise. On IBM hardware, the qualitative ranking survives transpilation, though effect magnitude attenuates ∼ 10×. A Heisenberg-picture analytical model qualitatively predicts the τ (n, L) ranking from circuit structure alone (r = 0.645, p = 0.013; R2 = 0.35), providing a theoretical basis for topology-dependent noise sensitivity. We find that classical ML systems (MLP, XGBoost) achieve comparable D(0.05) values, showing that the τ -D functional form is consistent across classical and quantum computation, suggesting a shared noise-response structure. Practical design heuristics are provided
Abstract Circuit topology—the pattern of two-qubit entangling gates—determines noise propagation paths in variational quantum circuits (VQCs). Using the normalized rank-displacement diagnostic D(ε) across 26 experiment configurations spanning five topologies and five CPTP noise types, plus 135 IBM ibm fez hardware circuits, we show that topology accounts for 48.9% of explainable D(0.05) variance under ω 2 decomposition (Cohen’s d = 2.66 between ring and star; permutation p = 7.1×10−12). The ranking hierarchy (star>grid≈linear>ring, where lower D indicates better ranking preservation) is invariant across the four nondepolarizing noise types (Kendall τ = 1.0 over four ranked lists, p = 0.017 by exact permutation test) but collapses under depolarizing noise. On IBM hardware, the qualitative ranking survives transpilation, though effect magnitude attenuates ∼ 10×. A Heisenberg-picture analytical model qualitatively predicts the τ (n, L) ranking from circuit structure alone (r = 0.645, p = 0.013; R2 = 0.35), providing a theoretical basis for topology-dependent noise sensitivity. We find that classical ML systems (MLP, XGBoost) achieve comparable D(0.05) values, showing that the τ -D functional form is consistent across classical and quantum computation, suggesting a shared noise-response structure. Practical design heuristics are provided
Variational quantum circuits (VQCs) have been proposed as promising models for nonlinear learning tasks in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era. This study presents a hybrid classical-quantum framework for nonlinear time-series forecasting that integrates causally-filtered Hidden Markov regime detection with multiple VQC architectures. Four circuit architectures are defined as an explicit [Formula: see text] factorial design that isolates circuit depth from entanglement topology (shallow: depth 1/linear; ring: depth 1/ring; deep: depth 4/linear; heavy: depth 4/ring), each with reported qubit count, parameter count and gate count, and are evaluated under an analytic depolarizing/readout noise model. Three nonlinear classical baselines (support-vector regression, gradient boosting, and a multilayer perceptron) are compared alongside a linear autoregressive (AR) baseline, and the Hidden Markov Model (HMM) regime feature is fit only on training data and propagated causally into the test set to remove look-ahead leakage. Across 20 Monte Carlo replicates, we find that every VQC architecture is outperformed by every classical baseline, including plain linear AR (paired t-tests, all [Formula: see text]; Cohen’s d up to 4.8). Within the VQC family, circuit depth - not shallowness - is associated with better performance (deep/heavy [Formula: see text] shallow/ring), while entanglement topology alone has little independent effect once depth is controlled. An ablation removing the HMM-derived feature shows it contributes negligibly to forecast accuracy in this setting. Under this confound-controlled design, we find no evidence of a forecasting advantage for the tested VQC architectures over classical linear or nonlinear baselines, which we report as a cautionary result for claims of near-term quantum advantage in forecasting.
Variational quantum circuits (VQCs) are a leading approach to quantum machine learning on near-term devices, yet it remains unclear which circuit architecture yields the best accuracy-parameter trade-off on classical tabular data. We present a systematic empirical comparison of four VQC families -- multi-layer fully-connected (FC-VQC), residual (ResNet-VQC), hybrid quantum-classical transformer (QT), and fully quantum transformer (FQT) -- across five regression and classification benchmarks. Our key findings are: \textbf{(i)}~FC-VQCs achieve 90-96\% of the R2 of attention-based VQCs while using 40-50\% fewer parameters, and consistently outperform equal-capacity MLPs (mean R2=0.829 vs.\ MLP720's 0.753 on Boston Housing, 3-seed average); \textbf{(ii)}~FC-VQC's Type~4 inter-block connectivity provides partial cross-token mixing that approximates the role of attention -- explicit quantum self-attention yields only marginal gains on most datasets while significantly increasing parameter count; \textbf{(iii)}~expressibility saturates at circuit depth~≈3, explaining why shallow VQCs already cover the Hilbert space effectively; \textbf{(iv)}~LayerNorm on the fully quantum transformer improves classification accuracy, suggesting normalization is important when all operations are quantum; \textbf{(v)}~in our noise study on Boston Housing, FQT degrades gracefully under depolarizing noise while QT collapses. All results are validated across three random seeds. These findings provide practical architectural guidance for deploying VQCs on near-term quantum hardware.
Abstract Variational quantum circuits (VQCs) are a central paradigm for quantum machine learning, yet their practical deployment is limited by poor trainability, sensitivity to noise, and the lack of input-adaptive parameterization. In this work, we introduce TensorDual-VQC, a tensor-structured operator-learning framework that models variational quantum computation as an input-conditioned mapping that jointly governs quantum state encoding and circuit parameter generation. The proposed approach employs a shared low-rank Tensor-Train (TT) backbone with dual output heads, inducing a coupled representation that constrains the hypothesis space to a structured low-dimensional manifold. Under standard smoothness and low-rank assumptions, we show that the approximation behavior is governed by the TT-rank rather than the ambient parameter dimension, and that shared latent structure can enable more compact representations than decoupled parameterizations in structured regimes. We further analyze trainability through the induced Neural Tangent Kernel, showing that the multi-branch gradient structure enriches the span of gradient features and can improve kernel conditioning under mild non-degeneracy conditions. In addition, we relate robustness to quantum noise to the intrinsic effective dimension of the tensor parameter manifold, providing a first-order scaling characterization of output variance under stochastic perturbations. We evaluate TensorDual-VQC on quantum dot classification, quantum simulation, and combinatorial optimization tasks under both simulated noise and real quantum hardware. Across all settings, the proposed framework achieves higher accuracy, faster convergence, and greater stability than standard VQCs and hypernetwork-based baselines when quantum resources are matched. These results suggest that structured operator learning with shared low-rank representations provides a principled and practical approach to scalable, noise-resilient quantum learning in the NISQ regime.
We deploy a Quantum Counterfactual Mediation Analysis (QCMA) framework on IBM Quantum processors to ask a precise, hardware-grounded question: are causal regimes identified in noiseless simulation preserved under real quantum noise? Integrating partial quantum state tomography with a linear structural equation model, we decompose inter-architectural performance contrasts into direct effects and indirect quantum-mediated effects across twelve experiments spanning three circuit topologies and two benchmark datasets. Five of six topology-dataset pairs (83%) retain their causal regime when migrating from noiseless simulation to physical hardware. Decoherence inflates quantum-mediated contributions by up to one order of magnitude a noise artefact, not quantum advantage while the Neutral regime dominates both backend. These findings indicate that hardware noise may substantially limit the effective utilization of quantum resources in current NISQ circuits, and motivate further investigation into coherence-preserving circuit design strategies.
Quantum circuit optimization plays a critical role in improving the performance of algorithms executed on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. While modern quantum compilers provide multiple optimization levels, selecting an appropriate optimization strategy remains a non-trivial task due to the complex interplay between circuit structure and hardware noise. In this work, we present a comprehensive noise-aware evaluation of quantum circuit optimization strategies using a diverse set of 33 circuits, including Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT), Grover's search, Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE), and randomly generated circuits. We analyze the impact of different transpiler optimization levels on circuit depth, entanglement (CNOT count), and output fidelity under a realistic depolarizing noise model. Our experimental results reveal that no single optimization level consistently yields the best performance across all circuit types. While aggressive optimization is beneficial for structured circuits such as QFT and VQE, moderate optimization levels often provide a better trade-off between circuit complexity and fidelity for unstructured or randomly generated circuits. These findings highlight that optimization-level selection is inherently dependent on circuit characteristics and cannot be effectively addressed using static or heuristic approaches alone. To address this challenge, we further propose a lightweight learning-based model that predicts the optimal optimization level based on circuit features. The model achieves an accuracy of 93.9% across the evaluated dataset, demonstrating that simple machine learning techniques can effectively approximate optimal compiler decisions without requiring exhaustive evaluation. Overall, this work provides practical insights into optimization behavior in NISQ systems and introduces a scalable approach for adaptive optimization selection, contributing toward more efficient quantum software development.
Variational quantum circuits (VQCs) -- parameterised quantum circuits trained by classical optimisation of a quantum cost function -- underpin most near-term quantum machine learning, yet systematic guidance on design choices (ansatz structure, encoding, optimiser, gradient estimation) and their interaction with specific ML task requirements remains fragmented. This paper proposes the Variational Quantum Circuit Design Space (VQCDS) framework, characterising 48 VQC configurations (3 ansatz families x 3 encoding strategies x 4 optimisers) across 12 ML benchmark tasks -- regression, classification, generative modelling, and reinforcement learning -- on IBM Quantum Eagle and IonQ Forte. VQCDS finds: LSAD-structured ansatz (Silva et al., 2024) outperforms hardware-efficient ansatz on 10 of 12 tasks (+8.0pp mean AUC, 2.1x lower variance); amplitude encoding outperforms angle encoding for p > 16 features (+12.4% R2); quantum natural gradient descent (QNG) reduces regression convergence by 48.4% vs. Adam; and task-ansatz alignment via mutual information-guided entanglement provides +8.4pp AUC and +14.4% R2 across task types. VQCDS provides an evidence-based VQC design guide covering 48 configuration evaluations across 12 tasks.