Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Trivial SO(3) Holonomy of Kabsch Transport for Regular Pure Three-Qubit States

Alexandru Rora

Published Aug 23, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For a pure three-qubit state, the node-local Gram matrices of the three pairwise Pauli correlation tensors satisfy an exact affine identity, T_AB T_ABᵀ − T_AC T_ACᵀ = (n_C² − n_B²)·1₃, proved by a short two-copy swap argument. The identity is strictly stronger than the anisotropic-invariance theorem of Cheng and Hall, which it reproves in three lines. Three consequences follow. Each edge determinant is fixed by the opposite Bloch length, det T_AB = κ − n_C², so at most one of the three can be positive and at least two edges of every regular state are orientation-reversing. The triangular loop trace obeys tr(T_AB T_BC T_CA) = 4I_K − (n_A² + n_B² + n_C²) and is bounded, 0 ≤ tr(T_AB T_BC T_CA) ≤ 1, the lower bound proved here and the upper following from Szalay's entanglement ordering. And the nearest-proper-rotation (Kabsch) factors of the three edge tensors compose trivially around the triangle, R_AB R_BC = R_AC, for every pure three-qubit state meeting a stated regularity condition. The deposit contains the manuscript (9 pp.), supplementary material with the full proof program and provenance record (53 pp.), and a reproducibility archive of 172 files: 64 verification scripts with one log each, exact symbolic targets, and a SHA-256 manifest. Version note (v2.1.18) Version 2.1.18 supersedes version 1. Retitled around the affine Gram identity; version 1's undefined-polynomial step in the vertex-exclusion proof is replaced (conclusion unchanged); two new theorems added (the Kempe loop-trace identity with 4·I_Kempe ≥ Σn², and the edge-determinant identity det T_AB = κ − n_C² giving at least two nonpositive determinants); F₁ ≤ 1 proved; the prior-art claim against Williamson et al. withdrawn; and the reproducibility archive rebuilt to 174 checksummed payloads with 65 scripts, a mutation battery and an invariant sweep.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22070403

Related papers

What Contextual Holonomy Detects: the All-versus-Nothing Sector, Two Gap Certificates, and the Section Dependence of Wigner-Friend Holonomy

Manuel Flores Gordillo

Preprint. Third paper of the contextuality-obstructions program, alongside Paper A (the canonical class of the MASA context stack), Paper B (the obstruction spectrum of Weyl context families), Paper D (the observer-context category) and a synthesis note. The slogan "contextual holonomy encodes quantum contextuality" is attractive and, as usually stated, false. This paper gives it a sharp form. On the context stack of maximal abelian subalgebras the canonical degree-2 class has order exactly n, and its cocycle holonomy along closed context loops detects EXACTLY the all-versus-nothing sector of contextuality for closed-triple Weyl families at even local dimension. Both containments are strict, each by an explicit certificate: at d=3 the class is nontrivial of order 3 while the achievable state-independent AvN value is 0, and KCBS exhibits state-dependent contextuality where the class shadow vanishes. The Wigner-friend loop generated by H and S splits by level: its projective (Pancharatnam) holonomy is +1 while its determinant-section holonomy is exactly -i, so any interpretational claim about "the" holonomy of that loop must state which one it means. ATTRIBUTION. The classification of state-independent values for qudit Weyl families, the even/odd dichotomy and the fixed value d/2, on which the state-independent side of the equivalence rests, is DUE TO Abramsky, Cercelescu and Constantin (FSCD 2024). Attainment at general even d is the Raussendorf-Okay-Zurel-Feldmann construction. This paper uses both and rediscovers neither. A RETRACTION IS CARRIED IN THIS PAPER, NOT BURIED. An earlier draft presented the tier-two facets of the d=4 census on a (1/(2*sqrt2))Z grid with a single coefficient magnitude 3/(2*sqrt2), and read the resulting unit-coefficient bounds 4*sqrt2 and 14*sqrt2/3 as placing Tsirelson's sqrt2 inside the tier-two geometry. The whole presentation was a normalization artifact and is withdrawn (Retraction 1): the stored lift has coefficients in {0,+-1} with integer bounds 6 and 7, every facet functional in the census is rational, and Q(sqrt2) is not among the eighteen canonical arithmetic fields. Certificate: d4_arithmetic_profile.py. WHERE THE EVIDENCE IS THIN, STATED IN THE PAPER. Two sweeps quoted here drew no positive instances at all: the d=4 half of the 2,100-family equivalence test, and the 6,500-trial false-certificate sweep, which draws no contextual family at any of d=2,4,8 and therefore establishes the absence of false certificates only vacuously. Both are disclosed where they appear. Theorem 2 is labelled machine-validated rather than proved: the closed form is established end to end for the deletion families treated, while the general closed-triple d=2 statement in compressed coordinates remains open and is recorded as open in the verification ledger. HARDWARE CAVEAT, STATED UP FRONT. The quoted significances, about 56 sigma for the ray-level Wigner-friend holonomy and 35.4 sigma for the Peres-Mermin witness above the deterministic bound 4, are shot-noise statistical only, computed under the implemented witness model and conditional on compatibility and nondisturbance assumptions. They are not systematics-aware and neither measurement is loophole-free; a roughly 3.5 sigma preparation offset on one strand is itself evidence of unmodelled systematics. We also record that the pinned value S = 4.6125 cannot be recomputed from the stored counts (a naive recomputation gives 4.5662, a gap of about 2.7 standard errors); the archived value 4.558 +- 0.018 is the one an independent reader can reproduce from the deposited data. Read these as consistency checks on real hardware, not as precision measurements or certifications. STATUS AND SCOPE. This is a preprint, not a peer-reviewed article. It was held back from the first publication batch and released only after three adversarial review passes; what each pass found, and how each item was closed, is recorded in verification/INDEX.md rather than quietly fixed. One defect found there is NOT closed and belongs to the companion Paper B, which cites a false-certificate artifact that is not in fact in the repository; it is recorded rather than left for a reader to discover. COMPANIONS. Paper A: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630431 . Paper B: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630630 . Paper D: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630697 . Note: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630739 . Code archive: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21498498 AI-ASSISTANCE DISCLOSURE. Large-language-model assistants (Anthropic Claude) were used substantially in drafting, in developing the verification scripts, in literature search and in proposing proofs. Every load-bearing claim is machine-verified independently of that assistance by the scripts named in the text, and the author takes full responsibility for the results, including any errors. VERIFICATION CODE. https://github.com/manuflog/contextuality-obstructions

•Jul 28, 2026•0 citations

Collective charge response is not determined by the few-particle sectors

M.J. Baek

Preprint and reproducibility archive; not peer reviewed. What this record contains. The full text of the manuscript "Identical Few-Particle Gauge Hamiltonians, Programmable Collective Charge Response" (M. J. Baek), its Supplementary Information with complete proofs, and the archive that certifies every closed-form value the paper states. The result. Few-particle dynamics are routinely used to infer collective response in paired quantum matter. This work constructs finite-range interacting response twins that defeat that inference exactly. For any prescribed finite p, two positive finite-range parents have complete static gauge Hamiltonians that coincide at every Peierls link phase on every sector N ≤ p and first separate at N = p+1; their zero-twist finite-density ground rays are the same Dicke condensate, yet their collective charge curvatures differ extensively. The obstruction has no universal depth, and the paper locates it exactly: the blind depth equals the spectator body order, the algebraic bound is independent of geometric range, and bounded range still bounds depth only through the number of sites a ball can hold — so no arbitrary-depth family of uniformly fixed range is claimed. Conversely, a structurally closed exact-pair tower closes at depth two. What is hidden is designable: with d(d+1)/2 displacement families the whole symmetric response-tensor difference is locally realizable at interior filling, and a triangular-lattice twin pair differs only in shear while both diagonal responses stay equal. A 4×4 hard-core-qubit discriminator gives an exact factor-of-two contrast with an internal null control and a state-preparation certificate in 17 equal-time settings. What is certified, and what is not. Results proved in closed form are stated as theorems and proved in full in the Supplementary Information; results established by exact rational or symbolic computation are labelled computer-assisted and carry the script that produces them; the 16-qubit discriminator is a blueprint with an end-to-end noise simulation, not a hardware demonstration, which is not claimed anywhere. Scope limits, open proof lines and one refuted conjecture are recorded explicitly rather than omitted. The archive. response_twins_unified_v1.0.zip contains the manuscript and Supplementary sources, the proof notes, the complete fail-closed verification harness (31 executed stages in release mode — 27 claim-bearing certificate stages, 1 non-claim diagnostic stage and three fail-closed gates — and 24 in quick mode) with one frozen log per stage, independent reimplementations of the load-bearing calculations, negative controls that must fail, the exact-arithmetic certificates behind every closed-form value in the paper, the figure-generation scripts, the scientific claim and provenance record (79 rows with status and scope notes, 50 of them naming the in-archive script or certificate that checks them, the rest saying in words why not), and a per-file SHA-256 manifest of all 209 payload files. Verifying it. Extract the archive and run python3 REPRODUCIBILITY/run_all.py --mode quick for the fast subset or --mode release for all 31 stages; bash BUILD.sh rebuilds both PDFs from source. The three gates check journal-format limits, the release payload against its manifest, and every number the documentation states about the artefacts. Running the harness does not modify the archive: all runtime output is written outside the immutable tree, so verification cannot invalidate the manifest. README.md separates reproducing the content (TeX Live 2023 or newer) from reproducing the archived PDF bytes, which needs the exact producing build recorded inside the PDFs. Licences. Manuscript, Supplementary Information and documentation CC BY 4.0; source code MIT; certificate data CC0 1.0. LICENSE.md is the authoritative per-file mapping and is included both in the archive and as a separate file on this record.

•Aug 7, 2026•0 citations

Crossing Holonomy Theorem

Craig Edwin Holdway

This Theorem establishes the round-trip transport residual (T − I)_rot = (1/160)A from a second independent derivation route (barrier symmetry B = e^{(π/4)A}Θ acting on an ordered pair of noncommuting generators), confirming and strengthening the T48 result. The barrier symmetry acts by exchange-and-inversion: BPB¹ = −Q, BQB⁻¹ = −P, consistent with T47. One-leg transport is modeled by X_{n→d} = (I + λP)(I + λQ); the return leg by X_{d→n} = (I − λQ)(I − λP). A supporting lemma establishes by explicit second-order expansion that T = X_{d→n}X_{n→d} satisfies: T − I = 2λ²A − 2λ²I + O(λ³) where A = ½[P,Q] is the antisymmetric generator and −2λ²I is an isotropic normalization drift that does not affect relative phase or branch observables. Using P² = Q² = I on the reduced two-state space (supported by T36–T37) and [P,Q] = 2A. Under the one-leg normalization λ² = 1/320 inherited from T8 via T48: (T − I)_rot = (1/160)A That both the T48 near-identity route and the T49 barrier-symmetry route converge on the same residue is structurally significant. Status: First-order cancellation, second-order decomposition, and scalar term analysis solid by direct computation. λ² = 1/320 inherited from T8 via T48, not rederived here. B exchange-and-inversion action on P, Q assumed consistent with T47, explicit derivation from T17 kernel geometry open. P² = Q² = I supported by T36–T37, not independently rederived. Qubit algebra correspondence structural, holds within T36–T37 hypotheses, does not assert the full framework is a quantum theory. Dependencies: T7, T8, T17, T36, T37, T47, T48.

•May 3, 2026•0 citations

A Universal Bound for Qutrit Antipodal Tables: κ ≤ 1.059, Reference States, Common Averages and Coupled Certificates

Vasily Psykovsky

Seventh note in the QMEM series on qubit-versus-qutrit antipodal tables. Preprint, version 1; not peer reviewed. An antipodal table records the expectation values of n fixed binary measurements on m pairs of states with opposite values, without shared randomness. Its factorization norm γ₂ is a factorization-based measure of possible qutrit–qubit separation. The condition γ₂ ≤ 1 is necessary for qubit reproducibility and sufficient when the table has at most three rows or at most three columns. For larger tables, γ₂ > 1 certifies a separation, while γ₂ ≤ 1 does not exclude one. The constant κ is the supremum of γ₂ over all qutrit antipodal tables. Main results: Universal bound. Every qutrit antipodal table satisfies γ₂ < 1.058972, improving the previous bound √5/2 ≈ 1.118034. Consequently, 1.007479 ≤ κ < 1.058972. A simpler closed-form bound is γ₂ ≤ 3/(2√2) ≈ 1.060660. Reference states. If all measurements annihilate a state whose largest eigenvalue is at most s (½ ≤ s < 1), then γ₂² ≤ 3/2 − 1/(4s), for arbitrary numbers of pairs and measurements. Every mixture of the pairs' averages is annihilated by those measurements. At s = ½, the bound gives γ₂ ≤ 1, excluding any separation detectable by γ₂; this applies, for example, whenever the table contains an orthogonal pure pair. The underlying pointwise inequality is sharp. Distinguishability and overlap. The pair distinguishability c introduced in Note 6 satisfies c ≤ 1 − tr(ρ⁺ρ⁻) ≤ 4‖σ‖(1 − ‖σ‖) when ‖σ‖ ≥ ½, where σ is the pair's average and ‖σ‖ denotes its largest eigenvalue. Common averages in every dimension. A table whose pairs all share the same average satisfies γ₂ ≤ 1 in any finite dimension, for arbitrary numbers of pairs and measurements. Any excess of γ₂ above one therefore requires pairs with different averages. Coupled certificates. A general factorization bound couples the measurement constraints through the span of all pair averages and encompasses the certificates of Notes 5 and 6. On the certified separating tables of Note 3, a one-parameter family of coupled certificates produces upper bounds within approximately 0.002 of the certified lower bounds. The note is self-contained: Appendix A proves the two results from Note 6 needed for the universal bound. The accompanying reproducibility archive includes proof audits, verification scripts, numerical results, preregistration records, and SHA-256 manifests. The computational checks supplement, but do not replace, the mathematical proofs.

•Nov 13, 2026•2 citations

One sided sequential sharing of tripartite nonlocality for pure and mixed three-qubit states

Sk Sahadat Hossain

Indian Journal of Physics•Sep 28, 2024•1 citation

Balanced Antipodal Qutrit Pairs: Lorentzian Factorization, Qubit Equivalence, and Equality Classification

Vasily Psykovsky

This preprint establishes a Lorentzian factorization theorem for balanced antipodal quantum-state pairs in three-dimensional Hilbert space, with consequences for qubit–qutrit equivalence, prepare-and-measure correlations, and quantum dimension witnesses. We define a pair of qutrit states as balanced when tr(ρ₊ρ₋)² ≤ (1 − tr ρ₊²)(1 − tr ρ₋²). This class includes orthogonal pure-state pairs and pairs with orthogonal supports. Main contributions: Universal factorization theorem. We prove that every prepare-and-measure correlation table generated by balanced qutrit pairs and admissible binary measurements, without shared randomness, satisfies the Euclidean factorization bound γ₂(T) ≤ 1, regardless of the number of pairs or measurement queries. Exact qubit reproducibility. Combining the factorization theorem with an earlier exact qubit criterion, we establish that balanced qutrit configurations are qubit-reproducible whenever there are at most three antipodal pairs or at most three binary queries. In particular, three orthogonal pure-state pairs cannot distinguish a qutrit from a qubit in this setting. Lorentzian geometric construction. The proof uses the quadratic form Q(X) = 2 tr(X²) − (tr X)² on Hermitian 3 × 3 matrices, with signature (8,1). Its dual representation and the spectral inequality −e₂(A) ≤ 1 yield an explicit Euclidean Gram factorization. Unconditional equality classification. We show that every equality configuration of three orthogonal pure-state pairs belongs, up to unitary equivalence, to an embedded-qubit configuration or one of two previously constructed genuinely three-dimensional families: the spin-1 family and the common-vector family. This removes an additional hypothesis required in the preceding note. Reduction of the remaining open problem. We show that any possible three-pair separation can be reduced to configurations containing pure states paired with states of rank at most two, with at least one overlapping pair. We also introduce a semidefinite-programmable certificate whose conjectured universal validity is supported by numerical experiments but remains unproved. The general conjecture that three arbitrary antipodal qutrit state pairs never separate a qutrit from a qubit remains open. The proved results are independent of the numerical investigations. The accompanying reproducibility archive contains preregistered B4h experiments, symbolic and numerical verification scripts, computational results, and SHA-256 manifests. This is the fifth preprint in a research series on qubit–qutrit equivalence, separation, and the geometry of quantum correlations. Status: Research preprint, version 1 (13 November 2026); not peer reviewed.

•Nov 13, 2026•2 citations
For a pure three-qubit state, the node-local Gram matrices of the three pairwise Pauli correlation tensors satisfy an exact affine identity, T_AB T_ABᵀ − T_AC T_ACᵀ = (n_C² − n_B²)·1₃, proved by a short two-copy swap argument. The identity is strictly stronger than the anisotropic-invariance theorem of Cheng and Hall, which it reproves in three lines. Three consequences follow. Each edge determinant is fixed by the opposite Bloch length, det T_AB = κ − n_C², so at most one of the three can be positive and at least two edges of every regular state are orientation-reversing. The triangular loop trace obeys tr(T_AB T_BC T_CA) = 4I_K − (n_A² + n_B² + n_C²) and is bounded, 0 ≤ tr(T_AB T_BC T_CA) ≤ 1, the lower bound proved here and the upper following from Szalay's entanglement ordering. And the nearest-proper-rotation (Kabsch) factors of the three edge tensors compose trivially around the triangle, R_AB R_BC = R_AC, for every pure three-qubit state meeting a stated regularity condition. The deposit contains the manuscript (9 pp.), supplementary material with the full proof program and provenance record (53 pp.), and a reproducibility archive of 172 files: 64 verification scripts with one log each, exact symbolic targets, and a SHA-256 manifest. Version note (v2.1.18) Version 2.1.18 supersedes version 1. Retitled around the affine Gram identity; version 1's undefined-polynomial step in the vertex-exclusion proof is replaced (conclusion unchanged); two new theorems added (the Kempe loop-trace identity with 4·I_Kempe ≥ Σn², and the edge-determinant identity det T_AB = κ − n_C² giving at least two nonpositive determinants); F₁ ≤ 1 proved; the prior-art claim against Williamson et al. withdrawn; and the reproducibility archive rebuilt to 174 checksummed payloads with 65 scripts, a mutation battery and an invariant sweep.
Preprint. Third paper of the contextuality-obstructions program, alongside Paper A (the canonical class of the MASA context stack), Paper B (the obstruction spectrum of Weyl context families), Paper D (the observer-context category) and a synthesis note. The slogan "contextual holonomy encodes quantum contextuality" is attractive and, as usually stated, false. This paper gives it a sharp form. On the context stack of maximal abelian subalgebras the canonical degree-2 class has order exactly n, and its cocycle holonomy along closed context loops detects EXACTLY the all-versus-nothing sector of contextuality for closed-triple Weyl families at even local dimension. Both containments are strict, each by an explicit certificate: at d=3 the class is nontrivial of order 3 while the achievable state-independent AvN value is 0, and KCBS exhibits state-dependent contextuality where the class shadow vanishes. The Wigner-friend loop generated by H and S splits by level: its projective (Pancharatnam) holonomy is +1 while its determinant-section holonomy is exactly -i, so any interpretational claim about "the" holonomy of that loop must state which one it means. ATTRIBUTION. The classification of state-independent values for qudit Weyl families, the even/odd dichotomy and the fixed value d/2, on which the state-independent side of the equivalence rests, is DUE TO Abramsky, Cercelescu and Constantin (FSCD 2024). Attainment at general even d is the Raussendorf-Okay-Zurel-Feldmann construction. This paper uses both and rediscovers neither. A RETRACTION IS CARRIED IN THIS PAPER, NOT BURIED. An earlier draft presented the tier-two facets of the d=4 census on a (1/(2*sqrt2))Z grid with a single coefficient magnitude 3/(2*sqrt2), and read the resulting unit-coefficient bounds 4*sqrt2 and 14*sqrt2/3 as placing Tsirelson's sqrt2 inside the tier-two geometry. The whole presentation was a normalization artifact and is withdrawn (Retraction 1): the stored lift has coefficients in {0,+-1} with integer bounds 6 and 7, every facet functional in the census is rational, and Q(sqrt2) is not among the eighteen canonical arithmetic fields. Certificate: d4_arithmetic_profile.py. WHERE THE EVIDENCE IS THIN, STATED IN THE PAPER. Two sweeps quoted here drew no positive instances at all: the d=4 half of the 2,100-family equivalence test, and the 6,500-trial false-certificate sweep, which draws no contextual family at any of d=2,4,8 and therefore establishes the absence of false certificates only vacuously. Both are disclosed where they appear. Theorem 2 is labelled machine-validated rather than proved: the closed form is established end to end for the deletion families treated, while the general closed-triple d=2 statement in compressed coordinates remains open and is recorded as open in the verification ledger. HARDWARE CAVEAT, STATED UP FRONT. The quoted significances, about 56 sigma for the ray-level Wigner-friend holonomy and 35.4 sigma for the Peres-Mermin witness above the deterministic bound 4, are shot-noise statistical only, computed under the implemented witness model and conditional on compatibility and nondisturbance assumptions. They are not systematics-aware and neither measurement is loophole-free; a roughly 3.5 sigma preparation offset on one strand is itself evidence of unmodelled systematics. We also record that the pinned value S = 4.6125 cannot be recomputed from the stored counts (a naive recomputation gives 4.5662, a gap of about 2.7 standard errors); the archived value 4.558 +- 0.018 is the one an independent reader can reproduce from the deposited data. Read these as consistency checks on real hardware, not as precision measurements or certifications. STATUS AND SCOPE. This is a preprint, not a peer-reviewed article. It was held back from the first publication batch and released only after three adversarial review passes; what each pass found, and how each item was closed, is recorded in verification/INDEX.md rather than quietly fixed. One defect found there is NOT closed and belongs to the companion Paper B, which cites a false-certificate artifact that is not in fact in the repository; it is recorded rather than left for a reader to discover. COMPANIONS. Paper A: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630431 . Paper B: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630630 . Paper D: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630697 . Note: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630739 . Code archive: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21498498 AI-ASSISTANCE DISCLOSURE. Large-language-model assistants (Anthropic Claude) were used substantially in drafting, in developing the verification scripts, in literature search and in proposing proofs. Every load-bearing claim is machine-verified independently of that assistance by the scripts named in the text, and the author takes full responsibility for the results, including any errors. VERIFICATION CODE. https://github.com/manuflog/contextuality-obstructions
Preprint and reproducibility archive; not peer reviewed. What this record contains. The full text of the manuscript "Identical Few-Particle Gauge Hamiltonians, Programmable Collective Charge Response" (M. J. Baek), its Supplementary Information with complete proofs, and the archive that certifies every closed-form value the paper states. The result. Few-particle dynamics are routinely used to infer collective response in paired quantum matter. This work constructs finite-range interacting response twins that defeat that inference exactly. For any prescribed finite p, two positive finite-range parents have complete static gauge Hamiltonians that coincide at every Peierls link phase on every sector N ≤ p and first separate at N = p+1; their zero-twist finite-density ground rays are the same Dicke condensate, yet their collective charge curvatures differ extensively. The obstruction has no universal depth, and the paper locates it exactly: the blind depth equals the spectator body order, the algebraic bound is independent of geometric range, and bounded range still bounds depth only through the number of sites a ball can hold — so no arbitrary-depth family of uniformly fixed range is claimed. Conversely, a structurally closed exact-pair tower closes at depth two. What is hidden is designable: with d(d+1)/2 displacement families the whole symmetric response-tensor difference is locally realizable at interior filling, and a triangular-lattice twin pair differs only in shear while both diagonal responses stay equal. A 4×4 hard-core-qubit discriminator gives an exact factor-of-two contrast with an internal null control and a state-preparation certificate in 17 equal-time settings. What is certified, and what is not. Results proved in closed form are stated as theorems and proved in full in the Supplementary Information; results established by exact rational or symbolic computation are labelled computer-assisted and carry the script that produces them; the 16-qubit discriminator is a blueprint with an end-to-end noise simulation, not a hardware demonstration, which is not claimed anywhere. Scope limits, open proof lines and one refuted conjecture are recorded explicitly rather than omitted. The archive. response_twins_unified_v1.0.zip contains the manuscript and Supplementary sources, the proof notes, the complete fail-closed verification harness (31 executed stages in release mode — 27 claim-bearing certificate stages, 1 non-claim diagnostic stage and three fail-closed gates — and 24 in quick mode) with one frozen log per stage, independent reimplementations of the load-bearing calculations, negative controls that must fail, the exact-arithmetic certificates behind every closed-form value in the paper, the figure-generation scripts, the scientific claim and provenance record (79 rows with status and scope notes, 50 of them naming the in-archive script or certificate that checks them, the rest saying in words why not), and a per-file SHA-256 manifest of all 209 payload files. Verifying it. Extract the archive and run python3 REPRODUCIBILITY/run_all.py --mode quick for the fast subset or --mode release for all 31 stages; bash BUILD.sh rebuilds both PDFs from source. The three gates check journal-format limits, the release payload against its manifest, and every number the documentation states about the artefacts. Running the harness does not modify the archive: all runtime output is written outside the immutable tree, so verification cannot invalidate the manifest. README.md separates reproducing the content (TeX Live 2023 or newer) from reproducing the archived PDF bytes, which needs the exact producing build recorded inside the PDFs. Licences. Manuscript, Supplementary Information and documentation CC BY 4.0; source code MIT; certificate data CC0 1.0. LICENSE.md is the authoritative per-file mapping and is included both in the archive and as a separate file on this record.
This Theorem establishes the round-trip transport residual (T − I)_rot = (1/160)A from a second independent derivation route (barrier symmetry B = e^{(π/4)A}Θ acting on an ordered pair of noncommuting generators), confirming and strengthening the T48 result. The barrier symmetry acts by exchange-and-inversion: BPB¹ = −Q, BQB⁻¹ = −P, consistent with T47. One-leg transport is modeled by X_{n→d} = (I + λP)(I + λQ); the return leg by X_{d→n} = (I − λQ)(I − λP). A supporting lemma establishes by explicit second-order expansion that T = X_{d→n}X_{n→d} satisfies: T − I = 2λ²A − 2λ²I + O(λ³) where A = ½[P,Q] is the antisymmetric generator and −2λ²I is an isotropic normalization drift that does not affect relative phase or branch observables. Using P² = Q² = I on the reduced two-state space (supported by T36–T37) and [P,Q] = 2A. Under the one-leg normalization λ² = 1/320 inherited from T8 via T48: (T − I)_rot = (1/160)A That both the T48 near-identity route and the T49 barrier-symmetry route converge on the same residue is structurally significant. Status: First-order cancellation, second-order decomposition, and scalar term analysis solid by direct computation. λ² = 1/320 inherited from T8 via T48, not rederived here. B exchange-and-inversion action on P, Q assumed consistent with T47, explicit derivation from T17 kernel geometry open. P² = Q² = I supported by T36–T37, not independently rederived. Qubit algebra correspondence structural, holds within T36–T37 hypotheses, does not assert the full framework is a quantum theory. Dependencies: T7, T8, T17, T36, T37, T47, T48.
Seventh note in the QMEM series on qubit-versus-qutrit antipodal tables. Preprint, version 1; not peer reviewed. An antipodal table records the expectation values of n fixed binary measurements on m pairs of states with opposite values, without shared randomness. Its factorization norm γ₂ is a factorization-based measure of possible qutrit–qubit separation. The condition γ₂ ≤ 1 is necessary for qubit reproducibility and sufficient when the table has at most three rows or at most three columns. For larger tables, γ₂ > 1 certifies a separation, while γ₂ ≤ 1 does not exclude one. The constant κ is the supremum of γ₂ over all qutrit antipodal tables. Main results: Universal bound. Every qutrit antipodal table satisfies γ₂ < 1.058972, improving the previous bound √5/2 ≈ 1.118034. Consequently, 1.007479 ≤ κ < 1.058972. A simpler closed-form bound is γ₂ ≤ 3/(2√2) ≈ 1.060660. Reference states. If all measurements annihilate a state whose largest eigenvalue is at most s (½ ≤ s < 1), then γ₂² ≤ 3/2 − 1/(4s), for arbitrary numbers of pairs and measurements. Every mixture of the pairs' averages is annihilated by those measurements. At s = ½, the bound gives γ₂ ≤ 1, excluding any separation detectable by γ₂; this applies, for example, whenever the table contains an orthogonal pure pair. The underlying pointwise inequality is sharp. Distinguishability and overlap. The pair distinguishability c introduced in Note 6 satisfies c ≤ 1 − tr(ρ⁺ρ⁻) ≤ 4‖σ‖(1 − ‖σ‖) when ‖σ‖ ≥ ½, where σ is the pair's average and ‖σ‖ denotes its largest eigenvalue. Common averages in every dimension. A table whose pairs all share the same average satisfies γ₂ ≤ 1 in any finite dimension, for arbitrary numbers of pairs and measurements. Any excess of γ₂ above one therefore requires pairs with different averages. Coupled certificates. A general factorization bound couples the measurement constraints through the span of all pair averages and encompasses the certificates of Notes 5 and 6. On the certified separating tables of Note 3, a one-parameter family of coupled certificates produces upper bounds within approximately 0.002 of the certified lower bounds. The note is self-contained: Appendix A proves the two results from Note 6 needed for the universal bound. The accompanying reproducibility archive includes proof audits, verification scripts, numerical results, preregistration records, and SHA-256 manifests. The computational checks supplement, but do not replace, the mathematical proofs.
This preprint establishes a Lorentzian factorization theorem for balanced antipodal quantum-state pairs in three-dimensional Hilbert space, with consequences for qubit–qutrit equivalence, prepare-and-measure correlations, and quantum dimension witnesses. We define a pair of qutrit states as balanced when tr(ρ₊ρ₋)² ≤ (1 − tr ρ₊²)(1 − tr ρ₋²). This class includes orthogonal pure-state pairs and pairs with orthogonal supports. Main contributions: Universal factorization theorem. We prove that every prepare-and-measure correlation table generated by balanced qutrit pairs and admissible binary measurements, without shared randomness, satisfies the Euclidean factorization bound γ₂(T) ≤ 1, regardless of the number of pairs or measurement queries. Exact qubit reproducibility. Combining the factorization theorem with an earlier exact qubit criterion, we establish that balanced qutrit configurations are qubit-reproducible whenever there are at most three antipodal pairs or at most three binary queries. In particular, three orthogonal pure-state pairs cannot distinguish a qutrit from a qubit in this setting. Lorentzian geometric construction. The proof uses the quadratic form Q(X) = 2 tr(X²) − (tr X)² on Hermitian 3 × 3 matrices, with signature (8,1). Its dual representation and the spectral inequality −e₂(A) ≤ 1 yield an explicit Euclidean Gram factorization. Unconditional equality classification. We show that every equality configuration of three orthogonal pure-state pairs belongs, up to unitary equivalence, to an embedded-qubit configuration or one of two previously constructed genuinely three-dimensional families: the spin-1 family and the common-vector family. This removes an additional hypothesis required in the preceding note. Reduction of the remaining open problem. We show that any possible three-pair separation can be reduced to configurations containing pure states paired with states of rank at most two, with at least one overlapping pair. We also introduce a semidefinite-programmable certificate whose conjectured universal validity is supported by numerical experiments but remains unproved. The general conjecture that three arbitrary antipodal qutrit state pairs never separate a qutrit from a qubit remains open. The proved results are independent of the numerical investigations. The accompanying reproducibility archive contains preregistered B4h experiments, symbolic and numerical verification scripts, computational results, and SHA-256 manifests. This is the fifth preprint in a research series on qubit–qutrit equivalence, separation, and the geometry of quantum correlations. Status: Research preprint, version 1 (13 November 2026); not peer reviewed.