Research Note This research note proposes a microscopic interpretation of photon reflection and refraction based on a continuous trajectory model. The central hypothesis is that the change in a photon’s direction at an interface may occur continuously over a finite effective interaction region rather than as an instantaneous reversal. Reflection and refraction are considered as possible outcomes of a common microscopic trajectory before a critical condition is reached. The model introduces a reference quadratic trajectory and microscopic deviations around it, expressed conceptually as fᵢ(x) = f₀(x) + δᵢ(x). The reference trajectory represents the statistical mean under identical photon, medium, and incidence conditions, while microscopic deviations may produce probabilistic differences in whether the critical condition is reached. A further hypothesis proposed in this first-stage model is that the area between the trajectory and the reflecting surface may be invariant for photons with equal energy: Eγ = constant → A[f] = constant This hypothesis does not assert an energy-area equivalence or replace established laws of optics. It is presented as a falsifiable hypothesis for future theoretical and experimental investigation. The purpose of this document is to publicly record the initial proposal and development of the idea and to provide a preliminary mathematical framework for future verification. This document does not claim that the proposed model has been experimentally validated or established as a physical theory.
Research Note This research note proposes a microscopic interpretation of photon reflection and refraction based on a continuous trajectory model. The central hypothesis is that the change in a photon’s direction at an interface may occur continuously over a finite effective interaction region rather than as an instantaneous reversal. Reflection and refraction are considered as possible outcomes of a common microscopic trajectory before a critical condition is reached. The model introduces a reference quadratic trajectory and microscopic deviations around it, expressed conceptually as fᵢ(x) = f₀(x) + δᵢ(x). The reference trajectory represents the statistical mean under identical photon, medium, and incidence conditions, while microscopic deviations may produce probabilistic differences in whether the critical condition is reached. A further hypothesis proposed in this first-stage model is that the area between the trajectory and the reflecting surface may be invariant for photons with equal energy: Eγ = constant → A[f] = constant This hypothesis does not assert an energy-area equivalence or replace established laws of optics. It is presented as a falsifiable hypothesis for future theoretical and experimental investigation. The purpose of this document is to publicly record the initial proposal and development of the idea and to provide a preliminary mathematical framework for future verification. This document does not claim that the proposed model has been experimentally validated or established as a physical theory.
A one dimensional reflection/refraction problem is by nature probabilistic because an incident photon either reflects or refracts with certain unknown probabilities. The problem is traditionally solved by matching the electric field and its derivative with respect to x at x=0, t=0 where the electric field for a photon follows from Maxwell’s electromagnetic equations and is given by Eo cos(-wt+kx) where p=hbar k. As such, this problem is treated “classically” We argue, however, that this is a quantum mechanical problem (the photon being a quantum particle). Furthermore, no information is needed about the form of the electric field. Reflection/refraction conserves energy. It also occurs at some x point which may be varied i.e. there is translational invariance. A conservation of energy equation may be immediately written. The first medium has an index of refraction n1=1 and the second n2<n1. The conservation of energy equation is: AA/c1 = BB/c1 + CC/c2 where AA, BB and CC are the incident, reflected and refracted intensities = energy per photon * speed * number of photons. AA etc. is written to show that the intensity is explicitly positive. If one considers A known, then B and C are two unknowns, but there is only one equation. Thus energy conservation is not the full reality or information of the problem. This problem may be mathematically solved by using a difference of squares which leads to two equations: (A+B) = C and p1 (A-B) = p2 C. These may be solved for B,C in terms of A. This, however, is not the most general solution in that it does not show invariance of x i.e. the point at which the index of refraction changes. In this note we investigate the consequences of including x in the solution and argue this leads to a kind of square-root probability function which together with its first derivative should be continuous at any x chosen to be the interface of the media. This leads to a solution of Aexp(ipx), instead of A (etc), which is the free particle wavefunction. Thus this wavefunction (or unusual probability) is a direct consequence of the spatial invariance in the problem, but ensures that no x dependence appears if one combines the two square-root probability equations to create an energy conservation equation which has nothing to do with x.
The work relates to the fundamentals of quantum physics and photonics, in particular to the formation of processes of reflection, refraction and absorption of waves of ballistic photons. The study of these problems is an important and urgent task for understanding the foundations of the material world, which has not yet been fully resolved. An important property of ballistic photons is their motion in a straight line, which can be curved under the action of physical fields on the photons and the parameters of the medium of their motion. However, if external factors remain constant, their motion continues in a straight line, which allows us to apply the laws of geometric optics to them. The fundamentals of the geometric wave laws of reflection and refraction of light are laid down of the Young and Fresnel. However, they used sinusoidal waves similar to transverse waves in the of musical strings, which contradicts the motion of spherical waves of ballistic photons. Elimination of these shortcomings is the main goal of the work, and its scientific novelty is the substantiation and development of new geometric models of light motion. Research Methods: Since this work has the level of scientific discovery, for finding which strict methods have not yet been created, therefore, general principles of development of the theory of scientific knowledge were used, based on the laws of dialectics and consistency with the basic laws of physics. The author's research methodology was also used, based on the transition to the initial quantum level of the material world. New Results of the Work and their Discussion: It is shown that the first point of contact of photon waves lies on the unified normal to their spherical surface and the contact surface. This shifts the real normal of wave reflection relative to the traditional normal from the point of intersection of the axis of the tube of incident waves with the surface of reflection by the value of -Δ = λmax sin α. The real axis of reflection of spherical waves is associated with the crests most distant from the initial point of their reflection. When photon waves are refractional, their total deviation is formed from the last point of their incidence on the refraction surface. This shifts the real point of the normal of wave refraction relative to the traditional normal from the point of intersection of the axis of the tube of incident waves with the surface of reflection by the value of +Δ = λmax sin α. Geometric models of all these processes at different angles of incidence of photon waves are developed and their simplified schemes are given. Conclusions: The proposed models and schemes of reflection and refraction of spherical photon waves significantly clarify and change previously known schemes and do not contradict the real laws of physics and optics, therefore they have the level of scientific discoveries and should replace previously known processes and schemes.
It is known that if a photon hits a surface with a different index of refraction (at an angle within a certain range), it has a specific probability “a” to reflect and 1-a to refract. In this note we ask: Where does this statistical nature come from? In previous notes, we have considered Fermat’s principle applied separately to explain two dimensional reflection and refraction. We have also used the idea of a difference of squares and energy conservation in one dimensional reflection/refraction to find values of the probabilities. The question we ask is: Why are there probabilities in the first place? Is there some general idea at work despite the complicated details of the photon interacting with the atoms of the new medium.We argue the general notion is due to the idea of spatial invariance which is linked to the translation operator d/dx which in turn in linked to a p impulse occurring at a given x .Thus the variables p and x are linked through the notion of an impulse existing at some x. The idea that d/dx may operate on a function of constant p and x to yield p, implies the function of p,x should have physical meaning. This is a problem as classically a particle moving with constant p should not be associated with any function of x except a constant. (All x points are the “same”.) Thus we argue that a “probability” in x is established with a constantly moving particle (or even photon). The eigenfunction of d/dx (or rather -id/dx) which exhibits some kind of spatial invariance is exp(ipx). This contains two different x probability distributions cos(px) and sin(px). We noted that d/dx is associated with p due to an impulse hit at say an x point. Thus various exp(ipx)s with different weights should appear together in a physical problem with impulses such as reflection/refraction. The weights of the various exp(ip1 x), exp(ip2 x) etc become linked to probabilities associated with the state 1, 2 etc. Thus the origin of these probabilities (i.e. their specific values) follow from the probabilistic form exp(ipx) which follows from d/dx. (In (1) we have argued that the x distributions in exp(ipx) may be further linked to the force which “created” the p in the first place, with different p values having different distributions cos(px), sin(px)).
It is known that a single photon moving in the x direction and encountering an n1-n2 index of refraction discontinuity at xo will either reflect or refract, with the probabilities for each summing to 1. This problem, however, is solved using a balance of Aexp(ipx)+Bexp(-ipx) = Cexp(ip2 x) at xo and the derivative d/dx, of this equation. The complex conjugate of one equation multiplied by the second yields: AA/c = BB/c + CC/c2 where E=pc and E is constant for the incident, reflected and refracted photon. The two continuity equations apply even in the case of a single photon, but in such a case one has either an incident photon changing to a reflected one or an incident to a refracted one. One never has all three together as in thte two continuity equations. We ask: How is it possible to include both a refracted and reflected photon together with the incident in the same equation? We suggest here that the form exp(ipx) applies to momentum, whether it is part of a particle or part of a potential field. exp(ipx) may be obtained from maximization of entropy -P(x)ln(P(x)) subject to the periodic constraint ipxP(x). We suggest that in a single photon interaction, one has momentum in media n1 and n2 and these allow for the continuity equation with the system interactions taking the place of a photon to create the balance. There is stochasticity in that a single photon either becomes a reflected or refracted one, but exp(ipx) does not simply apply to the photon. it may be applied to the n1-n2 interface momentum which is created during the interaction. This interaction is consistent with the a steady stream picture only involving photons . Thus for a single photon, it appears as if one has an entangled probability exp(ipx)’s for the incident, reflected and refracted photons, but actually the physical photon only plays a role as first an incident one and then either a reflected or refracted one with the n1-n2 interface momentum creating the missing exp(ipx) piece needed for the continuity balance. Ultimately, A,B and C become probabilities AA/c,= 1, BB/c = P(reflected) and CC/c2= P(refracted), but these are not obtained by maximizing entropy subject to a constraint.as one does not have independence of probabilities.We note that the two continuity equations combine to create a pressure balance which one wishes to have physically in the problem. The photon reflection-refraction problem may be reformulated for a particle with rest mass using a particle with E, p in a constant potential V1 reaching a V1-V2 (both constant) interface at xo with E remaining constant.
In Newtonian mechanics a particle with constant momentum moves deterministically according to x=p/m t. Even a quantum object such as a photon or electron should satisfy this equation on average to give meaning to the notion of the speed of light in a vacuum, for example. Thus it seems surprising that a quantum free particle is also associated with exp(ipx) which only contains momentum and is periodic and complex. Furthermore the physical consequences of exp(ipx) are real as shown in a two-slit interference experiment etc. In this note, we attempt to discover why exp(ipx) exists in the first place by examining the example of the reflection/refraction of light which occurs in the macroscopic classical world. Basically our argument is based on analyzing two important pieces of information in the system, namely the scalar energy (or particle count) and the vector momentum. A main point we make is that energy or particle number considerations are linked to determinism i.e. a specific time of interaction. One may note that the interaction x is fixed by the two medium barrier. This means a single incident photon exists in one time range and the reflected OR refracted photon in another. It is possible to compare the incident photon to either the reflected or refracted or to a sum of probabilities. In particular, a single photon has an energy E and a count of 1. If it reflects, it has an energy E and count of 1 so there is a balance, likewise for refraction. Thinking in terms of probabilities “a” and 1-a to reflect/refract: 1= a + 1-a. Can one perform such a matching for momentum, which is a physical piece of information? We argue one cannot. For example, a single incident photon has a momentum p which is linked to the impulse it may deliver. If it refracts, “all of a sudden” it is linked with momentum of p2 = n2 p where n2 is the index of refraction in the second medium and n1=1. This seems problematic because a physical impulse of 2p is all of a sudden an impulse of 2p2. Thus there exists a big problem which seems to require the notion of probability and all three momentum values p, -p and p2 considered together, unlike the situation of energy/particle number for which a comparison of the incident photon and one possible result yields a balance. Combining all three momenta, however, is also problematic in a deterministic picture because the incident photon exists in one time range and the reflected or refracted in another. How can one possibly compare them together? The solution seems to be to argue that the incident photon is only deterministic on average. In particular, if it has an x probability distribution over a certain length (called a wavelength), one does not know the precise time at which it hits “x” the medium interface. In such a situation, there is time uncertainty which allows all three momenta to be compared at the same x. This, however, leads to a major consequence, namely that so-called deterministic motion associated with constant p is deterministic on average, but contains repeated pockets of x probability distributions such that time is not deterministic within. We try to examine these ideas in this note.
The problem of a photon reflecting or refracting at an n1-n2 index of refraction is solved in (1) using the notion of continuity of the electric field of a photon and its d/dx derivative for the n1-n2 junction at x=0. The photon electric field behaves as cos(-wt+kx) or cos(-Et+px). We argue first of all that the photon is a quantum object and that this problem is really a quantum mechanical one as it may also be solved for a particle with rest mass using two different constant potentials V1, V2 instead of n1,n2. In this note, we consider the photon case for convenience. Given that the problem is really a quantum mechanical one (in our opinion), we ask: How far can one go by trying to solve it classically? We first point out that for a static uniform arrangement of objects in space, P(x)dx =dx/L, where L is an arbitrary length. In the case of particles moving at constant v, one may argue that each particle spends the same amount of time dt in each dx and that this also leads to a constant density in space. We suggest that for this to hold, one must consider a steady state problem and the notion of flux for physical reasons. This leads to writing the equation 1= Probability(reflect)+Probability(refract) as AA/c = BB/c + CC/c2 where AA, BB, CC are the incident, reflected and refracted fluxes and c1=c, c2=c/n2. We have shown in previous notes that one may mathematically write this single equation as: A+B=C and Ap-Bp = Cp2 using E=pc (with E the same for the incident, reflected and refracted photon) and then solve the two equations for the two unknowns B,C, setting A=1. This approach yields a result which matches experiment, but from the standpoint of classical physics, there is no a priori reason to take the square root of flux. It simply arises as a math trick so to speak, we argue, and there seems to be no physical motivation. Here, we suggest approaching the problem differently. We note that if c1-c2<<1, then there should be almost no reflection, while if c2<<1, there should be almost no refraction. We ask: What happens if one suggests that in the c1-c2<<1 case that one insists on BB dropping as (c1-c2)*(c1-c2), i.e. to second power as in a stable equilibrium and for CC dropping as c2*c2 for c2<<1 in the other extreme. This is a possible approach that seems to be linked to some kind of physical principle, and one may consider the simplest solution and compare it with experiment and find that it holds. In other words, it yields the same solution as the above approaches. Moreover, this approach gives a link with the square root approach of the above paragraph, because now one is linking c-c2 and c2 directly with square root fluxes A,B,C so as to obtain the quadratic feature automatically for c-c2<<1 or c<<1 when one ultimately uses AA, BB, CC. In other words, the assumption of quadratic vanishing of BB and CC, automatically leads to c-c2 or c2 vanishing of B and C, suggesting that one may automatically achieve the quadratic vanishing form by working with A,B,C square root flux variables. We suggest that this idea of quadratic vanishing of BB or CC possibly places the approach of using A+B = C, pA-pB=p2C on more physical grounds and points to a new kind of physics which uses A,B,C, namely quantum mechanics.