Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Why Measure Error Correlations Before Choosing a Code: An Industry Brief and Pre-Registered Benchmark Protocol

Rowan Brad Quni-Gudzinas

Published Aug 20, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This record bundles two engagement artifacts derived from the v1.4 register of the Trapped-Ion Ultrametric Testbed (10.5281/zenodo.22025544): (1) industry-brief-2026-08-20.md — "Why Measure Error Correlations Before Choosing a Code": a one-page brief answering whether the ultrametric quantum error-correction path is worth pursuing given its published independent-error threshold disadvantage (~55x below surface codes). The brief leads with the honest disclosure, frames the single falsifiable bet (error structure at scale is not independent), and offers four theory-neutral instruments (an 8-week trapped-ion probe, a laptop benchmark, an energy-audit template, and a QEC-Darwinism constraint checker). (2) correlated-error-benchmark-spec-2026-08-20.md — a pre-registered measurement protocol with six observables, five metrics, and three binding decision rules (including KILL-ULTRAMETRIC, which is binding on the program itself). The protocol is theory-neutral: the correlation metrics improve any code choice, ultrametric or not. Both artifacts are published as open engagement documents; the register's decision rules and kill-conditions are pre-registered. No hardware-advantage claim is made in either document.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22028077

Related papers

The Trapped-Ion Ultrametric Testbed: A Falsifiability Register for Testing p-Adic Structure in Quantum Dynamics

Rowan Brad Quni-Gudzinas

Sixteen published records from a single research program, spanning December 2025 to August 2026, are here organized into one testable claim: trapped-ion quantum simulators are the first near-term platform on which ultrametric (p-adic) structure in quantum dynamics can be accepted or rejected by measurement, and passive, dissipation-structured hardware is the engineering embodiment of that structure. The synthesis contributes a falsifiability register: five observables, each with a pre-registered prediction, a kill-condition, and an apparatus already demonstrated in the cited records. It also records what the program has already ruled out, including the finding that generic Page-Wootters clock-rest coupling violates ultrametricity at a 29-35 percent rate while diagonal coupling yields exact ultrametric structure -- the very asymmetry the trapped-ion protocol measures -- and the economic finding that trapped ions rank last among seventeen platforms on a joules-per-solution basis, making the ion trap a physics testbed rather than a production economics play. The paper discloses its premise depth: the falsifiable content rests on two named imported inputs, and the claims end where those inputs begin. A practitioner section specifies what can be built today without any new theory.

•Aug 19, 2026•0 citations

QEC-REPL-1: pre-registered independent replication of Google's 2022 surface-code scaling result

Devin Phillip Davis

Pre-registration, deposited before any outcome file of the dataset was analysed. It fixes the method and decision rules for an independent replication, with open-source Stim and PyMatching, of the surface-code scaling result in Google Quantum AI's dataset 10.5281/zenodo.6804040 (arXiv:2207.06431): R1 reproducing the provided PyMatching predictions; R2 whether distance-5 logical error per round is below the distance-3 average (Λ > 1) with data-fitted error models; R3 whether the abstract's per-cycle error rates are reproduced from the provided predictions of each decoder. Results will be published whichever way they fall.

•Oct 8, 2026•0 citations

A pre-registered entanglement-forged H₄ benchmark on trapped-ion hardware: accurate noise modelling, incomplete error correction

Venkata Rao Allu

We report a pre-registered benchmark of an entanglement-forged H4 ground-state calculation on IonQ Forte Enterprise 1, a live trapped-ion processor. The analysis was frozen and publicly committed before any hardware data existed. The experiment comprised one submission of 81 new circuits at 1,100 shots per circuit, with device debiasing disabled. A three-parameter analytic noise model, fixed in advance, predicted the uncorrected energy error to within approximately 1%: 23.84 kcal/mol measured versus 24.06 kcal/mol predicted. However, the frame-free corrected estimator returned an error of 3.46 kcal/mol, compared with 0.83 kcal/mol predicted. This missed the conventional chemical-accuracy threshold of 1 kcal/mol. The shot-noise-weighted chi-square per degree of freedom increased from approximately 2 in simulator rehearsals to 5.93 on hardware. Analysis of 732 residuals identified elevated discrepancies in strongly corrected, high-weight XY-type observables and a systematic offset in one measurement group. A subsequent correction-magnitude refit showed that improving the goodness-of-fit statistic did not necessarily improve energy accuracy. These results demonstrate that a noise model that predicts uncorrected hardware behaviour accurately may still fail to predict the performance of the correction built from it. The paper reports the pre-registered experimental design, hardware results, residual diagnostics, follow-up tests, and methodological limitations. This work is not a blind variational ground-state search. The exact-state dependencies of the shared-frame estimator are disclosed, and the results do not establish reliable chemical accuracy for the frame-free estimator. Code and data repository: https://github.com/Venkatallu11/quantum-chemistry-vqe

•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

The Revolutionary Beginner's Guide to Quantum Computing: Why We Don't Have Quantum Computers Yet — and What the Geometric Alternative Offers

Rowan Brad Quni-Gudzinas

A 20-chapter beginner's guide to quantum computing that starts with an honest question — why don't we have quantum computers yet? The guide teaches the standard curriculum accurately, explains why the standard approach faces a thermodynamic wall (a 20,000-fold cooling gap that is Carnot-limited), and introduces the ultrametric alternative: passive geometric fault tolerance on Bruhat-Tits trees, with DOI-registered evidence, computationally validated error thresholds 75 times higher than surface codes, and three falsifiable predictions. This is the v1.2 edition (August 2026). Five quantitative statements from the May 2026 edition are corrected, each verified by an independent computation deposited with this record (artifacts/verification/verify_guide_claims.py, 35 checks, all passing; see Appendix B). Appendix A records the research program's progress since May 2026, including a trapped-ion falsifiability register, an audit of a 2026 no-go theorem on quantum error correction and quantum Darwinism, and the program's own correction on prime-valuation readings of quantum codes. This deposit includes the complete source set: manuscript, HTML, PDF, references (BibTeX), citation audit, project plan, license, and verification artifacts. v1.2.1 (August 2026): post-publication audit corrections. Chapter 20's summary now lists seven open problems (including the QEC–Darwinism tradeoff); the LHC temperature comparison is marked approximate (95×, rounded); Appendix A correction #5 completed; the citation audit's internal-reference count corrected; open problem 7 carries its numeric bound (F_L > 0.874). No quantitative claims changed. v1.2.2 (August 2026): deposit-file corrections. LICENSE now contains the full CC BY 4.0 International legal code, and README.md is the deposit manifest (a project-blueprint README was attached in v1.2.1 by an automation error). No content changes.

•May 26, 2026•0 citations

Why large-scale quantum computing faces hard physical limits: a source-loss balance tested against measured data

Oleg Arnold

This note applies a single first-order source-loss balance, C dθ/dt = A − ρθ, to systems across many scales — from a planetary surface to a qubit register — and reports, with exact numbers, where the balance reproduces measured values and where it does not. The central quantitative result concerns quantum error correction. Using published surface-code and trapped-ion data (Google Quantum AI, Nature 638, 920 (2024); Quantinuum Helios colour-code results, 2026), the note shows that the logical error per cycle falls by a constant factor Λ only while errors are independent. Correlated bursts act as a common loss channel whose rate does not fall with code distance; the quoted floor is about 3×10⁻¹⁰ per cycle, reached at distance about 46 for Λ = 2.17. For factoring a 2048-bit integer (about 1.4×10³ logical qubits, 6.5×10⁹ Toffoli gates, 4.96 days at a 1 μs cycle), the permitted logical error is 1.7×10⁻¹⁵ per qubit per cycle. At measured suppression factors this requires code distances of about 78 (Λ = 2.17) or about 24 (Λ = 12), while the published design uses 25 — and the correlated-error floor is not removed by increasing distance. This is a quantitative statement about where the scaling of error suppression stops matching the requirements of large computations, not a claim that small-scale quantum devices cannot work. The note also lists, separately and with exact values, the tests the balance fails: quark mass-step prediction (T6), gas/solid classification (T8, p = 0.81), nuclear count with A = 3, 4, prediction SP1 (−11.8% against a 10% threshold), coupling versus number of doors (T10, p = 0.015), width-to-cosmological-scale mapping (q₀ = −0.528 ± 0.011 against 0), human loss-rate estimates (11.1 and 15.3 W/K), critical Q₁₀ = 3.03 against measured 2.0–2.3, Higgs width from the b-quark exit alone (13.7% residual), shell boundaries (13 of 18), and several time constants. Of nine tests where the balance gives a value different from the standard one, one agreed with measurement and eight did not; the rules and thresholds were written before the data were examined. Successful checks include: photosynthesis stage efficiencies (0.487 × 0.094 = 0.0458 against 0.046 reported), a three-stage 2.45 GHz rectenna chain (0.906³ = 0.744), closure of the lunar surface energy budget to a ratio of 1.005, mode quality factors Q = m/Γ for the τ lepton (7.84×10¹¹), the Z boson (36.5) and the Higgs boson (3.38×10⁴), the Higgs lifetime from its width (290.87 fs against 290.3 ± 0.5 fs, a consistency check of standard formulas), and the proton-decay bound ρ < 1.3×10⁻⁴² s⁻¹. The complete theory, tests, scripts and the list of open items are maintained at https://zenodo.org/records/23812417. This note is a standalone publication; readers are invited to report measured values that disagree.

•Nov 13, 2026•0 citations

Measurement as Record-Registration: A Locked-Null Protocol for Testing Record-Level Structure in Quantum Computing Readout

William T Partin

This manuscript presents a methods-forward, operational protocol for evaluating whether any structured dependence remains in quantum-computing measurement records after explicit modeling of standard quantum and device-level mechanisms. Classical definiteness is defined at the record layer, and pre-record states are treated as predictive descriptions rather than as classical outcome facts. Within this operational stance, the protocol converts questions about outcome status and record formation into a falsifiable test program grounded in preregistered analysis rules and standard measurement telemetry. A locked null-model family is specified in advance, incorporating standard quantum dynamics together with documented device-level mechanisms including drift, correlated and non-Markovian noise, crosstalk proxies, and leakage indicators. The framework provides operational definitions, a conservative postulate set, preregistered endpoints, residual-adjudication criteria, negative controls, a fixed windowing discipline, and a bound-first reporting standard designed to yield informative constraints under null results. Any candidate contribution beyond the declared null family must appear as structured, reproducible residual dependence that survives the locked null family and the full residual-filter sequence. Version 4.4 refines the protocol specification, clarifies evidentiary boundaries, and strengthens the integration of the synthetic demonstration. The manuscript includes a fully specified classical simulation that executes the decision pipeline under controlled conditions. The synthetic study illustrates how the protocol classifies a bounded-null case, a measured-artifact case, a partial-artifact/unresolved-covariate case, an injected structured-residual case, and a failed-topology case. This demonstration establishes computational executability of the protocol and clarifies the behavior of the decision tree, but it does not constitute empirical evidence for any physical mechanism. Because the protocol relies only on standard measurement telemetry and preregistered analysis rules, it is directly implementable across contemporary quantum-computing platforms and does not depend on any single dataset, backend, or hardware realization. The manuscript is a specification paper: it defines a reproducible evidentiary framework for record-level claims, while large-scale empirical implementation, hardware benchmarking, and cross-platform replication remain subsequent studies.

•Mar 17, 2026•0 citations
This record bundles two engagement artifacts derived from the v1.4 register of the Trapped-Ion Ultrametric Testbed (10.5281/zenodo.22025544): (1) industry-brief-2026-08-20.md — "Why Measure Error Correlations Before Choosing a Code": a one-page brief answering whether the ultrametric quantum error-correction path is worth pursuing given its published independent-error threshold disadvantage (~55x below surface codes). The brief leads with the honest disclosure, frames the single falsifiable bet (error structure at scale is not independent), and offers four theory-neutral instruments (an 8-week trapped-ion probe, a laptop benchmark, an energy-audit template, and a QEC-Darwinism constraint checker). (2) correlated-error-benchmark-spec-2026-08-20.md — a pre-registered measurement protocol with six observables, five metrics, and three binding decision rules (including KILL-ULTRAMETRIC, which is binding on the program itself). The protocol is theory-neutral: the correlation metrics improve any code choice, ultrametric or not. Both artifacts are published as open engagement documents; the register's decision rules and kill-conditions are pre-registered. No hardware-advantage claim is made in either document.
Sixteen published records from a single research program, spanning December 2025 to August 2026, are here organized into one testable claim: trapped-ion quantum simulators are the first near-term platform on which ultrametric (p-adic) structure in quantum dynamics can be accepted or rejected by measurement, and passive, dissipation-structured hardware is the engineering embodiment of that structure. The synthesis contributes a falsifiability register: five observables, each with a pre-registered prediction, a kill-condition, and an apparatus already demonstrated in the cited records. It also records what the program has already ruled out, including the finding that generic Page-Wootters clock-rest coupling violates ultrametricity at a 29-35 percent rate while diagonal coupling yields exact ultrametric structure -- the very asymmetry the trapped-ion protocol measures -- and the economic finding that trapped ions rank last among seventeen platforms on a joules-per-solution basis, making the ion trap a physics testbed rather than a production economics play. The paper discloses its premise depth: the falsifiable content rests on two named imported inputs, and the claims end where those inputs begin. A practitioner section specifies what can be built today without any new theory.
Pre-registration, deposited before any outcome file of the dataset was analysed. It fixes the method and decision rules for an independent replication, with open-source Stim and PyMatching, of the surface-code scaling result in Google Quantum AI's dataset 10.5281/zenodo.6804040 (arXiv:2207.06431): R1 reproducing the provided PyMatching predictions; R2 whether distance-5 logical error per round is below the distance-3 average (Λ > 1) with data-fitted error models; R3 whether the abstract's per-cycle error rates are reproduced from the provided predictions of each decoder. Results will be published whichever way they fall.
We report a pre-registered benchmark of an entanglement-forged H4 ground-state calculation on IonQ Forte Enterprise 1, a live trapped-ion processor. The analysis was frozen and publicly committed before any hardware data existed. The experiment comprised one submission of 81 new circuits at 1,100 shots per circuit, with device debiasing disabled. A three-parameter analytic noise model, fixed in advance, predicted the uncorrected energy error to within approximately 1%: 23.84 kcal/mol measured versus 24.06 kcal/mol predicted. However, the frame-free corrected estimator returned an error of 3.46 kcal/mol, compared with 0.83 kcal/mol predicted. This missed the conventional chemical-accuracy threshold of 1 kcal/mol. The shot-noise-weighted chi-square per degree of freedom increased from approximately 2 in simulator rehearsals to 5.93 on hardware. Analysis of 732 residuals identified elevated discrepancies in strongly corrected, high-weight XY-type observables and a systematic offset in one measurement group. A subsequent correction-magnitude refit showed that improving the goodness-of-fit statistic did not necessarily improve energy accuracy. These results demonstrate that a noise model that predicts uncorrected hardware behaviour accurately may still fail to predict the performance of the correction built from it. The paper reports the pre-registered experimental design, hardware results, residual diagnostics, follow-up tests, and methodological limitations. This work is not a blind variational ground-state search. The exact-state dependencies of the shared-frame estimator are disclosed, and the results do not establish reliable chemical accuracy for the frame-free estimator. Code and data repository: https://github.com/Venkatallu11/quantum-chemistry-vqe
A 20-chapter beginner's guide to quantum computing that starts with an honest question — why don't we have quantum computers yet? The guide teaches the standard curriculum accurately, explains why the standard approach faces a thermodynamic wall (a 20,000-fold cooling gap that is Carnot-limited), and introduces the ultrametric alternative: passive geometric fault tolerance on Bruhat-Tits trees, with DOI-registered evidence, computationally validated error thresholds 75 times higher than surface codes, and three falsifiable predictions. This is the v1.2 edition (August 2026). Five quantitative statements from the May 2026 edition are corrected, each verified by an independent computation deposited with this record (artifacts/verification/verify_guide_claims.py, 35 checks, all passing; see Appendix B). Appendix A records the research program's progress since May 2026, including a trapped-ion falsifiability register, an audit of a 2026 no-go theorem on quantum error correction and quantum Darwinism, and the program's own correction on prime-valuation readings of quantum codes. This deposit includes the complete source set: manuscript, HTML, PDF, references (BibTeX), citation audit, project plan, license, and verification artifacts. v1.2.1 (August 2026): post-publication audit corrections. Chapter 20's summary now lists seven open problems (including the QEC–Darwinism tradeoff); the LHC temperature comparison is marked approximate (95×, rounded); Appendix A correction #5 completed; the citation audit's internal-reference count corrected; open problem 7 carries its numeric bound (F_L > 0.874). No quantitative claims changed. v1.2.2 (August 2026): deposit-file corrections. LICENSE now contains the full CC BY 4.0 International legal code, and README.md is the deposit manifest (a project-blueprint README was attached in v1.2.1 by an automation error). No content changes.
This note applies a single first-order source-loss balance, C dθ/dt = A − ρθ, to systems across many scales — from a planetary surface to a qubit register — and reports, with exact numbers, where the balance reproduces measured values and where it does not. The central quantitative result concerns quantum error correction. Using published surface-code and trapped-ion data (Google Quantum AI, Nature 638, 920 (2024); Quantinuum Helios colour-code results, 2026), the note shows that the logical error per cycle falls by a constant factor Λ only while errors are independent. Correlated bursts act as a common loss channel whose rate does not fall with code distance; the quoted floor is about 3×10⁻¹⁰ per cycle, reached at distance about 46 for Λ = 2.17. For factoring a 2048-bit integer (about 1.4×10³ logical qubits, 6.5×10⁹ Toffoli gates, 4.96 days at a 1 μs cycle), the permitted logical error is 1.7×10⁻¹⁵ per qubit per cycle. At measured suppression factors this requires code distances of about 78 (Λ = 2.17) or about 24 (Λ = 12), while the published design uses 25 — and the correlated-error floor is not removed by increasing distance. This is a quantitative statement about where the scaling of error suppression stops matching the requirements of large computations, not a claim that small-scale quantum devices cannot work. The note also lists, separately and with exact values, the tests the balance fails: quark mass-step prediction (T6), gas/solid classification (T8, p = 0.81), nuclear count with A = 3, 4, prediction SP1 (−11.8% against a 10% threshold), coupling versus number of doors (T10, p = 0.015), width-to-cosmological-scale mapping (q₀ = −0.528 ± 0.011 against 0), human loss-rate estimates (11.1 and 15.3 W/K), critical Q₁₀ = 3.03 against measured 2.0–2.3, Higgs width from the b-quark exit alone (13.7% residual), shell boundaries (13 of 18), and several time constants. Of nine tests where the balance gives a value different from the standard one, one agreed with measurement and eight did not; the rules and thresholds were written before the data were examined. Successful checks include: photosynthesis stage efficiencies (0.487 × 0.094 = 0.0458 against 0.046 reported), a three-stage 2.45 GHz rectenna chain (0.906³ = 0.744), closure of the lunar surface energy budget to a ratio of 1.005, mode quality factors Q = m/Γ for the τ lepton (7.84×10¹¹), the Z boson (36.5) and the Higgs boson (3.38×10⁴), the Higgs lifetime from its width (290.87 fs against 290.3 ± 0.5 fs, a consistency check of standard formulas), and the proton-decay bound ρ < 1.3×10⁻⁴² s⁻¹. The complete theory, tests, scripts and the list of open items are maintained at https://zenodo.org/records/23812417. This note is a standalone publication; readers are invited to report measured values that disagree.
This manuscript presents a methods-forward, operational protocol for evaluating whether any structured dependence remains in quantum-computing measurement records after explicit modeling of standard quantum and device-level mechanisms. Classical definiteness is defined at the record layer, and pre-record states are treated as predictive descriptions rather than as classical outcome facts. Within this operational stance, the protocol converts questions about outcome status and record formation into a falsifiable test program grounded in preregistered analysis rules and standard measurement telemetry. A locked null-model family is specified in advance, incorporating standard quantum dynamics together with documented device-level mechanisms including drift, correlated and non-Markovian noise, crosstalk proxies, and leakage indicators. The framework provides operational definitions, a conservative postulate set, preregistered endpoints, residual-adjudication criteria, negative controls, a fixed windowing discipline, and a bound-first reporting standard designed to yield informative constraints under null results. Any candidate contribution beyond the declared null family must appear as structured, reproducible residual dependence that survives the locked null family and the full residual-filter sequence. Version 4.4 refines the protocol specification, clarifies evidentiary boundaries, and strengthens the integration of the synthetic demonstration. The manuscript includes a fully specified classical simulation that executes the decision pipeline under controlled conditions. The synthetic study illustrates how the protocol classifies a bounded-null case, a measured-artifact case, a partial-artifact/unresolved-covariate case, an injected structured-residual case, and a failed-topology case. This demonstration establishes computational executability of the protocol and clarifies the behavior of the decision tree, but it does not constitute empirical evidence for any physical mechanism. Because the protocol relies only on standard measurement telemetry and preregistered analysis rules, it is directly implementable across contemporary quantum-computing platforms and does not depend on any single dataset, backend, or hardware realization. The manuscript is a specification paper: it defines a reproducible evidentiary framework for record-level claims, while large-scale empirical implementation, hardware benchmarking, and cross-platform replication remain subsequent studies.