Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Resourcefulness of quantum measurement

Rakesh Kumar Saini

Published Aug 19, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum measurements lie at the core of quantum information processing, enabling tasks ranging from state reconstruction and parameter estimation to sensing and computation. As quantum technologies scale and become increasingly precise, a central question emerges: what does it mean for a quantum measurement to be good? This thesis addresses this question by developing quantitative, operational, and physically grounded frameworks for assessing the quality and informational power of quantum measurements.The first part of the thesis focuses on the intrinsic quality of quantum measurements independent of any particular input state. Adopting the formalism of quantum resource theories, measurements are treated as resources ordered under classical post-processing, which cannot increase informational content. Restricting attention to informationally complete measurements, we employ frame theory to introduce a novel resource monotone termed completeness stability, defined as the minimum eigenvalue of a suitably scaled frame operator. We establish its operational significance by showing that the average error in quantum state tomography and the average variance in shadow tomography are tightly bounded by the inverse of the completeness stability. Maximizing this monotone identifies weighted complex projective 2-designs, including symmetric informationally complete POVMs and mutually unbiased bases, as optimal measurement configurations.The second part of the thesis extends these ideas to quantum parameter estimation, where measurement performance necessarily depends on correlations between the measurement and the encoded quantum state. By introducing a state-dependent inner product on operator space, we develop an operator-theoretic formulation in which both the classical and quantum Fisher information arise naturally from a single frame operator associated with the measurement and the reference state. Within this framework, the spectral properties of the frame operator provide a complete characterization of estimation performance. The maximum and minimum eigenvalues identify the best- and worst-case parameter-encoding directions, respectively, yielding sharp bounds on the achievable ratio of classical and quantum Fisher information. This establishes a direct connection between informational completeness, estimation robustness, and resource-theoretic monotonicity.The final part of the thesis returns to foundational questions concerning quantum measurement and arrival time. Using Bohmian mechanics, we develop a microscopic, first-principles account of the Hong–Ou–Mandel effect, a paradigmatic two-particle interference phenomenon. By analyzing particle trajectories guided by the wave function, we show how bosonic bunching and fermionic anti-bunching emerge dynamically from the guiding equation without invoking wave-function collapse. Beyond reproducing the Hong–Ou–Mandel dip, we demonstrate how experimental parameters such as barrier strength, phase velocity, and path asymmetry influence both coincidence probabilities and temporal correlations.Taken together, this thesis provides a unified treatment of quantum measurement quality across operational, metrological, and dynamical regimes. By bridging resource theory, frame theory, Fisher information, and trajectory-based quantum dynamics, it offers new insights into the structure, limitations, and physical interpretation of quantum measurements in both applied and foundational contexts.

DOI
10.25949/33235329

Related papers

Completeness stability of quantum measurements

Rakesh Saini, Jukka Kiukas, Daniel Klaus Burgarth +1 more

We introduce a resource monotone, the completeness stability, to quantify the quality of quantum measurements within a resource-theoretic framework. By viewing a quantum measurement as a frame, the minimum eigenvalue of a frame operator emerges as a significant monotone. It captures bounds on estimation errors and the numerical stability of inverting the frame operator to calculate the optimal dual for state reconstruction. Maximizing this monotone identifies a well-characterized class of quantum measurements forming weighted complex projective 2-designs, which includes well-known examples such as SIC-POVMs. Our results provide a principled framework for comparing and optimizing quantum measurements for practical applications.

arXiv:2506.11539•Physical Review A•Dec 4, 2025•4 citations

Characterizing Fisher information of quantum measurement

Rakesh Saini, Jukka Kiukas, Daniel Burgarth +1 more

Informationally complete measurements form the foundation of universal quantum state reconstruction, while quantum parameter estimation is based on the local structure of the manifold of quantum states. Here we establish a general link between these two aspects, in the context of a single informationally complete measurement, by employing a suitably adapted operator frame theory. In particular, we bound the ratio between the classical and quantum Fisher information in terms of the spectral decomposition of the associated frame operator, and connect these bounds to the optimal and least optimal directions for parameter encoding. The geometric and operational characterization of information extraction thus obtained reveals the fundamental tradeoff imposed by informational completeness on local quantum parameter estimation.

quant-pharXiv:2512.15428•Physical Review A•Dec 18, 2025•4 citations

From States to Measurements: Information-Theoretic Measures for Quantum Characterisation

Aritra Das

Quantum states and measurements are two central physical objects in the theory of quantum mechanics. The preparation, control and measurement of quantum states lies at the heart of modern quantum information processing protocols ranging from secure communication to quantum computation and precision sensing. And yet, the reliable operation of these advanced protocols ultimately rests on a far more essential prerequisite - our ability to calibrate, certify and benchmark the quantum states we prepare and the quantum measurements we perform. Quantum information theory provides a natural framework for these tasks, meaningfully connecting the resources we expend for characterisation with the accuracy and precision we can expect in return. While decades of advances in quantum information have refined our understanding of quantum characterisation and sharpened our practical ability to calibrate with enhanced precision, important questions about the fundamental limits of quantum characterisation remain unanswered. Although incorporating entanglement at the measurement stage is known to enhance the estimation of unknown quantum states, the extent of this improvement remains poorly understood. This leaves open a fundamental question on the utility of complex entangling measurement strategies, impeding progress towards bridging the significant gap between practically achievable precision and the ultimate theoretical quantum limit. Complementary to quantum state estimation, which is relatively well-established in theory and practice, the characterisation of quantum measurements lacks a rigorous information-theoretic foundation, leading to a dearth of principled benchmarks and provably optimal strategies despite growing experimental interest. This thesis develops and applies information-theoretic tools to answer questions in quantum characterisation, with an eye to enabling practical improvements beyond current techniques in the field. First, we introduce a computable measure of entanglement enhancement for quantum state estimation and study its variation across general multi-parameter estimation problems for higher-dimensional quantum states. We show that the entanglement enhancement is maximised for full qudit state tomography but grows only linearly with system dimension even when allowing an asymptotically large number of entangling operations. Our proposed tight upper bound to entanglement enhancement therefore constitutes a strong limitation on the utility of such entangling measurements. Next, we formulate the dual problem of quantum detector estimation, developing a comprehensive framework for maximally precise calibration centred around a newly introduced quantity - the detector quantum Fisher information. This information-theoretic measure stipulates the ultimate precision attainable for measurement calibration and identifies the optimal input states that achieve this precision. Further, our framework enables the first provably optimal detector estimation experiment and reveals the scope for entanglement-based enhancements, thereby placing measurement characterisation on equal footing with state characterisation. Considered together, these results suggest two contrasting conclusions about quantum characterisation. On the one hand, they show that for quantum state estimation, increasingly powerful entangling measurements offer only diminishing returns at the ultimate precision limit. On the other hand, they highlight practical quantum advantages available for detector estimation by providing a framework that can improve calibration performance and guide future experimental design. More broadly, these results complete and advance the triad of state, process, and detector characterisation, positioning quantum information measures as not merely abstract bounds, but practical guides for deciding when complex quantum resources are genuinely worth deploying and where near-term quantum advantages are most likely to be realised.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Maximal coherence of quantum measurement and the resource theory of sharpness

Kyunghyun Baek, Yonggi Jo, Hyunchul Nha

A resource theory of quantum measurement can be addressed in terms of quantum coherence and measurement sharpness, respectively. The former analyzes the off-diagonal structure of POVM elements in a predetermined basis while the latter analyzes the deviation from trivial, state-independent, measurements. We establish a direct connection between the two resource theories by identifying measurement sharpness as the maximal coherence that is achievable under all possible unitary changes of the reference basis. For a broad class of POVMs whose elements share a common eigenbasis, we show that the maximal distance-based coherence of measurement coincides exactly with the corresponding distance-based sharpness monotone. We further extend this equivalence, with element-additive distances, to POVMs whose elements admit a common mutually unbiased basis structure. These results provide a measurement-theoretic analogue of the maximal-coherence \& purity correspondence for quantum states. We also show that the maximal coherence of measurement is faithful with respect to trivial measurements and is monotonic under fuzzifying operations for dichotomic measurements, as well as under mixed-unitary and unitarily covariant preprocessing channels. Finally, we illustrate the operational meaning and limitations of the equivalence through qubit POVMs, single-photon phase sensing, and noisy photon-number resolving detection. In particular, the maximal Fisher information in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer is shown to be determined by the squared maximal coherence of the measurement, while in an imperfect photon-number resolving detector the maximal coherence behaves as a proper sharpness monotone, unlike conventional PVM-based unsharpness measures.

quant-pharXiv:2607.05847•Jul 8, 2026•2 citations

Resource theories of quantum coherence: foundations and applications

Benjamin Yadin

One of the fundamental features that separates quantum physics from classical physics is the idea of quantum superposition, also known as coherence. This thesis concentrates on understanding quantum coherence in the mathematical framework of resource theories, viewing it both as a resource to be harnessed and as a way to quantitatively characterise quantum states in contrast to classical states. We first examine the type of coherence resource theory which has emerged recently to cope with general settings where the physical nature of the medium encoding information is not crucial, such as computation. We identify the set of quantum processes in which coherence is neither created nor used, and use these to provide a physically motivated resource theory pictured in terms of interferometry. Using the same concepts, we then find connections between coherence and discord, a type of quantum correlation. In particular, we show how coherence can be used to generate discord, and explore basis-dependent discord as an intermediate quantity. The second part of the thesis applies the resource theory framework to quantify quantum macroscopicity, taken here to mean the extent to which coherence exists in a system on a macroscopic scale. We find the appropriate type of resource theory for this purpose, giving criteria for good measures of macroscopic coherence. We use these criteria to evaluate some previously proposed measures and highlight the role of the quantum Fisher information. Next, we build up measures based on the concept of macroscopic distinguishability and use them to show that macroscopic quantum states are fragile to noise induced by interaction with an environment. Finally, we apply measures based on the Fisher information to a range of experiments involving mechanical degrees of freedom, in order to compare their macroscopicity.

•Jan 1, 2017•3 citations

Quantum Resource Theories for Thermodynamics, Reference Frames, and Uncertainty

Varun Narasimhachar

Quantum information science is at the interface of physics and information theory, with applications including quantum computing and communication. Within this science, a resource theory is a detailed study of a particular class of physical processes, under which the possible state transitions are restricted. Given any initial physical state, the possible final states are also restricted. Initial states with a wealth of possible final states can then be considered more valuable than less versatile initial states, leading to a notion of "resourcefulness" of states. The broad goals of a resource theory include (1) to identify, characterize, and quantify resources; (2) to find an efficient way to determine whether an arbitrary instance of resource conversion is possible; and (3) to relate practical applications to resource conversion. In this thesis, we will take the resource-theoretic approach to understanding thermodynamics. The mathematical methods used in this work will enable us to also develop resource theories for measurement uncertainty and reference frames; in fact, the resource-theoretic treatment of thermodynamics is a combination of these two. Our approach is based on a model called thermal operations, applicable on individual quantum-mechanical systems out of thermal equilibrium. We study this model in detail, resulting in a better understanding of the resource of thermal inequilibrium. In a simplified version of the model where quantum coherence is neglected, we find that the conditions for state transitions are already more complex than the classical second law of thermodynamics. We extend the model to quantum systems controlled by classical circuitry. We also extend it to incorporate quantum coherence in the low-temperature limit. Measurement uncertainty is an important element in quantum mechanics. But its current understanding is through particular measures of uncertainty, such as the variance. We apply the resource theory approach to develop a measure-independent formalism for uncertainty, even in the case where the measurement is on part of a composite system with quantum correlations. Under physical processes restricted by some symmetry (e.g. rotational symmetry), asymmetric states act as resourceful reference frames. In this resource theory, we find the rate at which large quantities of resources can be interconverted through measurements.

•Jan 1, 2016•1 citation
Quantum measurements lie at the core of quantum information processing, enabling tasks ranging from state reconstruction and parameter estimation to sensing and computation. As quantum technologies scale and become increasingly precise, a central question emerges: what does it mean for a quantum measurement to be good? This thesis addresses this question by developing quantitative, operational, and physically grounded frameworks for assessing the quality and informational power of quantum measurements.The first part of the thesis focuses on the intrinsic quality of quantum measurements independent of any particular input state. Adopting the formalism of quantum resource theories, measurements are treated as resources ordered under classical post-processing, which cannot increase informational content. Restricting attention to informationally complete measurements, we employ frame theory to introduce a novel resource monotone termed completeness stability, defined as the minimum eigenvalue of a suitably scaled frame operator. We establish its operational significance by showing that the average error in quantum state tomography and the average variance in shadow tomography are tightly bounded by the inverse of the completeness stability. Maximizing this monotone identifies weighted complex projective 2-designs, including symmetric informationally complete POVMs and mutually unbiased bases, as optimal measurement configurations.The second part of the thesis extends these ideas to quantum parameter estimation, where measurement performance necessarily depends on correlations between the measurement and the encoded quantum state. By introducing a state-dependent inner product on operator space, we develop an operator-theoretic formulation in which both the classical and quantum Fisher information arise naturally from a single frame operator associated with the measurement and the reference state. Within this framework, the spectral properties of the frame operator provide a complete characterization of estimation performance. The maximum and minimum eigenvalues identify the best- and worst-case parameter-encoding directions, respectively, yielding sharp bounds on the achievable ratio of classical and quantum Fisher information. This establishes a direct connection between informational completeness, estimation robustness, and resource-theoretic monotonicity.The final part of the thesis returns to foundational questions concerning quantum measurement and arrival time. Using Bohmian mechanics, we develop a microscopic, first-principles account of the Hong–Ou–Mandel effect, a paradigmatic two-particle interference phenomenon. By analyzing particle trajectories guided by the wave function, we show how bosonic bunching and fermionic anti-bunching emerge dynamically from the guiding equation without invoking wave-function collapse. Beyond reproducing the Hong–Ou–Mandel dip, we demonstrate how experimental parameters such as barrier strength, phase velocity, and path asymmetry influence both coincidence probabilities and temporal correlations.Taken together, this thesis provides a unified treatment of quantum measurement quality across operational, metrological, and dynamical regimes. By bridging resource theory, frame theory, Fisher information, and trajectory-based quantum dynamics, it offers new insights into the structure, limitations, and physical interpretation of quantum measurements in both applied and foundational contexts.
We introduce a resource monotone, the completeness stability, to quantify the quality of quantum measurements within a resource-theoretic framework. By viewing a quantum measurement as a frame, the minimum eigenvalue of a frame operator emerges as a significant monotone. It captures bounds on estimation errors and the numerical stability of inverting the frame operator to calculate the optimal dual for state reconstruction. Maximizing this monotone identifies a well-characterized class of quantum measurements forming weighted complex projective 2-designs, which includes well-known examples such as SIC-POVMs. Our results provide a principled framework for comparing and optimizing quantum measurements for practical applications.
Informationally complete measurements form the foundation of universal quantum state reconstruction, while quantum parameter estimation is based on the local structure of the manifold of quantum states. Here we establish a general link between these two aspects, in the context of a single informationally complete measurement, by employing a suitably adapted operator frame theory. In particular, we bound the ratio between the classical and quantum Fisher information in terms of the spectral decomposition of the associated frame operator, and connect these bounds to the optimal and least optimal directions for parameter encoding. The geometric and operational characterization of information extraction thus obtained reveals the fundamental tradeoff imposed by informational completeness on local quantum parameter estimation.
Quantum states and measurements are two central physical objects in the theory of quantum mechanics. The preparation, control and measurement of quantum states lies at the heart of modern quantum information processing protocols ranging from secure communication to quantum computation and precision sensing. And yet, the reliable operation of these advanced protocols ultimately rests on a far more essential prerequisite - our ability to calibrate, certify and benchmark the quantum states we prepare and the quantum measurements we perform. Quantum information theory provides a natural framework for these tasks, meaningfully connecting the resources we expend for characterisation with the accuracy and precision we can expect in return. While decades of advances in quantum information have refined our understanding of quantum characterisation and sharpened our practical ability to calibrate with enhanced precision, important questions about the fundamental limits of quantum characterisation remain unanswered. Although incorporating entanglement at the measurement stage is known to enhance the estimation of unknown quantum states, the extent of this improvement remains poorly understood. This leaves open a fundamental question on the utility of complex entangling measurement strategies, impeding progress towards bridging the significant gap between practically achievable precision and the ultimate theoretical quantum limit. Complementary to quantum state estimation, which is relatively well-established in theory and practice, the characterisation of quantum measurements lacks a rigorous information-theoretic foundation, leading to a dearth of principled benchmarks and provably optimal strategies despite growing experimental interest. This thesis develops and applies information-theoretic tools to answer questions in quantum characterisation, with an eye to enabling practical improvements beyond current techniques in the field. First, we introduce a computable measure of entanglement enhancement for quantum state estimation and study its variation across general multi-parameter estimation problems for higher-dimensional quantum states. We show that the entanglement enhancement is maximised for full qudit state tomography but grows only linearly with system dimension even when allowing an asymptotically large number of entangling operations. Our proposed tight upper bound to entanglement enhancement therefore constitutes a strong limitation on the utility of such entangling measurements. Next, we formulate the dual problem of quantum detector estimation, developing a comprehensive framework for maximally precise calibration centred around a newly introduced quantity - the detector quantum Fisher information. This information-theoretic measure stipulates the ultimate precision attainable for measurement calibration and identifies the optimal input states that achieve this precision. Further, our framework enables the first provably optimal detector estimation experiment and reveals the scope for entanglement-based enhancements, thereby placing measurement characterisation on equal footing with state characterisation. Considered together, these results suggest two contrasting conclusions about quantum characterisation. On the one hand, they show that for quantum state estimation, increasingly powerful entangling measurements offer only diminishing returns at the ultimate precision limit. On the other hand, they highlight practical quantum advantages available for detector estimation by providing a framework that can improve calibration performance and guide future experimental design. More broadly, these results complete and advance the triad of state, process, and detector characterisation, positioning quantum information measures as not merely abstract bounds, but practical guides for deciding when complex quantum resources are genuinely worth deploying and where near-term quantum advantages are most likely to be realised.
A resource theory of quantum measurement can be addressed in terms of quantum coherence and measurement sharpness, respectively. The former analyzes the off-diagonal structure of POVM elements in a predetermined basis while the latter analyzes the deviation from trivial, state-independent, measurements. We establish a direct connection between the two resource theories by identifying measurement sharpness as the maximal coherence that is achievable under all possible unitary changes of the reference basis. For a broad class of POVMs whose elements share a common eigenbasis, we show that the maximal distance-based coherence of measurement coincides exactly with the corresponding distance-based sharpness monotone. We further extend this equivalence, with element-additive distances, to POVMs whose elements admit a common mutually unbiased basis structure. These results provide a measurement-theoretic analogue of the maximal-coherence \& purity correspondence for quantum states. We also show that the maximal coherence of measurement is faithful with respect to trivial measurements and is monotonic under fuzzifying operations for dichotomic measurements, as well as under mixed-unitary and unitarily covariant preprocessing channels. Finally, we illustrate the operational meaning and limitations of the equivalence through qubit POVMs, single-photon phase sensing, and noisy photon-number resolving detection. In particular, the maximal Fisher information in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer is shown to be determined by the squared maximal coherence of the measurement, while in an imperfect photon-number resolving detector the maximal coherence behaves as a proper sharpness monotone, unlike conventional PVM-based unsharpness measures.
One of the fundamental features that separates quantum physics from classical physics is the idea of quantum superposition, also known as coherence. This thesis concentrates on understanding quantum coherence in the mathematical framework of resource theories, viewing it both as a resource to be harnessed and as a way to quantitatively characterise quantum states in contrast to classical states. We first examine the type of coherence resource theory which has emerged recently to cope with general settings where the physical nature of the medium encoding information is not crucial, such as computation. We identify the set of quantum processes in which coherence is neither created nor used, and use these to provide a physically motivated resource theory pictured in terms of interferometry. Using the same concepts, we then find connections between coherence and discord, a type of quantum correlation. In particular, we show how coherence can be used to generate discord, and explore basis-dependent discord as an intermediate quantity. The second part of the thesis applies the resource theory framework to quantify quantum macroscopicity, taken here to mean the extent to which coherence exists in a system on a macroscopic scale. We find the appropriate type of resource theory for this purpose, giving criteria for good measures of macroscopic coherence. We use these criteria to evaluate some previously proposed measures and highlight the role of the quantum Fisher information. Next, we build up measures based on the concept of macroscopic distinguishability and use them to show that macroscopic quantum states are fragile to noise induced by interaction with an environment. Finally, we apply measures based on the Fisher information to a range of experiments involving mechanical degrees of freedom, in order to compare their macroscopicity.
Quantum information science is at the interface of physics and information theory, with applications including quantum computing and communication. Within this science, a resource theory is a detailed study of a particular class of physical processes, under which the possible state transitions are restricted. Given any initial physical state, the possible final states are also restricted. Initial states with a wealth of possible final states can then be considered more valuable than less versatile initial states, leading to a notion of "resourcefulness" of states. The broad goals of a resource theory include (1) to identify, characterize, and quantify resources; (2) to find an efficient way to determine whether an arbitrary instance of resource conversion is possible; and (3) to relate practical applications to resource conversion. In this thesis, we will take the resource-theoretic approach to understanding thermodynamics. The mathematical methods used in this work will enable us to also develop resource theories for measurement uncertainty and reference frames; in fact, the resource-theoretic treatment of thermodynamics is a combination of these two. Our approach is based on a model called thermal operations, applicable on individual quantum-mechanical systems out of thermal equilibrium. We study this model in detail, resulting in a better understanding of the resource of thermal inequilibrium. In a simplified version of the model where quantum coherence is neglected, we find that the conditions for state transitions are already more complex than the classical second law of thermodynamics. We extend the model to quantum systems controlled by classical circuitry. We also extend it to incorporate quantum coherence in the low-temperature limit. Measurement uncertainty is an important element in quantum mechanics. But its current understanding is through particular measures of uncertainty, such as the variance. We apply the resource theory approach to develop a measure-independent formalism for uncertainty, even in the case where the measurement is on part of a composite system with quantum correlations. Under physical processes restricted by some symmetry (e.g. rotational symmetry), asymmetric states act as resourceful reference frames. In this resource theory, we find the rate at which large quantities of resources can be interconverted through measurements.