Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Discrete Forbids the Gaussian, Connected Allows It: One Positivity Theorem and Five Physical Verdicts

Zongmin Liu

Published Apr 9, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A recurring situation in physics is that an observable is a linear functional of an unknown \emph{positive} measure, and the conjugate variable carries an arithmetic structure---it lives on a lattice, on a continuum, on a bounded interval. We show that this alone often decides the physics, and that the verdict flips with the structure. For a locally compact abelian group the L\'evy--Khintchine representation of an infinitely divisible law contains a Gaussian component if and only if the group is not totally disconnected. Hence the principle: \emph{discrete forbids the Gaussian, connected allows it}. We apply it in five places and obtain three qualitatively different kinds of answer. On $\Z$, where the Gaussian is forbidden, the Yang--Mills topological charge distribution is not infinitely divisible---an anomaly, with a model-free inequality $b_2\le-1/12+\langle Q^2\rangle/4$ and a real-time counterpart that puts a floor $\kappa_4/\kappa_2\ge J^2$ under any sphaleron rate. On $\R^d$, where it is allowed and \emph{extremal}, no admissible nonlocal form factor decays faster than a Gaussian. On the lattice $d\Z$, whose dual circle is connected so that the Gaussian survives the reduction, a measured decoherence curve must be a L\'evy exponent, a criterion that is complete, decidable by linear programming, and already sampled by the harmonics of a Talbot--Lau interferometer; three measured points must satisfy $(F_2-F_1)^2\le F_1F_3\le F_1(F_1+2F_2)$, with the walls saturated by a single momentum quantum and by Gaussian noise. On the real line with bounded support, where infinite divisibility is impossible outright, gravitational time-dilation decoherence admits no master equation whenever the internal spectrum is finite. We also report where the machine fails and why: it is blind in semiclassical limits, which closes the holographic R\'enyi line, and four further targets were pre-empted. We state the resulting pre-screen, and record one withdrawn claim in full.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.21924144

Related papers

From particle counting to Gaussian tomography

Kalyanapuram Rangachari Parthasarathy, Ritabrata Sengupta

The momentum and position observables in an [Formula: see text]-mode boson Fock space [Formula: see text] have the whole real line [Formula: see text] as their spectrum. But the total number operator [Formula: see text] has a discrete spectrum [Formula: see text]. An [Formula: see text]-mode Gaussian state in [Formula: see text] is completely determined by the mean values of momentum and position observables and their covariance matrix which together constitute a family of [Formula: see text] real parameters. Starting with [Formula: see text] and its unitary conjugates by the Weyl displacement operators and operators from a representation of the symplectic group [Formula: see text] in [Formula: see text], we construct [Formula: see text] observables with spectrum [Formula: see text] but whose expectation values in a Gaussian state determine all its mean and covariance parameters. Thus measurements of discrete-valued observables enable the tomography of the underlying Gaussian state and it can be done by using five one-mode and four two-mode Gaussian symplectic gates in single and pair mode wires of [Formula: see text]. Thus the tomography protocol admits a simple description in a language similar to circuits in quantum computation theory. Such a Gaussian tomography applied to outputs of a Gaussian channel with coherent input states permit a tomography of the channel parameters. However, in our procedure the number of counting measurements exceeds the number of channel parameters slightly. Presently, it is not clear whether a more efficient method exists for reducing this tomographic complexity. As a byproduct of our approach an elementary derivation of the probability generating function of [Formula: see text] in a Gaussian state is given. In many cases the distribution turns out to be infinitely divisible and its underlying Lévy measure can be obtained. However, we are unable to derive the exact distribution in all cases. Whether this property of infinite divisibility holds in general is left as an open problem.

arXiv:1504.07054•Infinite Dimensional Analysis Quantum Probability and Related Topics•Dec 1, 2015•25 citations

Finite Determinacy III: Spacetime and Gauge

Justin Smith

Finite Determinacy (FD) was developed from a representational question: whether theuse of real numbers for physical quantities should be read as implying arbitrarily precisephysical determination. Replacing that idealisation by objectively finite determinationleads to bounded shared resolution depth for related records. Close finite-informationand relational antecedents in quantum foundations were identified subsequently and areacknowledged here; they were not the route by which the present framework was developed,and no historical priority is claimed for those principles. This companion paper asks whatdynamical restrictions follow once the resulting finite-record geometry is combined withexplicit finite-rate premises.For self-containment the paper first reproduces the common foundation: bounded jointdepth and split-invariant refinement give exponential resolution and a non-zero two-registerwidth-product floor; a homogeneous, finitely additive area regularity promotes that scalarconstraint to a local area measure; and a primitive tick/readout role asymmetry suppliesorientation, after which the two-member sector is symplectic. The positive symmetric formused for compatible complex structure remains an independent structural input. Dynamicsthen adds a universal pace ceiling rmax, a saturated intra-pair exchange ceiling |dv/du| ≤ L,and an inter-pair causal conversion c∗. In the quantum branch, explicit coherent-recordand record-faithfulness assumptions lead through Weyl–Heisenberg representation theoryto finite-step unitary evolution and the Schrödinger law-form. In the gauge branch, recordgeneratedtransport and holonomy lead, under a minimal local reversible continuum closure,to Yang–Mills curvature-square dynamics. In gravity, locality, reversibility and isotropy givea minimal hyperbolic principal part, while an explicit spatially relational continuum closureleaves two transverse-traceless modes.The proposed contribution is therefore not a new finiteness or relationality principle,nor an exclusive derivation of familiar terminal equations. It is an independently developedfinite-geometric route from the physical interpretation of real-number representation to acommon pre-Hilbert, pre-gauge and pre-metric substrate, followed by sector-specific dynamicalconsistency conditions.

•Sep 20, 2026•0 citations

A Measured Decoherence Curve Must Be a L\'evy Exponent

Zongmin Liu

Complete positivity and translation covariance force the localization rate $F(\Delta)$ of any Markovian open dynamics---environmental decoherence and objective collapse alike---to be a continuous negative definite function of the path separation $\Delta$, i.e.\ a L\'evy exponent. We turn this structural fact into a finite, model-free, and \emph{complete} test on data. Sampling $F$ at commensurate separations $F_k\equiv F(kd)$ reduces the L\'evy--Khintchine representation to a linear feasibility problem whose dual is a Chebyshev positivity cone; the cone is polyhedral only for two points. Three points already give closed-form walls, $(F_2-F_1)^2\le F_1F_3\le F_1(F_1+2F_2)$ together with $F_2\le 4F_1$, saturated respectively by a single momentum quantum and by Gaussian noise---the two extreme rays of the admissible cone. The test detects a $1\%$ super-quadratic admixture from three points, and it is necessary \emph{and} sufficient, so a curve that survives is realized by an actual noise measure. A visibility-versus- separation scan therefore falsifies Markovian translation-covariant evolution with no model and no fitting.

•Mar 22, 2025•0 citations

Decoherence from discrete quantum gravity

Rodolfo Gambini, Rafael A. Porto, Jorge A. Pullin

•May 27, 2003•5 citations

Convergence of the Modular Data of a Solvable Gaussian Network: Conjectures, a Band-Edge Obstruction, and a Controlled Numerical Window

T. Weinmann

A solvable Gaussian network, the ground state of a scalar field on a weighted lattice with a truncated exponential interaction kernel, admits exact computation of the entropies and modular Hamiltonians of arbitrary regions. In the companion paper this model was used to test the matter sector of Jacobson's entanglement-equilibrium argument, with a first law whose contact term is consistent with the conformal value 2πξ_c. That consistency is a statement about finite lattices extrapolated to the continuum; the present paper isolates the step that was extrapolated: the convergence of the lattice modular data of a ball to the continuum modular Hamiltonian computed by Longo and Morsella. I formulate convergence conjectures (C1, C1a, C1a', C1b) and prove none of the deep ones. What is proved is elementary and stated with its proof status: the exact first law with the modular-Hamiltonian matrices of a restricted Gaussian state; a bulk identity for lattice balls, Σᵤ κᵤ = K(ℓ_A)(1 + O(ℓ⁻²)); sharp cell estimates for smooth lattice sums; a purely geometric test of the bulk identity over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 32; a non-Lipschitz obstruction at the band edge ν = 1/2, illustrated exactly by a two-oscillator model; and perturbation bounds with an accumulated-weight estimate which organises one proof strategy for C1a around a counting statement, provided a mode-wise condition holds, which fails at the extreme edge. For the counting I state a hypothesis E1' at fixed threshold s. The numerical section reports every value computed here, over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 12 with five dilute band probes per radius. The two-parameter decomposition R_c − 1 = a + b/x_eff² gives b = 0.959, 0.985, 0.997 and a = 0.039, 0.027, 0.021 at ℓ = 8, 10, 12, both moving towards the conformal values 1 and 0; the rates are not resolved, the direction of the trend is not robust against removing the smallest-band probe, and the dominant systematic of the pipeline (the k = 0 infrared prescription) shifts b by up to 0.23 at ℓ = 8, an order of magnitude above the ℓ-trend itself. The ℓ ≤ 32 field data of the companion paper remain cited, not recomputed. All numbers generated in this work are reproduced by distributed programs with a test suite.

•Nov 8, 2026•0 citations

The Decoherence Exponent: Stable Phase Noise and Constraints on Objective State Reduction

Milen V. Velev, Ivo D. Dinov

Let $L_u$ be a symmetric Levy process representing an unobserved phase lift, coupling to a quantum system via charge $Q$. Averaging $e^{iL_uQ}$ gives a completely positive dephasing semigroup. If the characteristic exponent lacks an intrinsic charge scale, the Levy-Khintchine theorem forces $η(ξ)=D | ξ|^α$ ($0<α\le2$), so coherences decay at $Γ_{ab}=D | q_a-q_b |^α$. For integer charge differences, the process descends to the wrapped variable $Θ_u=L_u\bmod 2π$; for real charges, the lift is the relevant phase. Schoenberg's theorem ensures complete positivity for any finite real spectrum when $0<α\le2$, while $α>2$ yields an analytic obstruction. This boundary is exact, verified numerically here. A Gaussian integrated phase gives quadratic charge dependence, though colored Gaussian noise need not yield a Markov semigroup. Two idealized non-Gaussian mechanisms are analyzed: inverse-power Poisson shot noise ($α=d/p$) and Bochner subordination of Brownian phase by an $α/2$-stable clock. For a bounded reduction walk, we prove Born probabilities for every symmetric bounded proposal law. Simulations of truncated stable laws ($α=0.5,1,1.5,2$) confirm this law-independence. In continuous time, $α$-stable drivers fail to reduce: the exact-flow (Marcus) equation oscillates, and the naive Ito jump equation fails to preserve state. For Gaussian white noise, the Itô model collapses to Born probabilities, whereas the exact-flow (Stratonovich) model does not collapse without a threshold and yields non-Born exit probabilities. The quadratic case recovers Milburn's small-step limit, not his exact Poisson dynamics. Finally, a bi-temporal geometry is examined as a possible compact phase source, but closed timelike curves, nonunitary evolution, and an unstable mode tower prevent a consistent field-theoretic realization.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2608.18335•Aug 20, 2026•0 citations
A recurring situation in physics is that an observable is a linear functional of an unknown \emph{positive} measure, and the conjugate variable carries an arithmetic structure---it lives on a lattice, on a continuum, on a bounded interval. We show that this alone often decides the physics, and that the verdict flips with the structure. For a locally compact abelian group the L'evy--Khintchine representation of an infinitely divisible law contains a Gaussian component if and only if the group is not totally disconnected. Hence the principle: \emph{discrete forbids the Gaussian, connected allows it}. We apply it in five places and obtain three qualitatively different kinds of answer. On Z\ZZ, where the Gaussian is forbidden, the Yang--Mills topological charge distribution is not infinitely divisible---an anomaly, with a model-free inequality b2≤−1/12+⟨Q2⟩/4b_2\le-1/12+\langle Q^2\rangle/4b2​≤−1/12+⟨Q2⟩/4 and a real-time counterpart that puts a floor κ4/κ2≥J2\kappa_4/\kappa_2\ge J^2κ4​/κ2​≥J2 under any sphaleron rate. On Rd\R^dRd, where it is allowed and \emph{extremal}, no admissible nonlocal form factor decays faster than a Gaussian. On the lattice dZd\ZdZ, whose dual circle is connected so that the Gaussian survives the reduction, a measured decoherence curve must be a L'evy exponent, a criterion that is complete, decidable by linear programming, and already sampled by the harmonics of a Talbot--Lau interferometer; three measured points must satisfy (F2−F1)2≤F1F3≤F1(F1+2F2)(F_2-F_1)^2\le F_1F_3\le F_1(F_1+2F_2)(F2​−F1​)2≤F1​F3​≤F1​(F1​+2F2​), with the walls saturated by a single momentum quantum and by Gaussian noise. On the real line with bounded support, where infinite divisibility is impossible outright, gravitational time-dilation decoherence admits no master equation whenever the internal spectrum is finite. We also report where the machine fails and why: it is blind in semiclassical limits, which closes the holographic R'enyi line, and four further targets were pre-empted. We state the resulting pre-screen, and record one withdrawn claim in full.
The momentum and position observables in an [Formula: see text]-mode boson Fock space [Formula: see text] have the whole real line [Formula: see text] as their spectrum. But the total number operator [Formula: see text] has a discrete spectrum [Formula: see text]. An [Formula: see text]-mode Gaussian state in [Formula: see text] is completely determined by the mean values of momentum and position observables and their covariance matrix which together constitute a family of [Formula: see text] real parameters. Starting with [Formula: see text] and its unitary conjugates by the Weyl displacement operators and operators from a representation of the symplectic group [Formula: see text] in [Formula: see text], we construct [Formula: see text] observables with spectrum [Formula: see text] but whose expectation values in a Gaussian state determine all its mean and covariance parameters. Thus measurements of discrete-valued observables enable the tomography of the underlying Gaussian state and it can be done by using five one-mode and four two-mode Gaussian symplectic gates in single and pair mode wires of [Formula: see text]. Thus the tomography protocol admits a simple description in a language similar to circuits in quantum computation theory. Such a Gaussian tomography applied to outputs of a Gaussian channel with coherent input states permit a tomography of the channel parameters. However, in our procedure the number of counting measurements exceeds the number of channel parameters slightly. Presently, it is not clear whether a more efficient method exists for reducing this tomographic complexity. As a byproduct of our approach an elementary derivation of the probability generating function of [Formula: see text] in a Gaussian state is given. In many cases the distribution turns out to be infinitely divisible and its underlying Lévy measure can be obtained. However, we are unable to derive the exact distribution in all cases. Whether this property of infinite divisibility holds in general is left as an open problem.
Finite Determinacy (FD) was developed from a representational question: whether theuse of real numbers for physical quantities should be read as implying arbitrarily precisephysical determination. Replacing that idealisation by objectively finite determinationleads to bounded shared resolution depth for related records. Close finite-informationand relational antecedents in quantum foundations were identified subsequently and areacknowledged here; they were not the route by which the present framework was developed,and no historical priority is claimed for those principles. This companion paper asks whatdynamical restrictions follow once the resulting finite-record geometry is combined withexplicit finite-rate premises.For self-containment the paper first reproduces the common foundation: bounded jointdepth and split-invariant refinement give exponential resolution and a non-zero two-registerwidth-product floor; a homogeneous, finitely additive area regularity promotes that scalarconstraint to a local area measure; and a primitive tick/readout role asymmetry suppliesorientation, after which the two-member sector is symplectic. The positive symmetric formused for compatible complex structure remains an independent structural input. Dynamicsthen adds a universal pace ceiling rmax, a saturated intra-pair exchange ceiling |dv/du| ≤ L,and an inter-pair causal conversion c∗. In the quantum branch, explicit coherent-recordand record-faithfulness assumptions lead through Weyl–Heisenberg representation theoryto finite-step unitary evolution and the Schrödinger law-form. In the gauge branch, recordgeneratedtransport and holonomy lead, under a minimal local reversible continuum closure,to Yang–Mills curvature-square dynamics. In gravity, locality, reversibility and isotropy givea minimal hyperbolic principal part, while an explicit spatially relational continuum closureleaves two transverse-traceless modes.The proposed contribution is therefore not a new finiteness or relationality principle,nor an exclusive derivation of familiar terminal equations. It is an independently developedfinite-geometric route from the physical interpretation of real-number representation to acommon pre-Hilbert, pre-gauge and pre-metric substrate, followed by sector-specific dynamicalconsistency conditions.
Complete positivity and translation covariance force the localization rate F(Δ)F(\Delta)F(Δ) of any Markovian open dynamics---environmental decoherence and objective collapse alike---to be a continuous negative definite function of the path separation Δ\DeltaΔ, i.e.\ a L\'evy exponent. We turn this structural fact into a finite, model-free, and \emph{complete} test on data. Sampling FFF at commensurate separations Fk≡F(kd)F_k\equiv F(kd)Fk​≡F(kd) reduces the L\'evy--Khintchine representation to a linear feasibility problem whose dual is a Chebyshev positivity cone; the cone is polyhedral only for two points. Three points already give closed-form walls, (F2−F1)2≤F1F3≤F1(F1+2F2)(F_2-F_1)^2\le F_1F_3\le F_1(F_1+2F_2)(F2​−F1​)2≤F1​F3​≤F1​(F1​+2F2​) together with F2≤4F1F_2\le 4F_1F2​≤4F1​, saturated respectively by a single momentum quantum and by Gaussian noise---the two extreme rays of the admissible cone. The test detects a 1%1\%1% super-quadratic admixture from three points, and it is necessary \emph{and} sufficient, so a curve that survives is realized by an actual noise measure. A visibility-versus- separation scan therefore falsifies Markovian translation-covariant evolution with no model and no fitting.
A solvable Gaussian network, the ground state of a scalar field on a weighted lattice with a truncated exponential interaction kernel, admits exact computation of the entropies and modular Hamiltonians of arbitrary regions. In the companion paper this model was used to test the matter sector of Jacobson's entanglement-equilibrium argument, with a first law whose contact term is consistent with the conformal value 2πξ_c. That consistency is a statement about finite lattices extrapolated to the continuum; the present paper isolates the step that was extrapolated: the convergence of the lattice modular data of a ball to the continuum modular Hamiltonian computed by Longo and Morsella. I formulate convergence conjectures (C1, C1a, C1a', C1b) and prove none of the deep ones. What is proved is elementary and stated with its proof status: the exact first law with the modular-Hamiltonian matrices of a restricted Gaussian state; a bulk identity for lattice balls, Σᵤ κᵤ = K(ℓ_A)(1 + O(ℓ⁻²)); sharp cell estimates for smooth lattice sums; a purely geometric test of the bulk identity over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 32; a non-Lipschitz obstruction at the band edge ν = 1/2, illustrated exactly by a two-oscillator model; and perturbation bounds with an accumulated-weight estimate which organises one proof strategy for C1a around a counting statement, provided a mode-wise condition holds, which fails at the extreme edge. For the counting I state a hypothesis E1' at fixed threshold s. The numerical section reports every value computed here, over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 12 with five dilute band probes per radius. The two-parameter decomposition R_c − 1 = a + b/x_eff² gives b = 0.959, 0.985, 0.997 and a = 0.039, 0.027, 0.021 at ℓ = 8, 10, 12, both moving towards the conformal values 1 and 0; the rates are not resolved, the direction of the trend is not robust against removing the smallest-band probe, and the dominant systematic of the pipeline (the k = 0 infrared prescription) shifts b by up to 0.23 at ℓ = 8, an order of magnitude above the ℓ-trend itself. The ℓ ≤ 32 field data of the companion paper remain cited, not recomputed. All numbers generated in this work are reproduced by distributed programs with a test suite.
Let LuL_uLu​ be a symmetric Levy process representing an unobserved phase lift, coupling to a quantum system via charge QQQ. Averaging eiLuQe^{iL_uQ}eiLu​Q gives a completely positive dephasing semigroup. If the characteristic exponent lacks an intrinsic charge scale, the Levy-Khintchine theorem forces η(ξ)=D∣ξ∣αη(ξ)=D | ξ|^αη(ξ)=D∣ξ∣α (0<α≤20<α\le20<α≤2), so coherences decay at Γab=D∣qa−qb∣αΓ_{ab}=D | q_a-q_b |^αΓab​=D∣qa​−qb​∣α. For integer charge differences, the process descends to the wrapped variable Θu=Lu mod 2πΘ_u=L_u\bmod 2πΘu​=Lu​mod2π; for real charges, the lift is the relevant phase. Schoenberg's theorem ensures complete positivity for any finite real spectrum when 0<α≤20<α\le20<α≤2, while α>2α>2α>2 yields an analytic obstruction. This boundary is exact, verified numerically here. A Gaussian integrated phase gives quadratic charge dependence, though colored Gaussian noise need not yield a Markov semigroup. Two idealized non-Gaussian mechanisms are analyzed: inverse-power Poisson shot noise (α=d/pα=d/pα=d/p) and Bochner subordination of Brownian phase by an α/2α/2α/2-stable clock. For a bounded reduction walk, we prove Born probabilities for every symmetric bounded proposal law. Simulations of truncated stable laws (α=0.5,1,1.5,2α=0.5,1,1.5,2α=0.5,1,1.5,2) confirm this law-independence. In continuous time, ααα-stable drivers fail to reduce: the exact-flow (Marcus) equation oscillates, and the naive Ito jump equation fails to preserve state. For Gaussian white noise, the Itô model collapses to Born probabilities, whereas the exact-flow (Stratonovich) model does not collapse without a threshold and yields non-Born exit probabilities. The quadratic case recovers Milburn's small-step limit, not his exact Poisson dynamics. Finally, a bi-temporal geometry is examined as a possible compact phase source, but closed timelike curves, nonunitary evolution, and an unstable mode tower prevent a consistent field-theoretic realization.