Discrete Forbids the Gaussian, Connected Allows It: One Positivity Theorem and Five Physical Verdicts
Zongmin Liu
Abstract
A recurring situation in physics is that an observable is a linear functional of an unknown \emph{positive} measure, and the conjugate variable carries an arithmetic structure---it lives on a lattice, on a continuum, on a bounded interval. We show that this alone often decides the physics, and that the verdict flips with the structure. For a locally compact abelian group the L\'evy--Khintchine representation of an infinitely divisible law contains a Gaussian component if and only if the group is not totally disconnected. Hence the principle: \emph{discrete forbids the Gaussian, connected allows it}. We apply it in five places and obtain three qualitatively different kinds of answer. On $\Z$, where the Gaussian is forbidden, the Yang--Mills topological charge distribution is not infinitely divisible---an anomaly, with a model-free inequality $b_2\le-1/12+\langle Q^2\rangle/4$ and a real-time counterpart that puts a floor $\kappa_4/\kappa_2\ge J^2$ under any sphaleron rate. On $\R^d$, where it is allowed and \emph{extremal}, no admissible nonlocal form factor decays faster than a Gaussian. On the lattice $d\Z$, whose dual circle is connected so that the Gaussian survives the reduction, a measured decoherence curve must be a L\'evy exponent, a criterion that is complete, decidable by linear programming, and already sampled by the harmonics of a Talbot--Lau interferometer; three measured points must satisfy $(F_2-F_1)^2\le F_1F_3\le F_1(F_1+2F_2)$, with the walls saturated by a single momentum quantum and by Gaussian noise. On the real line with bounded support, where infinite divisibility is impossible outright, gravitational time-dilation decoherence admits no master equation whenever the internal spectrum is finite. We also report where the machine fails and why: it is blind in semiclassical limits, which closes the holographic R\'enyi line, and four further targets were pre-empted. We state the resulting pre-screen, and record one withdrawn claim in full.