Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bose-Einstein condensation and collective Bogoliubov excitations of microwave photons in superconducting quantum electrodynamics circuits

Valentina Di Meo, Patrick Navez, B. Ruggiero, Claudio D. Gatti, F. Chiarello, Alessandro D’Elia, A. Rettaroli, G. Brida, Emanuele Enrico, Luca Fasolo, Mikahil Fistul, Ilya Eremin, Alexandre M. Zagoskin, Paolo Vanacore, P. Silvestrini, Mikhail Lisitskiy

Published Aug 7, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The seminal phenomenon of the Bose-Einstein condensation has been observed on a large variety of physical platforms, e.g., superfluid helium, fermions with attractive interactions, quasiparticles in solids, and ultracold atomic gases. Recently, the Bose–Einstein condensation of non-interacting photons in an optical microcavity has been confirmed experimentally. Here, we report the experimental observation of Bose-Einstein like condensation and collective Bogoliubov excitations in a low dissipative microwave resonator with embedded superconducting quantum network composed of multiple flux qubits. Under strong coherent pumping the resonator mode becomes macroscopically populated, giving rise to hybridized photon–qubit collective modes. The Bogoliubov-like collective excitations appearing in a response to a nearby-frequency probe tone, accompanied by pronounced bistability and hysteresis in the measured transmission coefficient, provide the first experimental evidence of a Bose–Einstein–like condensate of microwave photons on a superconducting circuit platform. A theoretical framework based on Gross-Pitaevskii formalism and taking into account the ac Stark effect inducing the effective interaction between photons, quantitatively reproduces the experimental observations and identifies the regime of appearance of microwave Bogoliubov excitations. These results establish a proof of principle for exploiting driven collective states in superconducting circuits as a platform for quantum-limited microwave detection and engineered many-body photonic systems for quantum information processing.

DOI
10.21203/rs.3.rs-10420335/v1

Related papers

Bose condensation and Bogoliubov excitation in resonator-embedded superconducting qubit network

Patrick Navez, Valentina Di Meo, Berardo Ruggiero +12 more

Superconducting qubit networks (SQNs) embedded in a low-dissipative resonator is a promising device allowing one not only to establish the collective quantum dynamics on a macroscopic scale but also to greatly enhance the sensitivity of detectors of microwave photons. A quantum ac Stark effect provided by coupling between an SQN and microwave photons of a resonator, leads to a strong nonlinear interaction between photons. Here, we present a two-tone spectroscopy experiment in which a set of 10 superconducting flux qubits is coupled to the input R- resonator and the output T- transmission line. An external microwave pump field close to the resonance frequency populates macroscopically the resonator mode as a Bose-Einstein condensate, while a second probe beam scans the resonances referred also as Bogoliubov-like excitations. The corresponding excitation frequency measured from the transmission coefficient, |S21(f)| displays an abrupt change of the resonant dip position once the power of the pump field overcomes a critical value Pcr. This sharp shift occurs in a narrow region of pump frequencies, and can be tuned by an applied magnetic field. It is a signature of bistability of the photon number inside the resonator, in agreement with theory.

quant-pharXiv:2601.15101•Jan 22, 2026•1 citation

Coherent Quantum Network of Superconducting Qubits as a Highly Sensitive Detector of Microwave Photons for Searching of Galactic Axions

Claudio D. Gatti, M. Affronte, Alexander G. Balanov +30 more

We propose a novel approach to detect a low power microwave signal with a frequency of the order of several GHz based on a coherent collective response of quantum states occurring in a superconducting qubits network (SQN). An SQN composes of a large number of superconducting qubits embedded in a low-dissipative superconducting resonator. Our theory predicts that an SQN interacting with the off-resonance microwave radiation, demonstrates the collective alternating current Stark effect that can be measured even in the limit of single photon counting. A design of the layout of three terminals SQN detectors containing 10 flux qubits weakly coupled to a low-dissipative R-resonator and T-transmission line was developed. The samples were fabricated by Al-based technology with Nb resonator. The SQN detector was tested in terms of microwave measurements of scattering parameters and two-tone spectroscopy. A substantial shift of the frequency position of the transmission coefficient drop induced by a second tone pump signal was observed, and this effect clearly manifests a nonlinear multiphoton interaction between the second-tone microwave pump signal and an array of qubits.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Apr 6, 2023•4 citations

Photon condensation in circuit quantum electrodynamics by engineered dissipation

D Marcos, Andrea Tomadin, Sebastian Diehl +1 more

We study photon condensation phenomena in a driven and dissipative array of superconducting microwave resonators.Specifically, we show that by using an appropriately designed coupling of microwave photons to superconducting qubits, an effective dissipative mechanism can be engineered, which scatters photons towards low-momentum states while conserving their number.This mimics a tunable coupling of bosons to a low-temperature bath, and leads to the formation of a stationary photon condensate in the presence of losses and under continuous-driving conditions.In this paper, we propose a realistic experimental setup to observe this effect in two or multiple coupled cavities, and study the characteristics of such an out-of-equilibrium condensate, which arise from the competition between pumping and dissipation processes.

arXiv:1201.3388•New Journal of Physics•May 1, 2012•72 citations

Collective Excitations and Critical Phenomena in Interacting Bose–Einstein Condensates

Dr. Narendra Kumar Ravi Nath Choudhry

Bose–Einstein condensation represents a quintessential manifestation of quantum mechanics at macroscopic scales, where a dilute gas of bosonic atoms undergoes a phase transition to form a coherent matter wave. This study presents a comprehensive theoretical investigation of collective excitations and critical phenomena in interacting Bose–Einstein condensates (BECs). Beginning with the Gross–Pitaevskii equation , we develop the Bogoliubov theory of excitations yielding the spectrum , where is the free-particle energy and characterizes contact interactions. The spectrum reveals phonon behavior at low momenta with sound velocity , transitioning to free-particle dispersion at momenta exceeding the inverse healing length . Collective modes in harmonically trapped condensates are analyzed in the Thomas–Fermi regime, yielding breathing mode frequency and quadrupole frequency . Damping mechanisms including Landau damping ( ) and Beliaev damping ( ) are characterized. The Lee–Huang–Yang correction extends the equation of state beyond mean field. Critical phenomena near are analyzed within the 3D XY universality class, with critical exponents , , and the interaction-induced shift with . All predictions show excellent agreement with experimental measurements on ultracold atomic gases.

International journal of engineering science & humanities.•Sep 18, 2019•0 citations

CLEO®/Europe-IQEC 2013: Strongly interacting many body physics with circuit quantum electrodynamics networks

Martin Leib, Lukas Neumeier, Frank Deppe +3 more

In its infancy circuit quantum electrodynamics (cQED) has quickly started reproducing fundamental quantum optical experiments, e.g. observation of vacuum rabi oscillations in frequency and time domain, with unprecedented cooperativity. This was possible because of the large coupling of the quasi one-dimensional microwave field of the superconducting transmission line resonators to the macroscopic dipole moment of superconducting qubits. cQED has matured to a discipline of experimental physics capable of performing fundamental quantum information tasks and is currently on the verge of crossing the border between few- to many body physics [1]. This opens up a exciting realm of completely new physical phenomena. Because of the ubiquitous influence of the electromagnetic environment however the number of microwave photons is not conserved which separates cQED systems from other quantum simulators involving atoms, e.g. cold atoms in optical latices. Instead cQED is ideally suited for exploring quantum many-body physics in the driven dissipative regime where the interplay of constantly injecting microwave photons and the unpreventable loss of microwave photons into the electromagnetic environment generates a whole new class of steady- but not equilibrium states. We propose an array of capacitively coupled superconducting resonators each coupled to an superconducting charge qubit and show that this device can be considered as an simulator for Bose Hubbard physics combined with the high flexibility of network topologies unique to cQED systems[2]. We further investigate the driven dissipative dynamics of this device. We refine this approach and calculate the eigenmodes and nonlinearities of a Josephson junction intersected transmission line resonator[3](c.f. fig.1a). This spectrum of eigenmodes shows the ultrastrong coupling of the Josephson junction to the resonator modes and nonlinearities are attainable that are significant on the single photon limit. We now proceed one step further and and consider the incorporation of multiple Josephson junctions. A novel transfer matrix technique has to be employed to investigate the eigenmode spectrum of the device.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•May 1, 2013•0 citations

Thermo-optical interactions in a dye-microcavity photon Bose–Einstein condensate

Hadiseh Alaeian, Mira Schedensack, Clara Bartels +2 more

Superfluidity and Bose–Einstein condensation are usually considered as two closely related phenomena. Indeed, in most macroscopic quantum systems, like liquid helium, ultracold atomic Bose gases, and exciton-polaritons, condensation and superfluidity occur in parallel. In photon Bose–Einstein condensates realized in the dye microcavity system, thermalization does not occur by direct interaction of the condensate particles as in the above described systems, i.e. photon–photon interactions, but by absorption and re-emission processes on the dye molecules, which act as a heat reservoir. Currently, there is no experimental evidence for superfluidity in the dye microcavity system, though effective photon interactions have been observed from thermo-optic effects in the dye medium. In this work, we theoretically investigate the implications of effective thermo-optic photon interactions, a temporally delayed and spatially non-local effect, on the photon condensate, and derive the resulting Bogoliubov excitation spectrum. The calculations suggest a linear photon dispersion at low momenta, fulfilling the Landau's criterion of superfluidity. We envision that the temporally delayed and long-range nature of the thermo-optic photon interaction offer perspectives for novel quantum fluid phenomena.

arXiv:1710.01706•New Journal of Physics•Oct 26, 2017•24 citations
Abstract The seminal phenomenon of the Bose-Einstein condensation has been observed on a large variety of physical platforms, e.g., superfluid helium, fermions with attractive interactions, quasiparticles in solids, and ultracold atomic gases. Recently, the Bose–Einstein condensation of non-interacting photons in an optical microcavity has been confirmed experimentally. Here, we report the experimental observation of Bose-Einstein like condensation and collective Bogoliubov excitations in a low dissipative microwave resonator with embedded superconducting quantum network composed of multiple flux qubits. Under strong coherent pumping the resonator mode becomes macroscopically populated, giving rise to hybridized photon–qubit collective modes. The Bogoliubov-like collective excitations appearing in a response to a nearby-frequency probe tone, accompanied by pronounced bistability and hysteresis in the measured transmission coefficient, provide the first experimental evidence of a Bose–Einstein–like condensate of microwave photons on a superconducting circuit platform. A theoretical framework based on Gross-Pitaevskii formalism and taking into account the ac Stark effect inducing the effective interaction between photons, quantitatively reproduces the experimental observations and identifies the regime of appearance of microwave Bogoliubov excitations. These results establish a proof of principle for exploiting driven collective states in superconducting circuits as a platform for quantum-limited microwave detection and engineered many-body photonic systems for quantum information processing.
Superconducting qubit networks (SQNs) embedded in a low-dissipative resonator is a promising device allowing one not only to establish the collective quantum dynamics on a macroscopic scale but also to greatly enhance the sensitivity of detectors of microwave photons. A quantum ac Stark effect provided by coupling between an SQN and microwave photons of a resonator, leads to a strong nonlinear interaction between photons. Here, we present a two-tone spectroscopy experiment in which a set of 10 superconducting flux qubits is coupled to the input R- resonator and the output T- transmission line. An external microwave pump field close to the resonance frequency populates macroscopically the resonator mode as a Bose-Einstein condensate, while a second probe beam scans the resonances referred also as Bogoliubov-like excitations. The corresponding excitation frequency measured from the transmission coefficient, |S21(f)| displays an abrupt change of the resonant dip position once the power of the pump field overcomes a critical value Pcr. This sharp shift occurs in a narrow region of pump frequencies, and can be tuned by an applied magnetic field. It is a signature of bistability of the photon number inside the resonator, in agreement with theory.
We propose a novel approach to detect a low power microwave signal with a frequency of the order of several GHz based on a coherent collective response of quantum states occurring in a superconducting qubits network (SQN). An SQN composes of a large number of superconducting qubits embedded in a low-dissipative superconducting resonator. Our theory predicts that an SQN interacting with the off-resonance microwave radiation, demonstrates the collective alternating current Stark effect that can be measured even in the limit of single photon counting. A design of the layout of three terminals SQN detectors containing 10 flux qubits weakly coupled to a low-dissipative R-resonator and T-transmission line was developed. The samples were fabricated by Al-based technology with Nb resonator. The SQN detector was tested in terms of microwave measurements of scattering parameters and two-tone spectroscopy. A substantial shift of the frequency position of the transmission coefficient drop induced by a second tone pump signal was observed, and this effect clearly manifests a nonlinear multiphoton interaction between the second-tone microwave pump signal and an array of qubits.
We study photon condensation phenomena in a driven and dissipative array of superconducting microwave resonators.Specifically, we show that by using an appropriately designed coupling of microwave photons to superconducting qubits, an effective dissipative mechanism can be engineered, which scatters photons towards low-momentum states while conserving their number.This mimics a tunable coupling of bosons to a low-temperature bath, and leads to the formation of a stationary photon condensate in the presence of losses and under continuous-driving conditions.In this paper, we propose a realistic experimental setup to observe this effect in two or multiple coupled cavities, and study the characteristics of such an out-of-equilibrium condensate, which arise from the competition between pumping and dissipation processes.
Bose–Einstein condensation represents a quintessential manifestation of quantum mechanics at macroscopic scales, where a dilute gas of bosonic atoms undergoes a phase transition to form a coherent matter wave. This study presents a comprehensive theoretical investigation of collective excitations and critical phenomena in interacting Bose–Einstein condensates (BECs). Beginning with the Gross–Pitaevskii equation , we develop the Bogoliubov theory of excitations yielding the spectrum , where is the free-particle energy and characterizes contact interactions. The spectrum reveals phonon behavior at low momenta with sound velocity , transitioning to free-particle dispersion at momenta exceeding the inverse healing length . Collective modes in harmonically trapped condensates are analyzed in the Thomas–Fermi regime, yielding breathing mode frequency and quadrupole frequency . Damping mechanisms including Landau damping ( ) and Beliaev damping ( ) are characterized. The Lee–Huang–Yang correction extends the equation of state beyond mean field. Critical phenomena near are analyzed within the 3D XY universality class, with critical exponents , , and the interaction-induced shift with . All predictions show excellent agreement with experimental measurements on ultracold atomic gases.
In its infancy circuit quantum electrodynamics (cQED) has quickly started reproducing fundamental quantum optical experiments, e.g. observation of vacuum rabi oscillations in frequency and time domain, with unprecedented cooperativity. This was possible because of the large coupling of the quasi one-dimensional microwave field of the superconducting transmission line resonators to the macroscopic dipole moment of superconducting qubits. cQED has matured to a discipline of experimental physics capable of performing fundamental quantum information tasks and is currently on the verge of crossing the border between few- to many body physics [1]. This opens up a exciting realm of completely new physical phenomena. Because of the ubiquitous influence of the electromagnetic environment however the number of microwave photons is not conserved which separates cQED systems from other quantum simulators involving atoms, e.g. cold atoms in optical latices. Instead cQED is ideally suited for exploring quantum many-body physics in the driven dissipative regime where the interplay of constantly injecting microwave photons and the unpreventable loss of microwave photons into the electromagnetic environment generates a whole new class of steady- but not equilibrium states. We propose an array of capacitively coupled superconducting resonators each coupled to an superconducting charge qubit and show that this device can be considered as an simulator for Bose Hubbard physics combined with the high flexibility of network topologies unique to cQED systems[2]. We further investigate the driven dissipative dynamics of this device. We refine this approach and calculate the eigenmodes and nonlinearities of a Josephson junction intersected transmission line resonator[3](c.f. fig.1a). This spectrum of eigenmodes shows the ultrastrong coupling of the Josephson junction to the resonator modes and nonlinearities are attainable that are significant on the single photon limit. We now proceed one step further and and consider the incorporation of multiple Josephson junctions. A novel transfer matrix technique has to be employed to investigate the eigenmode spectrum of the device.
Superfluidity and Bose–Einstein condensation are usually considered as two closely related phenomena. Indeed, in most macroscopic quantum systems, like liquid helium, ultracold atomic Bose gases, and exciton-polaritons, condensation and superfluidity occur in parallel. In photon Bose–Einstein condensates realized in the dye microcavity system, thermalization does not occur by direct interaction of the condensate particles as in the above described systems, i.e. photon–photon interactions, but by absorption and re-emission processes on the dye molecules, which act as a heat reservoir. Currently, there is no experimental evidence for superfluidity in the dye microcavity system, though effective photon interactions have been observed from thermo-optic effects in the dye medium. In this work, we theoretically investigate the implications of effective thermo-optic photon interactions, a temporally delayed and spatially non-local effect, on the photon condensate, and derive the resulting Bogoliubov excitation spectrum. The calculations suggest a linear photon dispersion at low momenta, fulfilling the Landau's criterion of superfluidity. We envision that the temporally delayed and long-range nature of the thermo-optic photon interaction offer perspectives for novel quantum fluid phenomena.