The Yamagishi Macroscopic Superposition Limit Theory ── 3rd ed.: The Density Correction Never Reached the Table of Radii, and E_G=Gm²/R Hides the Separation ── [Paper 55]
For the problem of the limit of macroscopic superposition, epitomised by "Schr\"odinger's cat," we present the picture of an auto-commit mechanism in the Universe OS and evaluate its critical particle number N_crit quantitatively using existing objective collapse models. The core of this paper is a correction. The first edition held that N_crit≈10¹¹ is fixed by overflow of the thread memory cost M(N) = M₀·2^N; but confronting this 2^N model with the holographic information capacity of the universe, ~10¹²² bits, yields N 405, so that the model itself disagrees with the asserted value by eight orders of magnitude (Theorem 2.1). Moreover the 2^N model carries the strong premise that "a classical substrate simulates quantum mechanics." This revision therefore relocates the grounds for N_crit to collapse models, presenting evaluation tables from the CSL model (Γ=λ N²) and Penrose gravitational collapse (τ=ħ/E_G) (Section 3). The result positions N_crit~10¹¹ as a marker of the quantum--classical transition region corresponding to microsecond-scale collapse under standard CSL parameters. That value, however, depends on the model and time criterion adopted and is not derivable from the OS picture alone. The current reach of molecular interference experiments is N~10³--10⁴, far from testing this regime (Section 4). Two further qualifications added in the second edition: (i) the CSL law Γ=λ N² holds only within the correlation length r_C≈10⁻⁷ m, and N=10¹¹ (R≈0.86\ μm) exceeds that condition by about ninefold --- that row is an extrapolation (note to Proposition 3.1). (ii) The Penrose table computes mass from a nucleon count but volume from an atom count, so its effective density is about 62 kg/m³ rather than solid density; recomputing at solid density shortens τ uniformly by about 3.2×, leaving the order-of-magnitude conclusions unchanged (note to Proposition 3.2). Both qualifications reinforce this paper's conclusion that N_crit is not uniquely determined. A note on the aim of this work. This is a structural reinterpretation of well-established physics, not a proposal for a new physical law. Every relation shown is a substitution into, or a geometric re-reading of, equations that are already known and that remain unchanged. The aim is a modest one: to make a few recurring geometric structures — in particular the solid angle 4π and the exponent n = 2 — easier to see within a single picture. Where a particular unit convention is adopted (for example G = 4π), this is a choice of notation, not a claim about nature. Nothing here is intended to contradict existing results. On the making of this work: The ideas and content of this work stem from the author's own considerations. Assistance from an AI (a large language model) was used for structuring, English translation, and checking the algebra. Any remaining errors or misinterpretations are solely the author's. Feedback and corrections are sincerely appreciated. ----- 「シュレーディンガーの猫」に代表されるマクロ重ね合わせの限界問題に対し、宇宙OSの自動コミット機構という描像を提示し、その臨界粒子数 N_crit を既存の客観的収縮模型により定量評価する。本稿の中核は訂正にある。初版はスレッドメモリコスト M(N) = M₀·2^N のオーバーフローにより N_crit≈10¹¹ が決まるとしたが、この 2^N 模型を宇宙のホログラフィック情報容量 ~10¹²² ビットに突き合わせると N 405 となり、模型自身が主張値と8桁食い違う(定理2.1)。さらに 2^N 模型は「量子力学を古典的基盤が模擬している」という強い前提を含む。そこで本改訂版は N_crit の根拠を崩壊模型へ移し、CSL模型(Γ=λ N²)およびPenroseの重力崩壊(τ=ħ/E_G)による評価表を提示する(第3節)。結果として N_crit~10¹¹ は、CSL標準パラメータの下でマイクロ秒スケールの収縮に対応する量子・古典転移域の目安として位置づけられる。ただしその値は採用する模型と時間規準に依存し、OS描像のみからは導出されない。 第2版で追加した2つの限定:(i) CSLの Γ=λ N² は相関長 r_C≈10⁻⁷ m の内部に限られる増幅則であり、N=10¹¹(R≈0.86\ μm)はこの条件を約9倍超過している——当該行は外挿値である(命題3.1の注記)。(ii) Penrose表は質量を核子数、体積を原子数として計算しているため実効密度が約 62 kg/m³ となり固体密度ではない;固体密度で計算し直すと τ は一律約 3.2 倍短くなるがオーダーの結論は不変である(命題3.2の注記)。いずれも「N_crit は一意に定まらない」という本稿の結論を補強する方向に働く。現行の分子干渉実験の到達点は N~10³--10⁴ であり、この領域を検証する能力はまだない(第4節)。 本稿の位置づけ。本稿は確立した物理法則に対する構造的解釈であり、新たな物理法則を提案するものではありません。示される関係はいずれも既知の式への代入、またはその幾何学的な読み替えであり、元の式は変わりません。目的はささやかで、繰り返し現れる幾何構造——とくに立体角 4π と指数 n = 2——を一つの描像の中で見やすくすることにあります。特定の単位系(例:G = 4π)を採る箇所は記法上の約束であって、自然についての主張ではありません。既存の結果と矛盾する意図はありません。 作成にあたって:本稿の着想と内容は、著者自身の考察に基づくものです。文章の構成整理や英訳、数式の確認には AI(大規模言語モデル)の助力を得ました。最終的な内容の解釈や誤りがあれば、それらはすべて著者の責に帰します。お気づきの点があれば、ご教示いただければ幸いです。
For the problem of the limit of macroscopic superposition, epitomised by "Schr"odinger's cat," we present the picture of an auto-commit mechanism in the Universe OS and evaluate its critical particle number N_crit quantitatively using existing objective collapse models. The core of this paper is a correction. The first edition held that N_crit≈10¹¹ is fixed by overflow of the thread memory cost M(N) = M₀·2^N; but confronting this 2^N model with the holographic information capacity of the universe, 10¹²² bits, yields N 405, so that the model itself disagrees with the asserted value by eight orders of magnitude (Theorem 2.1). Moreover the 2^N model carries the strong premise that "a classical substrate simulates quantum mechanics." This revision therefore relocates the grounds for N_crit to collapse models, presenting evaluation tables from the CSL model (Γ=λ N²) and Penrose gravitational collapse (τ=ħ/E_G) (Section 3). The result positions N_crit10¹¹ as a marker of the quantum--classical transition region corresponding to microsecond-scale collapse under standard CSL parameters. That value, however, depends on the model and time criterion adopted and is not derivable from the OS picture alone. The current reach of molecular interference experiments is N10³--10⁴, far from testing this regime (Section 4). Two further qualifications added in the second edition: (i) the CSL law Γ=λ N² holds only within the correlation length r_C≈10⁻⁷ m, and N=10¹¹ (R≈0.86\ μm) exceeds that condition by about ninefold --- that row is an extrapolation (note to Proposition 3.1). (ii) The Penrose table computes mass from a nucleon count but volume from an atom count, so its effective density is about 62 kg/m³ rather than solid density; recomputing at solid density shortens τ uniformly by about 3.2×, leaving the order-of-magnitude conclusions unchanged (note to Proposition 3.2). Both qualifications reinforce this paper's conclusion that N_crit is not uniquely determined. A note on the aim of this work. This is a structural reinterpretation of well-established physics, not a proposal for a new physical law. Every relation shown is a substitution into, or a geometric re-reading of, equations that are already known and that remain unchanged. The aim is a modest one: to make a few recurring geometric structures — in particular the solid angle 4π and the exponent n = 2 — easier to see within a single picture. Where a particular unit convention is adopted (for example G = 4π), this is a choice of notation, not a claim about nature. Nothing here is intended to contradict existing results. On the making of this work: The ideas and content of this work stem from the author's own considerations. Assistance from an AI (a large language model) was used for structuring, English translation, and checking the algebra. Any remaining errors or misinterpretations are solely the author's. Feedback and corrections are sincerely appreciated. ----- 「シュレーディンガーの猫」に代表されるマクロ重ね合わせの限界問題に対し、宇宙OSの自動コミット機構という描像を提示し、その臨界粒子数 N_crit を既存の客観的収縮模型により定量評価する。本稿の中核は訂正にある。初版はスレッドメモリコスト M(N) = M₀·2^N のオーバーフローにより N_crit≈10¹¹ が決まるとしたが、この 2^N 模型を宇宙のホログラフィック情報容量 10¹²² ビットに突き合わせると N 405 となり、模型自身が主張値と8桁食い違う(定理2.1)。さらに 2^N 模型は「量子力学を古典的基盤が模擬している」という強い前提を含む。そこで本改訂版は N_crit の根拠を崩壊模型へ移し、CSL模型(Γ=λ N²)およびPenroseの重力崩壊(τ=ħ/E_G)による評価表を提示する(第3節)。結果として N_crit10¹¹ は、CSL標準パラメータの下でマイクロ秒スケールの収縮に対応する量子・古典転移域の目安として位置づけられる。ただしその値は採用する模型と時間規準に依存し、OS描像のみからは導出されない。 第2版で追加した2つの限定:(i) CSLの Γ=λ N² は相関長 r_C≈10⁻⁷ m の内部に限られる増幅則であり、N=10¹¹(R≈0.86\ μm)はこの条件を約9倍超過している——当該行は外挿値である(命題3.1の注記)。(ii) Penrose表は質量を核子数、体積を原子数として計算しているため実効密度が約 62 kg/m³ となり固体密度ではない;固体密度で計算し直すと τ は一律約 3.2 倍短くなるがオーダーの結論は不変である(命題3.2の注記)。いずれも「N_crit は一意に定まらない」という本稿の結論を補強する方向に働く。現行の分子干渉実験の到達点は N10³--10⁴ であり、この領域を検証する能力はまだない(第4節)。 本稿の位置づけ。本稿は確立した物理法則に対する構造的解釈であり、新たな物理法則を提案するものではありません。示される関係はいずれも既知の式への代入、またはその幾何学的な読み替えであり、元の式は変わりません。目的はささやかで、繰り返し現れる幾何構造——とくに立体角 4π と指数 n = 2——を一つの描像の中で見やすくすることにあります。特定の単位系(例:G = 4π)を採る箇所は記法上の約束であって、自然についての主張ではありません。既存の結果と矛盾する意図はありません。 作成にあたって:本稿の着想と内容は、著者自身の考察に基づくものです。文章の構成整理や英訳、数式の確認には AI(大規模言語モデル)の助力を得ました。最終的な内容の解釈や誤りがあれば、それらはすべて著者の責に帰します。お気づきの点があれば、ご教示いただければ幸いです。
Substituting the Yamagishi patch m=4π and the sync patch ₀=r (Paper 14) into Bohr's centripetal equilibrium (mv²)/(r) = (1)/(4π₀)(e²)/(r²) produces the compact form 16π² v² r² = e² ⟺ (4π v)· r = e , which we call the Bohr--Yamagishi equation. We also give its extension to arbitrary principal quantum number n_quant. The algebra is elementary and correct. Withdrawal in the 2nd edition: The first edition presented a "Microscopic Non-Collapse Theorem", asserting that radiative damping is cancelled inside the 16π² toroidal cocoon because Ratio=(16π²)/(16π²)=1. This claim is withdrawn. Any nonzero quantity divided by itself equals 1; this is not a property of 16π² and constitutes no mechanism. The same error appeared in the first editions of Papers 09 and 13 and has been withdrawn there as well. On why atoms do not collapse: this question was answered by quantum mechanics in 1926. In a stationary state the probability density |_n|² is time independent, so there is no oscillating dipole moment and hence no radiation. This paper does not replace that explanation, and the equation obtained here is a restatement of the equilibrium condition of the 1913 Bohr model --- a picture itself superseded by the Schr\"odinger equation. _(scope note)_ Scope of this paper: This paper offers a structural interpretation of existing physical law. It does not claim the discovery of new physical laws or the proof of open problems. Note on units: Substitutions such as m=4π are a choice of natural units. G and ħ are dimensionful; their numerical values depend entirely on the unit system. Setting G=4π is legitimate in exactly the same sense as setting G=1 (geometric units) or G=6.674×10⁻¹¹ (SI); physics does not single out one of these as "correct." What this paper exhibits is therefore how the equations look in this unit system, not a new fact about nature. A note on the aim of this work. This is a structural reinterpretation of well-established physics, not a proposal for a new physical law. Every relation shown is a substitution into, or a geometric re-reading of, equations that are already known and that remain unchanged. The aim is a modest one: to make a few recurring geometric structures — in particular the solid angle 4π and the exponent n = 2 — easier to see within a single picture. Where a particular unit convention is adopted (for example G = 4π), this is a choice of notation, not a claim about nature. Nothing here is intended to contradict existing results. On the making of this work: The ideas and content of this work stem from the author's own considerations. Assistance from an AI (a large language model) was used for structuring, English translation, and checking the algebra. Any remaining errors or misinterpretations are solely the author's. Feedback and corrections are sincerely appreciated. ----- 「なぜ原子の中の電子は連続的に電磁波を放出してわずか 10⁻¹¹ 秒で原子核へ墜落しないのか」というミクロ非放射崩壊の謎に対し、ボーアの円軌道方程式から幾何学的に立ち上がる 16π² トーラス繭による完全な保護構造を証明する。本稿の論証は3段階からなる。第一段階:電子の向心力とクーロン力とのつり合い式 (mv²)/(r) = (1)/(4π₀)(e²)/(r²) に m=4π および ₀ = r を同時適用し、分母に 16π² = (4π)² を出現させることで「ボーア・山岸方程式(16π² v² r² = e² ⟺ 4π v · r = e)」を厳密導出する。第二段階:ボーアの角運動量量子化条件 m v r = n_quant ħ との整合性を検証し、一般の主量子数 n_quant に対する拡張形式 4π v_n r_n = e / n_quant を定式化する。第三段階:本方程式と論文14のモード判定基準との整合性を確認する。 第2版における撤回: 初版は「16π² トーラス繭の遮蔽効果(Ratio=(16π²)/(16π²)=1)により放射漏洩がゼロとなる」とする「微視的非崩壊定理」を提示していた。この主張を撤回する。比が1になるのは任意の非零数について成立する自明な事実であり、機構を構成しない(論文09・13初版にも同種の誤りがあり、同時に撤回されている)。 加えて、原子が崩壊しない理由は量子力学によって既に説明されている。定常状態の確率密度 |_n|² は時間に依存せず、振動する双極子モーメントが存在しないため原理的に放射しない(シュレーディンガー 1926)。本稿のボーア・山岸方程式はボーア模型の枠内における向心力平衡条件を書き直したものであり、原子の安定性を説明するものではない。 _(射程注記)_ 本稿の位置づけ:本稿は既存の物理法則に対する構造的解釈を提示するものであり、新たな物理法則の発見や未解決問題の証明を主張しない。 単位系についての注記:m=4π、₀=r 等は自然単位系における規約の選択である。本稿が示すのはこの規約を採ったとき方程式がどう見えるかであって、自然についての新事実ではない。 本稿の位置づけ。本稿は確立した物理法則に対する構造的解釈であり、新たな物理法則を提案するものではありません。示される関係はいずれも既知の式への代入、またはその幾何学的な読み替えであり、元の式は変わりません。目的はささやかで、繰り返し現れる幾何構造——とくに立体角 4π と指数 n = 2——を一つの描像の中で見やすくすることにあります。特定の単位系(例:G = 4π)を採る箇所は記法上の約束であって、自然についての主張ではありません。既存の結果と矛盾する意図はありません。 作成にあたって:本稿の着想と内容は、著者自身の考察に基づくものです。文章の構成整理や英訳、数式の確認には AI(大規模言語モデル)の助力を得ました。最終的な内容の解釈や誤りがあれば、それらはすべて著者の責に帰します。お気づきの点があれば、ご教示いただければ幸いです。
Version 4 (October 2026), interim correction: an independent review found that the main result is a reformulation rather than a recovery. Both inputs to the budget-saturation condition, the superposition cost and the budget B = ħ/τ, are posited, so its agreement with the Penrose–Diósi criterion holds by construction. The uniform-sphere coefficient in the testable prediction is off by a factor of 6/5, and the tabulated collapse times use a small-displacement formula outside its range. These results should not be cited until the revised version is posted. Details are in the Revision History of the PDF.We show that the Penrose–Diósi gravitational collapse criterion — which predicts that quantum superpositions decay on a timescale τ = ℏ/E_G, where E_G is the gravitational self-energy of the difference mass distribution — arises as the budget-saturation condition of the selective reconstruction framework (Russell 2026a). When the reconstruction budget B is identified with ℏ/τ_local via the Margolus–Levitin theorem, the Russell constraint C_super ≤ B becomes the Penrose–Diósi inequality E_G ≤ ℏ/τ. "Observation" is thereby reframed not as a primitive physical event but as the condition under which the gravitational self-energy of a superposition exhausts the geometric reconstruction budget of the boundary observer. The result is observer-dependent and recovers relational quantum mechanics as a consequence of resource constraints. A falsifiable, mass-scaling prediction (τ ∝ M⁻² d⁻² R³) is derived for levitated-nanosphere experiments. A structural isomorphism with Nanite's LOD scheduling algorithm is noted as a conceptual heuristic. Epistemic status: The budget identification is motivated by the Margolus–Levitin theorem but is not formally derived from AdS/CFT. This is a working paper inviting scrutiny, not an established result.v3 (2026-05-27): Format converted from HTML to LaTeX. §5 collapse-time table recomputed under the stated d=R, ρ=2200 kg/m³ convention (prior values were inconsistent with the formula by ~30 orders of magnitude). Reference 8 updated per consolidation of Virtualized Geometry into Spacetime as Optimal Allocation. Minor text corrections: sub-femtokelvin → sub-microkelvin, Verlinde (2010) → (2011), Stanford → ETH Zurich. Figures regenerated with layout fixes (no content changes). ORCID, email, and concept DOI added to front matter.
In the Bose–Marletto–Vedral (BMV) class of tabletop gravity experiments, two mesoscopic masses are each placed in a spatial superposition and their Newtonian interaction is used as a witness of gravitationally induced entanglement. Aspelmeyer [5] has sharpened the standard argument: observing entanglement at the 10-15 kg scale already rules out current Diósi–Penrose (DP) collapse models. Here we ask a complementary question: when the source mass itself is the object in superposition, what is the sign of the gravity-induced decoherence *rate* as a function of M/r (mass over characteristic superposition scale), and where in the mass range is that rate actually measurable? We compare three branches: (A) linearized quantum field theory, which gives reversible phase accumulation and Gamma = 0; (B) DP / continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) collapse, for which Gamma > 0 and grows steeply with M/r (positive trend); and (C) a phenomenological strawman of variable vacuum-foam / stochastic-spacetime suppression, Gammafoam = Gammafbg exp(-3 kappa GM/(rc2)), for which the trend is negative. Branch C is not derived from any specific quantum-gravity model; it is introduced only to give the sign question a non-trivial alternative. We solve the rates for a uniform sphere (density rho = 2000 kg/m3, superposition separation d = 10 r) and find: (i) a rate-resolved window M ~ 2×10-16 to 10-14 kg in which the DP rate exceeds a BMV-class environmental floor of 0.05 s-1 but is still measurable — this window lies below the regime where entanglement-survival alone, à la Aspelmeyer, already excludes DP; (ii) the phenomenological strawman foam-suppression branch is observationally degenerate with QFT-zero on Earth, because d ln Gammafoam / d ln M = -2 kappa GM/(rc2) ~ -10-37 to -10-35 across the entire lab range. Discriminating this toy from QFT-zero would require the near-Schwarzschild regime x = GM/(rc2) ~ O(1). Shot-noise-limited run counts are ~6 at M = 10-15 kg, ~104 at M = 10-16 kg, and environment-limited below M = 10-16 kg. All numerical values are illustrative/synthetic order-of-magnitude estimates.
VERSION NOTE (v2, 2026-07-02): This version supersedes v1 (April 2026). The central empirical-viability claims of v1 — a thermodynamically viable collapse kernel and a favorable DESI DR1 cosmological signature — were falsified by the author's own subsequent analysis. Fixing the smearing length to its holographically mandated value forces confrontation with the full hierarchy of collapse bounds, where spontaneous-heating measurements exclude it by ~9 orders of magnitude. The work has been rewritten as a parameter-free no-go constraint. v1 is retained below for the version record but should not be cited as a viability result. ABSTRACT (v2): The Diósi–Penrose (DP) model of gravity-induced wavefunction collapse requires an ad hoc mass-smearing length, set phenomenologically at the nucleon scale, R0 ~ 1e-15 m. We show that this scale is fixed by holographic cosmological geometry: evaluating the Károlyházy metric variance over the cosmological apparent horizon, as mandated by the Bousso covariant entropy bound, yields R0 = (lP^2 RH)^(1/3) = 3.3 fm from measured constants alone — a parameter-free reproduction of the historical choice. The decoherence-time kinematics survive every current test: a quantum–classical partition at m_crit ≈ 120 m_e protects atomic chemistry (electron tau ~ 1e21 s) and matter-wave interferometry (C60: ~115 yr) while imposing definiteness on macroscopic bodies, with the ambiguous mesoscopic window falling in the macromolecular regime accessible to near-term interferometry. The standard dynamical realization does not survive. The Einstein Equivalence Principle suppresses single-nucleus dipole bremsstrahlung by a derived factor (k_X R0)^2 ≈ 3e-8, and any noise cutoff below 1e18 Hz evades the underground X-ray bound; but neither defense touches spontaneous heating, which with the standard prefactor predicts ~28 mW/kg — nine orders of magnitude above cryogenic heat-leak ceilings. The heating is charge-independent and probes THz phonons via the relative momentum diffusion of atoms separated by 1e5 correlation lengths, so it is immune to the equivalence principle and robust to any high-frequency cutoff. The framework derives exactly two temporal scales (the pixel light-crossing rate ~1e22 Hz and the horizon refresh rate ~1e-19 Hz); neither lands in the fifteen-decade escape window, and inserting one by hand reinjects the free parameter the construction eliminates. We conclude that if objective collapse is sourced by cosmological holographic geometry, it cannot be mediated by continuous stochastic momentum diffusion: a parameter-free no-go constraint forcing gravity-induced reduction toward non-dissipative or purely kinematic mechanisms.
A model of the vacuum as a face-centered-cubic lattice predicts a two-step quantum–classical threshold, at 13.1 and 22.6μg, from the hypothesis (P3) that a center-of-mass excitation stays coherently representable only while its reduced Compton wavelength is resolvable by the lattice. Collapse models also limit macroscopic coherence, so the two must be told apart by more than a scale. Taking P3 as a hypothesis, not a derived result, we derive discriminators from the model’s postulates and compute the counterpart in Diósi–Penrose collapse and in continuous spontaneous localization (CSL). The thresholds depend on total mass alone, the same for every material, while both collapse models depend on density. Below 13.1μg, the model predicts no intrinsic decoherence, where collapse takes 1 s for Diósi–Penrose and about a microsecond for CSL at its experimental bound, for 10−15 kg over 1μm; this also separates the model from energy-driven reduction models, which dephase at every mass. The model predicts no measurable heating. Two consistency requirements follow: read as position localization, its rate scale would exceed the LISA Pathfinder bound by 66 orders of magnitude, and read as strong energy-basis dephasing it would destroy the phase of classical oscillations of macroscopic bodies. The Compton-scale correction does not alter the motion of microgram bodies. If the effective mass of a mechanical mode is the relevant mass, a mechanical cat state quoted at 16.2μg bounds the irreversible coupling at 37 orders below its natural scale; in another common convention, that mode is below the threshold. A worked levitated-particle example, an outlook for near-future data, and a public script complete the analysis.
In the Diósi–Penrose (DP) model a superposition of two mass distributions decays at the rate E_G/ħ. Diósi's master equation uses the mass-density operator smeared over a length R0; Penrose's formulation uses the density of the stationary state, and the "parameter-free" choice R0 = u_rms (the zero-point amplitude) links the two. This preprint examines what each choice implies for spontaneous heating and for collapse rates, and states separately which results are standard and which are new. Main results:• Heating per unit mass is 2πGħ∫g², i.e. Għ/(4√π σxσyσz) for Gaussian smearing of per-axis widths σi. With R0 equal to the per-axis zero-point amplitude, Diósi's functional reproduces Penrose's E_G for displacements smaller than the lattice spacing.• For a crystal ball, E_G splits exactly into a continuum term and a per-atom granular term. The continuum term is already contained in the per-atom term (the gravitational analogue of the Lorentz local field), the granular term is lattice periodic, and it carries a Madelung reduction of 0.90 (Cu) and 0.29 (⁴He).• Copper is predicted to heat at 12.1–12.8 pW/kg. This is in mild tension with the 10 pW/kg figure adopted after background subtraction from the Bayreuth heat leak.• The published Debye–Waller values of hcp ⁴He follow a convention in which the reported ⟨u²⟩ is half the one-dimensional mean-square displacement. One direct cross-check and four consistency checks support this reading. With it, the solid-helium prediction becomes 6–8 fW/kg instead of 21 fW/kg.• For any liquid (⁴He or ³He) the one-body density is uniform, so Penrose's granular E_G vanishes. The solid/liquid ⁴He collapse-rate ratio is ≈6 for d ≪ u, 2.8 at 0.2 nm and 1.15 at 1 nm, which quantifies a conjecture of Diósi (2013).• Heating under Penrose's prescription depends on the dynamical completion. For every completion that splits ⟨ρ⟩ into non-negative pieces, the liquid heats at most 2πGħn = 1.15 fW/kg; maximal localization then gives a liquid/solid ratio of 0.155. Density-matrix and configuration-based completions give anything from ~10⁻²⁶ to order one.• Experiment: – Ionizing radiation deposits nearly the same power per kilogram in every material and therefore mimics the fixed-R0 signal. – Underground at LNGS, unshielded environmental gammas still deposit 0.6–8 pW/kg, so ≥20 cm of lead is needed. – The nearest-term test of the zero-point prescription is to compare the heat leaks of heavy, stiff metals with copper; tungsten is predicted at ≈77 pW/kg, six times copper. – Underground helium calorimetry at 1–0.1 pW/kg would test colored fixed-R0 models up to R0 ≈ 10–21 pm, provided the cell-wall heat release can be subtracted to 5–0.5%.