For the tilted family $J_w = w(a_1+a_2-b_1-b_2) + \sum_{ij} s_{ij}E_{ij}$ containing the $I_{3322}$ Bell functional at $w=1$, we map where and why the almost-quantum set (NPA level $1{+}AB$) exceeds NPA level 2, using a subset-relaxation diagnostic: adjoin the twelve level-2 words to the $1{+}AB$ basis in subsets and measure each subset's share of the gap. The excess is sharply localized and structurally rigid. (i) At $w=1$, the four matched words $A_1A_2, A_2A_1, B_1B_2, B_2B_1$ on the marginal-anchored settings recover 92% of the gap, while either party's complete pair structure, all eight third-setting words, and every mismatched cross-party pairing recover exactly none; at the level of the certified separation witness $T^*$, infeasibility appears already under a single cross-party pair of anchored words, one per wing, while every single-party and every third-setting subset leaves $T^*$ feasible. (ii) The mechanism is algebraic: reversal-symmetrized ordering differences obey $\langle A_1A_2B_jB_3\rangle - \langle A_1A_2B_3B_j\rangle = \frac{1}{2}\langle[A_1,A_2][B_j,B_3]\rangle$, an expectation of commutator products across the wings, and sharp sequential measurement reads only anticommutators, so the excess lives in a sector unreadable in principle on either wing alone. (iii) The gap requires the functional's marginal anchor to oppose and co-locate with the aligned correlator block: moving either, aligning their signs, or deleting the marginals annihilates the gap. (iv) In the anchor weight the gap opens only on a finite window, $w \in (0.90, 0.95)$ to $(2.25, 2.50)$, with a two-lobed interior peaking near $w=2$ at $4.07\times10^{-3}$ -- 7.7 times the separation of standard $I_{3322}$, which sits just inside the lower edge. Experiments probing the almost-quantum boundary should therefore run the tilted functional near $w=2$, not the textbook one. The headline values are certified in exact rational arithmetic: the two-word infeasibility of $T^*$, the matched-four value, the peak, and one closure; remaining grid values are floating-point with two solver families agreeing to five digits. Files in this record: the paper (PDF); exact rational proof objects for the four headline certificates (window_paper_certificates.json); a standalone verifier requiring only the Python 3 standard library (verify_window_certificates.py); analysis scripts (why_level2.py, anchor_tracking.py); and certificate generators (certify_window.py, refreeze_window.py). See README_window.txt. Companion record with the certified separation and its certificates: doi:10.5281/zenodo.21534675.
For the tilted family Jw=w(a1+a2−b1−b2)+∑ijsijEij containing the I3322 Bell functional at w=1, we map where and why the almost-quantum set (NPA level 1+AB) exceeds NPA level 2, using a subset-relaxation diagnostic: adjoin the twelve level-2 words to the 1+AB basis in subsets and measure each subset's share of the gap. The excess is sharply localized and structurally rigid. (i) At w=1, the four matched words A1A2,A2A1,B1B2,B2B1 on the marginal-anchored settings recover 92% of the gap, while either party's complete pair structure, all eight third-setting words, and every mismatched cross-party pairing recover exactly none; at the level of the certified separation witness T∗, infeasibility appears already under a single cross-party pair of anchored words, one per wing, while every single-party and every third-setting subset leaves T∗ feasible. (ii) The mechanism is algebraic: reversal-symmetrized ordering differences obey ⟨A1A2BjB3⟩−⟨A1A2B3Bj⟩=21⟨[A1,A2][Bj,B3]⟩, an expectation of commutator products across the wings, and sharp sequential measurement reads only anticommutators, so the excess lives in a sector unreadable in principle on either wing alone. (iii) The gap requires the functional's marginal anchor to oppose and co-locate with the aligned correlator block: moving either, aligning their signs, or deleting the marginals annihilates the gap. (iv) In the anchor weight the gap opens only on a finite window, w∈(0.90,0.95) to (2.25,2.50), with a two-lobed interior peaking near w=2 at 4.07×10−3 -- 7.7 times the separation of standard I3322, which sits just inside the lower edge. Experiments probing the almost-quantum boundary should therefore run the tilted functional near w=2, not the textbook one. The headline values are certified in exact rational arithmetic: the two-word infeasibility of T∗, the matched-four value, the peak, and one closure; remaining grid values are floating-point with two solver families agreeing to five digits. Files in this record: the paper (PDF); exact rational proof objects for the four headline certificates (window_paper_certificates.json); a standalone verifier requiring only the Python 3 standard library (verify_window_certificates.py); analysis scripts (why_level2.py, anchor_tracking.py); and certificate generators (certify_window.py, refreeze_window.py). See README_window.txt. Companion record with the certified separation and its certificates: doi:10.5281/zenodo.21534675.
Two companion papers established that the almost-quantum excess of the tilted I3322 family is a frustration-window phenomenon and conjectured the structure generic. Here we test the conjecture in both directions, with exact rational certificates for every headline claim. Necessity: we certify closures (gap ≤4×10−7 in each case) for three deformations that remove one ingredient each -- tilted CHSH families in the 2222 scenario (three tilt patterns, swept; certified at w=1), one-wing anchoring in 3322, and the (3,2) hybrid scenario -- so cross-wing opposition and three settings per wing are each necessary, and no tilted two-setting functional in the families tested registers the almost-quantum excess (the 1+AB/level-2 gap) at all. Genericity: for the tilted I4422 family (Collins-Gisin staircase, anchor weights (2,2,1,0)), we map the window and certify: the I4422 almost-quantum landmark at w=1 to width 5×10−7; the excess at w=1, 2.30033×10−2≤gap≤2.30047×10−2 -- in comparable normalization 10.8× the textbook I3322 separation; a peak lower bound gap(w=7/5)≥3.888×10−2; and the upper-edge closure gap(w=17/10)≤7.1×10−7. The anchor law generalizes quantitatively and is certified: the matched words on the heavy anchored pair {1,2} recover f∈[0.69260,0.69267] of the gap, every other single matched pair is inert, and the three matched pairs within the anchored triple -- exactly the marginal support -- jointly recover f∈[0.98813,0.98825]. One structural novelty refines the conjecture: the I4422 window opens at w=0+ rather than at an interior branch crossing, so the finite upper edge appears generic while the lower edge admits two types. Three further certified results: the quantum value is pinned at the peak by an exact rational strategy in dimension six meeting a rational dual of an intermediate relaxation (9.522944386≤maxQJ7/5≤9.525780588), giving a certified experimental corridor maxQ~−maxQ≥4.618×10−2; grid points become intervals via convexity and dual chords against exact deterministic lower lines, pinning entire branches within ∼10−6; and the same machinery run in reverse certifies the window open on all of [1/2,8/5] with margin ≥1.36×10−3. All certificates are single rational Bareiss-verifiable objects checkable with the Python standard library; certified zeros carry the necessity claims just as certified values carry the excess. Files in this record: the paper (PDF); certificate files with full rational proof objects (genericity_certificates.json, extended_certificates.json); standalone verifiers requiring only the Python 3 standard library (verify_genericity_certificates.py, verify_extended.py); and generating/exploration scripts (certlib.py, run_certs.py, ext_certs.py, cert_l2b.py, pin_maxq.py, quantum_cert.py, genericity_battery.py, polish.py). Companion records: the certified separation (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21534675) and the tilted I3322 window (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21603712).
Three companion papers established that the excess of the almost-quantum set over NPA level 2 on tilted Imm22 functionals is a frustration phenomenon: it exists only where a marginal anchor opposes a co-located correlator block, it lives on a finite window in the anchor weight, and it is policed by matched cross-party level-2 words at the anchored settings. This paper climbs the ladder and dissects the mechanism, with exact rational certificates for every headline value. The ladder grows: the normalized excess at w=1 is certified to [2.038580,2.038617]×10−2 at m=5 and [4.274637,4.274741]×10−2 at m=6 -- with the I5522 and I6622 classical bounds (11 and 16) re-enumerated exactly -- so the growth ratio decelerates (10.8→3.54→2.10), roughly tracking (m−3)2. The anchor law of the previous paper fails upward and is replaced: at m=5 every single matched pair is inert (the heaviest, certified to ≤8×10−6 of the gap) while the triangle of matched pairs on the three heaviest settings carries [0.74590,0.74595]; at m=6 the triangle in turn drops to ≤0.2596 while the 4-clique carries [0.81660,0.81665]; at m=7 the pattern continues to the 5-clique. A chordless 4-cycle recovers only 0.20 where the 4-clique recovers 0.82: the policing unit is the clique, not the cycle. In every certified instance the minimal adequate clique is the complete graph on the marginal support minus its lightest (sacrificial) setting -- the same setting the anchor sweep shows being driven anti-aligned and then released, so the static law and the dynamic cascade are one structure. Genuinely triadic words become load-bearing: at the tilted I4422 peak, same-wing length-3 words (the real, Bargmann-type 3-cycle sector) police a sector mixed words cannot reach, with a certified unique share of [0.18845,0.18884] -- the completion refusal retreats into sectors of higher cyclic order as the functional's tension increases. As a corollary the quantum value at the peak is pinned to 9.522944386≤maxQ≤9.524082942 (width 1.14×10−3) and the certified experimental corridor widens to 4.788×10−2. The I5522 upper edge is certified onto deterministic branches 12w−1 and 18w−11 crossing at exactly w=5/3. Three of our own published predictions failed this round and are reported with the same standard as the confirmations. Every certificate is a rational Bareiss-verifiable object checkable with the Python standard library. Files in this record: the paper (PDF and source); the certificate file with full rational proof objects (paper4_certificates.json); a standalone verifier requiring only the Python 3 standard library (verify_paper4.py, which also re-enumerates the classical bounds 11, 16, 22); generating and exploration scripts (certlib.py, p4_certs.py, i5522.py, i6622.py, m7.py, m7scan.py, syn.py, lobes.py, lean.py, raylib.py); and the interior-anatomy figure (lobe_anatomy.png). The improved quantum pin is archived in the extended_certificates.json of the genericity record. Companion records: the certified separation (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21534675), the tilted I3322 window (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21603712), and the genericity and necessity tests (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21616031).
Gigena et al. [npj Quantum Inf. 11, 82 (2025)] proved the exact quantum maximum of the doubly-tilted CHSH functional Bαβ=α⟨A0⟩+β⟨B0⟩+CHSH and observed that the NPA level required to reach it grows without evident bound toward the critical line α+β=2. We quantify the mechanism on the symmetric slice s=2−α−β: (i) the quantum value leaves the local bound cubically, cQ=4−s+s3/6−s4/36+O(s5); (ii) each NPA level overshoots quadratically, ck(s)=4−s+aks2+O(s3), with the almost-quantum coefficient computed exactly, a1+AB=3/64; (iii) the divergence of the required exact level is equivalent to positivity of the single sequence (ak) - proven for every k in the companion paper. We prove the supercritical side completely: for all α,β≥1 and every level the hierarchy is exact, via three explicit rational certificates realizing an affine identity. The hierarchy's exactness thus undergoes a phase transition at the critical line. On the subcritical side we certify the first four levels in exact arithmetic (rational pseudo-moments beating cQ, confirmed by Sturm's theorem). We identify the exact mechanism: rescaled to the critical corner, the limiting obstruction is the Motzkin polynomial, the classical nonnegative-but-not-sum-of-squares form, so the finite-level failure sits in the restricted-certificate regime. The phase boundary has a precise geometric reading via Nie's finite-convergence theorem and Marshall's boundary Hessian condition: a self-tested optimum is finitely NPA-certifiable whenever its boundary Hessian is nondegenerate (contact order two), which holds for the single tilt and fails exactly at the doubly-tilted cubic touch. Three verified errata in the published polynomial system of Gigena et al. are documented.
Four companion papers located, dissected, generalized, and laddered the excess of the almost-quantum set over NPA level 2 on tilted Imm22 functionals. This paper asks why the numbers are what they are, and answers for the bottom of the tilted I3322 window: the constants are algebraic all the way down. Three thresholds are proven exactly. The no-signaling-line visibility threshold of I3322 is the golden ratio conjugate, λ3∗=(5−1)/2 (explaining a numerical coincidence between two cost conventions, since 1/λ−1=λ precisely at φ; the same constant appears elsewhere in Bell physics as a critical detection efficiency, with no known derivation connecting the two). The quantum maximum of the I3322 correlator part is exactly 5, attained by a hexagonal configuration -- a non-facet functional whose value appears to be new. The I4422 threshold is λ4∗=210−6, the positive root of x4+12x2−4, by a symmetrization argument in which two feasibility intervals kiss exactly at the quartic root. Below the window, the flat branch is a theorem: an affine family of zero-slack rational duals proves the gap vanishes identically on [0,471/500], certified closure gives gap≤2.3×10−8 at w=2357/2500, and certified opening gives gap≥1.10×10−6 at w=1889/2000, so the lower edge lies in [0.942,0.9445]. Inside, ten dual-solver points spanning five orders of magnitude follow the onset law gap=21(w−22/3)2 to 1--2%, down to gaps of 5×10−10; the coefficient follows from the envelope theorem given the measured unit marginal susceptibility (1.00(2)), and the edge is a staggered pair of bifurcations, level 1+AB at we=22/3 and level 2 at weL2=0.955934(3). The edge constant is derived at first order: the flat branch's 1+AB completion obeys a Clifford--Wick pairing and carries an eight-dimensional relation ideal (the dual hexagon plus five operator sum rules); the marginal mode must break relations to turn on, and the cheapest tilt breaks exactly three while preserving five, at a price certified in both directions by exact arithmetic over Q(2) to be 82/3 per 4 units of anchor -- hence 22/3. The certificates' entries lie in 61Z[2] and 181Z[2], extending the series' exact-certificate method beyond the rationals for the first time. A failed derivation route -- a homogenized fractional SDP whose optimum sits at infinity, so that every finite iterate overestimates the edge by 1.7×10−4 -- is documented alongside the successes, in the company of the field's own precedent that at this boundary only exact objects adjudicate. Files in this record: the paper (The_Algebraic_Edge.pdf and .tex); the Q(2) certificate pair for the marginal-price theorem with its standalone verifier (q2_edge_certificates.json, verify_q2_edge.py); the lower-edge theorem's proof objects -- the zero-slack flat-dual family, the rational level-2 flat completion, and the closure/opening pair -- with verifier (edge_bracket_certificates.json, verify_edge_bracket.py); the onset-law data table (onset_table.json); generating scripts (gen_edge_bracket.py, gen_onset_table.py); and a README. Both verifiers require only the Python 3 standard library. Companion records: the certified separation (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21534675), the tilted I3322 window (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21603712), the genericity and necessity tests (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21616031), and the ladder anatomy (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21625241).
The Navascués--Pironio--Acín (NPA) hierarchy gives the standard semidefinite outer approximations to quantum behaviors. Whether \emph{any} finite level can already equal the quantum set has remained open even in the bipartite scenario with two binary measurements per party. We demonstrate that \emph{no finite level} is exact. For the symmetric doubly tilted CHSH functional hα=A0B0+A0B1+A1B0−A1B1+α(A0+B0), set T=1−α. Its quantum maximum satisfies [ωQ(1−T)−(4−2T)]/T3→4/3, whereas every fixed NPA level satisfies [ωL(1−T)−ωQ(1−T)]/T3→+∞. Under the corresponding boundary rescaling, an explicit expectation of the positive operator ωQ(1−t2)I−Ht converges to the Motzkin polynomial. A bounded fixed-level error would therefore make the Motzkin polynomial plus a nonnegative constant a sum of squares, which is impossible. Consequently, every standard NPA relaxation based on a fixed finite list of words in the measurement projectors strictly contains the complete quantum set, and its nonquantum behaviors accumulate at a local deterministic behavior. Thus, the finite-level exactness of CHSH and all one-sided tilted CHSH maxima does not extend to an exact finite-level description of the complete quantum set in the minimal scenario.