Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

LIEB-ROBINSON BOUNDS AND ENTANGLEMENT LIMITS IN QUANTUM DYNAMICS WITH INFINITE-DIMENSIONAL MEMORY: A SKETCH

Rajit Chatterjea

Published Jul 25, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In prior work by Mozumdar [1], a Lieb–Robinson-type bound for one-dimensional lat-tice systems evolving under discrete-time collision-model dynamics coupled to finite-dimensional,exponentially mixing bond memories was established.In this paper we see what survives when each bond memory is replaced by a separable, infinite-dimensional Hilbert space : the natural setting for physically realistic memory carriers such asbosonic modes, transmission-line resonators, or itinerant photonic pulses with a long but finitecoherence time. We show that the purely combinatorial, causal part of the finite-dimensionalargument (strict nearest-neighbor propagation, the light-cone counting bound) survives verbatim,since it never uses the dimension of the memory space. The mixing part of the argument doesnot survive verbatim: two structural facts used silently in the finite-dimensional proof : normequivalence on HM , and compactness of the unit ball of B(HM ) : fail in infinite dimensions, andboth are load-bearing. We introduce a weighted, energy-cutoff mixing hypothesis adapted from theopen-quantum-systems literature on Gaussian and quasi-free bosonic dynamics, show that it restoresa version of the memory-history contraction lemma, and sketch the resulting infinite-dimensionalLieb–Robinson bound. We flag precisely which steps are rigorous under the new hypothesis andwhich remain conjectural.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.21541187

Related papers

Lieb--Robinson Bounds and Entanglement Limits in Quantum Dynamics with Finite-Dimensional Memory

Jeet Mozumdar

We derive an extension of the Lieb--Robinson bound that accounts for memory effects in quantum lattice systems evolving under discrete-time non-Markovian dynamics generated by local interactions with finite-dimensional memory subsystems associated with each bond. The global evolution is unitary on an extended Hilbert space \[ \mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{ext}} = \bigotimes_{i=1}^{N} \mathcal{H}_i \otimes \bigotimes_{\text{bonds}} \mathcal{H}_M^{(i)}, \] while non-Markovian behavior, arising from repeated coupling to the same bond memory at successive time steps, leads to temporal correlations in the system. In this work, “finite memory” refers specifically to memory subsystems of fixed finite Hilbert space dimension whose reduced dynamics satisfy an exponential mixing condition in operator norm, meaning that correlation functions decay exponentially over time, with a characteristic timescale \(\tau\). More precisely, the memory channels satisfy \[ \left\| \mathcal{T}_M^s(X) - \mathrm{Tr}(X)\,\sigma_M \right\| \le c\, e^{-s/\tau}\, \|X\|, \] for all memory observables \(X\), where \(\sigma_M\) is a stationary state, and \(c>0\) depends only on the memory dynamics. For a one-dimensional lattice with nearest-neighbor interactions, we prove that the connected correlation function, defined as \[ C_{i,j}(t) := \sup_{\substack{A_i = A_i^\dagger,\; B_j = B_j^\dagger \\ \|A_i\|\le 1,\; \|B_j\|\le 1}} \left| \mathrm{Tr}\!\left[(A_i \otimes B_j)\rho(t)\right] - \mathrm{Tr}\!\left[A_i \rho_i(t)\right]\, \mathrm{Tr}\!\left[B_j \rho_j(t)\right] \right|, \] satisfies an exponential bound of the form \[ C_{i,j}(t) \le C_0 \exp\!\Big[-\frac{d(i,j) - v_{\mathrm{eff}}(\tau)\, t}{\xi}\Big], \] where \(d(i,j)=|i-j|\) and \(\xi>0\) is independent of system size and time. The effective velocity \(v_{\mathrm{eff}}(\tau)\) is explicitly bounded in terms of the local interaction strength and the memory mixing parameters, ensuring the system exhibits a finite light cone, meaning that information propagation is confined to a region growing linearly with time, with a well-defined maximum speed. In the limit \(\tau \to \infty\), the bound no longer guarantees a finite propagation speed, reflecting the transition to a persistent memory regime where correlations do not decay exponentially. As an operational consequence, the entanglement fidelity between two-site reduced states \(\rho_{i,j}(t)\) and a maximally entangled state satisfies \[ F_{i,j}(t) = \langle \Phi^+ | \rho_{i,j}(t) | \Phi^+ \rangle \le \tfrac{1}{2}\bigl[1 + C_{i,j}(t)\bigr]. \] These results extend Lieb--Robinson theory to a class of discrete-time quantum dynamics with memory subsystems associated with each bond, enabling resummation of multi-step memory effects into an effective correlation propagation kernel that governs the decay of temporal correlations. This establishes a quantitative relationship between the timescale of memory mixing and the effective speed of information propagation in the system.

•Apr 26, 2026•1 citation

Lieb-Robinson bound for one-dimensional continuum fermions

Marius Lemm, Hailun Lu, HARMAN PREET SINGH

The central difficulty in quantum many-body physics is that the Hilbert space dimension grows exponentially with the total degrees of freedom. A key feature to circumvent this problem is locality, which manifests dynamically through an approximate causal structure in the form of a Lieb-Robinson bound (LRB). LRBs have been proved for quantum spin systems and certain lattice boson systems, but so far never for realistic continuum systems. We present the first LRB that applies to a standard system of one-dimensional continuum fermions. It applies to initial states with controlled moments of local particle number and energy and is thus thermodynamically stable. Our result breaks the main technical barrier that has existed for using the vast locality toolbox on continuum systems.

arXiv:2611.11655•Nov 8, 2026•0 citations

Lieb-Robinson Light Cones in Long-Range Bosonic Systems

Carla Rubiliani, Cheng Shang, Tomotaka Kuwahara

Lieb-Robinson bounds formulate emergent causality in quantum many-body dynamics. In this Letter, we study interacting bosonic systems with long-range interactions, in which both the standard assumptions of short-range interactions and uniformly bounded local energy scales are absent. We derive upper and lower bounds whose effective light-cone exponents are governed by a nontrivial interplay between the decay exponent $α$ and the bosonic interaction order $p$. The propagation protocol concentrates bosons within blocks, creating a mediating sublattice with amplified interactions. For $p\ge4$ and $2d<α\le2d+1$, the resulting exponents coincide, determining the optimal leading light-cone power. The upper bound includes $α=2d+1$ with arbitrarily small exponent loss, using a fixed-$k$ extension of the bounded-interaction result. Our results reveal that the interplay between long-range couplings and unbounded bosonic degrees of freedom gives rise to a richer light-cone structure than in either long-range bounded systems or short-range bosonic systems alone.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2611.00776•Nov 3, 2026•1 citation

Light-cones in many-body open quantum systems with memory

Xie-Hang Yu, Mark Spencer Rudner, Rahul Trivedi

Memory effects in many-body quantum systems interacting with an environment significantly impact their behavior. Nevertheless, much of our understanding of many-body open quantum systems is based on models within the Born-Markov approximation where these effects are neglected. In this paper, we consider a general class of spatially local open quantum lattice models with a non-Markovian environment that is approximated as Gaussian. Our main result is a set of Lieb-Robinson bounds for such models. For models where the environment has independent local baths, we show that the Lieb-Robinson velocity is controlled by one-norm of the memory kernel within the evolution time-interval, yielding a linear light cone whenever the memory kernel has a bounded one-norm. For models where excitations can propagate through the environment, we prove a polynomial light cone that captures bath-mediated acceleration of information spreading. In both of these cases, we show that the derived Lieb-Robinson bounds are tight by also constructing lattice models saturating these bounds. Finally, we consider the problem of approximating a non-Markovian model by a larger Markovian model, which contains the system spins together with only a finite number of bosonic environment modes. We establish that as a consequence of our Lieb-Robinson bounds, the number of environment modes {per system site} needed to accurately capture local observables is independent of the size of the system.

arXiv:2410.15481•Oct 20, 2024•10 citations

From Local Forgetting to Spatial Attenuation? Reference-Stable Contraction in Partial-SWAP Collision Models.

Jeet Mozumdar

We study whether local forgetting in finite-dimensional quantum memory can be composed into attenuation of information across a network. We first prove a reference-stable contraction for repeated partial-SWAP collisions between a system qubit and a memory qubit that is depolarized between collisions: for two joint system--reference states with the same reference marginal, the trace distance contracts over a two-collision block by a factor at most $1-\epsilon$, with $\epsilon=(1-\lambda)^2\sin^2(2\theta)$, uniformly in the reference system and its dimension. This estimate cannot simply be iterated across a branching structure, because the reference marginals required by the hypothesis are not preserved after the first stage. We therefore analyse one explicit branching channel ($\theta=\pi/8$, $\lambda=4/5$) through its numerically recorded Pauli transfer tensor and derive conditional exponential attenuation bounds with rate at most about $0.73$ per generation. These bounds are conditional on the correctness of the recorded transfer tensor and on a depth-three base case. Both have numerical support, but neither has yet been rigorously certified. We also prove, unconditionally, a single-path lower bound showing that the contraction coefficient of the depth-$r$ channel is at least $g^r$ with $g\approx0.68$. The channel is nearly single-path, so it only weakly tests composition, and we identify the missing ingredients for a discriminating test: symmetric children and reuse of memory. A final section reports finite-chain numerical diagnostics and a conjectured probe-mean formula for a reused-memory model; no theorem is claimed there. No Lieb--Robinson-type or spatial attenuation bound is established. Relationship to the Earlier Preprint The present work develops a substantially revised research program building on the earlier preprint, Lieb–Robinson Bounds and Entanglement Limits in Quantum Dynamics with Finite-Dimensional Memory, published on Zenodo on April 26, 2026. The earlier manuscript proposed a general memory-dependent Lieb–Robinson bound, including an effective propagation velocity and associated correlation estimates. The current work replaces that proposed theorem-level result with a mathematically established local result: reference-stable trace-distance contraction under repeated partial-SWAP collisions with depolarized finite-dimensional memory. Beyond this local result, the manuscript investigates whether such contraction can be composed into spatial attenuation. A branching-channel transfer-tensor framework is developed, with attenuation estimates stated conditionally on outstanding verification requirements. A separate shared-memory extension remains exploratory. The distinction between established, conditional, numerical, and conjectural results is made explicit throughout. In particular, the present manuscript does not claim to establish a general Lieb–Robinson-type or spatial attenuation bound. The overarching research question—whether local reference-stable forgetting can be composed into a general spatial attenuation bound for coupled system–memory networks—remains open.

•Nov 10, 2026•0 citations

Tightening the Lieb-Robinson Bound in Locally Interacting Systems

Zhiyuan Wang, Kaden R. A. Hazzard

The Lieb-Robinson (LR) bound rigorously shows that in quantum systems with short-range interactions, the maximum amount of information that travels beyond an effective "light cone" decays exponentially with distance from the light-cone front, which expands at finite velocity.Despite being a fundamental result, existing bounds are often extremely loose, limiting their applications.We introduce a method that dramatically and qualitatively improves LR bounds in models with finite-range interactions.Most prominently, in systems with a large local Hilbert space dimension D, our method gives a LR velocity that grows much slower than previous bounds with D as D → ∞.For example, in the Heisenberg model with spin S, we find v ≤ const.compared to the previous v ∝ S, which diverges at large S, and in multiorbital Hubbard models with N orbitals, we find v ∝ √ N instead of previous v ∝ N , and similarly in the Nstate truncated Bose-Hubbard model and Wen's quantum rotor model.Our bounds also scale qualitatively better in some systems when the spatial dimension or certain model parameters become large, for example in the d-dimensional quantum Ising model and perturbed toric code models.Even in spin-1/2 Ising and Fermi-Hubbard models, our method improves the LR velocity by an order of magnitude with typical model parameters, and significantly improves the LR bound at large distance and early time.

arXiv:1908.03997•PRX Quantum•Sep 3, 2020•69 citations
In prior work by Mozumdar [1], a Lieb–Robinson-type bound for one-dimensional lat-tice systems evolving under discrete-time collision-model dynamics coupled to finite-dimensional,exponentially mixing bond memories was established.In this paper we see what survives when each bond memory is replaced by a separable, infinite-dimensional Hilbert space : the natural setting for physically realistic memory carriers such asbosonic modes, transmission-line resonators, or itinerant photonic pulses with a long but finitecoherence time. We show that the purely combinatorial, causal part of the finite-dimensionalargument (strict nearest-neighbor propagation, the light-cone counting bound) survives verbatim,since it never uses the dimension of the memory space. The mixing part of the argument doesnot survive verbatim: two structural facts used silently in the finite-dimensional proof : normequivalence on HM , and compactness of the unit ball of B(HM ) : fail in infinite dimensions, andboth are load-bearing. We introduce a weighted, energy-cutoff mixing hypothesis adapted from theopen-quantum-systems literature on Gaussian and quasi-free bosonic dynamics, show that it restoresa version of the memory-history contraction lemma, and sketch the resulting infinite-dimensionalLieb–Robinson bound. We flag precisely which steps are rigorous under the new hypothesis andwhich remain conjectural.
We derive an extension of the Lieb--Robinson bound that accounts for memory effects in quantum lattice systems evolving under discrete-time non-Markovian dynamics generated by local interactions with finite-dimensional memory subsystems associated with each bond. The global evolution is unitary on an extended Hilbert space Hext=⨂i=1NHi⊗⨂bondsHM(i), \mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{ext}} = \bigotimes_{i=1}^{N} \mathcal{H}_i \otimes \bigotimes_{\text{bonds}} \mathcal{H}_M^{(i)}, Hext​=⨂i=1N​Hi​⊗⨂bonds​HM(i)​, while non-Markovian behavior, arising from repeated coupling to the same bond memory at successive time steps, leads to temporal correlations in the system. In this work, “finite memory” refers specifically to memory subsystems of fixed finite Hilbert space dimension whose reduced dynamics satisfy an exponential mixing condition in operator norm, meaning that correlation functions decay exponentially over time, with a characteristic timescale τ\tauτ. More precisely, the memory channels satisfy ∥TMs(X)−Tr(X) σM∥≤c e−s/τ ∥X∥, \left\| \mathcal{T}_M^s(X) - \mathrm{Tr}(X)\,\sigma_M \right\| \le c\, e^{-s/\tau}\, \|X\|, ∥TMs​(X)−Tr(X)σM​∥≤ce−s/τ∥X∥, for all memory observables XXX, where σM\sigma_MσM​ is a stationary state, and c>0c>0c>0 depends only on the memory dynamics. For a one-dimensional lattice with nearest-neighbor interactions, we prove that the connected correlation function, defined as Ci,j(t):=sup⁡Ai=Ai†,Bj=Bj†∥Ai∥≤1,∥Bj∥≤1∣Tr ⁣[(Ai⊗Bj)ρ(t)]−Tr ⁣[Aiρi(t)] Tr ⁣[Bjρj(t)]∣, C_{i,j}(t) := \sup_{\substack{A_i = A_i^\dagger,\; B_j = B_j^\dagger \\ \|A_i\|\le 1,\; \|B_j\|\le 1}} \left| \mathrm{Tr}\!\left[(A_i \otimes B_j)\rho(t)\right] - \mathrm{Tr}\!\left[A_i \rho_i(t)\right]\, \mathrm{Tr}\!\left[B_j \rho_j(t)\right] \right|, Ci,j​(t):=supAi​=Ai†​,Bj​=Bj†​∥Ai​∥≤1,∥Bj​∥≤1​​∣Tr[(Ai​⊗Bj​)ρ(t)]−Tr[Ai​ρi​(t)]Tr[Bj​ρj​(t)]∣, satisfies an exponential bound of the form Ci,j(t)≤C0exp⁡ ⁣[−d(i,j)−veff(τ) tξ], C_{i,j}(t) \le C_0 \exp\!\Big[-\frac{d(i,j) - v_{\mathrm{eff}}(\tau)\, t}{\xi}\Big], Ci,j​(t)≤C0​exp[−ξd(i,j)−veff​(τ)t​], where d(i,j)=∣i−j∣d(i,j)=|i-j|d(i,j)=∣i−j∣ and ξ>0\xi>0ξ>0 is independent of system size and time. The effective velocity veff(τ)v_{\mathrm{eff}}(\tau)veff​(τ) is explicitly bounded in terms of the local interaction strength and the memory mixing parameters, ensuring the system exhibits a finite light cone, meaning that information propagation is confined to a region growing linearly with time, with a well-defined maximum speed. In the limit τ→∞\tau \to \inftyτ→∞, the bound no longer guarantees a finite propagation speed, reflecting the transition to a persistent memory regime where correlations do not decay exponentially. As an operational consequence, the entanglement fidelity between two-site reduced states ρi,j(t)\rho_{i,j}(t)ρi,j​(t) and a maximally entangled state satisfies Fi,j(t)=⟨Φ+∣ρi,j(t)∣Φ+⟩≤12[1+Ci,j(t)]. F_{i,j}(t) = \langle \Phi^+ | \rho_{i,j}(t) | \Phi^+ \rangle \le \tfrac{1}{2}\bigl[1 + C_{i,j}(t)\bigr]. Fi,j​(t)=⟨Φ+∣ρi,j​(t)∣Φ+⟩≤21​[1+Ci,j​(t)]. These results extend Lieb--Robinson theory to a class of discrete-time quantum dynamics with memory subsystems associated with each bond, enabling resummation of multi-step memory effects into an effective correlation propagation kernel that governs the decay of temporal correlations. This establishes a quantitative relationship between the timescale of memory mixing and the effective speed of information propagation in the system.
The central difficulty in quantum many-body physics is that the Hilbert space dimension grows exponentially with the total degrees of freedom. A key feature to circumvent this problem is locality, which manifests dynamically through an approximate causal structure in the form of a Lieb-Robinson bound (LRB). LRBs have been proved for quantum spin systems and certain lattice boson systems, but so far never for realistic continuum systems. We present the first LRB that applies to a standard system of one-dimensional continuum fermions. It applies to initial states with controlled moments of local particle number and energy and is thus thermodynamically stable. Our result breaks the main technical barrier that has existed for using the vast locality toolbox on continuum systems.
Lieb-Robinson bounds formulate emergent causality in quantum many-body dynamics. In this Letter, we study interacting bosonic systems with long-range interactions, in which both the standard assumptions of short-range interactions and uniformly bounded local energy scales are absent. We derive upper and lower bounds whose effective light-cone exponents are governed by a nontrivial interplay between the decay exponent ααα and the bosonic interaction order ppp. The propagation protocol concentrates bosons within blocks, creating a mediating sublattice with amplified interactions. For p≥4p\ge4p≥4 and 2d<α≤2d+12d<α\le2d+12d<α≤2d+1, the resulting exponents coincide, determining the optimal leading light-cone power. The upper bound includes α=2d+1α=2d+1α=2d+1 with arbitrarily small exponent loss, using a fixed-kkk extension of the bounded-interaction result. Our results reveal that the interplay between long-range couplings and unbounded bosonic degrees of freedom gives rise to a richer light-cone structure than in either long-range bounded systems or short-range bosonic systems alone.
Memory effects in many-body quantum systems interacting with an environment significantly impact their behavior. Nevertheless, much of our understanding of many-body open quantum systems is based on models within the Born-Markov approximation where these effects are neglected. In this paper, we consider a general class of spatially local open quantum lattice models with a non-Markovian environment that is approximated as Gaussian. Our main result is a set of Lieb-Robinson bounds for such models. For models where the environment has independent local baths, we show that the Lieb-Robinson velocity is controlled by one-norm of the memory kernel within the evolution time-interval, yielding a linear light cone whenever the memory kernel has a bounded one-norm. For models where excitations can propagate through the environment, we prove a polynomial light cone that captures bath-mediated acceleration of information spreading. In both of these cases, we show that the derived Lieb-Robinson bounds are tight by also constructing lattice models saturating these bounds. Finally, we consider the problem of approximating a non-Markovian model by a larger Markovian model, which contains the system spins together with only a finite number of bosonic environment modes. We establish that as a consequence of our Lieb-Robinson bounds, the number of environment modes {per system site} needed to accurately capture local observables is independent of the size of the system.
We study whether local forgetting in finite-dimensional quantum memory can be composed into attenuation of information across a network. We first prove a reference-stable contraction for repeated partial-SWAP collisions between a system qubit and a memory qubit that is depolarized between collisions: for two joint system--reference states with the same reference marginal, the trace distance contracts over a two-collision block by a factor at most 1−ϵ1-\epsilon1−ϵ, with ϵ=(1−λ)2sin⁡2(2θ)\epsilon=(1-\lambda)^2\sin^2(2\theta)ϵ=(1−λ)2sin2(2θ), uniformly in the reference system and its dimension. This estimate cannot simply be iterated across a branching structure, because the reference marginals required by the hypothesis are not preserved after the first stage. We therefore analyse one explicit branching channel (θ=π/8\theta=\pi/8θ=π/8, λ=4/5\lambda=4/5λ=4/5) through its numerically recorded Pauli transfer tensor and derive conditional exponential attenuation bounds with rate at most about 0.730.730.73 per generation. These bounds are conditional on the correctness of the recorded transfer tensor and on a depth-three base case. Both have numerical support, but neither has yet been rigorously certified. We also prove, unconditionally, a single-path lower bound showing that the contraction coefficient of the depth-rrr channel is at least grg^rgr with g≈0.68g\approx0.68g≈0.68. The channel is nearly single-path, so it only weakly tests composition, and we identify the missing ingredients for a discriminating test: symmetric children and reuse of memory. A final section reports finite-chain numerical diagnostics and a conjectured probe-mean formula for a reused-memory model; no theorem is claimed there. No Lieb--Robinson-type or spatial attenuation bound is established. Relationship to the Earlier Preprint The present work develops a substantially revised research program building on the earlier preprint, Lieb–Robinson Bounds and Entanglement Limits in Quantum Dynamics with Finite-Dimensional Memory, published on Zenodo on April 26, 2026. The earlier manuscript proposed a general memory-dependent Lieb–Robinson bound, including an effective propagation velocity and associated correlation estimates. The current work replaces that proposed theorem-level result with a mathematically established local result: reference-stable trace-distance contraction under repeated partial-SWAP collisions with depolarized finite-dimensional memory. Beyond this local result, the manuscript investigates whether such contraction can be composed into spatial attenuation. A branching-channel transfer-tensor framework is developed, with attenuation estimates stated conditionally on outstanding verification requirements. A separate shared-memory extension remains exploratory. The distinction between established, conditional, numerical, and conjectural results is made explicit throughout. In particular, the present manuscript does not claim to establish a general Lieb–Robinson-type or spatial attenuation bound. The overarching research question—whether local reference-stable forgetting can be composed into a general spatial attenuation bound for coupled system–memory networks—remains open.
The Lieb-Robinson (LR) bound rigorously shows that in quantum systems with short-range interactions, the maximum amount of information that travels beyond an effective "light cone" decays exponentially with distance from the light-cone front, which expands at finite velocity.Despite being a fundamental result, existing bounds are often extremely loose, limiting their applications.We introduce a method that dramatically and qualitatively improves LR bounds in models with finite-range interactions.Most prominently, in systems with a large local Hilbert space dimension D, our method gives a LR velocity that grows much slower than previous bounds with D as D → ∞.For example, in the Heisenberg model with spin S, we find v ≤ const.compared to the previous v ∝ S, which diverges at large S, and in multiorbital Hubbard models with N orbitals, we find v ∝ √ N instead of previous v ∝ N , and similarly in the Nstate truncated Bose-Hubbard model and Wen's quantum rotor model.Our bounds also scale qualitatively better in some systems when the spatial dimension or certain model parameters become large, for example in the d-dimensional quantum Ising model and perturbed toric code models.Even in spin-1/2 Ising and Fermi-Hubbard models, our method improves the LR velocity by an order of magnitude with typical model parameters, and significantly improves the LR bound at large distance and early time.