Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Joint State-Law Fixed Points in Quantum Theory: Recursive Dynamics, Bifurcations, and Renormalization-Group Deformations

Kwan Hong TAN

Published Jul 23, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This article develops a joint state-law fixed-point method for self-consistent quantum models. A physical model is represented by a density operator and a finite-dimensional vector of effective law parameters; admissible dynamics consist of a state-update channel and a law-update map. A recursive solution is their joint fixed point. This formulation separates stationarity of a state-dependent Hamiltonian from genuine co-determination of states and laws and preserves the option of completely positive trace-preserving subsystem dynamics. Three general results are obtained: existence for continuous maps on compact convex state-law domains, uniqueness and iterative stability under a contraction condition, and persistence of non-degenerate fixed points under weak deformation. An exactly solvable two-state model displays a supercritical pitchfork bifurcation, critical exponent one-half, and a divergent zero-field susceptibility at the feedback threshold. In renormalization-group theory space, the same perturbative result yields first-order shifts of fixed-point coordinates and critical exponents. An action-level construction shows how recursive consistency operators can enter the standard functional flow without adding ad hoc terms to the Wetterich equation. Covariant gravity and laboratory phase-shift formulas are presented as conditional templates whose predictions require a specified kernel and normalization. The framework therefore contributes a broadly applicable method linking quantum channels, nonlinear dynamics, fixed-point theory, and renormalization-group deformations, while making no claim to a completed theory of quantum gravity.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.21505328

Related papers

A Unified Theory of Characteristic Equations for the Renormalization Group: From Critical Phenomena to Quantum Gravity and Information Theory

shifa liu

This paper establishes a comprehensive, rigorous, and unified theory of characteristic equations for the renormalization group (RG). Extending the methodology developed in companion works on knot theory and fluid mechanics, we formulate the RG flow as a dynamical system on an infinite-dimensional theory space and demonstrate that the linearized RG operator L at a fixed point gives rise to a universal characteristic equation det(L − λI) = 0, whose eigenvalues λn determine all critical exponents, scaling laws, relaxation rates, and oscillation frequencies of the system. We prove that the RG flow is a semi-group, that its fixed points correspond to critical theories, and that the characteristic spectrum is invariant under S-duality. We derive rigorous characteristic equations for ϕ4 theory, Gross-Neveu models, quantum electrodynamics, holographic RG, and asymptotically safe gravity. We establish variational principles, topological extensions with θ-angles, non-equilibrium Keldysh-RG, information-theoretic entropy production, and connections to tensor networks, quantum computing, and machine learning. We prove a completeness theorem: any RG flow can be uniquely decomposed into a superposition of characteristic eigenmodes. The theory is then elevated to a Grothendieck topos, providing the ultimate mathematical foundation. Numerical predictions are systematically compared with experimental data, achieving agreement within 0.1% for the 3D Ising model, 3D XY model, superfluid helium, and QCD coupling constant. The theory is closed under the most general mathematical framework known: the internal logic of the RG Characteristic Topos. Furthermore, a completeness theorem (Theorem 22.13) establishes that the characteristic equation fully determines the RG equivalence class of any system, and the internal logic of the topos is self-referential closed (Theorem 22.16), ensuring that the entire theory is both externally and internally consistent. Three previously open constructive problems — the non-perturbative holographic inverse problem, the entropy–black hole entropy equivalence, and the CMB non-Gaussianity inverse problem — are resolved explicitly as Theorems 23.2–23.4, thereby completing the constructive aspects of the theory. The three constructive resolutions are mutually consistent within the topos-theoretic framework: the holographic inverse problem (Theorem 23.2) provides the spectral input for the entropy–black hole equivalence (Theorem 23.3), while the CMB non-Gaussianity formula (Theorem 23.4) reduces to the standard slow-roll result as a direct consequence of the characteristic spectrum. The consistency is formally established in Theorem 23.5. Thus the theory is now complete at all levels: mathematical foundations (topos, spectral theory), constructive algorithms (inverse problems, quantum simulation), and observational predictions.

•Dec 31, 2025•0 citations

Renormalization flows for 1D mixed states and a quantum Goursat lemma

Léo Le-Nestour, David Pérez-García, Alberto Ruiz-de-Alarcón

Renormalization provides a framework for relating microscopic models of physical systems to effective descriptions at larger length scales. This procedure is studied for the boundary states of non-chiral two-dimensional topologically ordered models. The initial data consist of renormalization fixed points built from representations of finite-dimensional $C^*$-Hopf algebras, which are then perturbed by uniform on-site noise quantum channels and repeatedly coarse-grained. The resulting flows admit an intrinsic algebraic description in terms of completely positive maps on the $C^*$-Hopf algebra or, equivalently, positive linear functionals on its enveloping $C^*$-Hopf algebra. Their iteration is governed by convolution powers, and convergent trajectories yield new matrix product density operator fixed points, described by finite $*$-quantum hypergroups. This provides a concrete physical interpretation of such structures. For finite group algebras and their duals, we provide explicit classifications via Goursat's lemma for groups. Finally, we formulate and prove a quantum generalization of Goursat's lemma for finite-dimensional $C^*$-Hopf algebras, a result of independent interest, which gives an explicit structural description of all convergent renormalization trajectories.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2607.08568•Jul 10, 2026•0 citations

Renormalization-group study of the fixed points and of their stability for phase transitions with four-component order parameters

J. C. Tolédano, Louis Michel, P. Tolédano +1 more

The renormalization-group recursion relations are solved for the effective Hamiltonians relative to phase transitions with four-component order parameters. For this value of n there are 22 types of Hamiltonians which can be classified into two categories according to the action of their normalizer ${G}_{N}$ on the corresponding parameter space (${G}_{N}$ is the symmetry group leaving globally invariant this space). In the first case, ${G}_{N}$ generates a finite number of isolated fixed points whose characteristics can be deduced from the detailed investigation of five Hamiltonians only.In the second category, for which ${G}_{N}$ is a continuous group, there are, in addition to isolated fixed points, continuous manifolds of physically equivalent fixed points (the dimension of the manifolds is either one or three). In the search for a stable fixed point, the continuous manifolds can be ignored, while the isolated points are related to the five former Hamiltonians. For n=4, it is necessary to solve the recursion relations to two-loop order. The only possible stable ones among the fixed points then arise from a splitting of points which coincide, to one-loop order, with the isotropic fixed point. Extending, to two-loop order, a result recently established to the preceding order, we show that if a stable fixed point exists, it is unique. For n=4, the stable fixed point has one of three possible symmetries : di-icosahedral, hypercubic, or dicylindrical.Despite this anisotropy of the critical fluctuations, the exponents associated with any of the stable fixed points are identical to order ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}$ to the ``isotropic'' exponents corresponding to n=4. The cubic point is destabilized by any operator of symmetry lower than cubic. The dicylindrical one remains stable with respect to certain anisotropies of lower symmetry. We examine the available experimental data in light of the preceding theoretical results concerning the critical behavior and the thermodynamic order of the transitions. On the other hand, we establish two general symmetry conditions relative to the stable fixed points determined by the renormalization-group equations. The first one specifies group theoretically, for each value of n, the possible symmetries ${G}_{i}^{\mathrm{*}}$ of the stable fixed points. The second one formulates a necessary condition for the occurrence of an anisotropic stable fixed point: The normalizer ${G}_{N}$ of the considered parameter space must fulfill the condition ${G}_{N}$\ensuremath{\subset}@;${\mathrm{BG}}_{i}^{\mathrm{*}}$ for one, at least, of the former ${G}_{i}^{\mathrm{*}}$ groups. These rules are shown to be very restrictive for n=4: On the basis of symmetry the lack of a stable fixed point can be asserted for 10 Hamiltonians out of 22, without solving the fixed-point equations.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jun 1, 1985•71 citations

Lectures on the functional renormalization group method

János Polonyi

Abstract These introductory notes are about functional renormalization group equations and some of their applications. It is emphasised that the applicability of this method extends well beyond critical systems, it actually provides us a general purpose algorithm to solve strongly coupled quantum field theories. The renormalization group equation of F. Wegner and A. Houghton is shown to resum the loop-expansion. Another version, due to J. Polchinski, is obtained by the method of collective coordinates and can be used for the resummation of the perturbation series. The genuinely non-perturbative evolution equation is obtained by a manner reminiscent of the Schwinger-Dyson equations. Two variants of this scheme are presented where the scale which determines the order of the successive elimination of the modes is extracted from external and internal spaces. The renormalization of composite operators is discussed briefly as an alternative way to arrive at the renormalization group equation. The scaling laws and fixed points are considered from local and global points of view. Instability induced renormalization and new scaling laws are shown to occur in the symmetry broken phase of the scaler theory. The flattening of the effective potential of a compact variable is demonstrated in case of the sine-Gordon model. Finally, a manifestly gauge invariant evolution equation is given for QED.

arXiv:hep-th/0110026•Open Physics•Jan 1, 2003•330 citations

Fixed-Point Hamiltonians in Quantum Mechanics

T. Frederico, A. Delfino, Lauro Tomio D +1 more

We show how to derive fixed-point Hamiltonians in quantum mechanics from a proposed renormalization group invariance approach that relies in a subtraction procedure at a given energy scale. The scheme is valid for arbitrary interactions that originally contain point-like singularities (as the Dirac-delta and/or its derivatives). One example of diagonalization of a fixed-point Hamiltonian illustrates the procedure for an interaction that contains regular and singular parts. In another example, the fixed point Hamiltonian is derived for the case of higher order singularities in the interaction.

arXiv:hep-ph/0101065•Jan 8, 2001•10 citations

When Does State-Law Co-Determination Have Physical Content? Fixed-Point Representations, No-Signalling, and Model Discrimination

Kwan Hong TAN

Proposals that physical states and laws jointly determine one another are often presented through fixed-point equations. Yet any ordinary fixed-law theory can be rewritten in joint fixed-point form by adding a constant law-update map. Fixed-point form alone therefore carries neither empirical content nor a distinctive metaphysics. This article turns that objection into a constructive philosophy-of-physics programme. First, it proves a trivial-embedding result and identifies six non-vacuity conditions for substantive state-law co-determination: non-constant physical dependence, representation invariance, counterfactual rigidity, compositional closure, recovery of a declared baseline, and cross-context discriminability. Second, it extends the existence question beyond finite-dimensional compactness by formulating a conditional weak-* fixed-point result on the state space of a unital C*-algebra. Third, it supplies an explicit bipartite quantum-statistical model in which a correlation-dependent law parameter is selected jointly with a Gibbs state. The model has a complete tensor-product rule, an exact bifurcation condition, and a no-signalling operational stage based on local completely positive trace-preserving maps. Finally, it shows how empirical content arises only when one law-selection parameter must compress observations across multiple intervention contexts; a single context remains observationally equivalent to a fixed-law description. The resulting account replaces the metaphor of a “recursive universe” with a more disciplined claim: state-law closure is scientifically meaningful only when it imposes invariant, compositional, and risky relations across possible experiments.

•Jul 29, 2026•0 citations
This article develops a joint state-law fixed-point method for self-consistent quantum models. A physical model is represented by a density operator and a finite-dimensional vector of effective law parameters; admissible dynamics consist of a state-update channel and a law-update map. A recursive solution is their joint fixed point. This formulation separates stationarity of a state-dependent Hamiltonian from genuine co-determination of states and laws and preserves the option of completely positive trace-preserving subsystem dynamics. Three general results are obtained: existence for continuous maps on compact convex state-law domains, uniqueness and iterative stability under a contraction condition, and persistence of non-degenerate fixed points under weak deformation. An exactly solvable two-state model displays a supercritical pitchfork bifurcation, critical exponent one-half, and a divergent zero-field susceptibility at the feedback threshold. In renormalization-group theory space, the same perturbative result yields first-order shifts of fixed-point coordinates and critical exponents. An action-level construction shows how recursive consistency operators can enter the standard functional flow without adding ad hoc terms to the Wetterich equation. Covariant gravity and laboratory phase-shift formulas are presented as conditional templates whose predictions require a specified kernel and normalization. The framework therefore contributes a broadly applicable method linking quantum channels, nonlinear dynamics, fixed-point theory, and renormalization-group deformations, while making no claim to a completed theory of quantum gravity.
This paper establishes a comprehensive, rigorous, and unified theory of characteristic equations for the renormalization group (RG). Extending the methodology developed in companion works on knot theory and fluid mechanics, we formulate the RG flow as a dynamical system on an infinite-dimensional theory space and demonstrate that the linearized RG operator L at a fixed point gives rise to a universal characteristic equation det(L − λI) = 0, whose eigenvalues λn determine all critical exponents, scaling laws, relaxation rates, and oscillation frequencies of the system. We prove that the RG flow is a semi-group, that its fixed points correspond to critical theories, and that the characteristic spectrum is invariant under S-duality. We derive rigorous characteristic equations for ϕ4 theory, Gross-Neveu models, quantum electrodynamics, holographic RG, and asymptotically safe gravity. We establish variational principles, topological extensions with θ-angles, non-equilibrium Keldysh-RG, information-theoretic entropy production, and connections to tensor networks, quantum computing, and machine learning. We prove a completeness theorem: any RG flow can be uniquely decomposed into a superposition of characteristic eigenmodes. The theory is then elevated to a Grothendieck topos, providing the ultimate mathematical foundation. Numerical predictions are systematically compared with experimental data, achieving agreement within 0.1% for the 3D Ising model, 3D XY model, superfluid helium, and QCD coupling constant. The theory is closed under the most general mathematical framework known: the internal logic of the RG Characteristic Topos. Furthermore, a completeness theorem (Theorem 22.13) establishes that the characteristic equation fully determines the RG equivalence class of any system, and the internal logic of the topos is self-referential closed (Theorem 22.16), ensuring that the entire theory is both externally and internally consistent. Three previously open constructive problems — the non-perturbative holographic inverse problem, the entropy–black hole entropy equivalence, and the CMB non-Gaussianity inverse problem — are resolved explicitly as Theorems 23.2–23.4, thereby completing the constructive aspects of the theory. The three constructive resolutions are mutually consistent within the topos-theoretic framework: the holographic inverse problem (Theorem 23.2) provides the spectral input for the entropy–black hole equivalence (Theorem 23.3), while the CMB non-Gaussianity formula (Theorem 23.4) reduces to the standard slow-roll result as a direct consequence of the characteristic spectrum. The consistency is formally established in Theorem 23.5. Thus the theory is now complete at all levels: mathematical foundations (topos, spectral theory), constructive algorithms (inverse problems, quantum simulation), and observational predictions.
Renormalization provides a framework for relating microscopic models of physical systems to effective descriptions at larger length scales. This procedure is studied for the boundary states of non-chiral two-dimensional topologically ordered models. The initial data consist of renormalization fixed points built from representations of finite-dimensional C∗C^*C∗-Hopf algebras, which are then perturbed by uniform on-site noise quantum channels and repeatedly coarse-grained. The resulting flows admit an intrinsic algebraic description in terms of completely positive maps on the C∗C^*C∗-Hopf algebra or, equivalently, positive linear functionals on its enveloping C∗C^*C∗-Hopf algebra. Their iteration is governed by convolution powers, and convergent trajectories yield new matrix product density operator fixed points, described by finite ∗*∗-quantum hypergroups. This provides a concrete physical interpretation of such structures. For finite group algebras and their duals, we provide explicit classifications via Goursat's lemma for groups. Finally, we formulate and prove a quantum generalization of Goursat's lemma for finite-dimensional C∗C^*C∗-Hopf algebras, a result of independent interest, which gives an explicit structural description of all convergent renormalization trajectories.
The renormalization-group recursion relations are solved for the effective Hamiltonians relative to phase transitions with four-component order parameters. For this value of n there are 22 types of Hamiltonians which can be classified into two categories according to the action of their normalizer GN{G}_{N}GN​ on the corresponding parameter space (GN{G}_{N}GN​ is the symmetry group leaving globally invariant this space). In the first case, GN{G}_{N}GN​ generates a finite number of isolated fixed points whose characteristics can be deduced from the detailed investigation of five Hamiltonians only.In the second category, for which GN{G}_{N}GN​ is a continuous group, there are, in addition to isolated fixed points, continuous manifolds of physically equivalent fixed points (the dimension of the manifolds is either one or three). In the search for a stable fixed point, the continuous manifolds can be ignored, while the isolated points are related to the five former Hamiltonians. For n=4, it is necessary to solve the recursion relations to two-loop order. The only possible stable ones among the fixed points then arise from a splitting of points which coincide, to one-loop order, with the isotropic fixed point. Extending, to two-loop order, a result recently established to the preceding order, we show that if a stable fixed point exists, it is unique. For n=4, the stable fixed point has one of three possible symmetries : di-icosahedral, hypercubic, or dicylindrical.Despite this anisotropy of the critical fluctuations, the exponents associated with any of the stable fixed points are identical to order ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}$ to the ``isotropic'' exponents corresponding to n=4. The cubic point is destabilized by any operator of symmetry lower than cubic. The dicylindrical one remains stable with respect to certain anisotropies of lower symmetry. We examine the available experimental data in light of the preceding theoretical results concerning the critical behavior and the thermodynamic order of the transitions. On the other hand, we establish two general symmetry conditions relative to the stable fixed points determined by the renormalization-group equations. The first one specifies group theoretically, for each value of n, the possible symmetries Gi∗{G}_{i}^{\mathrm{*}}Gi∗​ of the stable fixed points. The second one formulates a necessary condition for the occurrence of an anisotropic stable fixed point: The normalizer GN{G}_{N}GN​ of the considered parameter space must fulfill the condition GN{G}_{N}GN​\ensuremath{\subset}@;BGi∗{\mathrm{BG}}_{i}^{\mathrm{*}}BGi∗​ for one, at least, of the former Gi∗{G}_{i}^{\mathrm{*}}Gi∗​ groups. These rules are shown to be very restrictive for n=4: On the basis of symmetry the lack of a stable fixed point can be asserted for 10 Hamiltonians out of 22, without solving the fixed-point equations.
Abstract These introductory notes are about functional renormalization group equations and some of their applications. It is emphasised that the applicability of this method extends well beyond critical systems, it actually provides us a general purpose algorithm to solve strongly coupled quantum field theories. The renormalization group equation of F. Wegner and A. Houghton is shown to resum the loop-expansion. Another version, due to J. Polchinski, is obtained by the method of collective coordinates and can be used for the resummation of the perturbation series. The genuinely non-perturbative evolution equation is obtained by a manner reminiscent of the Schwinger-Dyson equations. Two variants of this scheme are presented where the scale which determines the order of the successive elimination of the modes is extracted from external and internal spaces. The renormalization of composite operators is discussed briefly as an alternative way to arrive at the renormalization group equation. The scaling laws and fixed points are considered from local and global points of view. Instability induced renormalization and new scaling laws are shown to occur in the symmetry broken phase of the scaler theory. The flattening of the effective potential of a compact variable is demonstrated in case of the sine-Gordon model. Finally, a manifestly gauge invariant evolution equation is given for QED.
We show how to derive fixed-point Hamiltonians in quantum mechanics from a proposed renormalization group invariance approach that relies in a subtraction procedure at a given energy scale. The scheme is valid for arbitrary interactions that originally contain point-like singularities (as the Dirac-delta and/or its derivatives). One example of diagonalization of a fixed-point Hamiltonian illustrates the procedure for an interaction that contains regular and singular parts. In another example, the fixed point Hamiltonian is derived for the case of higher order singularities in the interaction.
Proposals that physical states and laws jointly determine one another are often presented through fixed-point equations. Yet any ordinary fixed-law theory can be rewritten in joint fixed-point form by adding a constant law-update map. Fixed-point form alone therefore carries neither empirical content nor a distinctive metaphysics. This article turns that objection into a constructive philosophy-of-physics programme. First, it proves a trivial-embedding result and identifies six non-vacuity conditions for substantive state-law co-determination: non-constant physical dependence, representation invariance, counterfactual rigidity, compositional closure, recovery of a declared baseline, and cross-context discriminability. Second, it extends the existence question beyond finite-dimensional compactness by formulating a conditional weak-* fixed-point result on the state space of a unital C*-algebra. Third, it supplies an explicit bipartite quantum-statistical model in which a correlation-dependent law parameter is selected jointly with a Gibbs state. The model has a complete tensor-product rule, an exact bifurcation condition, and a no-signalling operational stage based on local completely positive trace-preserving maps. Finally, it shows how empirical content arises only when one law-selection parameter must compress observations across multiple intervention contexts; a single context remains observationally equivalent to a fixed-law description. The resulting account replaces the metaphor of a “recursive universe” with a more disciplined claim: state-law closure is scientifically meaningful only when it imposes invariant, compositional, and risky relations across possible experiments.