Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Eurasia Journal of Mathematics Science and Technology Education

How a representation-independent approach to quantum mechanics can aid student learning

James K. Freericks

Published Jul 21, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum mechanics is traditionally taught in a specific representation—the position-space representation—because the time-independent Schrödinger equation is simplest to formulate there. But this leads to a number of conceptual issues both associated with language and with the formalism, especially if one starts more formally and then emphasizes representations for calculations. In this work, we describe a number of these issues and argue why restricting to a representation-independent formalism (that is, working with abstract operators and state vectors independent of any specific representation) fixes many of these issues. Then representations can be introduced later when needed for specific applications (but we find the need to do this can be sharply reduced from current paradigms).

DOI
10.29333/ejmste/18981

Related papers

Deriving the time-independent Schrödinger equation

Jonathan Gorard

Abstract A discussion of the physical meaning of the Schrödinger wave equation can not only constitute an exciting introduction to some of the more abstract ideas of quantum mechanics, but serves more generally as a useful demonstration of the application of mathematics to modern physics. This frontline uses physical concepts and mathematical techniques that would be accessible to a sufficiently interested secondary school student, in order to derive the simplest, one-dimensional case of the time-independent Schrödinger equation: the derivation relies only upon aspects of Newtonian/wave mechanics, quantum theory, complex numbers and calculus that would be covered in an advanced secondary school syllabus.

Physics Education•Sep 14, 2016•3 citations

Multiple representations for Quantum Mechanics

Marco Giliberti, Luisa Lovisetti

Abstract In a cultural, history-based, sense-making approach to Quantum Mechanics multi-representations are fundamental to improve conceptual learning of abstract, mathematical aspects. In fact, they can be integrated among each other allowing students to actively manipulate concepts and instruments which would otherwise be difficult and little accessible. In this presentation we will show different (and interconnected) representations of vectors in complex Hilbert spaces and of eigenvalues and eigenvectors of Hermitian matrices together with an evaluation of their efficacy for students conceptual understanding.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Mar 1, 2026•0 citations

The Mathematics of Quantum Mechanics

Jeffrey Alan Barrett

Abstract Quantum mechanics is written in the language of linear algebra. On the Schrodinger picture the theory represents quantum-mechanical states using the elements of a Hilbert space and represents observable physical properties and the standard dynamics using the linear operators on the state space. We consider the mathematical notions for understanding and working with the standard formulation of quantum mechanics. Each mathematical notion is characterized geometrically, algebraically, and physically. The mathematical representation of quantum-mechanical superpositions is discussed.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 26, 2019•1 citation

From discrete states to wavefunctions

Martin Kamela

In the spin-first approach to learning quantum mechanics, students explore the 2-state spin Hilbert space before proceeding to wavefunctions and the related infinite-dimensional state space. In this note, we suggest a strategy to help students make this conceptual leap. Approximating continuous space with a finite number of locations, we construct a setting where students' intuition from spin space carries over to a position basis. We derive the position basis representations of the momentum and kinetic energy operators, solve simple bound state problems, and consider limitations to the discrete representation of position.

American Journal of Physics•Apr 22, 2026•0 citations

States as Vectors

Tilak Sinha

From here, we take up the task of reformulating quantum mechanics in the language of inner product space. We start by introducing vector space through the familiar example of a set of finite dimensional, complex, column matrices under addition and multiplication by scalars. The inner product is then introduced as a dot product generalized to complex vectors leading to the idea of an inner product space . This is adequate to show how the concept of a quantum state can be described by a normalized vector in an inner product space so that the state space can be identified with the inner product space. Amplitudes are associated with inner products , and observables with orthonormal bases in this space. Hence the laws of quantum mechanics are reformulated. We then point out that the now reformulated laws are independent of the space of description and the reader is urged to contemplate an universality which would reflect the independence with respect to the representation space . This creates the stage for the introduction of the abstract inner product space and the formulation of quantum mechanics in this setting. The chapter concludes with this description. The transformed laws are now called postulatesof quantum mechanics .

Chapman & Hall/CRC eBooks•Jun 18, 2021•0 citations

Phase space quantum mechanics - Direct

S. Nasiri, Y. Sobouti, F. Taati

Conventional approach to quantum mechanics in phase space, (q,p), is to take the operator based quantum mechanics of Schrödinger, or an equivalent, and assign a c-number function in phase space to it. We propose to begin with a higher level of abstraction, in which the independence and the symmetric role of q and p is maintained throughout, and at once arrive at phase space state functions. Upon reduction to the q- or p-space the proposed formalism gives the conventional quantum mechanics, however, with a definite rule for ordering of factors of noncommuting observables. Further conceptual and practical merits of the formalism are demonstrated throughout the text.

arXiv:quant-ph/0605129•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Sep 1, 2006•15 citations
Quantum mechanics is traditionally taught in a specific representation—the position-space representation—because the time-independent Schrödinger equation is simplest to formulate there. But this leads to a number of conceptual issues both associated with language and with the formalism, especially if one starts more formally and then emphasizes representations for calculations. In this work, we describe a number of these issues and argue why restricting to a representation-independent formalism (that is, working with abstract operators and state vectors independent of any specific representation) fixes many of these issues. Then representations can be introduced later when needed for specific applications (but we find the need to do this can be sharply reduced from current paradigms).
Abstract A discussion of the physical meaning of the Schrödinger wave equation can not only constitute an exciting introduction to some of the more abstract ideas of quantum mechanics, but serves more generally as a useful demonstration of the application of mathematics to modern physics. This frontline uses physical concepts and mathematical techniques that would be accessible to a sufficiently interested secondary school student, in order to derive the simplest, one-dimensional case of the time-independent Schrödinger equation: the derivation relies only upon aspects of Newtonian/wave mechanics, quantum theory, complex numbers and calculus that would be covered in an advanced secondary school syllabus.
Abstract In a cultural, history-based, sense-making approach to Quantum Mechanics multi-representations are fundamental to improve conceptual learning of abstract, mathematical aspects. In fact, they can be integrated among each other allowing students to actively manipulate concepts and instruments which would otherwise be difficult and little accessible. In this presentation we will show different (and interconnected) representations of vectors in complex Hilbert spaces and of eigenvalues and eigenvectors of Hermitian matrices together with an evaluation of their efficacy for students conceptual understanding.
Abstract Quantum mechanics is written in the language of linear algebra. On the Schrodinger picture the theory represents quantum-mechanical states using the elements of a Hilbert space and represents observable physical properties and the standard dynamics using the linear operators on the state space. We consider the mathematical notions for understanding and working with the standard formulation of quantum mechanics. Each mathematical notion is characterized geometrically, algebraically, and physically. The mathematical representation of quantum-mechanical superpositions is discussed.
In the spin-first approach to learning quantum mechanics, students explore the 2-state spin Hilbert space before proceeding to wavefunctions and the related infinite-dimensional state space. In this note, we suggest a strategy to help students make this conceptual leap. Approximating continuous space with a finite number of locations, we construct a setting where students' intuition from spin space carries over to a position basis. We derive the position basis representations of the momentum and kinetic energy operators, solve simple bound state problems, and consider limitations to the discrete representation of position.
From here, we take up the task of reformulating quantum mechanics in the language of inner product space. We start by introducing vector space through the familiar example of a set of finite dimensional, complex, column matrices under addition and multiplication by scalars. The inner product is then introduced as a dot product generalized to complex vectors leading to the idea of an inner product space . This is adequate to show how the concept of a quantum state can be described by a normalized vector in an inner product space so that the state space can be identified with the inner product space. Amplitudes are associated with inner products , and observables with orthonormal bases in this space. Hence the laws of quantum mechanics are reformulated. We then point out that the now reformulated laws are independent of the space of description and the reader is urged to contemplate an universality which would reflect the independence with respect to the representation space . This creates the stage for the introduction of the abstract inner product space and the formulation of quantum mechanics in this setting. The chapter concludes with this description. The transformed laws are now called postulatesof quantum mechanics .
Conventional approach to quantum mechanics in phase space, (q,p), is to take the operator based quantum mechanics of Schrödinger, or an equivalent, and assign a c-number function in phase space to it. We propose to begin with a higher level of abstraction, in which the independence and the symmetric role of q and p is maintained throughout, and at once arrive at phase space state functions. Upon reduction to the q- or p-space the proposed formalism gives the conventional quantum mechanics, however, with a definite rule for ordering of factors of noncommuting observables. Further conceptual and practical merits of the formalism are demonstrated throughout the text.