Universal Axiomatization of the Binary Excluded Middle Law and the Dual Ontology-Cognition Entropy System — A Fundamental Framework for Unified Observation Theory
Addressing cross-disciplinary fundamental issues including paradigm separation between classical and quantum observation, logical drift in general artificial intelligence probabilistic frameworks, and ambiguous uncertainty tracing in information systems, this study proposes a universal axiomatic framework of the binary excluded middle law and establishes a dual theoretical architecture consisting of ontology entropy and cognitive entropy. Strict logical demonstration verifies that all objective physical systems, regardless of microscopic or macroscopic scale, obey binary exclusive truth-value constraints without inherent superposition states or intrinsic probabilistic uncertainty. Phenomena such as quantum superposition, observational fuzziness, and probabilistic ambiguity are cognitive representations arising from information isolation and insufficient observational coupling, rather than inherent ontological properties of physical systems. This study redefines the essential nature of observation as a threshold-induced phase transition process, in which continuous information aggregation reduces cognitive entropy and eventually drives the system toward a deterministic binary steady state. Under this dual-entropy paradigm, the Schrödinger’s cat superposition paradox is fully and self-consistently resolved, eliminating long-standing logical ambiguities in quantum observation interpretation. This paper further conducts cross-domain adaptability analysis and constructs a unified fundamental logical framework for physical observation, intelligent cognition, information evaluation, and numerical computation, while outlining a phased systematic research roadmap. The results indicate that the binary excluded middle law serves as a universal underlying logical meta-rule for natural and intelligent information systems. The proposed dual ontology–cognitive entropy system fundamentally unifies the paradigms of classical and quantum physics, natural science, and artificial intelligence, possessing significant fundamental theoretical innovative value and broad engineering application prospects.
Addressing cross-disciplinary fundamental issues including paradigm separation between classical and quantum observation, logical drift in general artificial intelligence probabilistic frameworks, and ambiguous uncertainty tracing in information systems, this study proposes a universal axiomatic framework of the binary excluded middle law and establishes a dual theoretical architecture consisting of ontology entropy and cognitive entropy. Strict logical demonstration verifies that all objective physical systems, regardless of microscopic or macroscopic scale, obey binary exclusive truth-value constraints without inherent superposition states or intrinsic probabilistic uncertainty. Phenomena such as quantum superposition, observational fuzziness, and probabilistic ambiguity are cognitive representations arising from information isolation and insufficient observational coupling, rather than inherent ontological properties of physical systems. This study redefines the essential nature of observation as a threshold-induced phase transition process, in which continuous information aggregation reduces cognitive entropy and eventually drives the system toward a deterministic binary steady state. Under this dual-entropy paradigm, the Schrödinger’s cat superposition paradox is fully and self-consistently resolved, eliminating long-standing logical ambiguities in quantum observation interpretation. This paper further conducts cross-domain adaptability analysis and constructs a unified fundamental logical framework for physical observation, intelligent cognition, information evaluation, and numerical computation, while outlining a phased systematic research roadmap. The results indicate that the binary excluded middle law serves as a universal underlying logical meta-rule for natural and intelligent information systems. The proposed dual ontology–cognitive entropy system fundamentally unifies the paradigms of classical and quantum physics, natural science, and artificial intelligence, possessing significant fundamental theoretical innovative value and broad engineering application prospects.
Mainstream quantum mechanical interpretations, classical logical paradox resolution frameworks, cognitive theories of human deceptive behavior, and probabilistic artificial intelligence models universally exhibit a fundamental methodological flaw. These conventional approaches prioritize subjective observational phenomena and cognitively constructed appearances as theoretical presuppositions, thereby conflating the intrinsic determinacy of objective ontology with illusory uncertainty arising from incomplete information and limited cognitive capacity. This study systematically examines such paradigm-level biases by conducting a cross-disciplinary methodological comparison between prevalent theoretical frameworks and the dual paradigm integrating the binary excluded middle law and ontology–cognitive entropy. The proposed paradigm establishes the binary determinacy of objective ontology—independent of observation, reasoning, and subjective perception—as the foundational axiom. All apparent uncertainties, including quantum superposition, instantaneous quantum transitions, formal logical contradictions, cognitive ambiguity, and probabilistic model outputs, are attributed to transient cognitive entropy states induced by insufficient information convergence. The dynamic cognitive entropy metric complements the missing continuous evolutionary mechanism in traditional quantum theories and fundamentally resolves the inherent defects of appearance-oriented methodological frameworks. Cross-domain comparisons demonstrate that the ontology–cognitive entropy dual paradigm features ontology–cognition dichotomy, dynamic entropy quantification, and full logical self-consistency without subjective presuppositions. This framework provides a rigorous, unified, and objective theoretical foundation for addressing pervasive uncertainty problems in fundamental physics, formal logic, cognitive science, and artificial intelligence, supporting both basic theoretical innovation and engineering risk-control applications.
This comprehensive interdisciplinary investigation synthesizes six foundational domains in modern physics and computer science: quantum vacuum dynamics, quantum measurement theory, binary computation architecture, artificial intelligence evolution, relativistic temporal structure, and quantum entanglement phenomena. Quantum vacuum—far from representing absolute emptiness—exhibits continuous zero-point energy fluctuations generating virtual particle-antiparticle pairs via Heisenberg uncertainty principle, with Casimir effect providing experimental verification through measurable attractive force (F/A = -ℏcπ²/240d⁴) between conducting plates. Schrödinger's cat paradox illustrates quantum superposition collapse upon measurement, revealing observer-dependent reality contradicting classical determinism and motivating interpretational frameworks including Copenhagen collapse, many-worlds branching, and decoherence mechanisms. Binary computation architecture—utilizing base-2 representation (0,1 states)—exploits transistor switching characteristics enabling universal information encoding, with von Neumann architecture establishing stored-program paradigm foundational to modern computing. Artificial intelligence evolved from Turing's universal computation and symbolic reasoning systems through connectionist neural networks to contemporary deep learning architectures achieving superhuman performance in pattern recognition, natural language processing, and strategic game-playing domains. Einstein's special relativity demonstrates temporal relativity through velocity-dependent time dilation (τ = τ₀√(1-v²/c²)) and general relativity's gravitational time dilation near massive objects, with GPS satellite corrections providing daily experimental confirmation. Quantum entanglement—non-local correlation between spatially separated particles violating Bell inequalities—enables quantum information protocols including quantum cryptography, quantum teleportation, and quantum computation while challenging classical notions of locality and realism. The synthesis reveals deep connections: quantum vacuum provides cosmological initial conditions for universal genesis; measurement problem connects consciousness to physical reality; binary architecture enables AI substrate; relativistic effects constrain information transmission; and entanglement enables novel computational paradigms transcending classical limits.
Classical information theory and quantum information theory are respectively based on Boolean algebra and Hilbert space projection lattices, lacking a unified logical framework for cross-scale physical propositions covering classical, mesoscopic and quantum domains. Traditional physics attributes the classical-quantum transition to continuous spatial scale variation, which is essentially external parameter determinism and cannot explain the peculiar intermediate characteristics of mesoscopic systems. This paper constructs the philosophical and mathematical foundation of mesoscopic information theory based on the coupling of S4 modal logic and the non-distributive modular lattice M₃. A composite axiom system is proposed, and Axiom 3 (a–g) realizes the consistent embedding of S4 modal operators on non-distributive lattices. The cross-scale evolution of physical systems is reinterpreted as discrete phase transition of propositional lattice types, with an endogenous CHSH-type correlation threshold τ≈2.414 serving as the operational criterion for mesoscopic phase. A Möbius-weighted lattice entropy independent of Shannon and von Neumann entropy is established to characterize structural information of mesoscopic logical systems. Noise and decoherence are redefined as intrinsic signals of lattice structural transition rather than simple information dissipation. This study establishes the independent ontological status of mesoscopic propositional systems, breaks the scale-phenomenological paradigm in traditional cross-scale physics, and provides a new foundational framework for the unification of cross-scale information theory.
The unmediated, instantaneous long-range correlation demonstrated by quantum entanglement has been repeatedly confirmed by experiments, yet it forms an irreconcilable logical paradox with humanity’s fundamental understanding of cosmic scale, spatial separation, and cognitive limitations. If entanglement is acknowledged to possess infinite, universal action capacity, it would lead to the extreme conclusion that humans could directly reach the boundaries of the universe and connect with the entire cosmos through microscopic quantum phenomena—a notion entirely at odds with the reality that humanity has yet to escape the solar system and remains largely ignorant of the vast majority of the universe. Through rigorous logical deduction, this paper proposes the only self-consistent dual possibilities: first, quantum entanglement may possess undiscovered physical limitations, with its nonlocal properties effective only within a finite scale; second, modern physics may harbor fundamental cognitive biases regarding the nature of space, the meaning of distance, and the reality of separation, suggesting that space is not an objective, independent foundational physical entity. This paper systematically demonstrates the rationality, self-consistency, and revolutionary implications of these two possibilities for physics and cosmology, offering a novel theoretical framework to resolve the underlying conflict between quantum mechanics and cosmology.
Modern physics has achieved extraordinary predictive success, yet it continues to face unresolved conceptual tensions concerning the role of the observer, the nature of information, and the origin of physical structure. From quantum measurement to cosmology, the assumption of an observer-neutral reality increasingly appears insufficient to fully account for empirical phenomena and theoretical inconsistencies. This manifesto proposes an Informational Observer-Centered Framework, in which information is treated as a fundamental ontological substrate and observation as an active, structured process rather than a passive act of measurement. Within this perspective, physical systems, observers, and informational exchanges form a unified dynamics, where state reduction, decoherence, and emergent classicality arise from informational interactions and constraints. Rather than introducing a new closed theory, this manifesto establishes a conceptual foundation unifying several complementary models—including Informational State Dynamics, observer-dependent informational compression, and informational interpretations of quantum and cosmological phenomena—into a coherent research program. The framework is explicitly non-dogmatic, open to falsification, and intended as a guiding structure for further theoretical development and empirical testing. The aim of this document is not to replace existing physical theories, but to clarify their conceptual boundaries and propose an integrative lens through which unresolved problems in quantum foundations, cosmology, and cognitive systems may be systematically explored.
This paper, based on two fundamental physical axioms—Information Conservation (A1) and Computability (A2)—systematically argues for the intrinsic logical structure necessary for describing physical reality. Research shows that in aself-referential universe model constrained by local observations, the truth-valuejudgment logic of physical propositions necessarily deviates from classical Booleanlogic. The core root lies in the “local-global inequivalence” of physical systems: theinformation contained in the global physical state cannot be completely determinedby any finite observational procedure within a finite spacetime region. This leads tothe invalidity of the law of excluded middle within the system, and consequently,the logical structure mathematically manifests as a non-distributive orthomodularlattice, i.e., Birkhoff–von Neumann quantum logic. This structure is proven tocorrespond exactly to the subobject lattice in the ∞-topos TA constructed previously. This theoretical framework finally leads to a testable cosmological prediction:the central value of the non-Gaussianity parameter fNL of the cosmic microwavebackground (CMB) temperature fluctuations is about −3.2. Next-generation CMBexperiments (such as CMB-S4) will be able to test this prediction precisely, andthe results can be used to evaluate whether the quantum logical structure emergingfrom the basic axioms is suitable for describing the real universe.