In the Bose–Marletto–Vedral (BMV) proposal, two masses placed in superposition become entangled only if the gravitational field between them is quantum — a proposed table-top test of whether gravity is quantum. This paper reframes the question through quantum Darwinism. A mass's Newtonian field is a record of its position imprinted on nearby matter; a classical field is one that broadcasts that record objectively, whereas a genuinely quantum field can remain in superposition and refuses to copy a which-path record. The paper models exactly a source in superposition, its recording environment, and its partner mass, and proves an objectivity–entanglement monogamy: if the field records the position redundantly across many fragments, the entanglement it can generate is exponentially small in that redundancy — a field cannot both broadcast and entangle. Several results follow. The field record is extensive. A sharp classical-versus-quantum dichotomy is carried by an information measure that rises from zero to one bit as the field becomes classical. The source's position is the unique objective observable. And earlier black-hole decoherence results reappear as the single-fragment limit. A measured entanglement therefore bounds the field's objective redundancy from above. The results are finite-dimensional theorems with exact numerics reproduced by self-testing code, and two algebraic cores are additionally verified by proof-checking software; the gravitational couplings and decoherence rates are imported, not re-derived. In short: a field cannot both broadcast and entangle — so the entanglement a BMV experiment measures is precisely the price gravity pays for not being classical.
In the Bose–Marletto–Vedral (BMV) proposal, two masses placed in superposition become entangled only if the gravitational field between them is quantum — a proposed table-top test of whether gravity is quantum. This paper reframes the question through quantum Darwinism. A mass's Newtonian field is a record of its position imprinted on nearby matter; a classical field is one that broadcasts that record objectively, whereas a genuinely quantum field can remain in superposition and refuses to copy a which-path record. The paper models exactly a source in superposition, its recording environment, and its partner mass, and proves an objectivity–entanglement monogamy: if the field records the position redundantly across many fragments, the entanglement it can generate is exponentially small in that redundancy — a field cannot both broadcast and entangle. Several results follow. The field record is extensive. A sharp classical-versus-quantum dichotomy is carried by an information measure that rises from zero to one bit as the field becomes classical. The source's position is the unique objective observable. And earlier black-hole decoherence results reappear as the single-fragment limit. A measured entanglement therefore bounds the field's objective redundancy from above. The results are finite-dimensional theorems with exact numerics reproduced by self-testing code, and two algebraic cores are additionally verified by proof-checking software; the gravitational couplings and decoherence rates are imported, not re-derived. In short: a field cannot both broadcast and entangle — so the entanglement a BMV experiment measures is precisely the price gravity pays for not being classical.
Christodoulou and Rovelli (CR) [1] have argued that a Bose et al.-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) experiment that confirmed the quantum nature of gravity would give laboratory evidence for a quantum superposition of spacetime geometries created in the course of the experiment. Hanif et al. [2] have argued that mass interferometers can be used to test whether gravity acts as a quantum entity when measured. We note that not all quantum models of gravity imply that mass superpositions necessarily become significantly entangled with any degrees of freedom of the gravitational field during the experiments discussed.
A recent paper by Aziz and Howl (Nature 2025) argues that, once quantum matter is described at the level of quantum field theory and coupled to a classical gravitational field, higher order processes can generate entanglement between two spatially separated masses. A contemporaneous critical note (Marletto, Oppenheim, Vedral, Wilson, arXiv:2511.07348v1) shows that, in the actual nonrelativistic limit employed there, the interaction becomes ultra local, the total unitary factorizes, and no entanglement is generated from a product input. In this comment we (i) restate the core point of that critique, (ii) give a channel theoretic reformulation that makes the conclusion model independent, and (iii) clarify the distinction between activation of entanglement in already quantum matter and genuine mediation of entanglement by a classical field. Once these clarifications are in place, the standard BMV inference that observation of gravity mediated entanglement strongly indicates nonclassical gravitational degrees of freedom remains intact.
The Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) proposal infers that gravity is quantum if two masses, each in a spatialsuperposition, become entangled through gravity alone. No such experiment has been performed. Its reading has twoweak points: non-gravitational interactions (Casimir-Polder, electric dipoles) also entangle, and a classicalgravitational channel can imprint the Newtonian phase without entangling. We simulated the two-spin experiment(10^-14 kg nanodiamonds, 250 um superpositions, 2.5 s, six separations from 125 to 800 um, nine-settingtomography) under quantum gravity, classical channels and no gravitational phase, with unknown Casimir strength(x0.2-20), dipoles, terms of the wrong power, calibration and mass errors, dephasing and finite shots, and measuredeach instrument's false-alarm rate before trusting it. In sealed runs a lone witness called classical-gravity worldsquantum in 10.7% of cases (data-tuned bases 15.4%), and reading only the 1/r shape of the phase did so in 68.3% ofclassical-channel worlds. A three-valued instrument (W1) that demands entanglement beyond what non-gravity alonecan produce together with the Newtonian coefficient, and that needs an independent dipole calibration, never called aclassical world quantum (0 of 16,500 over four seals). A first claim that a null result can read "classical" rested on aclassical channel whose phase had the wrong sign; corrected, the channel hid behind its own decoherence and theclaim became Unresolved. Classical channels must pay coherence for the phase, and that cost grows as the massesapproach, so the dependence of coherence on separation is a fingerprint. Fixing its shape as phi^2 failed a seal(Falsified: 25 of 1022), although the signal was present in 1020 of them; with the power left free the final seal gave Ron all five claims: a time-sliced classical channel never seen before was called classical in 996 of 996 worlds,quantum worlds never (0 of 1500), and classical worlds overall in 57.0%. All results are simulated. ※ Data and code. All scripts (AGPL-3.0-or-later, GNU Affero General Public License v3.0 or later), the four seal documents with their SHA-256 files, develop logs andresult files are provided as Bridge_Paper_A_Witness_Is_Not_a_Verdict_scripts_v1.0.0.zip; every world isregenerated from its seed. ※ AI use. Designs, code, analyses and text were produced by Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5,Anthropic) working with M. Watabe, who chose every direction.
We develop a low-energy, Newtonian-limit effective field theory (EFT) describing gravitationally induced decoherence arising from a classical stochastic gravitational channel. The framework is formulated as completely positive, Markovian Lindblad dynamics coupled to the mass-density operator with spatially correlated white noise. We derive scaling laws for single-mass superpositions and for two-mass Bose–Marletto–Vedral (BMV) configurations, identify four universal parametric regimes, and construct a model-independent testability window in the parameter space of noise strength and correlation length. Our results provide a direct operational link between laboratory-scale entanglement experiments and foundational questions concerning the quantum or classical nature of gravity.
We revisit the Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) tabletop experimental proposal---which aims to witness quantum gravity using gravity-mediated entanglement---analyzing the role of locality in the experiment. We first carry out a fully quantum modeling of the interaction of matter and gravity and then show in what way gravity-mediated entanglement in the BMV experiment could be accounted for without appealing to quantum degrees of freedom of the gravitational field. We discuss what assumptions are needed in order to interpret the current BMV experiment proposals as a proof of quantum gravity, and also identify the modifications that a BMV-like experiment could have in order to serve as proof of quantum gravity without having to assume the existence of local mediators in the gravitational field.
Reconciling quantum mechanics and general relativity remains one of the most profound challenges in modern physics. The BMV (Bose-Marletto-Vedral) experiment can assess the quantum nature of gravity by testing whether gravitational interactions can generate entanglement between quantum systems. In this work, we show that entanglement can be generated by gravity without requiring spacetime superpositions or quantum spacetime degrees of freedom by using mediators that do not satisfy the usual property of local tomography when coupling to quantum matter. Specifically, we showcase how entanglement can be generated using three distinct toy models that display non-locally tomographic couplings between quantum matter and a locally classical gravitational mediator. These models include (i) fermionic systems with the parity superselection rule, (ii) non-Abelian anyonic systems, and (iii) a novel bit anti-bit model. Our results demonstrate a crucial point: a gravitational mediator which does not exhibit superpositions of its classical basis but still qualifies as non-classical via non-locally tomographic coupling mechanisms can generate entanglement through local interactions. This work also underscores the importance of relaxing local tomography in exploring the quantum-gravitational interface. It provides a novel perspective on the role of spacetime degrees of freedom in entanglement generation through local interactions.