Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Closing Gap and the Honest Infinity: Exact Laws of Quantum-Limited Measurement

Richard Goodman, Richard Goodman

Published Jul 11, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

How much can a measurement know? Near a quantum critical point the answer diverges: as the spectral gap closes, the information a probe carries about its control parameter grows as ^-4. This paper presents that law, and the estimation theory surrounding it, as a connected body of machine-certified mathematics. The finite Cram\'er--Rao bound is proved from a Cauchy--Schwarz core and completed by its two missing pillars --- monotonicity under any stochastic post-processing and additivity over independent experiments --- so that ``no pipeline beats the raw data'' is a theorem, not a slogan. A concrete two-outcome readout of a Landau--Zener probe is shown to saturate the quantum limit at the exact rational value 16/625: a certified calibration constant rather than a numerical estimate. Where the information matrix of a two-parameter critical probe degenerates, its full eigenstructure is derived --- the unidentifiable direction exactly, its claimed pseudoinverse verified against all four Penrose conditions --- and the variance bound along the lost direction, which ordinary total division silently reports as 0, is restored to an honest by wheel-valued arithmetic. The resulting trichotomy (finite\,/\,\,/\,) turns a division-by-zero failure into a classification, and yields an unexpected theorem: thermal noise restores identifiability. A finite-cutoff interpretation gives the bosonic operator calculus executable semantics, locating the canonical commutator's truncation defect on the

DOI
10.6084/m9.figshare.32964611

Related papers

The Closing Gap and the Honest Infinity: Exact Laws of Quantum-Limited Measurement

Richard Goodman

How much can a measurement know? Near a quantum critical point the answer diverges: as the spectral gap closes, the information a probe carries about its control parameter grows as ^-4. This paper presents that law, and the estimation theory surrounding it, as a connected body of machine-certified mathematics. The finite Cram\'er--Rao bound is proved from a Cauchy--Schwarz core and completed by its two missing pillars --- monotonicity under any stochastic post-processing and additivity over independent experiments --- so that ``no pipeline beats the raw data'' is a theorem, not a slogan. A concrete two-outcome readout of a Landau--Zener probe is shown to saturate the quantum limit at the exact rational value 16/625: a certified calibration constant rather than a numerical estimate. Where the information matrix of a two-parameter critical probe degenerates, its full eigenstructure is derived --- the unidentifiable direction exactly, its claimed pseudoinverse verified against all four Penrose conditions --- and the variance bound along the lost direction, which ordinary total division silently reports as 0, is restored to an honest by wheel-valued arithmetic. The resulting trichotomy (finite\,/\,\,/\,) turns a division-by-zero failure into a classification, and yields an unexpected theorem: thermal noise restores identifiability. A finite-cutoff interpretation gives the bosonic operator calculus executable semantics, locating the canonical commutator's truncation defect on the

•Jul 12, 2026•0 citations

Global Bounds beyond Local Quantum Metrology

Hai-Long Shi, Augusto Smerzi

Quantum Cramér--Rao theory is intrinsically local: it bounds precision near a specified parameter value, and its saturating measurement generally depends on that value. Barankin-type bounds use finite parameter displacements, but remain anchored to a chosen reference value. This leaves open a basic global-estimation problem: when the parameter is known only within a broad domain, what precision can be guaranteed by a single estimator and a single measurement strategy fixed before the true value is localized? We answer this question by introducing global score functions tied to a weighted variance over the whole parameter domain. Their correlations generate a hierarchy of precision bounds: global Cramér--Rao and Barankin-type bounds arise as restricted levels, whereas unrestricted score correlations yield a fully global bound for the prescribed weighted variance. The hierarchy recovers local Cramér--Rao theory in the many-repetition limit and reveals genuinely global precision limits for finite data over broad domains. In the quantum setting, the construction identifies when this fully global bound can be realized by a single parameter-independent measurement. The same framework extends to Bayesian estimation, recovering the Van Trees bound in the local limit while yielding stronger finite-width lower bounds on the Bayesian mean-square error beyond this limit.

quant-pharXiv:2605.28374•May 28, 2026•4 citations

The Finite-Calibration Limit: What a Device Characterisation Can Claim Between Calibrations

Majid Hussain

Quantum control practice runs on characterisations: measured coherence times, gate errors, frequencies, and crosstalk figures, taken at calibration and consumed by every layer of the control stack until the next calibration replaces them. A premise rides silently in that consumption — that the characterisation remains current between calibrations — and this paper examines and refuses it. We argue three points, each held at its own strength. First, a characterisation is a finite observer's estimate, not a standing fact: at calibration time it already carries a strictly positive uncertainty floor from finite probes, and the act of probing is itself a physical intervention on the device. Second, between calibrations the device's parameters move — relaxation times fluctuate on hour scales through two-level-system dynamics, and environmental drift reshapes the error landscape — so the uncertainty a consumer should attach to a characterisation widens with time since calibration under any honest model. Third, these two facts compose into a limit with an operational consequence: under the declared drift model a characterisation carries a finite validity horizon, and in every case it carries expiry semantics — a control stack that consumes a characterisation without an expiry is acting on an unexamined exactness claim. The finite horizon is conditional and the finite-calibration limit section states its converse: a mean-reverting drift confined within tolerance admits an infinite horizon, and nothing here forbids that case. We then instantiate the external contract of the companion limits paper for this setting: a characterisation ships with a declared validity budget and a declared expiry model; consumers check validity before acting on it; and on expiry the fail-closed forms are refusal of the stale figure and escalation to recalibration with a declared deadline. We state a minimal stochastic validity model — latent device state, calibration posterior, hazard-widening between calibrations, derived expiry rule — as a declared model whose parameters an installation must estimate, not a law derived here. The authority boundary of the resulting layer is advisory by design choice, and we give the rationale rather than presenting the choice as a consequence. Related work has built the detection and tracking instruments this contract would consume; what is added here is the register those instruments lack: validity as a first-class, expiring, refusable claim.

•Aug 18, 2026•0 citations

Operational Identifiability of Tensor Product Structures: Exact Rigidity Laws, a Two-Operation Threshold, and an Aliasing Limit

Ryan Cardwell, Claude

Here's what this paper means for actual humans: WHAT THIS IS ABOUT. When you build or use a quantum device, everything rests on knowing what its parts are: which degrees of freedom are "qubit 1," which are "qubit 2." The companion paper ("Forged Frames") showed that simple mathematical criteria cannot certify this; convincing fakes exist. This paper answers the question that result leaves standing: what is the MINIMUM experimental information that genuinely pins down a system's subsystem structure, and when can that information silently fail? WHAT WE FOUND, IN PLAIN TERMS. Four things. (1) EXACT LAWS INSTEAD OF MEASUREMENTS. Any wrong choice of parts must visibly distort the family of unentangled states, and we derive exactly how much, at every system size: closed-form constants (verified to seven decimal places), an explicit error bound, and a surprise. The two natural ways to measure "wrongness" (state distortion versus operator scrambling) turn out to be literally the same measurement, up to a fixed number, whenever the two parts have equal size. Wrongness cannot hide. (2) THE TWO-OPERATION THRESHOLD. You can pin down what your subsystems are by implementing just TWO generic operations and checking their statistics, while a THOUSAND mutually commuting operations tell you nothing at all. Diversity of control, not volume of control, is what fixes what your qubits are. The residual uncertainty is proportional to your measurement tolerance, with a constant we derive exactly and show how to compute in advance, so an experimenter can screen candidate operation pairs and pick a strong one (random pairs are typically several times worse, occasionally catastrophically so). (3) THE ALIASING LIMIT: CERTIFICATION CAN PASS WHILE TELLING YOU NOTHING. If you sample your certification data at special "resonant" times (set by the operations' energy scales), a maximally wrong assignment of subsystems passes the test perfectly. What your qubits are depends on when you looked. We characterize these blind spots exactly (for qubits they are universal and computable in advance; the danger windows shrink with the square root of your tolerance), and the fix costs almost nothing: sample at two different times, at least one away from the resonant set. With that, certification is restored; we prove it exactly and measure it. (4) REAL-LAB BUDGETS. We work out what certification costs in actual measurement shots (the error falls off unusually fast, inversely with the total number of shots rather than with its square root), how hardware noise floors the procedure, and how a simple reference measurement removes that floor to first order. A single seven-row table in the paper is effectively a lab protocol: it shows, condition by condition, which kinds of experimental access identify the subsystem structure (two generic operations: yes; one operation, commuting operations, resonant sampling: no). WHY IT MATTERS. For quantum hardware: this is a concrete recipe for certifying that the qubits you think you have are the qubits you physically have, with explicit tolerances, a sampling-time warning that is a real failure mode on calibrated hardware, and shot budgets. For foundations: the contested question "does physics determine its own subsystems?" gets a quantitative operational answer. Physics determines an operational subsystem CLASS (not one preferred coordinate representation of it), and that class is fixed by two operations sampled at two times, and by nothing less that we tested. WHAT IT OPENS UP. The seven-row identifiability table is a blueprint for a tabletop experiment on any small quantum platform; running it on hardware would move this from simulation to laboratory fact. On the theory side the paper leaves sharply posed open problems: the exact global constants when the two parts differ in size, the number-theoretic structure of long-time sampling (the failure times form a small-divisor hierarchy), and the extension from two parts to many. METHODS NOTE, BECAUSE IT MATTERS FOR TRUST. Every quantitative claim was pre-registered in the companion scripts before its run. The full ledger, including predictions that failed and one published-in-note constant that our own later theory overturned, is an appendix of the paper. All code, data, and working notes are in the deposit, seeded for exact reproduction. WHO AND HOW. A human-AI collaboration: research direction and standards of evidence by Ryan Cardwell (Crystalline Labs); design, code, derivations, and drafting by Claude (Anthropic), including autonomous sessions under the program's pre-registration rules, with adversarial reviews by other AI models incorporated and credited.

•Aug 15, 2026•7 citations

Information Limits of Outcome-Resolved Incidence Certification

Qingchun Zhang

Calibrated support observations can constrain a complete quantum instrument without identifying its action by unrestricted tomography. We study what those observations guarantee when the noise law is not supplied. On a fixed four-dimensional incidence-record experiment, we define the set of all complete two-outcome completely positive instruments compatible with the exact raw rejection and outcome probabilities, retaining the classical flags. Exact ideal data identify the target, but an explicit family of complete instruments reproduces the nonzero-data category laws of a low-error contamination device while admitting coherent error of square-root order. A target-ray mass certificate and a common complete-dilation comparison give a universal upper, while an exactly feasible rational instrument supplies a stronger lower witness. At the diagnostic parameter r = 1/300000000, the unhalved target-relative worst-case radius lies between 0.000258065115532250 and 0.000951566242566. The result separates avoidable inequality conservatism from information absent from the measured data. Fixed-functional and fixed-map optimizations have separately certified scopes; they do not solve the global radius. The conclusions are conditional on the supplied carrier, calibration and common-device model. They do not establish an apparatus, device-independent certification, a finite-sample power guarantee or complete formal verification. Selected supporting declarations have one recorded successful Lean 4.19.0 macOS execution and declaration-specific source, type and axiom review; this is not an end-to-end formalization.

•Oct 13, 2026•0 citations

Quantum metrology beyond the quantum Cramér-Rao theorem

Luigi Seveso, Matteo A. C. Rossi, Matteo G. A. Paris

A usual assumption in quantum estimation is that the unknown parameter labels the possible states of the system, while it influences neither the sample space of outcomes nor the measurement aimed at extracting information on the parameter itself. This assumption is crucial to prove the quantum Cram\'er-Rao theorem and to introduce the quantum Fisher information as an upper bound to the Fisher information of any possible measurement. However, there are relevant estimation problems where this assumption does not hold and an alternative approach should be developed to find the genuine ultimate bound to precision of quantum measurements. We investigate physical situations where there is an intrinsic dependence of the measurement strategy on the parameter and find that quantum-enhanced measurements may be more precise than previously thought.

arXiv:1605.08653•Physical Review A•Jan 10, 2017•48 citations
How much can a measurement know? Near a quantum critical point the answer diverges: as the spectral gap closes, the information a probe carries about its control parameter grows as ^-4. This paper presents that law, and the estimation theory surrounding it, as a connected body of machine-certified mathematics. The finite Cram'er--Rao bound is proved from a Cauchy--Schwarz core and completed by its two missing pillars --- monotonicity under any stochastic post-processing and additivity over independent experiments --- so that ``no pipeline beats the raw data'' is a theorem, not a slogan. A concrete two-outcome readout of a Landau--Zener probe is shown to saturate the quantum limit at the exact rational value 16/625: a certified calibration constant rather than a numerical estimate. Where the information matrix of a two-parameter critical probe degenerates, its full eigenstructure is derived --- the unidentifiable direction exactly, its claimed pseudoinverse verified against all four Penrose conditions --- and the variance bound along the lost direction, which ordinary total division silently reports as 0, is restored to an honest by wheel-valued arithmetic. The resulting trichotomy (finite,/,,/,) turns a division-by-zero failure into a classification, and yields an unexpected theorem: thermal noise restores identifiability. A finite-cutoff interpretation gives the bosonic operator calculus executable semantics, locating the canonical commutator's truncation defect on the
How much can a measurement know? Near a quantum critical point the answer diverges: as the spectral gap closes, the information a probe carries about its control parameter grows as ^-4. This paper presents that law, and the estimation theory surrounding it, as a connected body of machine-certified mathematics. The finite Cram\'er--Rao bound is proved from a Cauchy--Schwarz core and completed by its two missing pillars --- monotonicity under any stochastic post-processing and additivity over independent experiments --- so that ``no pipeline beats the raw data'' is a theorem, not a slogan. A concrete two-outcome readout of a Landau--Zener probe is shown to saturate the quantum limit at the exact rational value 16/625: a certified calibration constant rather than a numerical estimate. Where the information matrix of a two-parameter critical probe degenerates, its full eigenstructure is derived --- the unidentifiable direction exactly, its claimed pseudoinverse verified against all four Penrose conditions --- and the variance bound along the lost direction, which ordinary total division silently reports as 0, is restored to an honest by wheel-valued arithmetic. The resulting trichotomy (finite\,/\,\,/\,) turns a division-by-zero failure into a classification, and yields an unexpected theorem: thermal noise restores identifiability. A finite-cutoff interpretation gives the bosonic operator calculus executable semantics, locating the canonical commutator's truncation defect on the
Quantum Cramér--Rao theory is intrinsically local: it bounds precision near a specified parameter value, and its saturating measurement generally depends on that value. Barankin-type bounds use finite parameter displacements, but remain anchored to a chosen reference value. This leaves open a basic global-estimation problem: when the parameter is known only within a broad domain, what precision can be guaranteed by a single estimator and a single measurement strategy fixed before the true value is localized? We answer this question by introducing global score functions tied to a weighted variance over the whole parameter domain. Their correlations generate a hierarchy of precision bounds: global Cramér--Rao and Barankin-type bounds arise as restricted levels, whereas unrestricted score correlations yield a fully global bound for the prescribed weighted variance. The hierarchy recovers local Cramér--Rao theory in the many-repetition limit and reveals genuinely global precision limits for finite data over broad domains. In the quantum setting, the construction identifies when this fully global bound can be realized by a single parameter-independent measurement. The same framework extends to Bayesian estimation, recovering the Van Trees bound in the local limit while yielding stronger finite-width lower bounds on the Bayesian mean-square error beyond this limit.
Quantum control practice runs on characterisations: measured coherence times, gate errors, frequencies, and crosstalk figures, taken at calibration and consumed by every layer of the control stack until the next calibration replaces them. A premise rides silently in that consumption — that the characterisation remains current between calibrations — and this paper examines and refuses it. We argue three points, each held at its own strength. First, a characterisation is a finite observer's estimate, not a standing fact: at calibration time it already carries a strictly positive uncertainty floor from finite probes, and the act of probing is itself a physical intervention on the device. Second, between calibrations the device's parameters move — relaxation times fluctuate on hour scales through two-level-system dynamics, and environmental drift reshapes the error landscape — so the uncertainty a consumer should attach to a characterisation widens with time since calibration under any honest model. Third, these two facts compose into a limit with an operational consequence: under the declared drift model a characterisation carries a finite validity horizon, and in every case it carries expiry semantics — a control stack that consumes a characterisation without an expiry is acting on an unexamined exactness claim. The finite horizon is conditional and the finite-calibration limit section states its converse: a mean-reverting drift confined within tolerance admits an infinite horizon, and nothing here forbids that case. We then instantiate the external contract of the companion limits paper for this setting: a characterisation ships with a declared validity budget and a declared expiry model; consumers check validity before acting on it; and on expiry the fail-closed forms are refusal of the stale figure and escalation to recalibration with a declared deadline. We state a minimal stochastic validity model — latent device state, calibration posterior, hazard-widening between calibrations, derived expiry rule — as a declared model whose parameters an installation must estimate, not a law derived here. The authority boundary of the resulting layer is advisory by design choice, and we give the rationale rather than presenting the choice as a consequence. Related work has built the detection and tracking instruments this contract would consume; what is added here is the register those instruments lack: validity as a first-class, expiring, refusable claim.
Here's what this paper means for actual humans: WHAT THIS IS ABOUT. When you build or use a quantum device, everything rests on knowing what its parts are: which degrees of freedom are "qubit 1," which are "qubit 2." The companion paper ("Forged Frames") showed that simple mathematical criteria cannot certify this; convincing fakes exist. This paper answers the question that result leaves standing: what is the MINIMUM experimental information that genuinely pins down a system's subsystem structure, and when can that information silently fail? WHAT WE FOUND, IN PLAIN TERMS. Four things. (1) EXACT LAWS INSTEAD OF MEASUREMENTS. Any wrong choice of parts must visibly distort the family of unentangled states, and we derive exactly how much, at every system size: closed-form constants (verified to seven decimal places), an explicit error bound, and a surprise. The two natural ways to measure "wrongness" (state distortion versus operator scrambling) turn out to be literally the same measurement, up to a fixed number, whenever the two parts have equal size. Wrongness cannot hide. (2) THE TWO-OPERATION THRESHOLD. You can pin down what your subsystems are by implementing just TWO generic operations and checking their statistics, while a THOUSAND mutually commuting operations tell you nothing at all. Diversity of control, not volume of control, is what fixes what your qubits are. The residual uncertainty is proportional to your measurement tolerance, with a constant we derive exactly and show how to compute in advance, so an experimenter can screen candidate operation pairs and pick a strong one (random pairs are typically several times worse, occasionally catastrophically so). (3) THE ALIASING LIMIT: CERTIFICATION CAN PASS WHILE TELLING YOU NOTHING. If you sample your certification data at special "resonant" times (set by the operations' energy scales), a maximally wrong assignment of subsystems passes the test perfectly. What your qubits are depends on when you looked. We characterize these blind spots exactly (for qubits they are universal and computable in advance; the danger windows shrink with the square root of your tolerance), and the fix costs almost nothing: sample at two different times, at least one away from the resonant set. With that, certification is restored; we prove it exactly and measure it. (4) REAL-LAB BUDGETS. We work out what certification costs in actual measurement shots (the error falls off unusually fast, inversely with the total number of shots rather than with its square root), how hardware noise floors the procedure, and how a simple reference measurement removes that floor to first order. A single seven-row table in the paper is effectively a lab protocol: it shows, condition by condition, which kinds of experimental access identify the subsystem structure (two generic operations: yes; one operation, commuting operations, resonant sampling: no). WHY IT MATTERS. For quantum hardware: this is a concrete recipe for certifying that the qubits you think you have are the qubits you physically have, with explicit tolerances, a sampling-time warning that is a real failure mode on calibrated hardware, and shot budgets. For foundations: the contested question "does physics determine its own subsystems?" gets a quantitative operational answer. Physics determines an operational subsystem CLASS (not one preferred coordinate representation of it), and that class is fixed by two operations sampled at two times, and by nothing less that we tested. WHAT IT OPENS UP. The seven-row identifiability table is a blueprint for a tabletop experiment on any small quantum platform; running it on hardware would move this from simulation to laboratory fact. On the theory side the paper leaves sharply posed open problems: the exact global constants when the two parts differ in size, the number-theoretic structure of long-time sampling (the failure times form a small-divisor hierarchy), and the extension from two parts to many. METHODS NOTE, BECAUSE IT MATTERS FOR TRUST. Every quantitative claim was pre-registered in the companion scripts before its run. The full ledger, including predictions that failed and one published-in-note constant that our own later theory overturned, is an appendix of the paper. All code, data, and working notes are in the deposit, seeded for exact reproduction. WHO AND HOW. A human-AI collaboration: research direction and standards of evidence by Ryan Cardwell (Crystalline Labs); design, code, derivations, and drafting by Claude (Anthropic), including autonomous sessions under the program's pre-registration rules, with adversarial reviews by other AI models incorporated and credited.
Calibrated support observations can constrain a complete quantum instrument without identifying its action by unrestricted tomography. We study what those observations guarantee when the noise law is not supplied. On a fixed four-dimensional incidence-record experiment, we define the set of all complete two-outcome completely positive instruments compatible with the exact raw rejection and outcome probabilities, retaining the classical flags. Exact ideal data identify the target, but an explicit family of complete instruments reproduces the nonzero-data category laws of a low-error contamination device while admitting coherent error of square-root order. A target-ray mass certificate and a common complete-dilation comparison give a universal upper, while an exactly feasible rational instrument supplies a stronger lower witness. At the diagnostic parameter r = 1/300000000, the unhalved target-relative worst-case radius lies between 0.000258065115532250 and 0.000951566242566. The result separates avoidable inequality conservatism from information absent from the measured data. Fixed-functional and fixed-map optimizations have separately certified scopes; they do not solve the global radius. The conclusions are conditional on the supplied carrier, calibration and common-device model. They do not establish an apparatus, device-independent certification, a finite-sample power guarantee or complete formal verification. Selected supporting declarations have one recorded successful Lean 4.19.0 macOS execution and declaration-specific source, type and axiom review; this is not an end-to-end formalization.
A usual assumption in quantum estimation is that the unknown parameter labels the possible states of the system, while it influences neither the sample space of outcomes nor the measurement aimed at extracting information on the parameter itself. This assumption is crucial to prove the quantum Cram\'er-Rao theorem and to introduce the quantum Fisher information as an upper bound to the Fisher information of any possible measurement. However, there are relevant estimation problems where this assumption does not hold and an alternative approach should be developed to find the genuine ultimate bound to precision of quantum measurements. We investigate physical situations where there is an intrinsic dependence of the measurement strategy on the parameter and find that quantum-enhanced measurements may be more precise than previously thought.