Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Reconstructing the Canonical Commutation Relation from a Correlation Matrix: From Three Technical Assumptions to \([X,P]=i\hbar\)

Yunlong Guan

Published Jul 9, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The canonical commutation relation \([X,P]=i\hbar\) is a fundamental postulate of quantum mechanics. This paper presents a rigorous reconstruction of this relation from an alternative algebraic starting point: a correlation matrix defined on an abstract index set, supplemented by three technical assumptions regarding its spectral inverse and an emergent distance. The system relaxes to a translation-invariant state, where the correlation matrix acquires a Toeplitz structure. The equidistance constraint enforced by uniform correlations selects a uniform lattice in the continuum limit via \(\Gamma\)-convergence. On this lattice, the Toeplitz matrix is diagonalized by the discrete Fourier transform, yielding a plane-wave basis. Translation symmetry yields the momentum operator; Fourier duality yields the position operator. The commutator \([X,P]=i\hbar\) is recovered as an algebraic corollary of the Toeplitz geometry and Fourier duality. The existence of a minimal nonzero action scale \(\hbar\) arises from the topology of the compactification core (\(S^3\), Hopf invariant \(c_1=1\)); its precise numerical value is not required for this derivation. The Hilbert space structure itself—the inner product, completeness of the basis, and the dual representation of observables—emerges naturally from the same Toeplitz–Fourier geometry. This paper does not claim a derivation from deeper principles—rather, it demonstrates that, given the three stated assumptions, the CCR can be rigorously recovered without postulating it as an independent axiom of quantum mechanics. ORCID: 0009-0007-1999-0293 Email: 1352533302@qq.com

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.21284594

Related papers

Revisiting the Algebraic and Analytic Descriptions of Quantum Mechanics

Ortwin Fromm, Felicitas Ehlen

The Wintner-Wielandt theorem exposes a fundamental incompatibility between the canonical commutation relation (CCR) and the Hilbert-space formulation of quantum mechanics. While the conventional approach preserves the CCR by extending the Hilbert-space framework to a rigged Hilbert space, this work develops the complementary alternative. Retaining the Hilbert space, the unavoidable trace obstruction requires a boundary modification of the CCR, consistently realizable only in a space of finite, albeit arbitrarily large, dimension. In this setting, the eigenvalue problems of position and momentum admit explicit solutions within the Hilbert space. We show that the highest-energy components of the position eigenvectors retain a non-vanishing uniform weight, implying that the full spectrum remains relevant. The resulting autonomous matrix algebra also yields a new physical observable, the action difference. In the position basis, this observable gives rise to a momentum matrix with a discrete Cauchy kernel. After an alternating phase transformation, this matrix acts on plane waves in the infinite equidistant lattice model as the Schroedinger momentum operator, revealing a structural connection between the algebraic and analytic approaches. This framework retains the standard Hilbert-space spectral theory and remains closely connected to the familiar analytical structure of quantum mechanics, including the momentum operator and the uncertainty principle.

arXiv:2602.14126•Feb 15, 2026•0 citations

Position--Momentum Duality as Spectral Diagonalization of Bilocal Propagation A Continuation of the Action--Phase Program

Jonatan P. camargo

The objective of this work is to investigate whether the position--momentum duality can be reformulated, without ad hoc hypotheses and without circular reasoning, as a direct consequence of the spectral structure of bilocal unitary propagation. We start from the architecture already established in the Action--Phase program: the physical phase is given by \(\phi=S/\hbar\); self-adjoint structural operators organize the dynamics on a discrete lattice; such operators admit interpretation as unitary filters via Cayley realization; and the discrete unitary evolution can be written exactly as propagation by a bilocal kernel \(W(x,y)\). The central question is to determine under what hypotheses this bilocal kernel can be represented as a function of a self-adjoint structural operator, \[ \hat W=f(\hat H), \qquad \hat H=\hat H^\dagger, \] and how this structure implies the existence of an intrinsic spectral basis in which the propagation becomes diagonal. It is shown, step by step, that the spectral decomposition of \(\hat H\) induces a corresponding decomposition of the kernel, \[ W(x,y)=\sum_n f(\lambda_n)\,\phi_n(x)\phi_n^*(y), \] so that the unitary evolution begins to act multiplicatively on the spectral modes, \[ \widetilde\Psi_n(t+\Delta t)=f(\lambda_n)\widetilde\Psi_n(t), \] without the introduction of additional structures. In the homogeneous case, it is demonstrated that the eigenfunctions of the structural operator are discrete Fourier modes and that the continuous spectral parameter coincides with the usual wavenumber. In this regime, the spectral representation exactly reproduces the momentum sector of standard quantum mechanics. Outside this case, ``momentum'' is reinterpreted more generally as the spectral coordinate of the operator generating the propagation. The result of this stage is, therefore, conceptually precise: the position--momentum duality does not need to be postulated as an ontological duplication, but emerges as a duality between the nodal basis and the spectral basis of the same structural operator that governs the unitary propagation. The work does not intend, at this stage, to completely reconstruct the theory of canonical observables, nor to definitively resolve multiparticle systems or formulate a general covariant theory. Its role is to establish the minimum layer in which the spectral structure of propagation provides the mathematical origin of position--momentum duality, opening a controlled continuation program for these problems.

•Apr 6, 2026•0 citations

Real-commutant phase selection from real Hilbert representations

Mohamed Haj Yousef

Complex Hilbert space is usually assumed at the start of quantum mechanics. This paper formulates a reverse construction for the one-particle and operator-algebraic setting. Starting from a real Hilbert space carrying an orthogonal representation, the admissible imaginary units are identified with the skew-adjoint square roots of − Id in the Real commutant of the complexified representation. The novelty is not the isolated use of complexification, spectral orientation, or polar decomposition, but their order of dependence: first the symmetry representation defines an intrinsic operator-valued phase space; then an oriented internal time flow selects a distinguished point of that phase space; only afterward are the usual complex one-particle, observable, probability, and Weyl–CCR structures invoked under their standard hypotheses. In the terminology used here, this oriented internal flow is the reversible or inner-generative side of a dual-time distinction. It is not a second observer clock and not an additional Lorentzian coordinate: mathematically it is the strongly continuous orthogonal group U ( t ) = exp ( t A ) on the real Hilbert space. Its Stone-dual variable is energy/frequency λ ; canonical conjugation pairs λ with − λ ; positive energy orients this pair and selects the canonical phase on the dynamic sector through A = J | A | = | A | J . Thus inner-generative time is the source of phase orientation, while irreversible record time, projection, memory, and decoherence enter only as later reduced-dynamics layers. No spectral gap at zero is required, and zero modes remain visible as residual phase data rather than being hidden by the construction. The selected phase is invariant under time-orientation-preserving symmetries and changes sign under time reversal, giving the usual antiunitary action after complex reconstruction. The paper also makes explicit the monoidal limitation: two selected local phases do not make the raw real tensor product the standard composite system; the standard composite is recovered only after imposing the J -balanced, equivalently complex, tensor product rule. Thus the result is a reconstruction of compatible complex kinematics on the selected one-particle/operator-algebraic sector, not a derivation of all quantum foundations from purely real data.

Physics Letters A•Aug 13, 2026•0 citations

The Dual Dynamical Foundation of Orthodox Quantum Mechanics

Diana Taschetto, Ricardo Correa da Silva

This paper combines mathematical, philosophical, and historical analyses in a comprehensive investigation of the dynamical foundations of the formalism of orthodox quantum mechanics. The results obtained include: (i) A deduction of the canonical commutation relations (CCR) from the tenets of Matrix Mechanics; (ii) A discussion of the meaning of Schrödinger's first derivation of the wave equation that not only improves on Joas and Lehner's 2009 investigation on the subject, but also demonstrates that the CCR follow of necessity from Schrödinger's first derivation of the wave equation, thus correcting the common misconception that the CCR were only posited by Schrödinger to pursue equivalence with Matrix Mechanics; (iii) A discussion of the mathematical facts and requirements involved in the equivalence of Matrix and Wave Mechanics that improves on F. A. Muller's classical treatment of the subject; (iv) A proof that the equivalence of Matrix and Wave Mechanics is necessitated by the formal requirements of a dual action functional from which both the dynamical postulates of orthodox quantum mechanics, von Neumann's process 1 and process 2, follow; (v) A critical assessment, based on (iii) and (iv), of von Neumann's construction of unified quantum mechanics over Hilbert space. Point (iv) is our main result. It brings to the open the important, but hitherto ignored, fact that orthodox quantum mechanics is no exception to the golden rule of physics that the dynamics of a physical theory must follow from the action functional. If orthodox quantum mechanics, based as it is on the assumption of the equivalence of Matrix and Wave Mechanics, has this "peculiar dual dynamics," as von Neumann called it, then this is so because by assuming the equivalence one has been assuming a peculiar dual action.

arXiv:2402.15031•Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A•Dec 28, 2024•1 citation

Fourier Transform, Dirac Commutator, Energy Conservation, and Correspondence Principle for Electrical Engineers

Christopher Jayun Ryu, Erhan Kudeki, Dong-Yeop Na +2 more

The canonical commutation relation is a fundamental postulate of the quantum theory regarding the operators needed in quantum description of physical observables. It is shown that the Fourier transform is derivable from this seemingly simple postulate along with the basic properties of the position and momentum operators. Further discussions on the canonical commutation relation reveal its connection to a more fundamental notion that energy must be conserved. This discussion also unveils the mathematical homomorphism between the classical and quantum theories for systems represented by sum separable Hamiltonians. Another link between the classical and quantum theories is established by the correspondence principle which states that the classical theory emerges from quantum theory in the limit of vanishingly small Planck constant. Finally, the quantum Maxwell’s equations, which have been derived in our previous works, are presented and briefly discussed, and the 3-D mode transform is derived that can be interpreted as a generalization of the Fourier transform. We present both the details and meanings of the 3-D mode transform which will serve as a foundation for a full 3-D quantum finite-difference time-domain method.

IEEE journal on multiscale and multiphysics computational techniques•Jan 1, 2022•3 citations

Quantum Mechanics from the Constraint Axiom: A Derivation from Octonionic Algebra

Murad Ahmadov

The complete mathematical structure of quantum mechanics is derived from first principles, tracing all fundamental results to the constraint axiom via octonionic algebra. Without postulates, empirical fitting, or measurement assumptions, the following results are established: (1) Quantum states must reside in a complex Hilbert space over the complex numbers. (2) The canonical commutation relation between position and momentum follows from octonionic non-commutativity together with holographic information bounds. (3) The Heisenberg uncertainty principle arises as a mathematical theorem from the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality. (4) The Schrödinger equation emerges from time translation symmetry. (5) Spin one-half arises from the structure of the relevant Clifford algebra. (6) The Pauli matrices originate from the quaternion subalgebra contained within the octonions. (7) The Born rule appears as the unique probability measure on complex projective space. Related resourcesAdditional preprints, theoretical frameworks, and ongoing work by the author are available at:https://murad-ahmadov.github.io/

•Mar 19, 2026•0 citations
Reconstructing the Canonical Commutation Relation from a Correlation Matrix: From Three Technical Assumptions to [X,P]=iℏ[X,P]=i\hbar[X,P]=iℏ
Abstract The canonical commutation relation ([X,P]=i\hbar) is a fundamental postulate of quantum mechanics. This paper presents a rigorous reconstruction of this relation from an alternative algebraic starting point: a correlation matrix defined on an abstract index set, supplemented by three technical assumptions regarding its spectral inverse and an emergent distance. The system relaxes to a translation-invariant state, where the correlation matrix acquires a Toeplitz structure. The equidistance constraint enforced by uniform correlations selects a uniform lattice in the continuum limit via (\Gamma)-convergence. On this lattice, the Toeplitz matrix is diagonalized by the discrete Fourier transform, yielding a plane-wave basis. Translation symmetry yields the momentum operator; Fourier duality yields the position operator. The commutator ([X,P]=i\hbar) is recovered as an algebraic corollary of the Toeplitz geometry and Fourier duality. The existence of a minimal nonzero action scale (\hbar) arises from the topology of the compactification core ((S^3), Hopf invariant (c_1=1)); its precise numerical value is not required for this derivation. The Hilbert space structure itself—the inner product, completeness of the basis, and the dual representation of observables—emerges naturally from the same Toeplitz–Fourier geometry. This paper does not claim a derivation from deeper principles—rather, it demonstrates that, given the three stated assumptions, the CCR can be rigorously recovered without postulating it as an independent axiom of quantum mechanics. ORCID: 0009-0007-1999-0293 Email: 1352533302@qq.com
The Wintner-Wielandt theorem exposes a fundamental incompatibility between the canonical commutation relation (CCR) and the Hilbert-space formulation of quantum mechanics. While the conventional approach preserves the CCR by extending the Hilbert-space framework to a rigged Hilbert space, this work develops the complementary alternative. Retaining the Hilbert space, the unavoidable trace obstruction requires a boundary modification of the CCR, consistently realizable only in a space of finite, albeit arbitrarily large, dimension. In this setting, the eigenvalue problems of position and momentum admit explicit solutions within the Hilbert space. We show that the highest-energy components of the position eigenvectors retain a non-vanishing uniform weight, implying that the full spectrum remains relevant. The resulting autonomous matrix algebra also yields a new physical observable, the action difference. In the position basis, this observable gives rise to a momentum matrix with a discrete Cauchy kernel. After an alternating phase transformation, this matrix acts on plane waves in the infinite equidistant lattice model as the Schroedinger momentum operator, revealing a structural connection between the algebraic and analytic approaches. This framework retains the standard Hilbert-space spectral theory and remains closely connected to the familiar analytical structure of quantum mechanics, including the momentum operator and the uncertainty principle.
The objective of this work is to investigate whether the position--momentum duality can be reformulated, without ad hoc hypotheses and without circular reasoning, as a direct consequence of the spectral structure of bilocal unitary propagation. We start from the architecture already established in the Action--Phase program: the physical phase is given by ϕ=S/ℏ\phi=S/\hbarϕ=S/ℏ; self-adjoint structural operators organize the dynamics on a discrete lattice; such operators admit interpretation as unitary filters via Cayley realization; and the discrete unitary evolution can be written exactly as propagation by a bilocal kernel W(x,y)W(x,y)W(x,y). The central question is to determine under what hypotheses this bilocal kernel can be represented as a function of a self-adjoint structural operator, W^=f(H^),H^=H^†, \hat W=f(\hat H), \qquad \hat H=\hat H^\dagger, W^=f(H^),H^=H^†, and how this structure implies the existence of an intrinsic spectral basis in which the propagation becomes diagonal. It is shown, step by step, that the spectral decomposition of H^\hat HH^ induces a corresponding decomposition of the kernel, W(x,y)=∑nf(λn) ϕn(x)ϕn∗(y), W(x,y)=\sum_n f(\lambda_n)\,\phi_n(x)\phi_n^*(y), W(x,y)=∑n​f(λn​)ϕn​(x)ϕn∗​(y), so that the unitary evolution begins to act multiplicatively on the spectral modes, Ψ~n(t+Δt)=f(λn)Ψ~n(t), \widetilde\Psi_n(t+\Delta t)=f(\lambda_n)\widetilde\Psi_n(t), Ψn​(t+Δt)=f(λn​)Ψn​(t), without the introduction of additional structures. In the homogeneous case, it is demonstrated that the eigenfunctions of the structural operator are discrete Fourier modes and that the continuous spectral parameter coincides with the usual wavenumber. In this regime, the spectral representation exactly reproduces the momentum sector of standard quantum mechanics. Outside this case, ``momentum'' is reinterpreted more generally as the spectral coordinate of the operator generating the propagation. The result of this stage is, therefore, conceptually precise: the position--momentum duality does not need to be postulated as an ontological duplication, but emerges as a duality between the nodal basis and the spectral basis of the same structural operator that governs the unitary propagation. The work does not intend, at this stage, to completely reconstruct the theory of canonical observables, nor to definitively resolve multiparticle systems or formulate a general covariant theory. Its role is to establish the minimum layer in which the spectral structure of propagation provides the mathematical origin of position--momentum duality, opening a controlled continuation program for these problems.
Complex Hilbert space is usually assumed at the start of quantum mechanics. This paper formulates a reverse construction for the one-particle and operator-algebraic setting. Starting from a real Hilbert space carrying an orthogonal representation, the admissible imaginary units are identified with the skew-adjoint square roots of − Id in the Real commutant of the complexified representation. The novelty is not the isolated use of complexification, spectral orientation, or polar decomposition, but their order of dependence: first the symmetry representation defines an intrinsic operator-valued phase space; then an oriented internal time flow selects a distinguished point of that phase space; only afterward are the usual complex one-particle, observable, probability, and Weyl–CCR structures invoked under their standard hypotheses. In the terminology used here, this oriented internal flow is the reversible or inner-generative side of a dual-time distinction. It is not a second observer clock and not an additional Lorentzian coordinate: mathematically it is the strongly continuous orthogonal group U ( t ) = exp ( t A ) on the real Hilbert space. Its Stone-dual variable is energy/frequency λ ; canonical conjugation pairs λ with − λ ; positive energy orients this pair and selects the canonical phase on the dynamic sector through A = J | A | = | A | J . Thus inner-generative time is the source of phase orientation, while irreversible record time, projection, memory, and decoherence enter only as later reduced-dynamics layers. No spectral gap at zero is required, and zero modes remain visible as residual phase data rather than being hidden by the construction. The selected phase is invariant under time-orientation-preserving symmetries and changes sign under time reversal, giving the usual antiunitary action after complex reconstruction. The paper also makes explicit the monoidal limitation: two selected local phases do not make the raw real tensor product the standard composite system; the standard composite is recovered only after imposing the J -balanced, equivalently complex, tensor product rule. Thus the result is a reconstruction of compatible complex kinematics on the selected one-particle/operator-algebraic sector, not a derivation of all quantum foundations from purely real data.
This paper combines mathematical, philosophical, and historical analyses in a comprehensive investigation of the dynamical foundations of the formalism of orthodox quantum mechanics. The results obtained include: (i) A deduction of the canonical commutation relations (CCR) from the tenets of Matrix Mechanics; (ii) A discussion of the meaning of Schrödinger's first derivation of the wave equation that not only improves on Joas and Lehner's 2009 investigation on the subject, but also demonstrates that the CCR follow of necessity from Schrödinger's first derivation of the wave equation, thus correcting the common misconception that the CCR were only posited by Schrödinger to pursue equivalence with Matrix Mechanics; (iii) A discussion of the mathematical facts and requirements involved in the equivalence of Matrix and Wave Mechanics that improves on F. A. Muller's classical treatment of the subject; (iv) A proof that the equivalence of Matrix and Wave Mechanics is necessitated by the formal requirements of a dual action functional from which both the dynamical postulates of orthodox quantum mechanics, von Neumann's process 1 and process 2, follow; (v) A critical assessment, based on (iii) and (iv), of von Neumann's construction of unified quantum mechanics over Hilbert space. Point (iv) is our main result. It brings to the open the important, but hitherto ignored, fact that orthodox quantum mechanics is no exception to the golden rule of physics that the dynamics of a physical theory must follow from the action functional. If orthodox quantum mechanics, based as it is on the assumption of the equivalence of Matrix and Wave Mechanics, has this "peculiar dual dynamics," as von Neumann called it, then this is so because by assuming the equivalence one has been assuming a peculiar dual action.
The canonical commutation relation is a fundamental postulate of the quantum theory regarding the operators needed in quantum description of physical observables. It is shown that the Fourier transform is derivable from this seemingly simple postulate along with the basic properties of the position and momentum operators. Further discussions on the canonical commutation relation reveal its connection to a more fundamental notion that energy must be conserved. This discussion also unveils the mathematical homomorphism between the classical and quantum theories for systems represented by sum separable Hamiltonians. Another link between the classical and quantum theories is established by the correspondence principle which states that the classical theory emerges from quantum theory in the limit of vanishingly small Planck constant. Finally, the quantum Maxwell’s equations, which have been derived in our previous works, are presented and briefly discussed, and the 3-D mode transform is derived that can be interpreted as a generalization of the Fourier transform. We present both the details and meanings of the 3-D mode transform which will serve as a foundation for a full 3-D quantum finite-difference time-domain method.
The complete mathematical structure of quantum mechanics is derived from first principles, tracing all fundamental results to the constraint axiom via octonionic algebra. Without postulates, empirical fitting, or measurement assumptions, the following results are established: (1) Quantum states must reside in a complex Hilbert space over the complex numbers. (2) The canonical commutation relation between position and momentum follows from octonionic non-commutativity together with holographic information bounds. (3) The Heisenberg uncertainty principle arises as a mathematical theorem from the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality. (4) The Schrödinger equation emerges from time translation symmetry. (5) Spin one-half arises from the structure of the relevant Clifford algebra. (6) The Pauli matrices originate from the quaternion subalgebra contained within the octonions. (7) The Born rule appears as the unique probability measure on complex projective space. Related resourcesAdditional preprints, theoretical frameworks, and ongoing work by the author are available at:https://murad-ahmadov.github.io/