Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

SIC-POVMs, a Stark Conjecture, and the 12th: A Formalization via Paraconsistent Belnap Multilattices

Christopher Mills

Published Jul 7, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper establishes, inside the Lean 4 proof assistant, a three-level formal identification. The levels are: (i) Belnap multilattice axioms for Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SIC-POVMs at $d=2^n$; (ii) the Zauner conjecture; and (iii) the mixed-signature Stark conjecture for the ray class field $K_d=\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{(d-3)(d+1)})$, a real-quadratic case of Hilbert's Twelfth Problem. Fiducials are unit-normalized and satisfy $(d+1)|\langle\psi,D_{a,b}\psi\rangle|^2=1$. The equivalence hilbert_embedding_equiv_zauner is proved by rfl: the Belnap embedding into $\mathbb{C}^{2^n}$ and the Zauner conjecture at $d=2^n$ are definitionally the same proposition. The Belnap skeleton (orbit size $4^n$, Frobenius closure $\mu\circ\delta=\mathrm{id}$, join-equiangularity, Born rule) contains zero sorries. Open arithmetic content is marked by named gap axioms for Stark units on WH frames; a proof of Stark would close all three levels at once. For dimension $d=12$ we prove SICPOVM_Exists 12 outright. We construct an exact fiducial in a finitely presented $\mathbb{Q}$-algebra, verify 143 overlap identities with native_decide, and transfer everything to $\mathbb{C}^{12}$ along a ring homomorphism. The theorem crystal_forces_d12_sic depends on no axiom beyond Lean 4's standard foundations and compiler trust. This is, to our knowledge, the first machine-checked SIC-POVM existence in any dimension. For the frontier dimension $d=2048=2^{11}$ the transport apparatus is formalized and sorry-free. It includes a forward map $\varphi\colon B^{\oplus 11}\to\mathbb{C}^{2048}$, a reduction $\psi$ with $\psi\circ\varphi=\mathrm{id}$, a conditional reduction to Stark, and a non-real character obstruction that blocks the false branch. Unconditional existence remains open; the machinery that surrounds it is closed.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.21251166

Related papers

From Ghost SICs to SIC-POVMs: A Galois Reduction of Zauner's Conjecture

Hassan Khodaiemehr

Symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measures (SIC-POVMs, or SICs) are optimal minimal measurements for quantum state tomography. Problem~1 of Horodecki, Rudnicki and Życzkowski's open problems in quantum information asks for SICs in infinitely many dimensions. By work of Appleby--Flammia--Kopp and Radchenko--Wheeler, ghost SICs, which satisfy the SIC equations with Hermiticity up to parity, exist unconditionally for $d\ge4$. We study the passage from ghosts to SICs. We compute all isolated points of the complexified SIC variety for $d=4,5,6$; exactly half are SICs. We prove that no symmetry of the SIC equations maps a ghost to a SIC, so the step is purely arithmetic, and that a SIC exists in dimension $d$ whenever the ghost overlap units satisfy a place law: each Galois conjugate is real or unimodular according to the infinite place of the real quadratic field $F$ below it. If the unit field is abelian over $F$, the place law is the Stark relation $c_-=κ$; equivalently, a Galois conjugate of an associated near-group fusion category is unitary exactly when it is pseudo-unitary. For $d$ a power of a prime $p\equiv5\pmod 6$ or of $3$, an infinite family, we prove that under the algebraic part of Stark's conjecture $c_-=κ$ is equivalent to the triviality of $κ$ on the Hilbert-class-field part of the unit field. That condition involves no complex conjugation, and it follows from a sign-free multiplet hypothesis. We state an explicit $GL_2$ reciprocity law for the squared ghost overlaps that implies $c_-=κ$, and we prove it for the computed algebraic overlaps in $d=5,7,11,15$ by Artin reciprocity and a check in every ray class. Zauner's conjecture remains open: the algebraic part of Stark's conjecture and the multiplet hypothesis are not proved here.

quant-pharXiv:2611.01524•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

SIC-POVMs and the Stark Conjectures

Gene S. Kopp

Abstract The existence of $d^2$ pairwise equiangular complex lines [equivalently, a symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measure (SIC-POVM)] in $d$-dimensional Hilbert space is known only for finitely many dimensions $d$. We prove that, if there exists a set of real units in a certain ray class field (depending on $d$) satisfying certain algebraic properties, a SIC-POVM exists, when $d$ is an odd prime congruent to 2 modulo 3. We give an explicit analytic formula that we expect to yield such a set of units. Our construction uses values of derivatives of zeta functions at $s=0$ and is closely connected to the Stark conjectures over real quadratic fields. We verify numerically that our construction yields SIC-POVMs in dimensions 5, 11, 17, and 23, and we give the first exact SIC-POVM in dimension 23.

arXiv:1807.05877•International Mathematics Research Notices•Jun 19, 2019•58 citations

The $2048$ Chrysopoeia: An Explicit Construction Program for the $d=2048$ SIC-POVM Moduli

Christopher Mills

Companion to the SIC–Stark–12th formalization, this paper lays out an explicit program for the diagonal moduli $N_k=|\psi_k|^2$ of the $d=2048$ SIC-POVM. It reports what direct computation has settled and what remains open. Five results are in place. The $a=0$ stratum reduces to a flat autocorrelation condition on the real moduli, a condition verified on $d=12$ to a residual near $10^{-58}$. Unconstrained numerical recovery is blocked by a genuine local minimum (residual $3.9\times 10^{-3}$). The moduli field is the real index-2 subfield, of degree $2^{27}$, of the ray class field of conductor $(d)\,\infty_1\infty_2$, calibrated on the $d=12$ fiducial where the moduli have degree 4 or 8 and generate a field of degree 16; its unramified ascent is verified to degree 128. Stark-unit $L$-values supply the moduli without building the full field, a method validated end to end on $d=12$. An integer norm sieve separates degenerate $S$-unit aliases by discriminant $-m_d$. Still open: the reduced character set for the 1024 moduli and unconditional existence.

•Jul 7, 2026•0 citations

SIC-POVMs from Stark units: Prime dimensions n 2 + 3

Marcus Appleby, Ingemar Bengtsson, Markus Grassl +2 more

We propose a recipe for constructing a fiducial vector for a symmetric informationally complete positive operator valued measure (SIC-POVM) in a complex Hilbert space of dimension of the form d = n2 + 3, focusing on prime dimensions d = p. Such structures are shown to exist in 13 prime dimensions of this kind, the highest being p = 19 603. The real quadratic base field K (in the standard SIC-POVM terminology) attached to such dimensions has fundamental units uK of norm −1. Let ZK denote the ring of integers of K; then, pZK splits into two ideals: p and p′. The initial entry of the fiducial is the square ξ2 of a geometric scaling factor ξ, which lies in one of the fields K(uK). Strikingly, each of the other p − 1 entries of the fiducial vector is a product of ξ and the square root of a Stark unit. These Stark units are obtained via the Stark conjectures from the value at s = 0 of the first derivatives of partial L-functions attached to the characters of the ray class group of ZK with modulus p∞1, where ∞1 is one of the real places of K.

arXiv:2112.05552•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 2022•20 citations

A Conjecture on Almost Flat SIC-POVMs

Ingemar Bengtsson, Markus Grassl

A well supported conjecture states that SIC-POVMs -- maximal sets of complex equiangular lines -- with anti-unitary symmetry give rise to an identity expressing some of its overlaps as squares of the (rescaled) components of a suitably chosen fiducial vector. In number theoretical terms the identity essentially expresses Stark units as sums of products of pairs of square roots of Stark units. We investigate whether the identity is enough to determine these Stark units. The answer is no, but the failure might be quite mild.

quant-pharXiv:2512.13201•Dec 16, 2025•2 citations

SIC-POVMs from Stark units: Dimensions n2 + 3 = 4p, p prime

Ingemar Bengtsson, Markus Grassl, Gary McConnell

The existence problem for maximal sets of equiangular lines (or SICs) in complex Hilbert space of dimension d remains largely open. In a previous publication we gave a conjectural algorithm for how to construct a SIC if d = n2 + 3 = p, a prime number. Perhaps the most surprising number-theoretical aspect of that algorithm is the appearance of Stark units in a key role: a single Stark unit from a ray class field extension of a real quadratic field serves as a seed from which the SIC is constructed. The algorithm can be modified to apply to all dimensions d = n2 + 3. Here we focus on the case when d = n2 + 3 = 4p, p prime, for two reasons. First, special measures have to be taken on the Hilbert space side of the problem when the dimension is even. Second, the degrees of the relevant ray class fields are “smooth” in a sense that facilitates exact calculations. As a result the algorithm becomes easier to explain. We give solutions for 17 different dimensions of this form, reaching d = 39 604. Several improvements relative to our previous publication are reported, but we cannot offer a proof that the algorithm works for any dimensions where it has not been tested.

arXiv:2403.02872•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 2025•15 citations
This paper establishes, inside the Lean 4 proof assistant, a three-level formal identification. The levels are: (i) Belnap multilattice axioms for Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SIC-POVMs at d=2nd=2^nd=2n; (ii) the Zauner conjecture; and (iii) the mixed-signature Stark conjecture for the ray class field Kd=Q((d−3)(d+1))K_d=\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{(d-3)(d+1)})Kd​=Q((d−3)(d+1)​), a real-quadratic case of Hilbert's Twelfth Problem. Fiducials are unit-normalized and satisfy (d+1)∣⟨ψ,Da,bψ⟩∣2=1(d+1)|\langle\psi,D_{a,b}\psi\rangle|^2=1(d+1)∣⟨ψ,Da,b​ψ⟩∣2=1. The equivalence hilbert_embedding_equiv_zauner is proved by rfl: the Belnap embedding into C2n\mathbb{C}^{2^n}C2n and the Zauner conjecture at d=2nd=2^nd=2n are definitionally the same proposition. The Belnap skeleton (orbit size 4n4^n4n, Frobenius closure μ∘δ=id\mu\circ\delta=\mathrm{id}μ∘δ=id, join-equiangularity, Born rule) contains zero sorries. Open arithmetic content is marked by named gap axioms for Stark units on WH frames; a proof of Stark would close all three levels at once. For dimension d=12d=12d=12 we prove SICPOVM_Exists 12 outright. We construct an exact fiducial in a finitely presented Q\mathbb{Q}Q-algebra, verify 143 overlap identities with native_decide, and transfer everything to C12\mathbb{C}^{12}C12 along a ring homomorphism. The theorem crystal_forces_d12_sic depends on no axiom beyond Lean 4's standard foundations and compiler trust. This is, to our knowledge, the first machine-checked SIC-POVM existence in any dimension. For the frontier dimension d=2048=211d=2048=2^{11}d=2048=211 the transport apparatus is formalized and sorry-free. It includes a forward map φ ⁣:B⊕11→C2048\varphi\colon B^{\oplus 11}\to\mathbb{C}^{2048}φ:B⊕11→C2048, a reduction ψ\psiψ with ψ∘φ=id\psi\circ\varphi=\mathrm{id}ψ∘φ=id, a conditional reduction to Stark, and a non-real character obstruction that blocks the false branch. Unconditional existence remains open; the machinery that surrounds it is closed.
Symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measures (SIC-POVMs, or SICs) are optimal minimal measurements for quantum state tomography. Problem~1 of Horodecki, Rudnicki and Życzkowski's open problems in quantum information asks for SICs in infinitely many dimensions. By work of Appleby--Flammia--Kopp and Radchenko--Wheeler, ghost SICs, which satisfy the SIC equations with Hermiticity up to parity, exist unconditionally for d≥4d\ge4d≥4. We study the passage from ghosts to SICs. We compute all isolated points of the complexified SIC variety for d=4,5,6d=4,5,6d=4,5,6; exactly half are SICs. We prove that no symmetry of the SIC equations maps a ghost to a SIC, so the step is purely arithmetic, and that a SIC exists in dimension ddd whenever the ghost overlap units satisfy a place law: each Galois conjugate is real or unimodular according to the infinite place of the real quadratic field FFF below it. If the unit field is abelian over FFF, the place law is the Stark relation c−=κc_-=κc−​=κ; equivalently, a Galois conjugate of an associated near-group fusion category is unitary exactly when it is pseudo-unitary. For ddd a power of a prime p≡5(mod6)p\equiv5\pmod 6p≡5(mod6) or of 333, an infinite family, we prove that under the algebraic part of Stark's conjecture c−=κc_-=κc−​=κ is equivalent to the triviality of κκκ on the Hilbert-class-field part of the unit field. That condition involves no complex conjugation, and it follows from a sign-free multiplet hypothesis. We state an explicit GL2GL_2GL2​ reciprocity law for the squared ghost overlaps that implies c−=κc_-=κc−​=κ, and we prove it for the computed algebraic overlaps in d=5,7,11,15d=5,7,11,15d=5,7,11,15 by Artin reciprocity and a check in every ray class. Zauner's conjecture remains open: the algebraic part of Stark's conjecture and the multiplet hypothesis are not proved here.
Abstract The existence of d2d^2d2 pairwise equiangular complex lines [equivalently, a symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measure (SIC-POVM)] in ddd-dimensional Hilbert space is known only for finitely many dimensions ddd. We prove that, if there exists a set of real units in a certain ray class field (depending on ddd) satisfying certain algebraic properties, a SIC-POVM exists, when ddd is an odd prime congruent to 2 modulo 3. We give an explicit analytic formula that we expect to yield such a set of units. Our construction uses values of derivatives of zeta functions at s=0s=0s=0 and is closely connected to the Stark conjectures over real quadratic fields. We verify numerically that our construction yields SIC-POVMs in dimensions 5, 11, 17, and 23, and we give the first exact SIC-POVM in dimension 23.
The 204820482048 Chrysopoeia: An Explicit Construction Program for the d=2048d=2048d=2048 SIC-POVM Moduli
Companion to the SIC–Stark–12th formalization, this paper lays out an explicit program for the diagonal moduli Nk=∣ψk∣2N_k=|\psi_k|^2Nk​=∣ψk​∣2 of the d=2048d=2048d=2048 SIC-POVM. It reports what direct computation has settled and what remains open. Five results are in place. The a=0a=0a=0 stratum reduces to a flat autocorrelation condition on the real moduli, a condition verified on d=12d=12d=12 to a residual near 10−5810^{-58}10−58. Unconstrained numerical recovery is blocked by a genuine local minimum (residual 3.9×10−33.9\times 10^{-3}3.9×10−3). The moduli field is the real index-2 subfield, of degree 2272^{27}227, of the ray class field of conductor (d) ∞1∞2(d)\,\infty_1\infty_2(d)∞1​∞2​, calibrated on the d=12d=12d=12 fiducial where the moduli have degree 4 or 8 and generate a field of degree 16; its unramified ascent is verified to degree 128. Stark-unit LLL-values supply the moduli without building the full field, a method validated end to end on d=12d=12d=12. An integer norm sieve separates degenerate SSS-unit aliases by discriminant −md-m_d−md​. Still open: the reduced character set for the 1024 moduli and unconditional existence.
We propose a recipe for constructing a fiducial vector for a symmetric informationally complete positive operator valued measure (SIC-POVM) in a complex Hilbert space of dimension of the form d = n2 + 3, focusing on prime dimensions d = p. Such structures are shown to exist in 13 prime dimensions of this kind, the highest being p = 19 603. The real quadratic base field K (in the standard SIC-POVM terminology) attached to such dimensions has fundamental units uK of norm −1. Let ZK denote the ring of integers of K; then, pZK splits into two ideals: p and p′. The initial entry of the fiducial is the square ξ2 of a geometric scaling factor ξ, which lies in one of the fields K(uK). Strikingly, each of the other p − 1 entries of the fiducial vector is a product of ξ and the square root of a Stark unit. These Stark units are obtained via the Stark conjectures from the value at s = 0 of the first derivatives of partial L-functions attached to the characters of the ray class group of ZK with modulus p∞1, where ∞1 is one of the real places of K.
A well supported conjecture states that SIC-POVMs -- maximal sets of complex equiangular lines -- with anti-unitary symmetry give rise to an identity expressing some of its overlaps as squares of the (rescaled) components of a suitably chosen fiducial vector. In number theoretical terms the identity essentially expresses Stark units as sums of products of pairs of square roots of Stark units. We investigate whether the identity is enough to determine these Stark units. The answer is no, but the failure might be quite mild.
The existence problem for maximal sets of equiangular lines (or SICs) in complex Hilbert space of dimension d remains largely open. In a previous publication we gave a conjectural algorithm for how to construct a SIC if d = n2 + 3 = p, a prime number. Perhaps the most surprising number-theoretical aspect of that algorithm is the appearance of Stark units in a key role: a single Stark unit from a ray class field extension of a real quadratic field serves as a seed from which the SIC is constructed. The algorithm can be modified to apply to all dimensions d = n2 + 3. Here we focus on the case when d = n2 + 3 = 4p, p prime, for two reasons. First, special measures have to be taken on the Hilbert space side of the problem when the dimension is even. Second, the degrees of the relevant ray class fields are “smooth” in a sense that facilitates exact calculations. As a result the algorithm becomes easier to explain. We give solutions for 17 different dimensions of this form, reaching d = 39 604. Several improvements relative to our previous publication are reported, but we cannot offer a proof that the algorithm works for any dimensions where it has not been tested.