Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Can Quantum Mechanics Work Without Imaginary Numbers? A Critical Examination of the Role of Complex Numbers in the Quantum Description of Nature

Ijaz Durrani

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.13140/rg.2.2.33056.96004

Related papers

Complex numbers, quantum mechanics and reality

International Journal of Latest Trends in Engineering and Technology•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

The mystery of square root of minus one in quantum mechanics, and its demystification

C.P. Kwong

To most physicists, quantum mechanics must embrace the imaginary number i = square root of minus one is at least a common belief if not a mystery. We use the famous example pq -qp = h/(2 pi i) to demonstrate the possible elimination of i when constructing this noncommutative relationship. We then discuss the role of i in the formulation of Schroedinger's wave equation. Common to the original development of these two quantum theories was the use of complex exponential to represent the fundamental variables (i.e., p, q, and the wave function). Understanding this complex function from the right perspective, as we suggest in this essay, removes the mysteries surrounding the complex nature of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:0912.3996•Dec 20, 2009•3 citations

Why is quantum physics based on complex numbers?

Felix M. Lev

arXiv:hep-th/0309003•Finite Fields and Their Applications•Sep 15, 2005•21 citations

On quantum tunneling in real time

Neil Turok

A detailed real time description of quantum tunneling in the semiclassical limit is given, using complex classical trajectories. This picture connects naturally with the ideas of post-selection and weak measurement introduced by Aharonov and collaborators. I show that one can precisely identify the complex classical trajectory which a post-selected tunneling particle has followed, and which dominates the path integral in the limit as Planck's constant tends to zero. Detailed analytical calculations are presented for tunneling in cubic and quartic potentials. For a long post-selected tunneling time, the imaginary part of the tunneling coordinate is found to achieve very large values just before the particle tunnels. I discuss how the real and imaginary parts of the particle's coordinate may, in principle, be independently measured using weak measurements. It would be very interesting to observe this effect, which would demonstrate the essential role of complex numbers in our closest possible classical description of reality. Extensions to quantum field theory and general relativity are briefly discussed.

arXiv:1312.1772•New Journal of Physics•Jun 5, 2014•51 citations

Geometric Law of Quantum Mechanics and the Imaginary Unit

Kwon, Se Kyun

Mathematically, the imaginary unit 𝑖 has long been regarded as an algebraic generator extending the real numbers to the complex field. Yet a century after the birth of quantum mechanics (1925–2025), the answer to its oldest question is now clear: quantum mechanics is not merely a mathematical structure—it is a physical reality, and all quantities appearing in its non-commutative relations are physical. Therefore, 𝑖 is not a mere algebraic extension but the universal operator demanded by the geometric completeness of non-commutative reality between position and momentum. The imaginary unit is a physical reality. The canonical relation [𝑥, 𝑝] = 𝑖ℏ is not merely algebraic—it is a geometric law, showing that the complex structure of quantum mechanics arises inevitably from physical reality itself. It stands without contradiction, without complexity. This is nature. In the (𝑥, 𝑝) plane, 𝑖 represents a 90° rotation and ℏ quantizes the curvature of that rotation. Complex numbers thus arise as the natural geometric language of non-commutative physics, providing a geometric resolution to the century-old question of physical completeness first raised by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (1935).

•Nov 14, 2025•0 citations

On the statistical meaning of complex numbers in quantum mechanics

Luigi Accardi, Aniello Fedullo

Lettere al nuovo cimento della societa italiana di fisica/Lettere al nuovo cimento•Jun 1, 1982•122 citations
To most physicists, quantum mechanics must embrace the imaginary number i = square root of minus one is at least a common belief if not a mystery. We use the famous example pq -qp = h/(2 pi i) to demonstrate the possible elimination of i when constructing this noncommutative relationship. We then discuss the role of i in the formulation of Schroedinger's wave equation. Common to the original development of these two quantum theories was the use of complex exponential to represent the fundamental variables (i.e., p, q, and the wave function). Understanding this complex function from the right perspective, as we suggest in this essay, removes the mysteries surrounding the complex nature of quantum mechanics.
A detailed real time description of quantum tunneling in the semiclassical limit is given, using complex classical trajectories. This picture connects naturally with the ideas of post-selection and weak measurement introduced by Aharonov and collaborators. I show that one can precisely identify the complex classical trajectory which a post-selected tunneling particle has followed, and which dominates the path integral in the limit as Planck's constant tends to zero. Detailed analytical calculations are presented for tunneling in cubic and quartic potentials. For a long post-selected tunneling time, the imaginary part of the tunneling coordinate is found to achieve very large values just before the particle tunnels. I discuss how the real and imaginary parts of the particle's coordinate may, in principle, be independently measured using weak measurements. It would be very interesting to observe this effect, which would demonstrate the essential role of complex numbers in our closest possible classical description of reality. Extensions to quantum field theory and general relativity are briefly discussed.
Mathematically, the imaginary unit 𝑖 has long been regarded as an algebraic generator extending the real numbers to the complex field. Yet a century after the birth of quantum mechanics (1925–2025), the answer to its oldest question is now clear: quantum mechanics is not merely a mathematical structure—it is a physical reality, and all quantities appearing in its non-commutative relations are physical. Therefore, 𝑖 is not a mere algebraic extension but the universal operator demanded by the geometric completeness of non-commutative reality between position and momentum. The imaginary unit is a physical reality. The canonical relation [𝑥, 𝑝] = 𝑖ℏ is not merely algebraic—it is a geometric law, showing that the complex structure of quantum mechanics arises inevitably from physical reality itself. It stands without contradiction, without complexity. This is nature. In the (𝑥, 𝑝) plane, 𝑖 represents a 90° rotation and ℏ quantizes the curvature of that rotation. Complex numbers thus arise as the natural geometric language of non-commutative physics, providing a geometric resolution to the century-old question of physical completeness first raised by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (1935).