Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of anomalistics

Macroscopic Complementarity Between Subjective and Objective Food Image Assessments

Markus Maier, Anastasia Vogel, Moritz C. Dechamps

Published Jun 22, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT) proposes that subjective experiences and objective physical measurements constitute macroscopic complementary subsystems related through acausal, non-local entanglement correlations. The non-commutability conjecture of the GQT predicts that measurement within one subsystem modifies the state of the entire system, including the eigenvalues of the complementary subsystem. Maier and Dechamps (2025) provided preliminary evidence for this conjecture by demonstrating that the storage (non-erasure) versus erasure of objective color parameters (hue and lightness) systematically affected subjective likability ratings across four studies (higher subjective likability mean score in the non-erasure compared to the erasure condition). The present research conceptually replicated these color-erasure findings in a different stimulus domain. In four studies (total N = 647), participants rated photographs of food dishes on subjective tastiness while the objective food parameters (calorie values and stimulus IDs) were either stored (non-erasure condition) or permanently deleted (erasure condition). As in the color studies, limited stimulus sets were fixedly assigned to conditions within each study, deliberately introducing a stimulus-bias confound to protect the acausal complementary relation from the destructive impact of the non-transmission (NT) axiom. Following a predefined three-step analysis plan, preregistered Study 1 (Step 1) documented a strong erasure effect on tastiness ratings. Participants evaluated food dishes as more appetizing in the non-erasure compared to the erasure condition (BF10 = 1309.22, d = .66), and Studies 2a–2c (Step 2) replicated this effect with three independently drawn stimulus sets (BF10s ranging from 10.40 to 26 × 10¹⁵, ds ranging from .26 to .50). In Step 3, preregistered overall analyses including a stratified permutation test (p = .002), a multilevel model (β = 4.72, p = .011), and sensitivity analyses ruled out the biased stimulus assignment alternative. These findings provide cross-domain evidence for the non-commutability conjecture: the documentation of objective stimulus parameters appears to acausally co-relate with subjective evaluations, consistent with macroscopic complementary relations as proposed by the GQT. The implications for substance dualism, physicalism, and dual-aspect monism are discussed.

DOI
10.23793/zfa.2026.037

Related papers

Macroscopic Complementary Relation Between Subjective Observations and Objective Measurements of Colors

Markus A. Maier, Moritz C. Dechamps

In the Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT), a theory designed to describe psychophysical phenomena, the subjective and objective aspects of reality are considered to be complementary. The research presented here focused on investigating such a macroscopic complementarity between subjective and objective reality descriptions within the context of color assessment. In particular, the non-commutability conjecture of the GQT posits that two observables derived from the subjective and objective subsystems do not simultaneously provide specific eigenvalues. Rather, the act of measurement within one subsystem, e. g. the performance of objective measurements on a stimulus, modifies the state of the entire system, including the eigenvalues of the other subsystem, e. g. the subjective experience of this stimulus. This conjecture was tested empirically in four studies and in three overall analyses of the complete data set combining all four studies. The experimental manipulation involved a measurement variation of one aspect of the supposed complementary pair, namely the storage (non-erasure condition) or deletion (erasure condition) of objective color parameters (hue and lightness). It was anticipated that the erasure manipulation would influence the other part of the pair, namely the subjective evaluations of color with respect to brightness and likability. The primary hypothesis, which tested erasure-dependent effects on variations in subjective brightness scores was confirmed in Studies 1 and 2 but could not be replicated in Studies 3 and 4. The initial findings obtained with this dependent variable can thus be considered false positives and the primary hypothesis could not be confirmed. However, the second hypothesis, which tested erasure-effects on subjective likability mean scores revealed the following results: The exploratory findings from Studies 1 and 2, as well as the confirmatory findings from Studies 3 and the preregistered Study 4, indicated an erasure effect on subjective likability, whereby higher likability scores were observed in the non-erasure condition compared to the erasure condition in each study. Since the experimental design was intentionally contaminated by a “color bias” alternative explanation to stabilize the effect documentation, a clear causal erasure interpretation cannot be provided at the single study level. To overcome this contamination an overall analysis strategy was pre-planned and performed on the combined data set. Several overall analyses ruled out the “color bias” alternative explanation and another confound. In conclusion, the overall results provided evidence for an erasure effect on subjective likability supporting the model of GQT. This can be interpreted as macroscopic complementary relations between objective and subjective reality descriptions as proposed by the GQT. The implications of these findings for our understanding of the nature of reality and for the validity of the GQT are discussed.

Journal of anomalistics•Jul 24, 2025•2 citations

Non-Classical Correlation Between Subjective and Objective Color Observations

Markus Maier, Anastasia Vogel, Johannes Storch +1 more

In recent research testing the non-commutability conjecture of the Generalized Quantum Theory, Maier and Dechamps (2025) reported macroscopic complementary relations empirically documented as non-classical correlations between subjective assessment of likability of colors and variations of objective documentations of these colors. Specifically, they found higher likability mean scores in a condition where objective color parameters were not erased and stored in a result file compared to a condition in which these parameters were erased and inaccessible by experimenters. This effect was robust across four studies. Each study’s design in this series of experiments was intentionally confounded with a “color bias” variable. Only limited sets of colors after random creation were specifically assigned to one of the two conditions, so that the effect of the erasure manipulation could alternatively be explained by the specific features of the colors assigned to conditions (the confound was later statistically ruled out by permutations). The presence of a confound was introduced to avoid the impact of the NT axiom, which forbids a strict causal testing approach. Rather, according to the NT axiom when macroscopic complementary relations are tested in a strictly causal way, initial effect documentations should be followed by a decline within and across studies. In the study presented here, the studies of Maier and Dechamps (2025) were conceptually replicated by a strict, i. e. unconfounded, causal testing strategy, to explicitly test the proposed impact of the NT axiom. In two experimental conditions (within-subjects) objective color parameters were either stored or not stored. Assignment of colors to conditions was randomized on the participant level this time ensuring an unconfounded design. The prediction derived from the NT axiom was that under such circumstances the erasure-dependent likability effect should initially be found and later drastically decline. The results supported this prediction: A higher likability mean score was initially found in the non-erasure compared to the erasure condition with strong Bayesian evidence (BF10 = 39.77), replicating the previous findings but now followed by a decline within the study. These findings are in line with the conjectures of the GQT. Specifically, they indicate that subjective assessments and objective measurements of colors are non-commutable and that the data follow the predictions of the NT axiom exhibiting an “effect and decline” data pattern when strictly causally tested. An additional permutation analysis showed that the probability to find such an effect and decline data pattern by chance was very low (p < .03) indicating that it could hardly be interpreted as “false positive” finding. The impact of this and the previous results on the validity of the GQT in describing psychophysical relations as non-classical correlations between spatio-temporally separated subjective assessments and objective measurements of colors is discussed.

Journal of anomalistics•Jun 22, 2026•0 citations

Color Erasure - Replication

Moritz C. Dechamps, Markus Maier

This study aims to conceptually replicate a previously observed "color values erasure effect" on subjective color preferences. The research investigates whether the storage or deletion of objective color data influences participants' subjective likability ratings of colors, as predicted by Generalized Quantum Theory's macroscopic complementarity principle. Purpose The primary purpose is to test whether participants rate colors as more likable when the objective color values are stored compared to when they are deleted immediately after data collection. This builds on four previous studies that demonstrated this erasure effect using limited color sets. The current study employs a within-subjects design where each participant evaluates 36 colors (18 in each condition) on a 101-point likability scale. Methodology Participants will view colors randomly selected from a 360-degree color circle (30-70% lightness range, 100% saturation) and rate how much they like each color. Crucially, participants remain unaware of the erasure manipulation. The same 18 colors will be assigned to the "stored" condition and the same 18 colors to the "deleted" condition across all participants - an intentional confound designed to avoid "strict causality tests" that theoretically might destroy the complementarity effect. Expected Outcomes We expect two main findings: (1) Higher mean likability ratings in the stored condition compared to the deleted condition (tested via sequential Bayesian analysis with BF > 10 criterion), and (2) The observed effect size should occur in less than 5% of random color-to-condition permutations, suggesting the effect is not simply due to color bias. The study will use sequential data collection up to N=5,000 participants, with smartphone use prohibited based on previous findings of reduced effect sizes on mobile devices.

•Jun 26, 2025•0 citations

Acausal Psychophysical Correlations in a Causally Closed World? Evidence from (Un)Confounded Erasure Paradigms and the Limits of Physicalist Methodology

Markus Maier, Moritz C. Dechamps

This response addresses commentaries by Thomas Rabeyron, Ian Tierney, and Harald Walach on two articles in this issue concerning macroscopic complementary relations between subjective and objective aspects of reality, framed within the Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT). The central concern shared by the commentators is whether the erasure-confound paradigm can robustly avoid the non-transmission (NT) axiom-induced decline that has affected earlier experimental paradigms in this research area. We argue that the NT axiom expresses an epistemic restriction arising whenever causal-deterministic documentation is applied to phenomena that contain an autonomous-subjective component. Under this reading, the erasure-confound paradigm achieves only a reduced-objective documentation of the effect at the single-study level, because the confound prevents an unambiguous causal interpretation, while the effect is established indirectly across studies through the exclusion of the alternative explanation (the “color selection bias” confound). This design decouples evidence accumulation from the arrow of time and is proposed to circumvent the decline. We then put the decline prediction to an empirical test by reporting three previously unpublished color-erasure-with-confound studies (Studies 5–7), which together with the four studies of Maier and Dechamps (2025) form the complete record of seven studies in this paradigm, with no file drawer. The erasure effect appeared in the predicted direction in every study (sign test p = .008), and combined stratified permutation analyses across three independent 36-color sets ruled out the color-selection-bias confound as a joint explanation (Fisher p = .010; Edgington p = .018). An inverse-variance weighted meta-regression on the seven effect sizes returned a non-significant downward slope (b = −0.018, 95% CI [−0.043, 0.006], one-tailed p = .07), and the seventh study yielded an effect still clearly present (BF₁₀ = 3,679.73, d = .30). The data are consistent with a stable, reduced-objectively documented acausal psychophysical correlation rather than the attrition predicted by the NT axiom under direct replication. Further specific points raised by individual commentators, such as the experimenter-psi interpretation and the choice of subjective and objective measurements, are addressed in shorter form.

Journal of anomalistics•Jun 22, 2026•0 citations

Complementarity of subjective and objective realities: An experimental investigation of variations of subjective self-reported intelligence data when objective data are erased or not-erased

Markus Maier, Chantale Geißler, Emilia C. DeMattia +2 more

The Complementarity Principle (CP), introduced by Nils Bohr, described the wave-particle duality of quantum phenomena and its dependence on the measurement setup exploring the quantum states. In general, this principle summarized the fact that two mutually exclusive and contradictory states of quantum events can be reconciled as a measurement-dependent occurrence of these states. Originally, the CP was postulated only for the realm of quantum mechanics, but recently the Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT) extended its area of applicability to the macroscopic domain. According to GQT complementarity relations are also hypothesized to exist between macroscopic objective and subjective measurements of the same concept. This implies objective measurement-dependent variations of subjective experience. To test this hypothesis, seven studies were conducted in which individual variations in subjective intelligence ratings were tested in relation to the availability or non-availability of corresponding objective individual intelligence data. Only one pre-registered study (Study 2) showed strong Bayesian evidence for H1 (BF10 > 10), indicating, as predicted, higher subjective intelligence ratings when objective data were erased compared to a condition in which objective data were available within a male sample. This effect could not be replicated in direct replication attempts, nor did a moderator search in subsequent studies find any robust systematic variation in the data. The results seem to question the validity of the macroscopic complementarity conjecture derived from the GQT. On the other hand, they could also be interpreted as the “effect and decline” data pattern that the Model of Pragmatic Information would predict when conducting empirical confirmations of macroscopic complementarity relations. Possible future research strategies to clarify these different interpretations are discussed.

Journal of anomalistics•Jun 30, 2024•2 citations

Generalized Quantum Theory and the Falsification Gap: A Critical Evaluation Integrating Quantum Cognition and Contextuality-by-Default

Lukas Geiger

Abstract (English) Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT) and the Model of Pragmatic Information (MPI) seek to account for non-local correlations in macroscopic systems by positing formal isomorphisms with quantum-mechanical structures. Drawing on a narrative literature review (72 cited sources selected from more than 90 screened), this article evaluates the isomorphism approach in relation to quantum cognition, Contextuality-by-Default, and random matrix theory. The Correlation Matrix Method (CMM) is re-evaluated in light of Grote's critique, the non-significant replications in Nailing Jelly, and newer positive but methodologically mixed CMM findings, and candidate dependence-aware multiplicity procedures whose applicability remains to be checked. Two burden-of-proof criteria are formulated, but not executed on the target datasets in this paper; they specify analyses that any GQT-favourable reading must clear beforehand: a classical instrument baseline, following Tull & Ozawa's result that fixed-length sequential decision data satisfying no-signalling from the future admit a simple classical Markov instrument model, so that order, context, and measurement-disturbance effects carry no evidential weight of their own; and a schematic partition-logic ledger, following Svozil, which asks whether incompatible modes of inquiry over a value-definite latent state space can explain complementarity without genuine contextuality. In philosophy-of-science terms, GQT is provisionally positioned as a degenerating research programme in Lakatos's sense: the Non-Transmission Axiom generates a falsification gap that neither proponents nor critics have yet closed. One testable hypothesis proposed here is that the decline effect may reflect a statistical artifact that can be checked by re-analyzing existing CMM data with appropriately specified multiplicity methods. A productive future direction lies in convergence with quantum cognition and in falsifiable tests of macroscopic complementarity. Zusammenfassung (Deutsch) Die Generalisierte Quantentheorie (GQT) und das Modell der Pragmatischen Information (MPI) zielen darauf ab, nicht-lokale Korrelationen in makroskopischen Systemen durch formale Isomorphie mit quantenmechanischen Strukturen zu erklären. Auf Grundlage eines narrativen Literaturüberblicks (72 zitierte Quellen aus über 90 gesichteten Quellen) bewertet dieser Beitrag den Isomorphie-Ansatz unter Integration der Quantenkognition (Quantum Cognition), Contextuality-by-Default und Random-Matrix-Theorie neu. Die Korrelationsmatrix-Methode (CMM) wird im Licht der Grote-Kritik, der nicht signifikanten Replikationen in Nailing Jelly sowie neuer positiver, aber methodisch gemischter CMM-Befunde und möglicher abhängigkeitsbewusster Mehrfachtestverfahren mit noch zu prüfender Anwendbarkeit neu bewertet. Es werden zwei Beweislast-Kriterien formuliert, aber in diesem Beitrag nicht an den Zieldatensätzen ausgeführt; sie benennen Analysen, die jede GQT-freundliche Lesart zuvor passieren muss: eine klassische Instrument-Baseline nach dem Ergebnis von Tull & Ozawa, wonach sequentielle Entscheidungsdaten fester Länge mit No-Signalling aus der Zukunft ein einfaches klassisches Markov-Instrumentmodell zulassen, sodass Reihenfolge-, Kontext- und Messstörungseffekte für sich genommen keine Beweiskraft besitzen; sowie ein schematisches Partition-Logik-Ledger nach Svozil, das prüft, ob inkompatible Erhebungsmodi über einem wertdefiniten latenten Zustandsraum Komplementarität ohne echte Kontextualität erklären können. Die GQT wird wissenschaftsphilosophisch vorläufig als degenerierendes Forschungsprogramm im Lakatos'schen Sinne eingeordnet: Das Non-Transmission-Axiom erzeugt eine Falsifikationslücke, die weder Befürworter noch Kritiker bislang schließen konnten. Als zentrale testbare Hypothese wird formuliert, dass der Decline-Effekt ein statistisches Artefakt darstellen könnte, das durch Reanalyse mit passend festgelegten Mehrfachtestverfahren überprüfbar ist. Die produktivste Zukunftsperspektive liegt in der Konvergenz mit der Quantenkognition und falsifizierbaren Tests makroskopischer Komplementarität. Current scope and improvements The paper specifies a classical-instrument baseline and partition-logic ledger; neither has been executed on the target data. The fixed-length no-signalling theorem is stated with prefix-marginal equality. Restricted model comparisons and parallel Bell evidence have separate inferential roles. The proposed interferometer uses a positive-semidefinite Gram statistic with a matched finite-sample null; an asymptotic Marchenko–Pastur bulk edge alone is not a significance threshold. The CMM record retains positive but method-dependent findings. Dependence-aware multiplicity methods are candidates for future reanalysis, subject to their assumptions and error targets. Limits: This is a narrative methods review and prospective test design. It does not establish generalized entanglement, an NT-Axiom mechanism, or empirical validity of the proposed interferometer.

•Oct 3, 2026•0 citations
The Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT) proposes that subjective experiences and objective physical measurements constitute macroscopic complementary subsystems related through acausal, non-local entanglement correlations. The non-commutability conjecture of the GQT predicts that measurement within one subsystem modifies the state of the entire system, including the eigenvalues of the complementary subsystem. Maier and Dechamps (2025) provided preliminary evidence for this conjecture by demonstrating that the storage (non-erasure) versus erasure of objective color parameters (hue and lightness) systematically affected subjective likability ratings across four studies (higher subjective likability mean score in the non-erasure compared to the erasure condition). The present research conceptually replicated these color-erasure findings in a different stimulus domain. In four studies (total N = 647), participants rated photographs of food dishes on subjective tastiness while the objective food parameters (calorie values and stimulus IDs) were either stored (non-erasure condition) or permanently deleted (erasure condition). As in the color studies, limited stimulus sets were fixedly assigned to conditions within each study, deliberately introducing a stimulus-bias confound to protect the acausal complementary relation from the destructive impact of the non-transmission (NT) axiom. Following a predefined three-step analysis plan, preregistered Study 1 (Step 1) documented a strong erasure effect on tastiness ratings. Participants evaluated food dishes as more appetizing in the non-erasure compared to the erasure condition (BF10 = 1309.22, d = .66), and Studies 2a–2c (Step 2) replicated this effect with three independently drawn stimulus sets (BF10s ranging from 10.40 to 26 × 10¹⁵, ds ranging from .26 to .50). In Step 3, preregistered overall analyses including a stratified permutation test (p = .002), a multilevel model (β = 4.72, p = .011), and sensitivity analyses ruled out the biased stimulus assignment alternative. These findings provide cross-domain evidence for the non-commutability conjecture: the documentation of objective stimulus parameters appears to acausally co-relate with subjective evaluations, consistent with macroscopic complementary relations as proposed by the GQT. The implications for substance dualism, physicalism, and dual-aspect monism are discussed.
In the Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT), a theory designed to describe psychophysical phenomena, the subjective and objective aspects of reality are considered to be complementary. The research presented here focused on investigating such a macroscopic complementarity between subjective and objective reality descriptions within the context of color assessment. In particular, the non-commutability conjecture of the GQT posits that two observables derived from the subjective and objective subsystems do not simultaneously provide specific eigenvalues. Rather, the act of measurement within one subsystem, e. g. the performance of objective measurements on a stimulus, modifies the state of the entire system, including the eigenvalues of the other subsystem, e. g. the subjective experience of this stimulus. This conjecture was tested empirically in four studies and in three overall analyses of the complete data set combining all four studies. The experimental manipulation involved a measurement variation of one aspect of the supposed complementary pair, namely the storage (non-erasure condition) or deletion (erasure condition) of objective color parameters (hue and lightness). It was anticipated that the erasure manipulation would influence the other part of the pair, namely the subjective evaluations of color with respect to brightness and likability. The primary hypothesis, which tested erasure-dependent effects on variations in subjective brightness scores was confirmed in Studies 1 and 2 but could not be replicated in Studies 3 and 4. The initial findings obtained with this dependent variable can thus be considered false positives and the primary hypothesis could not be confirmed. However, the second hypothesis, which tested erasure-effects on subjective likability mean scores revealed the following results: The exploratory findings from Studies 1 and 2, as well as the confirmatory findings from Studies 3 and the preregistered Study 4, indicated an erasure effect on subjective likability, whereby higher likability scores were observed in the non-erasure condition compared to the erasure condition in each study. Since the experimental design was intentionally contaminated by a “color bias” alternative explanation to stabilize the effect documentation, a clear causal erasure interpretation cannot be provided at the single study level. To overcome this contamination an overall analysis strategy was pre-planned and performed on the combined data set. Several overall analyses ruled out the “color bias” alternative explanation and another confound. In conclusion, the overall results provided evidence for an erasure effect on subjective likability supporting the model of GQT. This can be interpreted as macroscopic complementary relations between objective and subjective reality descriptions as proposed by the GQT. The implications of these findings for our understanding of the nature of reality and for the validity of the GQT are discussed.
In recent research testing the non-commutability conjecture of the Generalized Quantum Theory, Maier and Dechamps (2025) reported macroscopic complementary relations empirically documented as non-classical correlations between subjective assessment of likability of colors and variations of objective documentations of these colors. Specifically, they found higher likability mean scores in a condition where objective color parameters were not erased and stored in a result file compared to a condition in which these parameters were erased and inaccessible by experimenters. This effect was robust across four studies. Each study’s design in this series of experiments was intentionally confounded with a “color bias” variable. Only limited sets of colors after random creation were specifically assigned to one of the two conditions, so that the effect of the erasure manipulation could alternatively be explained by the specific features of the colors assigned to conditions (the confound was later statistically ruled out by permutations). The presence of a confound was introduced to avoid the impact of the NT axiom, which forbids a strict causal testing approach. Rather, according to the NT axiom when macroscopic complementary relations are tested in a strictly causal way, initial effect documentations should be followed by a decline within and across studies. In the study presented here, the studies of Maier and Dechamps (2025) were conceptually replicated by a strict, i. e. unconfounded, causal testing strategy, to explicitly test the proposed impact of the NT axiom. In two experimental conditions (within-subjects) objective color parameters were either stored or not stored. Assignment of colors to conditions was randomized on the participant level this time ensuring an unconfounded design. The prediction derived from the NT axiom was that under such circumstances the erasure-dependent likability effect should initially be found and later drastically decline. The results supported this prediction: A higher likability mean score was initially found in the non-erasure compared to the erasure condition with strong Bayesian evidence (BF10 = 39.77), replicating the previous findings but now followed by a decline within the study. These findings are in line with the conjectures of the GQT. Specifically, they indicate that subjective assessments and objective measurements of colors are non-commutable and that the data follow the predictions of the NT axiom exhibiting an “effect and decline” data pattern when strictly causally tested. An additional permutation analysis showed that the probability to find such an effect and decline data pattern by chance was very low (p < .03) indicating that it could hardly be interpreted as “false positive” finding. The impact of this and the previous results on the validity of the GQT in describing psychophysical relations as non-classical correlations between spatio-temporally separated subjective assessments and objective measurements of colors is discussed.
This study aims to conceptually replicate a previously observed "color values erasure effect" on subjective color preferences. The research investigates whether the storage or deletion of objective color data influences participants' subjective likability ratings of colors, as predicted by Generalized Quantum Theory's macroscopic complementarity principle. Purpose The primary purpose is to test whether participants rate colors as more likable when the objective color values are stored compared to when they are deleted immediately after data collection. This builds on four previous studies that demonstrated this erasure effect using limited color sets. The current study employs a within-subjects design where each participant evaluates 36 colors (18 in each condition) on a 101-point likability scale. Methodology Participants will view colors randomly selected from a 360-degree color circle (30-70% lightness range, 100% saturation) and rate how much they like each color. Crucially, participants remain unaware of the erasure manipulation. The same 18 colors will be assigned to the "stored" condition and the same 18 colors to the "deleted" condition across all participants - an intentional confound designed to avoid "strict causality tests" that theoretically might destroy the complementarity effect. Expected Outcomes We expect two main findings: (1) Higher mean likability ratings in the stored condition compared to the deleted condition (tested via sequential Bayesian analysis with BF > 10 criterion), and (2) The observed effect size should occur in less than 5% of random color-to-condition permutations, suggesting the effect is not simply due to color bias. The study will use sequential data collection up to N=5,000 participants, with smartphone use prohibited based on previous findings of reduced effect sizes on mobile devices.
This response addresses commentaries by Thomas Rabeyron, Ian Tierney, and Harald Walach on two articles in this issue concerning macroscopic complementary relations between subjective and objective aspects of reality, framed within the Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT). The central concern shared by the commentators is whether the erasure-confound paradigm can robustly avoid the non-transmission (NT) axiom-induced decline that has affected earlier experimental paradigms in this research area. We argue that the NT axiom expresses an epistemic restriction arising whenever causal-deterministic documentation is applied to phenomena that contain an autonomous-subjective component. Under this reading, the erasure-confound paradigm achieves only a reduced-objective documentation of the effect at the single-study level, because the confound prevents an unambiguous causal interpretation, while the effect is established indirectly across studies through the exclusion of the alternative explanation (the “color selection bias” confound). This design decouples evidence accumulation from the arrow of time and is proposed to circumvent the decline. We then put the decline prediction to an empirical test by reporting three previously unpublished color-erasure-with-confound studies (Studies 5–7), which together with the four studies of Maier and Dechamps (2025) form the complete record of seven studies in this paradigm, with no file drawer. The erasure effect appeared in the predicted direction in every study (sign test p = .008), and combined stratified permutation analyses across three independent 36-color sets ruled out the color-selection-bias confound as a joint explanation (Fisher p = .010; Edgington p = .018). An inverse-variance weighted meta-regression on the seven effect sizes returned a non-significant downward slope (b = −0.018, 95% CI [−0.043, 0.006], one-tailed p = .07), and the seventh study yielded an effect still clearly present (BF₁₀ = 3,679.73, d = .30). The data are consistent with a stable, reduced-objectively documented acausal psychophysical correlation rather than the attrition predicted by the NT axiom under direct replication. Further specific points raised by individual commentators, such as the experimenter-psi interpretation and the choice of subjective and objective measurements, are addressed in shorter form.
The Complementarity Principle (CP), introduced by Nils Bohr, described the wave-particle duality of quantum phenomena and its dependence on the measurement setup exploring the quantum states. In general, this principle summarized the fact that two mutually exclusive and contradictory states of quantum events can be reconciled as a measurement-dependent occurrence of these states. Originally, the CP was postulated only for the realm of quantum mechanics, but recently the Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT) extended its area of applicability to the macroscopic domain. According to GQT complementarity relations are also hypothesized to exist between macroscopic objective and subjective measurements of the same concept. This implies objective measurement-dependent variations of subjective experience. To test this hypothesis, seven studies were conducted in which individual variations in subjective intelligence ratings were tested in relation to the availability or non-availability of corresponding objective individual intelligence data. Only one pre-registered study (Study 2) showed strong Bayesian evidence for H1 (BF10 > 10), indicating, as predicted, higher subjective intelligence ratings when objective data were erased compared to a condition in which objective data were available within a male sample. This effect could not be replicated in direct replication attempts, nor did a moderator search in subsequent studies find any robust systematic variation in the data. The results seem to question the validity of the macroscopic complementarity conjecture derived from the GQT. On the other hand, they could also be interpreted as the “effect and decline” data pattern that the Model of Pragmatic Information would predict when conducting empirical confirmations of macroscopic complementarity relations. Possible future research strategies to clarify these different interpretations are discussed.
Abstract (English) Generalized Quantum Theory (GQT) and the Model of Pragmatic Information (MPI) seek to account for non-local correlations in macroscopic systems by positing formal isomorphisms with quantum-mechanical structures. Drawing on a narrative literature review (72 cited sources selected from more than 90 screened), this article evaluates the isomorphism approach in relation to quantum cognition, Contextuality-by-Default, and random matrix theory. The Correlation Matrix Method (CMM) is re-evaluated in light of Grote's critique, the non-significant replications in Nailing Jelly, and newer positive but methodologically mixed CMM findings, and candidate dependence-aware multiplicity procedures whose applicability remains to be checked. Two burden-of-proof criteria are formulated, but not executed on the target datasets in this paper; they specify analyses that any GQT-favourable reading must clear beforehand: a classical instrument baseline, following Tull & Ozawa's result that fixed-length sequential decision data satisfying no-signalling from the future admit a simple classical Markov instrument model, so that order, context, and measurement-disturbance effects carry no evidential weight of their own; and a schematic partition-logic ledger, following Svozil, which asks whether incompatible modes of inquiry over a value-definite latent state space can explain complementarity without genuine contextuality. In philosophy-of-science terms, GQT is provisionally positioned as a degenerating research programme in Lakatos's sense: the Non-Transmission Axiom generates a falsification gap that neither proponents nor critics have yet closed. One testable hypothesis proposed here is that the decline effect may reflect a statistical artifact that can be checked by re-analyzing existing CMM data with appropriately specified multiplicity methods. A productive future direction lies in convergence with quantum cognition and in falsifiable tests of macroscopic complementarity. Zusammenfassung (Deutsch) Die Generalisierte Quantentheorie (GQT) und das Modell der Pragmatischen Information (MPI) zielen darauf ab, nicht-lokale Korrelationen in makroskopischen Systemen durch formale Isomorphie mit quantenmechanischen Strukturen zu erklären. Auf Grundlage eines narrativen Literaturüberblicks (72 zitierte Quellen aus über 90 gesichteten Quellen) bewertet dieser Beitrag den Isomorphie-Ansatz unter Integration der Quantenkognition (Quantum Cognition), Contextuality-by-Default und Random-Matrix-Theorie neu. Die Korrelationsmatrix-Methode (CMM) wird im Licht der Grote-Kritik, der nicht signifikanten Replikationen in Nailing Jelly sowie neuer positiver, aber methodisch gemischter CMM-Befunde und möglicher abhängigkeitsbewusster Mehrfachtestverfahren mit noch zu prüfender Anwendbarkeit neu bewertet. Es werden zwei Beweislast-Kriterien formuliert, aber in diesem Beitrag nicht an den Zieldatensätzen ausgeführt; sie benennen Analysen, die jede GQT-freundliche Lesart zuvor passieren muss: eine klassische Instrument-Baseline nach dem Ergebnis von Tull & Ozawa, wonach sequentielle Entscheidungsdaten fester Länge mit No-Signalling aus der Zukunft ein einfaches klassisches Markov-Instrumentmodell zulassen, sodass Reihenfolge-, Kontext- und Messstörungseffekte für sich genommen keine Beweiskraft besitzen; sowie ein schematisches Partition-Logik-Ledger nach Svozil, das prüft, ob inkompatible Erhebungsmodi über einem wertdefiniten latenten Zustandsraum Komplementarität ohne echte Kontextualität erklären können. Die GQT wird wissenschaftsphilosophisch vorläufig als degenerierendes Forschungsprogramm im Lakatos'schen Sinne eingeordnet: Das Non-Transmission-Axiom erzeugt eine Falsifikationslücke, die weder Befürworter noch Kritiker bislang schließen konnten. Als zentrale testbare Hypothese wird formuliert, dass der Decline-Effekt ein statistisches Artefakt darstellen könnte, das durch Reanalyse mit passend festgelegten Mehrfachtestverfahren überprüfbar ist. Die produktivste Zukunftsperspektive liegt in der Konvergenz mit der Quantenkognition und falsifizierbaren Tests makroskopischer Komplementarität. Current scope and improvements The paper specifies a classical-instrument baseline and partition-logic ledger; neither has been executed on the target data. The fixed-length no-signalling theorem is stated with prefix-marginal equality. Restricted model comparisons and parallel Bell evidence have separate inferential roles. The proposed interferometer uses a positive-semidefinite Gram statistic with a matched finite-sample null; an asymptotic Marchenko–Pastur bulk edge alone is not a significance threshold. The CMM record retains positive but method-dependent findings. Dependence-aware multiplicity methods are candidates for future reanalysis, subject to their assumptions and error targets. Limits: This is a narrative methods review and prospective test design. It does not establish generalized entanglement, an NT-Axiom mechanism, or empirical validity of the proposed interferometer.